The Stone Roses Made of Stone

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 03. 2019
  • El film nos muestra la historia de una banda que prácticamente se había dado por muerta, y donde vemos más de cerca el antes y el después, el carisma de su vocalista Ian Brown y su bajista Mani y el conflicto que causó la disolución tanto en los años noventa como después, en la misma gira de reunión donde los roces con su baterista Reni que parecían subsanados vuelven a aparecer en un polémico concierto en Amsterdam.
    Un trabajo dedicado del director Shane Meadows, que aparte de filmar el documental, se declara un fan de la banda de Manchester, por lo cual hace una cámara muy acertada para registrar momentos clave como la emoción fluyen de él en varias partes del documental:
    Copyright © Derechos Reservados.
  • Hudba

Komentáře • 178

  • @thefishdevil
    @thefishdevil Před 2 lety +23

    I like it when Liam Gallagher says The Stone Roses are the best band to come out of Manchester. Praise indeed from a man of his confidence.

  • @jamiewm
    @jamiewm Před rokem +23

    Reni is the glue that holds the Roses together, an absolutely incredible drummer and those harmonies 👌

  • @Foo-oo-oo-oolsGold89
    @Foo-oo-oo-oolsGold89 Před 9 měsíci +14

    I was lucky enough to see The Stone Roses play there last ever gig at Hampden park Glasgow back in 2017. It was the best gig i have ever been to. From syart to finish the crowd were absolutely bouncing. I will never ever forget that night as long as i live. Primal Scream were the support act. What a way to warm up before those opening moments of I wanna be adored when the crowd went ballistic.

  • @gazsince1966
    @gazsince1966 Před 5 měsíci +8

    That "Fools Gold" at Heaton Park!! Wow!!

  • @AndyAsh1983
    @AndyAsh1983 Před 3 lety +14

    The 3 people that have disliked this video obviously has no music taste what so ever!

    • @cf2584
      @cf2584 Před 3 lety +1

      Exactly 🤘

  • @GT380man
    @GT380man Před 3 lety +8

    I was too old to truly appreciate this band & got here through drifting into Ian Brown’s solo work. Hearing the classic Stone Roses songs just now made me realise I hadn’t been too old, they were just part of my late 20s/early 30s instead of my teens. I miss our ordinary lives & the extraordinary times & people.
    Can we have it all back please??

  • @Weegie_in_Spain
    @Weegie_in_Spain Před rokem +8

    What a video! I've been learning Spanish for the past 3 and a half years. It's fantastic feeling understanding what's being said in both languages. Lucky to have introduced at least 3 people onto the Stone Roses over the years. Saw them at their final amazing gig at Hampden, what a day!

  • @raihanshrk1955
    @raihanshrk1955 Před 5 měsíci +13

    2024 still the best in the fucking world

    • @beyondthehorizon75
      @beyondthehorizon75 Před 5 měsíci +3

      At least _one_ of the very best ever.
      It’s just such a shame they can’t get along. I don’t even know who can’t stand the other the most. Ian and John? Ian and Reni? Mani seems so cool he even gets along with his enemies so I can’t see him being any problem whatsoever.
      It’s really a musical tragedy this band can’t get their sh!+ together. It’s bad enough we won’t hear the unbelievably talented drumming of Reni again (hope I’m wrong) but to know we’ll never get any new Roses is the worst. As corny as it may sound, they should have gotten a therapist like Metallica did. Therapy works if one puts I the effort. These guys needed it even more than Metallica did.
      I absolutely loved the two new songs - especially Beautiful Thing. I think if they cut the crap and just grew the hell up they could’ve made an album just as good or even better than Second Coming (which I love).
      It’s just so sad.
      On the bright side, I’m loving Liam and John’s new songs. I really think Just Another Rainbow was a straight up new Roses song or at least a very slightly altered version of one.
      It’d be amazing if Reni joined on the next Gallagher/Squire album.

