Hi guys! Just wanted to let you know, in light of all the new things JK Rowling has said in the past year (2020) ĂĄnd her new book, I don't want to actively recommend her works of fiction any longer. I am still keeping this video up so you can see the other recommendations, but just wanted to make this clear. Check out these articles to learn more on the JK situation and her views: www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/article/2020/06/10/opinion-why-jk-rowling-wrong-side-history www.allure.com/story/jk-rowling-transphobic-tweets
TL:DW 1:08 The Diviners by Libba Bray 2:23 Ninth House by Leigh Berdugo 3:48 The Naturals by Jennifer Lynn Barnes 5:17 Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson 7:06 The Cuckoo's Calling by J. K. Rowling 8:25 A Study In Charlotte by Brittany Cavallaro
I would suggest "Murder mystery of Reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It's a wonderful book to read in the mystery detective genre, a must-read for mystery lovers by Agatha Christie. Unlike normal crime thriller this book doesn't focus on brutality of the crime but it focuses on the mystery.
Lots of great recs to add to my wishlist lol. ----- 'A Study in Charlotte' has a beautiful cover. ----- My favourite crime book is one which I never would have looked twice at if it hadn't been assigned reading for Uni, and that's 'The City and the City by China Mieville. Highly recommend!
personally thinking, Japanese crime novels are CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED. There are so many fantastic ones like Devotion of Suspect X, Journey Under the Midnight Sun, Confessions etc.... they are the pinnacle of Asian crime lit which few people discover. PLEASE READ THEM, its really worth it. and they are DARK
I am on the fence with continuing Truly Devious series. I didn't enjoy Truly Devious as much as I thought I would. Vermont and Ellingham Academy are beautiful. (I actually prefer to be there than in Hogwarts đ). I would love to read Cuckoo's Calling and A Study In Charlotte. đ
I LOVE TRULY DEVIOUS !! but lil rant about study in charlotte i don't know how i feel about it... like it's so good but so much at the same time like i feel like i was almost forcing myself to read it ?!
Thank you very much this really helped me to decide what book (Mystery/Murder book) to buy cause im just new to the book world ya know... BUT!!! Thank you very muchđ„°â„ïž
i find it so hard to find murder mystery books and not thrillers?? thank you fro the video! I've loved the diviner series, it's incredibly fun and diverse, and deep. Ninth house is better than everyone says and that's my hot take, the murder mystery and dark academia vibe is soooo addicting!! truly devious is a love letter to murder afficionados. A study in charlotte is interesting because of the fact that the retelling exists within the sherlock homles 'universe', and that's so cool. Anyway, great vid, might think about checking that JKR book, without buying it obviously, since it's the only book here i haven't read and i love all of the other recomendations you made! great vid!
Thx. Ur shallow comments on Jk.Rawling made me realize somebody just canât improve themselves and broaden their horizon no matter how many books theyâve read.
Reading this comment with Gillian Flynn author, I remember a very good book worth the read. Slid through my app, and yas. GONE GIRL by Gillian Flynn is also a worth ot one. â„ïž
The book its about a detective, she has a scare on her face, her partner got killed with a shotgun, her sister died of cancer, but the sister las words where her husband name, (detective brother in low), so she has to investigate why her sister last words where the name, and than in the middle of the investigation she meet a Doctor... she finds that her brother in law, and the doctor wife know the same lawyer so thats how she meets the doctor, i hope someone can find this book and comment the name, i just wsnt to know if there is a movie đđ...
Truly devious is a SUCH a gr8 book!! I just couldn't put it down...I cmplted the trilogy in 2 days....I am still not over it....I'll recommend it to everyone
Was genuinely daunted by the prominence of the Harry Potter display behind you, fearing you have a very young mind that doesn't care about things making any sense, which is crucial for mur/mys novels. But your recs weren't bad at all. Thanks.
