History of Karachi, Part 2, From Abdullah Shah Gazi to Sindhi dynasties

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 01. 2024
  • References
    Abdullah Shah Ghazi
    Tafheemaat by Ustaz Imam Syed Abul Ala Modudi, part 3
    Al-Tareekh by Imam Dhahabi Volume 3
    Deybul and Arab Conquests of Sindh
    ChachNama by Ali Kufi and Mirza Kalech Baig
    kitaab e Futooh ul Buldan by Balazari
    Arabs in Sindh by John Jahangir Bede
    Karachi Islands
    The Indus Delta Country: A Memoir, Chiefly on Its Ancient Geography and History by Malcolm Robert 1884
    Entry Route of Muhammad Bin Qasim in South Eastern Sindh. Journal of the Pakistan Historical Society 45(4)
    Manora by Dr Abdul Hameed Khan
    Sindh's Political History
    History and Culture of Sindh by Ansar Zahid Khan
    Contributions of India to Hadith literature by Ishaq 1955
    Journal of the Pakistan Historical Society, Volume 41 1993
    Memoirs of Seth Naomal Hotchand
    The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians
    The Muhammadan Period · Volume 1
    By Henry M. Elliot · 1867
    Kurrachee: Past, Present And Future 1890
    By: Alexander F. Baillie
    Karachi's Archeological Sites
    DISCOVERIES OF NEOLITHIC SETTLEMENTS IN MALIR RIVER VALLEY, SINDH, PAKISTAN
    Dr Shamshad Akhtar
    Muhammad Rafique Dhanani
    ARCHAEOLOGICAL FIELD RESEARCH IN PAKISTAN SINCE INDEPENDENCE: AN OVERVIEW
    M. Rafique Mughal
    Pakistan Archaeology
    Number 8-1972
    Muhammad Ishtiaq Khan
    Karachi in the Mirror of History, Usman Damohi
    ____________________________________________________________________
    IN THIS CHAPTER WE DISCUSS
    Intro :
    Is Debal actually Karachi? 1:00
    4 forts of Karachi 2:12
    Debal is Karachi 6:14
    Muhamad Nafs e Zakiya and His movement, his arrival in Karachi, and his resistance against Abbasids 8:12
    Abdullah Al Ashtar aka Abdullah Shah Gazi, how he became a threat to Abbasids 17:05
    Mohaditheen of Karachi, Traditionists of Hadith mentioned in Siha e Sittah (The Six Authentic) 21:00
    Sindhi Dynasties, Turks in Karachi, Karachi mentioned as Kurrashee by Turk Admiral in 1557, Moguls capture Karachi 24:22
    Kalhora-Baloch dispute, how a Rishta dispute turned into a war, Karachi falls to Balochs 29:43
    Kalhora Talpur-Baloch Dispute, how a murder brought Balochs back to Karachi 33:30
    the arrival of Hindus in Karachi, Bhojumal builds Karachi 35:30
    oin this channel to get access to perks:
    / @shafaatali007

Komentáře • 324

  • @asgharumar8364
    @asgharumar8364 Před 5 měsíci +7

    شفاعت یقین نہیں آرہا کہ آپ اتنا علمی کام کرسکتے ہیں ،،،آپ کا کامیڈین امیج اور یہ شعبہ ! آپ مجموعہ ضدین ہیں،,,,,میں حیرت میں ہوں۔۔۔۔

  • @nanjit
    @nanjit Před 5 měsíci +11

    This is what should be taught in Pakistan Studies, Good Podcast very informative

    • @muhammadharis8006
      @muhammadharis8006 Před měsícem

      Hahaha bro iska 10% such bhi agr parrha dia hota toh aj India Pakistan 1 hota

  • @sabahatrubab5156
    @sabahatrubab5156 Před 5 měsíci +16

    The research is commendable. I couldn't scroll down without completing the video. I had no idea that an anchor could have gone so deep in history. You did great 👍 👏 👍

    • @ShafaatAli007
      @ShafaatAli007  Před 5 měsíci +3

      Glad you enjoyed it!

