"You're Either STUPID, Insane Or A LIAR!" | Julia Hartley-Brewer Slams Labour's Definition Of Women
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 07. 2024
- Julia Hartley-Brewer slams the Labour Party’s definition of a woman, as she claims “voters will not put up with this!”.
Speaking to Spiked Online’s Tom Slater, Julia said "You're either stupid, insane or a liar if you claim that a woman is anything other than an adult human female."
JK Rowling has also described Anneliese Dodds' comments as “nonsensical” past comments on gender, as the Labour MP was announced as women and equalities minister.
The Harry Potter author has previously accused Labour of having “abandoned” her and others campaigning for women’s rights.
Ms Rowling has become known as a fierce advocate for the rights of biological women after criticising Scottish Government proposals to introduce self-identification for transgender people.
Ms Dodds was appointed a minister of state - Minister for Women and Equalities - in the Department for Education, serving under Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson who was named also Minister for Women and Equalities.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#trans #transgender #gender #jkrowling
Can not understand why every REAL women in the UK does not think the same way as Julia !
They do, but they know they will get a visit from plod, if they say anything.
Think they are petrified too.
Because they are too sensible.
I’m a Real woman now since transitioning from Dave the truck driver .
No need for "real" or "biological". We women are just women. And men are never ever women. Or vice versa.
No money for defence. But plenty for illegal immigrants in 5 star hotels 😂😂
Yes, who’d have thought it eh?
CORRECT 💯😡
Starmer himself won that right for them.... as a lawyer
They don't continue to function as 5 star hotels when they house immigrants they become hostels.
Agreed
A Minister for Women who cannot define what a woman is. For heavens sake, if that doesn't set alarm bells ringing about this Govt then nothing will.
Basically minister for anyone who wants to consider themselves a woman whether they are or not.
l agree
The insane are running the asylum ! Just like in the U.S.!
Maybe Labour need a common sense minister like the Tories had.
If this wasn't reality...I would have thought it was an monty python, sketch 😊
STUPID, Insane Or A LIAR - Labour are all three.
Get real... the whole conversation of what constitutes a woman is intended to divide and undermine; same as the anti semitism brigade...to even bring this subject is absolutely pointless - which is why the Tory press want to turn it into a thing.
Very true 👌🏻
Ah…you lost. Right wing tears hehehe
@@Lloyd.Brownecan you define a woman?
@@TeddyG-y6s why… are you still playing that false narrative? Everything is a concept. When we all agree what the definition is, we will move on.
we are in for 5 years of utter madness😩🤬
I wish I could say, "Beam me up, Scotty".
I picked the wrong time to quit whiskey
i dident vote for it
@@knoxyish The unemployed, the unemployable, foreigners, students and weirdos voted for it.
Imagine how empowered the wokerati feel now.
Tony B-liar should be in prison. He took the country to an illegally war in Iraq 🇮🇶.
Is that all? Every single thing wrong with this country today can be laid at his door. Blair is left of Lenin, shame the British gave him free rein to do it, re-elected him twice and believed him when he told them "things can only get better"! He set the UK on the path of ruin and now is back to finish the job.
Not just war, Blair opened the floodgates to immigrants from Islam who hate our guts and our way of life. Spanner Starmer is just a follow on.
…and how did he get the country behind him? He murdered our fellow citizens on 7/7…
It wasn’t an illegal war - it was an ill-judged, unnecessary, and immoral war. Not the same thing
Then he opened the boarders to allow the enemy in.
How much money could we spend on our armed forces if we weren’t spending billions on immigrants?
they cut the military because 'they' didn't have the money, yet have money to give to the corrupt Zelensky!?
YES sir 👌🏻
And sending aid to countries that do not need it.
Speaking of which, where are they? At our borders defending our country? Na
Around 8.5 million pounds per day and constantly rising. So about £30 billion a year. Wasted putting up people with no right to even be here!
The fact that Lammy is our Foreign Secretary says it all...
Scarey
I dread to think of him on the world stage. He makes out he's a working class hero, yet went to Harvard!
@@paulinek9764 how someone with a law degree, masters in law and passed the bar exam can be as thick as a plank is one of life's great mysteries.
@@tonygreenfield7820 They're often the stupidest.
And look at who the Justice Minister is.
