A Sword That Swings You | Because Science Footnotes
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 04. 2018
- Grab your new Because Science merch here: shop.nerdist.com/collections/...
Kyle takes a swing at Monster Sword physics, responds to your comments, and more!
Subscribe for more Because Science: bit.ly/BecSciSub
More science: nerdist.com/topic/science-tech/
Watch more Because Science: nerdi.st/BecSci
Follow Because Science on:
Facebook / becausescience
Twitter / becausescience
Instagram / becausescience
Follow Kyle Hill: / sci_phile
Follow us on FB: / becausescience
Follow us on Twitter: / becausescience
Follow us on Instagram: / becausescience
Follow Nerdist: / nerdist - Věda a technologie
Thanks for watching! Let me know how’d you like me to release some bloopers that are incredibly embarrassing. ALSO, that dinosaur puke figure is just a scientist’s estimation - there are no recording puke fossils indicating that this happened. - KH
Because Science Hey mention one of my comments from the Thanos throwing a moon in this video. You were almost invested in it.
Because Science bloopers please!
Maybe some bloopers at 500k subscribers and more at 750k and a million.
Bloopers please
Make the bloopers a bonus weekend video. =D
yes PLEASE
I definitely want to see a Kyle blooper reel. Maybe at 350K or 400K subs. Don't want to wait too long.
The Kyle Hill Hissy-Fit Power Hour!
Yes! Make it an hour!
325K sounds good :P
DREWSONofthe43 a monthly half hour blooper reel!
Kermit of Rivia no we don't,if we subed that mean we like him.
Cause of Death: Crushed by Dinosaur Vomit.
A sad, strange little man, may he rest in puke. 😵😷
XD
In soviet Russia, you no swing sword, sword swing you. ;)
wolfrider as a Russian can confirm
I just saw the title of this video and I knew I would find this comment. CZcamsrs, y'all never disappoint me.
that would be a fun method of travel
That intro, about the puke and the cats, I know that struggle.
Bloopers should be at the end of each episode, when the content is fresh. Otherwise its less funny if we see it months later out of context.
Nitrous Oxide this 👆 💯
I mean.... you got a point there but..... you have to consider that there is a lot of bloopers by now so.....
@@Brian_DJ_Mercedes meh montage?
Orrr slap them bad boys throughout the episodes as comic relief. With his enthusiasm and energetic personality it definitely makes for a lighter entertaining experience Inclusive of the theme of the episode and subjects at hand.
*Pulls out Cuban sandwich, ready to hear about swords swinging you*
"I'm gonna talk about vomit killing you and relatable cat information also about them vomiting"
*Puts down sandwich.*
Wonderful, I regrettably picked the sandwich back up and started eating when the actual discussion of swords came up, and then you did it again. You, Kyle, are an ass.
Quote I was having diner. Bad choices were made.
me af
You know who can wield that
Giant sword or Any sword for that matter Effectively . . .?
-Guts
Can we have weekly Because Science Bloopers episodes? :D
yesss where is it
I have doubts that a brachiosaurus could vomit, especially with it head erect. The forces required to achieve this would almost certainly kill the poor animal.
i thought i had heard they didnt have the ability to vomit at all. like, they lacked the gag reflex or some such. but, if it did vomit, wouldnt it just do what cats do? lower its head and neck like they do, until it was at a lower height than its stomach, to counter the effects of needing to push it up so high?
Even with it's head lower than its stomach, a brachiosaur almost certainly couldn't have created enough pressure to push its stomach contents up past the highest point of its esophagus (above it's shoulders), down the length of its neck (with the esophagus' muscular action trying to push the food back down to the stomach), and finally out its mouth.
Perhaps. But, thinking again about how cats puke, usually scooching as flat on the ground as they can, it wouldn't be unreasonable to imagine a brachiosaur might kneel on its front two legs, keeping its back side at a higher level to accomodate the process if it had to. Essentially, the vomit would... flow out rather than shoot out. Enjoy your lunch everyone!
Incidentally, I think bipeds are the only creatures that 'shoot' out their vomit. Cats and dogs just bring it to their mouth and let it fall to the ground. So I think a brachio would be just fine. Tyrannos, alos etc might have a harder time.
PS, Ngk, ngk, ngk... sounds like a good techno track... psychedelic puke... ok, I'm out
A brachiosaurus probably couldn't manage putting its hips above its shoulders. One needs to keep in mind the size of these animals and the tremendous stresses their bodies already deal with to manage such a large mass at 1g. There are anatomical limitations for megafauna, which smaller creatures don't have to deal with (e.g. square-cube law).
I cant believe this is an actual conversation
In case of Time Travel, thanks for the info about dinosaurs!
