History of Ukraine - Manny Man Does History

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 04. 2022
  • DONATE TO UKRAINE: donation.babynyar.org/en/
    PATREON: / johndruddy
    ONLINE STORE: www.johndruddy.com/shop/
    PODCAST: open.spotify.com/show/55aKvEr...
    TWITTER: / johndruddy
    INSTAGRAM: / johndruddy
    CZcams CHANNEL 1: / johndruddymannyman
    CZcams CHANNEL 2: / @johndruddydoesstuff5585
    Find out all about the long and arduous history of the people of Ukraine.
    CORRECTION: Towards the end when I refer to Uzbekistan, I incorrectly pointed to Turkmenistan on the map. Apologies! It was a series of consecutive late nights…
    Written and created by JOHN D RUDDY @johndruddy
    Illustrated and edited by JOHN D RUDDY @johndruddy
    Enjoy! Please share! BUY MY BOOKS HERE: johndruddy.com/books/

Komentáře • 374

  • @HistorySkills
    @HistorySkills Před 2 lety +172

    This is an amazing initiative. I am proud to be part of this collaboration and hoping we can make a little bit of a difference to some people’s lives.

    • @spaghettimon3851
      @spaghettimon3851 Před 2 lety +1

      Pray the Donbass region free themselves from the Euromaidan fascists in Kiev that is cluster bombing murdering 15,000 people! 🇨🇺❤⬛🟦🟥📘🟦🟥

    • @meh...9500
      @meh...9500 Před 2 lety +1

      He implied that right wing groups are Nazi's during the end I was once his biggest fan but in his eyes it seems I am a Nazi.

    • @shaynewheeler9249
      @shaynewheeler9249 Před 2 lety +1

      Save Ukraine

    • @purpleblastoise
      @purpleblastoise Před rokem +1

      God bless Donetsk and Lugansk people's republics! 🇨🇺❤⬛🟦🟥🆓️🟦🟥

    • @shaynewheeler9249
      @shaynewheeler9249 Před rokem

      Shampoo 🧴🧴🧴

  • @robertsnavely3447
    @robertsnavely3447 Před 2 lety +72

    I showed this video to my 8th-grade history students and they say: "We were captivated for the whole 20 minutes and we thoroughly appreciate your effort to educate us on this deeply important topic." They clapped at the end and asked for more videos from the Irish guy and "Bug-eyed History"!

    • @FiveMissiles
      @FiveMissiles Před 7 měsíci

      you seem like a teacher id want to have

    • @kieranhurst8543
      @kieranhurst8543 Před 2 měsíci +4

      I'll take shit that never happened with a side of fries

  • @historywithhilbert146
    @historywithhilbert146 Před 2 lety +92

    Excellent video and brilliant explanation of Ukrainian history. I just love your art style - must be a lot of fun to draw all the characters!

  • @PakBallandSami
    @PakBallandSami Před 2 lety +115

    “Ukraine is truly resisting tyranny...
    As the Russian forces get closer to Poland, many Ukrainians go--not further west from the border--but back into Ukraine...don't think it couldn't happen here. Vigilance has been required of us, but nothing like the vigilance that has been required of the Ukrainian people.
    It may yet be.”
    ― Shellen Lubin

  • @HistoriaGraecia
    @HistoriaGraecia Před 2 lety +16

    Your animation style is so unique and nice! Glad to be part of this collaboration, got to know so many new and incredible channels!

  • @jona.scholt4362
    @jona.scholt4362 Před 2 lety +14

    Thinking of all th senior citizens in Ukraine who cannot be moved or cannot be moved without a major effort is painful. I think of my grandma in her last two years and can't even imagine. I also have think of those with special needs, especially the children, and all of the confusion this tragedy has caused. Sad doesn't begin to describe it. It's a great thing these channels, so many of which I have loved watching for years, are doing something to aid the people of Ukraine in their struggle against the Tyrant Putin.

