Reacting to Musicians Ranking Themselves by Talent
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- Virtual World Tour tickets out now! www.twosetviolin.com/virtualtour
Practice Apparel!: www.twosetapparel.com
Follow TwoSet Apparel: / twosetapparel
Submit your music memes: / lingling40hrs
***Passionate about Classical Music? Join our team! Go to this link: www.twosetviolin.com/apply
_______________________________________
S H O P: www.twosetapparel.com
W E B S I T E: www.twosetviolin.com
F A C E B O O K: / twosetviolin
I N S T A G R A M: / twosetviolin
T W I T T E R: / twosetviolin
T I K T O K: / twosetviolin
W E I B O: www.weibo.com/twosetviolinoff... - Hudba
The fact that the blue-haired guy ranked himself second but literally EVERYONE ELSE ranked him last was honestly soooo satisfying!! 😂
That was almost certainly the goal of the video
@@Brenosakaguti Which really suggest he was planted (i think). He did play the part very well though. IF (just if) he wasn't real, he's certainly realistic.
the fact he has blue eyes and blue hair, makes him so egocentric and arrogant, but nothing to see with ability to judge musical quality.
I honestly kinda feel bad how he got (reasonably) dunked on by everyone lmao.
@@milanradulovic3915 - His ability to judge musical skill - this video was about skill, not talent, despite the title - was hampered by his own complete lack of skill.
I would have ranked them
6) Blue hair
5) Multi instrumentalist
4) Piano boy
3) Singer
2) Drummer
1) Piano girl
Same
Same yeah exactly
thats exactly my rank too
this is the correct ranking. i feel like if singer had another line of lyrics, it would've popped more
Yeah, that's my ranking too
The blue haired guy is a perfect example of the Dunning Kruger effect. People who believe they are incredible at something often tend to have a lot of gaps in their knowledge and are worse than they think. This is because they have enough surface information to feel like they know a lot, but there is still so much that they don’t know that they don’t know, that they are worse than they think. Also the flip side of this exists where people who are really talented tend to under estimate their skill.
She dodged a bullet. He needs to get his ego in check before getting into another relationship.
The blue haired guy is a perfect example of overt narcissism.
this reminds me of james charles
Absolutely. I've dealt with that a bit for every skill that I've learned, though over the years I think I've learned to temper it a bit. Usually if I start to feel confident at a skill, I remember to tell myself that it's only because I don't know shit about it yet. For any of the skills that I'm alright at, I'm generally very aware of how much I don't know
@@wasabi2093 "that's a narcisist" *said no one ever on the internet
As a drummer I can tell you that 5 was a pretty good spot for him. He played a basic beat with basic fills. But he seems like a super nice guy.
He was locked in though. It certainly wouldn't have hurt if he displayed an ability to play more complex and fluid grooves, but I think a 5 is a little low for him.
@@GavriJ I'm not a guitarist, but I would give the the multiinstrumentalist guy some credit for the Fleetwood Mac piece. Not the easiest thing to play, I think. He seemed to play that well based on the clip we saw here. I think LingLing gave him a lot of shit for his multiinstrumentalist attitude and overconfidence, but I think I could rank him above the drummer. Would have to see the full video to be sure, though.
He also rushed a lot. Being a drummer without solid time, is not good.
I feel the drummer was really flashy, basic grooves but people see him going crazy and think "wow he's gotta be good"
I agree, he was just flashy and that’s it, not bad in any particular way, just decent I guess
The Chopin piece that the guy chose it's either above his skill level or in a very early stage of practice to be performed in public. I would rather play something "easier" but beautifully and accurately.
Right! He was very insecure playing it
Yeah the fantasie impromptu he was playing was pretty unpolished and his technique wasn’t that good. But he wasn’t that bad.
I think it also has to do with him playing on an electric keyboard? The touch and how you control your fingers on the keyboard may be different from playing on a classical piano.
@@nanopopquiz7460 not really. Also that particular keyboard is fairly high quality with weighted keys and everything. The keys might feel plastic but it wouldn’t change how you play.
Might be honestly just nerves, I get slippery fingers every time someone watches me play.
The blue haired guy literally voted the pianists last who definitely put months of practice to play those tough pieces and voted himself *2nd* who basically just played the basic chords which he learned "last week". Smh .
Edit: And everyone else voted him last lol
To be fair to the others, not only did he ask for it, he really was the least proficient.
But he was sooo full of himself, I wonder if the whole thing wasn't an act (yes, I'm an optimist, lols).
I really thought the rankings went the other way around when he was doing his list, like 6 meant top! (Then realised he's just deluded)
bruh ☠️
Hello Fellow Potterhead and Ling Ling Wannabe! I agree with you 100%
@@kacrichton4434 I thought the exact same thing till Brett and Eddy said something and I thought the the blue hair guy was delusional.
1. Piano girl (solid technique, confidently played, bonus for nice composition :D)
2. Singer girl (just overall solid, in tune, some nice runs)
3. Piano guy (was nervous so giving the benefit of the doubt, some technical missteps but i can see some good fundamentals)
4. Drummer (idk it seemed pretty basic, wished he'd played some more technical stuff)
5. Multi instrumentalist (the guitar was fine but the cello... that's a hobbyist srry)
6. Blue hair lol
💜 Thanks! - Piano girl aka Summer :)
Jesus Christ died for your ssinssssssssss
Agree
I think the 3 and 4 like, the drummer is basic but it feel really solid. but the piano guy... play something hard but it feel a bit off... Like I think If it based on this one performance only.. I put the drummer on 3 and the pianist on 4.
the tone the multi instrumentalist had on the guitar was pretty harsh, pretty ironic lol
Guitarist here. i cant talk on his cello playing, but the multi instrument guy actually played that initial song quite well. the song, “never going back again” is difficult because it requires travis picking along with consistent bar chords. its easy to bag on him but he actually played a pretty difficult song
I play guitar as well and totally agree! He just didn't need to bring that cello.
@@morinagaby only that it sounds worse when you play it. Or thats my guess. But maybe you are really good, who knows?
@@morinagaby Why do you show random jubilee videos to your teacher. I highly doubt you are telling the truth. But a video would shut me up wink wink.
For me, if you play a simple piece beautifully, I will give you more props than if you play a difficult piece poorly. People are trying to show off the wrong things, and it is coming through loud and clear. Everyone here is trying to demonstrate their technical mastery of 'difficult' material, but that's not what music is really about. The girl with the purple hair was the best for me, and I was impressed by the drummer, but everyone else left me completely underwhelmed. I really don't like the vocal affectation of both singers, it is so contrived and anonymous sounding, every modern singer does that same thing they're both doing.
Was thinking this as well, that song is genuinely really hard to play on guitar. Didn’t need to play the cello
You don't have to be a musician to see how infuriatingly stupid this is (I should know; I'm not one). To take Eddie's analogy further, this would be like if you got a basketball player, a tennis player, and a golfer together and then asked a group of mostly baseball and soccer fans which person is the best sportsman. And then each participant was given ten seconds to demonstrate their skills. And then when ranking each other they say things like "well I really like the color of your shirt so you're first." Madness.
But it does make for a fun and interesting Twoset review video at least!
Yeah you summed it up perfectly hahaha
@Jackson Larson : Well put. And still it would have been an exercise in futility because what is good in any form of art is purely a matter of opinion, a personal aesthetic. _Music is a communication, not a competition._ It is however true that to a degree we can rate proficiency and precision. If that's all it is to some, I have to point out that a machine can only imitate art, not create art. Yet we can build machines to do things faster and more precise.
