@Charles Stanford Frighteningly accurate. I can't remember if it was Alaska, Washington or Oregon (I was researching all three around the same time), but I read a few years ago that in at least one of those states, the #1 cause of meth-related deaths was drowning.
*criminally overlooked Also, Iron Giant was Vin Diesel's first opportunity to practice and grow his acting range for a later role that'd challenge the very concept of what it means to be an "actor" - Groot.
Two other things I would say are wrong are that it was a box-office bomb and it was one of the last 2D animated movies to be produced before CGI took over the animated film industry.
I love how this movie isn't just demonizing the army too. The General is clearly reasonable and doesn't want any bloodshed. The writing is super nuanced and balanced.
It's just like how Onward didn't demonize COLT BRONCO!!! COLT BRONCO!!! was just doing his job and wanted to get Ian and Barley home because he genuinely cared for their safety. Someone should give a medal to COLT BRONCO!!! COLT FRICKING BRONCO!!! YEAH!!!
It's because Prometheus has the most egregious example of running directly away from something instead of running perpendicular and getting out of the path of danger. And a character died because of it.
Hate to be that guy (that's a lie I love being that guy) but I've never seen The Iron Giant so technically you should have said figuratively not literally since I don't care.
You two are hilarious great job but honestly your on the internet saying that youve never seen iron giant and you dont care. if you didn't care you honestly wouldnt have typed that .most people that dont care about movies they havent seen dont waste their time to typing about it they ignore this movie and move on.
"I think that's enough fun for one day..." 😂 I watched that scene recently, the way Dean looks over the paper and sees the wave coming towards him and shakes with fear and pulls the paper up to cover his face. 😂
"He's offing those soldiers who are just following orders. Murder is murder" he cries at the robot The giant robot. The giant robot acting on his programming. Kinda like he was... following orders.
It's also the era it's set in, The 1950s was only a decade after World War II and the advent of the Cold War. There was a lot of fear of Communism spreading in the years following WWII due to the Korean War which broke out at decades start
For example, the motive may be homage, but the action was sinning! Good luck with history Jeremy! (Love the content ofc tho, keep up the good sinning!)
It is, yet it makes no sense in the context. Imagine somebody sees a dying man in a ditch and saves them. That man they saved later is revealed to be a serial killer. Nobody is going to judge the good samaritan for trying to help somebody in pain.
Including when hogarth taped his flashlight torch to his gun wouldn't it just be shot anyway even though it's a BB gun I'm surprised that he didn't sin that! Just me?
To be fair, a "fallout protective shelter" and a "ground-zero nuclear blast protective shelter" are two wildly different things, and they make a point of that.
I was thinking that, there was mention of the fallout shelter but the general says "There's no way to survive this," and Dean says "It wouldn't matter." So it's clear everyone (except maybe Mansley) is well aware that the fallout shelter won't save them from a direct hit. Which makes sense in context, they wouldn't build a more sturdy shelter in a small remote town in Maine, nowhere near any major population center or important military installation. No reason to believe the Soviets would nuke them there, but there might still be radioactive fallout from more distant nukes dropped on more important targets.
@@benn454he other one does exist ever since Hiroshima. Have you ever heard about a Japanese guy that did survived the explosion in the ground zero because he was on the basement of a building?
Michael Fisher These assholes in your reply section couldn’t hurt a fly. That’s why they play it up so much as to sound like people who COULD rip wings off of a butterfly, when in reality these twinkle toes would fucking cry if a lobster got cooked alive. I’ll be honest, I save ants lives and try like hell to not cry when I see people throw live lobsters in boiling water, but hey, I’m God. All of my creations deserve life except humans who rip wings off of butterflies.
fun fact: the whole reason Vin Diesel voiced Groot is because the director of Guardians of the Galaxy was impressed and reminiscent of his performance in Iron Giant. Like he legitimately specifically asked for Vin!
Okay. Nuke goes off, creates EMP temporarily shutting down the self repair thing. Train hits him, no EMP instant repair. That's about all I can guess. The rest are pretty spot on.
Beautifully done piece for an underrated film. Tim McCanlies, co writer of this film, was my roommate when we went to film school. He went on to have a modest career which includes the creation of "Smallville" the series. I am very happy for him.
This is a masterpiece, I was about 10 when it came out and really stuck with me as I got older and older, consequently I remember the superman series too, but only in passing (though I watched it all) in my opinion this film is vastly better then smallville
It’s a travesty that crap like “Trolls”, “Angry Birds”, and sh*t animated films are financially successful while “The Iron Giant”, one of the best animated films of the past 20 years, wasn’t!
The reward for true art is not money, but rather being remembered in history. A lot of painters like van Gogh and el Greco die penniless and poor but their works are forever treasured by posterity.
It's a sad truth, but none the less an easy to understand one. You watch a quality movie, and that experience sticks with you for years, but you watch a shit cash grab movie like Trolls, or Angry Birds, and you forget about it halfway through, leaving you easily convinced to watch it again, for the first time....
Idk about you guys but I think 3 sins AT LEAST should have been removed for the scene with Dean talking to the trucker guy. Because that sh*t is funny.
And he sinned the giant for passing out when its an ALIEN robot. If he could sin the giant for passing out then why didn't he sin it for loosing its memory after crashing on earth?
I'm surprised you didn't sin the fact that the giant saved the kid when he fell and he didn't die. As if landing on a giant metal hand is better than landing on snow
They didn't fall that far before he caught them. And since Hogarth rides in his hand he probably got a feel on how to hold humans. Plus that little jerk of motion with his arm cushioned the fall for them. At least that's what I think.