  • @ThePacificWarChannel
    @ThePacificWarChannel Před 2 lety +48

    Very proud to be part of #ProjectUkraine =) amazing videos by all the great content creators! 🇺🇦

  • @Number1Irishlad
    @Number1Irishlad Před 2 lety +37

    Its awesome to see that so many of yall in this project ukraine have already dropped videos for it. Thank yall for doin what you do~
    Slava Ukraine

  • @ExoticD
    @ExoticD Před rokem +7

    My great grandpa comes from Ukraine! He was in WW1 as a behind the lines medic. Eventually everything he'd seen and done got to him and with the russians being pushed back he deserted home till the war was over. With the Russian revolution, many gangs roamed the Ukrainian country killing and robbing many. Eventually my great grandpa had enough of the poverty and murders and ended up getting a ticket to Canada with his wife and kids. They took a train up to the Baltics where they then took a boat to great Britain, and after that sailed to Canada. They ended up settling in Saskatchewan (as you mentioned) where we've lived to this day. There's much more to the story but I'm not much of a writer, so these are the basics of what happend. I'm glad you made this video so I can understand all that went on during these times.

  • @jessicaaxe7120
    @jessicaaxe7120 Před rokem +10

    Thank you for this! And I appreciate you mentioning the other countries that are suffering the same horrors that Ukraine is currently facing. Peace to Ukraine, but also to Syria, Yemen, Palestine, and others.

  • @HikmaHistory
    @HikmaHistory Před 2 lety +3

    I'm glad I discovered your playlist through this playlist! Great content!

  • @JeremyStrozer
    @JeremyStrozer Před 2 lety +5

    Great episode, wonderful cause. Particularly appreciate the message at the end about suffering in many parts of the world. Peace to the world. Thanks John!

  • @lukeh2556
    @lukeh2556 Před 2 lety +29

    Very cool to hear the Candian Ukrainian diaspora mentioned. In the prairies it's often less a question of wether soneone has Ukrainian ancestory but how much, and when I was abroad when asked if asked if their was any food from home I missed I would amusesdly say Pierogi.

    • @ryanelliott71698
      @ryanelliott71698 Před 2 lety

      It wasn’t until that long ago I found out Canada had the second largest Ukrainian population. Probably helps I’m from Ontario and anything outside of it is kinda vague

    • @saloenjoyer7381
      @saloenjoyer7381 Před 2 lety

      Pierogi are called "Vareniki" in Ukraine

    • @lukeh2556
      @lukeh2556 Před 2 lety +1

      @@saloenjoyer7381 true, I think maybe it's because the polish influence in the midwest that Peirogi became the catch all name for them

    • @lukeh2556
      @lukeh2556 Před 2 lety

      @@ryanelliott71698 yeah one of a few things that kind of creates a unique identity for western Canada

    • @katherinegilks3880
      @katherinegilks3880 Před 2 lety

      @@lukeh2556 Lots of western Canadians don’t have Ukrainian ancestry - 2/3 of us don’t. It isn’t part of my Canadian identity for sure. Not so say I don’t support Ukraine, because I do, but it isn’t special. It really bothers me how much people expect us to support Ukraine compared to Syria or Yemen or anywhere else. It is blatantly racist. People just expect us to care because they’re our cousins - but Ukrainians aren’t any more my cousins than Syrians are.

  • @HistoryandHeadlines
    @HistoryandHeadlines Před 2 lety +7

    It is really fascinating watching everyone's videos in the playlist.

  • @MomMom4Cubs
    @MomMom4Cubs Před 2 lety +56

    Slava Ukraina!
    Viva Ukraine!
    Ukrainians are strong, and they will ensure.

    • @Ian-fw2fp
      @Ian-fw2fp Před 2 lety +1

      *endure

    • @Mck499
      @Mck499 Před 2 lety +1

      @@Ian-fw2fp dude shut up

    • @hanrenchou128
      @hanrenchou128 Před 2 lety

      The people have to endure with this their government incompetent and greediness's meat grinder. God bless the people who suffer from war.

  • @veritasetcaritas
    @veritasetcaritas Před 2 lety +2

    Delighted to be with you in this collaboration!

