WHO IS ALBERTO'S FATHER?? || LUCA THEORY

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 07. 2021
  • The Pixar movie Luca holds many secrets to which we need answers. Perhaps in not JUST this sweet story about two best friends. We know Alberto’s father abandoned him but we also know who Alberto’s father is! Stay tuned…
    Check out my last two videos!
    The Conjuring: • The Warren’s LIED?? ||...
    CRUELLA: • Let’s fix CRUELLA
    EQUIPMENT I USE
    iPad Air amzn.to/3wggMhs
    BOSE Headphones amzn.to/3qHbuKJ
    Stylus Pen amzn.to/3qEyHgJ
    Recording Mic amzn.to/3hql1BR
    360° Keyboard / Case amzn.to/3dZq3Eg
    Start using ShareASale for your website: shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=44&u=2...
    MUSIC:
    🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶
    Dramatic Orchestral by JP Bianchini jpbianchini.com
    Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC By 3.0
    Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/-dramatic-orchestral
    Music promoted by Audio Library • Dramatic Orchestral - ...
    🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶
    Terminus by Scott Buckley / scottbuckley
    Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC By 3.0
    Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/3w2Y90h
    Music promoted by Audio Library • Terminus - Scott Buckl...
    🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶
    DISCLAIMER: Some links above may be affiliate links. If you decide to make a purchase using the links in this description, I may receive a small commission. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for supporting this channel. I am grateful for each and every one of you.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 11K

  • @RandomCritique
    @RandomCritique  Před 2 lety +6192

    BY THE WAY, did you get LGBTQ+ vibes from this movie?? I mean... I believe the director when he said it's a friendship story butttt we can also interpret art differently and I choose to interpret it as an LGBTQ+ story ☺️ 🌈 🏳️‍🌈

  • @elvicr7410
    @elvicr7410 Před 2 lety +914

    I feel like Alberto's dad is called Bruno or a relative of his

    • @cherrypie3422
      @cherrypie3422 Před 2 lety +22

      That’s what I thought when I watched this!

    • @thejadekatana8891
      @thejadekatana8891 Před 2 lety +18

      I'm not an Italian speaker so I thought Bruno meant brain

    • @jgplayz4225
      @jgplayz4225 Před 2 lety +5

      Yeah! And maybe his dad also had a friend named Giorno

    • @gracekennedy2281
      @gracekennedy2281 Před 2 lety +16

      YES BC SILENCIO BRUNO

    • @cow1844
      @cow1844 Před 2 lety +2

      I thought so too!

  • @goldenreward3797
    @goldenreward3797 Před 2 lety +2893

    I watched this theory where Alberto's father's name is "Bruno" which is the reason why he says " silenzio bruno " , because his father would always tell him and discipline him. "Don't put that in ur mouth, don't do that... etc". "Masimo" isn't "Bruno" so... ??

    • @monalisa2331
      @monalisa2331 Před 2 lety +124

      Omg yeah! I had that theory too, and I've been commenting it on so many things lol
      It's my favorite one!

    • @avibreak2701
      @avibreak2701 Před 2 lety +70

      Maybe he changed his name to start over

    • @goldenreward3797
      @goldenreward3797 Před 2 lety +21

      @@avibreak2701 perhaps!! just a theory tho :)

    • @morganagensini1216
      @morganagensini1216 Před 2 lety +35

      uhm, there in Italy we actually say silenzio bruno, thats a common thing that we say

    • @goldenreward3797
      @goldenreward3797 Před 2 lety +15

      @@morganagensini1216 you say the exact 2 words "silenzio bruno?" i thought Bruno is a name? :D

  • @mrfantastic8451
    @mrfantastic8451 Před 2 lety +31

    I think that Massimo may have a twin brother who is actually Alberto's father. Because Massimo's behavior is too good to be the one who abandoned Alberto.

  • @Aaron_Smith_OM
    @Aaron_Smith_OM Před 2 lety +21

    I think Pixar is leaning more into personal stories versus just old stories with general morals. Luca, Turning Red, Onward; these are very personal stories with a more relatable, human, and massive impacts. I'm excited for Pixar.

  • @kobyaguilera5585
    @kobyaguilera5585 Před 2 lety +4364

    Plot twist: Alberto’s Dad just went to go milk

    • @Sonicthehedgehog-qm9kh
      @Sonicthehedgehog-qm9kh Před 2 lety +115

      Oh wow you gotta do him like that

    • @tragicreeze
      @tragicreeze Před 2 lety +62

      i believe this as lore

    • @Basil.123
      @Basil.123 Před 2 lety +34

      Stop-

    • @Selener404
      @Selener404 Před 2 lety +33

      No because Albertos dad doesn’t show up in the whole movie and if he did they would show Albertos dad

    • @Basil.123
      @Basil.123 Před 2 lety +44

      @@Selener404 Learn to take a joke

  • @firepower7654
    @firepower7654 Před 2 lety +744

    I think it’s far more touching to think of Massimo adopting Alberto as his son when he had no obligation or family ties to do so. Especially when Alberto represents something that he not only at one time hated but actively hunted to hurt. Massimo got to know and love Alberto as a person and when it was revealed to him that Alberto was a sea monster, Massimo realized he had been wrong in his beliefs about sea monsters all along. A much more beautiful perspective than it was his dad that he had to go out and find after being ditched by him.