    • @maxguerra9155
      @maxguerra9155 Před měsícem

      @@beyondthehorizon75 agreed.

  • @GT380man
    @GT380man Před 3 lety +9

    If like me you’d not quite sussed the deep liking for each other this group of men have, watch Reni as he queues Ian in perfectly at 20min 28sec. The look between them isn’t just professional understanding, it’s joy.

    • @garethh2711
      @garethh2711 Před 3 lety +3

      When you watch that Waterfall clip you realise how integral Reni is to the band. Effortlessly keeping the beat, perfect flourishes whilst also singing backing vox.

  • @IanMcCausland
    @IanMcCausland Před 3 lety +13

    a millions miles away from the Uk, this band just rocked my world here in the middle of Canada. Loved see this film!!

  • @jsharpe2841
    @jsharpe2841 Před 2 lety +18

    Obligatory comment about Reni being an underrated drummer here!

    • @scoot8534
      @scoot8534 Před rokem +3

      His voice is angelic , listen to the backing

  • @mikkelgo
    @mikkelgo Před 2 lety +5

    Heaton 2012
    I was there.
    My (not so) soon-to-be wife was there too.
    My still-to-be-born babygirl was there.
    I think my life peaked right there!
    And the crowd was amazing and sang their lungs out and I was truly honored to have this experience with all of them.
    Thanx Ian, Reni, Mani and John
    I've owe you big time...
    🙏🍋
    (and thanx to Shane as well:-)

  • @mrkipling2201
    @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety +11

    I love their early stuff as well. ‘ So Young ‘ and ‘ Tell Me ‘ are brilliant songs in my opinion. So different from what they would become, sound wise.

    • @connorforsyth8492
      @connorforsyth8492 Před 2 lety +1

      Every playlist i have has So young, Tell me and the Elephant Stone Demo

    • @mrkipling2201
      @mrkipling2201 Před 2 lety

      @@connorforsyth8492 excellent!! Good choices 👍👍

    • @rizzledizzle3443
      @rizzledizzle3443 Před 2 lety +1

      Agree, very sex pistols though

  • @mrkipling2201
    @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety +6

    When they come on the stage at Spike Island the subtitles in this upload is ‘ retire, retire, retire now ‘said by Ian Brown. It’s actually time, time, time is now!!!

  • @blueshorecreative3146
    @blueshorecreative3146 Před rokem +5

    What a band! All I can say is - good on Reni for coming back and giving all those people joy.

    • @Carl-hj6sf
      @Carl-hj6sf Před 7 měsíci

      She's not, she was great back in the day but they layed it on to be difficult. There's more to this interview after this clip when she says interview over and they start taking the piss out of her because they made her look stupid.

  • @alanmares3388
    @alanmares3388 Před 3 lety +14

    Best band ever imagine how big they would of been If there wasnt that gap in recording

    • @mrkipling2201
      @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety

      The ‘ One Love ‘ single was a sample of what the album would have probably sounded like if they had started recording it just after Spike Island and the Glasgow green show. It’s a shame that they didn’t. Or weren’t able to.

    • @alukuhito
      @alukuhito Před 2 lety

      would *have been

    • @runandraisans6055
      @runandraisans6055 Před 2 lety

      The court stuff with the record company fuck them up totally as a unit too much going on to concentrate writing songs plus other things like them all having starting a family they all drifted apart from each other
      Then reni leaving was basically the end of the band

  • @stenchosmells
    @stenchosmells Před 2 lety +8

    If I had 1 wish…………. but I can’t ever see it happening 🎸 🍋

  • @ferpolar7493
    @ferpolar7493 Před rokem +8

    Stone roses forever!

    • @misvhs
      @misvhs  Před rokem +1

      subscribe we hope your support

  • @paulharris8983
    @paulharris8983 Před 2 lety +7

    Great doc. The Roses are awesome. Love that John is really grumpy.