Jeremy: “History will judge you by your actions and their outcomes, not your motives”. Also Jeremy: “those innocent soldiers were just following orders”
Prepared for a ton of angry comments. Still a great movie of it's time. If you didn't remove a *SIN* for that *Tearful Superman* you would had hell to pay
CinemaSins: "Hang tight, everyone! I'm going to sin The Iron Giant!" Everyone: "What?! He Wouldn't!" CinemaSins: "One..." Everyone: "He would." CinemaSins: "Two..." Everyone: "No! Don't do it!" CinemaSins: "Ding!"
i laughed when he taped that giant flashlight to the end of his gun. the lamp covers all of the barrel and he'd just shoot it off. that's probably what a kid would do though, so i thought it was great
Lucas Tigy I’ve seen this movie no joke about 35 times. EVERY time since I saw it as a little kid, that flashlight has bothered me haha. Other than that hands down my personal favorite movie of all time. But that damn flashlight...
As a guy who grew up with this movie, I used to tape flashlights to my bb guns in the exact same way to replicate this movie and never thought of it like that so you're totally right lol
To be honest Cinemasins should have put that as a sin for the torch light to be shot anyway and he should have taken of a sin for Dean's "Yeah?!" scene.
@@justsomeguy1014 but cinemasins "sins" are 95% bullshit. Watch the film directly before watching one of his vidoes are you'll realise how lazy he is with criticism. And yes some of them are jokes but you can't back up the wrong criticism by saying "it's a joke" when there is no humour in it at all
x KGRB yeah I’m not here to support cinemasins at all I think he’s a complete sellout and has failed to do what he says he does hence why I said “I came here to tell him to fuck off”
@@Kriss25Toku Well, you have to admit it's a great animated movie, sure there could be "Cartoon/fantasy" physics moments but it has a strong mood of the story.
There's actually a pretty cool documentary about how messed up the production of this movie was. "What if a gun had a soul and didn't want to be a gun"
if a gun had a soul, why would it not want to be a gun? That's like saying "What if a boy had a soul and didn't want to be a man?" Hm... maybe I'll try writing a children's story about a gun who's nervous about being a gun, until he saves a S. African farm family from being beaten, r*ped to death in front of their child who was then boiled alive. (yes it happened; only in my story it wouldn't happen because dad used gun). Actually, I like that idea... Not the r*pe/murder, the idea of a gun as a hero... I'll have to think on that.
Fact:The creators of the movie were originally going to title it:"The Iron Man" but they didn't want it to be confused with the other comic book character
This is definitely my favorite movie. I'm so glad it didn't break 100 sins. I know they're inconsequential, but sometimes meaningless things have meaning.
Whenever someone starts asking about a sequel, I keep thinking that it could only happen in modern day, Hogarth is a very old man, and his grandchildren (great grandchildren?) encounter the Iron Giant, who returns to Rockwell, having rebuilt himself over the preceding decades and only now being complete due to climate change melting the Greenland glacier he was stuck in at the end of the original film. I would imagine the main plot being mostly a rehash of the original, with xenophobia being prevalent with a fear of AI thrown in. The antagonist would likely be someone trying to hack or reverse engineer the giant without regard for it's potential suffering, and a nature vs nurture argument being the moral center.
How about pick up where the giant came from,if it went for that bump he would have been a gun,what if he was a scout for an invasion,but there's some sort of message or something
I am two minds about that. Mind 1: I second your idea along with a hint of his origins. Mind 2: They will mess it up like The Incredibles or it will turn into a franchise and that will ruin everything
This was my son's favorite movie when he was growing up, it was something we could always watch together ❤ Great memories spending time with my little guy.
It’s crazy whenever Vin Diesel do any animated movie they give him little to no lines: iron giant and Groot/ baby Groot. That’s when everyone enjoys his acting 😂😂
“This movie’s parents are so bad they should be in a Stephen King adaptation.” Well it does take place in Maine, where weird stuff always happens (like a *giant metal robot* crashing into a small town). 😂😂😂
"You're like Hitler, but even Hitler cared about Germany or something!" Cinemasins sinning Iron Giant after some many years of praising it, ladies and gentlemen.
NitroProductions0123 I always thought the junkyard artist kinda looked like RDJ...... 👀👀👀 Tom Holland and RDJ for the live action remake of The Iron Giant???
i'm honest tired of people say "There is nothing wrong with my favorite movie" because in reality no movie is perfect, For example the pixar movie the are just like by majority of people and "graet" reviews but doesn't mean the are perfect
Didnt point out that when the 2 kids fell and The Giant caught them, they still were falling onto metal, which is still as hard, if not harder than snow covered ground. Even if there was some give to the catch.
Actually a human being can survive a worse fall than that. They fell maybe 10-15 feet on their asses, so at worst they'll just have a few sprains, maybe a pelvic/tarsal fracture
Welshy I mean tbh it’s based on the 50 and Sputnik was a thing and everyone was on the hey because of nukes aliens and other space stuff so I’m sure people didn’t care about real ness. Yes I know its made in the 90s
I wish they had included scene showing Giants dream, yeah we liked the Mystery but it confirms that he’s part of an army of death bots just like him who conquer planets
Tafari TV that would make people ask a lot of questions like who made them, why are they being sent to conquer other planets, and are they all sentient or is it just the one who went to earth.
One of the falling kids has ugly brown shoes for some reason. Jeez, someone give the boy some sneakers! Hogarth has sneakers, falling boy #2 has sneakers, why must falling boy #1 be so poor?
Jonus Aguilar I’d love to do a remake, only if I was directing it. I’d fight the studios for total control of the project. Damn the consequences, practical effects not to much CGI! We’re building an actual Iron Giant! F*ck the price we’re making art! We’re gonna stick so damn close to the animated movie/original source, but not be afraid to take chances and do something different! We’re gonna attempt to stay as true to the heart of the story as long as possible! This will be a giant goddamn love letter by fans of the Iron Giant! We’ll also dive deeper into the backstory of the Iron Giant while sticking to what everyone has unofficially come to agree upon.