    • @chrissyclark37
      @chrissyclark37 Před 2 lety

      Sooooooo,
      TELL. ME THE REASON YOU WORKED SO HARD MAKING THIS AND THERES NO REPLYS so umm hi there :D

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety

      But in this theory, Massimo "ditched" him in order to protect him from other humans finding out his location. Isnt that touching enough?

    • @firepower7654
      @firepower7654 Před 2 lety +10

      @@fizzy69o.0 Silenzio, Bruno!! (Sorry....I couldn't help it). I don't agree. Abandoning a child is never, ever the right thing to do. If Massimo had to protect him from other humans and he was his biological father, his duty would have been to his son first and he should have taken him away somewhere safe and stayed with him so that he would always be 100% sure he was safe. It would be his job to protect him. Ditching him on an island within a couple of miles of a human village isn't safe and would cause mental anguish for the rest of the boys life. Real father's never ditch their children.

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety

      @@firepower7654 sorry my first reply was removed cuz i said i'd f**k Alberto with a harpoon cuz of "silenzio Bruno" shit. Anyway i think Massimo considered it the best option cuz he probably thought that keeping humans away from Alberto is the best way to protect him. Yeah maybe it wasnt the best idea to leave him all by himself and he probably figured it out at the end of the movie

    • @gregorymetellus2681
      @gregorymetellus2681 Před 2 lety

      im sry im not gonna read that

  • @margheritacamerana467
    @margheritacamerana467 Před 2 lety +9

    wow, I can’t believe you thought about it that much! It was such a good theory and I loved it 😍

  • @lanabeele201
    @lanabeele201 Před 2 lety +6

    In the short movie ciao Alberto you can see Alberto calling Massimo "dad". That could mean that he recognized him after a while?

  • @macaroni5703
    @macaroni5703 Před 2 lety +640

    I personally think that his dads name is Bruno because of the way he described it.
    *”Alburto don’t put that in your mouth”* is a very parent thing to say.

  • @MsOmbre
    @MsOmbre Před 2 lety +137

    Giulia and Alberto are Siblings...
    The whole TIME.
    😳it's a big shock!
    He was jealous of his sister🤣

    • @breezy_gafa1128
      @breezy_gafa1128 Před 2 lety +4

      There not in the movie her dad says he came into the world with one arm

    • @sasquatch6772
      @sasquatch6772 Před 2 lety +2

      @@breezy_gafa1128 could be lieing and that hat is weird

    • @anyazane9886
      @anyazane9886 Před 2 lety +1

      @Headless_Alien u meant Lying

    • @kalicakes-6966
      @kalicakes-6966 Před 2 lety +2

      They both like there bff 😂

    • @breezy_gafa1128
      @breezy_gafa1128 Před 2 lety +1

      @@sasquatch6772 yea cause he’s gonna lie of how he lost his arm

  • @kirbierae25
    @kirbierae25 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Oh my gosh, your theories make so much sense! Thank you for using your time on 4th of July to make this video for us. You're so sweet. Have a good night

  • @destineedavis7353
    @destineedavis7353 Před 2 lety +1

    you unlocked it. IM SO PROUND I WAS TRYING TO FIND OUT - THANK YOU

  • @ok-xv6sd
    @ok-xv6sd Před 2 lety +371

    Here me out, what if the man is looking for the sea monster that killed his wife but was also looking for his son?

    • @RandomCritique
      @RandomCritique  Před 2 lety +53

      Yes!

    • @bloop_gkb_blep5710
      @bloop_gkb_blep5710 Před 2 lety +9

      But his father abandoned him so why would he look for him....

    • @ok-xv6sd
      @ok-xv6sd Před 2 lety +27

      @@bloop_gkb_blep5710 idk maybe he regretted getting milk?

    • @sexy0rthrus
      @sexy0rthrus Před 2 lety +7

      I feel like how sneaky and nosey Giulia is she would've found out about a little brother in her past for sure. Massimo is too soft to keep secrets from her imo.

    • @eyefamily1424
      @eyefamily1424 Před 2 lety +2

      @@ok-xv6sd lmao

  • @mychannel9111
    @mychannel9111 Před 2 lety +609

    when I watched the part where luca's mom and dad came looking for him I wondered "hmm... how do they already know how to walk?"

    • @kalphia9183
      @kalphia9183 Před 2 lety +85

      Because in like the beginning of the movie they said they’ve been to human land before

    • @jacelynnwolfe8965
      @jacelynnwolfe8965 Před 2 lety +2

      Sane

    • @cat6024
      @cat6024 Před 2 lety +19

      I’m starting to wonder if alberto actually invented walking if “sea monsters” older than them went to the human land and walked 🤔

    • @elexiamay9926
      @elexiamay9926 Před 2 lety +4

      Well they probably went to the surface bc they don’t want Luca to they obviously know how to walk

    • @obseed3041
      @obseed3041 Před 2 lety +4

      @@cat6024 I'm starting to doubt that the lights are fish too.

  • @abdullahayube6138
    @abdullahayube6138 Před 2 lety

    AHHHHHH girl i love u and ur theory's! im a fan of ur coraline theory's aswell :D

  • @MiguelFlores-fk8un
    @MiguelFlores-fk8un Před 2 lety

    You are an absolute legend

  • @2C0D3PUNK2
    @2C0D3PUNK2 Před 2 lety +273

    The reason julia isnt there, is because that she wasnt born yet. And "Bruno" is "Masimo" in another language, that means julia is younger then alberto, they can possibly be brother and sister?? idk!!