  • @hugoarmandocastanedasilva8557

    Documental increíble, muchas gracias por subirlo.

  • @Horizon344
    @Horizon344 Před rokem +3

    So so film, thx for the upload of it

  • @RAF_KUL
    @RAF_KUL Před 3 lety +5

    Thanks for the upload.👏

  • @nuriaoncala8254
    @nuriaoncala8254 Před 3 lety +1

    Goosebumps.Just loved watching the bit where the band is playing at Razzmatazz in Barcelona.So many amazing bands i enjoyed seeing in there,so many great memories.

  • @bottle273
    @bottle273 Před 3 lety +2

    Thanks for sharing. Great to see. The Fools Gold live was really well edited and a moving rendition. Their music moves with the times. All the best to The Stone Roses.

  • @alukuhito
    @alukuhito Před 2 lety +3

    Thanks for uploading this!

  • @nooneelse2732
    @nooneelse2732 Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks 4 the upload from argentina

  • @northernvibes6838
    @northernvibes6838 Před 3 lety +5

    Brilliant!! Ian brown is an absolute legend thank you for sharing that northern sole stone roses,

    • @GT380man
      @GT380man Před 3 lety +1

      Just love Northern Lights, Ian Brown’s memory maybe of his Northern Soul days. I was a southern boy and of course missed it all, but we knew about it. It was unique. Never before or since.

  • @user-jh3ul2yo5z
    @user-jh3ul2yo5z Před 3 lety +3

    thanks they are the best

  • @HaaHeee-jq2sg
    @HaaHeee-jq2sg Před 5 měsíci +3

    I was so lucky to go to heaton park locked up at age of 20 missed out on spike Island this well made up for it because it was better😊❤🎉

  • @richardshipman8399
    @richardshipman8399 Před 3 lety +1

    thanks for posting

  • @wzarg3874
    @wzarg3874 Před rokem +7

    Que bonito es que esto esté en español

    • @RubberPlan
      @RubberPlan Před 2 měsíci

      Sin dudas, es una de esas icónicas bandas que nunca fueron muy escuchadas en Latinoamérica, eso hace que sea un poco difícil encontrar material en español de ellos, esto es una verdadera maravilla 🍋

  • @richardrennie8221
    @richardrennie8221 Před 2 lety +1

    I thoroughly enjoyed this doco.

  • @deandermody7154
    @deandermody7154 Před měsícem

    brilliant presentation that shane !

  • @carlosgonzalez447
    @carlosgonzalez447 Před 3 lety +2

    Gracias

  • @Nofashists
    @Nofashists Před 11 měsíci +4

    Never got that new album, what a band

  • @hugovandermeer1566
    @hugovandermeer1566 Před rokem +1

    Shades of Alvin Lee 'Going Home' Ten Years After, guitar harmonics. Really tasty piece of work.

  • @Carl-hj6sf
    @Carl-hj6sf Před 3 lety +3

    Thanks for uploading this! I've got it on dvd but who had a dvd player these days!?

    • @Carl-hj6sf
      @Carl-hj6sf Před 3 lety +1

      @@freespirit8243 I remember them from when dinosaurs used to run about

  • @jambo28
    @jambo28 Před 3 lety +8

    8:24 reni breaks the fourth wall

  • @garrieleepeck8753
    @garrieleepeck8753 Před 3 lety +1

    Love the stones!!!

  • @alancooper5147
    @alancooper5147 Před 3 lety +4

    Absolute genius 👏

  • @essentialfix
    @essentialfix Před 2 lety +4

    I met these Legends in a pub in West Didsbury called The Midland "Alfonso" used to run the joint. We came to grab some weed and saw these guys at the bar.... I got their Autograph on a pack of Marlboro cigs.... we even shared a blunt! Ian drank quadruply brandy and coke 😂🤣 ()______)____________***********

  • @listentothenightfilms
    @listentothenightfilms Před rokem +10

    Picked up the baton The Beatles handed them. Should have been ever bigger.

