Nokia Lumia 1020 vs HTC One | Pocketnow
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- Please note, a correction has been made to the HTC One's screen size (4.7") via annotation. We regret the error. (Description and links below)
We've put the new PureView Goliath (aka Nokia Lumia 1020) up against its predecessor and we've thrown it into the snake pit with the reigning king of flagship Android sales, the Galaxy S 4. But Samsung isn't the only contender in the high-end Android space, and our 1020 was beckoning us to throw it into the ring with a stouter foe, one with a build that could take a beating. "An aluminum one," our suddenly-creepy imaginary talking Lumia 1020 demanded.
Well, we weren't about to ask it twice. That all-seeing PureView crater-eyeball is horrifying. So we tossed the 1020 into the fightin' cage with our trusty old Sprint-edition HTC One, and the following video is what came of all the ruckus. Within it, polycarbonate throws cuffs against machined metal, gentle curves do battle with edgy chamfers, and a 4MP camera does its best to shelter its UltraPixels from the assault of a 41MP PureView titan. And it doesn't end till folding chairs start cracking skulls.
We better go before we run out of stupid fighting metaphors. Tune in below for ten minutes of HTC-against-Nokia including some rather lovely landscape photos and video, if we do say so ourselves and then dive on down to the comments to tell us about your love for BoomSound, your hatred of embedded batteries, or how thankful we should be to live in scenic Boston (we know). Nokia Lumia 1020 vs HTC One starts right now!
Follow Michael:
/ captain2phones
Subscribe: bit.ly/pocketno...
pocketnow.com
Follow us:
flipboard.com/@...
/ pocketnow
/ pocketnow
google.com/+poc...
/ pocketnow
About us:
Pocketnow has been a key source of mobile technology news and reviews since its establishment in 2000. With offices on three continents, Pocketnow offers round-the-clock coverage of the mobile technology landscape, from smartphones to tablets to wearables. We aim to be your number-one source for mobile tech news, reviews, comparisons, and commentary. If you love mobile as much as we do, be sure to subscribe!
Nokia Lumia 1020 vs HTC One | Pocketnow
• Nokia Lumia 1020 vs HT...
PocketNow
/ pocketnow
Corrected just after upload and noted via annotation, upvoted comments, and in the first line of the description. Please read the description, folks. ^MF
Nokia Lumia 1020 for me!! Getting it on Friday coming all being well!
Bought mine yesterday, yellow, 64 GB version, cant wait to get it! :)
Xscrambler Cool! It's working out great for me. I love how the camera works. :D
HTC One screen size error (4.7" vs 5") corrected via annotation. Thanks for the heads-up, folks! (Please vote up for visibility.) ^MF
I own a HTC one... Correction, I own my FOURTH HTC one. Never again will I buy one... When I first got the phone I thought it was awesome, it had everything, great looks, feel, build quality, and what a fantastic camera! After 3 months my microphone stopped working, then the top speaker stopped working, and then it wouldn't read my SIM... And then it kept crashing. When I had it sent off for repair they just gave me a new one, fantastic... Until I used the camera, every shot had a purple glow to it, and to cut a long story short, so did the next two replacement handsets... Now I've been offered the Nokia 1020 as a replacement and I really can't wait! BEFORE ANYONE BUYS THE HTC ONE, PLEASE GOOGLE- HTC ONE CAMERA PROBLEM... It seems that hundreds of cameras are faulty and they have no clue why, or how to fix them! Stay well clear for now.
HTC One is the more eye catching????? The Lumia is bright yellow and is unmissable!!! I had the One, hated the picture quality but it's the best Android I've ever had. Getting my Lumia 1020 tomorrow and can't wait
So...How is your new Lumia? Is it better then the One?
Nice video. Professional and straight to the point. By far one of the best channels I have found for reviews. Keep up the good work. Subscribed!
these are easily the best mobile device comparisons on CZcams.
nokia lumia 1020 the king
This guy never gives decisive conclusions.
finally a comparison between phones and not their OS's. good job michael
Internals don't matter when you have an OS that's as smooth as Windows Phone. Adding quadcore processors and more RAM just makes the OS that much better. If people and app developers saw this, Windows Phone's whole ecosystem would be so much more legit that Android and iOS.
yeah..but if that was the case, BB would be on top all.