  • @gbiallas5728
    @gbiallas5728 Před 2 lety +5

    I like how much effort that he puts into these videos

  • @ming1408
    @ming1408 Před 2 lety +12

    Are you still working on Monarchs of England Part 3? just wanna know.
    LongLiveUkraine

  • @drillstevejr2290
    @drillstevejr2290 Před 6 měsíci +2

    9:48 as a Canadian I love to see my country being meantioned by history channels especially in a positive light 😊
    🇨🇦 ❤ 🇺🇦

  • @dimanyak373
    @dimanyak373 Před rokem +3

    As a ukrainian I'm very thankful for your efforts put into this video, though there are some inaccuracies I'd like to point out.
    1. Ukraine doesn't mean 'borderland'. It's just not right semantically, as though it's similar to the word for borderland(okraina), their prefixes are actually opposite in meaning. Both words come from the word 'krai', which can mean either 'border' or 'land', but the prefix o- means it's outside of the 'krai', while prefix u- is the opposite. Ukraine basically means inland, and not the borderland.
    2. Russia actually recognised Ukrainian independence many times. During the dissolution of the Soviet Union, in the Budapest memorandum, which was a guarantee of safety of Ukraine, given in exchange for it's leftover nukes. It changed in 2014 when ukrainian people have ousted out the pro-russian dictator and Russia invaded Crimea and Donbass

  • @danieldmelniki8834
    @danieldmelniki8834 Před rokem

    Grateful for this Playlist! @Kings and Generals & Company!!

  • @PakBallandSami
    @PakBallandSami Před 2 lety +1

    love the art man

  • @aaron3890
    @aaron3890 Před rokem +1

    Brilliant summary!

  • @beelarmi
    @beelarmi Před 2 lety +4

    This is actually pretty good John, i mean this is pretty solid history, unlike much of what i see daily on twitter and reddit

  • @NoodleBerry
    @NoodleBerry Před měsícem +3

    I've fallen out with seemingly every communist in my city over this so it's nice to see people siding with the invaded, even online

  • @LSTNSCRFN
    @LSTNSCRFN Před 2 lety

    Amazing job!!!

  • @genjibeeps998
    @genjibeeps998 Před 2 lety +6

    As i Feeling bad for Ukraine,
    I approve this 🇺🇦
    But greetings from belarus 🇧🇾

  • @Vitess7
    @Vitess7 Před 2 lety

    thank you for it :)

  • @MRresievil310
    @MRresievil310 Před rokem +3

    Good news: Ukraine is still around and still fighting back Russian tyranny!

  • @oliversherman2414
    @oliversherman2414 Před 2 lety

    I love your channel keep up the great stuff about

  • @yegorkhmelenko7511
    @yegorkhmelenko7511 Před 2 lety

    Now,it’s video my favourite in this CZcams channel

  • @F14TomcatEnjoyer
    @F14TomcatEnjoyer Před 2 lety

    Hi manny I hope you see this but in my social studies class we always watch your videos!!

  • @fredlandry6170
    @fredlandry6170 Před 2 lety

    Cool, interesting video.

  • @je1342
    @je1342 Před 2 lety +1

    Do more of this type of videos

  • @idr1488
    @idr1488 Před 2 lety +1

    Good video

  • @liamlachance9951
    @liamlachance9951 Před 2 lety

    John, that was beautiful

  • @javertbeckstrom1077
    @javertbeckstrom1077 Před 2 lety

    Thank you

  • @HappiKarafuru
    @HappiKarafuru Před rokem +1

    How amazing this small nation in a middle of Europe endure so many conflict and warfare and bloodshed, empire rise and crumble throughout it existance, with a lot of different ethnicity, culture and religion yet they remain strong and kept moving on.

  • @PakBallandSami
    @PakBallandSami Před 2 lety +5

    even if you don't add the current suction in ukraine it still one of the most interesting pert of east europe it has one of the best and interesting history of all the countries in eastern europe
    form the time of the russian empire to the USSR time it has one of the most interesting history so these types of videos are great for me i end up learning so much about that place and love it
    great vid btw

  • @phillipwatson1580
    @phillipwatson1580 Před 2 lety +4

    would u be able to do a history of the space race during the cold war type video mate? that would be fantastic

  • @annoyedbrox4851
    @annoyedbrox4851 Před 2 lety

    Yay I luv your Vids

  • @lukeh2556
    @lukeh2556 Před 2 lety +11

    Wow when you expand the scope of history and see the amount of unique cultures, identities and histories that have been a part of what would become Ukraine the russian narrative of Ukraine being nothing more than a part of russia really falls apart

  • @xzhestx
    @xzhestx Před 6 měsíci +2

    One thing about the name of our country: Ukraine doesn't mean "borderland", it just means "land". As in "planet Earth". And it's russian colonisers who claim it's a "borderland" to their empire. If you think about it, how could a most ancient slavic city, centre of the slavic culture be a center of a borderland?

