2021 Audi Q8 vs Range Rover Velar review - which is the best luxury SUV? | What Car?
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- In this clash of German and British premium SUVs we examine all the style and all the substance that both have to offer. But which is best? Watch to find out.
Save thousands on your next new car with What Car? at www.whatcar.com/new-car-deals/
New videos are uploaded to What Car? each week. Don't miss a single one. Subscribe now: bit.ly/2Obgxjd
Visit our website at www.whatcar.com/
What Car? is the UK's biggest car-buying brand and has been helping Britain's car buyers make purchasing decisions for more than 40 years. Our tests are widely regarded as the most trusted source of new car advice.
This channel brings you trusted reviews on all the new models on the market, all the latest first drives, reader reviews, and great car-buying advice.
All reviews are available in full online at Whatcar.com - the UK's leading car-buying website, offering trusted reviews and data on every new car. The website also offers advice on car leasing, new car deals and new and used cars for sale.
Follow What Car? here:
LIKE What Car? on Facebook: goo.gl/yv5jF8
FOLLOW What Car? on Twitter: goo.gl/SJzmT8
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/2W81iu9 - Auta a dopravní prostředky
So which is the best looking luxury SUV on sale? Vote in our poll at 2:09 to vote for the Audi Q8, Range Rover Velar, Porsche Cayenne Coupe or Maserati Levante
None of the above. Try the new BMW X5, the 'gold standard.'
henlo carwow's son
@@markwilson8925 very smart buying
I don't agree.. What a foul play.. Audis flagship and range rover base variant cars... Take evoque autobiography and review
Darlings...the Q8 can be compared with the Range Sport.
I;d take the Velar any day over Bane xD
Think you should have tested the 3 ltr engine in the Velar. That would have made it much fairer test . Velar for me with the 3ltr Diesel engine
Q8's technology is beyond perfect
Or so you think
trueee. audi infotainment is like ihpone xs , and that rr is like 2009 samsung tablet laggy af! lol
@The Automotive. 80% of which you will never use during day to day driving
So how is the terrain response in the Q? :)
The best 4X4, or nice in cabin tech? Hmmm, difficult question - NOT.
I love the comparison of these two and really great when you include info like price drops over the years. Thank you for sharing
I love that there is no mention whatsoever of the off-road capabilities of the Velar. Typical of most buyers I guess.
What car do you drive, mate ?
Both of these cars are very good looking , however I would probably choose the Range Rover as i like the sharper lines of the design .
I love Range rover
Isn’t the Q8 a rival the Sport not the Velar? Also, the flush door handles aren’t Velar specific, the new Evoque has them.
How can you compare Cayenne coupe, q8 and levante against the Velar? Velar is not on their size...
A A you’re wrong, exactly their size
I think these are more comparable to Range Rover Sport
They are the same size but still....we get a lot of amateurs. Cars don`t compare only by size dear
To all those people debating if the Velar is the same size or not, it is not the same size. Furthermore, the Velar belongs to a different segment altogether. The Velar competes against the Porsche Macan, Mercedes GLC, GLC Coupe, Audi Q5 and the BMW X3 and X4 and to a very small extent the GLE Coupe and the BMW X6. In this case the Velar is right in the middle when it comes to size, with only the GLE Coupe and BMW X6 being larger. So no, they can't compare the Velar to the Q8 which is larger and also more expensive
@@sven548 late reply since I never got a notification😅 but no I'm not wrong! You can read LordTechPro's reply to my comment😁
Waiting for my Velar P380 R Dynamic S HSE in silicon silver 22 in 7 spoke gloss black plus some other goodies
The good flex, congrats😂
How have you found it ?
@@Mcfckinkladze I have really enjoyed owning and driving my Velar I have had zero issues with the vehicle plenty of power and a surprisingly smooth quiet ride the 22 in rims
@@stevelambert6489 Reassuring to hear that. My partner is picking up a 21 plate tomorrow with just under 10k on it. Some of the comments would have you believe it’ll break down on the way home 😂
Pick something of the same class SUV for comparison might be a good way to start? Thought Velar is below Q7 size?