    • @Horizon344
      @Horizon344 Před rokem

      That would be The La's more than SR, SR was never poppy enough to be that level as an act, they were always niche/alternative

    • @clinteastwood6875
      @clinteastwood6875 Před 2 měsíci

      @@Horizon344Made of Stone, Waterfall and She Bangs the Drums are very poppy.

  • @Derazed85
    @Derazed85 Před rokem +10

    We all can see that Liam got his attitude from Ian, no doubt what so ever....

  • @cjns5253
    @cjns5253 Před 3 lety +18

    Ian is just naturally cool Liam Gallagher tries to hard sometimes Ian just has it

    • @user-fi6td5xj9x
      @user-fi6td5xj9x Před 3 lety +2

      I think they both pretty cool tbh

    • @hibernian797
      @hibernian797 Před 3 lety +7

      Liam doesn't need to be brought into this. Oasis and the stone roses are both great bands.

  • @mikethompson5549
    @mikethompson5549 Před rokem +3

    Made of Gold❤

  • @arricammarques1955
    @arricammarques1955 Před 9 měsíci +3

    The Planet of the Roses

  • @michaelx9079
    @michaelx9079 Před 3 lety +4

    Saw them at Spike Island ......but that fools gold was astounding.....reni and mani just sitting on the groove while chris rips it up....threw in a bit of ticket to ride and le freak in that mindblowing solo

    • @cubits303
      @cubits303 Před 3 lety +1

      *John *daytripper

    • @michaelx9079
      @michaelx9079 Před 3 lety +1

      Cubits my mistake...... the nile rogers quote was what really pricked my ears...... their were tons of others in that solo I half know too.....what a guitar player

    • @barrystraughan2678
      @barrystraughan2678 Před 3 lety

      And Squire showing that he truly is greatest guitarist of his generation!

    • @Therejectionartist
      @Therejectionartist Před 2 lety

      It was worth the price of the admission at heaton park. Highlights for me were also the opening bass lines at the start of the gig. The crowd was so hyped up, just seeing the joy and people going wild, unforgettable. This is the one was great as well, but fools gold was something else. Honestly felt like my life had fallen into place after finally seeing them live, something just clicked in a good way. People used to say that about the doors, that getting to one of their gigs was like a defining moment in their life.

  • @arricammarques1955
    @arricammarques1955 Před 3 lety +9

    They wanna to be a door!

    • @arricammarques1955
      @arricammarques1955 Před 3 lety +1

      @@freespirit8243 No, its a play on words. I wanna be adored..

