Berry wrote and played the piano on this one: every member of REM was totally integral to their sound. A true band in every sense. I can still remember the very first time I heard Radio Free Europe - love at first listen.
i'm getting chills. i was so so lucky to see them in 1986. fables tour. it was astounding. a religious thing without the pulpit. thank you r.e.m. for inspiring my whole life.
Totally - saw them on the Little America tour, then the Reconstruction and Paegent tours - I ate, slept and breathed this band for about 4 years... then by Document the frat boys started to show up at their shows and it felt like genie was out of the box.
In the pantheon of rock drummers/songwriters, he's right up there at the apex with Henley, Ullrich, and Peart (I'm sure I'm forgetting at least one big name).
@@ClueSign No he's not, they all are. I LOVE Millsy, don't get me wrong, but this band isn't REM without Buck, Berry and Stipe. I realize musically, Berry was maybe "more replacable", but he did a lot behind the scenes in writing and arranging. In short, REM does not exist without all 4 of those guys.
I f the world could listen to these guy now in 2018, we would see and hear that music is the earth's spoken language. REM you guys made my life what it is today..............greatest live album ever!
i remember downloading ever REM song i could find on kazaa back in the 90s and finding a live version of this song which became my favorite REM song. this video is super close to that version. in the version i had from kazaa when he sings "pull your dress on" there's a guy in the background that yells "YYYYEEEEEAAAAH." only difference in the versions but still memorable to me. love it.
As I am from Massachusetts i wish I was there but in 84 I was only 4 and was a little late to the rem party kinda herd of them in the early 90,s but really started to get into them in the early 2,000 and started going through there back catalog and fell in love with them and luckily for me got to see them 3 times 03 04 and 08 before they called it a day also saw Peter buck play in a small club in Massachusetts in 2019 and he came out after the show and i got to meet him that was pretty cool as from 2001 when I started to pay attention to present day r.e.m. is my favorite band
I grew up with them and saw them 6 X in uni. I think they said that when they heard this song they realized they were good. Reminds me of my college girlfriend and all is good
It was revealed this was written in an iconic alternative music clubs parking lot. REM in their van were watched playing football supposedly. City gardens ♥
I have a hard time believing that explanation. It's a beautiful song, but loaded! For me... it sounds like they're involved in an Illuminati ritual. "11 GALLOWS on your sleeve". Standing to soon. 12 bloodline families. 1 group GETS to go. Somebody is in charge of them. Put your dress on...We GET to leave. Somebody had their dress off for a reason. Stay real close. (He's protecting someone). Notice how Michael nods solemnly and raises his hand as if to say he gets no choice. They are laying it out for you here. They get to leave because no one was a sacrifice. Who was sacrificed prior?? MANY- Kurt Cobain, River Phoenix to name a few...list is long. Hollywood is a dark place. REM gives you plenty hints in their lyrics and music.
Was sorry to hear that Peter Holsapple (on piano here) had a falling out with REM over writing credits for songs on Green. Supposedly it's covered in the follow up to It Crawled From The South. I have a library card and I gotta use it here.
I think he's raising his musical stand high to signify "standing too soon...shoulders high in the room" Bring an ominous quality to how that feels.... Painting the picture.
Possible mis-transposition: I think at the end he says standing to sooth shoulders... He keeps that lyric to himself until the very end, and it explains "heaven assumes shoulders..."
Put your hair back, we get to leave Eleven gallows on your sleeve Shallow figured winner's paid Eleven shadows way out of place Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Pull your dress on and stay real close Who might leave you where I left off? A perfect circle of acquaintances and friends Drink another, coin a phrase Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room Try to win and suit your needs Speak out sometimes but try to win Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
This is from, "Tour Film" back in 88/89. Your post is of great quality!!! At the end (3:38) I think he says, "...standing to serve." ...but I could be wrong.
Peter's confusing the hell out of me. He's playing with a capo, which he almost never does, but even though it's on the second fret he's still playing in the correct key. What gives? Is his 12-string tuned a whole step down to D?