Q8 smaller than Q7
I would say Velar is more like Q5 or future Q6
Amin Haq
Q3=evoque
Q5=velar
Q7=sport/vogue
Q8=no competitor from range rover
Evoque defeated Q5 but new Evoque is more expensive
Q3 = (Nothing that small from Land Rover)
Q5 = Evoque
Q7 = Velar or Range Rover Sport
Q8 = (Nothing that size from Land Rover)
Or
Evoque = Q5
Velar/Range Rover Sport = Q7
Range Rover = (Nothing that big from Audi)
Let’s be accurate here....
Velar any day💗
D300 Velar HSE with air suspension would be a better comparison. Fast and sporty in dynamic mode!
Velar against the Q8? Really? Not RR, Velar. Why not take Discovery sport then?
Great presentation!
Velar 😊
This 2 car is my favourite. This style is wonderful.💚💜💟👏
Q8 for me all day long....well done Germany, never fail when building some fantastic machines......
jay phil except when it comes to motorcycles😅 and even than Ferrari and lambo is still better but i get what you mean german cars are a good midrange😉
Was there any mention about which is the most reliable?
I have not travelled in either car..... I enjoyed knowing about both these cars
Range rover is good
Hhhh
May be compared to a Ford Pinto
Please improve Audio quality (using air Pod pro)
Velar is based on Jaguar’s F-Pace/XE, which competes with Audi Q5/A4.
15k difference? Extremely poor comparison....
Indeed, in reality the Velar’s direct competitor is Q5, which has similar pricing and size.
As tested, there is only a £5k difference between these two models.
Orfan Productions - true, however that’s just specification...
By that theory you could compare a low spec bmw 5 series with a top spec Kia Optima (that would be priced within £5k of each other)
would that be a good comparison?
@@benhenry1571 Of course, that would be a perfect comparison and one that is done ALL the time. Surely you've played that game yourself, where you think: 'well, for £30k, I could get a nice NEW Golf GTi, but if I went used, I could get a 2015 C63 AMG instead'? Comparing the high spec of one against the low spec of a more 'prestige' marque is more than common place. I've already seen some websites/magazines making features of the incredible low price of the upcoming Corvette C8, asking 'what else can you get for $60k?', and then throwing in options like a 6 year old 911 Turbo or a 4 year old R8. But you don't even need to compare the Optima to the 5 Series, why not just keep it in the same marque? Poverty spec 2 litre 5-Series against a well specced 3 litre 3-Series? Bargain basement E-Class against a C-Class with every box ticked? Once we know what budget we have......... we can always make completely mad and irrational comparisons on where best for us to spend it! 😉
Orfan Productions - I certainly do make those comparisons all the time, you are however introducing a third variable (new/used)
For me in a car review I want to see like for like comparisons which I don’t agree this is.
It feels like these were the two cars they could borrow so decided to do a comparison video.
The Q8 looks suburb in the flesh BTW!
It would be better to compare velar with the same engine v6 3,0d. In this case Q8 would be a little bit cheaper than Velar and it is quite explainble
Did you realize that you used the word BUT in practically every sentence!
But me no buts.
Thats a terrible spec’d Velar
Q8 several years ahead of Landrover whatever model you select
Had Velar. Now Q8...
Velar is better. Drives smoother,love air suspension. Softer seats. Long trips on Audi exhausting.. on Velar i would be driving 100mph without noticing how fast i am going. Audi two hand on steering wheel . Velar knee on the wheel you good.I feel like gas pedal is longer on audi or something. When you accelerating you hear it on Audi engine sounds nice, but its an effort. Velar drives up the slope like its not there. Audi looses speed.
Just my observation, might be in my head.
Great analysis man.. Now its time for 2020 Q7.. That's what I'm waiting for....
It should've been q8 vs range rover sport not the velar
But still velar has a better look than awful Q8 which looks like Nissan Juke in shape.
Very nice video
Agree with everything that’s been said about comparing apples and pears. You evaluate a Q8 against a 3 litre RRSport not a Velar. A year ago I changed my Sport for a Q8. The Sport looks it’s age now, still pretty but not as sharp or head-turning as the Q8. In some ways I miss my RR. It’s an SUV whereas the Q8 is a big car but this makes it more agile and fun to drive. It’s ahead with tech (although the latest RR Pivy-pro system is a lot better than on my 7 year old car) and build quality is better than the latest Sport, which I tried out before buying the Q8. Might go back to a RR one day, when they have caught up.