  • @addisonzuk8823
    @addisonzuk8823 Před 2 lety +130

    Lmao when she said, this is just a theory, I continued with: “a FILM theory!”

  • @theTR3ND3R
    @theTR3ND3R Před 9 měsíci +1

    as someone who had a younger sibling who watched this every day for a few months this was very entertaining

  • @vinayvadnere5900
    @vinayvadnere5900 Před 2 lety

    I love your videos they are very helpful with the doubts I had !

  • @liadoll
    @liadoll Před 2 lety +383

    when you said that la luna and luca was made by the same person i was like "thats it, you win." 😂

  • @Lu-ki3vg
    @Lu-ki3vg Před 2 lety +190

    They should make like a short film of Albertos past or his life

    • @kbivolcic
      @kbivolcic Před 2 lety +4

      agreed

    • @thianne6525
      @thianne6525 Před 2 lety +1

      Yes

    • @Ironmittens
      @Ironmittens Před 2 lety +3

      I can definitely see Disney+ making a series about Luca and Giulia at school and within that giving Alberto a story in the village with Giulias father.

    • @antonellaroca5722
      @antonellaroca5722 Před 2 lety +2

      They did. The short film la luna

    • @Lu-ki3vg
      @Lu-ki3vg Před 2 lety

      @@antonellaroca5722 righttt

  • @shwethasriram2674
    @shwethasriram2674 Před 4 dny +1

    i feel like he is probably more of a relative than his actual father, also its more nice to think that he adopted alberto even though they weren't related at all

  • @prettydisguised5487
    @prettydisguised5487 Před 2 lety

    Love your channel and done i’ve been subscribed for five years that’s how muchnI love this channel!!👍🏾😍😇😌😊

  • @sadblob4577
    @sadblob4577 Před 2 lety +251

    from an artist’s pov, they could just be reusing character models for convenience. I know i’ve done that multiple times with my own OCs. However I do really like this theory though and it provides a nice backstory

    • @LeviTheFrog
      @LeviTheFrog Před 2 lety +4

      Thanks for ruining the fun 🙄

    • @sadblob4577
      @sadblob4577 Před 2 lety +5

      @@LeviTheFrog XD my bad lol, i like looking at things from different perspectives /lh /nm

    • @Breezy_TM
      @Breezy_TM Před 2 lety +14

      @@LeviTheFrog hater

    • @Loverobloxhehe
      @Loverobloxhehe Před 2 lety +8

      @@LeviTheFrog bruh he is just saying what other people’s POVs see

    • @dantejredwards1701
      @dantejredwards1701 Před 2 lety

      But what about the other clues

  • @camtheman9380
    @camtheman9380 Před 2 lety +449

    But Julia’s father said “ that’s how I came into this world “ about the arm so its obviously a deep fake

    • @gianlucaroccisano2027
      @gianlucaroccisano2027 Před 2 lety +27

      he prolly lying bc i swear luca's grandma said something coming to the surface like killied someone of sum lol

    • @natalie-xl1cm
      @natalie-xl1cm Před 2 lety +5

      @@Venus-uq8wj it’s not a big deal 💀

    • @watermelonme7153
      @watermelonme7153 Před 2 lety +6

      Exactly that was What I was going to say Julia‘s dad says that’s how I came into the world

    • @Sleepy_Slytherin
      @Sleepy_Slytherin Před 2 lety +5

      10:56 in the video backs up her theory. 😊

    • @fortnitepoop2876
      @fortnitepoop2876 Před 2 lety +1

      czcams.com/video/qc6CdcLJHb8/video.html

  • @artandthings1408
    @artandthings1408 Před 9 měsíci +1

    This theory fits perfectly! I totally agree

  • @erickchall1423
    @erickchall1423 Před 2 lety

    OH MY GOODNESS that was SO SMART of you!

  • @rachelxqyz
    @rachelxqyz Před 2 lety +144

    I also found another clue proving her theory is true: The opening song to Luca is an Italian song, and in the song, I heard the words “La Luna.” Don’t believe me? Rewatch the beginning of the movie.

  • @spaceshipx1408
    @spaceshipx1408 Před 2 lety +428

    I’m all for your theory, but there are some more thing that I just thought of, Alberto isn’t 13, Luca is 13, and alberto is 14 while gulia is 12, and why would massimo be worried that alberto is gone, when he wanted him gone in the first place? This is just randomly put together BUT in the end credits of Luca, everyone in Lucas school knows that he’s a sea monster, does gulias mom not know that massimo’s OTHER child was a sea monster? I know for a fact that Luca talks about alberto, sends letters and calls him on the phone, as the credits show. Does gulias mom not recognize anything? Enrico I know is trying to connect something, I think enrico is coming up with another film or animation that COULD give some more clues to your theory. And possibly massimo knows that Alberto is definitely his son seeing that albertos a see monster and wants him to stay with him, and I’m not sure if I got the details correctly from this, but in the end credits alberto gets a birthday present which is is knife, but how would massimo know albertos birthday? Alberto could’ve told him, but massimo probably didn’t tell him when it was, sorry for bad English, I suck at spelling and grammar😅 but that’s all I have to say

    • @RandomCritique
      @RandomCritique  Před 2 lety +45

      Hmm you're right! What if the mother has no idea

    • @zulfahdollie5565
      @zulfahdollie5565 Před 2 lety +7

      This is way too long-

    • @spaceshipx1408
      @spaceshipx1408 Před 2 lety +7

      @@zulfahdollie5565 and why is that

    • @spaceshipx1408
      @spaceshipx1408 Před 2 lety +7

      @@zulfahdollie5565 wait I just realized that you commented on one of my videos that'd why your name seems familiar!

