В Ваджраяне обязательно нужно следовать Учителю.И титул здесь - это не предмет демократических выборов, оценочного скждения и поверхностных позитивных чувств.
NOT LIKE THIS VIDEO AND SHOULD BE SUE AND CRITICIZED FOR PLAGIARISM, PROVOKE ISSUE THAT ALREADY BEEN SOLVED AND CLEAR PEACEFULLY IN KAGYUD AND EVEN BUDDHIS VAJRAYANA COMUNITY I really don't know what to said. This western learn Buddhis but name spiritual guide but selling cheap gossip for earn small money that she just copy paste 😂 from many internet as many her article I checked just copy paste form many western website and just put one on her article AND WITHOUT PUT THE SOURCE, i dare her to show that this is HER ORIGINAL RESEARCH in sadhana or ASKING / GET PERMISSION from website shE COPY 100% .. You all can check just by simple Google and many her website All only just 2023. Some of them just laughing to her that rather share good meditation tips more to cheap teen gossip and just plagiarism 100 % even mantra and even description.. ( have in website in western author doesn't mean they already right baby) but I'm cannot stand the name Chanel of spiritual guide meditation ( IT'S MORE TO NEWS AND GOSSIP IN BUDDHISM AND COLLECTION OF COPY PASTE THEFT PLAGIARISM OF WESTERN BUDDHISM BY SOME GREEDY SMALL MONEY DESPITE NO QUALIFICATIONS OF SCHOLARS IN BUDDHA DHARMA Her just want small cheap money than thinking about the Consequences of the view.. About the scandal as she already published the video do she dare to EVEN ASK TO LIKE AND Subscribe REALLY SHAMELESS.. IF YOU can publish this ASK YOUR AUTHENTIC BUDDHISM GURU IS YOU MADE THE RIGHT THING OR NOT OR YOU JUST PLANTING WRONG VIEW WITH OUT RESEARCH MORE JUST BY VIDEO BY WESTERN AND ASK THE PROPER VAJRAYANA BUDDHISM GURU WITH AUTHENTIC LINEAGE WHATEVER MONASTIC OR LAY PEOPLE NOT JUST GOGGLE AND COPY PASTE DO WE CAN STEALING AND PLAGIARISM COPY PASTE AND SHARE BUDDHA DHARMA VAJRAYANA MANTRA AND VIEW IF NOT RIGHT LIKE IN SADHANA JS THAT MAKING PLANTING SEEDS OF WRONG VIEW AND MISLEADING BUDDHA DHARMA AM I MAKE GOOD MERRIT OR BAD MERRIT. China spy? If you born in tibetan occupied by china and china tibetan and government knowing you you can be automatically became Chinese spy? That old video already been laughed by tibetan and western BUDDHISM scholar , why not YOU SAID H. H AND H. E SAKYA, SOME KAGYU ,NYINGMA LEADER ALSO CHINA SPY AS SOME OF THEM FROM FORM TIBETAN (TAR CHINA) ?? RESEARCH AND UNDERSTANDING THE ISSUE AND MATTER FIRST. LEARN CHINESE , INDIAN AND TIBETAN AND READ AND COMPARE FROM BOTH SIDE IF NOT YOU JUST SHAMELESSLY FOLLOW ING STUPID PEOPLE BUT USING COOL NAME SPIRITUAL GUIDE CHANEL.. IF NOT BECAUSE PITTY FOR YOU AND OTHER THAT REALLY HAVE GOOD INTENTION TO LEARN BUDDHA DHARMA, Especially to People who knows the Truth and Respect KAGYU Sangha and H.H Karma pa and felt sorry for your ignorant copy paste without checking both KAGYU side or inner ring and felt sorry for you cause make easy bad karma so I remind you, hate and dislike me if you like, kinda harsh but you make many mistakes despite promoting