Always a joy watching your vids Michael. Just awesome.
The more I see of the One the more impressed I get. HTC has made a monster!. Great review btw,Michael..
A great review of two very impressive phones. I like the camera of the Nokia, but the Windows platform keeps me from wanting to jump right in (I am currently an Android user). As other comments have noted, there is more to a phone than a great camera. Well done, PR, thumbs up to the video and I'm a new subscriber. I look forward to more reviews!
Got to love these videos by such a great writer and Tech junky .Thanks Michael
I really enjoy your reviews Mr. Fisher, keep up the good work :)
*gives standing ovation* very good review michael fisher!
this was a very good comparison, very unbiased, unlike the other comparisons and reviews out there.
I have both. HTC One is the better phone but the lumia is good for those days you feel like tossing and dropping your phone around
Yes, the Dutch courts forbid the supplier, STM, from further supplying HTC with these Nokia designed/exclusive components. But Nokia also filed multiple patent violation claims with the ITC, which is reviewing the case against HTC. To date, HTC has not clarified if and when the Nokia HAAC microphones will cease to be included in the HTC One's construction.
Your voice is so awesome, I could easily see you voice acting in some adult swim show or something. You should seriously look into that.
always happy to see informative videos that give me the information I want.
You do the best reviews those guys at phonedog are bias as hell. Please continue to keep up the good work
*old man voice* Darn thing interrupting Matlock! I remember when a phone was just a phone!
i absolutely agree to u on this point. with this small a screen, there was no need fr 1080p. Infact a 1080p screen shuld be avoided for anything below 5'.
Fellow watchers, if you could like this and get it seen I would greatly appreciate it!
Michael, I'm going to buy a microphone and I love the quality and sound of yours. What is it?
About the daylight visibility, If you set the Lumia to auto brightness and select sunlight readability then it will get ridiculously bright when outside/...
Allright: A year ago I first bought my WP. Nothing fancy, just a Lumia 610, but I liked the experience. Then I bought a flagship android phone with all the bells and whistles and sold it after a month. The android was just a huge mess to me and despite high-end spec it still tended to lag! Now I'm a happy user of a Lumia 720, but it's time to shop for something new and there comes my question: is there anything in HTC One, that can convince a case-hardened WP fanboy to switch back to android? :D maybe some other device? Or maybe I should better stick to WP and just wait for 2014 nokia lineup?
For now I'm waiting for the CES, when Nokia will probably announce their 5" device with internals of the 1520. Then we'll see :)
Same goes to me. I know it sounds a bit Fanboy-ish, but I don't claim, that Nokias are the best. They just fit me the most :)
if u use whattsapp a lot then android is way better. that was my only reason for dumping my nokia 920. actually it was all the messaging platforms. when texting wp keyboard takes up 3/4 of the screen. its so very annoying
i've had the 620 for about a week and i love everything besides the app store. That's probably the only thing that's selling me about android phones tbh.
If you don't mind some the limitations of the windows app store, i say go for the 1020 !!
Does Windows phones have Instagram yet? I'm now ready to upgrade from my HTC one. There's so many great phones out now though it seems impossible to choose. I'm thinking to decide based on battery life as that's the main issue I've dealt with in the last year and a half. Also I'd love it to be waterproof and have wireless charging. Only phone to satisfy seems to be Sony z2....but it just seems too big for me as I'd like 4.5_4.7 inch. I wonder if the new LG g3 will be waterproof? Or I could wait to see the s5 active even though I don't love Samsung phones as I find they lag too much.
Sorry Nokia is the best choice for me .
Tbh
It's what I've been saying since the preorder! You can't stop the ONE!!!
"Mistake," singular, unless there's another I'm missing. Also, this makes three comparisons in two days. Errors happen. ^MF
Which is why the ITC is reviewing the case against HTC for multiple Nokia owned patent violations (>~40).
Good review.... No biased comments made about each phones...keep it up
As is said at the end, I think it comes down to which OS you want to run. I'm all for Windows Phone and have had my 1020 for two days and love it as both a camera and a phone.
The HTC One is a lovely looking phone but I would never have an Android phone again. Maybe if HTC brought the design to its next Windows Phones?