    • @zulfahdollie5565
      @zulfahdollie5565 Před 2 lety +2

      @@spaceshipx1408 lol

  • @sahiba1792
    @sahiba1792 Před 10 měsíci

    I never knew that thank you for this wonderful video

  • @thelatest88
    @thelatest88 Před 2 lety

    O.M.G I never would have thought that in a million years. You are probably so right

  • @acoloci4941
    @acoloci4941 Před 2 lety +321

    They should make a movie called alberto showing his side of the story

    • @Alex-cc1ms
      @Alex-cc1ms Před 2 lety +8

      this is actually a good idea ngl

    • @izzytheslayy
      @izzytheslayy Před 2 lety +1

      @@Alex-cc1ms mhm

    • @nxquix
      @nxquix Před 2 lety +1

      Great idea 📝

    • @Wad1s
      @Wad1s Před 2 lety

      You mean Alberto

    • @mrstorys4432
      @mrstorys4432 Před 2 lety +7

      I know the idea but I don’t think they make a whole movie about it I feel like they’d probably go on the Disney+ shorts

  • @esthrexlla972
    @esthrexlla972 Před 2 lety +320

    Fun fact: One of the producers is a producer who produced “La Luna” which is the film you doubted was alike, but is it just a coincidence? Also Theory: what if Albertos father was named Bruno because when Luca asked “why is his name Bruno?” Alberto acted very strange about it giving a nervous laugh replying with “it doesn’t matter” THIS IS ONLY A THEORY

    • @Cold_Sapphire
      @Cold_Sapphire Před 2 lety +12

      THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING

    • @gigikju9934
      @gigikju9934 Před 2 lety +16

      hmmm I've heard the "Bruno theory" many times before, and I think he probably just heard a random sailor say it (he learned "What's wrong with you, stupido" the same way) But it's still a great theory!

    • @janemilton6858
      @janemilton6858 Před 2 lety +10

      A FILM THEORY

    • @dracomalfoy4267
      @dracomalfoy4267 Před 2 lety +4

      I don't think so apparently they say silenzio Bruno in Italy

    • @cringeygreenapple12
      @cringeygreenapple12 Před 2 lety +2

      A FLIM THEORY

  • @kevinharrell8509
    @kevinharrell8509 Před 2 lety

    girl you did a great job.

  • @davidmallette5615
    @davidmallette5615 Před 2 lety

    O.M.G thank you for posting this video i was think "who is Alberto's father is" like thank you good work :D

  • @CombatTheorists
    @CombatTheorists Před 2 lety +78

    "He still has not come back with the milk yet..."

  • @XxXK1770rD13XxX
    @XxXK1770rD13XxX Před 2 lety +263

    "Don't take it too seriously. It's just for fun."
    Gets 4 million views from everyone totally on board with this theory.

    • @petersaysthings
      @petersaysthings Před 2 lety +4

      I noticed almost all the Luca edits, theories, and reviews on CZcams tend to get millions of views in general lol this fandom makes me happy.

    • @amazingavery5785
      @amazingavery5785 Před 2 lety +3

      i agree

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +3

      @@petersaysthings Luca is a super underrated movie. It easily makes it into the top 10 Pixar movies and it was made in a pandemic.

    • @Splashifed
      @Splashifed Před 2 lety

      when theres not 4 million subs

    • @nanosec611
      @nanosec611 Před 2 lety

      Same I agree

  • @Moonfxirylunar
    @Moonfxirylunar Před 2 lety +1

    My eyes were glued and I was like I got to Watch this video

  • @jayshields9
    @jayshields9 Před 2 lety

    Sooooooo love ❤️ your videos!!!

  • @tsoncorneliast
    @tsoncorneliast Před 2 lety +70

    “Yes, I counted” 😂😂

  • @xJenniii
    @xJenniii Před 2 lety +97

    I NEED A PART 2 OF LUCA THEY CAN'T LEAVE ME HANGING WITH QUESTIONS

  • @carlytomasso3744
    @carlytomasso3744 Před rokem

    i loved this!!!

  • @ajjtstudios9867
    @ajjtstudios9867 Před 2 lety

    Thank you for working so hard😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

  • @ClaartjeY
    @ClaartjeY Před 2 lety +185

    I mean, I like this theory better than the one where his father is a car 🤣🤣

  • @alialtersaccounts1816
    @alialtersaccounts1816 Před 2 lety +461

    I feel like Bruno would be Alberto’s dad.
    Why? I’ll explain.
    Since Alberto’s father left, he has been calling his doubts “Bruno” and I think the reason is because Albertos dad would tell Alberto that he can’t do this, and that, etc etc etc.
    This could explain why he named his self-doubt Bruno, because that was the name of his father.
    Though he still misses him no matter what.

