Which Top WATERPROOF Mascara is really the BEST?
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2021
- I’m a huge fan of waterproof mascara for my short, straight Asian lashes so y’all know I had to see which one is really the best! In today’s video we’re wear-testing 5 best selling waterproof mascaras and scoring them by application, volume, length, curl, wear, and price to see which is ACTUALLY the best one. If your fav waterproof mascara isn’t on this list, let me know what your holy grail is in the comments!
Follow me on Instagram: / frmheadtotoe
__
▶▶ Watch more of Jen's videos ◀◀
Which Top MASCARA is Really the Best?
• Which Top MASCARA is R...
How to Curl Straight, Stubborn Lashes
• LASH ROUTINE (How to c...
Natural "no-makeup" makeup for Monolids
• Natural "No-Makeup" Ma...
__
▶▶ PROUCTS USED ◀◀
L'Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara
bit.ly/3gdXIKL
Lancome Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara
bit.ly/3im3g8B
Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara
bit.ly/2S7VLrs
Maybelline Sky High Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara
bit.ly/2SdVbs6
Heroine Make Volume & Curl Super Waterproof Mascara
bit.ly/3z6Fe7H
Mascara guard (this is such a must-have!)
bit.ly/3qKwkHT
My FAV eyelash curler
bit.ly/2RrEn0f
__
▶▶ COUPON CODES ◀◀
ESQIDO Lashes:
Click here bit.ly/1pILomn and use code HUGS for 10% off!
Sigma Brushes:
Click here bit.ly/tYs9c4 and use code FRMHEADTOTOE to get 15% off your entire order!
__
▶▶ FOLLOW JEN ◀◀
My Blog: www.frmheadtotoe.com
Instagram: / frmheadtotoe
Facebook: / frmheadtotoe
Twitter: / frmheadtotoe
Snapchat: frmheadtotoe
Subscribe to my 2nd channel! / frmjen
__
Music by Lucas Hogg - Maybe Forever - thmatc.co/?l=AFDAAF8C
Disclaimer: This video is not sponsored by any of the companies mentioned. Some of the links above are affiliate links. Thanks for your love & support! :) - Jak na to + styl
Anyone else typically use ONLY waterproof mascaras like me? Comment with your favorite waterproof mascara and what you want to see me wear test for the next Showdown video! :)
Waterproof mascara is the only way my stick straight lashes stay curled throughout the day! Currently I've been obsessed with the L'Oreal, Air Volume Mega Mascara. As long as you wipe the excess before putting on the mascara, it stays on all day, with no smudging.
I pretty much gave up on waterproof eyeliners as they never survive against my oily lids, but waterproof mascara CONQUERS THROUGH!!! Also, L'Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise is my holy grail and hoping that it never discontinues 😅
Lancôme Deficils or Benefit bad gal
My favorite is Etude House Curl Fix Mascara. Wear test for red lipstick or sunscreen would be awesome! :)
MUFE Aqua Smoky Lash Mascara
Heroine Make Volume is definitely my top choice also! I’d love to see a showdown for waterproof eyeliners from you (both gel/liquid and regular) - Asian eyelids always makes the perfect product harder to find!
YES pls do a waterproof eyeliner showdown!
Recommendations for a waterproof one without fibers?
0
Thank you for taking the time to do this video. Waterproof mascara is the only mascara that holds my curl. I haven't found many reviews that focus on Waterproof specifically.
The last one looked the best at the end of the day. Also the Lash Blast and the Sky High looked decent at the end of the day. I ONLY use waterproof as i have watery eyes and allergies so they always itch. I'm gonna try that last one. It definitely looked the best at the end of the day, which is my marker because it so often looks 'used' by the end of the day and that one didn't on you. Cool!
I’ve been subscribed and watching you for years and YOU LITERALLY HAVE NOT AGED😩😍
I have the same concerns as you when it comes to mascara application and my favorites are the L’Oreal Telescopic waterproof and Clinique Lash Power. I love that the Lash Power is a fiber mascara so no need for oil based cleanser removal. Just warm water and it all comes off at the end of the day, also doesn’t smudge. Feel free to give those a try too 😊
Since high school I’ve been curling my lashes and using waterproof mascara to keep my curl. A lot of them are great at keeping a hold and wearing through the day but I always get transfers on my bottom lash line. This was helpful!!
