5 Reasons You Should (Not) Buy An Electric Car
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
- Should you buy an electric car? How to know if buying an EV is right for you.
Sponsored by Progressive. Should your next car be combustion or electric?
Subscribe for new videos every Wednesday! - goo.gl/VZstk7
Buying a new car is a big decision, and there are an abundance of choices. Among those choices are powertrain, like gasoline, diesel, hybrid, plug-in, hydrogen, or electric. Making the switch to electric can be intimidating, how do you know if an electric car is right for you? In this video we'll cover five aspects of buying an electric car, and discuss for each reason why you may (or may not) want to buy an EV. Those five aspects include: cost, convenience, charging, driving, and the environment.
Don't forget to check out my other pages below!
Facebook: / engineeringexplained
Official Website: www.howdoesacarwork.com
Twitter: / jasonfenske13
Instagram: / engineeringexplained
Car Throttle: www.carthrottle.com/user/engi...
Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/engineeri...
EE Extra: / @engineeringexplainede...
NEW VIDEO EVERY WEDNESDAY! - Auta a dopravní prostředky
And if you only need a car to travel from time to time, then you should buy a Delorean with a flux capacitor.
Very funny comment.
Especially good with the optional Mr. Fusion.
Ahahaha good one
Found the Dad jokester!
Nice one lol
For me, and probably many other young people the problem is we haven't settled for a long term house/apartment to install Level 2 chargers in.
@Not Hitler "I dont care about the environment to hell with mother nature!"
You should drop the "not" from your name.
That still isn't a problem. A lot of places have chargers now, so charge the car when you go shopping.
you don`t really need that, it`s just faster to charge with one.
Bjarne Olav Kjølstad I don't have a garage in my apartment, not even a outdoor outlet... I know they won't bother to install any, because mostly old people with no car or fossil cars live here
@@FSXgta ok, I charge with a outdoor outlet at home and a type 2 charger at work.
The math only stacks up in the US where petrol is sold as cheap as water. In the EU for instance, electric has a major lifetime running cost advantage.
I thought the price wasnt so bad until i remembered it was per liter!
But at the same time, a lot of people in europe live in apartments with often no parking space and don't have the option of charging their cars whenever they want.
@@Vertical690 Yay, public transport is good but. And rental cars. And, gasp, walking
That being the case why are e car sales so poor in Europe? Even after subsidies. And taxes that triple the cost of fuel. I like e cars and would love to own one. But 1, I don't have a driveway and 2, I can only afford $5000 to buy a car so even secondhand e cars are beyond me. And I'm not some gangsta salvage engineering genius like Rich Rebuilds!
God bless the u.s then, the land of the most free car enthusiast 🇺🇸
What keeps me from getting into purely electric cars is that I live in an apartment building. I am on the 3rd floor, facing away from an open air parking lot. There are no electrical outlets near the parking lot, and I'm not going to dangle a 300ft cord from my apartment window to the parking lot just to have some other tenant unplug my car cause he wanted a giggle.
I also wouldn't be able to charge my car at work because they don't have electrical access on the outside of the building. They also refuse to put in electric car chargers because not enough (literally 0) employees have electric cars to justify it.
Not to be that guy, but I refuse to sit and babysit my car for hours at a charging/fuel station just to make sure I have enough juice for a couple days.
Being on the poorer side makes electric only vehicles almost impossible to realistically own. For some people it's not a problem, and they have the ability to work around lack of charging support in their lives. For me, it's not practical until the infrastructure improves around me.
Your situation is quite common.
This is why electric hasn't taken over yet. Plus I'm not sure how far past 100k a electric would run.
Read the edit please.
I agree with you 100%, but wanted to let you know that once most EVs start charging, you can not simply unplug them. You have to use an app, key, or button inside the vehicle to remove the charger.
Edit: I didn't understand what you meant at the time. While no one would be able to unplug the car at the car itself, if you're using an extension cord; someone could easily unplug the car by unplugging the extension cord.
Oh yea thats unfortunate mate. Sister got lucky with her underground parking at her place and was able to get an outlet down there to charge nightly.
This isn't a plug for tesla (pun intended lol), but the superhcarging network may take care of you. We don't have a tesla (yet), but the supermarket where we do $95% of our grocery shopping had a ten stall supercharging network put in about a year ago. We go there at least once a week, and from people I have talked to it will get them from 0-80% (what tesla recommends your max be for every day use) in half an hour. I can easily swing that, should I choose to. The cost of the car is really what is holding me back lol. That and, aside from wanting one, our current vehicles are perfectly fine and paid off, costing nothing but standard maintenance and fuel.
Apparently, Progressive only had one requirement for this video...
No whiteboard.😁
I actually just canceled my progressive insurance because they were charging me $600 more a year for my insurance. I was with them 8 years.....
@@Hallowsaw What are progressive insurance?
@@1300l It's an insurance company like GEICO
@@Hallowsaw I was with Geico, then State Farm, then Progressive, went over to Root, now back at Progressive. It pays to shop around for your car/home owner/renters insurance yearly.
@@AlGoYoSu I need to shop around too. It's just too easy to stick with one company.
You're the reason why i'm still loving to learn about mechanical engineering, especially automotive engineering
Bruh. Same.
Big facts
@no post Why dont you try searching for a job in US or Europe?
Finally, a balanced objective and fair representation of the difference between owning an EV or ICE car, thank you
This was made when gas was $2 a gallon.
What is ICE supposed to stand for?
@@zechariahcameron3645 Internal Combustion Engine.
@@spacingguild thank you sir!
Always appreciate an objective look, thank you!
Timestamps:
1. Cost 0:40
2. Convenience 3:53
3. Charging 6:32
4. Driving 8:17
5. Environment 10:05
Thank you
@@jimbomacgee3499 you’re welcome
1 year later....thanks Nolan. Hope you're doing well...
@@d.lawrence5670 yeah no problem, I’m doing pretty good
Thanks.
$2 a gallon??? It's almost $2 a litre in the UK give or take...
Covid-19 made gas prices super low in USA.