I just starting reading books in this lock down and I found that I liked any kind of novels but their content should believe good. I read the summary before buying the book. And I liked his she told the summary of all books I will definitely buy 3 of them cuz I loved their story. I hVe been looking for reccomendations by Audrie neffeneger and Preeti shenoy. But the are just telling self help books. I am so glad I found some one who can reccomend me books related to my interests. Thank you so much Leo mam
How do you know if youâve hit the reading slump. This happened a couple of days ago and Iâm walkways wasting time and I feel guilty so I decided to read a book but I didnât like it but I forced myself to keep reading to equal the amount of time Iâve wasted on my phone, is this a reading slump? I want to read and enjoy books, but idk cause the books I pick up I donât enjoy it and I want to enjoy it
I'm making a crime mystery book here's what it is about:give feedback pls: A series of murders that happen at the same time in various countries are investigated.The victims are not related in anyway but have 3 main similarities: the murders happen to all explore the same remote place in there their past life,They all have a letter that is from a person,who was said to be dead 30 years ago,though the date appeared to be sent only a decade ago and a pair a spectacles that contained a unusual key like screw,which joined the two temples with a up hinge. This murder mystery is unlike any other...
hakim kaddour if you are buying their books, you are funding them and so in a way their believes and their platform (esp if theyâre as famous as JK) too. Iâm not saying my opinion is the right one, as I will always love HP, but I do feel the need to discuss these things.
@@leoraaileen I totally do agree with you for one should be selective. However, this, at the same time, means one should not fund the authors whom he or she don't share the same beliefs and those whom he or she don't know which beliefs they have (otherwise One will find himself or herself funding their, the authors, platform). the question is: does this mean that you are funding only the authors whom you are sure they share same beliefs as you?( not that logical) I just felt the need to discuss this with you and thanks for answering.
@@leoraaileen Well the book's name is 'The witness' by Nora Roberts., But the thing is once when I didn't knew about the book name I was desperate to read it at any cost, and now when I know its name, I didn't even read it once..đ€Šââïžđ
tu pourrai mettre les sous titres en français? ce serait vraiment VRAIMENT super :) could you put the subtitles in french? it will be really REALLY great :) Thanks
hiii! she said some really transphobic things on twitter :-( if you google it you will def find some articles on it, I also linked one talking about it in my description!
books with leo hey yeah thanks for putting the link. Seriously as a proud Hufflepuff and a huge fan of Harry Potter im just shocked and speechless. I wanted to be a writer because of how inspiring she was to me and now im just sad and angry left with a sour taste of wasted hope
Love The Diviners too, I've only read Part 1 too even though I've got both the sequels rented from the library sitting right next to međI've never read JK Rowling's pen name works and I've always wanted to; in light of the (several) recent times that she can't seem to shut her mouth I doubt I ever will lol I think separating the art from the artist is justifiable on a case by case basis but in this case, in my opinion I don't care to explore any more of her work. A shame she feels the need to use her massive platform to spread hateful messages.
omg go read the diviners right now hahaha. And with JK it is a complicated case. I also think that there is such a big, loving supporting community built up after her work that does support anybody, no matter their gender identity. However I would certainly understand if you never pick up the Cormoran Strike books.
@@leoraaileen Oh i totally agree about HP, I'll always love it and the HP community is insanely cool. That's exactly the sort of thing that makes it complicated!! I'm not sure if her other works would even interest me anyway - I had wanted to read them just to see what else she was writing besides HP. But since I don't really care for the author I don't care to see anymore what she's writing now if that makes sense hahaha!
Ill always support JK Rowling lol. Just because you dont agree with her beliefs doesnt mean you still can't support her as an author. Sorry but I think it was pretty lousy of you to straight up tell people not the support her. You could have just said you dont and leave it at that. Shes an amazing author with her own beliefs that im sure lots of people agree with..she just made a mistake by not keeping it to herselfđ€Šââïž. I swear people are so sensitive these days smh. I think she still deserves to be supported for her work. Harry Potter meant alot to alot of people. The reason I think she used that alias is not because of that drama anyway and more because i think she wanted people to love her book as mystery novel, and not just because it came from her.
Good recommendations I'm definitely checking out on some of them for sure!! I'm so disappointing for J.K. as well, such horrible thing for her to spread those kind of messages đ€đ€
I just wanted to say that I think including the JK Rowling book was not the way to go here. I think there are a bunch of authors out there who have written books that have all those similar things you enjoyed about Rowlings book. I know you don't support her ideas about transgender women like you stated, but you are still encouraging people to read a book she wrote, and there will probably be people who maybe don't know what's going on with her and will buy the book. I think it would've been better to just elevate a different author who your views do allign with more, that maybe doesn't get as much exposure. In no way is this meant to hate on your video, I just wanted to share that that rec left a very bad taste in my mouth.