    • @KhawjaAziz
      @KhawjaAziz Před 5 měsíci

      Brilliant scholarship with your amazing research is greatly appreciated, Thank you

  • @gmunnar7260
    @gmunnar7260 Před 5 měsíci +7

    آپکی ماشاءاللہ بہت اچھی تحقیق و کاوش ھے ۔۔۔ ایسی تحقیق کے لیے آپکو مشورہ دونگا کہ آپ سندھ کے پرانے دانشوروں سے بھی رابطے میں رھیں کیوں کہ انکی تحقیقات سے آپکو بہت زیادہ فائدا ھوگا ۔۔۔۔۔

  • @naumanrahoo7296
    @naumanrahoo7296 Před 5 měsíci +9

    I am was surprised to watch this series of documentaries that how a commendabale research made by you can miss the epoch Samma dynasty the last indigenous Sindhi people to rule over their ancestral land who is glorry is even praised by great poet of Sindh in his poetic master piece " Shah jo risalo"

    • @ShafaatAli007
      @ShafaatAli007  Před 5 měsíci +2

      You are right, the reason Saama Dynasty is not mentioned here is because of its significance with reference to the history of Karachi. All Sindhi dynasties mentioned here are used because of their importance in reference to the history of the region which we call Karachi.

  • @TalkofSage
    @TalkofSage Před 6 měsíci +8

    آپ کی کراچی کے اوپر تحقیق بے انتہا قابل ستائش ہے اور کراچی والو ک لیے لازوال تحفہ اور علمی میدان بہت بڑی جست و کوشش ہے، تہ دل سے آپ کے لیے دعا گو،
    ایک کراچی والا۔

  • @zainulabideen6218
    @zainulabideen6218 Před 5 měsíci +3

    I don't think I have ever heard about this history of Karachi even though I've spent my entire life here. Thank you so much!

  • @amintahami8817
    @amintahami8817 Před měsícem

    Mashallah zabardast... Informative season...

  • @Pahchnakyenahipahchna
    @Pahchnakyenahipahchna Před 5 měsíci +1

    بہت شکریہ اپ کی بدولت کراچی اور اس کی نوائی ایریو کے بارے میں کافی کچھ جاننے کو ملا ۔
    خاص طور پر اس ریجن کے بارے میں ۔
    ہم اپ کے اس کاوش کو دل سے سراتے ہیں

  • @ghayoorabbas6417
    @ghayoorabbas6417 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Thank you shafaat ali.. app ne behtreen tehkik ki hai.. poora ilmi podcast hai ye..

  • @alimechs
    @alimechs Před 6 měsíci +5

    Buhat acha kaam kartay hain aap or video bhi khoob banatay hain aap bus isi tarhaan banatay rahain

  • @ZenKhalil
    @ZenKhalil Před 5 měsíci +6

    Brilliant. Thank you Shafaat for thorough research & shedding light on the history of Sindhi Region which has been hidden since Decades from many. Keep it up bro. Der alaaaa

  • @HaqShanaas
    @HaqShanaas Před 5 měsíci +5

    such an under rated channel. shafat bhai marvelous work you are doing

  • @ghufranbaig7687
    @ghufranbaig7687 Před 21 dnem

    Masha Allah,
    Shafaat bhai keep it up.
    Welcome done research.
    Thank you so much

  • @fahadbayg8781
    @fahadbayg8781 Před 5 měsíci +4

    Very informative historical research. Well done....! Sharafat Sahab.

  • @user-ve1jy6ds1r
    @user-ve1jy6ds1r Před 5 měsíci +2

    Very informative Shafaat sb, again, well done! 👍

  • @shahvader
    @shahvader Před 5 měsíci +3

    Great historical research work .👍

  • @imranayan4204
    @imranayan4204 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Shafqat Bhai apko dekh k bohat khushi hoei historical knowledge Dena acha laga apka bolny ka adaz bohat Pasand h

  • @hamzaalishah7309
    @hamzaalishah7309 Před 6 měsíci +2

    MashaAllah great work shafaat Ali keep it up❤️

  • @javaidnazir3720
    @javaidnazir3720 Před 5 měsíci

    Good 👍 information bohat khub

  • @kkamraanahsan173
    @kkamraanahsan173 Před měsícem

    Very interesting and informative. Keep up the good work sir 👌 👍

  • @hussainhanif5047
    @hussainhanif5047 Před 5 měsíci

    So far the best youtube podcast show! - Great work @shafaatali

  • @manzoorqureshi3180
    @manzoorqureshi3180 Před 5 měsíci

    Well done Shafaat. Great episode based on a big effort n research. Keep on contributing creative work. Thanks a lot. Stay blessed.