Its $1.9 a gallon here in texas
@@pleasedontwatchthese9593 1.45€/L in Greece(6.46$/gallon). Thats why we have max 1400cc cars here. We need 12€ every 100km (14.12$ every 62 miles) if its a small diesel like a fiat punto we need half the price.
Thats because yall don't have guns
BT DT even if it’s $2.50 which is like £2 that’s still 3.5litres compared to 1l in the uk. The equivalent in the uk would be about $7.50 a gallon
I was a traditional car enthusiast that only would support combustion cars until my girlfriend got her plug in hybrid (15 Ford Fusion Energi) and now can see what's so great about electric cars. My next daily driver car is undoubtedly going to be electric in some fashion.
Thanks for making this video. I really appreciate the great non biased information!
$500 to install an 220 outlet NEXT to the panel? As an electrician, I am in the wrong area of the country to earn a buck.
This video says $500, Amazon says $500, every form I read said $500, then when I called my local electrician he quoted me $200. . .
Depends on where you live. Local labor rates, material costs. I can easily see it. With all the storm damage material supply is starting to be a real problem. I've seen wire cost go up as much as 50% in the last 6 months. Aluminum wire costs have skyrocketed to the point where it's no longer cost effective to run at any length and size whereas it used to be cheaper than copper for larger sizes just a year ago. Material and labor markets make a big difference on the cost.
We paid $250 to get a NEMA 14-50 installed right next to our electrical panel here in Texas.
Yar Nunya Yar is right. Reason: Aluminum cold flows over times; copper doesn't. If you don't know the implications of that, ask an older electrician.
oneselmo Um, no. The issue with aluminum is oxidation. Us an oxidation inhibitor such as NoAlOx and aluminum is perfectly fine to use.
I think the more relevant question to ask in many cases would be "Should I buy a new(er) car?". And if you don't drive much, the answer is no. At least if what you have is reliable.
unless you do a lot of miles per day? maybe not... or you want to enjoy the comfort of a silent and fast/responsive commute.
@@AlexDubois they said if you don't drive much...
That's true if you don't value the increased performance, convenience and safety features that are more readily available on newer cars. Keeping an older car is pretty much always going to be more cost effective, but cars are getting better and adding new features all the time, and you need to decide if those factors tip the scales to determine that you are willing to spend more money on a newer car.
But I think you are right that a lot of people just default to buying a new car, when if they considered it logically, what they want would be satisfied at a cheaper price by buying an older one.
It also depends where you live whether an old car goes bad quickly. In St. John's, NL or Halifax, NS, cars rust very quickly because of the heavy use of road salt, and will deteriorate whether or not they are driven often. 7-10 years is usually the reliable lifespan. However, warm wintered Vancouver, BC has some of the oldest used cars in good condition, where a lightly driven and properly maintained car is still in great shape after 30+ years.
Must be a Toyota then
"Let's assume both cars are trouble free for 4 years" you shouldn't have used a VW for this example then
Zoikes, I've got 1 year left 🤞
Why the heck is the American government giving tax breaks to people buying foreign cars? That is absolutely ridiculous!
VW is one of the best cars in the world. Sorry you Americans botch it up once it gets there :P
That's hilarious. I've owned several VWs. For each of the new ones, the first three years were needed to find and fix all the bugs and flaws. After that, it was smooth sailing for many miles. They are a PITA until you shake them down.
@@jonkirkwood469 VW are some of the finest cars out there.
i really like that you tell us both the negatives and positives because there is nothing perfect :)
You’re the reason I’m going back to school to learn more.
why go to school if you want to learn?
The Vibe wow. Way to summarize the entire American education system.
I mean, it's true. I dropped out of university because I wanted to learn more. Now if you want a certification of some kind, maybe because you want a job in the field that you're learning in, then yeah you need to go back to school.
Other than that though, you can learn just about anything you could want to know for free on the internet, much of that here on CZcams.
@@natalyasparrow6748 yeah, go to college to qualify for jobs, not to learn. As you said, everything you need to learn is free on the internet, short of PHD level education.
Ppl are telling you to don't go to school to learn..
Come on guys, i'm happy for him. Ppl who complaim about go to shcool to learn are the ones who can do it.. who want but can't wish to go to shcool.
We bought our Model 3 in September 2019. Within a week I realized the massive convenience factor. I leave my garage every day with the equivalent of a full tank. Our other car is a 2019 Volvo XC90. In the 12 months of owning both we put 16,000 miles on the Tesla and about 5,000 on the Volvo. When the Volvo lease is up in November of 2021 it will turn into a Model Y and we'll be 2 EV home. We live at 8,000 feet above sea level in the Colorado Rockies....winter is not an issue.
it's like living at a gas station! Full tank every morning
And I'm also assuming that you don't have the same loss of power due to elevation with the Tesla....
@@Momo_8k how does elevation causes loss of power? legit don't know if it's a thing or your are joking
@@japalocoturbo Less air density => less fuel per combustion cycle => less power
That's why piston airplanes can't climb too high without a compressor.
@@japalocoturbo in an ICE vehicle, power comes from air and fuel. More of either one increases power. Higher elevations have thinner atmosphere, meaning less air enters combustion. Less air = less power. Naturally aspirated cars make less power and run slower times at elevation (Colorado) than at sea level.
The opposite occurs with forced induction (turbos and superchargers) where the main function of both are to introduce air into the engine. I don't have personal experience with forced induction at elevation, but those types of motors should not lose *as much* power compared to naturally aspirated cars.
Electric motors don't need air and fuel to operate. So they should produce the same amount of power at any elevation.
Non-scientific, but hopefully that's helpful. Reply if more clarification is needed.
Nice to see someone local doing great content on CZcams.
220v (level2) is a super easy install, especially if you already have an electric dryer or stove. You can plug in directly to those outlets if you buy a charger off Amazon or Ebay. About 150 to $300 USD.
Great vid. Who woulda thought, some of the most well rounded advice around EV and ICE is from a guy who’s a an actual car enthusiast
“You should never spend money for less convenience”
But also Miata :D
You don't buy an EV for convinience, you do it for everybody else.