I don’t like to wear lashes unless for special occasions.
Thank you for making this video! You are the ONLY CZcamsr I trust with mascara recs! My fave was UD Cannonball bc you suggested it but they discontinued it :(
I BEEN WAITIN FOR THIS ONE
I’m a little late but for the plastic wands that are meant for length, you have to twist the wand instead of moving it side to side. It doesn’t clump up when you twist it.
My fave is Holika Holika’s Lash Correcting mascara in #01 Hyper Curling. Lashes don’t go crunchy, takes several coats really well, lengthens, holds curls well and doesn’t clump! They’ve just come out with an extension version too which has fibres in :)
I typically only use waterproof mascara in the summer when I go to the beach or pool. My current fave is Tarte Lights, Cameras, Splashes, but I also love the L'Oreal Voluminous!💜
waterproof liquid eyeliners! thank you for doing this, i was just looking for product recommendations
It's amazing the quality of products you can find at Japanese drugstores. From mascara to facial SPF and everything in between!
Love this video. I have difficult-to-apply-Asian-eyes too and tried so many waterproof mascaras, the Japanese one has been my fav. the whole time over 5 years. And working as a flight attendant I have to wear it thru over 20 hrs sometimes and that one really works the best no matter Dry dry weather or humid weather where I am. 2nd fav. is Maybeline but i dont see the one i used on market anymore :( Anyways, after many many years i havent visited your channel Im impressed on your videos consistency and honesty
A mascara guard?!? 🤯🤩 I can’t believe I’ve never seen this ahhhhh!! Thank you! 🙏🙏🙏
I just received my first tube of Heroine last week and I was honestly blown away, the only mascara I’ve ever tried that didn’t smudge under my eyes after years and years and dozens of recommendations and trials of countless mascaras
I honestly didn’t believe it was possible for mascara not to smudge on me, I’m actually so excited about it lol
I highly recommend CANMAKE TOKYO Quick Lash Curler! It’s really popular in Japan😄
i used the sky high (non waterproof) and they made my lashes fall straight down immediately after application, which was SO disappointing because the length it gave my lashes was unreal :(( i started using it with the pmel mascara base, which helps my lashes keep its curl all day, but without the mascara base i only use the sky high mascara for bottom lashes! my holy grail is def the etude house curl fix though- for people with thin, stubborn lashes, asian mascaras are definitely the best :)
Is the Etude house one waterproof ?
I love the Sky High because it holds really well, but I also noticed that I'm losing lashes when using it (a lot more than when using other mascaras).
My absolute fave mascara is the waterproof maybelline lash stiletto! I always come back to it!
This one is sooo good 😍
I love ILIA’s mascara. I work more than 12 hours and I am impressed by how my lashes are still curled and long ☺️
I love that you made a waterproof video! My lashes are just like yours, they do not hold a curl with most if not all mascaras that’s not waterproof.
Very frustrating!
Thank you Jen for this review! I purchased 3 tubes of the Heroine Make Long & Curl mascara as it's my HG mascara, but it's nice to see American drugstore options when I run out
I was surprised with how many good ones there are now! Especially with drugstore mascaras, I was really impressed!
How do you take it off? It's so hard to remove it
@@jesykrodriguez2390 order the kiss me heroine speedy mascara remover! it literally melts the mascara off!
Omg thank you. My limp asian lashes are so so so thankful. ❤️
Thank you for this review! I have a hard time removing waterproof mascara so a Showdown on waterproof mascara remover would be great!
Clinique Take the Day off is good but expensive. I love the Nivea express waterproof eye makeup remover.
Hi Jen! Thank you so much for this video! I loved it! Your girl needs a lotttt of help with waterproof mascara. I always trust your reviews & recommendations because I have the same struggles. Can you make a waterproof eyeliner show down next? I’ve yet to find one that actually works!
have you tried the one by Pur?
Oh oh oh so excited for this! I’m just about running out on my tube of Mr Big waterproof!
Would love to see a video on the best long-lasting transfer proof lipstick in the future!
Heroine Make had been my HG for years. Wears like armor and does not smudge. Its made it through partying in Vegas and childbirth (twice!) You cant go wrong with it imo
Thank you for the video! My favorite is the Etude House Curl Fix Mascara.