meditation and ... ( BUT IF YOU BUDDHISM YOU SHOULD ADMIT YOUR VIDEO, BLOG INSTAGRAM IS LOT PLAGIARISM AND MANY WRONG OPINION BIG AUTHOR THAN IN SADHANA SOURCE. AND WITH BIG HEART CONFESS IT AND ASK THE AUTHOR AND AT LEAST CHECKED WITH YOUR BUDDHISM MASTER WITH AUTHENTIC LINEAGE GURU FIRST, THEN I'M REALLY HOPE YOU CAN BE GOOD MEDIA THAT PROMOTE MEDITATION, BENEFITS TO FOLLOW BUDDHISM, PRACTICE OF THE DEITY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING NOW IS LIKE MIX FOOD WITH POISON OF WRONG VIEW AND NOT UNRESPOSIBLE PERSONAL OPINION AND YOU DON'T KNOW BECAUSE YOU JUST BLINDLY STEALING PLAGIARISM IT BY JUST COPY PASTE SOME YOUR ARTICLE KINDA ROUGH AS THE FLOW KINDA FORCED🙄😟🤭) It's more about your stealing, plagiarism, copy paste without proper really check and study and not asking permission from the author and not putting the source.. You just easily foolish your self. And make fooling and target of people who understand the situation and the truth. I really can't control myself again even in this video.. Use your basic common sense. You thinking thousands monk, H.H Dalai lama, some trulku, Senior elder monk, and Hundred million eyes and ear of Tibetan,East and west student and devote is stupid kind people that just know meditation, study BUDDHISM. Do your understanding is higher than them and do you think they don't get all Blessings of Deity you plagiarism in you article and can not know which one is Non Sense which one is the Truth, which one is just Sensation, how to humane Delivery the Truth on right time??? I'm really praying for my HEART THAT YOU REALLY PRACTICE MEDITATION YOU PROMOTE AND SHARE IN MANY YOUR VIDEO AND BE ADVANCED THAN JUST HAPPY LY SATISFIED IN KNOWLEDGE IN BASIC AND THE BUDDHISM DEITY YOU SHARE ON YOUR ARTICLE WHATEVER TARA KURUKULE EVEN YOUR BASIC BUDDHISM VIDEO AND REALLY HURRY UP QUICKLY SWIFTLY BECAME BUDDHA SO YOU KNOW THE TRUTH AND CAN KNOW MORE HOW TO ACT, HOW TO TALK, HOW TO PUT MIND AND HOW TO CONTEMPLATING, STUDY, EXAMINE, BUDDHA DHARMA TEACHING and PHENOMENON, I WILL PROSTATE TO YOU MANY TIMES.. BUT JUST DO ALL YOU SAID AND SHARE, TEACH US IN YOUR ARTICLE AND VIDEO AND REALIZED IT JUST LIKE GOOD ATHELETE DEDICATED PRACTICE TILL BECAME CHAMPIONS OR HOW A STUDENTS LEARN DELIGENCE, STUDY, RESEARCH, TESTING, UNDERSTAND TILL BECAME PROFESSOR AND TEACH AND GUIDE OTHER.. IF NOT ALL YOU SAID IS JUST BULLSHIT AND JUST A MEDIUM FOR CHEAP DREAM THAN BEEN MESSMERING IN BEAUTY OF BUDDHIS TEACHING WITHOUT ABILITY THAT JUST PLAGIARISM COPPY PASTE OTHER WESTERN BUDDHIS BLOG OR OPINION AND SELLING IT CHEAPSKATE CHEAPLY FOR SMALL MONEY FOR ADDS AVENUE.. ( Hopefully I'm wrong and you are not.... Please) Really don't play or underestimate Vajrayana Buddhisme IT'S SACRED AND HOLLY THINGS.. YOU MAKE IT RIGHT CONGRATULATIONS ITS GOOD AND BENEFITING YOU 👍🙏🏆, YOU IGNORANT AND ACTUALLY MADE WRONG AND BAD ONE, CONGRATULATIONS IT'S REALLY BAD AND MISLEADING YOU TO BAD KARMA AND EFFECT... SURE BOTH CAN NOT HAPPENED INSTANTLY BUT THE KARMA ALREADY MOVE ON THE PATH LIKE AUTOMATICALLY TRAIN LINE..