@@Tore_Lund Nobody should feel morally obligated to buy something that, under current circumstances, is only marginally better for the environment. Until full renewables/nuclear becomes reality, we need to make EVs more convenient to convince people to switch.
@Patrick No you don't. Why do you think there is a tax Rebate, so more people can have fun?
@@specialopsdave I Agreed on that, just Rolling out EVs without a similar goverment incentive to clean Up the Grid, does very little, to reduce emissions. Hopefully the US Will get back on track with the Paris Accord, so in 15 years, driving an EV Will be the on!y sane choice, both financialy and environmentally.
@Patrick Growing Up in Europe in the 70', I must admit, that I feel embarressed today, using at least two sundays every month to protest nuclear power since kindergarten. But that was the sentiment then. Actually today, Europeans are close to 50% approval of nuclear, but nobody wants Them in their own town. Still the Countries that have plenty of reactors, like France, export to the rest of Europe, So we are using it, while looking the other way.
Regarding the "EV's run on coal" argument, the nice thing with EV's is that when you upgrade the grid to use more gas/hydro/solar/wind/nuclear power you automatically upgrade all the vehicles charging off it at no cost to the consumer. With ICE doesn't matter what you do with the grid ICE still pollutes exactly the same.
EVs, even when running on fossil fuels, use that energy more efficiently than ICE vehicles. Especially when you include the energy used transporting gasoline and diesel in huge tanker trucks
@@ThomasBomb45 Plus extraction of oil, transporting of oil, refining oil. All take a colossal amount of energy.
In the UK we have several green energy suppliers.
According to a donut media video I watched, over time, even on our dirtiest energy source, the carbon footprint of electrics us smaller. Initially though the production of these batteries has a huge carbon footprint, and other environmental/ ethical issues.
@@ThomasBomb45 coal isn't transported?
I still remember your drifting video...come a long way..very very proud
5 reasons why I'm gonna stick to my 96 Accord until it disintegrates.
you will disintegrate first
Ehh, i made the switch from my 96 camry to a new car because I watched crash test videos, and those 90s cars are pretty scary haha new cars are light-years ahead in safety, that's my only motivation to get newer cars.
My 93 sentra was literally a coffin on wheels. Super scary crash tests results.
@@NoName-gv6nm ill write that in you coffin, at 100 mhp your super safe car wont protect you
@@omegarugal9283 How often do you drive 100 MPH?
Giggling. 88 Camry owner.
P.S. Manual. 6 cylinder.
And ...No stinkin' airbags. Fuel filter not located in the G.D.M.F. - wait for it - GAS TANK. No scan device or board for me to be fleeced because of it.
Yes, yes and yes. I basically have the "cheap" version of Jason's stable: an e-Golf (bought new 6 months ago) and an Na8 Miata (and my girlfriend has a Civic). The Miata may be the fun car, but the e-Golf is also a pretty fun vehicle, thanks to instant torque and the Golf chassis. I have often read that an electric car can only be a second vehicle because of the limited range. In actuality, it really is the first car as the cost of operation, comfort and convenience are the best. I never even used the rapid charger and I don't even plan to. I bought the car knowing full well its pros and cons and I knew that for longer distances, we would simply use the Civic. But for suburban driving, even the errands to go to the other side of town (up to 100 km in total), the Golf is the way to go. If we ever need to change the Civic for a bigger vehicle, a RAV4 prime would be high on the shopping list. As for noise, let's be real: most cars on the road don't even sound good. If you drive a Mustang GT as your daily, good for you, but if your daily is a Corolla, Civic, Mazda 3, etc, you won't miss the noise, but you will enjoy the absence of vibrations. As for shifting gears, yes, a good manual is fun, but one-pedal driving is just another kind of fun that is also legitimate.
As someone who is seeking to have both vehicles this video was very helpful for beginners thank you
Also, I was at Bryce Canyon and Zion this summer-both of which are way off the beaten path-and lots of Teslas were at those parks. I’m not sure how convenient charging was, but it surely didn’t stop folks from using electric cars way out in the country!
Some use camp site power hookups, will do it one day
Sasquatch 2001 oh man never thought of that but they have 220s there. What a great idea!
Most major national parks and such have charging in nearby tourist stops and towns. Its really little places like rural Tennessee where I can't take my model 3. I was there for a wedding at an AirBnB and it just wouldn't have worked. I swapped with my buddy or would have rented for this trip, as my model 3 SR+ is the only car my gf and i have. This was the only trip in 20,000 miles that we didn't feel comfortable with.
I've got a 2017 Chev Volt, my boss has a model X Tesla, and my daughters friend has a Chevy Bolt. My second vehicle is a new Nissan Frontier pickup. I'm only charging the Volt on 120V and I'm at around 80% electric. (It has a 53 mile electric range before going to gasoline.) Most of the EV miles are local, and the gas miles are on a road trip. My boss uses his Tesla a lot around town, but uses his gasoline SUV when doing road trips. My daughters friend only has the Bolt, and attends local college, so he's fine with an EV.
FYI - when I road trip, I usually rent a cheap sedan so I don't put tons of miles on my vehicles and my insurance gives me a break for low miles. I'm hoping more and more people go EV, so gas stays cheap when I have to drive my pickup. Lots of choices in vehicles out there!!!
well maybe.. It's also a matter of supply and demand. I work in the fuels business, and our refineries price fuels by what the demand is. My segment is pipelines, much smaller than our refinery group, and when demand is low and refinery margins are low, our little business can make better profits than several multi-billion dollar refineries. And if they try to make less product, their efficiency drops, so even if they sell it for more, they don't maintain their profit. (I've got 35+ years in the industry) So, if you are looking at wholesalers or retailers that can "gouge" ,I agree with you, but that doesn't apply to the entire process stream.
Just the electricity used in the refinery to produce a gallon of gas is about 7 kwh. This is always produced by the cheapest way possible. Over 90% of the time this is coal and onsite at the refinery. That is typically more electricity than an EV uses to drive 30+ miles.