I think #2 and #5 looked best! But you are gorgeous all the time 🥰
FYI - the "advanced film" version of the heroine make mascara is a little easier to remove but is still waterproof!
Ooh, good to know!
I've been waiting for somebody to review more waterproof mascaras. Their quality is really put to test with all the MASK wearing. I wish somebody tested mascaras by wearing a mask all day...:P I find that even the best ones smudge and flake.
I tried the Heroine Makeup Volume super waterproof mascara and finally it has ticked all boxes for me as I have oily skin. It was easy to remove with the Maybeline eye makeup removal. I only found it on Amazon-Australia as I haven't seen it in any store and price online was AU$22 not too bad price. Am very happy with how it works and at least it doesn't smudge (and I also have one eye that leaks) easily as the other expensive brands. Compare with other mascaras I used to look like a racoon and am glad I watched your video so I can make a decision of what to try. Thanks for your advice!!
You HAVE to try the Maybelline colossal cat eye waterproof mascara. Been using it for like 6+ years and its the best for asian lashes
Thank you for this thorough and so helpful review!! I have a new mascara fave on the way! 🥳👏🏼 And yes I only wear waterproof mascara too. everything, literally everything else smudges eventually.
Nice review. I use Lancome Monsieur Big, regular formula which seems water resistant. It often goes on sale in dept stores. Just purchased 2 for $24. Also can get at ulta few times a year for $12.50. It is my favorite mascara, almost never pay full price. Sales are mostly on Holidays about 3 to 4 times a year. At that price point well worth it.
Gotta try the Heroine one. And I’m glad I’m not the only one who gets mascara all over the lids, whew! I’m normal lol! That’s what got me into getting the mascara guard
Jen, you should do a review of the Grande Lash Serum! Would love to see your results. I’ve been using it for 2 months and had great results.
I've tried ALL of the mascaras listed here and in my opinion the best (smudge- proof against oily lids, waterproof and holds a curl on Asian lashes) are Korean mascaras... The top of which is Tonymoly Shocking Mascara (I like the copper one best)
The copper one would be the extreme lash? Or the milligram volume??
My right eye is more watery than my left for some reason. A tear or two will often come out when I lay on my right side, whether my eye is open or closed. Don’t have the problem on my left. My mascara and eyeliner smudge more on my right eye because of this. You’re definitely not alone with this problem haha.
I don’t typically use waterproof because I have a hard time removing it without scrubbing too hard on my eyes. 😶 My holy grail mascara is Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara with Primer and it is the BEST, keeps my curl and doesn’t irritate my eyes! ❤️
you should definitely try pond’s cold cream to remove your waterproof mascara. it always works for me!
You can try micellar water, a biphasic cleanser or just a straight up lightweight oil like almond, grapeseed, rosehip or hempseed oil (dont recommend heavy oils like castorn olive or coconut, as they ca clog pores if used directly on skin). You can use a cleansing oil or balm too but I haven't tried those as they're so expensive. Usung oil is the best trick, it melts off anything and it's cheap. And then follow it with a water based cleanser and you're set :)
Yes! This is my all time favorite mascara. 😘
Lancôme Monsieur Big is my HG mascara I feel like I’m wearing natural falsies bc of how perfect looking my lashes look 😅. I should definitely check out the others you’ve mentioned!
Do you mean the waterproof version?
Exactly the video i was looking for, thank you!
I have can only use waterproof also. Cant wait for a part 2 🙂 please try maybelline last stiletto and maybe full & soft waterproof mascara
Thank you Jen! 🥰💋
Absolutely precise. BRAVO!
I’m sure there’s great mascaras out there, and it’s nice to know there’s other options. But I’ve been using the kiss me heroine mascaras for over 10 years (tried a few other brands along the way), these are just my tried and true. Also just don’t feel like spending any extra money anymore to try née ones.😆 but this video was super helpful!! Thanks for comparing all those!
do you prefer the regular or waterproof one?