Venerable Karmapa Rinpoche can manifest two bodies however in essence one soul…. ❤❤❤… I humbly bow down thrice to both of Venerable Karmapa Rinpoches 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Only bad thing is that one of the high lamas was not telling the truth ( Tai Situ or Shamar Rinoche) nothing wrong to test the hand write for authenticity when even Dalai Lama wanted to test the bones of the Buddha himself to scientific enquiry, and if you resist to a single test show you have some to hide; also one of the Karmapa fathered a child ( shown with DNA test) and have several accusations of sexual misconduct even to minors where the other just got married in legal terms without deceiving young ladies.
Situ Rinpoche lied and didn't let the letter checked. Shamar Rinpoche chose the right Karmapa. It's all about power and possessions provided by Western riches who are tired of 1st world life and do something eccentric. The fraud Karmapa is the one from Tibet
There is a popular belief in Buddhism that reincarnate can be in three forms; mind, body and speech. so it isn't hard to comprehend two reincarnate of one superior being
He was asked to confirm a recognition that he was told was unanimous. He did that, without being directly involved. Years later he also confirmed (more privately) that the other candidate was an emanation of Karmapa, when asked to do so.
The Dalai Lama has no say in the Karma Kagyu Lineage. The Karmapa and Shamarpa are considered inseparable. Only Shamar Rinpoche has the right to recognize. The Dalai Lama was tricked into recognizing the Beijing chosen Karmapa . He was told all Kagyu regents were unanimous. Now Orgyen Trinlay has escaped his Gelugpa handlers , distanced himself from Tai Situ and reached out to Thaye Dorje. Let’s hear from them directly who is who and not the Gelugpa.
It's not Dalai Lama business to recognize everybody. He has his Gelug school and Kagu shouldn't be his business. It has always been Shamarpa's responsibility. It's that simple.
We don’t have the power to tell who’s the real karmapa so let’s just end this whole mess . Two of the heart sons recognised the two Karmapas and we should respect it. The two Karmapas met and have a good relationship. It is the people below who are constantly at each others throat. Instead of pinning against each other we should work collectively to return the once powerful Karma Kagyu lineage to its original glory. Karmapa khenno
May All Beings be free from Attachment and Aversion. Pray 🙏. May All Beings find happiness and the cause of happiness. May All Beings be free from sadness and the causes of sadness. Understanding this, then where is the problem. Pray 🙏
Respect and love for both Karmapas. May they live long and their wishes be fulfilled. I had the good luck, that my teachers told me from beginning, that Karmapas have many emanation and their is not about of wrong and right. Now both has meet and give advice, not to discuss, because this is not helpfull for the dharma practice. So even if sombody is devoted to only one of them, the instruction is clear.
@@lordofdalords When we all can perceive sincerely everyone else as a Buddha, but if we have defilements? At least speaking from my own experience as a sentient being.
Why this old contraversy is being ploughed back again and again? There is no new important information or insight in whole this video except reiterating what is already in public. domain. This body of assortment of explanations, clarifications, claims and counter claims and others has not helped to resolve unwanted and unwarranted so-called Karmapa contraversy. So is the real purpose of recycling?
I only have a comfortable impression when I see and hear Situ Rinpoche and "his" Karmapa. Although I don't know if this young man can reach his full potential under the current circumstances. The former one was outstanding in every concern. This is a viewpoint from outside - I'am christian 😊
The up-date situation is that the two Karmapas have met few years ago and they respect each other so much . Instead of the out-dated ridiculous controversy , they are now united and turn the Dharma wheel together .
Это влажные фантазии всяких приспособоенцев с поверхностным взглядом, они встретились, уважают, работают, но более этого это ничего не означают.Кармапа только один, Тринле Тхае Дордже.
the real karmapa doesnt want to debate and the fake one is scared to debate . hence they decided to respect each other and move on . Its the disciples who are being fooled.
