European countries recognition of Palestine: too little too late? | UpFront
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 05. 2024
- Marc Lamont Hill discusses the latest move towards recognising Palestinian statehood with analyst Mouin Rabbani.
On May 28th, Norway, Spain, and Ireland will officially recognise Palestine as an independent state, joining the more than 140 other countries that have already done so, in a move they hope will pressure Israel and its allies to find a solution to the war. However, the US and other major Western powers have long opposed unilateral recognition, arguing instead that a two-state solution should come after peace talks.
The announcements have been heavily criticised by Israel, claiming it was “rewarding terrorists”. Meanwhile, Hamas called this new recognition a “turning point”.
Will this mark a significant shift in the West’s position on the conflict? Or is it, as some critics have said, too little, too late?
This week on UpFront, Marc Lamont Hill speaks to Jadaliyya co-editor Mouin Rabbani.
The world must stand with truth.
Exactly,Finish Hamas,eradicate Radical Islam and make a real Country for Palestinians.
What kind of truth everyone knows Muslim has a problems and Islam is the biggest problem because of Islam there is no peace in our world
what truth? your truth?!
@@bycrescentmoon8001world truth
@@bycrescentmoon8001 not mine.. and not your truth
Arrest Netanyahu immediately
for defending his country? right.
Unfortunately that won’t change much since the entire “state” of Israel is filled with psychopaths
@@bycrescentmoon8001please stop the jokes
@bycrescentmoon8001 👍 like it or hate it , It's a Palistians State belongs to Palistine
@@bycrescentmoon8001his country????? His country is Poland not frickin Israel!!!! Get some frickin history lessons. His name is not even Benjamin Netanyahu it’s actually Benjamin millakowski
It feels so good to see Marc Lamont hill working for Al Jazeera
Ireland may create an embassy in ramallah
there’s an election coming…
Brilliant analysis. The expansion of the settlements is proof positive they were ALWAYS negotiating in bad faith. The Americans have never taken concrete action against them.
It is American colony.
It’s because America has an interest in that area.
The Irish Parliament and Senate have already (over a year ago) passed a law banning products made in the occupied territories but the executive won't implement it. What people outside don't realise is that the Irish government (executive part) were initially on Israel's side. It's the reaction of the Irish people to what is happening that is causing them to do what they are doing. If you listen to the speech that the Irish representative made, you will understand what I mean. The Irish people understand the Palestinian people's position because the same methods were used to suppress Nationalist Catholics in Northern Ireland by the British. They used imprisonment without trial, murder of civilians and more importantly misinformation about what was happening was given to the outside world by the BBC, while outside media who went there had to go through the British army and were controlled by it.
Excellent. Very clear, Mr. Rabbani.
Thank you. Knowledgeable discussion
Marc is doing an amazing job!
somehow the algorithm sent this channel to my recommendation list, as far as Marc Hill working for Al Jazeera I support ppl doing what they feel is in their best interests. I don't know about the issues being discussed nor do I feel an interest to find out> I wish the best to all parties involved
At least
TOO LITTLE TOO LATE from WESTERN 🌎❤...
...But
NOY AT ALL from UAE+SAUDIA+QATAR+PAKISTAN😢....If these COUNTRIES would be SERIOUS to SETTLE 🇵🇸❤ CONFLICT ...then 🇮🇱 in NOT LESS THAN 1 DAY would RECOGNIZE..... 🇵🇸 AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE....
But Unfortunately These COUNTRIES LEADERS are BUSY in BUISNESSES😢💔 how to grow their PROPERTIES+ ISLANDS😢
ALLAH G,
Pleaseeeee 🙏 SHOWERS YOURS GREAT BLESSINGS Upon INNOCENT 🇵🇸 who are FIGHTING for their RIGHTS since 1948,
Ameen sum Ameen.
crying now? after all that aggravation? not a good look for you.
toooooo late - oh yes.
They've had a state for a long time this is just recognition basically meaningless.
The solution to resolving the Israeli and Palestinian conflict is First, Israel must immediately stop its arrogance and violence in controlling its territory and comply with all UN resolutions. Second, with the recognition of two countries, namely the state of Israel and the state of Palestine, both countries must be willing to accept the division of their respective territories in accordance with international law under UN supervision. Third, recognition of the territorial division of each country, namely that the territory of the State of Israel constitutes 2/3 of the territory it controls, while the territory of the State of Palestine constitutes the remaining 1/3 of its territory. Included in the territory of the Palestinian state are the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and the Aqsa Mosque area. With a solution to recognize the two countries and divide this region, it is hoped that the conflict in the Middle East will subside and become a peaceful region.
The west does more for gaza then the middle east. and the middle east also does nothing for ukraine. so if you want to blame someone start here ..
The 🇺🇲 reminds me of Nero's Rome; inconsistent rhetoric coupled with violent aggression against anyone who opposes their egocentric, erratic desire for utter dominance.
That's true Mathma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela is no more however Nelson Mandela and Mahatma Gandhi should stand side by side to give Palistine back thier land South Africa did its best because of Ramaposa his wrong doing people made huge remarks, however Palistine has to be a two state nation however the opposition party is for the resources to thier country to bargain poor Palistine 😢😢😢😢
Can someone give me some clarification please. Firstly I stand with the Palestinian people and condemn the atrocities and ruthlessness committed by the IDF, Israeli government and those monsters in human appearance who blocked the road and damaged the humanitarian supplies for the victim of a one sided slaughter in Gaza. But from the perspective of the Palestinian and Arab/muslim world, was the goal to only get recognition for a Palestinian state or literally erase Israel from the map and officially establish the whole region as the land of Palestine and most probably governed by an Islamic ideology ? How does the status quo change ? What was the initial goal for the terrorist attack of Hamas (not freedom fighters sorry) and as a consequence so many children who lost their lives, others will probably live as orphans and cripples ?
Every party has an opinion on the borders of these 2 states. There is just no consensus on the borders. And none of these 2 parties are going to give up Jerusalem. There is only an ideal without a viable solution.
Historical jews lived in Palestine.
CZcams. Golden meir in Palestine.
How could you negotiated one on one for your color? Are you serious? It has to be always a third apart and this is ended whether you believed or not free Palestine from the river to the sea we will never rest until we are free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤🙏✌️🙏✌️🙏🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Now, Palestinian don't have a true leader like Gandhi or Nelson Mandela. Palestinian not united at this moment. If you want a country, you need a leader,
All been arrested by the occupation. Palestinian politicians in occupation prison must be released to lead Palestine.
Nelson Mandela was released from prison to lead South Africa after 27 years.
They do not want a country. They are just a hate group.
Actually there is one. He is in prison in Israel. His name is Marwan Barguti. The Israelis do not want him to speak. He would be the perfect leader for a Palestine State, both for the Palestinians as well as the Jews in Israel.
From the river to sea Palestine will be free
too bad they can’t even practice what they’re preaching these days…in the river…
@@bycrescentmoon8001paid comments
Palestine has to be freed! There is no other option
Israel has given Gaza as state of Palestinian Arab muslim that came from mecca,petra
P ❤
Free Palestine