@@jimbailey5681 I could see that, but capo 2 doesn't really work for F chords. Do you think his guitar is tuned down? Watching his chord shapes, I feel like that has to be the case. Regardless I don't see why Peter felt the need to do that, he played 12 strings throughout the 80's and had .13 guage strings, so I wonder what compelled him to switch things up for this.
I think he was using Peter Holsapple's 12-string, which I believe was tuned down. I guess since it's such a pain to retune a 12-string, the easiest route was to use a capo. I've not seen 'Tourfilm' in years, but I do remember seeing a few shots of Holsapple playing that guitar to supplement Peter's playing. Puzzles me too, but that's all I can figure
Two reasons why I made the comment. 1. Because Stipe himself has spoken about that hair cut and how bad it was and B. because his barber should have been arrested for it. Was never fixated with it when watching Tourfilm all those years ago and obviously it's more about him singing live in concert and being able to front his band which he does here admirably. Bill has such a feeling for this song and that makes sense since he wrote the music for it.
I can't picture him at like Super Cuts just handing them a picture of some punk rock guy and hoping for the best. He had to have directed this haircut. Lol
Probably one of the finest REM songs ever recorded.
So many good ones!
Can't disagree!!! Hard to believe that this was on Murmur!!!
This live performance though doesn’t stand up to the original at all imo
@@hw343434 This live performance is awesome. Not at all sure what they should have done.
agreed.... so beautiful
I listened this song when I was 17
I'm 43 today and I still listening it with the same emotion
Berry wrote and played the piano on this one: every member of REM was totally integral to their sound. A true band in every sense. I can still remember the very first time I heard Radio Free Europe - love at first listen.
Mine too
Is this like one of the greatest songs ever?
what the fuck is the song about
Yes.
YES
Indeed
Is what I was thinking hehehe : -D 👍
i'm getting chills. i was so so lucky to see them in 1986. fables tour. it was astounding. a religious thing without the pulpit. thank you r.e.m. for inspiring my whole life.
Fables is one of my faves, that and Murmur and Document. saw the Document tour. but fables was special.
Totally - saw them on the Little America tour, then the Reconstruction and Paegent tours - I ate, slept and breathed this band for about 4 years... then by Document the frat boys started to show up at their shows and it felt like genie was out of the box.
I misread the top comment at first and thought a new, Beatles-inspired, nickname for the band had been coined: “The Fables Four”
Yes I saw Fables Tour in St. Pete. Great show; such a thrill to see this band… they were enigmatic.
@@peterolson5232 omg you’re SO right! Everything changed when the frat boys sang “Superman!”
Bill Berry is credited by the band in interviews as the main songwriter here. If this is his legacy in music......well it's an amazing one.
Pretty much played everything for the band. They kinda sucked after he left. He wrote a helluva lot of great songs. Find The River for one.
In the pantheon of rock drummers/songwriters, he's right up there at the apex with Henley, Ullrich, and Peart (I'm sure I'm forgetting at least one big name).
bellerophon30 bill ward from Black Sabbath
Ulrich?! Lol
@@iangrubb6470 I didn't know he did Find The River. I guess Everybody Hurts is his masterpiece.
my teenage years still continue with rem
All I can do is hit replay again and again and again. Oh and Peter Buck, sigh... So very easy on the eyes
Mike Mills' bass playing on this tune (as usual) propels the song so magnificently! I also love his singing voice.
He's like their most valuable player.
@@ClueSign No he's not, they all are. I LOVE Millsy, don't get me wrong, but this band isn't REM without Buck, Berry and Stipe. I realize musically, Berry was maybe "more replacable", but he did a lot behind the scenes in writing and arranging. In short, REM does not exist without all 4 of those guys.
What an incredible song
Mike Mills background vocals on this and So. Central Rain really make the songs.
I will not rest until I get enought of this magical music. I can't believe how many years I lived without it
so nice to see the lyrics...i've been singing random words all these years! LOL
For some reason,this song makes me cry every time I hear it. It's an incredible song.