  • @user-cq3ko6fd5j
    @user-cq3ko6fd5j Před 15 dny

    Very informative impressive

  • @sohailbukhari8195
    @sohailbukhari8195 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Iss tarah ki deep research iss khity k liyay kabhi nahi hui weldone sharfat

  • @masoodqureshi7387
    @masoodqureshi7387 Před 3 měsíci

    Really amazing, a very thoughtful innovative approach to bring historical n archaeological aspects, a factual study should be told to students in schools.

  • @ahmedsiddiqui9966
    @ahmedsiddiqui9966 Před 5 měsíci +1

    The more I listen, the more I respect
    The more I learn, the more I bow down to the efforts he made to dig out tge real history of my beloved city, Karachi. Hatts off buddy, more success to you. Syed Shafaat Ali

  • @haseebwekr9892
    @haseebwekr9892 Před 5 měsíci +6

    Jaldi jaldi video kroaao sir jee part 3 ki.. bohat khoob information hai aur bohat hi interesting hai sirr.. Bss please jldi video pash kren sir bss intezar nhi ho rha hai ❤❤❤

    • @ShafaatAli007
      @ShafaatAli007  Před 5 měsíci +1

      کوشش ہوگی کہ ہفتے کی دوپہر تک اپلوڈ کر دوں۔ نہ کر سکوں تو پیشگی معذرت۔

  • @mansurbaloch6622
    @mansurbaloch6622 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Bro! Great work Enjoyed both parts

  • @mubeen44us
    @mubeen44us Před 5 měsíci +1

    Very informative 👏 i hope all new Pakistani generation learns this at school. Good work @Shafaat Ali

  • @Fivestar314
    @Fivestar314 Před 5 měsíci +2

    good information

  • @huzaifadurrani9724
    @huzaifadurrani9724 Před 5 měsíci +3

    It is always fascinating to listen your reaearch details about karachi, keep it up man!

  • @hidden6127
    @hidden6127 Před 5 měsíci

    بہت خوب

  • @syedali8625
    @syedali8625 Před 5 měsíci +3

    Surprisingly very deep and detailed research by you or your research team.well done Shafat Ali big thumbs up 👍

  • @MuhammadAbdullah-cq6mv
    @MuhammadAbdullah-cq6mv Před 5 měsíci

    Amazing research! Fantastic narration!

  • @princessflower7825
    @princessflower7825 Před 5 měsíci

    Shafqat bhai kia he achi knowledge de ap ne karachi or abdullah shah ghazi rehmatullah alh ke wel done

  • @surriyaarif173
    @surriyaarif173 Před 5 měsíci

    Zaberdast ❤

  • @Nina21258
    @Nina21258 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Excellent. Keep it up .

  • @sameramahmood2281
    @sameramahmood2281 Před 5 měsíci

    Lovely narration keep telling ❤

  • @Conversations_with_QT
    @Conversations_with_QT Před 3 měsíci

    Very comprehensive. I knew you just as a comedian but hats off to you man! Back to back watching. Stay blessed☺👼

  • @arifzaki1
    @arifzaki1 Před měsícem

    Your work is great and remarkable

  • @bxddiestax4738
    @bxddiestax4738 Před 5 měsíci

    Magnificent work

  • @anaskhanvlogs101
    @anaskhanvlogs101 Před 5 měsíci

    Most informative video....❤

  • @Nina21258
    @Nina21258 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Love your style of narration 👌

  • @mustafasultan6436
    @mustafasultan6436 Před 5 měsíci

    Beautifully explained.