STARMER DOES NOT KNOW ~~~ WHAT AN ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT IS EITHER.
No country without it's own steel industry can win a war.
Yes - and I think it’s been a DELIBERATE move to destroy ours. It is not a coincidence that our public utilities were all snapped up by China, India, the Arabs - they wanted to suck us dry then close it down so THEY have the capability, we don’t and we become entirely dependent on them. It’s wrong wrong wrong and our political class have committed treason by allowing it
Or when we have been flooded with our enemies
Starmer bragged in his leadership speech today that he has more diversity and LGBTQ than any other party. Made me feel sick
You've got another Trudeau on your hands. Good luck!
Identity politics 101
Mr Turnip
I'd be much more interested in hiring people I knew to be authentic and highly capable in their roles. Skin colour, gender and sexuality have nothing to do with that. Hallmark leftist racism and everything-else-ism all the way. Don't we look great?!
I have never been so depressed at the thought of how much damage Labour will do to the UK.
I can't understand how naive people are ,voting Labour/Tory is voting for the same ,they are Globalists and hope to bring an end to the West as we've known it .Wake up for goodness sake
lol
Yes those Torries were so much better they got booted out
@@randybackgammon890 They were equally as horrific, but the Starmer regime will see multiple freedoms being taken away, as well as our culture.
It could be worse to be fair. They could readmit Mr Corbyn to the party and make him foreign secretary?
Just follow the science, XX Female/Ms, XY Male/Mr.
It should be an criminal offence to mis-chromosome someone.
Since when did they follow the science ever.
@@wadoryujujutsukempo6289 oh they did during the lockdowns , don’t you remember ? 😂😂😂they only follow the science when it suits them
True greater than 99% of the time. Very occasionally, there are sex chromosome abnormalities like XXY, XYY.
@@rhysjaggar4677yes but humans are still only male or female. The exception proves the rule. That’s like saying humans don’t have two arms because some humans are born with one or none.
Two genders. Male. Female.
The men of Britain are 100% with you.
Especially the islamic and jewish ones as they are getting exactly what they want 😊
This is them trying to pay and use our media to implement there hatred and beliefs in britain
Really, then why aren't you on the beaches stopping the bloody boats
@laviniasey ahhh I didn't make my point well.
She said the woman of Britain had, had enough of men pretending to be women.
what are they getting
Plenty of money for Zelensky but none for our own defence.
Because Ukraine is fighting a war and for the moment saving us from having to do that!!!!
@@turboslag we are not at war with Russia nor should be poke our noses in either .
@@turboslag your are indoctrinated to the point you think Russia intends to invade the UK. Whilst the enemy that is plotting your demise is right under your nose. 😂
@@turboslag Ukraine isn't at war with Russia. Guaranteed when Trump gets in it will soon stop. Its the Biden family with all their money laundering that's keeping it going.
@the_forbinproject2777 erm. The west is threatened. So we should just sit back and act like we know nothing about it and to just ignore it? What fairytale world you living in?
Well said Julia, this context rubbish needs to stop. Call me old fashioned, a bigot, I don't care, a woman is an Adult Human Female.
Totally agree with you Julie! Women who says it depends on the context, it’s bloody disgusting!
Thank God for this lady!!
I just cannot believe we are having these types of conversations. It truly is insanity of the highest level.
The acronym WOKE : Wasteful Oddballs Kidding Everyone.
It really is insane. We could be sorting the economy, but we're stuck on nonsense.
@@Madonnalitta1
No dear , it’s YOU and your ilk that are fixated on this.
An ex Home Secretary who was guilty of serious misconduct by fiddling her expenses whilst she was a government minister, gets a high level cabinet position in Starmers new government. What is going on.
Big corruption
Stuff the woke ideology and extreme Islamist. I want England and Christianity.
⁴
We are a Christian country and we need to protect our history and British culture! We do not want to become a country controlled by Islamic Extremists!
lol
Have to ask...... define "WOKE" ...... in my opinion "Equality" falls into this label too in my opinion .....
@@hmtr2236 "Woke" = The inability to define a woman. Fixed it for you.
Well said, totally agree. Fight back women.
Starmer admitted our country is in a mess yet he's offered more aid to Ukraine, starmer is the Tories on steroids
Tony Blair’s policies has brought our country to “BENDING THE KNEE TO ISLAM”. Does the country need his advice.