This is so an analogy so accurate and well-phrased! Thanks for sharing! :)
Jubilee is straight trash, though. If you know anything about their political content, you know what I’m talking about. It’s entertaining to make fun of, but it’s never as representative as they claim it to be.
"Which doctor gets paid more, the general or the specialist?"
SAY IT EDDY🙌🙌🙌
Which get paid more?
@@catlat8035 the specialist
But specialist is harder to get a job. And in music, making a song requires knowledge of many instruments combined. You’ll not likely to make a good song with one classical instrument.
To be fair, having a good and caring gp can make such a huge difference in your life though and is someone you will hopefully have to call on a lot more often than a specialist, so I'm not sure this comparison is entirely accurate. Even though money wise yeah he's right.
@@11panithilopas9 or you can have people who are good players play a song written by good songwriters.
FINALLY someone called out the "20 different time signatures" line as being completely wrong lol
As soon as someone says something like that, you instantly know they don't know much about music. I have tried to talk to a few that have made those kinds of comments and have never been able to figure out what they think it means.
I mean any person who listen with their ears could tell it was 4/4
@@barongerhardt no that is completely fair.
Can imagine that singer being completely lost in a working band context not recognising that was in the same time signature throughout. Or maybe not, maybe she just misused the word ‘time signatures’ and meant something completely different
She's a singer who can only kind of play guitar though so she probably isn't too worried about time signiatures and that's why she got that so wrong
Oh my god the fact that they ranked shitty Fantaisie Impromptu above piano girl is outrageous. She was by far the best of the 6, and unarguably above piano guy.
Yeah the 5th place doesn't seems fair
@@onlygigachadsknowsmyname thats why I took 1st place in middleschool talent show with easy-peasy Solfegietto lmao
yeah and the fact they think fantasie impromptu is more difficult... bro its literally trinity ATCL exam repertoire, and extremely common
@@Anna_Tang being common/well known doesn't make it easier to play
his technique was odd for a Chopin piece, hell for any piano piece. I wonder why he chose that one even though he wasn't quite ready yet
No one:
Not a single soul:
Michael: Learn more instruments to be better musicians!
Musicians who put their soul into one instrument: Am I a joke to you?
Edit: There's absolutely nothing wrong with playing more than one instrument! I play a few myself 😅
i think its more difficult for a pianist to learn another instrument than the opposite since the piano is the most straightfoward *innitially* and most musicians know that as a second one if they arent mainly a pianist
“Jack of all trades, master of none”
You can only become the best at one instrument; playing more will only divide your attention.
@@brandonstinson4988 thats why any professional is mediocre at their second instrument, because they focus on their main one
*I name my violin with my own soul*
*CHOCOLATE*
Personally, I think they should have had much more refined musicians to rank. All were quite "ordinary" (as am I). Mastery of any instrument is no easy task and that's why you have to practice 40 hours a day.
They literally played basics lol. I don't think any of them actually know music theory aside from the drummer boy because he was clearly in time.
I doubt the drummer knew any theory. My father was a drummer so I could keep time with a metronome loooong before I ever knew what a quaver was. I see ranking people as easier when it's a lot of beginners though. Intermediate vs intermediate would have assumedly cause more non-musician listeners to not pick up on the subtleties of the players individual musicianship. Granted, it would have been a lot more fun for us TwoSet viewers!!
@@renascitur7051 And the purple shirt pianist. If she plays at that level, there's no doubt she’s taken music theory at some point.
@@singingbeaker True lol.
I honestly think those were the only musician they could get to do this kinda thing...
1. Piano Girl
6. Blue Hair
2-5 is pretty subjective, but I think 1 and 6 are pretty justifiable locks. It would have been more interesting if they had done this as a blind test, as I think looks definitely come into play when people are voting on something like this, which might be fine for AGT, but not for a "rate the talent" scenario.
Very justified, blue haired def a show off and probably had no one else in his life who was a musician compare to
Justified, I liked singin chick more than piano girl, but I aint mad at piano girl as your number 1. We can all agree blue hair McGee is 6.
I feel bad for the fact that they gave the pianist an Electro. The keys on those instruments are often different feeling, so I feel as though the way the pianists adapted to playing on a piano that’s not even full (88 keys) and feels weird is very impressive
and since keyboard-keys are usually plastic it makes a unintentional thud sound when you press on them which distracts from the music in my opinion.
The force feedback are really important in fantaisie for the muscle memorie etc
There's definitely a piece I wouldn't be able to play on that that I can play well on a normal piano
That’s true they feel totally different and play different, i sound way better on a grand piano then I do on my schools cheap Yamaha electric pianos.
And how do we know, that this Choping-player has an classical piano at home? And with or without pedal?
I got so annoyed when Summer was ranked 5 by Instagram followers. I’m a pianist and I personally think she played so well. I loved the piece she played and her dynamics/expressions were very good
Aw thanks, Caitlyn :) always happy to see Ling Ling piano gang here
As a non musician she was my favourite. I think she did what music is supposed to do: makes us feel emotions. Personally I found her as the most consistent in her playing and was pronouncing all the notes just right. Idk maybe some of the words I'm using are wrong but that's how I felt. It looked like she knew what she was doing.
She was by far the most talented person in the video! By a landslide.
I had to learn this when I was younger. Still remember when I used to learn a bunch of prog songs as a kid, was playing them in a group with no one really paying attention. And then some guy walks up and plays 3 chord jack johnson and everyone is mega impressed. I had to learn the simple fact that most people who listen to and consume "music" are not actual musicians. Asking their opinion on music would be like asking for medical advice from a 10 year old.
@@anthonyfaiell3263 similarly, an important lesson to learn is that passion, effort, and skill do not equate to fame, money, or others’ attention. And how that is perfectly okay. To expect every person on earth to understand the nuances of every single craft out there, and therefore to appreciate only the most talented or genius creations is ridiculous.
Summer was extremely underrated, as piano player I can confirm she was loads better than that messed up blurry 1 phrase fantasie impromptu. She played the arpeggios expressively, had rubato and dynamics.
@@SummerSweeSingh Woaaah a TwoSet fan too!
As a fellow pianist I liked your playing the best too by far :)
Definitely going to check out your compositions cause I really liked the mysterious, somewhat dark and melancholic vibe of what you played. Very moving!
@@comedyfriendsenglish oh, yay! I am admittedly a wannabe Ling Ling (but am far from that) and knew as soon as the Jubilee and Twobilee videos dropped that TwoSet would like react and have been on the edge of my seat waiting for the video. I love TwoSet and have been subscribed for years :) I grew up playing classical piano (ages 7-17) but never majored in music / didn’t go to conservatory and got my BA in Legal Studies with a Music Minor from UC Berkeley. Worked at a law firm for a while before deciding to pursue music and am now a studio/touring keys player, composer, and arranger for a variety of artists. I also have a super small, relatively new band that’s a fusion of classical crossover and prog / math rock called GRP. Would love to hear your thoughts on our songs “Storm”, “Willow Tree”, and “At Dusk” (all on Spotify / iTunes etc.) :)
@@SummerSweeSingh Ayy I also never majored in music. It's just a hobby for me but I really really love it. I guess that's why we're all here as Ling Ling wannabes :)
Checked out all the pieces you suggested! I swear I can totally hear you play in them, especially the piano solo in "Storm". You really seem to enjoy the "push and pull" with the dynamics. Really enjoyed that in your Jubilee performance too :P
And the vibe seems familiar too. I feel like your playing sounds very ethereal in a really nice way. Maybe that's a weird way of describing it but that's how I feel. The 5/4 in Willow Tree added to that feeling I think.