Michael a rare gem❤❤❤
What a precious wee gem this still is. Brilliant version too. Thanks for posting!
My favorite REM song 💖
Perfect song
Perfect band
"Speak out sometimes... and try to win.."
i read your comment just a michael stipe sang the words :)
Synchronicity
I f the world could listen to these guy now in 2018, we would see and hear that music is the earth's spoken language. REM you guys made my life what it is today..............greatest live album ever!
Amen. Me too.
close of side one. i can remember drifting off to sleep as the side played out, like what the song is describing.
Great Song, Great Band, Great to see them young and vibrant in their prime. This is my favorite song from Murmur
Having chills all over my body. This is awesome ❤❤❤
Absolutely beautiful
i remember downloading ever REM song i could find on kazaa back in the 90s and finding a live version of this song which became my favorite REM song. this video is super close to that version. in the version i had from kazaa when he sings "pull your dress on" there's a guy in the background that yells "YYYYEEEEEAAAAH." only difference in the versions but still memorable to me. love it.
FUNNY..NOT the song for that! ...But tempting...🤣
I got to see REM in the mid '90s, they were just fabulous~
seeing them play colleges in Massachusetts and Rhode Island back in 1984 was everything to me
As I am from Massachusetts i wish I was there but in 84 I was only 4 and was a little late to the rem party kinda herd of them in the early 90,s but really started to get into them in the early 2,000 and started going through there back catalog and fell in love with them and luckily for me got to see them 3 times 03 04 and 08 before they called it a day also saw Peter buck play in a small club in Massachusetts in 2019 and he came out after the show and i got to meet him that was pretty cool as from 2001 when I started to pay attention to present day r.e.m. is my favorite band
Normally u may say this persons genius but band were genius : -D
Michael's got hair! Good years.
Uma das mais lindas canções de todos os tempos. Viva o REM!!!!
9 straight exceptional albums (including Chronic Town). 9. Unparalleled. The best band there ever was.
the first 6 albums were great...then they started to suck
@@JohnDoe-sx2zk the quality went when the hair went in my view
Too good. Love Perfect Circle.
Viva R.E.M, Michael Stype, Peter Buck, David Byrne et al always. x
You forgot Marc Boland. What the hell?
I grew up with them and saw them 6 X in uni. I think they said that when they heard this song they realized they were good. Reminds me of my college girlfriend and all is good
Genius, that's all that can be said
The world needs more rem 💗
One all the best songs🤘🤘🤘
Brings back those memories of youth.
It was revealed this was written in an iconic alternative music clubs parking lot. REM in their van were watched playing football supposedly. City gardens ♥
I have a hard time believing that explanation. It's a beautiful song, but loaded! For me... it sounds like they're involved in an Illuminati ritual. "11 GALLOWS on your sleeve". Standing to soon. 12 bloodline families. 1 group GETS to go. Somebody is in charge of them. Put your dress on...We GET to leave. Somebody had their dress off for a reason. Stay real close. (He's protecting someone). Notice how Michael nods solemnly and raises his hand as if to say he gets no choice. They are laying it out for you here. They get to leave because no one was a sacrifice. Who was sacrificed prior?? MANY- Kurt Cobain, River Phoenix to name a few...list is long. Hollywood is a dark place. REM gives you plenty hints in their lyrics and music.
Best American band
Ouvi o album murmur no spotify, o primeiro disco do REM,excelente!
I heard it when it was first released, and totally agree, excellent!!!!
Astonishingly beautiful, this never fails to move me.
Love this song so much!!!😘😘😘😘
I saw them at Midway stadium in st. Paul, Minnesota. Awesome!
Was sorry to hear that Peter Holsapple (on piano here) had a falling out with REM over writing credits for songs on Green. Supposedly it's covered in the follow up to It Crawled From The South. I have a library card and I gotta use it here.