The fact is somebody try to split the Karmapa lineage by creating the dispute of the two Karmapas . However , when the two Karmapas grown up , they are proved to be highly enlightened lamas who have the wisdom to unite together n lead their disciples to move on
The Great Masters like Jamyang Künste Wangpo , does not have a long lineage history like the Karmapas, but was very respected by all the religious schools of Tibet. Many Rinpoches like the late Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, Dzongsar Khyentse Choeky Lodre and more were his reincarnation and all of them worked togather for the benefit of all sentient beings. It is a great tragedy that Karmapa’s regents were unable to choose the same path…
I like that they agree to share Much work to be done Can they overcome the oppression the Chinese give them continually And be happy in all circumstances I think so ha Namaste namasta namakusa
There is only one Venerable Karmapa in this world. Each incarnation of Karmapa will leave a prophetic letter to his disciples, asking his disciples to find the reincarnation of his soul boy. The guru of the 16th Karmapa was Tai Situ Rinpoche. After Tai Situ Rinpoche death, Tai Situ Rinpoche reincarnated and became a disciple of the 16th Karmapa. After 16th Karmapa death, the 16th Karmapa reincarnated and became a disciple of Tai Situ Rinpoche. , that is, the 17th Karmapa Ugyen Trinley Dorje. This is the history of the Kagyu lineage.
Karmapa is a Buddha. He can manifest many emanations for the benefits of all sentient beings. 16th Karmapa as being a omniscient cleary knew about the future. Its all play of Karmapa to benefits us..Have a pure perception towards both Karmapa..and you will receive blessings of Karmapa.. Stop this useless fighting about Karmapa. Karmapa knows well than ignorant beings like us. Karmapa Khenno❤
the sun sets in the horizon, the fools keep arguing about the length of their shadows, soon darkness comes and takes them away, they neither saw light nor its beauty, neither did they take a single step towards their destination.
The title "Bejing Karmapa" is misleading! seems to imply that Ogyen Trinley Dorje has a connection with the Beijing Gov. He was recognized as the Karmapa by Beijing more for the title influence and he was invited to visit Beijing twice. However he chose to leave China for better religious development and Dharma activities. He was questioned, searched and raided by Indian gov. because they suspect that he was a Chinese spy. Ogyen Trinley Dorje never lose his mind and hope on people. When he left China, he left a note saying that his leaving is not to betray his country and nation, that he will find back the black hat and some Dharma tools left by the past Karmapa. Sadly because of this controversy, he hasn't been able to achieve his goal in order to return to his homeland. From all this challenges and passing thru, I greatly admire Ogyen Trinley Dorje as the unsurpassed lineage leader in my heart! The only other one who has the similar experience is the Dalai Lama.
Hellow fake news 🗞️ It was 1994, an attack on KIBI, Karmapa Internation Buddhist Institute located New Delhi, during the Karmapa enthronement ceremony, it's not in Rumtek. Secondly you added The Shamarpa's video clip without captioning, people like to know what he was saying. Don't spread fake news ✖️
One is recognised by Sutu Rinpoche and another one is recognised by Shamar Rinpoche. Both Rinpoche have long authentic historical importance. Any one who says true or false must be spiritually achieved wisdom. I will not be surprised if there are another ten more Karmapa incarnations!
@@Dakiharu those who support Shamarpa Rinpoche and another who supports Situ Rinpoche. Both groups are pointing to each other and trying to authenticate one ianother. In realiry both are pulling the leg of Karmapa institude. If there are any one who can defame Karmapa institude and linage. It is these two group trying to support respective Rinpoche. Not knowing that their love, respect and belief is doing more harm than good to Kamtsang Sect. Let there be hundred more Karmapa. As long as they serve people it is ok. Your belief and respect for Sharmapa will invite more accusation from another group. Wake up! This is 21st century. Be more civil. No more arguments. I am not Kagyuepa. But I respect both Karmapa Rinpoche. I am doing what every Kamtsang follower should be doing.