  • @Spido68_the_spectator
    @Spido68_the_spectator Před 2 lety +10

    Great as always,
    However you forgot a main thing : the 2004 revolution that ousted a pro russian guy as well and made Putin furious !

  • @nightspeakerthefallenwing3451

    Great video of the history Ukraine! I always thought about Ukraine as a lacking country to Europe but when the wind changes it changes my views on Ukraine, I love it when people fight for their freedom from oppression and when the Ukrainian people stepped up to the plate they did it with all they got against the rising threat that is Russia, may Ukraine be remembered not from books but in physical form, Slava Ukraina!

  • @mathiaslambing9112
    @mathiaslambing9112 Před 2 lety +3

    Very well made video, but could you ever make a video about Estonia? Not that you would, but you could.🙃

  • @zeleeba8774
    @zeleeba8774 Před rokem +1

    4:13 is the coat of arms of the Kingdom of Galicia (western region of Ukraine). It would be more appropriate to insert the seryabryanik of Yaroslav the Wise, the prototype of the coat of arms of Ukraine. By the way, the coat of arms of Ukraine means a falcon soaring down, in Russia, the coat of arms of Staraya Ladoga is also similar to the coat of arms of Ukraine.

  • @paginavecchia4146
    @paginavecchia4146 Před 2 lety +6

    I am very pleasantly surprised!
    I myself am from Ukraine and a historian by education, and for the first time I see English-language material on the history of Ukraine to which I have no complaints in principle. It is obvious that the authors worked very well and that the main thing was to show such a difficult topic to understand as the History of Ukraine!
    Thanks so much!
    By the way, for the region of Transcarpathia in Ukraine, there another Irish figure who is very important - Egán Ede. He did a lot to awaken the national consciousness of Ukrainians in this area.
    Erin go Bragh!
    Slava Ukraini!

  • @joshvega5469
    @joshvega5469 Před 2 lety +5

    That project Ukraine just had like 4 history video in my feed for Ukraine warms my heart a bit

  • @spoopyghosti6961
    @spoopyghosti6961 Před 2 lety +1

    11:55
    Hmm.. it’s almost like he’s trying to tell someone this

  • @kingofcards9516
    @kingofcards9516 Před 2 lety +5

    Good video.
    One of your better videos with more history than your own politics.

  • @user-wr5ct6ks1c
    @user-wr5ct6ks1c Před 2 lety +3

    Thanks, that's pretty much it. There are nuances, but in general everything is correct. I just want to add that there have always been Ukrainians, and we have our own language, and we have always been oppressed by all sorts of empires, we are a long-suffering people ...

    • @Iesu-Christi-Servus
      @Iesu-Christi-Servus Před 2 lety

      Не забудь благодарить товарищу Сталину за то, что создал Украину и рисовал ее границы на карте с макиавеллизмом.

  • @majesticfirebird2310
    @majesticfirebird2310 Před 2 měsíci

    4:34 The first "Volodimir The Great", anyway (I think we all know who the second one is, he was in the news a lot at the beginning of the current conflict).
    I came back to this video after hearing that Ukraine will become a member of NATO. It holds up pretty well, considering how much longer the war has gone on since this video's publication. After the enitselaP-learsI (had to reverse it to get around CZcams restrictions) video has come out, and you've taken a break from all that hard work, any chance of a May 2024 Ukraine update video, Mr Ruddy? 🥺

  • @Jishy2415
    @Jishy2415 Před 2 lety +1

    haven't watched it yet, but please include Mahknovshcina because every other type of these video's haven't

  • @Muslim-og3vc
    @Muslim-og3vc Před 2 lety +1

    12:08, love this video but a small mistake here as that is the turkmen ssr, not suprised you made a mistake since it looks similar to the uzbek ssr

  • @tizianotognoni7457
    @tizianotognoni7457 Před rokem +2

    I would love to See you make a similar Video on belarus, as i think it's equally important to highlight the distinct cultural identity of the belarusian people considering that they very much still suffer under russian colonialism

  • @thecount1374
    @thecount1374 Před 2 lety

    Yes!