  • @muhammadkashif7613
    @muhammadkashif7613 Před 5 měsíci

    Waiting for next episode ❤

  • @riazahmed-ir3vm
    @riazahmed-ir3vm Před měsícem

    Zbrdst

  • @fatimajabeen9828
    @fatimajabeen9828 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Thank you for this

  • @faisalalansari9024
    @faisalalansari9024 Před 5 měsíci +1

    جيتے رہو ۔۔۔۔ ❤

  • @user-xd9pf1bw5v
    @user-xd9pf1bw5v Před 2 měsíci

    Very nice ❤

  • @shahfahad8051
    @shahfahad8051 Před 6 měsíci +4

    Good content, good graphics. If you are looking for improvements, put your B camera at 15 degree, currently its at 10 degree or less. And take a face close up from B camera.

  • @urbanhawk84
    @urbanhawk84 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Much awaited

  • @sitarakhan788
    @sitarakhan788 Před 5 měsíci

    Bohat umda good

  • @OptimisticIslandVacation-ex4nl
    @OptimisticIslandVacation-ex4nl Před 5 měsíci +1

    U r right Karachi was part of Balochistan and the Hindu merchants came to Karachi after the Khan of Kalat admission ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @SamarNiaz29
    @SamarNiaz29 Před 5 měsíci +2

    thank you for documenting all of this for future generations.

  • @fakeersaleemmemon6799
    @fakeersaleemmemon6799 Před 6 měsíci +9

    I have remained chairman mazar committee of Abdullah shah ghazi for one year, searched thoroughly
    Mazar was built-in by one the decedent out of 7 decedents of
    Qalander of Sehwan.

    • @ahmadafzal8151
      @ahmadafzal8151 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Please respect call hazrat Abdullah shah gazi rahmatulla

    • @ahmedshahab4105
      @ahmedshahab4105 Před 5 měsíci

      Ok you are from jadoo tona and baba industry of India/Pakistan. Got it.

    • @m.aryaanamiri2755
      @m.aryaanamiri2755 Před 3 měsíci

      @@ahmadafzal8151 he wasn't a prophet or a sahabi.

    • @creativetimaster2962
      @creativetimaster2962 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@m.aryaanamiri2755Mery Bhai Hazrat srf Prophets ya Sahabi's k lye likha nhi jata ,, yeh Buzurg or respect k lye ap apny dada k name k Sath b lga skty h tw itna baray Buzurg e Deen k Sath tw lgna chye bqi apki Marzi h

    • @m.aryaanamiri2755
      @m.aryaanamiri2755 Před 2 měsíci

      @@creativetimaster2962 Konsa Ghada Apne dada ke Saath Hazrat Laga ta hai?Hazrat aik honorary title hai reserved for sahabas and prophets.

  • @ammadali5859
    @ammadali5859 Před měsícem

    Wait for 3rd part sir

  • @shakeelmemon4888
    @shakeelmemon4888 Před 5 měsíci

    Good job❤❤❤

  • @sabidolati
    @sabidolati Před 5 měsíci

    Good info...bani umaya ki nslain,shoro sy he sadat all e rSool s.a.ww k peechy hyn

  • @fahmed84
    @fahmed84 Před měsícem

    Thanks

  • @fawadmajeed5103
    @fawadmajeed5103 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Shafaat Bhai Apki Research Bohat Hi Shandaar Hai , Aisa Feel Hua Ke Sara Manzar Khud Dekh Raha Hoon ❤
    Bohat Zabardast
    Kafi Arsay Baad Parha Likha Abchor Mila Hai , Jisay Samjhanay Ka Tareeqa Ata Hai
    Allah Taala Apoo Khush Rakhain ❤❤
    Main Kabhi Kabhi Proses Likh Leta Hoon Aur Mera Fav Period Is Pre And Post Partition , Waqt Milay To Us Daur Pe Bhi Video Banayr Ga
    Quaid E Azam Ya Gandhi Ya Lord Mount Batten Ke Ilawa Kuch Ho To Acha Hoga , Aide Waqiyaat Jinhain Chota Jaan Kar Nazar Andaaz Kar Diya Gaya Ho
    Shukriya

  • @asjahan7748
    @asjahan7748 Před 5 měsíci +2

    meray bhai, aaj knowledge bomb par knowledge bomb ka hit horaha hai, nice one, good job. sindh assembly aur bilawal ki taleem-e-balighan mai include hona chahiyay, maybe their attutude toward karachi might change

  • @mhamzaimran2364
    @mhamzaimran2364 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Karachi should be a separate province, this is the only way Karachi can prosper.