I really like all of them, thanks for the suggestions! :) Did you compose those? :o And I am curious to hear how you'd describe your playing/composing style in terms of vibe and feelings!
@@comedyfriendsenglish that’s awesome and music is absolutely such a fulfilling hobby to have! Glad to be part of the Ling Ling Wannabes club with you :)
And haha yay! Thank you so much for taking the time to listen to GRP! Yes, so GRP is a duo-drummer Jessica Burdeaux and myself on keys/piano. Our process goes something like this: I write a piece on piano and then record it; I send it to her and she writes a drum parts to it and we convene and discuss; then she officially records drums and then I compose any other additional instrumentation for the track and then hire session musicians to record those parts before mixing/mastering and releasing :)
Honestly 5/4 and 5/8 are my favorite time signatures (so much so that I’m getting a tattoo of one of them soon lmfao, I’m weird). I love writing in mixed and odd meters which all of the GRP songs have. “Storm” is in 12/8 in the beginning and then transitions to three bars of 6/8 and a bar of 2/8 which repeats before the B section which is in 4/4 …the main theme of “At Dusk” is (3 bars of 5/4 and then a bar of 6/4) repeated… the main theme of “Willow Tree” is (3 bars of 5/4 and 1 bar of 4/4) repeated and then transitions into a B section that’s in 6/4 and then the ending is in 7/8. Hope that all makes sense lol :)
@@SummerSweeSingh Hahaha what a time signature nerd!
*me totally not about to listen to them again to fact check the time signatures you told me about*
Must've loved the 20 different time signatures the drummer played lol
I noticed that "Willow Tree" didn't stay in 5/4. First the 5/4 caught me offguard and then I started counting and it didn't work and I was like "Wait, what?". And then I was in a comfortable 6/4 all of a sudden and had to go to the beginning to check if it really was 5/4 at the beginning to not make a fool of myself when mentioning the 5/4,
A drummer also seems like the perfect duo partner for you hahaha
One thing I love when improvising is to put the 2 or 9 in every chord I play hahaha. Especially major. I just love the sound of a B in A major or a D in C major. It sounds so fresh, shiny and bright. And I love the flat 6 in a major key cause it sounds so colorful and nostalgic :')
That video seemed to illustrate why pop music is so marketable. It’s all about how you make the audience “feel”, rather than showing the audience what is “the best”.
I think "feeling" is the whole point of music. HOWEVER, the shitty thing about pop music is that it takes the laziest route toward the emotional goal. Beautifully made music is nuanced, and intentional and complex
@@marygraham1709 will say it once and I’ll say it again after taking multiple theory classes and learning how to produce a lot actually goes into pop music. There’s so many unique patterns and Melodie’s I’ve heard in songs in the genre and yes maybe it isn’t the most technical, but tbh I’d rather hear something actually memorable than a septuplet arpeggio run in c harmonic minor and not to mention the fact more goes into actually making a pop song and producing it with all the layers of different instruments and contrasting melodic lines than most other genres
@@marygraham1709 there are plenty of pop music that all of those things and that are deeper beyond the frilly light beats. Every genre has it's good & bad songs, every genre has it pros & cons. If a simple, non-complex song makes some ppl feel happy and maybe wanna dance, well then that's music.
It’s not about whether it’s to feel or not it’s just that ordinary people’s taste haven’t changed since they’re 12
@@giocoso4576 jesus this is why no one likes classical musicians. Pretentious as fuck
My ranking:
6th - Blue haired guy
5th - the tallest guy
4th - the multi instrumentalist
3rd - the girl who sing
2nd - the drummer
1st - the girl in purple(pianist)
just for me:))
I agree ☝️😏
Guitar capos aren't really meant to be a training wheels kinda thing, it's just to raise the pitch in a way that makes the fingering more suited for the guitar in different keys. Classical guitarists use it for some renaissance and baroque lute music, flamenco players rarely play without one, etc. Just a really useful tool for raising pitch.
Yeah, their immediate dismissal of the capo was a pretty telltale sign they're not guitar players... or really know anyone who is. A quality capo is an essential tool for any guitarist.
FINALLY, SOMEONE SAID IT.
This! I feel like people are way too quick to judge guitarists for using any sort of tool in their playing and assume the guitarist is somehow less talented. I see this a lot for effects pedals (especially distortion) and I think it come from a misunderstanding of how these things are used and work. For example, people will say someone is covering up their mistakes using distortion, but in practice distortion is more likely to heighten your mistakes. (And for clarification, this isn't saying that guitarists who use effects are more talented. It's just to point out that effects don't replace talent, they just put more tools in the box.)
THANK YOU SIR !
@@WickedCitizen What is the prescribed punishment for misunderstanding the capo?
Hey Twoset, as a guitarist I need to correct you on the capo thing. Yes, us classical guitarists don't use it as much as electric or acoustic guitarists do. But capo for classical guitar exists too. Just as an example, I'm practicing Bach BWV 997, which is in C minor but transcribed in A minor. I bought, as suggested from my teacher a capo that was designed specifically for classical guitar in order to play it in the original key. Check out David Russell, he's one of the greatest guitarists and he actually played it with a capo. Hope you see it and it doesn't get lost in the wave of comments
Was going to say this. Capo doesn’t make the instrument any easier or harder to play, just puts you in a different key or range.
@@everythingexpert4795 yep was studying this yesterday XD because I was practicing in my Uncles guitar since I dont have one
@@everythingexpert4795 Exactly. I don't understand why people would look down on the use of capo when it actually just increases the versatility of guitar by allowing you to use "open strings" in different keys. Capos are great.
The capo is possibly the most misunderstood tool in the guitarist's toolbox. Beginners use it to make their lives easier in some cases, sure, but as a more advanced payer, there are certain figures and tone colors you just can't play without one.
Yeah I play classical guitar too and I’ll add that we’ll usually just play in the transposed key anyway. That Bach piece you mentioned is written in C- but it’s key isn’t so much important as it’s written harmonies cause instruments throughout history and geography have vastly varied tunings. Like take Toccata and Fugue. It’s written for D- but church organs were all tuned differently back then so it’ll always be pitched differently organ to organ.
Also unrelated but it’s interesting to play different transcriptions of the same piece. Like Moonlight sonata is in C#- and the most popular transcription is in A- but there’s also a version in D- which has the melody an octave lower which gives it a total different vibe. It’s also in drop D
my rankings coming from a musician:
1. Piano girl. Her compositions had lots of very nice colors and i honestly really enjoyed it. she seemed very grounded when she played. i also heard some parts that screamed debussy which i always love.
2. Guitar girl. As someone who has sung before i can vouch that having enough control for those runs is NOT easy. Overall very good
3. Drummer. Pretty solid time, he was going kind of ham on the ride, but i enjoyed it. good dynamics as well.
4. piano guy (kind of tied with drummer) Lots of respect for playing that piece especially with people there, not easy. I do agree the runs did feel a bit muddy and maybe weren’t executed perfectly, but otherwise i enjoyed it and i do think it would sound a lot better on a real piano.