Hi Julie, thanks for giving me a heads up, I agree with you, I don't feel the same way anymore (as in I don't want to recommend her books anymore, not even with a disclaimer like in this video) after all the things she's said and done in 2020. Have pinned a comment to make this clear to new viewers.
@@leoraaileen thanks for posting the pinned comment, and thank you for responding to me. Itâs great to see someone taking responsibility for their content like that.
Hi guys! Just wanted to let you know, in light of all the new things JK Rowling has said in the past year (2020) ĂĄnd her new book, I don't want to actively recommend her works of fiction any longer. I am still keeping this video up so you can see the other recommendations, but just wanted to make this clear. Check out these articles to learn more on the JK situation and her views: www.sbs.com.au/topics/pride/article/2020/06/10/opinion-why-jk-rowling-wrong-side-history
www.allure.com/story/jk-rowling-transphobic-tweets
Thank you I would no more read Harry Potter and the fantastic beasts
Just trashy
Cringe. This level of woke pandering is pathetic
TL:DW
1:08 The Diviners by Libba Bray
2:23 Ninth House by Leigh Berdugo
3:48 The Naturals by Jennifer Lynn Barnes
5:17 Truly Devious by Maureen Johnson
7:06 The Cuckoo's Calling by J. K. Rowling
8:25 A Study In Charlotte by Brittany Cavallaro
Tnq sooo much.... â€ïž
the cuckoo's calling isnt by JK Rowling lol
it's by Robert Galbraith
@@itzcomplicataed3538 I mean youâre right and youâre wrong if you check 7:11 youâll see that J.K Rowling did write that book
I love you.
Guess I've been living under a rock
MEOOOW CATTTYLEY hahahah why??
@@leoraaileen I'm new to booktube
Same here
Same bro
Hahahaha sorry guys iâm glad youâre all here now
me, here because Iâm in a murder mystery/crime mood because Iâm binging criminal minds: đđđ
Brycelyn Turner me being here rewatching my own vid and spotting this comment đ±
Im soo glad i found BookTube
me too â€ïžâ€ïž
I would suggest "Murder mystery of Reporter" by Jaiprakash Jha. It's a wonderful book to read in the mystery detective genre, a must-read for mystery lovers by Agatha Christie. Unlike normal crime thriller this book doesn't focus on brutality of the crime but it focuses on the mystery.
wow i never thought of the diviners and ninth house as murder mystery!!! i loved this vid bc im obsessed with murder mystery atm hahaha
megwithbooks welllll they kinda are! But i see where youâre coming from. And sameeeee âš thank you đ§Ąđ§Ąđ§Ą
@@leoraaileen It's actually listed as Paranormal Fantasy on Goodreads. I love the series â„ïž
diviners is not even a murder "mystery" the killer is literally revealed in the prologue
So many nice recs you gave! I love me some good mystery books so I will watch out for these!
catarinathebookworm thank you! These are all def so good â€ïž
Lots of great recs to add to my wishlist lol.
-----
'A Study in Charlotte' has a beautiful cover.
-----
My favourite crime book is one which I never would have looked twice at if it hadn't been assigned reading for Uni, and that's 'The City and the City by China Mieville. Highly recommend!
Thank you for this! I just added all these books on my reading list :D so excited!
jell glad to be of help!
personally thinking, Japanese crime novels are CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED.
There are so many fantastic ones like Devotion of Suspect X, Journey Under the Midnight Sun, Confessions etc.... they are the pinnacle of Asian crime lit which few people discover. PLEASE READ THEM, its really worth it. and they are DARK
the diviners is one of my favourite series. canât wait to read the fourth book!
minahil sheraz omg I reaaaally need to start in the second one đđ
Mine too!! Do you have a book recommendation for me based on LOVING the diviners:)?
Just added so many books to my TBR!! I subscribed :)
yay! glad to help
I am on the fence with continuing Truly Devious series. I didn't enjoy Truly Devious as much as I thought I would. Vermont and Ellingham Academy are beautiful. (I actually prefer to be there than in Hogwarts đ). I would love to read Cuckoo's Calling and A Study In Charlotte. đ
saaame I loved ellingham academy SO MUCH
Iâm really interested in Ninth House and Truly Devious! Those two are super hyped
loved both of them!!!