  • @garydixon6315
    @garydixon6315 Před 2 lety +4

    Before Oasis there was the Stone Roses ..🔥

  • @alessandrocolucci7283
    @alessandrocolucci7283 Před 3 lety +3

    This is the one

  • @therealalan.b
    @therealalan.b Před 3 lety +5

    45:33 my fucking drama teacher

  • @rossfraser3415
    @rossfraser3415 Před 4 měsíci +1

    The man can sing ……… it couldn’t be anyone else

  • @MW-zu3ci
    @MW-zu3ci Před 3 lety +4

    32:07 great

  • @bekiigic
    @bekiigic Před 2 lety +5

    39:47 Miles Kane

  • @TestTest-di5yu
    @TestTest-di5yu Před 3 lety +1

    damned cool band

  • @disobeytoday4685
    @disobeytoday4685 Před 2 lety +8

    New United song. To the the tune of *Stone Roses - Made of Stone*
    When Ole Solskjaer took the wheel
    Reminds me Ninety Nine was real
    That night in May, glory remains
    We won it all, it was a dream
    Scouse B*stards let go a scream
    Your glory went, I love that scene
    Sometimes I
    Fantasise
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Giggs out wide
    Beckham on the right
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Viva Ronaldo
    Viva United Road
    The greatest story ever told
    The Busby Babes, they brought it home
    We'll never die, we'll never die
    You won the trophy, we won three
    The Treble you will never see
    Knocked off your perch, I love that scene
    Sometimes I
    Fantasise
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Giggs out wide
    Beckham on the right
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Viva Ronaldo
    Viva United Road
    M!
    U!
    F!
    C!
    M!
    U!
    F!
    C!
    M!
    U!
    F!
    C!
    M!
    U!
    F!
    C!
    Sometimes I
    Fantasise
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Giggs out wide
    Beckham on the right
    Peter Schmeichel is the goalie
    Scholes, Butt, Cantona and Roy Keane
    Viva Ronaldo
    Viva United Road

    • @disobeytoday4685
      @disobeytoday4685 Před 2 lety

      @Stephen Greenhorn The first English team to win a European Cup, just 10 years after half the team was killed in a plane crash. Yeh.... Garbage

    • @rizzledizzle3443
      @rizzledizzle3443 Před 2 lety +3

      Not sure thatll take off motzart

  • @rizzledizzle3443
    @rizzledizzle3443 Před 2 lety +4

    Can we get a live album from this period or a Heaton park live album?

  • @HeavyMetalPowerBottom
    @HeavyMetalPowerBottom Před rokem +7

    Id like to think theres more to the story than Reni leaving just cos of problems with his monitor

    • @GT380man
      @GT380man Před 5 měsíci

      Reni never wanted Mega fame and he’d said that to the others. He might have been torn & then felt coerced. Technical difficulties was the final straw, maybe. Lovely guy, unbelievable drummer.

  • @coventry2367
    @coventry2367 Před 2 lety +2

    Best band 🍋🍋🍋

  • @martinwilliamdavies7977
    @martinwilliamdavies7977 Před 11 měsíci +4

    Why Did The Drummer Ruin It? We All Thought That John would chuck his toys out of the pram then him in the bucket hat does it. Oh well at least we got see them rehearse Waterfall together and we saw that magic of them in unison as The Stone Roses.

    • @glenndouglas8822
      @glenndouglas8822 Před 10 měsíci +9

      Reni didn't ruin it, he was nearly deaf through feedback( having been promised only the best technician's)so fucked off for a bit to calm down. Tour carried on absolutely fine with the four of them for a few more years after. No one and I mean no one hates on our Reni 😁🙌

  • @tangodelta7617
    @tangodelta7617 Před rokem +4

    Anyone know who is Reni imitating at 17:09 in?

  • @Paul_owie
    @Paul_owie Před 3 lety +5

    26:20
    (Interviewer) "Well, if you're the best band in the world why aren't your number one" 🙃
    Did she Carry on working after this interview. ? Wow!!

    • @mrkipling2201
      @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety +1

      It would be a huge surprise if she did!! That interview summed them up back then. Playing by their own rules, not playing the media game and coming across as cool as anything. Poor woman didn’t have a chance!! Or a clue!!

    • @Paul_owie
      @Paul_owie Před 3 lety +1

      @@mrkipling2201 she even ran out of questions. 😄

    • @mrkipling2201
      @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety

      @@Paul_owie 🤣🤣

  • @garyjones9910
    @garyjones9910 Před rokem +4

    Please can someone tell me what that dance tune playing at parr Hall is?

  • @WARDISWARD
    @WARDISWARD Před 3 lety +1

    Fuck Yeah , saw them in 1995 ..

  • @NewMinority
    @NewMinority Před 10 měsíci +3

    Renis flow ❤

  • @rizzledizzle9801
    @rizzledizzle9801 Před rokem +6

    Sad renis only played on 2 records, tragic really.

    • @glenndouglas8822
      @glenndouglas8822 Před rokem +1

      Might be because they only made two albums.....😉😁

    • @GT380man
      @GT380man Před rokem +5

      @@glenndouglas8822 I think it’s meant sad he didn’t play with other bands.

    • @richsan4923
      @richsan4923 Před rokem

      ​@@GT380man think he was in Ride?

