Israeli government rift on future of Gaza turning into a 'colossal game of chicken', analyst says
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- A growing rift within the Israeli government over the governance of Gaza after the war has become a 'colossal game of chicken' between rival factions who are each waiting for the other to make a mistake, according to Israeli political commentator Dr Ori Goldberg. He spoke with France 24's Mark Owen and said that Israelis have trouble articulating a critique of Netanyahu's management of the war and that as long as the war continues, Netanyahu continues to be safe in power.
#Israel #Gaza #Hamas
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.com/en/
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen
It's time to get rid of Netanyahu anyway you can.
Unfortunately Netanyahu is merely a symptom of the problem, not the problem itself.
Stop the genocide please.
There is no genocide in Gaza. Read the definition.
35,000 deaths .......but at least half of those are Hamas
So it is only 17,000 civilian deaths
@@vinm300 that is completely false 25000 are confirmed to be civilians (not all the bodies are recogniseble). Also kill combatants does not mean is not a genocide, In the Bosnian genocide 70% of the kill were combatants, that is because what determine what is a genocide is the intention of the action, that is why determine genocide intentions is so important.
F...... you. !!!!
Which genocide ????!!!! The one that comes from your people ???!!!! The Arabs ? The Palestinians ???!!!
You don't even know what are you talking about !!!
Is it Even Possible to Overcome the Horrors Palestinians are Experiencing?
How are these Kids going to Regain Trust in Life?
Same kids are wearing machine guns and they’re put in front of armies. I think if you worry about these kids, ensure their parents are behind bars, and teachers are teaching them love for their neighbour and not celebrate when neighbours suffer.
Your numbers don't add up.
@@Z10N4Z1Z LOL coming from Hamas that is a laugh
Hamas numbers do NOT add up
That is why the UN slashed them by half
LOL
the war began from 1948 when the west displaced the Palestinians
1929 hebron & jews lived there too arent they "Palestines" Or Only your "Muslims" Brothers are 2 Face
It began with the Balfour Declaration of 1917, when Britain decided to underwrite Zionism.
@@NoneOfUrBusiness-sk9bm
yes for the jews who live there before 1948 , they have the right to live there.
but displacing the arabs who live there too while importing European jews , thats criminal act
It also began when Israeli settlers started illegally colonizing the West Bank. And when Israel has sabotaged any two state solution, even to the point where Netanyahu supported Hamas over the more moderate and secular coalitions.
@@delos2279I think you need to learn history before commenting
That was a good inside analysis: Israel has never been able to overtake Palestinian liberation and resistance forces.
Great Interview
German Outlets still equate criticizing Israel with antisemitism
Amazing interview. Hello from NYC. Love your channel, great insight and interviews. I’ve been sharing with friends.
With such balls, i would be unable to walk. Thank you sir! We cannot be human by hiding the truth.
With this kind of Truth telling, no wonder Mainstream Media hasn't interviewed this Dr. Goldberg, he'd blow their whole narrative to smithereens 😂
Straight talk. Good job.
The journalist did an amazing analysis
He did not answer what Isreal should do. That's easy.
I don’t comment much but damn that Journalism was great!!
ya
A voice of reason coming out of Israel. There needs to be more like you.
Some of those killed on October 7th were in the military. That doesn’t justify their deaths however it is very important that the news is accurately reported.
Something else to note, all Israeli citizens serve in the army, making all citizens soldiers.
The Palestinians support Hamas to build a Sharia state. This means that they don't accept people who are different from them.
Also, all Israelis (except the Palestinians with Israeli citizenship including Palestinian Jews) are invaders - not civilians.
@@squareinsquare2078all is citizens are not soldiers! Maybe at best about 50-60% of the total population have served in the military. 20% of the Arab population are not allowed. There’s about 12% ultra orthodox, about 50% of women don’t serve in the military. Another Haaretz reports says that only 40% of men and 33%. The exemptions of arab and ultra orthodox citizens is a serious issue since their demographic is the fastest growing due to higher birth rates.
@@chikipu225 The Arabs aren't really citizens of Israel, they are 2nd class, like black people in apartheid South Africa. But even including that, by your numbers, at least 50% of people killed on October 7th were soldiers.
The war started in 1948.
"Mad, bad, and very, very dangerous."
May Allah bless you all. It was an honor taking part in this session with my teachers, Shaykh Abdullah and Shaykh Omar. May Allah accept from them, the Yaqeen team and all of us.
Izrell is out of control!!!