I loved "A Study in Charlotte"!
I LOVE TRULY DEVIOUS !! but lil rant about study in charlotte i don't know how i feel about it... like it's so good but so much at the same time like i feel like i was almost forcing myself to read it ?!
Thank you very much this really helped me to decide what book (Mystery/Murder book) to buy cause im just new to the book world ya know... BUT!!! Thank you very muchđ„°â„ïž
MY GAL making another amazing video
The clumsiness at the end got me
Just subscribed âšâšâš I love your shelves so much! Thank you for these recs, Iâve been looking to expand my murder mystery repertoire đ„°
Jennâs Bookshelf Thank you sm! yaaay hope this helped then
i find it so hard to find murder mystery books and not thrillers?? thank you fro the video! I've loved the diviner series, it's incredibly fun and diverse, and deep. Ninth house is better than everyone says and that's my hot take, the murder mystery and dark academia vibe is soooo addicting!! truly devious is a love letter to murder afficionados. A study in charlotte is interesting because of the fact that the retelling exists within the sherlock homles 'universe', and that's so cool. Anyway, great vid, might think about checking that JKR book, without buying it obviously, since it's the only book here i haven't read and i love all of the other recomendations you made! great vid!
thank you! yes it's super unfortunate that jk is saying all that stuff really. the book is real good.
Thx. Ur shallow comments on Jk.Rawling made me realize somebody just canât improve themselves and broaden their horizon no matter how many books theyâve read.
Ca anyone reccomend me a book that's like death note?
Nid Hasani Liar Game
Manga or novel? For a novel I would reccomened "And then there were none" by Agatha Christie, for a manga I would reccomened "The promised neverland"
Have you read Dark Places by Gillian Flynn?? It's really good!
Is it murder mystery
@@moderntech4784 yess a really good one
Thanks I will definitely read it
Reading this comment with Gillian Flynn author, I remember a very good book worth the read. Slid through my app, and yas. GONE GIRL by Gillian Flynn is also a worth ot one. â„ïž
I love mystery and crime books too đđ...
Thanks for the recommendations! Will definitely read these books :)
i have never read any crime novels so i want to start now.....HAPPY NEW YEAR
You too!!!
youâre my new fave booktuber âșïž
aaah thank u hahah
I need HELP finding a book name...please read the comments for book description.
The book its about a detective, she has a scare on her face, her partner got killed with a shotgun, her sister died of cancer, but the sister las words where her husband name, (detective brother in low), so she has to investigate why her sister last words where the name, and than in the middle of the investigation she meet a Doctor... she finds that her brother in law, and the doctor wife know the same lawyer so thats how she meets the doctor, i hope someone can find this book and comment the name, i just wsnt to know if there is a movie đđ...
The silent patient is one I would recommend really good novel đŻđŻ
I just read his second book the maidens and really enjoyed it! â€ïž
@@leoraaileen never read that one might stick that on my to read list too many so far đbut Iâll defo look into đŻ
So many that i want to read Great Rec video âšđ
thank you!
As a beginner whatâs the most book from the video u recommend to me? ( eng itâs not my first language)
Truly devious is a SUCH a gr8 book!! I just couldn't put it down...I cmplted the trilogy in 2 days....I am still not over it....I'll recommend it to everyone
I reccomend "one of us is lying" its where there are totally opposite kids who have detention together and one of them dies sooo ye
Ya I heard of it!
There's a sequel btw if you having read it. It's called one of us is next
Are this books without smut? Plz I really hate reading smut, and most of the books include smutđ€đ
I have hear of the first book just never read it or I don't know it by the name
I have few crime books đđđđ
Was genuinely daunted by the prominence of the Harry Potter display behind you, fearing you have a very young mind that doesn't care about things making any sense, which is crucial for mur/mys novels. But your recs weren't bad at all. Thanks.
Which one should i read first? Please respond.