Android 19 then that argument can be made with foreign soldiers killing our troops since we are seen as a threat to them. The whole point is that the giant isn’t morally wrong for attacking when he was attacked, for he was threatened
0:14 Cinema Sins: "In the eye of a hurricane there is-" Me: while sobbing because Burn is going to destroy me after Hurricane "Quiet for host a moment, a yellow sky"
Even though the Iron Giant is one of my all time favorite animated 90's films, i realize that it has it's ups and downs just like all movies, but that's okay because a movies ups and downs is what makes it interesting.
4:42 Her name is Annie dude, not Rachel. The sin still stands though: Strange man at the door, the middle of the night, nearest neighbors are probably miles away, and its only you and your adolescent child home. This lady is WAY to trusting.
We got another Muriel from Courage the Cowardly Dog lmao. Annie legit couldn't take a hint when Hogarth was obviously pissed at Kent for asking too much, then she suggests him to take some suspicious rando for sightseeing??
"THAT MISSLE IS TARGETED TO THE GIANTS CURRENT POSITION!! WHERE'S THE GIANT MANSLEY"?!?! Gets me every time.
Gaz that line deserves to have three sins removed.
@@disobey5615 indeed it did.
I love this line. I havent watched this movie in at least a decade but that line stuck in my head and its hysterical
@@DecimateTheWeak100 Same
! 😂
"MISSLE IS TARGETED TO THE GIANTS CURRENT POSITION" BTW how is that even possible?? well, it isn't.
As someone who lives in Maine, you'd be surprised at how many people jump into lakes in October... It's quite concerning, actually
Yeah if there's no sea ice it's beach season.
OMG, wow hahaha
Yeah I remember doing shit like that out in bar harbor :D. Good memories
@JT Watts PPFFFT IT IS
@Charles Stanford Frighteningly accurate. I can't remember if it was Alaska, Washington or Oregon (I was researching all three around the same time), but I read a few years ago that in at least one of those states, the #1 cause of meth-related deaths was drowning.
Should of taken off a sin for the scene with Dean on street
“Hey!”
Yeah?
“Your right in the middle of the road!”
YEAAAH??
“Alright”
Yup
I thought the same thing lol I LOVE that scene.
That made me literally LOL!
Rough day for Dean 😂
The only thing wrong with this movie is that it has been critically overlooked by people
That’s the only real sin.
Jon Harper I agree
*criminally overlooked
Also, Iron Giant was Vin Diesel's first opportunity to practice and grow his acting range for a later role that'd challenge the very concept of what it means to be an "actor" - Groot.
Two other things I would say are wrong are that it was a box-office bomb and it was one of the last 2D animated movies to be produced before CGI took over the animated film industry.
Maybe there could of been a sequel?
I love how this movie isn't just demonizing the army too. The General is clearly reasonable and doesn't want any bloodshed. The writing is super nuanced and balanced.
Brad Bird's movies are usually like that. Incredibles 2 was surprisingly well balanced.
Iron Giant is routinely on AFN.
It's just like how Onward didn't demonize COLT BRONCO!!! COLT BRONCO!!! was just doing his job and wanted to get Ian and Barley home because he genuinely cared for their safety. Someone should give a medal to COLT BRONCO!!!
COLT FRICKING BRONCO!!! YEAH!!!
WHERES THE GIANT MANSLY?
@@EverettBurger, what's AFN? I'm from the UK, I don't think I've ever heard of it. 🤔
Since the Iron Giant came out before Prometheus shouldn’t everyone retroactively have gone to the Iron giant School of running away from things.
Yes
Or the hogarth school of running away from things
Hario Dinio finally an answer
Maybe, but they sinned Prometheus first xDD So that's why it is what it is lol
It's because Prometheus has the most egregious example of running directly away from something instead of running perpendicular and getting out of the path of danger. And a character died because of it.
*Cinemasins:* Everything wrong with The Iron Giant
*Literally everyone:* Hey, we don't do that here
Yeah...
We dont.
Its a Taboo
Iron giant is on the pedestal
Hate to be that guy (that's a lie I love being that guy) but I've never seen The Iron Giant so technically you should have said figuratively not literally since I don't care.
I was literally about to write the same comment.
You two are hilarious great job but honestly your on the internet saying that youve never seen iron giant and you dont care. if you didn't care you honestly wouldnt have typed that .most people that dont care about movies they havent seen dont waste their time to typing about it they ignore this movie and move on.
“Hey!”
“Yeah?”
“You’re in the middle of the road!”
“YEAH!?”
“......ok.”
Ninjajack 64 should’ve definitely gotten a sin removal for that
"I think that's enough fun for one day..." 😂
I watched that scene recently, the way Dean looks over the paper and sees the wave coming towards him and shakes with fear and pulls the paper up to cover his face. 😂
@@combatwombat2134 the funniest scene in Iron Giant
Best part from any movie EVER.
Ninjajack 64 should of taken a sin off for that
"He's offing those soldiers who are just following orders. Murder is murder" he cries at the robot
The giant robot.
The giant robot acting on his programming.
Kinda like he was... following orders.
I was only following orders *incredibles movie robot at the trials*
True
Also it kinda reminds me of the daleks and the cybermen from doctor who
Fact
Good soldiers follow orders
You missed a sin
The bolt the kid recieves at the end was recovered from a nuclear blast. That shit is radioactive as hell
Maybe they're trying to tie up loose ends?
It was the 50s, people were going out of their way to be near some sort of radiation. It hasn't changed much either.