“Who needs to be put on the tile” 🤣 so true!
Please do a monthly
Blooper Compilation .
Featuring bloopers from that month episodes .
I'm pretty sure you're sitting on a gold mine :)
With funny and creative editing the sky's the limit !
Also if you want a practical demonstration of the physics of swinging huge swords, check out CZcamsr michaelcthulhu , he makes swords that while huge don’t even compare to monster hunter weapons and watch him try to swing them. What Kyle is explains here can be seen, Michael can hold the sword upright, but when he attempts to swing it, it becomes very apparent how the mass overcomes Michaels strength.
Exactly. I'm pretty sure he really messed up his back doing so as well? -- KH
I believe so, there was a period where he was not making videos because of that. Great work as ever Kyle.
“If you’re perfectly RIDGED”
LOL I liked the way he paused and made that face.
Omg that intro “who needs to be put on the tile(/not carpet)” is my life.
More Because Science Bloopers!
Thor wants us to be perfectly rigid. 😏
Peter Quil wishes he was perfectly rigid lol poor Starlord. no spoilers please
Javierm0n0 waaaaaay ahead of you buddy
Hey Kyle, long time watcher. I subscribed a few days ago as recently I've been made aware how much it helps awesome CZcamsrs. I have to say, you/your content/your delivery rock. There's no reason to get frustrated at bloopers. You give some wonderful advice about not needing to 100% everything/all the time. Don't forget it! lol (Would definitely watch the blooper reel.)
"You're already fire dead". Yep, I'd have to agree. Well put.
Dinosaur vomit! Wow!!
...legit the one thing that made me sub is the random facts he says.
That still seems odd.... I mean, can you imagine the throat muscle strength coming back up that distance? They probably lower their heads to make it easy, like... everything else that pukes.
Kara Forrenz i mean id hope so or itd have caused some major problems for the lower down dinos :D
*Hurp*
Karl Singh IMAGINE A BRACHIOSAURUS POOPING ON YOU!
ITS LIKE A SMALL CAR FALLING FROM YOUR ROOFTOP ON TOP OF YOUR HEAD BUT MADE OUT OF PURE SHIT
Because Science Blooper Scenes.
BSBS
2BS
BS^2
👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
Bloopers on a once a month basis! My goodness, I can't imagine how many bloopers these shows must produce!! I love this show, but I very much appreciate the effort it takes to make these quality videos! I would very much appreciate spectating some of the errors!!
The bloopers seem great! I can't wait to see them Kyle!
end-credits bloopers! like the movies.
Please analyze "why is Gamora" and find a scientific answer. I think that's the most troubling scientific question currently.
@ 4:45 - Nice triceps. Someone's been working out!
Kyle's rage in the bloopers would have the same amount of destructive power as Ragnarok in Thor: Ragnarok
You cannot effectively wield a bearing sword. They were ceremonial only which was the point of the comment. The bulkiest wieldable sword maxes out around 7-8 pounds.
Seconded.
Yeah, I was pretty disappointed he didn’t get Mancat's point...
I strongly agree. I have a well balanced 10 lb practice sword I made, and it's ungodly heavy, and it's just way too slow/clumsy to do anything useful with, though with good armor I could see a 8 lb sword being reasonable if well balanced. 15 lb is laughable for a sword I'd say, even for someone at strongman level of strength, it's hard to be strong enough to really need such a weapon.
Regarding the Intro: What does that mean about the sneeze in Jurassic Park? How dangerous was it?
corcorandm It should have ripped her face off and flung her lifeless corpse into the tree.
*credits roll*
awesome video as always very interesting. love to see more bloopers for sure, mondays to cheer me up
One of my favorite Let's Players, Roahm Mythril, compiles his bloopers in Let's Plays from the year, generally no bloopers from Perfect Runs in Mega Man, though, because he already shows those, into a video that he releases every April first.
Going along with the Monster Hunter sword swinging, I've been wondering which other weapons from MHW would be implausible to use in the real world, and if any of them would actually be theoretically effective. I was thinking that the ranged weapons would be more possible, and maybe the sword/shield combo or the dual swords
Kyle, love the show, not gonna lie, as a content creator im glad im not the only one that gets pissed off after having to redo the same damn take over and over because my stupid brain cant talk right for some reason. I legit loled watching them because I've done that so many times... haha
Keep up the good work man,for SCIENCE!
Also please make the bloopers a weekly thing I love it so much
Love the channel, guy!👍👍
bloopers after maybe the 50th episode on the new channel or like 200th episode overall...