5. Cello and guitar guy. First off i don’t like how he deducted points for someone not playing more than one instrument. talent is not defined by how many instruments you play. I did enjoy his guitar, but i think his cello playing needs work.
6. blue hair. It was quite simple, and maybe he does need practice. His voice sounded decent for the most part. i would’ve had more respect for him if he wasn’t as arrogant as he was. Anyway thank you for listening
As an amateur musician I agree with most of what you are saying but I would have drummer as 4, he did most basic stuff, also too much ride. Piano guy as 3, when I saw this on Jubilee I went to his channel and he can play he was just nervous.
@@reineh3477 ohh yeah that makes sense about piano guy. i definitely saw the talent there
I had the same ranking in my mind
as a classical pianist and singer, i can confidently say the purple haired girl deserves #1 and the singer girl deserves #2
no brainer.
I feel like people were mainly impressed by chopin not just because they know it's hard but because it's obviously fast. In reality the piece summer played had plenty of arpeggios that require a lot of movement too, and she nailed it, but non-musicians don't really recognize that
🤍
Also the fact he played litterally 10 seconds (obviously very bad played) and not the whole piece, it just mean so much. This piece is pretty easy when you understood how it works rythmically, but you are right people think it’s impressive because it’s fast. That’s why it’s pointless to ask non musician people to rank skills they don’t know anything about.
This is like the flight of bumvlebee roast
Summer is ok and the dude just sucked. Summer was missing legato and her fingers were really flat. The dude couldn’t properly play the not to mention, no tecnique in the slightest.
Also just wanna note summer wrote that piece
Now we know why the blue haired guy just broke up. He ranked himself #1 in the relationship while she ranked him #6.
Underrated comment...
Lol
As a fellow pianist and singer who listens to many genres and was also classically trained.
1. Pianist girl with her own composition: Amazing composition, great skill and fluidity when playing. Her technique was sound and it was a very moving piece that I can hear has inspirations from great musicians.
2. The girl that sang: Sang a very difficult song, my mind by yebba(Recommend everyone to listen to it). Good vocal control + nice runs .
3. Drummer: Really good rhythm, dynamics and expression
4.Piano dude: Not bad. Bad technique, never lifts his leg from the pedal so everything overlaps. Props for trying a super difficult song.
5. Multi-instrumentalist: Cello playing was awful. Guitar was ok. Recommend focusing on one instrument and being great at it before learning other instruments.
6. Blue-hair dude: Singing was pitchy, trying to cry while singing doesn't work and actually ruins your voice so don't recommend doing it. There was literally no patterns in the chord progression at all. Songwriting was the only good thing about it. I suggest practicing to sing more and actually learn to play piano. Lastly, get your ego in check though probably you have it in check after these ratings.
Kudos to @TwoSetViolin for this amazing video.
P.S I don't think any platform should ask musicians to rate themselves because we as musicians always judge ourselves to get better in the first place. So its just weird and could mess someone up
100% agree, although I think the multi-instrumentalist deserves a bit more credit. You said he should focus on one instrument before moving on, but to me his performance of "Never Going Back Again" by Fleetwood Mac was incredibly clear and showed no signs of fumbled notes (this is coming from a guitarist who also knows that song). Also Two-Set cut it out of this video, but he did sing with his guitar and I found it very nice with clear and controlled pitch. I find singing while playing a fingerstyle guitar song incredibly difficult (depending on the song) as there are many rhythms you have to keep track of (thumb vs index middle ring fingers vs singing). His cello playing I have no say over because I have never learnt cello, but admittedly it didn't sound great.
Hi! Pianist girl here, thanks so much for the kind words 💜
100% agree!
Definitely agree
I think the multi-instrumentalist got done dirty - Never Going Back Again is a really difficult song to play, let alone play well
"I can play a lot instruments"
Percussionists: "So?"
Lol
My ranking:
6. blue hair
5. sacrilegious cello
4. chopin guy (ugh i wanna put him higher just for chopin but uhh i dont know)
3. the drummer guy (+1 for the attidute, honestly)
2. the beautiful voice girl (i sing and what she did is really hard, at least for me)
1. the piano girl
And I agree with you guys that the first three of them seem more like proffesionals, totally
I'd switch the drums and the singer girl (I just really like drums lol) but other than that I totally agree with your order!
@@jonnybuijze1770 honestly i wouldn't mind that switch either, it was a hard choice to make, and im glad u agree on the rest
This seems to be the ranking in the comments and I agree too...
I put piano man at 2 because I feel like he’s in the beginning stages of practicing that piece, but he still showed good skill and understanding. The vocalist was some raw talent, but I put her at 4 simply because I feel like some vocal coaching would make a great deal of improvement which is the only reason I put the drummer at 3. Interchangeable to me though.
Aw thank you! Summer (Piano girl) here :) For context I am a pro (I left a more detailed comment about this somewhere else in the comments section) composer / arranger / studio + touring pianist & keyboardist.
The piece I played was an original composition which you can listen to in full on Spotify / iTunes etc. called “JFN” by Summer Swee-Singh :)
1. Girl pianist
2. Girl singer
3. Drummer
4. Male Chopin pianist
5. Cello and multiple instruments guy
6. Blue hair guy
Yeah. Based on what was seen here, yes. But really, none of all that impressive.
Finally!! Why does everyone rank the drummer so low!? That shit is hard like I’m a pianist of 12 years whose tried drumming for a few weeks
I like how you described them by their music and instruments.
Still, that blue guy tho...
The female singer was terrible. Her vocals were cliche garbage and her guitar playing was as basic as it gets. I wonder how long it’s going to take before people get tired of that style of singing.
@@giusepperesponte8077 I'm afraid I have to agree.
9:08 SHE REALLY SAID SKILL ISSUE💀💀💀🔥🔥🔥🔥
I assume that classical guitarists don't like capo's due to it limiting the range of the instrument or something?
Drummer went hard tho
I think the difficult thing about the video is that talent isn’t exactly the same thing as skill. Whereas skill is somewhat measurable, talent is a little more abstract. Sure, it can manifest into skill, but it’s also the nuance of understanding a subject and potential a person can reach with dedication and practice. All that to say, IG robbed Summer of the higher ranking she should’ve had in the context of this group
Hard to measure talent. The only thing you can rank them on is technical proficiency really, and Summer is the clear number 1. Blue hair guy... there's definitely some Dunning Kruger effect there ha. For all we know though he might practice like crazy after this and become really good in a few years.
I don't know why any musician would put themselves through this lol.
Why they put themselves through this? They obviously get paid to be there
money (hopefully) and exposure
Hey Lucas, Thank you :) Agreed 100% re: talent. Why did I participate? I’m clearly masochistic, lmao. TBH, I didn’t think I’d get cast when I put my name in the hat, so was v shocked when I got the casting confirmation. Mostly, I was curious to see who would show up (was honestly expecting there’d be some top tier musicians… was half expecting to know someone there-I did not-since the music world can be quite small in many ways), I love making myself a lil uncomfortable every day if possible (I’m weird), and also had hope that maybe TwoSet would react to the video (called it, LOL) or that some music directors would watch it and find out about me who didn’t know about me before so I could get more gigs :)
FYI there was no monetary compensation for our participation. I did it mostly out of curiosity and self-loathing lmao… and also bc I semi-know three people who have been on Jubilee videos (internet acquaintances) and found their experiences to be interesting and generally positive (Alec who won the musician dating pt. 1 video Jubilee did, Ray who was ranked #1 in ranking strangers intelligence who I found out went to my high school, and Jason Chu who was in some spectrum episode about rappers). I didn’t have work scheduled the for day of the shoot, so figured “Why not lose a little self respect?” Lololol jk
@@SummerSweeSingh Hey Summer! Well, you gave a good showing of yourself and your skills. You were the most skilled without a doubt. Hopefully, it brings a lot of eyes (and gigs), it looks like everyone was impressed with your playing so any music directors watching will surely be impressed.