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety +8

      It still could be Massimo if he changed his identity so his real name was Bruno

    • @cherrycherrylady1700
      @cherrycherrylady1700 Před 2 lety +3

      Hahaha really ? Why don't you go and give credits to the Supercarlibrothers youtube ? Cause that's were u got the info and now your trying to claim as yours... so unoriginal. 🙄

    • @franciscawutozum4299
      @franciscawutozum4299 Před 2 lety

      I DON'T THINK SO, BEACUSE WHERE IS SOMEONE NAMED BRUNO IN THE CARTOON??!??!!!?

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety +3

      @@franciscawutozum4299 chill and, like i said before, Massimo could've easily changed his identity after his affair with.... well, a fish. So his real name was actually Bruno

    • @franciscawutozum4299
      @franciscawutozum4299 Před 2 lety

      @Karter Sheppard That's also what I thought... Good thinking!

  • @natashaemerick4548
    @natashaemerick4548 Před 2 lety

    Omg you’re actually so right

  • @hollygregan
    @hollygregan Před 2 lety

    Love your vids

  • @seraphina453
    @seraphina453 Před 2 lety +315

    Alberto is 14, so I think the tally marks represent days, and his dad left him when he was 13, because 13 is they year you become a teenager, and the movie says he left because he thought alberto was old enough to take care of himself. i hope this makes sense lol

    • @salome7311
      @salome7311 Před 2 lety +10

      But if he was 13 he would have old enough to recognize him, since he would've only been gone for a year.

    • @seraphina453
      @seraphina453 Před 2 lety +4

      @@salome7311 who says Alberto doesnt recognize him?

    • @salome7311
      @salome7311 Před 2 lety +6

      @@seraphina453 It doesn't seem like he does. And I don't see why Alberto would pretend he doesn't know his father when they met.

    • @seraphina453
      @seraphina453 Před 2 lety +2

      @@salome7311 he knows enough to remember that his dad left him because of he was old enough to take care of himself. And would you really want people to know your parents abandoned you when you were their age? People can also deal with stress and trauma differently, and maybe his way of dealing with it was pretending his dad didn't exist

    • @salome7311
      @salome7311 Před 2 lety +2

      @@seraphina453 Okay, but after meeting him why would he completely ignore the fact that this man is his FATHER who left him just one year ago. You have a valid point but it just doesn't make sense in this story

  • @clayc3l487
    @clayc3l487 Před 2 lety +222

    i mean my theory is that when alberto was born his mom died- and thats how she revealed she was a sea monster.
    so when albertos dad found that out he was a lil upset. and when he washed the baby (bcs thats what you do right?)
    he found out that alberto was a sea monster. so when alberto got a little older he left him. that my theory

  • @eveofhades9260
    @eveofhades9260 Před 2 lety +3

    Having looked at this again, I think the boy in La Luna is Julia's father & the older man who looks like him is actually his father. So Julia's father, grandfather & great grandfather are on the boat in La Luna.

  • @cosmicbobayt4855
    @cosmicbobayt4855 Před 2 lety

    This is the BEST theory ever!!😨

  • @hawwa6864
    @hawwa6864 Před 2 lety +234

    my theory.
    alberto’s mum was also a sea monster. when alberto was young his mum left to sea, but never returned. his dad packed to leave in search for her. alberto wanted to come and help as he was a sea monster and his dad wasn’t. his dad refused. he left and all he said was
    “you’re old enough to take care of yourself”
    or he just didn’t love him, yk 😆👍

    • @wyattneff2682
      @wyattneff2682 Před 2 lety

      @Madeleine Robinson no not ......wow.....

    • @jalyaham9099
      @jalyaham9099 Před 2 lety +2

      heart breaking

    • @livthebest4947
      @livthebest4947 Před 2 lety

      He just went to get milk bruh

    • @Marcia-mo3gj
      @Marcia-mo3gj Před 2 lety +1

      @Madeleine Robinson fun fact the father adopted alberto lol

    • @hawwa6864
      @hawwa6864 Před 2 lety +1

      @@livthebest4947 wow so original and creative babe 🥺🥺🥺🥺😂😂😂😂💕💕💕🌈🌈🌈🌈🌈✨✨✨✨✨

  • @czhskala
    @czhskala Před 2 lety +118

    6:19 is when the theory starts

  • @TIARAADAEDITOR
    @TIARAADAEDITOR Před 3 měsíci +1

    Not me refinding this channel at 3:48 am in the morning, 2 years later.

  • @strandycraft1374
    @strandycraft1374 Před 2 lety +1

    I think you are right and this totally makes sense.

  • @codycook3190
    @codycook3190 Před 2 lety +45

    Julia's dad said he was born without his arm. He didn't lose it.

  • @brooklynvlogs9396
    @brooklynvlogs9396 Před 2 lety +263

    Isn't the best way to keep his son safe is to be the one hunting him? If he's the main hunter he can always fail to catch Alberto and thus keep his son safe from the humans. Considering the Humans had never seen a sea monster it's safe to say the dad did a good job.

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +2

      @Francesca Elin Constantino I never thought of this. I’ll use it to prove to some people that this video isn’t correct. A lot of people just believe what makes sense at first glance.

    • @ziblueberry2045
      @ziblueberry2045 Před 2 lety +1

      Did you know they're gay watch a movie again and they're gay

    • @firepower7654
      @firepower7654 Před 2 lety

      One keeps their son safe by encouraging others to hunt him down?