As an American I stand with Palestine. 💪🇵🇸
Evil has a way of unravelling itself... That's why it can NEVER win!!!
00:42 statement about Hamas killing 1200 civilians is factually incorrect. It was 764 civilians (695 of them Israelis) including 36 children and 373 military/security personnel
This is correct.
Yes, the 1,200 civilians lie s often repeated. AS is the 40 babies beheaded BS.
Most "soldiers" killed were not in army duty. They were just of military age. So they were indeed civilians.
@@noamsitbon8151 No, that's completely wrong. Vast majority of those 764 civilians were of combat age.
@@warmlycalculated390 Yes, that is exactly what I said. They were not in army duty. They were simply of army age. If an adult male Palestinian dies, it does not necessarily mean he was part of Hamas. The vast majority of the people who died were not in uniform, they were civilians.
What a Joke. As you can make a deal or negotiate with Hamas Extremists.
The war didn’t began on Oct 7. It began in 1948 when Israel began to steal the land of the natives arabs.
What happened in 1929 hebron then
This man is so full of it, it's unbelievable.
The minister is just trying to safe face and prevent himself from being rated highly in the charges that are coming after this is over.
From ' The States' I'm wondering why the recording of Jared Kushner regarding the value of Coast of Gaza Strip for development of Prestigious Properties.
Correction - Hamas killed just under 1200 Israeli citizens but one third of those were soldiers as Hamas attacked military bases first.
It was 1200 civilians. There were 300 and some soldiers and there were a small number of non Israels.
There was an interview on AJ with an Israeli woman saying the IDF were using tanks to shoot into their homes thinking “the enemy” was in there. They also said IDF fired at some of the festival goers accidentally.
"The latest figure on the number of deaths in the October 7 attacks is 1,139: 695 Israeli civilians, 71 foreign nationals, and 373 security forces. This data was published in December 2023, using social security data. There are additionally five people classed as missing, including four Israelis."
Why did Israeli intelligence allow that concert to go ahead when they were well aware of the pending situation? Why did the IDF open fire on Israeli civilians?
@@thompjackson well I had a silly theory on that. The Israelis living in the area that was attacked are known to be more liberal than the government, and so a lot of them did not have issues with Palestinians. So if the government knew there was a possibility of the attack around that area………..
Just my theory though.
@@humblehummingbird8420Not accidentally.
Egypt is pissed for a serious breech of the Philadelphia Corridor, Erdogan in Turkey broadcast Israel is a hegemonic state that will come after other parts of the Middle East if not stopped, and Netenyahu’s defense minister is against occupying Gaza.
Feels like Netanyahu should really watch his back, someone will come after him personally in the stealth of the night…there is a Brutus in the wings
860+/- civilians please offer the proper facts!
320 millions for aid or oil?!
Aid at first, and then oil and deportation.
I'm really lovin' on this guy, Dr. Ori Goldberg. I love how he just has on a shabby T-shirt, filming in front of his bed, so casual ha. :p
But everything he's saying is so incisive and spot on. Stellar performance.
Unfortuanlty not something you see from other Israeli analysts :(
Fascinating analysis. Thank you.
Dude! Why do you need such a huge desk? You can sit 30 people around that thing.
What did Dr. Frankenstein say?
If settlers go there I do not condemn, in advance, whatever the resistance does to them.
Israel was attacked by Hamas terrorist group, not a resistance movement!
how about 700,000 in the West Bank and East Jerusalem?
@@ryuuguu01 Same opinion. They’re terrorists.
@@joselimjoco3367would an illegal settlement taken by force be considered an attack?
@@joselimjoco3367 100% of Palestinians have the right to resist occupation. That includes Hms, who did nothing on October 7 that hasn’t been established as the terms of engagement by their enemy.
We are Fed up with unconditional US support for Israel....😮😮😮
They are surrounding PALÄSTINA 🇵🇸
Bravo! Thanks!
The Mole was Andrew Vacchs ordnance specialist in the Burke Novels. The Mole personified the "let's light this candle!" IDF mindset.
some country still having a medieval standard moral when it comes to war. Truly a wonderful civilization it is😊
Were they all civilians, I thought they were settlers and military.
Dr Ori Goldberg you are the voice of sanity. It was a great analysis and I wish more such an educated, central oriented approach would be presented in the media. Although the situation is hard we need more people who tell facts without emotions about what is happening, what can be done and what should be done so all that suffering won't repeat itself in the future.
Everything starts in October 7😢
Before that everything in order 😮
The war didn’t start with hamas so stop your colonial propaganda
Ahh really?