I heard Texas refineries use a lot of wind power, hope thats true! I use wind for my home power plan, 9.9¢ /kWh
@@bikesqump Yeah, mining coal in Texas is expensive, and wind power is nearly as cheap as importing. Plus, these oil/energy companies are starting to invest in renewables anyways in preparation for when fossil fuels go the way of the dodo.
Great Tips Good Stuff Very Clear Understanding 👍 Thanks!
Interesting. Thank you for giving the Pros and Cons of both. I also enjoyed the throwback Bogus Basin Rd footage ;)
Thank you very much for making this video. I appreciate the excellent, non-biased information! As someone who has had an EV, I can attest to how inconvenient they are in comparison to full hybrids and ICE vehicles. Yes, maintenance is less expensive, but repair charges can be prohibitively expensive if the broken component is not covered by warranty.
Thanks for a clear, concise breakdown of the pros and cons of EV's. No EV fanboy swooning, and no V8 (Because 'Murica) nonsense, either. EV acceptance will boil down to infrastructure and EV density in a particular area for those that require that infrastructure to operate their EV's. Where I am, the nasty winters really eat into range, and charging stations are fewer. When I retire in a couple years to the USA Southwest, I will definitely be in an EV for daily use with a gas-fed toy or two for the joy of shifting. Solar panels on the roof are part of that plan as well, and will lessen the footprint even more.
Great video, thank you!
Excellent video, very fair and quite detailed.
Great job! All those things plus 0-60 in an EV is second to none
Ben Sullins Yes, who cares about top end speed? When you're city driving, it's a race from one red light to the next. It's all about starting torque. As for maximum speed, some cop bored out of his skull sitting in a radar trap sees YOU blow by at 120mph+ and it's Yee Hah!, another high speed chase, and he gets to meet his ticket quota the easy way. I wave as I drive by doing 70 in a 60 zone because my ev just blew the doors off him up to 50mph, so he was embarrassed and cranked it up to show me how fast he was. 🤗
@@oneselmo Most accidents and deaths occur based on the driving you just described yourself doing.
Andrew Boehmer Nope! The most dangerous accidents are at intersections. You've got a green light and some entitled texting goof t-bones you as he/she runs the red light. Deadly multi vehicle accidents slamming cars into pedestrians or bus stops. There's lots of dash cam videos on you tube to educate you.
@@oneselmo You are factually incorrect, some videos you saw don't prove anything
That's an argument only valid to fanatics. 99% of drivers couldn't care less if their car gets to 60 in 5, 7 10 or 2 seconds. When you drive away you're not on a race track and when you get on the freeway, many times, there is enough traffic to prevent you to even accelerate that fast. So, this argument is to most irrelevant when choosing a car.
We're a single car household and our pure EV works perfectly for us, we do have a home EVSE though. Rapid charging on journeys is actually quite fun.
You buying a solar car though?
Richard Honor We bought a 2021 Kona ev two months ago, and have been using it as our daily driver ever since. I've kept track of our driving, and as near as I can figure, we've used the equivalent of $550 cad of gas to go 4,300 k. Our 2000 Vitara hasn't been driven for over three weeks (it gets app. 25mpg). Because our power company is a public utility, it is able to carry out a promotion of free charging at their 50kWh d.c. fast chargers for who knows how long. They are just starting to upgrade the chargers to 100kWh units. When we charge at home, our electricity costs app. $0.09 per kWh, and to charge from zero to 100% costs us around $5.75cad. That gives us a range of 428kilometers without charging. We have absolutely no buyer's remorse. 🤗🤗
We only have a Model 3 LR AWD, and it's fantastic! Had it since the end of '18. I only have a 15A plug in my garage, but it's enough especially if I can charge at work sometimes.
Same here, I have been enjoying your videos for as long as I have been able to understand technical english, and even tho I study medicine, I love learning about engineering, because of you!
Well done Jason. Your videos are well thought out, clear, and explain everything well. No wonder you have 2.82M susscribers. Wonderful! PS As a fellow Canuck, I loved your videos with The StraightPipes' Jacob and Yuri.
Nice summary. We are taking our Tesla to the north rim of the grand canyon in a few days. Plenty of chargers along the way, and hotels with chargers.
I just got back from north rim and saw a bunch of Tesla’s 😀 have fun!
@@atavanH Cool, thanks.
Just remember that the closest Tesla Superchargers are 150 miles (St. George, UT) and 120 miles (Page, AZ). Any chargers closer are 16kW (or less for what are in campgrounds). If you want to see Zion or Bryce (or about anything else) you need to plan ahead (but if you own a Tesla you are probably used to that).
@@edweeks6423 Thanks. We are staying in a hotel in Kanab that has a charger.
Living in Canada I’ve always wondered what the batteries would be like in our constant -30C weather.
Tesla Y has a heat pump so maybe this solves the problem with cold climates.
Dmitry Drozdov free perpetual heat! Cool!!
Wait...
Isnt it worse to find a charging point if you travel between the cities?
@@Welcometofacsistube No just less juice spent on heat.
@@christianbro2 Apparently they're out there on highways but if you go back roads then no.
I own
01 integra 400 miles to a tank
2017 altima 600 miles to the tank.
I'm good. Love what I've learned tho so thank you EE
Excellent video, very informative.
One thing worth mentioning, petrol cars are more fuel efficient when driving on the highway (higher speeds), but electric cars are the other way around (as their engine revs way higher on highway, electric cars not having a gear box).
Also, some other points to take into view: scarcity of the materials used in batteries (and the way they are mined), also the grid would probably just collapse, if everyone would suddenly switch to an electric car.
Your theory is a bit off. Cars are more efficient at slower speeds due to air resistance. The faster a car travels, the less efficient it is, gas or electric. The reason combustion cars have a higher MPG rating is due to start and stop traffic in the cities. Every time a gasoline car stops, the momentum energy gets turned into heat by the brakes. Electric cars capture this energy back by letting the momentum spin the electric motor turning into a generator that chargers the batteries, hence they use regenerative motor braking.
And the grid would not collapse with electric cars as the grid is designed to handle peak use which is only a few hours a day. Typically, peak hours are only 8 hours a day 5 days a week, while off peak is 16 hours a day 5 days a week and 24 hours on weekends and holidays.