@@syahirah3245 waterproof - mostly bc my eyes water/I cry a lot and my lashes droop easily without it
@@desormais22 thank you, definitely trying this one after my current mascara runs out☺️
@@syahirah3245 you’re so welcome, I hope it’ll work great for you!!❤️
My holy grail is Maybelline's Colossal Big Shot waterproof. I'm actually using Monsieur Big and Covergirl Lashblast right now too. ☺️😅
loved going through the comments here i'm actually picking up recommendations thx guys!
Yay - I was just researching the best mascara for Asian lashes... Don't you think sample mascara has a better wand than the full size?
My go to is not what she mentioned, but I have been using Maybelline Total Temptation blue bottle waterproof for a few years. They go on very thick and does not coat every single lashes. BUT it does not cause my lashes to be droopy or make me look like I have panda eyes later in the day.
what foundation did you use in the video (during Maybelline Sky High Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara)? Your makeup base looks so purrfect
Hi Jen! Could you please share where you got your blue blouse? It’s super pretty!
I've tried 4 out of 5 you showed today and I would say I like the heroine make most, I can say those hold a curl that don't quit! My current favourite is lash princess waterproof from essence and it's honestly my favourite in terms of accessibility, price, performance.
Ooh I also use the essence one! In comparison with the heroine make one, which one of them do you think is the best?
@@kaylalovestosleep I like the essence one more because it applies on my lashes softer with more volume, holds a curl, and easier to remove with cleansing oil or biphase. I also find it hold up decent in my workouts, usually no smudging unless I shut my eyes super tight when I working through tough reps. Which then, I get a little smudge but nothing close to racoon mask hah heroine make perform well too, but I find the crispy dry down to be super difficult to remove (even if I wash with oil cleanser, cleansers, biphase, and even micellar water afterwards, I'll still have remnants on my eyes 👀) and having to order overseas can be a hassle.
Great vid! Gotta know where you got the blue top you're wearing in the beginning! Love it
Do you prefer the super waterproof version or the regular/advanced film version for the kiss me mascara?
Heroine is great but hard to get in Europe. I’m using Shu Uemura Stretch Xtreme Precise Finish Waterproof Mascara. It’s pricey but out the 100 mascaras I have (literally all in one box) it’s the best result I’ve ever had.
L’Oréal voluminous lash paradise ended up on my lower lids. Lancôme monsieur held the curl and smudged very minimally.
I was obsessed with cannonball when you recommended it but they stopped selling it!
Omg the covergirl one looks amazing on you
Lash paradise is amazinggg.... i put it on, went out, accidentally fell asleep with it on, took a shower, went out again, and it stayedddd onnnnnn.... i used a micellar water to remove and came off easy
I have both the Heroine Make mascaras but I prefer the Long & Curl one instead of the Volume & Curl (is a bit more clumpy imo) :p
Great video! I’m a waterproof mascara wearer like you and my holy grail is the Lancôme one. I find the price is worth it as I really get full 3 months wear, sometimes I can stretch it too compared to the drugstore ones. The L’Oréal paradise dries so fast, like in a month so it’s not a good buy for me. Additionally, I suffer from dry eyes and for some reason, it doesn’t act up when I use the Lancôme compared to the drugstore ones that’s why it’s an overall favorite. I did recently try the sky high and like you, was quite impressed give the length and how it can coat each lash well. I enjoyed it and also like it as a “base” mascara for layering. I liked the Heroine Make long and curl better than the volume one. I’m curious what you think of the long and curl version. And yes, heroine make has a product to help dissolve the mascara that I do enjoy too which you apply like a mascara which is brilliant.
Can I ask which lancome mascara do you use?☺️
@@sunnyday2251 the Lancôme monsieur big waterproof version.
@@lengeronilla4981 Thank you! ✨✨
CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara, either the Red tube(long&curl) or Black tube(volume&curl) will make you WOW!
TRY!!!!!!!!!!!!! And the wand is super lower lashes friendly.
Even at the start of the video I had a feeling that the Japanese brand one was going to win haha. I kinda wished you included 1 more high end mascara to make it more even playing field though.
I always use herione long and curl. Now I will try the volume and curl.
I live in Europe and it’s hard to find my most favourite mascara which is Heroine Make. Guys for Asian eyes, especially Monolid, I agree 💯 % with her that Heroine make is worth the hype. But for those who live in Europe, it would be nightmare. Once you try and you love it, you will realizing that it’s not able to find it anywhere in Europe except buying online. Need to go back to Mybelline which does give the similar effect, but nothing can compete Heroine Make for me.