Person like us can't confirm who's real . if faith is perfect than dead dog teeth can be converted to Budha ringsel , like that if our faith is pure than they both can real . Its depends on our point of view 😇 namo budhey
I don't see why both can't be the Karmapa. At the enlightened level, you can manifest as many forms as you want. Also, centuries ago, the 18th Karmapa was prophesied to manifest two Nirmanakaya forms. Technically, these guys are the 18th Karmapa, as one Karmapa died as a small child, before he could be enthroned. I just don't think it's a big deal. What kind of people are they? is a better question.
There is no such thing as real or unreal. In another word there is no such thing as unchanging Entity. Every thing is impermanent. In my opinion whoever proofs to be rendering the greatest service to Dharma and sentient beings, that can be consider as the real karmapa. After all, the title Karmapa means one who performs, enlighten karma or activity for the benefit of others on the behalf of all the Buddha’s and Bodhisattvas. I think this the strongest criterial.
Rinpoche's are all about avatar reincarnation, who says there cannot be two reincarnation at the same time? Whom ever you are getting wisdom and knowledge he is the real karmapa. I'm getting from both so both are karmapa for me.
As a Tibetan and a buddhist, I think there isnt a real or fake reincarnation. It’s a belief which has been going on for centuries and no matter what people will believe in reincarnation based on their reasons. So, the reincarnation is not important, the important question is how it’s going to effect the Tibetan Buddhism.
even belief systems should make sense to common sense and logic. just blindly following what others say is the one thing buddha tried to warn about. He was against all superstitions but now buddhism has become pile of beliefs and superstition only.
Reincarnation can be many. But I wonder why High lamas were not clear on This particular issue. They are supposed to be enlighten who can't be confused. But here one reject the other's...
For those who do not know abt Tibetan Buddhism or it’s politics, the ‘2’ Karmapa controversy emerged from 1 man greed n ego. He was the shamarpa who died few yrs ago n thaye reincarnated him with the birth of his son. For this, there is no coincidence that the real Karmapa stands above all politics n is the one that is recognised n backed by both the Dalai Lama and Sakya Trizin.
When a great being dies, he can be reincarnated as 3, once each for body, speech and mind. So the question is not why are there 2, the question is where is the 3rd. ❤
The true Karmapa will Manifest by the Power of his Realization and smash the schism which exist in the precious kamtsang Lineage. He will do it with his miracolous Power. Take care for unitiy, peace and friendship and heal the Karma kagyü Lineage. So 2 candidates we have to wait for until 1 of them hast the kindness tu cure these problems... i forgot bot are just Substitution
If the prediction. letter/ letters were forged, as I suspect they may have been., I would expect the mashembo inauspiociosness we have in the lineage now. You can take a Tibetan out of Tibet, you can never take away their appetite for feudalism "Beware of worldly monks attached to large monasteries " Milarepa " A thousand Songs "
Who told u that dalai recognise is real Karmapa.u have read history of Karmapa then u will know who is real karmapa. Karmapa and Shamarpa are like father sons. If there is Shamarpa then only Shamarpa can recognise Karmapa The other Rinpoche are not allowed to do it.
Both can be Karmapa as we know how in other way or only one is Karmapa or it's just Chinese tatics to rule over Tibet. We all know after Dalai lama Karmapa is the most influence Buddhist leader in Tibet.China doesn't want to free Tibet (so they have to keep this leader under them under their control as of to control whole Tibetan and also to make sure that this religious leaders dont get involved in politics) but Which they were unable to do so on H.H Dalai lama and Karmapa. So after Karmapa also fled to India this drama of new Karmapa started. That's my point of understanding in Chinese politics. Keeping aside this politic things if they claims him to be Karmapa and is doing good for sentient beings and practicing Buddhism then good. As we know Karmapa can manifest in many forms maybe he can be one,maybe not we never know.
Let's be clear about those charges! They were made by Chinese-sponsored Chinese women without proof. Pure slander and propaganda by Beijing to discredit HH Ogygen Trinley Dorje who heroically escaped from Chinese-occupied Tibet. Spurious charges are not fact.