One word ....NO
Starmer knows he is lying, we know he is lying and he knows we know he is lying but he keeps on lying anyway
Not only lord stramer lying.... a lot of lords have been lying a lot for a lot of time ...including the chief of lords ..lord churchill 😂😂😂
Most men think it's insane as well.
Yes, Julia, we're so done. I've no time for anyone pretending that they don't know what a man or woman is.
What you gonna do about it? Stamp your feet?
But Lammy says that men can grow a cervix, is this indicative of a pathology?
Yes, insanity.
He still believes in Father Christmas 😂
It seems that the way😬
I was an RN and I can categorically state they can’t. I didn’t work in gynaecology though so maybe there are a few wannabe women growing one as we speak………..😂😂😂
If you can't fight - it's best not to tell the whole world.
How right you are
If they're short of money we all know where they could get 8 million a day.
Uber driver
A great deal of so-called academics have NO COMMON SENSE 🙄
Well said julia❤
Julia is a tool of the establishment, paid to says things she's allowed to say, to stay relevant, they all are, no journalism or journalists live there. Alternative media for the real info on this and all world affairs, those who would be silenced.
When did politicians ever tell the "TRUTH".
If you're a biological woman and voted Labour in, you probably need to rethink your political position if you thought this wouldn't happen.
No excuse for not knowing though, it was clear Sir Kier Starmer didn't know what a woman was or how to keep women's spaces safe.
Definitely Labour Conservatives tared with the same Brush 🧹 🧹 it’s just going to get worse 😮
I don’t know what people are thinking 🤔
Believe the OPPOSITE of what your GOV tells you to do, and you will be right.
The labour party won't do zero for hardworking tax payers who have worked all their lives and always payed their taxes and NI contributions.
We are nothing not important irrelevant to this country .
Heartbreaking.
All these weirdos need to just look at Julia, now that's a woman !
Julia.
You are the only one that speaks sense.
It’s people like you that we want in Government.
🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
SIR KNEEL will surrender
Stop being so generous. They are NOT stupid or insane. They are ALL LIARS!
They know will what a women is but choose to lie about it.
lol 😂
Go julia!
It would be nice if she'd stop talking for 5 seconds and let her guest speak.
Why is Blair even in the news?
His Ego thinks he's important
Because he’s the puppeteer operating Starmer!
@@Michelle-iz5bhand Shwab pulls Blairs
Hoping to be made a Lord of Whatever,like Cameron.
Just ignore them all.
Starmer is no centrist.
Definitely not. Didn't he say only a couple of weeks ago that he's a socialist?
@@catwoman7462 your right
I have to switch off if he pops up on television cannot stand him
@@Lewisevans1618 Listening to him speak is like nails down a blackboard.
Far left socialist
Labor party = Welfare party - has nothing to do with working people.
How ignorant
Yes Julia!! Well said!!
I have friends on the left and friends on the right but we all have one thing in common and that is we all despise Tony Bliar.
Totally agree. Nice to see two intelligent sensible folks talking COMMON SENSE.👍👍👍❤️❤️
They haven’t stopped lying and they have only been in a few days
Sorry, Mr Putin, we're a bit stuck for cash just now. Please dont attack us.
Exactly
Dont worry .. the house of lords are planning to colonize again .... the whole of Africa and India ...is lord Cecil Rhodes still pocketing diamonds in Kimberley then?????😂😂😂
when gorden brown left he said, sorry no money left
In 5 years that is what this government will be saying.
He also got rid of our gold!
Oh no trouble for immigrants
Good. Bring it on!
@josimpson7999 Your sort is insane!
@@rokketron Oh you’ve really upset me 🤣
Labour voters will be hearing this a lot. I TOLD YOU SO
The ECHR isn’t the problem it was a bluff by the Tories France has the ECHR but accepts 25% of asylum claims we accept 66% + the problem is having the actual will to do something
They want to remove any safeguards Europeans have, not that the ECHR upholds Europeans human rights anyway but they could be challenged by it if that court ever did its job properly.
If the government can't define a woman how can they jail someone for giving their definition? How do you criminalise something they can't define themselves?
People seem to forget there was no money when Labour last left office and the Tory party had to try and save the day .