Simply sublime! What a fantastic post, i feel privileged! Thank you so very much! : )
Can't figure out what. The sighn he's holding but this song gives me goosebumps perfect micheal stipe
I think he's raising his musical stand high to signify "standing too soon...shoulders high in the room" Bring an ominous quality to how that feels.... Painting the picture.
just amazing, best REM song IMO
Such magical song.
for me the best thing on Tourfilm. magic.
My favorite from Murmur
absolutely beautiful!!!!
Possible mis-transposition: I think at the end he says standing to sooth shoulders... He keeps that lyric to himself until the very end, and it explains "heaven assumes shoulders..."
Put your hair back, we get to leave
Eleven gallows on your sleeve
Shallow figured winner's paid
Eleven shadows way out of place
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Pull your dress on and stay real close
Who might leave you where I left off?
A perfect circle of acquaintances and friends
Drink another, coin a phrase
Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room
Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room
Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room
Try to win and suit your needs
Speak out sometimes but try to win
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room
beautiful.
george shackleford h
Excelent!!
This is from, "Tour Film" back in 88/89. Your post is of great quality!!!
At the end (3:38) I think he says, "...standing to serve." ...but I could be wrong.
*it's still a more coherent lyric than 'Stairway to Heaven'*
🤣🤣
A Perfect Song. 🔵
Geniali, REM MERAVIGLIOSAMENTEUNICI ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
im crying again :)
Me too! I don’t know what it is about this song. It kinda doesn’t make much sense but I think it’s more of a feeling that is evokes
Lindíssima.
I love REM.😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
Classic REM tune
Whoah.
THANKS.
@TheWorldinProgress Greensboro NC 1989. I was there.
this must have been the year I was born. pawsibly a moment.
Just perfect
Thanks for posting! Really nice video!
what a song... it could be about Donald.
brilliance
So love!
Increíble rem at their best
Perfect....Circle
argentina 2022!
"Heaven Assumed Shoulders High in A Room".......
Por Siempre. R.E.M....!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bill Berry wrote this one
Peter's confusing the hell out of me. He's playing with a capo, which he almost never does, but even though it's on the second fret he's still playing in the correct key. What gives? Is his 12-string tuned a whole step down to D?
He wanted to play open position chords. The capo made that easier
@@jimbailey5681 I could see that, but capo 2 doesn't really work for F chords. Do you think his guitar is tuned down? Watching his chord shapes, I feel like that has to be the case. Regardless I don't see why Peter felt the need to do that, he played 12 strings throughout the 80's and had .13 guage strings, so I wonder what compelled him to switch things up for this.
I think he was using Peter Holsapple's 12-string, which I believe was tuned down. I guess since it's such a pain to retune a 12-string, the easiest route was to use a capo. I've not seen 'Tourfilm' in years, but I do remember seeing a few shots of Holsapple playing that guitar to supplement Peter's playing. Puzzles me too, but that's all I can figure
Jim Bailey there we go! Peter very sparingly changed tuning, so it makes sense it was Holsapple's. Thanks for clearing that up!
Ya' rally!!?
Standing Too Soon
Se eu cantasse tão bem como o Michael stipe provavelmente eu não seria vagabundo kkkkk
micheal you have ruined my life :)
hehehehe sonzera
❤️✨✨✨
The same as the audio. HOW COULD THEY DO THIS :p
Good Taste of Music Club i
Who´s the keyboardist?
Stipe's barber should have been arrested for that haircut.
Two reasons why I made the comment. 1. Because Stipe himself has spoken about that hair cut and how bad it was and B. because his barber should have been arrested for it. Was never fixated with it when watching Tourfilm all those years ago and obviously it's more about him singing live in concert and being able to front his band which he does here admirably. Bill has such a feeling for this song and that makes sense since he wrote the music for it.
I can't picture him at like Super Cuts just handing them a picture of some punk rock guy and hoping for the best. He had to have directed this haircut. Lol
Perfect song.
It’s not any of them had great hairdos. Personally, I love it because it’s different and he is clearly about to lose most of his hair.
about one of stipe's male lovers
Doubling on the snare just doesn't work for me.
Great song, horrible haircut.
beautiful.