Reincarnation is politics, not reality. Since there is no self there is nothing to be reincarnated but the non-dual life energy itself, which is the same in all living beings.
Whoever the karmapa is, they are neither wrong nor right. The real Buddha is within you and take care of yourself. Don’t fight over judgment and comparison, all we need is to be awakened and one who can watch everything. We need to focus on truth not the worldly materials.
In 21 century, people sending man in moon and will be sending man to the Mars. I can not comprehand believing in two Karmapas. It is only believed by those who still, think, that the earth is flat, and the Lamas have pure hearts. We lost our country, because of such unbelievable interpretations.
One doesn’t have to be real to own the title. We respect both as the highest lama of Tibetan society.
The buddha not smiling. E d curren
@@brokenarrow9e+!Отличная книга.👏
В Ваджраяне обязательно нужно следовать Учителю.И титул здесь - это не предмет демократических выборов, оценочного скждения и поверхностных позитивных чувств.
It's a pity that one has returned to vulgarity and the other has been scandalized
NOT LIKE THIS VIDEO AND SHOULD BE SUE AND CRITICIZED FOR PLAGIARISM, PROVOKE ISSUE THAT ALREADY BEEN SOLVED AND CLEAR PEACEFULLY IN KAGYUD AND EVEN BUDDHIS VAJRAYANA COMUNITY
I really don't know what to said. This western learn Buddhis but name spiritual guide but selling cheap gossip for earn small money that she just copy paste 😂 from many internet as many her article I checked just copy paste form many western website and just put one on her article AND WITHOUT PUT THE SOURCE, i dare her to show that this is HER ORIGINAL RESEARCH in sadhana or ASKING / GET PERMISSION from website shE COPY 100% .. You all can check just by simple Google and many her website All only just 2023. Some of them just laughing to her that rather share good meditation tips more to cheap teen gossip and just plagiarism 100 % even mantra and even description.. ( have in website in western author doesn't mean they already right baby) but I'm cannot stand the name Chanel of spiritual guide meditation ( IT'S MORE TO NEWS AND GOSSIP IN BUDDHISM AND COLLECTION OF COPY PASTE THEFT PLAGIARISM OF WESTERN BUDDHISM BY SOME GREEDY SMALL MONEY DESPITE NO QUALIFICATIONS OF SCHOLARS IN BUDDHA DHARMA
Her just want small cheap money than thinking about the Consequences of the view.. About the scandal as she already published the video do she dare to EVEN ASK TO LIKE AND Subscribe REALLY SHAMELESS.. IF YOU can publish this ASK YOUR AUTHENTIC BUDDHISM GURU IS YOU MADE THE RIGHT THING OR NOT OR YOU JUST PLANTING WRONG VIEW WITH OUT RESEARCH MORE JUST BY VIDEO BY WESTERN AND ASK THE PROPER VAJRAYANA BUDDHISM GURU WITH AUTHENTIC LINEAGE WHATEVER MONASTIC OR LAY PEOPLE NOT JUST GOGGLE AND COPY PASTE DO WE CAN STEALING AND PLAGIARISM COPY PASTE AND SHARE BUDDHA DHARMA VAJRAYANA MANTRA AND VIEW IF NOT RIGHT LIKE IN SADHANA JS THAT MAKING PLANTING SEEDS OF WRONG VIEW AND MISLEADING BUDDHA DHARMA AM I MAKE GOOD MERRIT OR BAD MERRIT.
China spy? If you born in tibetan occupied by china and china tibetan and government knowing you you can be automatically became Chinese spy? That old video already been laughed by tibetan and western BUDDHISM scholar , why not YOU SAID H. H AND H. E SAKYA, SOME KAGYU ,NYINGMA LEADER ALSO CHINA SPY AS SOME OF THEM FROM FORM TIBETAN (TAR CHINA) ??