Credit crunch caused it
Can we remember that after the last time Labour were in government on Tony's watch, Gordon Brown on departure left a message on his desk for his successor, saying "There is no money"!
Like the US we owe trillions.
Gordon Brown? Fact check needed.
Perhaps Labour should have a chat with Farage as he is the only man that seems to have any idea about finances.
lol 😂
And ideas about everything else as well!
Tony Blair should not be able to have a say in anything! I hope they don’t start building houses for immigrants where our own people need housing!
They've already started housing them in new flats and houses
Its alarming that Blair has burst out of his crypt and started interfering. He had his turn already and he blew it.
He wrecked the country when he was in power.
I live in a small village, they're already in housing. It's not just happening in the cities
If Starmer isn't even good enough for a war criminal like Blair we are stuffed.
Ah we’re stuffed anyway with labour in for next 5 years 😢
Well said Julia!
Armed forces, UK standing army, 70,00. Russian standing forces, 350,000+. Should there be a conflict, good luck!
yeah, uk would still destroy russia... unless we, as a humanity, go back to stones and sticks, russia wouldn't stand a chance, mostly due to technology and logistics. not to mention the uk's allies.. the only thing that would make uk (or usa, or other major western power, for that matter) lose is politics. that is why, in my opinion, russia pushed all kinds of propaganda and conflicting ideologies in the west. a country with a polarized society, divided by all kinds of things (like this trans/lgbt/whatever ideology, religion (as always), race, sex/sexuality and lots of other stuff) is bound to fail. it has come to the point that you cannot have a conversation with anyone on any subject, let alone understanding. even more... words lost their meaning to a lot of people (obvious in this video, where there is a discussion about what a woman is... like, wtf). it's really scary, if you think about it.
@@cobepunkGood, that's reassuring... You'd better get ready to lead the charge or send your kids to the front line then.
@@The.Doctor.Venkman what? all i said is that in a hypothetical war between uk and russia, uk would win. not that i want a war. this is what i mean about understanding and words meaning. but, yeah go jump the hate train, it's trendy these days.
@@cobepunk Nobody's hating? I'm just pointing out you are naïve if you think [sic] "Russia wouldn't stand a chance, mostly due to technology and logistics" They are not interested in perpetual war, unlike the goons running the US, UK and EU. The war over there is done. There could have only ever been one outcome. After all, it was us that started it back in 2014, so what would you expect them to do?
@@cobepunk Of course we wouldn't win, we can't stop rubber dinghies coming across from France
Reform UK will get bigger and more votes
Whatever you do don't let these people bully, threaten or scare you with police into speaking like a normal person and to speak aloud with your normal person beliefs. Double down if they do. Keep speaking out and keep mocking anyone who spouts that LGBTQ ideology. Make sure you're separating the ideologues from the ones who are just doing their own thing though. There are many gay and lesbian(and even trans)folks who are totally against this garbage and know in the end it's hurting them and a detriment to them having this extreme ideology try to speak for them. It's like a cult now. If you step just one tiny bit out of line you're an apostate. JK Rowling being the best eg of that. If they'll do all that to her being the big progressive she is then it just screams cult.
Its not the LGB that are the issue, its the T and the Q and everything after it that are causing all the problems. The Far Left will meet the Far right soon enough and then its going to be catastrophic....
There's no such thing as "trans."
I'll not participate in someone's delusion.
@@Madonnalitta1I was just about to say the same!
I have a friend who is trans, had the full Monty, 🤮🤮🤮and this drives her up the wall. She just wants to be left alone like the rest of us and get on with her life. Now she gets more abuse than ever and she’s done nothing other than make her own choices, which is frankly her business, whatever others think.
lol 😂
BRAVO Madame!!!! Keep shouting the TRUTH!
Thank you!!
The women should have vote for reform UK
But they didn’t, as they are not thick.
Ventriloquist dummy comes to my mind, Sir Kier Starmer is the dummy and Tony Blair is the ventriloquist
Not as bad as the last Labour government left us with £165 billion annual deficit in 2010.
Credit crunch happened though
Never voting Conservative or Labour again in my life.
Reform always for me.
Its always good to speak the truth. Well done for standing your ground and many people agree with what you've just discussed .
They are not lunatics, they are very clever but only as long as it serves their own needs.