Waterproof liquid eyeliner!
The Mabeline has Aloe in it I would never try it. I thing your wild card looked the best on you!
Where did you get a mascara guard ? I have never heard of it. I would love to have one. I HATE putting any eye makeup on !!
Try Lilybyred’s mascara, I love it as much as I love the heroine make one!!
Been here long enough to say: waterproof Urban decay Cannonball
There's actually a heroine mascara mascara remover that dissolves their mascara as soon as you apply it! I highly recommend purchasing it!
Great to know! It’s definitely my favorite mascara but I always have such a hard time removing it 🥲
I’ve tried it! I didn’t think it was that much better than normal mascara removers :/
The Lancome Monsieur Big is $30 and was wondering what you would recommend that might be comparable for a little less?
The best waterproof mascara for my Asian lashes is: Maybelline The Colossal☺️ been using for years and years..
Same! I feel like us Asians really know our waterproof mascaras and ‘Maybelline the colossal’ has been my favorite for years 😊
I use the same! I also use it with Cover Girl Super Sizer waterproof mascara
You are a cutie. I've been looking around for a mascara that I can wear for my (eventual) upcoming wedding. So far, Heroine has come up at least twice. Naturally, because it might be the toughest one to get ahold of. This whole event is becoming a problem child. :0) Thank you for your thorough tryouts.
Thank you for this video! Right at the perfect time. Well, almost. I recently bought the Sky High and although I liked the length and amount of volume it gives, also love how natural at the same time they look, I made the mistake of buying the washable one, not the waterproof formula. And it uncurled my lashes immediately on application :( I have very straight stubborn lashes like my hair, and it's nearly impossible to make them hold a curl. So to see how these mascaras actually perform in that manner is amazing. Almost no reviewer comments about the uncurling thing that happens with most mascaras.
For me the problem is that mascara smudge on me because I have very dry skin and so all my lotion/cream give me the worst result. I love the tubing mascara a lot
Try the waterproof mascara from Clio (Korean Brand)!!
Love your top! Where is it from?
This mascara (kiss me heroine) changes everything, the best I've ever had. I'm from Germany, Berlin. I bought one online from the link. Unfortunately, the purchase only worked once. I'll see where I can order again. Many thanks!!!
Hallo Katharina, die Heroine mascara ist nach wie vor bei yesstyle erhältlich.
Tippe in die Suchleiste einfach waterproof mascara ein und diverse Ausführungen von heroine poppen auf.
Which lipstick are you wearing it looks like a berry color? Looks very pretty on you 🙂
The wild card was definitely the best. I just ordered mine I'm so excited for it. I'm retiring my better than sex mascara she's not giving me any life anymore
Would love to know your thoughts on L'Oreal Telescopic Mascara in Black :)
Which one is the least flakey? I have such trouble with that.
You need try clio mascara. Korean mascara have thin wand.
Woah! Who did the thumbnail for this video? I’m looking for a graphic artist to do some artwork for my videos.
Same here!!
What do you use to remove waterproof mascara?
Pencil eyeliner please
thank u
Where is your blue top from?
i wanna know too lol
I think it’s the Faye top from ASTR the Label.
Jen, I accidentally exit your live chat. Can you tell me the best non smudge eyeliner that you are using? I’m CTH. Thank you!
Lately I've been using the ONE/SIZE Point Made and Rare Beauty liquid eyeliners but I tend to rotate through a lot of different eyeliners! Maybe I need to do a Showdown for eyeliners next :)
Thank
You!!
Yes please do a showdown on eyeliner!!
fine point eyebrow pencils
Heroine Make is the bomb, it stays on after swimming and showering
The Loreal one smudges on me. I have oily lids
❤️
Definitely have one leakier eye 😂 my bottom lashes will smudge no matter what. But that’s because I touch my face too much. I wish they’d make makeup for people who can’t quit touching their face. By the time I go to bed there’s barely mascara left to remove.
The paradise mascara has so much product on the wand for me. I have to take some of it off. It’s an ok mascara. Not my favorite
Asian mascara made for Asian eyes can't be beat ;)