September 23, 2012 will be remembered as the date of the terrible Manaslu Disaster, a tragedy that occurred in Nepal in which 11 climbers lost their lives.
While outlining the climbing route on Manaslu, why do you repeatedly show Everest? For example, at 1:40, you talk about the dangers between camps 1 and 2 on Manaslu, but show the Western Cwm of Everest. 1:54 is the North Col on Everest. Again, at 3:21 you talk about Manaslu Camp 2, but show Everest. Why not just show the actual route you're talking about?
“…one of the least challenging summits. However, Manaslu’s notoriously challenging climate is a constant challenge.” Shakespeare level writing here, folks.
If he used a synonym for challenging in the second last word, and said changing instead of challenging climate it would have been a pretty good sentence
I always love your mini docs - well done, comprehensive but concise enough to get it done in less than 15 minutes. Perfect for a new mom like me! Good job!
I don't agree. In certain cases, it may be narcissism, specially in these times when everything is for and because of social media, but humanity itself is where it is thanks to its willing to face and conquer challenges that at some point looked impossible. We wouldn't have thrived if our ancestors hadn't pushed the limits at certain point in history
i don’t know how people could be comfortable climbing a mountain knowing people have died doing that exact trip, i know i wouldn’t be comfortable walking over peoples corpses buried beneath the snow
It does look like the Western Cwm doesn’t it. The image fades away too soon for me to see though. Edit. At 1.42.6 I made out t(E words CAMP 4 SOUTH COL 8000 metres. So well spotted Mr.F.Exception
@@fatalexception1269 yeah I sort of caught that which got me interested as it’s such a famous ridge line isn’t it. But then I thought that lots of mountains have similar ridge lines…that’s gravity for you! So I had to check. I’m trying to find Llotse north east climbs on CZcams. It’s a massive wall from what I can find.
@@v-2010 Exactly, where do you draw the line. I think you need to use common sense. If you want to climb the most dangerous mountain in the world, I don't think other people should put themself in danger to rescue you. If you go fishing like most people, you won't get hurt. If you go fishing on a boat in africa, in the middle of great white sharks, why should anyone come rescue you? Just because you like the adrenaline of great white sharks, doesn't mean someone else has to give up their life to come help you? And I'm against fireworks, because I have dogs. But every year, the hospitals get an overload of work on newyears eve, just because someone wanted to look cool and shoot fireworks while holding it instead of putting it on the ground. Why do we need people like this? They don't add anything useful to society.
Hey, would be nice is you could pronounce climbers properly. I mean it's the most important word in this genre. It's not clime-bers. The B is silent. Just saying.
what is wrong with you? saying that to someone who doesnt have english as their primary language is just rude. find another channel to watch if this annoys you.
WHY SO SHOCKED? YES PEOPLE ARE LEFT, BUT ONLY WHEN TO RESCUE THEM WOULD PUT OTHERS IN DANGER, PLUS THE FACT IF THEY CANT STAND AND WALK TO HELP THEMSELVES, IT'S NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO BRING SOMEONE DOWN CARRYING THEM. MOST CLIMBERS KNOW THIS AND HAVE TALKED ABOUT IT BEFORE CLIMBING.!
While outlining the climbing route on Manaslu, why do you repeatedly show Everest? For example, at 1:40, you talk about the dangers between camps 1 and 2 on Manaslu, but show the Western Cwm of Everest. 1:54 is the North Col on Everest. Again, at 3:21 you talk about Manaslu Camp 2, but show Everest. Why not just show the actual route you're talking about?
I met a guy who told me he climb Everest, l told him I was on my 14th pint of Guinness, he was well impressed.
“…one of the least challenging summits. However, Manaslu’s notoriously challenging climate is a constant challenge.”
Shakespeare level writing here, folks.
LOL! Yeah he really needs to read his scripts before reading them. Wait....
If he used a synonym for challenging in the second last word, and said changing instead of challenging climate it would have been a pretty good sentence
Summit and climate aren't the same, though.. so you misunderstood lol
@@user-us9xg3tw2x I’m more concerned about their use of the word “challenge” tbh
I always love your mini docs - well done, comprehensive but concise enough to get it done in less than 15 minutes. Perfect for a new mom like me! Good job!
0:30 challenge, challenge, challenge
Wow I didn’t realize how close the camps are together. Some are only 500 meters apart. I was expecting them to be miles apart
I’m so sick of these amateur wannabe documentaries. It’s just someone reading over the top of obviously unrelated stock footage
Reminds me of the sick amateurs, wanting to scale Himalayan peaks
Oh calm down, it’s still a fine video, needs some refining, sure, but why not watch something else if you’re sick of these?
Those pilots are incredibly skilled.