I liked your original piece! I've subscribed to your channel and will keep listening for more.
@@SummerSweeSingh I’m not surprised but still disappointed to hear that you didnt get paid :/
Intonation.
Rhythm.
Tone.
Dynamics.
All 4 lived together in harmony...then everything changed when America's Got Talent attacked.
😂😂😂
😂
😂🤣🤣lmao
best comment by Far!
There is no talent in Ba Sin Se :-)
The fact that multi instrumentalist took on "Never going back again" on guitar hasn't been picked up on widely. That's one of the toughest fingerpicking guitar pieces out there, and in the few seconds played on this video he did well
But that Cello was Just bad
@@aaaaa111aaaaa true
This is definitely true, “never going back” is really hard to play. I don’t think he played it as well as most covers I’ve heard, but at least he could play it. His cello was horrendous though and how he tried to use that as a way to look more talented rubbed me the wrong way. He should’ve focus that energy on making “never going back” sound better
Yeah I was thinking that too. Defiantly not the easiest thing to olay
Also scoffing at a capo is weird. Would you turn up your nose at monster bluegrass guitarists like Molly Tuttle or Billy Strings, who use a capo in every other song?
3:32 PLS HELP ITS SO BAD as a cellist my soul is weeping
wait i’m confused on how it was bad 😭 please explain
@@pokehim_ a) his cello is very bad and scratchy, like a cheao student cello b) his intonation is way off c) doesn't even sound like the bach suite. way too fast
The pianist (no. 6) being voted 5th place kind of took me by surprise, i mean her fundamentals are just spectacular. So glad twoset addressed this
Thanks! It me :) I knew it was a risk playing only original compositions (and I didn’t tel people until after the ranking that I’d composed my pieces) because I know people often mistake recognizability with “talent” and “likability”, but I went into this expecting a sh*tshow and it’s basically what I got.
If you want to check out the full piece of mine that they showed clips of in the video, it’s called “JFN” by Summer Swee-Singh and it’s on my CZcams channel, Spotify, iTunes, Amazon, etc.
@@SummerSweeSingh ohh, watched the original jubilee video and didn't see any comments of yours here, so glad to find your channel !
I really like how Brett and Eddy could have made this a funny video (which they still did), but actually touched on some nuanced conversations about the music world and what it means to be "talented"
That's part of their appeal, educational and entertaining at the same time
@@mangosago1213 that's awesome! glad to hear :)
Oh hey it's you, Sophie! I love your content, I think you're criminally underrated. Keep it up!
@@late8641 oh my gosh you are so kind! thank you so much ❤️
@@sr-kt9ml Except when talking about Viola
there is something to be said about multiple instruments. yeah going out to learn as many instruments as possible just so you can be "perceived" as musically talented is silly but learning to make music with whatever you can really help cement a wide variety of musical ideas in your head and can keep things fun and enjoyable and add so much to your musical ability. it did sound like that guy just learned a few things on a few instruments though just so he could be perceived as musically gifted as opposed to really learning the ins and outs of each instrument haha
I personally think the Multi-Instrumentalist guy was underrated. The first thing he played on guitar was a song by Fleetwood Mac called “Never Going Back Again” and it is an incredibly difficult finger picking song. It might not appear difficult, but it’s pretty tricky. Paul David’s, a great guitar CZcamsr, talks about how difficult it is as a finger picking song.
I think if he was less lousy on cello , or just didn’t play it and didn’t make the comments about good musicians being able to play different instruments he would have come across better.
@@feilik definitely, he completely ruined his guitar performance with his attitude and cello playing.
ok but the cello tho… i’m a cello player and dang that hurt my soul hearing the awful representation 😅😅 i’m sobbing, the technique- dude how do you call yourself a cello player/that u can play cello when THATS YOUR CELLO PLAYING.. this is awful
Ok, so I looked the song up, as well as Paul David's video about it, and I tried the song myself, since as a guitar player I wanted to see what the fuss was about.
First of all - the fingerpicking part of the song is not difficult if you've been playing the guitar seriously for any amount of time. Take literally any Tommy Emmanuel song that he plays using Travis picking and it's way more difficult. Or check out Buster B. Jones's "Buster B Boogie", now that's difficult fingerpicking. I'm not even talking about the right hand technique you need to play classical guitar music, no comparison there.
I will grant, however, that the song is hard on the left hand, especially if you overpress on the bar chords. However I only tried it on a classical guitar, which has a wider neck than a standard acoustic, so it's probably easier on the acoustic.
But the most important thing in this argument in my opinion, is that if you listen carefully, the dude in the video didn't even play the first 5 bars of the song correctly. The "trickiest" part of the song is to keep the bass going with your thumb, while simultaneously playing the melody. He is literally not doing it. In the first 4 bars he only plays the first and the third bass notes with his thumb, and, while hard to see/hear exactly, he seems to either be playing the second and fourth bass notes with his "i" finger, or not playing them at all. Makes no difference to be honest, because you should be playing them with your thumb and they must be clearly heard above the melody. All 4 bass notes per bar.
And the final bar in the video, the fifth bar, which Paul David, for example, calls out as the the trickiest part for the right hand, well, the guy in the video doesn't play it correctly at all. He is literally not playing the bass notes that make that particular bar tricky. If you slow down the video at 3:21 to 0.25 speed you can see exactly what he plays and how he plays it - wrong rhythm in the bass and not all notes are played.
I wouldn't normally care as everyone makes mistakes when playing live, god knows myself included, but you can't really praise a guy for playing a mildly tricky song, when he is not playing/simplifying the actual tricky parts.
In Blue Hair’s defense, I don’t think he messed up a single one of the eight whole note chords he played.
lol
Xd!!
lol but his singing was just not it
His playing was boring and his singing was bad. He was 6th only because he couldn't be 7th. I will say that I found the girl who sang nearly as boring and bad. She did not deserve the rank she got, but then I am 100 years old culturally.
You mean 4 chords
It’s really interesting to see how „impressive” drums are. As a drummer myself I thought that his playing was really basic and the other ones (especially purple shirt girl) were much better but at the end it’s all about the show and how well can you sell your instrument
Interesting. I agree with you about selling here. And I think drummer sold himself well by playing within his abilities as opposed to piano boy or cellist who chose pieces way above their calibre. Again, this itself is also a display of sound musicianship.
He kept it clean, seemed to have good technique, and was somewhat musically interesting. Imo, he deserves third place behind Piano Girl and the singer. Blue hair..well, he did what he did. Multi-instrumentalist had poor tone (hard to get on the cello, but necessary). And Piano Guy seems like he can play, it's just that he chose an ill prepared piece. Choosing a piece that you'll sound good on is half the battle.