  • @shaine6764
    @shaine6764 Před rokem

    it was necessary to show Petliura after Skoropadsky.

  • @lukeconnolly5709
    @lukeconnolly5709 Před 2 lety

    Could you do the North King Street Massacre please

  • @kokam4682
    @kokam4682 Před 2 lety +2

    Hey dude do history of Belarus 🇧🇾

  • @user-es8us2zv8y
    @user-es8us2zv8y Před rokem +1

    As a Ukrainian and person who was born in Uman and thoroughly familiar with the history of these neighborhoods, I would say that Cossacks didn’t kill peasants. On the contrary, there was an uprising of Ukrainian peasants against the Polish nobility. In the spring of 1768, Cossacks led by Maksym Zaliznyak appeared in Kholodny Yar near Chigyrin. Later, the uprising covered the entire territory of the Kyiv and Bratslav voivodeships. Maksym Zaliznyak with several hundred Haydamaks captured a number of fortified cities: Zhabotyn, Smila, Cherkasy, Korsun, Bohuslav, Lysyanka. The rebels were joined by peasants and burghers who destroyed the estates of Polish magnates and nobles, inns, churches and Uniate churches.
    The lordship fled to Uman, which belonged to the magnate Franciszek Salesius Potocki and was considered a major trading post.

  • @DraftTheHippies
    @DraftTheHippies Před 2 lety

    To quote a line from the Russian Soldier song Grey Haired Boy or Седой Парнишка for the Cyrillic speakers “Chechnya is in flames, a second Afghanistan”

  • @CivilWarWeekByWeek
    @CivilWarWeekByWeek Před 2 lety +3

    Ah there is that beautiful Irish accent

  • @Ghost_Tracker_2
    @Ghost_Tracker_2 Před 2 lety +13

    When the war started, I knew I can't do much except show support by making a drawing of my OC holding a Ukraine Flag as I pray that the war will be stopped. I pray for Peace in Ukraine. They shouldn't have to suffer like this.
    #StandwithUkraine

  • @AnimationFanboy2k4
    @AnimationFanboy2k4 Před 2 lety +31

    SLAVA UKRAINE!

  • @NikkieSato
    @NikkieSato Před 10 měsíci +2

    After the russian invasion. I was trying to find a video about the history of ukraine. And I found this video and I really like your history of ukraine video. I hope you will make more awesome video in the future 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦

  • @PakBallandSami
    @PakBallandSami Před 2 lety +4

    Ukraine: exists
    Russia: i don't like that

  • @Evzone1821
    @Evzone1821 Před 2 lety

    Based Ruddy

  • @Ian-fw2fp
    @Ian-fw2fp Před 2 lety

    would you mind doing a serb or greek history video one day?

  • @NoodleBerry
    @NoodleBerry Před měsícem

    Hey my family is Ukrainians who moved to Canada in the early 20th century!

  • @eldartaghiyev8422
    @eldartaghiyev8422 Před rokem +2

    And some days ago the last leader of USSR 🇷🇺 died.

  • @EdbertWeisly
    @EdbertWeisly Před 2 lety +1

    Ok

  • @cerebrummaximus3762
    @cerebrummaximus3762 Před rokem +2

    With every evil comes a good.
    And here is the good in the Ukraine-Russia war: ever since the war, the world (specifically the West) was made more aware about Ukraine. I am not sure you've noticed but Ukraine language preservation has vastly increased since the war. Streaming services, such as iirc Netflix, have begun to include Ukraine language options and subtitles.
    This pro-Ukraine sentiment (which controversial opinion: seems forced to me, people who have and had no clue about Ukraine suddenly dedicating their lives to it) has given Ukraine a massive opportunity. Money has been aided to Ukraine, that will help with pro-Ukraine education, and many people have started trying to learn Ukrainian.
    In the best possible scenario after the war, Ukraine (although possibly also devastated from the war) will have an enriched education, and with so many countries to aid would improve quickly, and hopefully a language renaissance. Due to so many people suddenly now knowing about Ukraine, tourism will increase as well.
    I wish the best for Ukraine (and Belarus too for that matter), with enriched history and a solidly stable language, no longer under Russian influence with few native Ukraine speakers.
    However with the good comes a bad: Russians are just normal people, like you and me - they don't necessarily want the war - and surprisingly few are actually hostile to Ukrainians (I've seen Russians and Ukrainians interact, and it's honestly so sweet, as if their countries haven't ever been against one another). Sadly, because of some guy (Putin or whoever thought the war was a good idea) above charging the country against Ukraine, without asking what the Russian public want, many Russians (innocent of the conflict, no hate towards Ukraine) have gotten antagonised and hated across the Internet.
    I am Bulgarian and have used my dad's YT account before (he has his name, which is Bulgarian ie: Slavic, as his username) to write comments. On a video unrelated to the war, I made a comment, unrelated to the war, and guess what some guy replied: they literally saw a Slavic name that looked "Russian" to them and literally damn replied to my comment "idk if you're Russian, your name looks Russian, but please stop the war". First of, he saw a Slavic name and instantly thought Russian no thought of consequence whatsoever. Second, like wtf do you expect me to do- go knock on Putin's door, saying "Hey stop the war pls, you're killing people" -"oh you're right, I'm sorry, okay I'll stop", like wtf.