During these off peak hours, power plants are idled or taken offline. There is a huge amount of surplus generating capacity off peak and we have the ability to charge tens of millions of electric cars with basically nothing more than basic routing upgrades to the grid.
@@redbaron6805 I meant petrols use less fuel on highway as in city, because of their higher gearing the engine runs on lower RPM
I think it's only fair to tell you that you're one of the reasons I'm studying Automotive Engineering today.
i been researching the subject for years and i have to say this is a very good video.
This is like the ultimate guide for shoppers looking to upgrade. Amazing detail and coverage.
This is NOT the ultimate guide because there is no section in this video about owning one in the north and dealing with the extreme cold. At best this is video telling everyone there is good and bad things about owning an EV but only scratching the surface of the bad things. The cost of the tires for instance, EV's require tire changes almost 2 to 1 compared to normal gas-powered SUV's due to weight and how much faster they are used up.
Great video, thanks! I would like to see more information on the manufacturing / total carbon footprint of ICE vs EV, emissions is only one environmental component.
The total carbon footprint of ICE cars will always be far higher than EV's. The additional emissions during manufacturing of an EV are offset typically within 12 to 18 months. Over 90% of lifetime emissions of a typical car comes from burning fuel. Barely 5% to 10% comes from manufacturing.
I agree with you! It's all about convenience! I drive a 3 cylinder gas car, I took a road trip from the Midwest to FL, and I drove 1,250 miles. I paid no more than $64 for gas plus I still have a half of a tank in the car. It took me 18 hours for the trip. If I had an electric car it would of taken about 24 hours per Tesla's charging guide. If I had to pay for electric, per Telsa cost calculation it would cost me $97.
How on earth would it cost $97? At $2 a gallon, that's only 26 mpg. My 2005 Taurus gets that. There must be some error in the information.
Must be a Mitsubishi Mirage?
@@soiceyboy33 my guess is Smart Car
@@soiceyboy33 and only 40 mpg
@@soiceyboy33 It could be a Mitsubishi Mirage or Koenigsegg's Gemera. 🤔
A really great EV Video simply packed with information pro and con EV’s in different circumstances; ie not simply ‘guns-ho’ for EV’s in every situation, which many YT reviewers take as read. Excellent. Thanks.
Drove my Chevy Bolt 1000 miles moving from Texas to Florida, no problem if it's a rare trip. Every other day of the year, being able to charge at home is SO much better than going to the gas station every week or two
I'm a petrol head, but not having to stop at gas stations would save me not only time, but also stop me from impulse buying slim jims...
Yep...
But you have to realize that on a road trip, you don’t wanna run the car below 20% so that means you have to stop ~ every 150 miles so you can fill up to 80% which is what’s recommended, but even at a Tesla level 3 supercharger, it takes about an hour and 15 mins to get from 20-50 miles up to 200. Does that sound like saving time or fun? A 10 hour trip going 700 miles becomes 13 or more if it’s not a Tesla brand Charger. Because when my dad and I tested a 2019 Model 3, it was always super far to each charger so the car tells you only go 65mph. I don’t want that to be the future of road trips. No thanks, I do like to go fast.
@@scottoleson1997 Where did I say anything about road trips, and why just assume someone watching this video isn't aware of this vehicles range, charging network, and Tesla's recommendations? I mean you're pretty much just repeating the cons that were mentioned. Why?
If it upsets you that people other than San Francisco's finest are interested in this car, perhaps you shouldn't read the comments.
Edit: If you think this is the future of the electric car, you are sorely mistaken. You are witnessing the genesis, and the tech is only going to get better, go farther, and be more commonplace.
@@InuranusBrokoff Few things annoy me more in youtube comments than irrelevant replies that attempt to argue against points that I am not making. I have never seen someone address that kind of reply as beautifully as you have done here. I commend you.
yes you can do a 4 hour journey without stopping at a station with an electric car saving you money and time. I think most EV's do 215 mile range. 211mpg where as petrol cars only do 45mpg
@@steve00alt70 Yes, but most petrol cars also carry around 20 gallons.
Bought a '16 Volt 2 years ago, this sounded a lot like me convincing my wife why it was a great idea.. ;) Still love the Volt too..
Those are the only EV’s or hybrids in my opinion that look good, or at least somewhat better than a bubbly car
Damn, an actual, honest look at ICE vs EV. Congrats.
This should be EV 101. This is the best pro and con conversation that I've seen, and it's all at a level anyone can understand. Okay, maybe you've glossed over the long distance, point-to-point a bit, but you have the supercharger network. My Bolt would not travel as well (but we have a PHEV as well). Great vid!
Went from a Subaru WRX to a Tesla model 3 SR+ and no regrets! Love my model 3, but I can see why electric is not for everyone! My weekly commute is about 200 miles and when I get home I just charge it in my garage!
When I take a longer road trip a have a Tesla charging station 10 minutes from my house at a mall, so I need to charge up quicker I leave the car there for 20 minutes while I walk around the mall.
I must say for someone that has driven manual his intere life that I do miss stick shift occasionally!
Funny story I’ve got an 18 wrx myself and would love a model 3 or even a coupe if they release one anytime soon. I love the turbo and awd but have wanted electric for some time now. I live right down the road from work, have superchargers being installed at the local target a mile or two away from me right now, and love the minimalism and less maintenance that comes with them.
I have to chip in as another Subaru guy. I still have my 03 WRX, she sits pretty in the garage and I take her out about twice a month. Daily since April is a Model S. They are both very enjoyable cars, in strikingly opposite ways. My advice is keep them both and enjoy accordingly.
@@alex86devapath as someone who's also driven manual most of my life, I must say I don't miss stick at all, especially in traffic. I hate automatics even more now... so clunky.