Woman - adult human female 😉
And Keir Starmer.....
It’s misogyny in politics
Denying me my biology is hurtful beyond words
lol 😂
Vote labour and this is what you get and more to come
The worst crimes are committed by those in power, because they are never held to account, let alone be prosecuted. We sometimes find out what they have done after they have died. Saville is not the only one by far.
So as a biological woman when i get referred to as a man on the phone can i claim a hate crime.
I love Julia she speaks what we are thinking. Thanks for telling the truth on the state of the coffers. But for Rachael Reeves to lie straight away. Unforgivable.
Well said Julia on trans issue.
Yup! I noticed straight away the lack of media coverage on the Ukraine childrens hospital being bombed. I found it outrageous! And where are the marches for theose decent helpless people.
Agree, Zelensky gets more coverage at NATO anniversary in US
Can Starmer last 5 years with the in fighting due to the fridge element's and lack of experience!
And just like Corbyn did he'll cow tow to the most extreme of his party and not criticize their insane beliefs and the heinous things they do or say. Only under extreme pressure did Corbyn even mention the Jew hatred of his party. It's only worse now though. But when you take in so many from a religion that's main tenet is to eradicate Semites how could they not know that would happen? Labor has been getting closer and closer to proving Jean-Pierre Faye's Horseshoe Theory correctly.
He won't last 5 minutes...
He's already reading what someone else has written ( just watch the speech outside number 10 )
Then we have someone else who is really dangerous in charge !!!
The groveller Rayner
Wait until Trump is back as president, Starmer's nightmare will be multiplied.
No they won't.. I don't give it 2 years there will be so much strife or a war..
Thank you for holding the line, Julia. I don't think KS realises how many courts he'll need if he tries making biology a hate crime! I would rather be prosecuted than call a man "she".
Yep! Me too 💚🤍💜
Julia is right that kindness is not the issue. Whether Julia is kind to trans people or I am unkind to trans people is irrelevant. The truth matters. We are sentient human beings who feel uncomfortable when asked to believe something that is obviously untrue. Dont force us to believe untruths or we will be forced to be unkind.
There is always money for migrants and Ukraine
What a thought...Starmer, the love child of Blair and Corbyn!
The women of Britain clearly aren't "done with this" and they clearly haven't "had enough of this nonsense" as they're still voting for it. Ladies, you have a lot of power... you are over 50% of the population... Vote for someone who does know what a woman is and this idiocy will stop.
the uk wouldn't fight a war alone ffs. that's why we are in NATO
Still wouldn't win against russia no young person in thier right mind would join the forces don't blame them
We wouln't be when the US votes Biden out. We will be well and truly alone. Unless Starmer increases military spending.
@lasttango7522 utter nonsense you are deluded if you think that
Most of European countries havnt a army or enough equipment
Labour got away scot free during the campaign. Starmer was hardly challenged. But he will be by the angry public.
Can anyone please explain when you have the nuclear deterant you need an army for defense.
Not even Putin wants a nuclear war.
Julia speaks more sense than anybody in the current government.
Anneliese Dodds always looks like she doesn’t know what day it is never mind a woman
I agree, does she know what she is, if she does she would not tell you😂
🔹 *_Will Labour offer all racial, ethnic & religious groups equal application of the law! Or will certain groups be allowed to do what they like whilst they wave their religious or ideological flags? We already know the answer! God help the J*ws._* 🔹
Great conversation with Tom Slater Julia, totally agree with the points you guys make 👍👍👍
Why would you need two women's ministers is it one woman and one man clothed in a dress ?!
Every child can tell the difference between man & woman, but adult female Minister for Women, Matt Walsh & Jonathan Willoughby cannot.
SNP !
Dodds is Scottish and seen too many in men in kilts
So so true
What a great speaker you are Julia, precise calm , doing a great job. 👏🌞💐
Very, very, VERY well said ! Total common sense ! Brilliant ! Why can't people like this lady run our country ? !
No more money for Ukraine!
Dear former rulers of the waves: what have you done to yourselves?
Wheres the bees
Indeed, Geo engineering, weather manipulation, Solar radiation management, cloud seeding, chemtrails, HAARP takes care of bees, our natural wonder
Well said I am a real woman and I am not only insulted but disgusted