    • @firepower7654
      @firepower7654 Před 2 lety +2

      @@ziblueberry2045 Any movie that has the characters having a secret can be interpreted as being "gay". The same theory is around about the X-Men. They are mutants that must keep the secret or they will be rejected by society. This movie was deeper than a "gay" story. It was a story about friendship, taking chances outside of ones comfort zone and placing the needs of someone else above your own wants.

    • @brooklynvlogs9396
      @brooklynvlogs9396 Před 2 lety

      @@ziblueberry2045 I mean the guy who made it said they're not but what does he know right?!?.....right?.....

  • @luc6982
    @luc6982 Před 2 lety +2

    I just watched Luca and wondered who is Alberto's father. I'm glad I stumbled on this theory because it makes sense. From what I can make out of the movie, Alberto said something about he always do something bad and that's why his father left him. I think that at some point when Alberto was a kid he was exposed as a sea-monster. To protect Alberto his father pretended to kill him or atleast scare the sea creature away from the people. To stop (scare) the people from hunting sea monsters he sacrificed his arm to make it seem like the sea creatures are vicious. It seems pretty solid too because the townfolks relies on Massimo in terms of dealing with sea creatures because he is the only one who had "encounter" with them. Then his father met Guilia's mother (idk if they're divorced) making Guilia and Alberto half siblings (both are free spirited and strong willed AND whipped for Luca)

  • @elenasalazar8442
    @elenasalazar8442 Před rokem

    this was awsome i was so surprised

  • @Miss_Violet293
    @Miss_Violet293 Před 2 lety +46

    Can we appreciate the fact she spent lucking for clues and connections of who is Alberto's father

  • @davidcalderon4391
    @davidcalderon4391 Před 2 lety +253

    Cool theory but I’m sure in the movie Julia’s dad says his missing arm was from him “being born that way”

    • @Plantixbojina_____6_9
      @Plantixbojina_____6_9 Před 2 lety +18

      He prob lied and lost it

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +9

      @@Plantixbojina_____6_9 no he didn’t. It doesn’t add up.

    • @Plantixbojina_____6_9
      @Plantixbojina_____6_9 Před 2 lety +7

      @@minecrafter3448 A sea monster really ate it now does it add up?

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +2

      @@Plantixbojina_____6_9 no. Have you seen what sea monsters look like? Do you really think they would eat someone’s arms? I’ve watched this movie many times, and during one of the watches, I looked at all of the farmers in the background. None of them would eat an arm. That’s basically every sea monster there.

    • @KingRichardDeLeonheart
      @KingRichardDeLeonheart Před 2 lety +2

      @@Plantixbojina_____6_9 why would he lie wouldn’t it be a good story to scare and tell to children

  • @jasonedwards978
    @jasonedwards978 Před 2 lety

    I love these words that you use😀

  • @mariaterrero8593
    @mariaterrero8593 Před 2 lety

    You are a true detective!😍

  • @psoreiko1990
    @psoreiko1990 Před 2 lety +170

    are we forgetting that Alberto himself said that his dad told him he was old enough to live on his own and left him?????? ....>>

    • @ajaakakjahshdhe
      @ajaakakjahshdhe Před 2 lety +13

      I'm thinking they will make a SEQUEL and name it Alberto instead of Luca and it will be about Alberto and why his dad left him and other stuff..

    • @e1901
      @e1901 Před 2 lety +4

      @@ajaakakjahshdhe like finding Nemo and finding dory? :0

    • @miss_dj6119
      @miss_dj6119 Před 2 lety +1

      @@e1901 yes yes!!!! :0

  • @MeltedBingsu
    @MeltedBingsu Před 2 lety +118

    Her dad isn’t the same person as the dad in that short, the dad in Luca the dad had no arm and he said he came into the world that way but the guy from the short had 2 arms, the creator probably just didn’t wanna make a new character for it

    • @pandarogy2506
      @pandarogy2506 Před 2 lety +4

      Also La Luna and Alberto are different skin tones and hair types. Plus if Massimo had abandoned him then he would’ve had to of done it while Alberto was very young and incapable of surviving on his own meaning Alberto would be dead. Plus he has no features to show he could be half human. Nothing that separates him from full blood sea monsters anyway

    • @danalee5890
      @danalee5890 Před 2 lety

      @@pandarogy2506 but in la Luna what if he didn’t know he was a sea monster and Alberto seemed smart he could survive and the dad owns a fishing job so he probably got a tan and the hair he probably has his mother’s hair and probably a mix of his skin tone and her skin tone

    • @miley7535
      @miley7535 Před 2 lety

      Yeah but it still could have been cut off after 🤔🤔

    • @SamanthaStone1998Channel
      @SamanthaStone1998Channel Před 2 lety

      @@miley7535 Alberto is a sea monster because was kidnapped by a witch

    • @Ang3lwil617
      @Ang3lwil617 Před 2 lety

      exactlyy I have my own theory on that but I believe that he still is Alberto's father