The Nokia Lumia 1020 leverages its 41MP sensor to produce over 3.2 micron virtual "super" pixels at default 5MP resolution while the HTC One uses smaller 2 micron "ultra" pixels at its fixed 4MP. Nokia also uses a patented full module 3 axis optical image stabilization (vs the HTC One's single lens element 2 axis OIS). Lastly, the overall size of the sensor has more influence on light gathering than the individual size of each pixels. Hence the 1020's overall superior low light performance
ah my mistake.
And yes I not saying ms isn't doing any software development for wp8, just that it won't arrive until next year.
Getting Nokia Lumia 1020 tomorrow, so exited
nokia lumia 1020 is the best
more pixels means more detail both zoomed and not zoomed. and nokias optic system is awesome along side an amazing flash
The ultimate htc one crushes that little toy they call Nokia
Im so impressed Michael..this video has no hint tat u are a windows phone lover..gj
Hey great video.
I have noticed that about Nokia, they never slam dunk it's competitors in terms of cameras.
HTC One all the way
Not
Says the guy with the apple logo
HTC One is really the best device since april, they really produced something unique almost complete
The Nokia camera is its selling point and wow it delivered.
I couldn´t find this info on youtube. I have my Nokia E6 always on Silent(+Vibration off). Is there a Status LED that is indicating new E-Mail, Whatsapp, Exchange Mail?
How can i see new messages, without touching or unlocking the phone.
You're right, but the camera on here is still better. It doesn't have a 41MP camera to take 41MP photos, it has it so you can have loseless zoom and lots of other goodies.
THICK is not a trend, I own a htc one and it feels so good on my hand surely fits my palm so well
This came to my recommendations in 2021, wishing they still made devices from aluminum. Not a fan of the glass backs we have anymore.
lumiaa 1020 owned not only htc one but also galexy s4 lumia 1020=best smart phone ever
It always astounds me how much processing power flagship Android devices have. Is this really necessary? Has Android really turned into such an unwieldy beast?
This guy looks and sounds like the Tony Stark of tech reviews... It's awesome...
both are marvelous phones..cannot judge between them which one to take.
another wonderful review. Keep up the good work!
Thank you Mr. Stark, now you can go please Ms. Potts.
I watched the video, and I never mentioned the s4, you don't I'm ignorant or anything. Tasker basically create tasks that have a cause and a effect. With a good voice plugin you can emulate what the motox is doing, just with more battery consumption.
Tried every lumia except for the 1020, weird to hear that there's app crashing, the 1020 is just a 920 with agreat camera, shouldn't have any bugs except for the camera software.
Lumia 1020 is a big daddy... getting mine soon. Thanks for the review.
the only reason because WP7 devices did not get WP8 is because of a new kernel and the hardware requirements microsoft made for WP8,
The kernel of WP7 is from like, Windows Mobile 5, from around 2005-2007 or something.
there's white and black mate versions, that big ass thing is subjective, I find it nice due to the fact that stands out its prowess
Guys, with regard to front facing camera, you're missing the point. You absolutely must include Video Calling performance, since in my opinion this would be one of the main reasons for having a front facing camera.
There is no contest to an iPhone5 and FaceTime which lets you have HD video calling, It works very well over 3G and handles poor connections much, much better than Skype does.
Skype has no Mobile HD calling on Android. It might do on some Lumia's.
You should do a vs in this area.
What innovation does the 1020 provide? Serious question because I'm not sure if I should get 1020 or HTC One. For a newer phone the 1020 really has some low specs. And that battery for a powerful camera like that I'm not surprised if it doesn't last half a day (I know I'm not going to use the camera all the time but still).
i dont care how much the phone weights whats important is how its looking and the power in it
What's the difference between Gorila Glass 3 and 2?
Someone's been watching Arrested Development...
I've really been impressed with HTC with their audio quality with speakers and microphone. I love both companies. MS really needs to gt their updates to windows phone 8 so that their will be a better experience and better phones.
I love1020
Micheal i have a question
i hope u can give a good advice
i have an iphone 5
so im buying an ipad
the ipad same the iphone but its big
so im thinking to but a windows phone device
is it a good OS?and i wait for htc 8xt or buy a lumia??
with my regards
1:58 , dat handshaking, wow
do you have a link to the background on that htc one?? I wanna use it
Which one has the better camera and has better quality?