Dying for Christmas by Tammy Cohen. You might also like that. â„ïž
Can i be honest? I like crime mysteryâs but i just dont like the dark magic cult like books, any recommendations
I just starting reading books in this lock down and I found that I liked any kind of novels but their content should believe good. I read the summary before buying the book. And I liked his she told the summary of all books I will definitely buy 3 of them cuz I loved their story. I hVe been looking for reccomendations by Audrie neffeneger and Preeti shenoy. But the are just telling self help books. I am so glad I found some one who can reccomend me books related to my interests. Thank you so much Leo mam
Have u read the murder mystery book titled The sweetness at the bottom of the pie by Alan Bradley? I think u will like it.
ooooh I'll look it up thank you!
Thank you these all seem amazing!!
How do you know if youâve hit the reading slump. This happened a couple of days ago and Iâm walkways wasting time and I feel guilty so I decided to read a book but I didnât like it but I forced myself to keep reading to equal the amount of time Iâve wasted on my phone, is this a reading slump? I want to read and enjoy books, but idk cause the books I pick up I donât enjoy it and I want to enjoy it
Same! I always read some easier ones, like children's to get out of it. My faves are by Neil Gaiman and Roald Dahl.
books with leo ahh ok Iâll give that a try thanks
@@waterunder3718 hope it works for you too! Or just read an old fave again.
books with leo yep thanks for the amazing idea I think that will definitely get me back into reading
Life is too short to read a bad book .
Does the book Truly devious have romance where the mc ends up with a guy in the end?
I'm making a crime mystery book here's what it is about:give feedback pls:
A series of murders that happen at the same time in various countries are investigated.The victims are not related in anyway but have 3 main similarities: the murders happen to all explore the same remote place in there their past life,They all have a letter that is from a person,who was said to be dead 30 years ago,though the date appeared to be sent only a decade ago and a pair a spectacles that contained a unusual key like screw,which joined the two temples with a up hinge.
This murder mystery is unlike any other...
What is the name of the book?
ok does anyone know of good Y/A murder mysteries that have romance in them (like actual romance w sex and stuff)
does anybody know a book where the main character kills somebody? (i would preferably want to know they killed somebody at the beginning) :))
I recommend come back for me
It's amazing!!!!
Hey you should check out this book called 11 and a half deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle it is an amazzzing book!!!
Viha Shah facts.
Seven and half
I just finished reading the truly devious series after u recommended them . Loved it . Thank u â€ïž
I reaaaally need to reread them so I can read the third one!!!
Love it!
Have you tried, one of us is lying by Karen McManus?
I have! Liked it, but was not that special to me personally
The Truly Devious covers are gorgeous
are these mystery books?
genuine question, do you only read books written by female authors?
You sound just like Belle from Once Upon A Time
Righhtttt
I also have a thing for boarding schools lol.
Paper Faerie hahahah yeah whilst filming this I was like Iâm...??? Really into that??? I guess đ
Judging a book by the beliefs of its author especially when the book doesn't reflect its author's beliefs is a bit .......
hakim kaddour if you are buying their books, you are funding them and so in a way their believes and their platform (esp if theyâre as famous as JK) too. Iâm not saying my opinion is the right one, as I will always love HP, but I do feel the need to discuss these things.
@@leoraaileen I totally do agree with you for one should be selective. However, this, at the same time, means one should not fund the authors whom he or she don't share the same beliefs and those whom he or she don't know which beliefs they have (otherwise One will find himself or herself funding their, the authors, platform). the question is: does this mean that you are funding only the authors whom you are sure they share same beliefs as you?( not that logical) I just felt the need to discuss this with you and thanks for answering.
did you mean study in scarlet?
i can't tell if she's British, Australian, French or American
to make it more fun, i'm none of those things.
so for start i live under rock. OK NEXT
Hey guys.,
I was reading a book one year ago which I had to stop due to some reason and now I just can wait to complete the book but the thing is I FORGOT ITS NAME..!!
Even I don't khow the author's name..đ©
Can you please help me finding the book's name..??
It would be a great help..
The story in that book is.. A teen girl who is very bright in study., her mom promises her a summer vacation but then denies for that and goes for some work., in that time the girl makes some new friends and with one of the girl she goes to bar with fake IDs nd there they both fall for 2 boys and goes to their house and finds that both are murderers.. the gil's new friend was murdered there and now the girl runs away to save her life where she lives with some police officers where then the house was attacked and all the officers were killed..
Then the girl runs away from the house and from here I haven't read further..
It would be a great help if you can find the book's name or the author's name..