We don’t know how much time has passed and if it’s still radioactive
@@dustyrusty6554 ever heard of Chernobyl? That went down years ago and it's still radioactive as all hell
ThatGuyOnCZcams yes
Still my favorite cartoon of all time. Also, that "Vin Diesel made me cry" sin removal was perfect.
It should have wipped out the sin counter.
Every two years, I forget that Vin Diesel voiced the Iron Giant. And every two years, I am just as shocked to remember.
This movie was so emotionally provoking to me as a kid and still is to me, a full grown adult.
I still nearly cry
It's also the era it's set in, The 1950s was only a decade after World War II and the advent of the Cold War. There was a lot of fear of Communism spreading in the years following WWII due to the Korean War which broke out at decades start
“History will judge your actions and their outcomes, not your motives.”
That....actually was a good line. (2:27)
Ikr. That's a pretty deep quote
Isn't it a rewording of what Rachel said in Batman begins?
For example, the motive may be homage, but the action was sinning! Good luck with history Jeremy! (Love the content ofc tho, keep up the good sinning!)
Unless you're Hitler. In which case both are criticized. Or Caesar. Or Joseph McCarthy. Or the Confederacy in the Civil War. Or the Crusaders.
It is, yet it makes no sense in the context.
Imagine somebody sees a dying man in a ditch and saves them. That man they saved later is revealed to be a serial killer. Nobody is going to judge the good samaritan for trying to help somebody in pain.
Cinemasins: Everything Wrong with The Iron Giant
Everyone: Nothing, the answer is nothing!
I never liked the movie that much.
I love the movie to death, but luckily I'm opened to criticism 😆
Remember, no movie is without sin!
It never got the box office it deserved
@@Antasma1 because not everyone saw it back then
“Hey!”
“Yeah?”
“You’re right in the middle of the-“
“YEAH?!”
Scene had me rolling, where is my sin
removed?
Including when hogarth taped his flashlight torch to his gun wouldn't it just be shot anyway even though it's a BB gun I'm surprised that he didn't sin that!
Just me?
"How does a robot pass out?"
What, you've never seen a Windows Blue Screen of Death or a macOS kernel panic?
Or an Amiga Guru Meditation (for older fans...)
Neil O'Rourke, at least he didn’t get the blue screen of death.
You guys never seen a computer lag out?
@@rhysjonsmusic the bug of doom
or when your wii goes
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
To be fair, a "fallout protective shelter" and a "ground-zero nuclear blast protective shelter" are two wildly different things, and they make a point of that.
One exists, and the other doesn't.
Yep, one prevents death from radiation and the other prevents death from nuke
Yeah, you could have whatever shelter you wanted, if it's not some hundreds of metres in bedrock and a nuke hits you, you are just dead
I was thinking that, there was mention of the fallout shelter but the general says "There's no way to survive this," and Dean says "It wouldn't matter." So it's clear everyone (except maybe Mansley) is well aware that the fallout shelter won't save them from a direct hit. Which makes sense in context, they wouldn't build a more sturdy shelter in a small remote town in Maine, nowhere near any major population center or important military installation. No reason to believe the Soviets would nuke them there, but there might still be radioactive fallout from more distant nukes dropped on more important targets.
@@benn454he other one does exist ever since Hiroshima.
Have you ever heard about a Japanese guy that did survived the explosion in the ground zero because he was on the basement of a building?
Aw. Being mean to The Iron Giant is like pulling the wings off a butterfly
I like doing that
easy peasy
Michael Fisher These assholes in your reply section couldn’t hurt a fly. That’s why they play it up so much as to sound like people who COULD rip wings off of a butterfly, when in reality these twinkle toes would fucking cry if a lobster got cooked alive. I’ll be honest, I save ants lives and try like hell to not cry when I see people throw live lobsters in boiling water, but hey, I’m God. All of my creations deserve life except humans who rip wings off of butterflies.
Devon Dow, thanks man kudos to you
@@FlyxPat Yeah, no prob bob.
Vin Diesel voiced The Giant ?! Everyday's a School day...
Don't know where you're living, but every day's a homeschool day still around here.
still more lines than groot.
I am the Iron Groot
fun fact: the whole reason Vin Diesel voiced Groot is because the director of Guardians of the Galaxy was impressed and reminiscent of his performance in Iron Giant. Like he legitimately specifically asked for Vin!
AkumuKaeda cool
Cinemasins: Everything Wrong with The Iron Giant
The Internet: So you have chosen... death...
EXACTLY my thought
Too far, they've gone too far!
Oh Lord shut the f up.
He was hella ruthless on this one too
Yes
Shame this film wasn't promoted properly when it first came out.
Bigger shame is the fact that the director of the movie, Brad Bird, confirmed its not getting a sequel.
@@knuxiellombardiybur8645
It kinda doesn't need one, though.
I never needed one anyway
It's tied up well enough by the end
@@knuxiellombardiybur8645 perfection needs no sequel.
@@mincelamon1680
Well that ending is a bit of a plot hanger but yeah
Okay. Nuke goes off, creates EMP temporarily shutting down the self repair thing. Train hits him, no EMP instant repair. That's about all I can guess. The rest are pretty spot on.
The parts were also scattered way further away
That's a good theory right there.
Those parts were probably flying around in orbit, and it would have took some time to reenter the Earth's atmosphere if they reentered at all.
Only the feet have rockets so everything else is stuck until it falls back to Earth. Can't start repairing till everything can move again.
The emp theory but the town and surrounding areas were not effective
This movie was ahead of its time like Atlantis the Lost Empire and Treasure Planet. All three films are great.