As soon as I saw the moon explode when Thanos grabbed it I almost yelled in the theatre “BECAUSE SCIENCE”
PoaS I immediately thought "Oh Kyles gotta do another episode"
Props for scientific accuracy
Spoiler Alert much? You know not everyone can watch the movie on opening day right? Cmon, Kyle! You said you'd ban posts like this one -_-
I’m dead at hearing him say “unconsciously” “who needs to be put on the tile?”
Hi Kyle
One thing id love to point out when your talking about the center of gravity on the monster hunter sword, is even IF we dont know what the 'real' version of the sword is made of, regardless of how its made or whatever, whatever its made of..... is denser then foam and wood, so regardless of what it is, you would need more strength to swing or even pick up the 'real' version
Do a video exploring the physics of the movie 'Ant-man', especially the new trailer where the van expands under the other van and sends it flying, what would happen in real life if that happened?
pretty please with science on top?
Definitely going to do an Ant-Man and The Wasp video. I'm leaning towards the villain, who looks to be a physical manifestation of quantum weirdness... -- KH
I figured you covered the topic pretty thoroughly on the 'quantum tunneling' video, but you can never have too much information
Life on Titan? That would be a strange lifeform. Luqid ethane would be in their blood to act as a solvent(using what is there as a water equivalent) and they would be extremely slow because their metabolism would be affected by the temperature. They would have to eat ice for mainly oxygen and something would still have to fix the nitrogen. So that they can still do complex organic chemistry.
TheAtheistPaladin there’s nitrogen in earths atmosphere and our body’s just filter it out, oh and it’s spelled “Titan”
Of course, there is nitrogen in earth atmosphere. I didn't say there wasn't any. I was talking about nitrogen because it required for complex organic chemistry. On earth, nitrogen enters the life cycle by nitrogen-fixing bacteria. Titan would require a simlar organism in the ecology.
My life goals sync right in with yours, these videos rock ! :)
I would like to to see the bloopers and outtakes at the end of each episode. It would make it perfect to see the chain of events end with crazy bloopers. Maybe as a small side episode if not at the end.
You are assume that some sort of warping is not being used, time could be passing a lot faster for the moon. Thanos would have needed an infinity stone that could change the flow of time for what he was targeting.
If Thanos could have slowed time time locally but dragged the moon down, then he could have taken a lot longer from the Moon's perspective to do so, just inching toward the planet. And from the Ground perspective the Moon would be roaring towards them.
If a compressive force is also applied to the moon, effectively increasing its binding force, then the moon may survive all the to the surface, Though the planet may not. Though how its velocity effects the energy released on impact, when the time flow is different for the planet and the moon, I will leave up to the egg heads to work out.
If the above is true, then you are wrong. If Thanos had nothing to warp time with in that way, then the movie is wrong ;)
Solanumtinkr He did not have the time stone.
Did he have the Tesseract , if so, that might be enough?
The Tesseract was no more at that point.
He did have the space stone housed within as well as every other stone except the time and mind stone.
Then I'd say that what we saw might be possible. The Tesseract might be able to draw power from space, but it probably involves it by warping space, which can mess with time flow. So yeah. Maybe it could work as seen.
Why did I get flat earth videos recommended after this video?
Hey Dude, absolutely love your show! My sugestion for the bloopers that you guys already have: it could be something similar to the double episode you just had, basically, just realese it when its ready... But, I think that it would be awesome to release them as they come, maybe once a month so they are fresh and can be easily linked to the episode were they happened. I know you guys already have a lot of work, but maybe a monthly release its doable; just saying, but I leave it for your consideration. Again, great show man, keep it up!!!
This blooper reel is something we all need in our lives asap!
Hey-o!
I'm actually dying to just those bloopers.
I LOVE THE PHILOSOPHICAL ENDINGS KYLE
How can Thanos snap his fingers wearing a metal gauntlet? There's not enough friction!
I'm a huge fan Kyle! Greetings from Brazil!
Absolutely love bloopers
I want all of the bloopers on an endless loop.
As a long-time cat owner, I can attest to the magical power of the "urgh urgh" sound a cat makes to force you out of a deep sleep.
That cat puke thing is totally true. You're dead to the world and all of a sudden you wide awake hoping your cat isn't on carpet.
We need your bloopers sir, we need bleeps and rage and frustration.
For Science!
7:04...You're killing me😂😂
Loved the existential dialogue from Kyle at the end. Just, wow.
It's what happens when I don't have anything written down -- my mind wanders -- KH
thanks for this episode today. had a pretty crappy day but what you said at the end reminded me it will be ok. thats our smart boy Kyle :).
Because Science bloopers? Weekly? Monthly? I want to see it.
You could release a bloopers highlight video on Saturday every week. Also I love your videos keep it up!