This was well done. I’m surprised you don’t have 1000x more subscribers. I’m one now.
Your anime-like live action depiction of death is interesting and provocative.
Interesting video.
Sometimes I wonder why humans put themselves at such risk and discomfort just for a view. But hey, maybe I'm not completely human..
They are narcissists, obsessed with social validation and novelty
It's not a view. It's putting yourself somewhere or in a situation where you actually feel something great. Society is numbing us to death.
Well worth the risk
Because it's there!
I don't agree. In certain cases, it may be narcissism, specially in these times when everything is for and because of social media, but humanity itself is where it is thanks to its willing to face and conquer challenges that at some point looked impossible. We wouldn't have thrived if our ancestors hadn't pushed the limits at certain point in history
Same time next year?
Yes, challenges are challenging.
Good vid 👏
Fantastic coverage of this tragedy.
Honestly where else was the snow going to go there in a divot in the mountain
Not in a million years I'd go there..
💁♂️ I would need a piss bag and it would be frozen. 🤦♂️🤣🤣🤣
i don’t know how people could be comfortable climbing a mountain knowing people have died doing that exact trip, i know i wouldn’t be comfortable walking over peoples corpses buried beneath the snow
People have died crossing many sidewalks you also walked on, should you never cross the road again because of it?
Note to self.. keep my fat as off the snowy mountains
1:35. Mt. Everest?
It does look like the Western Cwm doesn’t it. The image fades away too soon for me to see though.
Edit. At 1.42.6 I made out t(E words CAMP 4 SOUTH COL 8000 metres. So well spotted Mr.F.Exception
And maybe 50% of the images of the whole video are not from Manaslu either. But I’m not moaning about a CZcams upload. The more the merrier.
@@jamisbillson4872 It was actually as the image zoomed out and i recognised the distinctive north ridge of the mountain that gave it away for me.
@@fatalexception1269 yeah I sort of caught that which got me interested as it’s such a famous ridge line isn’t it. But then I thought that lots of mountains have similar ridge lines…that’s gravity for you! So I had to check. I’m trying to find Llotse north east climbs on CZcams. It’s a massive wall from what I can find.
I still don't get how they died. If the avalanche buried them then how were they on top?
Probably tried running out of their tents in the frenzy or the tents were broken open
Why are you trying to pass off Everest maps as Manaslu? Did the Khumbu icefall move there?
2:30 why is the ground moving up and down so much???
These people went up there by themself, I don't understand why other people need to come help them with helicopters.
Don't do something stupid.
@@v-2010 Exactly, where do you draw the line. I think you need to use common sense.
If you want to climb the most dangerous mountain in the world, I don't think other people should put themself in danger to rescue you. If you go fishing like most people, you won't get hurt. If you go fishing on a boat in africa, in the middle of great white sharks, why should anyone come rescue you? Just because you like the adrenaline of great white sharks, doesn't mean someone else has to give up their life to come help you? And I'm against fireworks, because I have dogs. But every year, the hospitals get an overload of work on newyears eve, just because someone wanted to look cool and shoot fireworks while holding it instead of putting it on the ground. Why do we need people like this? They don't add anything useful to society.
I agree they should help but whats with those examples xd
Yet another climbing disaster channel that thinks "crevice" and "crevasse" mean the same thing... THEY DONT
Depends on the context, being that a crevasse is a deep glacial crevice.
@@elgentleman6259Yes. And in this context he meant "crevasse" not crevice
Half these clips arent even of Manaslu. You also incorrectly show camps at wrong elevations. #clickbait
there are clips of other mountains in most of these videos i watch. it's the story that counts
AI🤮
I don’t see the point of climbing. take a helicopter and go to the gym for a workout
You lost me at "global warming"...
Thank you!!!
Hey, would be nice is you could pronounce climbers properly. I mean it's the most important word in this genre. It's not clime-bers. The B is silent. Just saying.
what is wrong with you? saying that to someone who doesnt have english as their primary language is just rude. find another channel to watch if this annoys you.
@RustyTonesJr hahahaha how stupid you can be dude u made my day kiddo
I’m better at camp 15……9,000 miles away, home!!! No thank you that shit is not for me.
I’m shocked that anyone helped! The summit is waiting.
WHY SO SHOCKED? YES PEOPLE ARE LEFT, BUT ONLY WHEN TO RESCUE THEM WOULD PUT OTHERS IN DANGER, PLUS THE FACT IF THEY CANT STAND AND WALK TO HELP THEMSELVES, IT'S NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO BRING SOMEONE DOWN CARRYING THEM. MOST CLIMBERS KNOW THIS AND HAVE TALKED ABOUT IT BEFORE CLIMBING.!
RIP HILARIE NELSON
What about the others
@@George_Kush No one else died dipshit