I don't have any chops so his drumming is better than mine 😅 I can pretty much just keep a groove and keep it together but nothing fancy
Honestly the drummer to me it looked like he was just hammering on the ride I’m surprised no one went deaf. He kept time but overall very basic playing aside from that fast fill. It sounded like he drank 5 energy drinks, either he was too nervous or just needs more practice
@@emilycaballero6052 not the best technique imo
It's not because he played a hard piece. It's because he freaking played a piece from "LaLa Land." People go with what they're familiar with and that's why it's so important to choose the right song when you're auditioning.
The pianist girl is Summer Swee-Singh, she's amazing and is on youtube doing lots of ensemble collabs with classical performers. Lots of violinists you can review!
Literally feeling the second-hand embarrassment from the blue guy sjsjjsjsjs he was so full of himself lmao. The guy who played the cello was kinda cringe, but at least he tried lol.
And I agree with your ranking. Those in the top three have that 'professional' vibe and we can totally see it just by the way they carry themselves and when they're actually on their instrument.
It doesn’t matter how good they think they are, only Ling Ling is best.
Yesss😉
Ling Ling supremecy
!ALL HAIL LING LING!
Such a dumb comment
How dare you compare Ling Ling to these pathetic mortals ಠ_ಠ
Tru
Classical Guitarist here, it's definitely true that capos can be used as a crutch (because they allow you to shift the basic open chord shapes into any key without needing to learn voicings for them higher up), but it's definitely not the case that that's all they are. They let you effectively raise the tuning of the open strings which can be pretty useful for playing in keys that aren't super guitar friendly. Also, there's a specific sound to those open chord voicings that's basically ubiquitous to pop/rock guitar music, you wouldn't use jazz voicings just because they're technically the same chord, right?
Some guitarists definitely do look down on you for using them but I think they themselves probably lack the understanding of the instrument they think they do lol
an open chord with a capo is still a barred chord, I'm confused by your 'open chord voicings' point.
@@McDoot because there is a completely different sound when you use an open chord shape with a capo rather than a barre chord shape
and open chords with capos are not barre chords
Jazz guitarist here and I couldn't agree more with you
Let's be honest, we all celebrated at 10:00
Summer is absolutely killer and writes great music. She’s in a prog/fusion/neo-classical band called GRP.
Hi!!! Summer here :) This comment is so cool to see on a TwoSet video as a very small-time composer-pianist, tbh. Thank you so much, Jesse; it’s WILD to see that anyone knows about or listens to my little, relatively new band.
I actually played a clip from my original “Storm” (by my band GRP) for Instagram (which they didn’t show in the Jubilee video) and the clip they showed in this video was also an original (solo) called “JFN” by Summer Swee-Singh. Both “Storm” and “JFN” are on Spotify / iTunes etc. if you’d like to hear the full pieces! :)
@@SummerSweeSingh Summer?! You gotta make a full fledged comment, not just a reply, or else Twoset wont be able to see this! quick, someone get this guy a mic!
@@Killerbee4712 I did make a comment (not just a comment reply)! Not sure how to keep it from getting lost in the sea of comments, but in any case appreciate your support so much :)
@@SummerSweeSingh Well regardless, im just glad twoset community has infested even Jubilee's casting. if only you dropped a twoset reference, then the entire community would've gone bonkers, you would've become the next hilary hahn lmao
@@Killerbee4712 I actually mentioned something about how “I don’t practice 40hrs a day but wish I did”, but it didn’t make the edit or maybe they didn’t film it (lots was edited out probably due to vid time constraints).
The instagram vote really says a LOT about how the uneducated general public sees musical talent - just play fast, difficult-sounding piece and BAM you're a genius. Doesn't matter HOW you played it, doesn't matter WHAT the pitches are, just hard and fast lol
This is also why meaningless piano-blitz in rhythm games are a thing and people love it lol
uneducated in what sense?
fast piano runs sound pretty interesting
which is why people include it in music
i partially agree with you. but saying uneducated is a bit harsh. sometimes it's just people don't even really listen. for me, im old so i take times slowly scrolling when im on SNS. but like one of my much younger friend, she could heart 10 pics in under a sec. i couldn't even understand what she looked because she was sooooo fast. her dynamic visual probably same as a dragonfly. she wouldn't have time to finish a full clip. probably just 2 sec then she made a quick decision she wouldn't even remember after 5 mins. there are just too many things for people to react, but with very little real information. so people getting numb and zombified, and blocking their ability to think clearly and make good judgments.
@@LijenC2357 somehow I find your comment more harsh than the op lol.
At least with 'uneducated', you can have an excuse for judging someone badly. Now, without the lack of being uneducated, I expect them to know better. So they know, they're educated, but despite all that, they're unable to use their brain to think or make good judgment, it's a case of hopelessness.
Purple outfit piano girl was by far my favorite. She gave a good polished performance and she composed that piece herself(?). Blue hair bro got taken down several pegs and I hope he went home to reflect deeply on why this happened.
I'm a ballet dancer. My only tye to you two is literally classical music. I'm addicted to these vids lol
Dancer here, too! And absolutely the same, still love to watch them :D
I would have ranked them
6 - Blue hair guy
5 - Multiple instruments guy
4 /3 - singer girl/piano guy - as a singer myself I felt while her voice was beautiful it was still quite unstable in places but that could be for a number of reasons (bad day/environmental factors/nerves)
2 - drummer
1 - piano girl
7.keely j
@@god8431 oh yay a comedian :)
Same
That drummer was shit dudes, all my students can play that after 6 months of practice
the most correct ranking
There's no such thing as talent; there is only practice. You know, that thing you're not doing right now.
shh, no need to call us out like that
Why you need to be so cruel???!!! (´；ω；`)
I feel so called out
yesss talent was not the best way of phrasing it
@@baoooool4722 r/Angryupvote
As a drummer I can only comment on a few things. His drumming for me was a 6/10. He played quite in time, he had dynamics but they were not very good (extremely big gaps between the louder and softer parts). Maybe the gaps were just bigger because of how the video was cut, but for me that was the biggest problem in his playing. Then he also had some issues with his technique (not consistent rim shots, volume was not always quite right on snaredrum, he did not always hit the cymbal the same way which could also be the fact that the drums weren't positionned very well). That's all the nitpicking I could do :) thanks for listening to my ted talk
As a non-drummer, this was such an interesting and informative comment. So interesting to learn about some of the skills and nuances involved in playing other instruments and I don't often hear this level of detail with drums.
I'm glad to see another drummer and your comments here! I think a lot of musicians would say that measuring a drummer against these other pitched instrumentalists is maybe unfair but I disagree. All your comments about consistency (arguably the most important thing for a drummer) and dynamics and such were spot on. I think its kinda funny how impressed they were (by the drummer) because they actually opened my eyes to a lot of things I hadn't noticed about the others. like Sedo choosing a tough piece, and actually they changed my mind about Mary, I didn't like her that much but her vocal runs were quite impressive tbf.
He also looks like he’s holding a TON of tension in his playing - some loosening up could help.
@@magunn26
That’s most likely bcuz he’s self taught.
That would also explain why he’s so "HEAVY" with all his hits.
Louder doesn’t mean better
I wouldn’t put him above 3.
His transitions to different points in his playing just felt very awkward (like the move to the Knocks on Snare)
Chad Smith is a great example of loud playing whilst being very good at keeping articulation betweens different "notes" and hearing accents…and everything else.
BRO PURPLE SHIRT GIRL FOR LIFE!!