Bloooopers please i love this show
I've done videos using the "writing in mid air" effect (inspired by you!) and yes... I feel your pain... I only did 6 or 7 of them... and there was a LOT of cursing that didn't make the cut. I feel your pain man... I feel your pain. lol
Ty Kyle :-*
Love the intro
KYLE WE NEED THESE BLOOPERS.
Way more outtakes please!! ;)
Need a blooper episode or two (like all SURPRISE LIGHTSABER episodes together, all marvel, etc), but having bloopers at the end for each episode would be cool too
Ahahahaha those bloopers are awesome. So funny. I watched them 4 times lol. What am i speaking Portuguese.
Lmfao I am the exact same way with jolting awake at the cat heaving sound. Far more effective than an alarm clock.
@4:00 - could still have done the water displacement ... just gently apply saran wrap (would still take far less time than all those measurements), do the displacement test, prop preserved and saved a lot of time while yielding far more accurate results
A great way to release bloopers would be to do a supercut of a bunch of them that are all similar like "using the wrong units", "drawing mishaps" and "math mistakes".
KYLE. please. PLEASE. release bloopers. I would PAY to watch those.
I would LOVE to see bloopers of your show. Also, i gave the g vs G correction like 2 episodes ago. Im so salty
Just at end of each clip you release bloopers. That would be great!
there is a dry alternative for working out mass. Wrap your expensive prop in plastic wrap and place in a container with a known volume. Add dry power - flour, sand, rice- until container if full. remove prop and measure how much more dry powder is needed to fill the container. The added powder will give you displacement volume without getting wet.
I don't know the best way to release bloopers.
I just know I really want to see them.
I would like bloopers the way you did it, just quick cuts with a little upbeat music in the background. I could watch those for hours.
Nice footnotes episode Kyle.
Kyle, release the bloopers as a sort of gag reel either every week, every other or monthly. I feel we would all enjoy a video purely made of bloopers and mess ups!
500k would be a good milestone for the bloopers. You'll get there in no time, you're already at 323K. And half a million seems good if you want to release some soon.
Just want to make sure we're not waiting forever if we're going to do it. But 323k in 90 days isn't that bad -- KH
Just release the bloopers in 5 minute episodes... In that few seconds I laughed so hard. "Relatively fragile shit!" "Am I speaking fucking Portuguese" lmfao Damn kyle didn't expect that out of you.
Hi Kyle I thought about this for a funny bloopers intro for you.... If you have seen Bill nye the science guy then that intro would be perfect for you. For example "Kyle Hill the because science guy.... Kyle..!Kyle...!Kyle! With that song playing you can have clips from your bloopers in the background or simply play them after! I love your content and the things that you do for the science community!
350,000 subscribers sounds like s good milestone for bloopers.
We want all of the bloopers all of the time. Just. Give us those. Yes please.
20:10 I tought you were a bout to say may the force be with you
Kyle! Another variable to take into account when considering sauropod vomit is the content of their guts!
Sauropods lacked complicated teeth capable of chewing, and instead had small, peg-like teeth that were used to rip plant matter (leaves and stems in particular) from woody trunks and branches. Brachiosaurus in particular would have had to have dealt with extremely tough conifer trees and would have had very dense plant material in its guts.
That's just part one though.
As sauropods lacked the mechanical advantage of having complicated chewing teeth, their bodies compensated for this by making the animal consume round stones that would then be churned in their gut, mashing the plant material within in order to assist in digestion.
If you were to consider the relative difference in mass from, say, chyme and undigested plant matter to stones, I'd guess it would be likely that you'd be stoned to death and bathed in highly volatile acid as a yummy treat to boot!
you should release your bloopers all the regularly that would be hella funny and could get your channel exposure to different groups
Bloopers were awesome
I just want a gif of Kyle bobbing his throat for the throw up noise
Cant wait to watch!!!
500K is a good milestone for the bloopers
JUST DO IT! the bloopers that is. Please. Thanks.
I was lunching during this episode. Thanks
YES!!! Let's get 500k subscribers and then do a segment, once a week, of bloopers for that weeks episode. That would be facking awesome
19:19 I 100% thought you were going to do a cat gagging noise
an uncut and a supercut version of the bloopers. possibly patreon download of the uncut footage would be great to make memes with. ;)
I would do anything to see a blooper take on your show. BTW, you rock in the way you explain things. Personally, I wish i could do the same, but you have one thing I don't....sources and backing.
Not sure if whatever you made the prop out of has a consistent density but if it does you could test it's density by making a small sample and use the Archimedes Method to work it out. Then multiply the prop's weight by the density of steel and divide it by the density of prop.
I personally think for bloopers it would be awesome to maybe start releasing them on a milestone but then make it like a monthly highlight reel