  • @SomasAcademy
    @SomasAcademy Před 2 lety

    Omg, just realized I wasn't subbed to this channel on my current account! Fixed that now.

  • @gamerheld2481
    @gamerheld2481 Před 2 lety

    Ukraine is in the Schengen area?! How could I miss that?

  • @MsCarfire
    @MsCarfire Před 2 lety

    Just let hm talk👍

  • @jalencampbell8807
    @jalencampbell8807 Před 2 lety +1

    No war Please! 🇺🇦

  • @mr.adamsworld5598
    @mr.adamsworld5598 Před 2 lety

    Bro every single time you upload I just yell in celebration

  • @treasureseeker358
    @treasureseeker358 Před rokem +1

    16:37
    18.3.2023
    ICC launches an arrest warrant against Putin for the mass deportation of Ukrainian children.

  • @wellingtonharris3293
    @wellingtonharris3293 Před 2 lety

    4:32
    Is rumored that the main reason why he did this was so that he could drink alcohol

  • @ironiceire
    @ironiceire Před 9 měsíci

    9:48 so this is how John K. was a Ukrainian descendent, I’d say Ukraine isn’t too pleased to have John associated with them tho, for obvious reasons. Would this also be the reason why Ren seems to have a slight Slavic accent?

  • @OskarW57
    @OskarW57 Před 2 měsíci

    I feel like the Polish Ukrainian and the Polish-Soviet wars should have been discussed

  • @user-wv1uj8zm6q
    @user-wv1uj8zm6q Před rokem +3

    Very good 👍
    Слава Украине 🇺🇦

  • @__xid__
    @__xid__ Před 2 lety +1

    I wrote a huge comment with a lot of examples and things to look out for about Ukranian war, because fakes are mentioned in this video. I think that author's work is really great, i love his other videos, and i tried to show the other side. But it's been deleted by google auto-censorship in seconds. I tried to post it for a few times - deleted in seconds. There's no point to discuss anything on a platform with too much censorship.
    Hope this comment won't be deleted =)

    • @SubcribeMinecraftNOW
      @SubcribeMinecraftNOW Před rokem

      It's probably because you're posting links to other websites than youtube. Those get auto-removed

  • @thebruhemojiorjoji8843

    12:09 you pointed at Turkmenistan not uzbekistan

  • @ThomasOneill-ih1ju
    @ThomasOneill-ih1ju Před 9 měsíci

    🤔

  • @iron545
    @iron545 Před 21 dnem

    These days it seems there are more and more pro russia people, especially in places of great influence and, somehow, on both ends of the political spectrum.
    Its nice to revisit these videos and remember there are still some compssionate people out there.

  • @raimondsstrelcs995
    @raimondsstrelcs995 Před rokem

    14.10 he fled the contry and then they woted him out. the order is importent

  • @boyboilNEO9055
    @boyboilNEO9055 Před 2 lety +2

    Hello

  • @zawiszaczarny7876
    @zawiszaczarny7876 Před 2 lety +10

    Very oversymplified. "Polish opression" came from the cossac's raids against Ottoman empire. The Polish Crown that signed with Ottomans a pact to stop those raids was trying to enlist them into the army to keep them under discipline and stop the slaughter. Ofcourse the myths of opression is what we hear today becouse of the rebellions history was later mostly written by kreml that aim was to keep this land as faithful as possible. The fact is leading Cossacs was a polish nobleman while fighting against the rebellion was an Ukrainian magnate. There ofcourse was opression but not between Poles towards Cossacs(this is modern view of nationalism non existing back than) but more by magnates and other wealthy multiethnical elites towards poor pepole. You also skipped Polish Ukrainian alliance when we fought soviets together in 1920.
    History you see is not so one sided and simple as you present my friend.