  • @fatimaahmed1106
    @fatimaahmed1106 Před 5 měsíci

    Best channel got people who love history like me

  • @Junaidjoosani
    @Junaidjoosani Před 6 měsíci +6

    Amazing work :)
    Feedback : Will it be possible to have these vlogs with english subtitles, if yes then it would be really big help

  • @ayeshafareedsyed8560
    @ayeshafareedsyed8560 Před měsícem

    Waiting for part 3

  • @urbanhawk84
    @urbanhawk84 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Simply amazing❤

  • @syed4494
    @syed4494 Před 6 měsíci

    I was waiting for your new vlog

  • @bushrasheikh7761
    @bushrasheikh7761 Před 5 měsíci +1

    MashaAllah Mutal’a Pakistan ki sari kami puri kr rhe han aap

  • @muhmmadmudasirkhan4166
    @muhmmadmudasirkhan4166 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Aslam u aliqum
    Dear kindly change some voice as it is signature for comedian shafat.
    Although it is a great excellent job to enlighten us as a nation.
    And a work you always want to do as a legacy.
    Allah bless you more. . . !

  • @shaheenlibrary137
    @shaheenlibrary137 Před 5 měsíci +1

    السلامُ علیکم ۔ کراچی کی تاریخ میں اولیاء اللہ آل رسول علیہ الصلوۃ والسلام کا تذکرہ اپ نے فرمایا بہت اچھا لگا برائے مہربانی تین ہٹی والے سید نور علی شاہ المعروف نوری شاہ بابا رح کے بارے میں بھی کوئی تحقیق بیان فرمایئے وہ حضرت عبداللہ شاہ غازی بابا رح سے بھی پہلے کے شہید ہیں ۔

  • @shahid19991
    @shahid19991 Před 5 měsíci

    Xcllent

  • @umerbyheart8407
    @umerbyheart8407 Před 6 měsíci

    Thank u Shafaat Ali bhai

  • @fmrana
    @fmrana Před 4 měsíci

    Can u provide link to Part 3. Couldn't find it when I searched. I did find a full version of this series. Will chk if part 3 is embedded in it.

  • @mycookingpassion6672
    @mycookingpassion6672 Před měsícem

    Kitne fozol log theye intihayi betuki baaton pr jung krtye thy
    Jihalt ki intiha thee
    Aapne bohat achcha work out kiya haye👍👍

  • @daniyaljunejo2821
    @daniyaljunejo2821 Před 5 měsíci

    Assalam o aliekum. Sir, Part 3 kab aa raha hai? I've been waiting ever since part 2 was aired.

  • @durr-enayab2913
    @durr-enayab2913 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Great history of Karachi.

  • @sagarsahab2245
    @sagarsahab2245 Před 5 měsíci

    Kon sa book parha hai ap ne?
    Thora hmhe b batayen, or wo kahan se mil sakta hai book?
    And onething more, jo book parha hai us ki pic to bhejen.

  • @somerandomthoughts7403
    @somerandomthoughts7403 Před 5 měsíci

    It's amazing ❤

  • @ejaziqbal8637
    @ejaziqbal8637 Před 5 měsíci +1

    ASALAMO ALAIKUM,please commentary regarding the Great Tipu Sultan is required.

  • @user-xe9dv8yq1k
    @user-xe9dv8yq1k Před 6 měsíci +3

    History of kelakot :Rawal Siddh Devraj, V.No. 909-1030 (AD 852-973) and Jam Lakha Fulani were contemporaries. 2 Jam Lakha Vs.No. Became the ruler of Kelakot in 901 (844 AD) History of kelakot :Jam Lakha Jadecha Bhati's capital 'Kelakot' was situated eight-nine kos (25 km) south of Bhuj city in Kutch region and five kos (15 km) away from the sea coast. It is said that he had built a series of seven kots in the hills along the Bhadresar river in the Kutch peninsula and in addition to these, he had built eight more kots at a distance of fifteen kos from Rajkot. These eight coats were collectively called 'Aathkot'. Local people believe that he named his capital 'Kairkot' in memory of his queen Kair, which later came to be known as 'Kelakot'. During his reign Kelakot state was under Nagarthatta Pargana of Sindh Pradesh.