Next gen RRSport is out. Ops on that?
@@akj2387 The sequel to my story is that I’ve gone back to a Sport. For the 18 months I had the Q8, it spent a total of nine weeks in the shop. It turned out to be a real problem car. I picked up a very late series 2 RRS, a showroom car, a cancelled order. I’m due to look at the series 3 but might just keep the one I’ve got. It has a lot of stuff on it that is also on the new one.
I'm always curious as to why car reviews mention the feel of the material on the binnacle. "You have some scratchy plastics up there." Who touches 'up there?'
Compare things that are comparable. You should try The Velar V6, 300 HP, 700 Newton, this will Make The difference. The only thing I hate on my Velar is the sport seat, I find it very inconfortable...but I am the only one in my entourage...only for this I deeply regret my previous Range Sport😭😭
I love both but have to go for the Audi. Perhaps do a comparison between the Velar SVAutobiography Dynamic Edition and the RSQ8?
RANGE ROVER
The Q8, you always want to take that car for any ride and you can't wait. The Velar, when you need to ride, its a pleasure.
The answer is - Velar SVR, which you can order already, while Audi RSQ8 isn't coming till next year.
NightCoder svautobiography* not meant to race
head says q8, heart says velar
Y don't u even make a video on Audi q3 and the range Rover evoque
Q8 is not comparable to Velar dude.. u got wrong cars together. Q8 is a Q7 which is coupe style. U can compare a Q8 with range rover sport however u better compare a Q7 with range rover sport. There is no such equivalent of Q8 in land rover range. There are GLE coupe and X6 though in other brands
sharif sayfe not true nigga
Those two cars are price wise in two different worlds. Between the base model 50 TDI and base model D240 are £15.000
Just test drove both these cars. Drove the velar V6 340 and it was cheaper and more powerful than the audi Q8 which is a V6 standard. That would have been the better comparison. The range rover was the better drive too. I thought the rest of the review was pretty spot on, nice job. I also think the two are very comparable though many feel the velar in in a smaller class, they feel comparable in size to me. Velar is a sexier looking car by far and gets the nod from me and I already own an SQ5 and a Cayenne.
It will be like marrying a woman who wants transplants all over her
velar should vs with Q5 or Q7 not Q8
Not even the Q7, the Q7 is from a completely different segment. It should go against the Porsche Macan, GLC Coupe, Q5 and X4. Even though an Evoque costs more than an Audi Q3 in most markets you don't compare it to a Q5 do you?
I was also wondering if there’s any truth in Audi’s next model being called partner?
I got a quote for £70k on road delivered Velar 3L D HSE Velar with panoramic roof with blue metallic paint and contrast black roof including Head up Display which having driven I prefer to Audi Q8 I have also driven..Audi just left me cold
Ok. Let's make it interesting. The Audi E-Tron vs the Audi Q8. The catch is you can only judge build quality, power train, handling and comfort. Range or fueling cannot be a factor. This will be the new comparison in the near future.
Where is the offroad capabilities comparison ?
How is a Velar priced same as the q8? If you compared the Q8 to the sport would that not be a fairer comparison? I'd go Q5 vs Velar and pick the velar anyday!!
Not a fair comparison. You should have compared the Q8 with the 3.0 Velar, not the 2.0 :(
Did he say the Velar is cheaper to own over 3 years?! Hilarious considering we can’t keep LR’s out of the shop here in the US. Regardless, both are under warranty during that time period. We ended up with the Q8 and it’s sublime driving experience. I do prefer our GLC’s redundant (nice quality) button interface, but the Q8’s snappy processor and large screens makes the all touchscreen interface easy to live with. I like the available haptic feedback button like click sensation; my wife prefers the iPad quickness when the haptic is off.
As noted, the Q8 is a bigger car than it appears on vids and pics. As a result, the back seat room is huge; right there with the new GLE; much bigger than an X5. The boot is plentiful. The car is long and wide as hell, so make sure it’ll fit in your garage. It dwarfs our GLC sitting next to it.