So far I've done about 1 year and over 20 000 miles on an EV as my only car, and I would like to point out, that a lot of the things Jason lists are very relevant but also case dependent. If you live outside the US do your own calculations. Gasoline is ridiculously cheap in the US compared to the EU for instance, which tilts the cost analysis for the benefit of the EV. As for road trips, this summer did my first 2000 mile EV Road trip and I loved how cheap it was to drive as well as the convenience of sleeping in the car with the aircon on through the night. But here in Finland we have a very good charging network so I can drive just about wherever I feel like. Again, do your study on how good it is where you live. How about business trips? At some point you'll have to stop for lunch or dinner, and that is when you plug in. Some 30 minutes of charging will take you far on fast chargers.
One tip I do have if you consider an EV - range is king. Consider how often you drive long trips and size your battery accordingly.
Finally, there are a few reasons I would go back to ICE. One is for the sound that a nice sports car makes. Another is for the handling and steering feedback, which is often considerably worse on EV's. Third reason is for towing. While the torque of the EV is great, you can't beat the fact that the ICE engine gets only more effective when you load it more so your relative mileage is actually often improved (when looking at consumed fuel / cargo weight that is moved around), where an ev will lose a significant portion of its range. And in many cases there might be no towing option for it at all.
" this summer did my first 2000 mile EV Road trip and I loved how cheap it was to drive as well as the convenience of sleeping in the car ...... " --- Sounds awful, can't imagine when I would go on a vacation where the plan was to sleep in the car.
@@davidmorrow4195 I would sleep in my old Camry Wagon. but I also agree with the first comment, the ‘19 Tesla Model 3 feels weird to drive, exactly like a GTA 5 car. It’s like fast off the line, but once you go 60, it feels like it’s just like the car is saying, “what, you still want more? 🙄fine.” And it’s kinda floaty to be honest without any weight in the front. Maybe to some people that’s fun, but all you hear is the whoosh from the road and honestly it’s a lot louder than I was hoping. And the autopilot mode beeps at you to keep your hands on the wheel so I don’t see the point. Just an overall disappointment in my opinion. But hey, you can make the turn signals make fart sounds in the settings, no joke. (Who is that even for???)
@@scottoleson1997 just rest your hand on the steering... I let it sort of rest by my thumb and you're good to go. Autopilot is the best! Love it for highway, traffic or if I'm just on a normal road, but need to take my eyes off the road for whatever reason.
@MadeInFinland "Another is for the handling and steering feedback, which is often considerably worse on EV's" I drive a Model 3 LR AWD and a BMW M2. Even with the M2 in Sport Mode, the Model 3 has much better/tighter feeling feel. Obviously if you want feedback (i.e. you're at the track) then that's a whole different ball of wax, but 99.9% of the people who buy these cars won't see, not to mention drive at the track.
@@brois841 not 99.9 … sorry. It’s more than one in 1000 drivers and enjoys a good handling vehicle. Not something that hugs the road because of the weight of the battery pack, but something agile and light.
Please make a video based on the production and disposal of the batteries used for these cars.
That would change this video greatly
Keep the great content up!
Yes. I imagine that continuing the compare/contrast theme with ICE vehicles would be most informative, including production and disposal of lubricants, over the life of the vehicle.
I love your videos and theyre almost always very informative but i play them to sleep sometimes.
Amusing level of irony in your comment.
Well for us, we went to a BMW i3 about 4 years ago. It cost more, it's the only car in the household and we sometimes need to do long trips to see family so it was primarily point 5 (Environment) that caused us to make the switch. I haven't burnt anything in the last 4 years and I've loved every trip as it's great fun to drive. I'm an ex-petrol head and bought my first VW Beetle at age 12, so I've always been fascinated by cars in many forms.
Why did you choose the i3? Just curious, the i3 always seemed ugly and overpriced to me.
with electric you must take into consideration how your electricity is made - those are your emissions. Simply look up the same info as in the video and calculate CO2/Watt.
@@drivingpsyche Well, the grid changes over time. But I'd argue the real boost for the environment when buying an EV is supporting the transition by paying money for such a car. In other words, even if the electricity is not fully green right now, you have contributed towards green mobility in the future.
@@drivingpsyche watch the video. It is explained that overall your emissions are almost always lower.
dreamintv don’t forget to include the carbon dioxide emitted in refining oil into gasoline.
No whiteboard? Dislike
(I kid I kid. Just joking, I'd never dislike EE).
Jonathan Matthews there is a white wall
Interesting factors to consider. Informative.
Very informative.
Don't buy electric vehicle because it's not a Toyota Celica.
Tell that guy to clean up his garage
🤣🤣🤣
Sweet, 3 on the tree? 😂
@@humphrey212 LOL
The reason the guy doesn't like electric is because he doesn't want to change his intro... "rrrev up your engine!"
I really like the idea of a plug in, so I can charge it at night and drive short distances on ev mode and go ice for the longer distances, also better for the engine since using it for short distances is not what they really like
You just described a plug-in hybrid. And I agree with you, they are great interim/transition vehicle to get people used to driving electric without the range anxiety worries.
Luv it! Good way to sum it all up about electric cars... and this is exactly why I luv my Internal Combustion Engine car. Still the best... for my specific needs.
This is a great channel I'm subscribed to, but you know what this channel needs? MOTORCYCLES!
Great video, as always. One small request: Can you include Canada as much as possible when giving information about the USA so as to cover all of North America? That also means adding metric units, but that's a good thing anyway. Thanks!
Considering Metric is superior in every possible way, and the fact that the rest of the world (roughly 7 Billion people) uses metric, it surprises me that anyone (let alone our awesome EE host here) would use US Customary Units as their sole measurement system for CZcams videos like these.
For charging, it is also worth considering charging stations at places like grocery stores. For the stores with fast chargers, you can do pretty well while you're doing something you might do anyway. Sometimes with a better parking spot than you would otherwise have.
Some stores have free level 2 charging as well. Which lessens the pain of not having charging in an apartment.
no oil + no food no cloths no nothing to buy at the store yep sounds good lets make the switch
This is the best HONEST EV/ICE video. It is 100% true you don’t understand how awesome it is to have a full battery every morning until you get a plug in. Charging at home is MORE convenient than buying gas!
I just like the sound, look, feel and smell of combustion engines as well as the ability to modify them to your hearts content.