The singer had a beautiful voice, but her guitar playing was similar to what the blue haired guy did on piano, only a bit better. Lyrically, I would like to see more from her as well.
Yeah, but with her music, it was clearly her voice that was 'the music' and the guitar that was accompanying her, so I think it's fair to judge her on the singing and not the guitar. You wouldn't judge a singer on the backing track either, right?
@@Roozyj I think my assessment was fair. A beautiful voice deserves equally beautiful accompaniment. But this was just one snippet in time. I'm sure she has people who want to work with her in that way. However, she judged the blue haired guy on his piano skills, so I was just pointing out that her guitar skill wasn't a whole lot better.
I wasn't impressed by either her voice nor her accompaniment skills on guitar.
Her voice was nice, but not outstanding, and her lyrics were terrible. Blue hair guy is a better song writer, I felt more listening to him. But her appreciation for multi-instrument players is the same as mine -- very high. LOL.
@@GrlRock That's true. If she judges blue hair guy that way, she should be judged by her guitar playing as well.
Tbh, I don't know much about music. I just liked the sound of her voice.
When you find out that the clip people voted on for the 'winner' was him playing a very simple piece from La La Land, not the Chopin
Well the Chopin wasn't rlly done incredibly well, if it was played rlly well then I wud prolly agree w u
The clip people voted for is actually the Chopin piece (I’m the pianist in the video). We had to play for 10 seconds and they posted that on Instagram story of jubilee then the audience voted. I actually messed up but they kept it cause we had only one shot.
The singer being really good but knowing nothing about music theory is a pretty accurate representation of us LOL. Also I feel like the reason Summer got done dirty is because people who don’t play piano tend not to pay attention to much of the technical stuff. As long as you play a difficult song and hit most of the right notes at mostly the right time, they’ll think you’re an expert. As others have pointed out Summer’s piece wasn’t exactly easy to play either -but it has a slower tempo and sounds less “complex”. Add that to the fact that no one paid attention to her nice dynamics and the great expression and energy she put in because they don’t realize that that’s a skill too.
The pure comedic bliss alongside vindication I experienced while watching this video - I can’t thank you enough! I decided to watch the original video and explore my own opinions first and it was amazing to see a lot of my thoughts echoed by you guys in hilarious fashion!
Thank you for all this great content!
They should have included Hilary Hahn and see the contestants reactions. 😂
The Fantasie Impromptu-guy reminds me of something my piano teacher told me “if you use too much pedal, that means you’re trying to cover up the stuff you didn’t practice well enough”😂
EDIT: Thank you for the 108 people that could (probably) relate! Never gotten so many likes on a comment🥺
In the guitar world it's ""hiding behind reverb." lol. Same energy.
ME: petal to the metal thru that sh*t man
Yeah I think that’s what actually happened there😂
Wait, so you're telling me that all I needed to do during my proficiency exams was use more pedal??? Dang, that would have been MUCH easier 😂
the pianist girl was on a league of her own here
pianist here, summer’s intonation and rhythm was incredible, so i think she was accurately placed. i can’t speak on singing tho
As a person who plays multiple instruments (5 and starting to learn my 6th), I would still say that focusing and putting your all on to one instrument is super awesome. I always call myself Jack of all trades and king of none but I certainly would love to become kingly in atleast one by the time I'm older.
I have a similar mindset. I don't think it should be shamed either way, it just depends on what your goals are.
I think it's good to have a main instrument and a bunch of other ones
@@gaminglegend Yes but tbh, I'd love to master two.... Taking inspiration from our dear Sophie Oui Oui and ofc the great Julia Fischer🙈😁
@@Rahul-gb6il Yep!
Yeah. I think that’s more common among people who find a single instrument limiting. I can relate.
3:52 the way editor-san blurred eddy...I can't-
Wtf HAHAHAHA
nahh this is the order:
6 = Blue Hair
5 = Cello/Guitar Guy
4 = Singer/Guitar Girl
3 = Male Pianist
2 = Drummer
1 = Female Pianist
(maybe switching the top two spots, im not sure)
After watching this I thought the musicians missed the ranking, and instagram was worse. You two had such a good take on each musician and I think the point about “professional” is what separated them. Three of them were hirable and three were bedroom musicians.
13:30 gosh Eddy's way of putting his point across!! So well- worded!
I KNOW RIGHT. So educated and articulate. You can tell they’re trained classical musicians.
Yesss, he can express himself with clarity and
eloquently.
As soon as I recognized Summer and the keyboard she uses in a lot of her videos I got so excited, and I thought everyone else would be near her level at least to give her some competition. Like bruh. It's not even a subjective thing, Summer is literally the most talented one lmao
Aw hi! It makes me happy you recognized me and my Nord :) you’re too kind 🥺🤍🙏🏽 I just posted a response video on my channel btw if you want to see the IG videos that IG used to vote on (not shown in the Jubilee CZcams video)
@@SummerSweeSinghomgg its summer, awesommmeee I'll check it out
Agreed, she really shined compared to the others. Her playing was lovely.
Strong words. I thought she was one of the least talented. Objectively.
@@LeNoLi. Imagine trolling on a TwoSetViolin video lmao, touch some grass
The two girls are the best. Blue hair guy just got crushed lol
Obviously the piano girl is the most solid. Blue haired guy was dunnning-krueger personified. The other where in the middle somewhere couldnt really judge them but do feel the drummer got overlooked because it's an instrument that's hard to grasp and to solo. He had pretty basic leaks but was really on point. Would be happy to have him in my band. I have issues ranking the singer, since she kinda have the voice of every good singers. Would've like to see her tackle a more technically difficult song idk.
i love how they nicknamed the first musician "blue-head boy" lol
Number 7- blue hair guy
Number 5- piano guy
Number 4- cello man
Number 3- drums dude
Number 2- guitar singer girl
Number 1- piano lady
Blue haired guy failed so hard he is the 7th out of the 6 participants.
😂😂 what I thought
And that's the correct answer right there.
Lmao yeah blue hair was multiple levels below everyone else
This is exactly how I ranked them too
Summer was done so dirty oh my god! I would rank her number one
For me it was summer, the drummer, the piano guy, the many instrument guy, then the girl singer and then the blu haired guy
Eddy going back to confirm the drummer's timing was beautiful and why I enjoy this channel.
His timing wasnt really great.. having not much experience with a drumkit, I can see why Eddy thought it wasnt bad, but his bassdrums are really sloppy, his bass+snaredrum hits flam, and his fills were just loud. In fact the whole performance was just loud, nothing else. But to non-drummers that does sound impressive quite often
@@robbertnugteren2801 he was just smacking the shit out of the cymbal and snare with no control of the cymbal and rushing during every fill. He used way too much body movement to fully get advantage of his hands. He was trying to show off and it was really awkward to look at, but we’ve definitely all been there.
what is summer doing with these guys anyway? Bruh this girl recomposed an entire polyphia song on piano. She's on a different level
I didn’t think I’d get cast tbh, so I was shocked when I did. I also expected there to be almost-Polyphia-level musicians there, so was surprised when there weren’t… Once I was there I decided to play original compositions on keys bc I figured I’d get some good feedback/critique, and I’m super glad I did. The excerpts from my composition you heard in the video is from “JFN” (by Summer Swee-Singh) if you want to hear the piece in its entirety :)
@@SummerSweeSingh I heard the piece!! Loved it .Beautiful as always summer !