@@MariaTjg ahh maybe you missed the part where the whole nation was under an oppressive settler colonial occupation ?
@@Marri12345 no comment 😏
@@MariaTjg
yes really there was no Hamas 20 years ago.
your racism and civilians bombing before 2005 is the reason why ppl chosen Hamas
@@heshaeza are you living in palestina? I'm not so have no comment about that situation.
From tragedy to farce. 5:00 becomes especially ominous.
Imagine u destroyed and conquer a land/ home. Then u argue who is going to be the head of this house. Iam 80's iam still young let me grow
You shouldn't start a war when you didn't have a game plan in place.
The defense minister should only do his duties and let the PM decide on larger matters post war. it seems that foreign powers are undermining Netanyahu and the defense minister is taking orders from them instead of the PM
This is the reality that nethanyu and Israeli citizens has to accept along with USA and the west. Give Palistine their land back and their freedom . Israel has lost both military and the moral war. They will be humiliated on all side
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Resistance is not terrorism
Now the Gaza assault has also brought to light the horrors of the seizure of land and displacement of Palestinians in 1948 to make way for modern Israel in the first place, the world must Never Forget
Some of the hostages are Americans with the matter with FGB
"The world has never been committed to our defense?" Someone should tell Bibi that the United States has provided Israel more than $300 BILLION for its defense and shares some of its most sophisticated weapons systems with Israel.
35,000 deaths .......but at least half of those are Hamas
So it is only 17,000 civilian deaths
the fact that some ppl are ok with the number of civilians casualties being 17000 only instead of 35000 is scary
And only 1200 Israeli civilians not a big deal, so why are they making a big deal about 1200 people that’s nothing
The IDF is renowned for its above-average cases of friendly fire in the field (this is true even without the consideration of their 'Hannibal Directive'). Centuries of military analyses have concluded there to be a direct correlation between friendly fire incidents and troops with heightened levels of fear/anxiety, poor discipline and situational awareness, and a zealous disregard for life. Everyone suffers (themselves included) for the IDF's general ineptitude.
Israel and USA need to see the People of Palistine form a New Government.With a leader.
Free Caledonia and end colonization
the port is what bb showed last September in un, so it serves israeil, not Palestinians.
🙏🙏🙏
When did Iaraelis live in Gaza before?
They always lived there but where disguised as Palestinians
There were a small number of settlements in Gaza that were dismantled by the Sharon government in 2005, and the settlers were forcibly removed back to Israel.
"Israel is a settler colonial
project that is nearing its end,as colonial projects reach their final phase become more brutal and ruthless." - llan Pappe
7:32
this guy needs a bit of pushback. no military achievement? total failure? what? hamas, even if it appears to still be present, is severely damaged. they are desperate. there is an argument for continuing with eliminating hamas. just saying that hamas is not defeated and presenting no evidence is disingenuous. yes, it is horrible, yes, netanhayoo and his extreme members in the govt are fkn insane but that doesn't excuse or tackle hamas.
"completely unable to destroy hamas" pfff what is this guy smoking?
Ive trained with these guys. Extremely overated and even though most were in good shape, most didn't have an athletic bone in their body. Most of my guys were already trained in American Mixed Martial Arts and that Krav Maga stuff wasn't working on us and remember they were frustrated.
no the war begun in 48
Lies war did not begin on 07 October 23
Occupying/settling in Gaza - might as well wait till Nov
If Trump comes in then Gaza is up for grabs
US playing god cop bad cap. Providing weapons to Is real while building a pier to provide food for Gazans
This war like most wars was caused by religious gods - steps back and think about that - humans are fighting over ideology - steps back again outside your usually religious rings and reflects - 🤔🤔🤔💡💡💡
Palestine is not orphan country to do what they want.
bibi dezath sentence creep
O k lest see if Israel atak USA
Israels religious right.....😂😂 thats a contradiction in terms.... religion is dead in israel the 10 commandments have been crumpled up and binned....
He is antisemetic 🤓
The hostages
This isreali gentelmen sounded very sensible and very aware of the real situation in Gaza and incapability of isreali Zionist regime..
May Allah bless you all. It was an honor taking part in this session with my teachers, Shaykh Abdullah and Shaykh Omar. May Allah accept from them, the Yaqeen team and all of us.
May Allah bless you all. It was an honor taking part in this session with my teachers, Shaykh Abdullah and Shaykh Omar. May Allah accept from them, the Yaqeen team and all of us.