Range Rover Velar for sure! What a beauty!♥️😍
For the price i wish both would offer more features as standard and Range Rover Infotainment is very slow and less reliable
You should compare Range Rover sport with Audi Q5
Audi Q8 my favourite car
Audi looks like it has been cut with a knife. Range Rover has a unique style and I love it
And I hate the range rover because it looks just like a blob
Velar has zero styling
Range rover is range rover
@@yuxuanxiao9285 zero styling? That isn’t true 😂 I think somebody’s poor and bitter. Be better.
the Q8 definitely
It's strange that you didn't make mention of the GLE Coupe or X6 🙁 which pioneered this segment.
I would prefer audi Q8
Q8 IS my dream car
Q8 ❤😍
Still pick the velar 100%
Why do so many car reviews always put 4x4 up against suv ‘s
I have the Velar whit the 3.0 V6 300 engine, awesome 😍
@@Andres-sr7uv I don’t know because i buy it cash
I like audi Q8
I asked to disagree with a touchscreen Audi Q8 I find it quite easy to use on the go as you get used to wear you need to press and the feedback you get gives you confirmation as for PCP deals if you look at Audi Q8 vorsprung compared to the velar you would need to add 20 grand with extras which does not reflect on your PCP deal
The haptic feedback is annoying and still you have to look at what you press. Defeats the point as you need to know what and where to press and if you have, only one point is solved there. BMW have done a better job of it all
Audi has great steering feeling and is agile? This reviewer has no idea what he is on about.
have you driven it? he has. you are talking from a place of ignorance
@@damiano8738 the irony 😂
@@dandan9442 weak response
Q8❤
llove Q8 this is my favorite car ❤️❤️❤️
Best audi q8
Couldn't agree more... Besides JLR is exactly unreliable.... Sadly I used to love Land Rover.
What do you drive?
Look wise i go with velar
Sporty? What planet...?
Would be interesting to drive the Q8 in Kuwait 😉
Keep in mind this is not the best example of a velar. The best look would be a white car with r dynamic black package and black contrast roof.
Your comment is written as fact, when in fact it’s opinion based.
@@Mcfckinkladze yeah you right
Bruh, No off-road test? 😑
Velar💓💓
Q8.❤
Q8!
if you want to become a partner at the dealership or at a mechanic I strongly suggest buying a velar it will be really wonderful.
What do you drive, mate ?
@@Mcfckinkladze currently a tesla model y, bought used from a friend to help him but i have my eye on a mirai. My previous car was a Subaru XV and before that it was a BMW X3. my dad had two land rovers on different occasions, the first was a velar, this one never went without problems for more than 6 months when the warranty ran out he sold it and bought a bmw x3 (later I bought it from him) a few years later he bought one evoque that it gave less problems than velar but going to Spain broke a connecting rod, the car had less than 2 years of use with all the correct revisions carried out at the dealership. Based on family experience, I do not particularly recommend the brand, but the experience with the brand may have been wonderful for other people.
Not fair comparison engine wise, but even dimension size I guess, ...and one important aspect of these SUVs were not tested, where the Velar would bit the Q8 in every sense, OFF-ROAD capability!!! ...take them both to some mudy, dirty road and then we are talking ;)
Actually, Audi is just cowboy slang for hello
Your comment is highly underrated.
the velar door handle wood suck in the winters where I'm from. an SUV not meant for winter.
Both of them are fantastic, but I go to the Audi Q8.
Q8 was compared to velar in carwow also...
Sport*
Both are my favourite.but I'm gonna choose the q8 cuz I love Germany 🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
RR for sure
To big for UK car parks
This is not even fair... The Velar would ve Looked dated 10 years ago so no way it can be compared to the mighty A8. 😎
Q8 should be compared with Range Rover Sport...
Velar isn't coupe as cayenne and x6 and q8
I'm prefer my vi😊
You will never find a perfect véhicule but the difference that really count is the ride, the quality and the maintenance sheet that comes with the véhicule. My only problem is that AUDI makes you pay the maintenance when you lease one of their vehicles. I understand why but they know that after 4 years the véhicule cost a fortune in maintenance. The RANGE ROVER is well just a name. They have the worst paint quality in the SUV market. You look at it and it scratches itself.
Audi's current angular design philosophy looks dated which, for me, is a deal breaker, this is particularly apparent in the Q8's cabin which looks extraordinarily tacky compared to the Velar's interior.
I want to buy R R
Velar 👍💥👑🐅
Q8 vs RANGE ROVER SVR!!.. svr would kill it..
RSQ8 would kill the SVR.
Velar the dream