  • @jalessabragg3230
    @jalessabragg3230 Před 2 lety

    Great job

  • @jaseelrinamore5272
    @jaseelrinamore5272 Před 8 měsíci

    I love ur vids soo much 😍❤️💗💓💚💖💋💕💜♥️💞💙☺️

  • @noahxavier6253
    @noahxavier6253 Před 2 lety +176

    Something that might add a little to your theory: When Massimo steps up after accepting Alberto and Luca at the end, the other sea monster hunters back away--it's clear that they won't fight with Massimo. This could be why he initially put on the obsessing with hunting sea monsters, as a means of protecting Alberto. I don't remember the exact moment, but I'm pretty sure there was a moment in the movie while they're out on the boat where someone mentions Massimo protecting the town from sea monsters. If Massimo is like...the head sea monster hunter, he's the one that hunts them for the town, this is a way he can protect his sea monster son.
    There are some holes in the theory, like you said, but at the same time the coincidences are just too much, haha. Personally, I like that he said he was born without his arm--it lends to this idea of disability as a normal part of life, rather than a trauma caused by a creature who is supposed to be symbolic for marginalized communities, however I can see why you would include it in your theory.
    This was super interesting! Thank you for posting!

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety +5

      So Massimo actually pretended to hunt sea monsters so he would prevent other people from actually hunting them? Yeah this is big brain time

    • @colinejayne
      @colinejayne Před 2 lety +1

      @@fizzy69o.0 it’s brilliant!

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety

      @@colinejayne true true

    • @roxannaluciano955
      @roxannaluciano955 Před 2 lety +2

      But when it rains he doesn’t turn to a sea monster so if anything he probably killed albertos dad

    • @fizzy69o.0
      @fizzy69o.0 Před 2 lety

      @@roxannaluciano955 bruh they never said Massimo is a sea monster, he's only the father of a sea monster

  • @MochaMachi
    @MochaMachi Před 2 lety +74

    Me: what about his arm? *skips. *sees the answer for the arm
    Me again: smart smart

  • @nathangardner-andrews4924

    That’s a really good discovery I wouldn’t ever notice that ❤️❤️😃

  • @reesaxavier790
    @reesaxavier790 Před 2 lety

    I love your vids

  • @Shoe26
    @Shoe26 Před 2 lety +239

    He’s actually 14 in the movie, and I’m guessing the tally marks are days so I’m thinking his dad left about 2 years before the movie took place… also Massimo and the dad from la Luna do look kinda different, also the dad from la Luna has a right arm and Massimo was born without one

    • @Jesoysauce
      @Jesoysauce Před 2 lety +2

      Huh

    • @eduardodudu9626
      @eduardodudu9626 Před 2 lety +1

      @@Jesoysauce he’s wrong

    • @eduardodudu9626
      @eduardodudu9626 Před 2 lety +2

      Hmm no was he wasn’t born with it he lost it on a fight which he says was from a sea creature fight but I don’t remember so u might he right

    • @larissak15
      @larissak15 Před 2 lety +10

      @@eduardodudu9626 nope Massimo was born without an arm because the movie takes place in the 50s and pixar needed a reason for him not to be able to fight in the war

    • @fishinspacey
      @fishinspacey Před 2 lety +7

      @@eduardodudu9626 no, he said that he lost it to a sea monster as a joke. i think his quote was “this is how i came into the world”

  • @morganarose3979
    @morganarose3979 Před 2 lety +58

    That would mean that Alberto and Julia are brother and sister.
    Unless if Julia’s dad has a twin brother and then his twin brother is Albertos dad.

    • @joshuatuiwainunu2017
      @joshuatuiwainunu2017 Před 2 lety +7

      Them being brother and sister would explain the sibling vibes they give off like how alberto is always pissed that luca hangs out with julia, how siblings get pissed when their friends hang out with their siblings. I love it

    • @morganarose3979
      @morganarose3979 Před 2 lety +5

      @@joshuatuiwainunu2017 true and same here

    • @jamiemac4248
      @jamiemac4248 Před 2 lety +2

      And why Alberto is mad about them hanging out

    • @fnfaesthetics929
      @fnfaesthetics929 Před 2 lety +1

      @JamieMac
      Bc he loves Luca, duh-

    • @dollsandall9926
      @dollsandall9926 Před 2 lety

      @@jamiemac4248 cuz he wants his friend Luca back. Unless he had a crush on Gulia which'd be disgusting if they ARE siblings

  • @jasefoley6594
    @jasefoley6594 Před rokem

    Keep up the good vids

  • @syrup2586
    @syrup2586 Před 2 lety

    this theory blew my mind

  • @ElijahWilson058
    @ElijahWilson058 Před 2 lety +52

    Let’s appreciate that she worked hard instead of having fun outside

  • @wisewisdomgaming8436
    @wisewisdomgaming8436 Před 2 lety +16

    This makes sense. Bc the dad was really nice to alberto in the movie. and when alberto left the dad got really sad.

  • @garygolden3070
    @garygolden3070 Před 11 měsíci

    I think u did a lot of very good work

  • @londyn132adams8
    @londyn132adams8 Před 2 lety

    Heyyyy girl I love you sooo much you are amazing

  • @julianoxford1165
    @julianoxford1165 Před 2 lety +207

    Adding to the theory, I would like to suggest that the whole "La Luna" short represents only a dream of Alberto. This would fit the surreal plot in the short with them going to the moon via a ladder. In the same way, Alberto could have dreamed of his father having both his arms, which would also explain the difference between the father in the short and Massimo in the film.

    • @salome7311
      @salome7311 Před 2 lety +15

      And maybe he had this dream after meeting Massimo, because he saw him as a father figure, he made him the dad in his dream.