Enjoy the stink, noise and inefficiency of your internal combustion engine as long as you can. Remember, people who owned horses and buggies probably said the same things as you... at one time. Best wishes holding on to the past. Cheers.
@@gwarlow Well they aren't inefficient nowadays, probably one of the most developed and refined forms of power generation. Currently they are faster than electric. They will still be developed far into the future, like the steam engine is with the extreme amounts of torque it can push. Power stations use steam to generate electricity.
Great discussion. Would love to hear your thoughts on the cost & environmental comparison IC vs electric if u include the petroleum and battery (rare earth metals) procurement and battery disposal or recycling. Not an easy task but important as well. Keep up the interesting videos!
Yeah, never hear anything about that. Just what we want, all kinds of dead electric cars / battery's laying around in a salvage yards, or Pay for a new battery? Total the car? GOTCHA! $$$
And EVs also need oil changed. It's in the regenerating brakes - Tesla for instance - and is done when tires are rotated with cost of about $240.
Rare metals in catalytic converter in exhaust systems in ICE cars
@@graemeglass7566 I don't get your point. Are you saying that's bad?
Not included is the carbon footprint for manufacturing all the solar equipment and wind generators as well as the installation impact. And the footprint of manufacturing and installation of transmission lines to carry the additional power to urban areas as well as the mfg. and installation of charging stations. Plus in major cities with existing apartments/condos and high rises, power needs to be delivered to residents with EVs. More impact.
Plus, as you mentioned in some of your other videos, EVs are much more responsive to the accelerator pedal than guzzle-line cars. When my Prius Prime switches over to gas, I have to consciously remember that stepping on the gas pedal will be laggy, whereas, in EV mode, it feels like the entire drive train is sliding on teflon (well, other than the tires on the road!).
Maby your clutch is dragging.
@@hubertwalters4300, no clutches here, haha.
@@mr88cet Sounds like something is dragging, check and see if your anchor is secured.
@@hubertwalters4300, haha! Nah, ICEs just don’t spin up as quickly as electric motors.
Very thorough comparison. Greatly appreciate the review!
Something else worth noting is that in Europe the scene is very different to the US in terms of vehicle emissions. Our vehicles can fail their emissions tests very easily, meaning you could buy a brand new car, but it's no longer road-worthy in 3 years due to stricter emissions regulations coming into place.
This happened recently with any black smoke at any RPM/load on diesels being a fail condition for the annual inspection in the UK. (Known as the 'MOT')
On top of this... Pre-COVID, the price of petrol and diesel in the UK was around $6.40~ per US gallon. (£1.30~ per litre)
Though electricity is more expensive here too, it's still only £0.24 per KW at a Supercharger ($0.33, though US Superchargers are pay per minute not per KW), and at home around £0.14 per KW ($0.19) depending on your area.
Give or take, a decently efficient modern petrol/diesel car (40 to 50 mpg) will get around 100 miles for £10 ($13.81), whereas a Model 3 will get around 200 miles for the same price at a Supercharger and closer to 400 miles from charging at home. :)
For me the test drive was decisive. Loved how electric vehicle drive, so got one. A "cheap" one, of course, but one nonetheless.
Good points in the video though.
I had a fully electric then had to go back to gas for a while, it's hard to describe the frustration because technically they had basically the same power specs but gas is just... laggy? It's that minor delay between your foot hitting the pedal and the gas hitting the engine that just kinda wears on you after you've had electric power, ya know?
You take it for granted. I did a lot of "perilous maneuvers" at the beginning because I thought that every car was as responsive as mine at the lights, during a start and stop, in roundabouts.. Now I know that only actual "fast cars" can keep up with the responsiveness.
@@riccardopiccinini666 lol yes! It took me a LONG time to remember to leave extra room for gas cars to shift gears
@Yar Nunya Not following your claim here. Most Turbo gasoline cars are 4 cylinder and the peak torque happens high in the RPM range. Diesel cars have some lower end torque but none have peak torque available at 0 RPM like electric cars.
I am personally excited about extended range plug in hybrids. This seems smart for people who enjoy traveling off the beaten paths, but who also want to lower emissions. The Jeep Wrangler 4xe, the F150 hybrid, and other vehicles like these make a lot of sense. I love the idea of being able to commute on electric, but have the engine ready to kick in when I want to explore or for long trips. One day I'm sure electric technology will advance to the point where range won't be much of an issue, but that day is not today. ICEs still have a place until then.
hmm yes
Got myself an Ioniq Electric and still got my Jetta TDI for long trips (very rare) and towing my trailer. Ioniq is our work horse now, costs SO little to drive daily especially compared to the Corolla I swapped it with (still great little cars those Corollas are). Won't go back, will probably end up getting a CT one day when it comes out and keep those cars for as long as we possibly can.
love my m3, used to charge it twice a week from my home from just a normal 110v outlet. Since covid, I just charge it once a week. Haven't been to a gas station in almost two years...
Same here! I'm going to install 220 50A in my garage for my woodworking tools, but I'll probably plug my car into that when I get home after road trips, though.
Here in norway there is no doubt that electric is the way to go. They are cheaper, electricity is way cheaper then fuel with an avarge price of 1,5$ pr liter and they can drive in bus lanes. There are more benefits other then that aswell.
sweden has crazy fuel prizes aswell, AND high taxes, because we have so many laze people that wont work...
Those high fuel prices are intentionally made insanely expensive to make people not want to pay for it.
@@nealp885 yeah thats what they make you think. the prizes are high because the government wants to get money, first, they take some of your salary, then you have to pay to own a house, then u have to pay five different costs to own a car, then they tax the electricity, then they take some more of ur money when u buy something. they just spread it out so it doesnt look so bad. in reality its around 80% of our money that goes to the government. but why? so they can play with thier rockets and nuclear weapons and of course pretend to be good for the enviroment and build a bunch of wind farms when nuclear is better in all ways.
@@lucasvanhamburg4937 What a bunch of crazy drivel. The government of Norway is taxing you to build rockets and nuclear weapons...???
You need to get your head examined.