Thank you..đ
Kushal Gupta iâve got no clue but omg this was a wild ride đ
@@leoraaileen Well the book's name is 'The witness' by Nora Roberts., But the thing is once when I didn't knew about the book name I was desperate to read it at any cost, and now when I know its name, I didn't even read it once..đ€Šââïžđ
tu pourrai mettre les sous titres en français? ce serait vraiment VRAIMENT super :)
could you put the subtitles in french? it will be really REALLY great :) Thanks
mymy hmr i dont speak french that well so that would be a tough cookie hahahah
@@leoraaileen oh it does not matter thank you anyway
Omg thank you
J.K. Rowling making scientific statements should not be remotely controversial. GOOD GRIEF!!!
Thank you for sharing
sorry I've been living under a rock, but what happened about Jk Rowling?
hiii! she said some really transphobic things on twitter :-( if you google it you will def find some articles on it, I also linked one talking about it in my description!
books with leo hey yeah thanks for putting the link. Seriously as a proud Hufflepuff and a huge fan of Harry Potter im just shocked and speechless. I wanted to be a writer because of how inspiring she was to me and now im just sad and angry left with a sour taste of wasted hope
I would appreciate your opinion on my recent thriller - the SOULLESS brain - available on Amazon. Thanks in advance.
some more trigger warnings for a study in charrlotte are drugs, and eating disorder behavior
Leo: if you donât know This book youâve been living under a rock.
Me: I dunno
Me:letâs go look for a rock that can fit me
The living under the rock comment.... Everyone don't go on booktube . Or even an avid reader .....
Love The Diviners too, I've only read Part 1 too even though I've got both the sequels rented from the library sitting right next to međI've never read JK Rowling's pen name works and I've always wanted to; in light of the (several) recent times that she can't seem to shut her mouth I doubt I ever will lol I think separating the art from the artist is justifiable on a case by case basis but in this case, in my opinion I don't care to explore any more of her work. A shame she feels the need to use her massive platform to spread hateful messages.
omg go read the diviners right now hahaha. And with JK it is a complicated case. I also think that there is such a big, loving supporting community built up after her work that does support anybody, no matter their gender identity. However I would certainly understand if you never pick up the Cormoran Strike books.
@@leoraaileen Oh i totally agree about HP, I'll always love it and the HP community is insanely cool. That's exactly the sort of thing that makes it complicated!! I'm not sure if her other works would even interest me anyway - I had wanted to read them just to see what else she was writing besides HP. But since I don't really care for the author I don't care to see anymore what she's writing now if that makes sense hahaha!
đ»
Ill always support JK Rowling lol. Just because you dont agree with her beliefs doesnt mean you still can't support her as an author. Sorry but I think it was pretty lousy of you to straight up tell people not the support her. You could have just said you dont and leave it at that. Shes an amazing author with her own beliefs that im sure lots of people agree with..she just made a mistake by not keeping it to herselfđ€Šââïž. I swear people are so sensitive these days smh. I think she still deserves to be supported for her work. Harry Potter meant alot to alot of people. The reason I think she used that alias is not because of that drama anyway and more because i think she wanted people to love her book as mystery novel, and not just because it came from her.
Good recommendations I'm definitely checking out on some of them for sure!! I'm so disappointing for J.K. as well, such horrible thing for her to spread those kind of messages đ€đ€
I knooooow!! i'm pissed too hahaha
You are so preety
I just wanted to say that I think including the JK Rowling book was not the way to go here. I think there are a bunch of authors out there who have written books that have all those similar things you enjoyed about Rowlings book. I know you don't support her ideas about transgender women like you stated, but you are still encouraging people to read a book she wrote, and there will probably be people who maybe don't know what's going on with her and will buy the book. I think it would've been better to just elevate a different author who your views do allign with more, that maybe doesn't get as much exposure. In no way is this meant to hate on your video, I just wanted to share that that rec left a very bad taste in my mouth.
Hi Julie, thanks for giving me a heads up, I agree with you, I don't feel the same way anymore (as in I don't want to recommend her books anymore, not even with a disclaimer like in this video) after all the things she's said and done in 2020. Have pinned a comment to make this clear to new viewers.
@@leoraaileen thanks for posting the pinned comment, and thank you for responding to me. Itâs great to see someone taking responsibility for their content like that.