Agreed
Stephen Lutz what about treasure planet
Underrated and good
Yo I loved Atlantis the lost city, I watched it so many times. Thanks for reminding me of that, I’m gonna watch it 👌🏻👍🏻
@@jacobrengen It's been so long since I watched that movie though. It is definitely an underrated movie.
Beautifully done piece for an underrated film. Tim McCanlies, co writer of this film, was my roommate when we went to film school. He went on to have a modest career which includes the creation of "Smallville" the series. I am very happy for him.
This is a masterpiece, I was about 10 when it came out and really stuck with me as I got older and older, consequently I remember the superman series too, but only in passing (though I watched it all) in my opinion this film is vastly better then smallville
You met a legend, half wrote one of the greatest movies every and a pretty good series. Hope you and him do well in the future
It’s a travesty that crap like “Trolls”, “Angry Birds”, and sh*t animated films are financially successful while “The Iron Giant”, one of the best animated films of the past 20 years, wasn’t!
quality content does not necessarily guarantee financial success, it's the sad truth.
The reward for true art is not money, but rather being remembered in history. A lot of painters like van Gogh and el Greco die penniless and poor but their works are forever treasured by posterity.
It's a sad truth, but none the less an easy to understand one. You watch a quality movie, and that experience sticks with you for years, but you watch a shit cash grab movie like Trolls, or Angry Birds, and you forget about it halfway through, leaving you easily convinced to watch it again, for the first time....
Trolls isn't crap. It's no masterpiece, like The Iron Giant, but it's still worth watching.
This is due to how the marketing for the movie was handled. Virtually non existent and that really hurt it.
"I am now the luckiest kid in America!"
Like there's some kid in Japan with 2 giant robots.
It's Japan. I'm sure every kid has at least 5 giant robots, 3 mech suits and enough weapons to make war machine cry
@@beebityboop your goddam right
There’s a kid in Japan who’s dad wants him to be IN the robot. Woof
Gundum, mekagodzilla, power ranger megazords, transformers... Should I continue
Don't get me started on the Ukrainian kid with 3 giant robots.
Idk about you guys but I think 3 sins AT LEAST should have been removed for the scene with Dean talking to the trucker guy. Because that sh*t is funny.
CinemaSins: *Sins cosmos for having their fingers on too many companies*
Disney: Pathetic
More like Nestlé as both are food companies (apparently).
Umbrella
Buy N' Large
And he sinned the giant for passing out when its an ALIEN robot. If he could sin the giant for passing out then why didn't he sin it for loosing its memory after crashing on earth?
Ivi-Tora Ineru I was gonna say, I mean those guys practically owned the earth
The idea that the Giant's hand, being slightly above the ground, would break the kids' fall any better than the ground would. *ding*
NorthWind Unlike the ground, the giant can move his hand down as he catches them so that the impact isn’t as jarring.
I think you mean "they survive this"
@@SasukeUchiha-qg4nn **ding**
@@cometvaudin2850 Yes, but he didn't, and not to mention the giant is made of iron while the ground has at least some snow.
Ding
“God damit did Vin Diesel just makes me cry?”
Might be one of the greatest cinema sins lines ever
Totally!
I'm surprised you didn't sin the fact that the giant saved the kid when he fell and he didn't die. As if landing on a giant metal hand is better than landing on snow
Christian Nik Unlike the ground, the giant can move his hand downwards as he catches the kids so that the impact is less jarring.
@@cometvaudin2850 the Giant could have. But if you watch the scene he didn't. Two sins.
They didn't fall that far before he caught them. And since Hogarth rides in his hand he probably got a feel on how to hold humans. Plus that little jerk of motion with his arm cushioned the fall for them. At least that's what I think.
Fair point
@@nickd5158 Plot twist, he wanted the blood on his hands
Jeremy: “History will judge you by your actions and their outcomes, not your motives”. Also Jeremy: “those innocent soldiers were just following orders”
padding the sin count. jeremy knows what he's doing.
That’s what they said about the nazis
Itachi Uchiha this comments describes you
Gilgamesh yes
Not to mention, if someone aims a tank at you, it's not murder, it's self defense.
"Did Vin Diesel just make me cry" Yes. Yes he did.
Prepared for a ton of angry comments. Still a great movie of it's time.
If you didn't remove a *SIN* for that *Tearful Superman* you would had hell to pay
don't worry most of the good movies he reviews he actually likes
He still does, I hear bird in th3 distance maybe it's a man who knows
YEAH I AGREE AS a KID I LOVED THIS MOVIE So if He Said's anything that is just wrong and not a SIN YOU GET THE 👎
My CZcams must be malfunctioning because this comment is 14 hours old and the video is 11 minutes old.
Where is the sequel!?
CinemaSins: "Hang tight, everyone! I'm going to sin The Iron Giant!"
Everyone: "What?! He Wouldn't!"
CinemaSins: "One..."
Everyone: "He would."
CinemaSins: "Two..."
Everyone: "No! Don't do it!"
CinemaSins: "Ding!"
What is the reference?, I can't remember.
@@nspcrazy1122 Toy Story 2
@@thewigglestunes9092 Oh, yeah. Thank you. I knew lt was animated, but lt just wasn't coming.
Remember, no movie is without sin!
Ha! I get the Toy Story 2 reference.
8:24 "I fear no man." "But that... Thing.."
(The Iron Giant's eyes going red and narrowing) "It scares me."
i laughed when he taped that giant flashlight to the end of his gun. the lamp covers all of the barrel and he'd just shoot it off. that's probably what a kid would do though, so i thought it was great
Lucas Tigy I’ve seen this movie no joke about 35 times. EVERY time since I saw it as a little kid, that flashlight has bothered me haha.
Other than that hands down my personal favorite movie of all time.