No worry Mihcael,your hair looks great no matter which camera :).
I have a HTC one and it's pretty good but,now i want to buy this 1020 to try the windows phone.Can someone who have this Nokia to tell me what is in that Play Store and Xbox? I mean,if it has enough apps or games? I heared a lot of people how said that it has a problem cause all his good games are for money.Is it true?
No it is not true. I had the nokia lumia 520 and it was great, considering the fact that it was the First lumia in the World then. Actually, Nokia has more useful apps and it is less about gaming. That is why most people pick the HTC one. It runs android and as a result, has a wider range in games. For example, if you are a fan of Subway Surfers then my advice is to stick with the HTC One because Lumia doesn't provide it. If you are not a gamer then go for the Nokia lumia 1020. ;)
Watch the video again from start to end!!! Watch it 5 more times!
that awkward moment when your phone nearly has better specs than your pc
Not Android - OEM skins are the issue - though HTC seem to have got Sense 5 pretty well sorted, as it runs just as well on a Snapdragon 400 2 core at 1.4mhz with 1GB of RAM as it does on a Snapdragon 600 4 core at 1.7Ghz with 2GB of RAM, at least according to the reviews for the One Mini.
A Good review Michael. The only thing you have been leaving out is..you're not explaining why a dual core is enough to run a windows phone compared to android's quad cores.
Also in terms of speed.. how does a dual core windows phone holds on its own compared to a Android device.
I would still like to buy both in 2021.
when it comes to smart phones, there is only 'ONE' winner
Why did your hands shake that bad with the lumia ? i never get that with my 920... Is the ois worse than the 920 ? :S
Fabulous video as per usual. Damn this would be a hard choice if I were shopping around for a new phone. Pretty glad I'm not!
If the HTC one went with around 8mp it would be perfect. I hate not having any zooming capability or cropping on my one. The software is great though... Maybe in the next iteration.
Truth be told, I envy Michael Fisher's hair...
The HTC One isn't 5 inch, it's 4.7. Nice comparison vid btw
Great review as usually.
Still don't get it huh? It's not how many MP the camera has but what they do with them.
i swear if only the lumia 1020 had a better app store it would be my daily driver no questions asked
Wait 5 inch? This video is one of the best you've produced Michael but you made quite some mistakes with the specs.
I'm gonna wait a year or two for actual phone upgrades. The 1020 JUST came out & the fact that it can actually be compared to an older phone is sad. I don't appreciate these phone companies putting out side grades rather than straight up upgrades.
I'm a bit confused though. It seems like the 920/925/928 still takes better low light photos, and has better stabilization than the 1020. If this is so, that's stupid, as this should be EVERY bit better than the 920/925/928.
The 1020 running android will be the only way Nokia can resurge back.
Forgot to mention the reason wich is the camera
now it's time for the Samsung Galaxy S4 Zoom to vs the Nokia Lumia 1020
The Lumia looks so unique
Not sure if it is in the works, but can you please a comparison video of all 4 major cell cameras when recording video (s4, one, iphone 5s, 1020) in the later future? The iphone 5s should be just around the corner, and and I'm due for an upgrade next month lol.
NOKIA WHY WINDOWS PHONE!!
WHY NOT ANDROID!!
I really like Nokia but windows phone is holding my back
Microsoft bay Nokia
the hardware is let down by its Operating System. Crazy Windows 8 WTF NOKIA.....Camera is great especially in natural light. But if you want a decent smart phone even the Iphone 4s walks all over it.
Ivan Tovu-Kalott well partly this was true but now here I am in 2017 using a NOKIA 6 so nope Nokia hasn't been forgotten like u said
Nokia is the king when it comes to camera. Nokia will regain it's title pretty soon.
you said it excels lumia about extra camera fx option but i dont see a object removing stuff in zoe. can someone explain it what does zoe actually do? can it do animations partial animations object removal and all other stuff lumia does?
song in background in video demo, "aadat - jal the band"
What the best smartphones for shooting video and picture?thanks you so much..
Yet another phone bowing down to the One.