    • @djpaulsid
      @djpaulsid Před 4 měsíci

      Reni had his own band The Rub. Played guitar and lead vocals

  • @69cobsy
    @69cobsy Před 3 lety +1

    ✌🍋🔥

  • @jpsnetworkingchannel3430
    @jpsnetworkingchannel3430 Před 3 lety +6

    How good was that rendition of Waterfall

  • @rubenpeterkin5863
    @rubenpeterkin5863 Před 2 lety +5

    20:25 reni , what a fuckin legend

  • @mcburnski
    @mcburnski Před 3 lety

    Wrenie, mani, broonie, squire. End of story

  • @genesisfootball1542
    @genesisfootball1542 Před 3 lety +10

    let's be honest, it's not the greatest rockumentary of all time is it

    • @alukuhito
      @alukuhito Před 2 lety

      No, but it's something.

    • @TomWardComedian
      @TomWardComedian Před 2 lety

      @@alukuhito hahahaha

    • @clinteastwood6875
      @clinteastwood6875 Před 6 měsíci

      So much interesting stuff with this band and yet a documentary like this that should’ve been amazing ends up underwhelming. Wastes 20 minutes on fans queuing up for the show. I know the band likes to be cryptic but they should have spoken more. More comments, anecdotes etc. We should have heard from Andy Couzens, Pete Garner, Cressa and others.

  • @cesaraugustogarciaalvarez6860
    @cesaraugustogarciaalvarez6860 Před 8 měsíci +3

    POW ¡¡¡ 😎

  • @andysheldon828
    @andysheldon828 Před 2 lety +1

    Banzai from Japan ! ( nice couple of hours escape from the disaster olympics )

  • @gargantuk
    @gargantuk Před 3 lety +2

    Where is their 'secret rehearsal space'? Warrington is not a good enough answer

  • @paulohare4391
    @paulohare4391 Před rokem +14

    we needed englinsh subtitles with all that manc talk, not spanish

    • @wzarg3874
      @wzarg3874 Před rokem +2

      Ño

    • @glenndouglas8822
      @glenndouglas8822 Před rokem +1

      It would be took down then, Paul. They put the Spanish release on to bypass CZcams regulations.✌️

  • @somebrummiekid4430
    @somebrummiekid4430 Před rokem +2

    Enjoy #wherewereyouin88 🌎

  • @standingontheshouldersofgi5876

    What's the tune at 1:13:14

  • @jerzykocemba8545
    @jerzykocemba8545 Před 2 lety +1

    !

  • @chihuahuaman7025
    @chihuahuaman7025 Před 3 lety +5

    I don’t speak French. I don’t understand what’s written but I know it’s French. Long live the queen!!!!

  • @fedea4723
    @fedea4723 Před 3 lety +1

    ;)

  • @joebrowning5027
    @joebrowning5027 Před 2 lety +1

    32:00 - 36:00

  • @user-lz4yn8xq5o
    @user-lz4yn8xq5o Před 3 měsíci +1

    Pinky and The Brain.......😊😮😂

  • @staffordshirebullterrierli7411

    I wanna be a Dog!

    • @staffordshirebullterrierli7411
      @staffordshirebullterrierli7411 Před 2 lety

      I waaaaannnnaaa be a doooooooooooggggggerrrg,
      I wanna be a dooooooooooogggggg!
      Mint guitar rifts!
      A doooooooooogggggg!
      I wanna be a dooooooooooogggggg
      you adore me
      You adore me
      You adore me
      I wanna
      I wanna
      I wanna be a Dog
      I wanna
      I wannnnnna
      I wannnnnnnnnnaaaaa be a Dog
      I wannnnnnnnaaaaaaaaaaaaa
      I wannnnnnnnaaaaaaaaaaaaa
      I wannnnnnnnnnaaaaa be a dog
      I wanna, i wanna, I gotta be a dog!
      I wanna be a dog 😂😍😂😍😂

  • @anthonynolan4488
    @anthonynolan4488 Před 2 lety +2

    Your film doesn’t play so doesn’t exit b

    • @suncat5160
      @suncat5160 Před 2 lety +5

      lol wat

    • @DaveTaste
      @DaveTaste Před 2 lety +1

      Stick to bone marrow mate.