But that damn flashlight...
As a guy who grew up with this movie, I used to tape flashlights to my bb guns in the exact same way to replicate this movie and never thought of it like that so you're totally right lol
To be honest Cinemasins should have put that as a sin for the torch light to be shot anyway and he should have taken of a sin for Dean's "Yeah?!" scene.
Me: How dare you sin this movie?!!!
Also Me: *still clicks on video
I came here to tell him to fuck off
@@justsomeguy1014 He sinned Mad Max Fury Road but still very clearly loved it. As the tagline says, "No movie is without sin."
@@justsomeguy1014 but cinemasins "sins" are 95% bullshit. Watch the film directly before watching one of his vidoes are you'll realise how lazy he is with criticism. And yes some of them are jokes but you can't back up the wrong criticism by saying "it's a joke" when there is no humour in it at all
x KGRB yeah I’m not here to support cinemasins at all I think he’s a complete sellout and has failed to do what he says he does hence why I said “I came here to tell him to fuck off”
@@disco.theque you shut your mouth this is the one movie without sin
Jeremy "How can a finger see?"
Me" My fingers have seen some things".
And they'll ne.ver. tell...
"everything wrong with the iron giant"
Them's fighting words, CinemaSins, tread lightly.
Remember, no movie is without sin!
@@Kriss25Toku except the iron giant lol
@@panickedhispanic5933 it got sin anyway so fuck it
@@Kriss25Toku Well, you have to admit it's a great animated movie, sure there could be "Cartoon/fantasy" physics moments but it has a strong mood of the story.
@@WindiChilliwack story that will is going nowhere
The Iron Giant: 85 Sins
The Incredibles: 85 sins
*Perfection.*
spiderman into the spiderverse too !
Adventure Bonnie诗源小灰, nope. That’s only for films directed by Brad Bird.
@@untitledjunk03 oh . Thanks for the remind . The director created two of these movies .
He must really hate brad bird...
HalDaftman Animations, I DO NOT! I LOVE ALL of his films. (Including Tomorrowland, that one is underrated as hell)
1:44 siren head called. He wants his forest back!
Iron giant: *NO!*
There's actually a pretty cool documentary about how messed up the production of this movie was.
"What if a gun had a soul and didn't want to be a gun"
"What if guns has emotions"
I believe it would jam or break it own firing pin.
It will still be a gun just not shooting ppl
Like maybe it wanted to be a flame thrower....
if a gun had a soul, why would it not want to be a gun?
That's like saying "What if a boy had a soul and didn't want to be a man?"
Hm... maybe I'll try writing a children's story about a gun who's nervous about being a gun, until he saves a S. African farm family from being beaten, r*ped to death in front of their child who was then boiled alive. (yes it happened; only in my story it wouldn't happen because dad used gun).
Actually, I like that idea... Not the r*pe/murder, the idea of a gun as a hero... I'll have to think on that.
HOW DARE YOU ?
But seriously thanks for finally doing this movie. One of my favourites as a child.
Why did you take your shirt off?
Same bro still to today my favourite
15 hours ago by the way.
@@amanzeihedioha what ??
I can't believe you didn't remove for "Where's the giant, Mansley?!"
General be like: "I know, audience - I got this".
It's not even lampshading - that's some fourth wall shattering stuff right there.
Here's a rule: Any movie that has 100 sins or less is a PERFECT movie
Ummm.... Transformers (2007)?
@@berengustav7714 a flawless masterpiece
Especially when most of the sins are just dumb jokes
Just went on a tirade about how entitled star wars fans are so seeing this awesome comment is quite the refresher. I'm in!
We have very different interpretations of not having a single fault.
"History will remember your actions and their consequences, not your motives."
That sounds like a terrifying villain line. I gotta make mine say it.
Sin: this movie was considered a failure.
This was the best movie ever.
A failure in the box office due to its shit marketing
Blame Quest For Camelot for the bad marketing
Fact:The creators of the movie were originally going to title it:"The Iron Man" but they didn't want it to be confused with the other comic book character
Imperial Guard #28 Oh right Iron-Dick!
Oh yeah true! Also correct me if I'm wrong, but the book that this was based off of was titled the Iron Man too right?
Thanos: "I am inevitable!"
Iron Giant: "You what?"
Groot?
Porygon?
This is definitely my favorite movie. I'm so glad it didn't break 100 sins. I know they're inconsequential, but sometimes meaningless things have meaning.
Whenever someone starts asking about a sequel, I keep thinking that it could only happen in modern day, Hogarth is a very old man, and his grandchildren (great grandchildren?) encounter the Iron Giant, who returns to Rockwell, having rebuilt himself over the preceding decades and only now being complete due to climate change melting the Greenland glacier he was stuck in at the end of the original film. I would imagine the main plot being mostly a rehash of the original, with xenophobia being prevalent with a fear of AI thrown in. The antagonist would likely be someone trying to hack or reverse engineer the giant without regard for it's potential suffering, and a nature vs nurture argument being the moral center.
Go get that made I’d pay to watch it
How about pick up where the giant came from,if it went for that bump he would have been a gun,what if he was a scout for an invasion,but there's some sort of message or something
Siege Kall Wow! I really love this idea. Thank you for that comment 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I am two minds about that.
Mind 1: I second your idea along with a hint of his origins.
Mind 2: They will mess it up like The Incredibles or it will turn into a franchise and that will ruin everything
Wonder how long his parts would remain radioactive after sustaining a direct nuclear blast, too?
Biggest sin: The Iron Giant was 100% sent to Earth to destroy humanity and it’s absurdly lucky that he broke and forgot that was his job.
The iron giant is goku:
Discuss
@@moseistrujillo8300 no
Wait so Hogarth is Grandpa Gohan
You're talking about that extra scene with all those giants and the static right?