    • @danylorusynskyi
      @danylorusynskyi Před 2 měsíci

      І що за цей союз 1920 українцям довелось заплатити західними землями України на користь Польщі, а Польща ж у 1921 уклала Ризький мир із совєтами за спиною в УНР. Dziękujemy bardzo za to

  • @erichayes8445
    @erichayes8445 Před 2 lety

    YO YOU MENTIONED MAKHNO

  • @stekra3159
    @stekra3159 Před 2 lety +1

    I man Austria is only Idepndent for 73 years and we have bild a national identy out of not being German. Whlie ther is more history behind Austria modern Austria is a very jung nation. Same is true for Ukraine today

  • @adriacortesabad8055
    @adriacortesabad8055 Před 2 lety

    VIDEO ABOUT THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR!!! 🇪🇸🇪🇸🇪🇸

  • @dianasorbara2136
    @dianasorbara2136 Před 2 lety +1

    #ProjectUkraine #Ukraine #IStandWithUkraine #

  • @jonahgrund8016
    @jonahgrund8016 Před 2 lety

    I am going to use this video for a project i am doing on the Russia Ukraine war thank you

  • @Silver_Prussian
    @Silver_Prussian Před rokem +3

    Meanwhile the university of Otawa with their study on how ukraine as an identity appeared in the 19th centuary are like: ok i guess our research doesnt mean anything

  • @Supergforce777
    @Supergforce777 Před 2 lety

    12:20 no free French army at the German surrender? I’m sure no one will be upset by this

    • @louiewood7689
      @louiewood7689 Před 2 lety +1

      Cos the free french were basically proped up by the major powers. Why not include Brazil Canada Australia. I think it makes sense to say that their were 4 major powers at play in the European war after 44

  • @nonameking4874
    @nonameking4874 Před 2 lety

    10:43 Are you kidding me? He did what?? He's just as bad as Honkler.

  • @AllyStrikesBack
    @AllyStrikesBack Před 2 lety +6

    "If Russia stops fighting there will be no war, if Ukraine stops fighting there will be no Ukraine"
    Protester.

  • @roysobak1421
    @roysobak1421 Před 2 lety +2

    1. Ukraine word - Not from borderlands. It means land/country. In Ukraina there is word Kraina - literally translates as country. You can say it's from word Kraj - translating like edge/border. I heard this a lot and It's true. But this word also translates as land. Like in Poland - Armia Krajowa. It's not a border army, it's home army. So, historians around the world, stop saying this nonsense.
    Bandera - never pledged to work with the nazis, he and his organization was acknowledged as freedom fighters in Nurnberg. Many soldiers did serve in wehrmacht and it was encouraged by OUN, not because they pledged or something else, but for military training. Oath of OUN-UPA was documented and it consisted only with pledges to fight for free Ukraine.

    • @user-mi7cm4hz6x
      @user-mi7cm4hz6x Před rokem +1

      Вот что пишет Грушевский по поводу первого употребления слова «оукраина» в летописи (под 1187 г., применительно к Переяславщине): «Як бачимо, цїла Переяславщина була властиво тільки пограничною маркою, оборонною границею руської кольонїзації з степом. Ся її роля була причиною, що до неї в наших джерелах було в перше приложене славне пізнїйше імя „України” )

    • @roysobak1421
      @roysobak1421 Před rokem

      @@user-mi7cm4hz6x Сльішал про "одно слово, разньіе значения"? Край стола єто не тоже самое что и край родной к примеру. В контексте Руси, разноплеменного образования, єто могло иметь значение пограничья. В контексте же народа и независимого государства данное значение смьісла не имеет. Цитируешь Грушевского, цитируй и других историков что считают иначе ведь консенсуса в єтом вопросе нет.