    • @Anglo_Saxon1
      @Anglo_Saxon1 Před 2 lety

      "There's a reason why I've still got my hair like this
      There's a reason why I still never wear a tie
      There's a reason why I still listen to this album at least once a week
      And it still gives me goosebumps"
      Nuff said fella.

  • @justinparkerthewildwolf6394

    The big gig at the end was an anticlimax, the vibe turned to shit halfway through shame really

    • @Carl-hj6sf
      @Carl-hj6sf Před 2 lety +10

      I was there. It really didn't. The fireworks, the atmosphere, the people. It was a fucking great day out!

    • @mikkelgo
      @mikkelgo Před 2 lety +7

      I think you're very wrong.
      It was really something.
      Really.

  • @234cheech
    @234cheech Před 3 lety +4

    IF ONLY IAN WAS A GOOD SINGER LIVE

    • @jumofi
      @jumofi Před 3 lety +3

      Bernard Sumner isn't too. New Order is a great band, what difference does it make?

    • @cf2584
      @cf2584 Před 3 lety

      You have no clue about music ,

    • @liamgallagher7717
      @liamgallagher7717 Před 3 lety +5

      If your slagging Ian brown of for his singing you’ve missed the point. Go and watch the X factor

    • @GT380man
      @GT380man Před 3 lety +6

      Ian Brown has an aura, which means it’s not essential that he sings well live. These days, the audience does it for him. They love Ian Brown. As do I.

    • @mrkipling2201
      @mrkipling2201 Před 3 lety

      He is.

  • @dansullivan7693
    @dansullivan7693 Před 2 lety +1

    Zzzzz

  • @hankfox3249
    @hankfox3249 Před 2 lety +7

    Ian brown has to be one of the worst singers ever. Sounds like he cant even be bothered most of the time

    • @williambarrow7790
      @williambarrow7790 Před 2 lety +12

      That's rubbish pal, he's the daddy of Manchester

    • @hankfox3249
      @hankfox3249 Před 2 lety +2

      @@williambarrow7790 30 years ago maybe

    • @Lee-jj8nt
      @Lee-jj8nt Před 2 lety +4

      He can definitely sing pal.
      He sounds far better when he sings in studio and most roses songs the vocals are soft, which dosent suit a live setting of amps and guitars and crowds, I'm not saying he's as good as LG live but check out Glasgow green 1990 or live in Manchester 1989.

    • @jimmym1955
      @jimmym1955 Před 2 lety +7

      And yet he's still the fuckin greatest!

    • @peterwalshmusic
      @peterwalshmusic Před 2 lety +8

      Compared to what though? Pavarotti? Being a great singer doesn’t mean being the perfect singer. Ian’s a great singer no one can do the Roses like Ian. Dylan wasn’t a “great” singer by most people standards but in my eyes he was a great singer.

  • @snakedriver
    @snakedriver Před rokem +8

    Good to hear how Squire dialed his live guitar back to the sound of the early album and ditched the stupid hard rock styles and posturing he employed in the second coming album and tour and the later disaster of the seahorses.

    • @rizzledizzle9801
      @rizzledizzle9801 Před rokem +1

      While i dont love that seahorses album, find it souless, it was a huge commercial success.

    • @usandusonly32
      @usandusonly32 Před rokem +5

      Second Coming is a brilliant record and Squire was on fire around that time. Ok, may have gone too far with some songs but it's still a fantastic record

  • @EmanTankx
    @EmanTankx Před 8 měsíci +7

    Bassist be looking like Mark Hamils long lost bastard son