And how is that 100%?
This was my son's favorite movie when he was growing up, it was something we could always watch together ❤ Great memories spending time with my little guy.
It’s crazy whenever Vin Diesel do any animated movie they give him little to no lines: iron giant and Groot/ baby Groot. That’s when everyone enjoys his acting 😂😂
No sin off for Mansley's phone call with the general when he laughs at him with the oven mitt and tries to hang up the phone???
Zwergz 112 “no sin off for hilarious phone gag” *ding*
I see cinemasins have finally lived long enough to see themselves become the villain... 15 SECONDS OF OPENING LOGOS!
Ding
“This movie’s parents are so bad they should be in a Stephen King adaptation.”
Well it does take place in Maine, where weird stuff always happens (like a *giant metal robot* crashing into a small town). 😂😂😂
Beethoven’s Fidelio Why does that sound like the plot to a Live Action Disney TV show?
Wait, with those major tropes, you mean this ISN'T a Stephen King adaptation?
100th like
As someone who lives in maine, almost nothing interesting ever happens here.
If this really was Stephen King's Maine, a giant metal robot would be the least of their worries.
Mansley: Hogarth? What kind of a name is Hogarth? Might as well have named him Zeppo.
Cinemasins: That's Marxist!
The one who stole the wish from the NOVA?
You know you're desperate when you have to sin the iron giant.
After YEARS of Jeremy praising the hell out of The Iron Giant in every other video, he finally sins it. Super!
He run out of movies or wants more views.
12:25 Jeremy, they point out in the movie that a fallout shelter will not do jack at ground Zero.
Right! It's a FALLOUT shelter, not a bunker buried half a mile under the ground!
Dean literally says that 5 seconds later too
So ima stop you right here at 0:06. Nothing. There is nothing wrong with this movie. 0 sins.
This movie was just training for Vin diesel as groot
Token right, before guardians of the galaxy.
This was a beautiful movie and people forget about it ALOT
I remember they played nothing but this movie during one Thanksgiving weekend on Cartoon Network.
Also, Alternative title: child gets harassed by a 30 year old trying to find gigantic bender in the woods of a small town in Maine.
"orders are orders" - And the Iron Giant has programming orders to defend himself offensively.
“Hog Hug ??
HOGARTH HUGHES !!”
Should’ve took a sin off for that reaction 😂
"Holy f*ck, he chloroformed a f*cking CHILD..."
Why was I dying after this line!1!!
8:40
Starting with a Hamilton reference?... fine, I will forgive you for sinning the unsinable.
Everything wrong with the Iron giant: No sequel.
Aydan Barry this movie doesn’t need one. Perfect as is
@@ceoofbeaners2719 I know,but they did tease one.
Don't give Disney the chance to fuck this up too :(
@@spiffygonzales5899 Well said.
Spiffy Gonzales Iron Giant isn’t a Disney film
3:40
Hogarth- "I'm the luckiest kid in America!"
Only America?
We didn't get a sequel , that's the only sin this movies deserves.
No one wants a shitty sequel.
@@annieme-tions Nah nigga this shit was my childhood, this movie deserves a sequel
@@LongboardManiac Pretty sure the sequel wouldnt follow the original
@@annieme-tions Calm down slugger it's a kids movie. Calm your tits chief.
@@LongboardManiac But it really doesn't
"You're like Hitler, but even Hitler cared about Germany or something!"
Cinemasins sinning Iron Giant after some many years of praising it, ladies and gentlemen.
I am here to just comment that there are 69 likes. That is all.
where was this again, i cannot remember, nor do i have the time to
@@thefly5466 rick and morty
It's like he has a sin quota.
Carlos Rafael Rodrigues Filho Agree!
I’m surprised Cinemasins didn’t sin “Hogarth”
yep sin for stupid name time
Mansley: Ho-GARTH? What kind of name is thatanyway?
It was probably popular in its time champ.....you know what buckaroo, no, it wasn’t
The kid looks like Tom Holland, and the junkyard artist looks a bit like Jeff Goldblum.
When The Iron Giant was released Tom Holland was only three years old.
Wizard Suth So? He’s just saying that coincidentally they look a bit similar.
NitroProductions0123 I always thought the junkyard artist kinda looked like RDJ...... 👀👀👀 Tom Holland and RDJ for the live action remake of The Iron Giant???
Obviously they’ll have to tweak some aspects (like Hogarth has to be aged up now and everything 😂) but I love the idea
Cassidy Smith Wait a little bit actually hold up
There are so many "There is nothing wrong with my favorite movie" cliches in the comments it would break the Sins counter for sure.
i'm honest tired of people say "There is nothing wrong with my favorite movie" because in reality no movie is perfect,
For example the pixar movie the are just like by majority of people and "graet" reviews but doesn't mean the are perfect
@@Kriss25Toku everything has flaws even great movies
Kriss25 Toku if you say a Pixar movie is perfect, then you get 10 sins for that lol
Yeah I watched this movie when I was born and I still like it
And there are so many comments like this that you know for 100% that you stole it because you’re so uncreative
1:54 I KNEW Jeremy would say that, maybe I’ve watched too much Cinemasins to know that
“you are who you choose to be” one of the greatest lessons to learn and a beautiful sentiment from this outstanding movie
Green Goblin says literally the exact same thing in Spider-Man.
Didnt point out that when the 2 kids fell and The Giant caught them, they still were falling onto metal, which is still as hard, if not harder than snow covered ground. Even if there was some give to the catch.
Actually a human being can survive a worse fall than that. They fell maybe 10-15 feet on their asses, so at worst they'll just have a few sprains, maybe a pelvic/tarsal fracture
i cant believe were going full real world logic on an animated kids movie about a massive space robot
Welshy i’m still surprised no one was set on fire or had their ears blown out.