  • @solomonlalani
    @solomonlalani Před 5 měsíci

    Shafaat: excellent work. I'm happy for you to stand out in the crowd. Keep it up!
    @10:03 there seems some error. You mentioned Fatimid empire during the life of Muhammad al-Nafs al-Zakiyya. That can't be true. al-Zakiyya died in 762, while Fatimid Caliphate was established in 909. Please check out. Thanks
    Sulaiman Lalani

    • @ShafaatAli007
      @ShafaatAli007  Před 5 měsíci +1

      Thank you Salman bhai for your feedback. I haven't mentioned Fatamid empire but Fatamid movement against Banu Ummaiya that was lead by Nafs e Zakiya.

  • @syedbilalhassannaqvi
    @syedbilalhassannaqvi Před 6 měsíci

    I really enjoy your storytelling.

  • @MuhammadAli-gw1xh
    @MuhammadAli-gw1xh Před 6 měsíci

    peshori amazing videos ...big fan sir

  • @zahranyas
    @zahranyas Před 5 měsíci

    Yar dono parts or mazeed detail me banaye please

  • @arsalanyousafzai9254
    @arsalanyousafzai9254 Před 27 dny

    Shafaat bhai when is the next part coming ??

  • @aurangzebkhan3280
    @aurangzebkhan3280 Před 3 měsíci

    When Part 3 will release?

  • @rameshdhar4979
    @rameshdhar4979 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Nice presentation
    Full of brutality, mistrust & deceit. Humanity missing from start to end.

  • @lightyork8268
    @lightyork8268 Před 5 měsíci +1

    I hope there is part 3 in detail and talks about Karachi during British rule.My grandfather was professor in DJ Sindh college and Karachi was dominated by highly educated sindhi Hindus.Tragically all had to leave in 1947-after reaching india most were extremely successful-if you check out the list of top educational institutes in Bombay (now Mumbai) they were all started by ex professors of DJ Sindh college.Most successful builders in Mumbai are Sindhis.Sindhis in india are considered to be most modern,successful,educated and hardworking people unlike Pakistan where Sindhis are supposed to be lazy,and only after government job-I have always wondered whether this difference is due to them following different religions or it is because traditionally refugees are hardworking and successful or the third possible reason being that the educated rich class migrated leaving behind their poor brethren who coincidentally were Muslims.The third reason is more plausible .Even in case of the other migrants who came from India to Sindh -as in comment sections we generally hear that the Muhajir community is hard working and successful while in India the view about Muslims from UPetc(from where Muhajirs migrated) is that of a backward and uneducated community.
    It would be interesting to understand what makes Sindhis in India and Muhajirs in Pakistan more successful than the local population.
    Another major difference between india and Pakistan is that in india the local languages are prime while in Pakistan a language that is an import from India is more important than all four local languages.it’s in imaginable in india for any language except local language being the sole official language of that state.