@@redbaron6805 I was not talking specifically about norway, but they do build rockets. And they are member of NATO.
Great vid. My only gripe is you glossed over the "do you have a place to charge at home". If you have electricity in your home, you can charge your car. I've been using a standard 110 outlet in my garage for almost a year and I love not having to go to a gas station... ever.
If you take infrequent road trips through remote areas, you can always rent an internal combustion vehicle.
I currently have two old-but-reliable ICE vehicles. My short-term plan is to drive them until they are ready for the scrapyard. After that, who knows.
Always informative! Are you accounting for emissions from power plants?
Depends on the the type of power plant. EV recharged by a coal plant puts out half the CO2 as a gasoline car the same size doing the same trip and even much better in stop and go commuter congestion.
In regards to resistance heating reducing range in electric cars, it's worth pointing out that the Model Y uses a much more efficient heat pump system (which I know you know, as you did a video on it), and thus doesn't suffer much of a penalty from operating in cold weather, especially if you have it plugged in and set a departure time, which allows it to prep the battery for maximum efficiency, if I'm not mistaken.
I'm gonna just steal Jason's thumbnails for my tinder account
Lmfao
Your phone is going to burst into flames once the ladies start swiping right on your profile.
@@2aminitials 😂😂
Jason, what car lift/jack do you use? Looking for something for a small 2 car garage for usual oil change, tire rotation maintenance. Thanks!
I know this may seem a bit random, but the results could optimise high-performance naturally-asperated engines: what do you think the optimal bore/stroke ratio for redline is? As in; regarding said ratio, what's the widest the cylinder bore could be for any given piston stroke length without reducing redline from the increased reciprocating mass of the piston heads? It's fine if you don't think that it's something you could figure out. It's just being in my mind for a why. And regardless, take care...
I love my BoltEV. Charge for free off my excess solar power. Blows by all the cars and pickups driving around slow trying to get better milage....
Can confirm. Just bought a 2017 Bolt Premium on Wednesday and haven't stopped smiling :D
I don't have solar, but I can charge at work for free at least.
Often people make an arguement concerning the environment effects of manufacturing batteries. You didn't mention that aspect.
He touched on it, towards the end. No real details, but it was mentioned.
He did mention it a bit quickly, but the entire footprint of electric cars, including manufacturing the car and the battery is still cleaner than a gas car in most states. Also keep in mind that the chart he is using is from 2015, and the chart has moved even more in favor of EV's in 2020 due to massive phase out of coal power in the USA..
@@redbaron6805 what about the cost from mining rare earth element? The environment impact is even worse
ramadhanisme,
No it’s not.
@@ramadhanisme7 EV's don't really have much rare earths if any. Even the batteries are mostly Nickel, along with Aluminum, Copper and Graphite. Lithium and Cobalt make up a small fraction of the total.
5 reasons?
I only needed 1, you're soo generous!
Yes you give a good insight into electric cars.
Wait, there's an electric Golf? That's news to me.
Lol where the fart have you been?
Do you live under a rock or a cave?!?!
never heard of an eGolf either, maybe non are in Canada
Same lol
He didn’t say Golf, he said golf CART ...
No one ever seems to mention how much gas people use up letting their ICE car warm up long enough to defrost or defog the windshield in winter. Nowhere near the range loss on an EV but it is still there, especially in very cold climates in winter.
There is no range loss on EVs or plug-in hybrids if you heat them before unplugging
Another thing to consider is if your work location provides charging. Mine does and it's free, so I save around $200/month on fuel alone. My general recommendation is to only get an EV if you have access to charging on a daily basis, either at home or work.
Home or office charging makes owning an EV far easier for sure. People have done it using public chargers, but it takes a bit more planning and having one relatively near by or close to places you frequent makes it a lot easier.
I get 45 miles per hour charge on a 75 amp breaker 220 Level 2 using the Tesla Wall connector
Side note about the eGolf and the Fiat 500e: They are fun, and relatively cheap; but even as an avid electric fan that sub 100 mile range was worrying. Logically I knew they had far more range than I would need 90% of the time, but when you get on the highway with the AC on and see that range meter dropping almost 3 miles for every mile you're going it's unsettling.
I think the newer eGolf's have more range, but don't quote me on that. The one I test drove was just over 100 miles.
The eGolf is just like the gas version 4 door Golf. The 500e is just like the gas Fiat. That's the problem though, neither was designed to be an EV. They're basically conversions. Well done ones, but it's still better to design a vehicle from the ground up to be an EV.
Buying a car that you can use only for driving around corners is useless. Imagine petrol car with 10l tank. Even if you´d have a petrol station in your courtyard, id would become annoying.
Even if you don´t need it, it´s better to have it and not use it, than need it and don´t have it.
@@Morpheus-pt3wq All depends on your setup. If you only drive 20 to 30 miles a day and charge it every night. A short range EV could work fine for your needs. Some people have been perfectly happy with a 500e or a Spark, or even the iMiev.
Glad to see that EVs are improving. However, there is one quibble I have in comparing an EV to ICE: the overall life of the vehicle. A well-engineered and properly maintained ICE vehicle can remain functional for multiple decades. Many EVs I'm seeing need total battery replacement around the 10 or 15 year mark. Given the bulk of the EV's emissions cost overall stems from the resources and energy required to build those battery packs, this means the lower emissions in the back end is canceled out as you need to make more batteries (or entirely new vehicles) to replace those that are ending their service lives. Obviously, this will improve with better engineering, technology, and developing methods to recycle the various components, but for now I'm sticking to ICE.
One of the biggest advantages I see in EV is that you are moving the combustion away from people. Vehicles are a huge source of pollution in cities so by reducing combustion (and brake wear) in cities that will improve health.
gas is $3.70 right now in LA area. We also had episodes of electricity outage...
Is it possible to do a series on recycling of electric car batteries? I'm not sure how much info is out there, but it would be nice to know what happens at the end of the lifecycle of them and what kind of impact that might have as well! Hopefully battery technology improves to the point where recycling is possible/much easier where we don't have to manufacture new batteries, but refurbish old ones.