Welshy I mean tbh it’s based on the 50 and Sputnik was a thing and everyone was on the hey because of nukes aliens and other space stuff so I’m sure people didn’t care about real ness. Yes I know its made in the 90s
@@Welshy the same movie that exhibits nosebleeding, chloroform and fast acting laxatives!
14:21 the best outake
I wish they had included scene showing Giants dream, yeah we liked the Mystery but it confirms that he’s part of an army of death bots just like him who conquer planets
Tafari TV that would make people ask a lot of questions like who made them, why are they being sent to conquer other planets, and are they all sentient or is it just the one who went to earth.
GODOFAWSOMENESS1 or was he the FIRST of many who are on the way
Tafari TV if that is true then Earth is screwed.
*Jeremy:* **does "EWW 'The Iron Giant'"**
*Me:* You go. I stay.
For a second I didn't know eww was an acronym 😂
No follow. :'(
CinemaSins: Everything Wrong with The Iron Giant
Me: How dare you?
Anvaka Thazit same with movies he dies that I like
He also caught the 2 falling kids with his metal hand so pretty sure there dead
The most superhero cliché ever imo!
Momentum!
That's what I was going for
One of the falling kids has ugly brown shoes for some reason. Jeez, someone give the boy some sneakers! Hogarth has sneakers, falling boy #2 has sneakers, why must falling boy #1 be so poor?
I honestly don't know why he has no sneaker maybe there a gift that his mom told him to were
I.G.'s brain launches a super fast trajectory program, that calculates the precise matching of hand and kids in a way not to injure them.
“You never go full Bambi” tropic thunder reference 😂
13:10 Also, congradulations. You just sent a highly irradiated object caught within a nuclear blast to child, lol.
It’s still the 50s back then they used nowadays proven as poisonous and cancer causing temperature conserving material in school walls
The re enter burned off the radiation
If they ever try to remake this, we storm the castle with pitchforks and torches.
If they ever try to make a live action, we nuke ourselves like Mansley tried to do.
I'm willing to give them a chance if and only if it's the same crew
Well it’s not owned by Disney (at least I don’t think it it) so the chances of that happening are significantly lowered.
A good remake means lots of people from younger generation can experience this movie like we did
Jonus Aguilar I’d love to do a remake, only if I was directing it. I’d fight the studios for total control of the project. Damn the consequences, practical effects not to much CGI! We’re building an actual Iron Giant! F*ck the price we’re making art! We’re gonna stick so damn close to the animated movie/original source, but not be afraid to take chances and do something different! We’re gonna attempt to stay as true to the heart of the story as long as possible! This will be a giant goddamn love letter by fans of the Iron Giant! We’ll also dive deeper into the backstory of the Iron Giant while sticking to what everyone has unofficially come to agree upon.
Jeremy: "Goddamit, did f*cking Vin Diesel just make me cry?!"
Me as my eyes well up: I know right!
10:40
None of those people are wearing coats when it's snowing.
“They were just following orders” casually looks back at the Nuremberg trials
"Just following orders" with regards to handling a giant alien robot and "just following orders" with regards to genocide aren't quite the same thing
Android 19 then that argument can be made with foreign soldiers killing our troops since we are seen as a threat to them. The whole point is that the giant isn’t morally wrong for attacking when he was attacked, for he was threatened
@@Drawngalaxy It... can be made. We don't prosecute soldiers for fighting their nations war. We prosecute the leaders for starting it.
Brendan Risney we don’t prosecute them, we make them POV’s for bargaining chips and or torture them. Then don’t just get a slap on the wrist
Troy Sheinsin the UK and US don’t torture.
There's nothing wrong with the Iron Giant.
They love movies, they don’t actually think them.
nerdgeekman of CZcams
Thank you! The Iron Giant is a masterpiece!!!!
@@nintengod6985 facts bro.. like wtf
beat me too it haha
0:14
Cinema Sins: "In the eye of a hurricane there is-"
Me: while sobbing because Burn is going to destroy me after Hurricane "Quiet for host a moment, a yellow sky"
It was a Hamilton reference!
Fun fact: Jermey said in an AMA on Reddit a few years ago this is his favorite movie they hadn’t done yet
Even though the Iron Giant is one of my all time favorite animated 90's films, i realize that it has it's ups and downs just like all movies, but that's okay because a movies ups and downs is what makes it interesting.
4:42 Her name is Annie dude, not Rachel. The sin still stands though: Strange man at the door, the middle of the night, nearest neighbors are probably miles away, and its only you and your adolescent child home. This lady is WAY to trusting.
We got another Muriel from Courage the Cowardly Dog lmao. Annie legit couldn't take a hint when Hogarth was obviously pissed at Kent for asking too much, then she suggests him to take some suspicious rando for sightseeing??
“Everthing Spoilers wrong duh.. with the iron giant in 14 minutes or less” is an epic opening
I have to believe they knew the title would cause these comments.
Haha
...
You guys realise that this is a joke and I understand it’s not what it says
Nobody:
Jeremy: Starts the video with his audition for Alexander Hamilton
@@LucyAdroit I can't wait until 2021 because I want to see him sin the Hamilton movie
I was scrolling through the comments just to find someone who'd mentioned that
@@Blaineiskindagay ha ha me too
Never understood why such an awesome film as this is overlooked by so many.
This was my favorite movie as a child, nice memories
Same
Same
Also, Imagine if out of nowhere the Iron Giant just said “Family” and hops into a giant muscle car and drives off 😂
Incoming fan art
After taking a bite, of course.
Imagine if he said "f#&@"