I feel like you could watch this with the sound off and still be able to tell that Summer is the most skilled. She looks confident and smooth while performing.
i would’ve loved to see them collaborate together, i feel like that would be a great marker for who are the better musicians.
like it’s one thing to play well on your own, and another to create with others
omg summer was so good! as a pianist id rank her 1 and the piano guy/drummer 2nd :)
Classical guitarists use a Capo (the "Cap" thing?) too, but not as frequently. The reasons include (among others) matching the comfortable register of a singer, getting to the original key the piece was written in, making the piece easier to play, or very rarely evening the sound color, by avoiding "open" strings.
not just for playing with singers. I'm practicing a capo on the 3rd fret just because I don't like the transposed key
Clearly you should just use barre chords instead of a capo..... doing a 5 fret span while barreing is doable right?
@@franceskinskij That's exactly why I included "getting to the original key the piece was written in" as one of the reasons.
@@Idiomatick Not always. It's pretty common for an open string to be used with a few notes down the neck. But of course we avoid it when possible.
And the guitarists in our choir also used capo...and they could transpose with ease while I, the pianist, hadn't learned how to transpose on the fly. Thankfully, I had access to a digital keyboard which could transpose for me while the guitarists just figured it out and added the capo as necessary. And they had a good laugh when the choir director asked for the G flat major piece to be shifted down a tone and landed in E major while I had to keep toiling away in G flat major. And I had a good laugh when my lovely C major piece got shifted into...Honestly, I can't remember what it was shifted into...but I do remember the guitarists couldn't find a single way to do it with any kind of capo without having some crazy difficult chording somewhere! Ah, such good laughs and good memories.
Ahhh. "That one cello piece" and Brett's soul-dead-eyes look is back! and in black and white. I've missed that!
I always enjoy B&E's comments and breakdowns on what the criteria of the rankings should have been.
(and did they forget their combs at the quarantine hotel?)
Their hair is so messy hahah! They look like they just woke up
The "cap" thing is called a capo, it's used to raise the pitch/key so singers can feel more comfortable within their vocal range. The more closer to the sound hole the capo is, the higher the sound/key.
1. piano girl (great emotion and dynamics, and also props for playing an original)
2. drummer (i’m a drummer/percussionist myself and that speed while keeping steady is crazy)
3. piano boy (seemed nervous, but pretty good. also pretty solid runs)
4. multi instrumentalist (a little rough around the edges, but he gets extra points for the lap guitar)
5. singer (good voice, pretty basic guitar. nice vibe, but a bit pitchy as well)
6. blue hair (i don’t consider myself a pianist, but i could play that with little practice)
Yh same with what I said with guitar I’m not great myself but I can do a song with 6 chord switches pretty good speed but I can’t sing so we’re even I think
Happy to see you guys back!
I feel like there should be a distinction made between musician who play for a hobby, and those who play professionally (generally speaking). There is such a huge distinction between these two and two separate videos could be made because then I feel like they would evaluate each other more “accurately”.
THIS!
Love you guys reacting and exposing people 👍🏼
Love this. The only thing I'd say is that the blue hair guy definitely is more of a coffee shop artist and songwriter. I think he needs to find a vocal coach. He needs to put the time in.
Bruce Lee once said "I fear not the man who has practiced 10,000 kicks once, but I fear the man who has practiced one kick 10,000 times."
A true master somebody who has practice 10,00 kicks 10,000 times
Who would be the equivalent of Ling Ling but for martial arts?
@@Neptas probably any 10th dan black belt or its equivalent, or a play on Bruce Lee's name; to me Ling Ling being the master of violin has a similar name to Lang Lang who is a popular master at piano
@@Neptas rickson gracie
1:20 another analogy: What is more impressive, knowing a couple sentences in 10 languages or knowing 2 languages flawlessly?
Yeah, this is a really good analogy
1. Piano girl - great articulation and expression
2. Singer girl - great vocal agility and control
3. Guitar and cello guy but not for the cello part - idk much abt guitar but it was pretty good
4. Drummer guy - he was pretty good idk man I definitely enjoyed his performance which is rly what matters in music
5. Piano guy - tried but didn’t execute it well and his hands are flat
10. Julius - nope
the guitar piece he played is ridiculously hard. (I'm kinda exaggerating but it's a very difficult piece)
i love the way two set analyzes this video and goes through how each musician is good and bad. solid musicians 👍
Any ranking not having the piano girl as #1 is just straight up wrong. She had full control over every aspect of that piece.
I would call them not musicians, but amateurs or in the case with the “blue haired I think I’m number 2 guy” is just a beginner (he literally played kindergarten chords, told a “heartbreaking story” and composed some “every romantic pop song ever” lyrics.
The distinction between what is an amateur and what is a professional musician is very, very blurry. Especially these days.
@@HawkOfGP - The difference between an amateur and a professional is the same as ever. Professional means they get paid to do it. Summer (the piano girl) is literally a professional musician.
@@FenrirInFlowers Well yes, that's one thing, but there are many reasons why I would not advocate the type of thinking Arsen espoused here. There are plenty of professional musicians who can barely play any instruments at all, but still managed to become successful. You don't actually really need to play any instruments to make a living making music, which is true of course of both many singers as well as many electronic music artists, for example.
But when many people picture a "professional musician", they think of someone who plays at least one instrument at a high enough level to be hired to do various types of recordings or live performances for a living. That's arguably a valid definition as well, but this difference between definitions can make the distinction blurry.
@@HawkOfGP - I wouldn't advocate Arsen's line of thinking either. These clips are quite short to judge players so dismissively. It's too reminiscent of exactly how blue-haired player treated the others.
First video I've seen of these guys, you two have a mad dynamic ;)
I played the drums for 9 years, he is pretty good, thats what a non player would find impressive. (Yeah he did have just one time signature but played different rythms, that was fun)
As a drummer of 15 years, I don’t agree. He is very eager to show off. What he plays isn’t hard. I mean it would be hard for someone who doesn’t play drums, but it’s very straight forward, but because it is loud and fast it seems impressive, until you actually listen to people like Taylor Hawkins or Travis Barker who takes the time to play fast right.
The guy was way too busy shaking his entire body in rapid movement to use proper technique, and while I’m not a fan of snobbery, proper technique is what makes a simple beat sound great. Hitting the cymbal just right. Knowing how to lay accents in a way that makes the beat sound more powerful and most of all keeping time when doing a fast fill.
@@NotDingse Yeah I maybe didn't explain myself well enough, but yeah its pretty good for someone who isn't a professional (I assume its his hobby) he doesn't do that bad. That's what I meant by "thats what a non player finds impressive" cause obviously one doesn't know tecnique and just listening to it may be fun, just as is fun to listen to children start playing!
We all know the hardest stuff to play is the slow one ;)
@@math_plant true dat
@@NotDingse well stated! I think his exaggerated movements really sold it to the non-drummers.
The amount of narcissism in the original video is thankfully reduced by our violin dads reacting to it
5:00 My literal first thought was, "his fingers are really flat"
I don’t know how I stumbled onto this channel, but you two are my new favorites
considering summer's piano piece was an original, she had by far the most talent. She wrote her own song which was beautiful, she had expressive qualities and her playing was phenomenal. I think the main part i would rank her first is that she wrote the piece herself and it was my gosh gorgeous, had lots of elements. people don't know how hard it is to write a good song until you try it.