    • @ubaidbaloch
      @ubaidbaloch Před měsícem

      Mery bhai let me explain it for you kisi ka lazy hona religion sy connect nh hota sindh k log chahy Hindu hon ya Muslim sab mihnat krty hen reason ye hy k yahan system corrupt he agy brh nh pata insan ek to Sindh me ppp ki government dunia ki sub sy corrupt party wo bh 25 salon sy govt me hy to education itna mila nh log ziada tar jagirdaron k zameno pr ghr bana kr beth ty hen to jin ko ghr nh wo kahan sy haq mangy gen or villages k jagirdar politics me hen to jo farmer hen ya unky zameno pr jo rhty hen vote unhi ko krty hen sub sy major problem ye hy second problem ye hy k Pakistan instable rha or sindh me separation tahreeken chlti rhi abhi bh chl rhi to ignore kia jarha hy govt level pr sindh ko daku raaaaj hy yahan rhi bat apki k ap yahan sy chly gye to Sindhi logon me DNA me hy business minded wo Muslim ho ya Sindhi frq nh prta tbhi ap jaldi agy nikal gye agr ap agriculture field sy hoty to same haryana bihar wala scene hota rhi bat muhajir ki to ye log manty nh hen pr ye hakeekat hy inke baron k pass kuch bh nh tha aj hi up men dekho Muslim community same halat me hy ye yahan akr successful isliye huye hen k partition k time pr sindhi bahot tadaaaad me india chaly gye businesses chor kr ghr chor kr to jo log ae India sy sub ko cities me ghr mily running businesses mily to unky liye easy hogaya tb itna shaoor tha nh k Muslim sindhi ya Hindu Sindhi jo yahan thy wo city shift hoty q k halat esy chl rhy thy to hr koi apny ghron me rha ye kuch basic reason hen or humari clashes bh bahot hui insy k ap Sindhi hen kahty hen nh hum muhajir hen even k muhajir koi nation nh hy ap jesy kahty ho hum sindhi hen ek kom hy na sindhi or doosri bat ye kahty hen humen alg state do sindh me esy to hoga nh k sindh k or tukre hon to ye major issues hen yahan

  • @sooper7888
    @sooper7888 Před 6 měsíci

    Good ❤

  • @alecbhatti8840
    @alecbhatti8840 Před 5 měsíci +1

    😊❤😊

  • @user-ww3fb5nr4q
    @user-ww3fb5nr4q Před měsícem

    sir ap se ek sawal krna hai time hai to bata den

  • @muhammadharis8006
    @muhammadharis8006 Před měsícem

    Bhai sahb 3rd part kahan hay

  • @jamalakhan
    @jamalakhan Před 5 měsíci

    tremenous

  • @user-ww3fb5nr4q
    @user-ww3fb5nr4q Před 5 měsíci

    ap ne kuch had sahi bataya

  • @TheHotOne_
    @TheHotOne_ Před 5 měsíci

    Just wana say "hats off to you" 👍

  • @s.h.chohan2891
    @s.h.chohan2891 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Another very informative episode Shafaat sb. However few observations.
    1. You style is very good. However from this style it appears as if Karachi was a metropolitan city in last 1000 years. No. There were human settlements in prehistoric era but no big city. In pre Islamic time Debol was a big city. But destroyed in earthquake in 8th century. Then it started by Bhojomal. Otherwise too small to be mentioned in any history or travelogue.
    2. Turkish Admiral Saeed was sent by probably Suleman the magnificent to recce this area. He wrote a book مراۃ العروس. He mentioned Gawader and Gujrat where he finally landed and travelled back to Istanbul thru today's Afghanistan, Uzbekistan and Azerbaijan. He didn't mentioned Karashi as this name was coined about 200 after him. I have that book if interested I can forward its PDF.
    3. Abdullah Ghazi story is right. He was hiding in this area as this was very thinly populated at that time so a good place for him to hide.
    4. My view point is Karachi area has never been part of Sindh and mostly neglected by Sindhi and Balochi rulers as there was no rich settlement here. That is why before Bhojomal it is not mentioned in any Sindhi or Balochi Gov archive.
    Even if you look at the geography of Karachi (may be use Google) you will see it is quite different from rest of the sindh.
    Anyway, I appreciate your efforts. Keep doing it. Will wait for your next episode.

  • @ashishjoshi11
    @ashishjoshi11 Před 6 měsíci +2

    Are Deval Hi sahi pronunciation hai .. DeBal bigada hua Pronunciation hai.. Deval Se Aage tha Dwarka jo Aaj Arab Sagar me dub chuka hai.. jiska kuchh hissa Bed Dwarka. Deev or Nagar Haveli ke Tor par Dikhta hai.. Jaha Somnath ka Mandir hai .. is jagar or iske Doobne ki Dastan Mahabharat Or Shrimad Bhagvat jesi Hindu Kitabon me Mojud hai .. Or ab ye archeological survey se bhi sabit ho chuka hai..

  • @Radiant9296
    @Radiant9296 Před 5 měsíci

    I would appreciate if you can provide your research links on the history of karanchi. Ty

  • @drfaisalsaeed2331
    @drfaisalsaeed2331 Před 6 měsíci

    Thank you bro