    • @JustAnotherJelly
      @JustAnotherJelly Před 2 lety +1

      Wow...grate theory

  • @PurrghostGamer008
    @PurrghostGamer008 Před 2 lety +54

    in Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs, Julia's father looks like Flint's father and Flint's father also fish's and Flint's father sells the fish or eats them and Flint's father also lives near the water

  • @takjam6716
    @takjam6716 Před 2 lety

    This is a really good video

  • @trevorsamanthawalker2461
    @trevorsamanthawalker2461 Před 10 měsíci

    Love this video

  • @vdieguez
    @vdieguez Před 2 lety +57

    When Alberto says he touched the moon I think he was thinking he was touching a reflection of it in the water and when touching it he touched a finish because when I was younger I thought the same thing. 😂 is quite funny thinking ab it

  • @brooketroyer8936
    @brooketroyer8936 Před 2 lety +150

    Honestly, this is the best theory so far about who Alberto's father is. All the other ones didn't really make sense but this one does in my opinion. And I have seen a lot of other theories because I really want to know. Great job on the video!

  • @tegantiu6698
    @tegantiu6698 Před 2 lety

    i love your videos

  • @rebeccasprenkel2650
    @rebeccasprenkel2650 Před 2 lety +1

    It’s probably is his father now that it makes sense thank you for telling us💙

  • @ItsEmma.7613
    @ItsEmma.7613 Před 2 lety +132

    To be honest I think this was a really good video, and theory. But there’s one thing maybe that Little boy could’ve been Massimo. ( but this is the best theory I’ve heard!)

    • @slayislaa
      @slayislaa Před 2 lety +5

      Hey, thats a really good idea you have, in could be!

    • @diybyfaith7373
      @diybyfaith7373 Před 2 lety +4

      The one thing I don’t get is why if that’s his father why did you not turn into one when it rained

    • @SamanthaStone1998Channel
      @SamanthaStone1998Channel Před 2 lety +2

      @@diybyfaith7373 Alberto's parents are Arthur and Aurora

    • @Colix.12
      @Colix.12 Před 2 lety +1

      Name him alberto

    • @midnigvts
      @midnigvts Před 2 lety +1

      I thought that Massimo could be the father bc the way he changed his mind when he saw alberto at the end and how fast he was to take him in but that would mean that he was (or could) be a sea monster and he didnt turn into one when he got wet and if he was one Gulia would be one too or half a sea monster

  • @limie4712
    @limie4712 Před 2 lety +432

    Plot twist that kid is Alberto's dad and gave him his hat and abondon him to be with gulias Dad

  • @RevengenceRaideN
    @RevengenceRaideN Před 2 lety

    I'm literally addicted to luca...I WATCHED IT MORE THAN 5 TIMES XD

  • @bumbum27636
    @bumbum27636 Před 2 lety

    Love it 😍🥰

  • @catloverkityjoejoe
    @catloverkityjoejoe Před 2 lety +100

    This literally made so much sense.. 5:23 surprised me tho... since they both have the same director it would be a really huge coincidence if it was an accident

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +2

      It’s openly announced that the dad from la Luna was the inspiration for massimo. They aren’t the same person.

    • @catloverkityjoejoe
      @catloverkityjoejoe Před 2 lety +1

      @@minecrafter3448 Oh.. well thats... a waste of a beautiful parallel

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety +1

      @@catloverkityjoejoe they didnt really waste it, seeing as they used the character design again to save time.

    • @catloverkityjoejoe
      @catloverkityjoejoe Před 2 lety +1

      ​@@minecrafter3448 No thats not what i meant I don't think they wasted the character but I just feel it would've been a really fun parallel

    • @minecrafter3448
      @minecrafter3448 Před 2 lety

      @@catloverkityjoejoe oh ok

  • @OfficialBananaMC
    @OfficialBananaMC Před 2 lety +256

    actually, Julia's mom is seen in the movie after the movie finishes, you can see Julia's mom with Julia and Luca eating breakfast or lunch or dinner

    • @paulina_z
      @paulina_z Před 2 lety +6

      is it biological though....

    • @trisk902
      @trisk902 Před 2 lety +23

      @@paulina_z of course it is. Julia’s mom looks exactly like julia

    • @jdrailfan391
      @jdrailfan391 Před 2 lety +15

      She’s talking about Alberto’s biological mom!

    • @paulina_z
      @paulina_z Před 2 lety +4

      @@jdrailfan391 dad doesnt though..

    • @jdrailfan391
      @jdrailfan391 Před 2 lety +4

      @@paulina_z ???

  • @godzilla8878
    @godzilla8878 Před 2 lety

    Ciao Alberto makes this confusing and AMAZING

  • @leiajewelcloud5876
    @leiajewelcloud5876 Před rokem

    omg this is all so true! How did I not notice this! I've watched the movie heeps of times!

  • @londonthe_robloxian7910
    @londonthe_robloxian7910 Před 2 lety +146

    aye y’all remember when Massimo (Guilla’s dad and Alberto’s dad) said that he was born without a arm?- Maybe.. the ex-wife cut it off! (JK) (JK) 😭😂

  • @themanster6034
    @themanster6034 Před 2 lety +65

    Well Julia's father had no hand and the boat scene said " this is how I came into the world"

  • @plinesnare
    @plinesnare Před 2 lety

    This is awesome