RESEARCH AND UNDERSTANDING THE ISSUE AND MATTER FIRST. LEARN CHINESE , INDIAN AND TIBETAN AND READ AND COMPARE FROM BOTH SIDE IF NOT YOU JUST SHAMELESSLY FOLLOW ING STUPID PEOPLE BUT USING COOL NAME SPIRITUAL GUIDE CHANEL..
IF NOT BECAUSE PITTY FOR YOU AND OTHER THAT REALLY HAVE GOOD INTENTION TO LEARN BUDDHA DHARMA, Especially to People who knows the Truth and Respect KAGYU Sangha and H.H Karma pa and felt sorry for your ignorant copy paste without checking both KAGYU side or inner ring and felt sorry for you cause make easy bad karma so I remind you, hate and dislike me if you like, kinda harsh but you make many mistakes despite promoting meditation and ... ( BUT IF YOU BUDDHISM YOU SHOULD ADMIT YOUR VIDEO, BLOG INSTAGRAM IS LOT PLAGIARISM AND MANY WRONG OPINION BIG AUTHOR THAN IN SADHANA SOURCE. AND WITH BIG HEART CONFESS IT AND ASK THE AUTHOR AND AT LEAST CHECKED WITH YOUR BUDDHISM MASTER WITH AUTHENTIC LINEAGE GURU FIRST, THEN I'M REALLY HOPE YOU CAN BE GOOD MEDIA THAT PROMOTE MEDITATION, BENEFITS TO FOLLOW BUDDHISM, PRACTICE OF THE DEITY, WHAT ARE YOU DOING NOW IS LIKE MIX FOOD WITH POISON OF WRONG VIEW AND NOT UNRESPOSIBLE PERSONAL OPINION AND YOU DON'T KNOW BECAUSE YOU JUST BLINDLY STEALING PLAGIARISM
IT BY JUST COPY PASTE SOME YOUR ARTICLE KINDA ROUGH AS THE FLOW KINDA FORCED🙄😟🤭)
It's more about your stealing, plagiarism, copy paste without proper really check and study and not asking permission from the author and not putting the source.. You just easily foolish your self. And make fooling and target of people who understand the situation and the truth. I really can't control myself again even in this video.. Use your basic common sense. You thinking thousands monk, H.H Dalai lama, some trulku, Senior elder monk, and Hundred million eyes and ear of Tibetan,East and west student and devote is stupid kind people that just know meditation, study BUDDHISM. Do your understanding is higher than them and do you think they don't get all Blessings of Deity you plagiarism in you article and can not know which one is Non Sense which one is the Truth, which one is just Sensation, how to humane Delivery the Truth on right time??? I'm really praying for my HEART THAT YOU REALLY PRACTICE MEDITATION YOU PROMOTE AND SHARE IN MANY YOUR VIDEO AND BE ADVANCED THAN JUST HAPPY LY SATISFIED IN KNOWLEDGE IN BASIC AND THE BUDDHISM DEITY YOU SHARE ON YOUR ARTICLE WHATEVER TARA KURUKULE EVEN YOUR BASIC BUDDHISM VIDEO AND REALLY HURRY UP QUICKLY SWIFTLY BECAME BUDDHA SO YOU KNOW THE TRUTH AND CAN KNOW MORE HOW TO ACT, HOW TO TALK, HOW TO PUT MIND AND HOW TO CONTEMPLATING, STUDY, EXAMINE, BUDDHA DHARMA TEACHING and PHENOMENON, I WILL PROSTATE TO YOU MANY TIMES.. BUT JUST DO ALL YOU SAID AND SHARE, TEACH US IN YOUR ARTICLE AND VIDEO AND REALIZED IT JUST LIKE GOOD ATHELETE DEDICATED PRACTICE TILL BECAME CHAMPIONS OR HOW A STUDENTS LEARN DELIGENCE, STUDY, RESEARCH, TESTING, UNDERSTAND TILL BECAME PROFESSOR AND TEACH AND GUIDE OTHER..
IF NOT ALL YOU SAID IS JUST BULLSHIT AND JUST A MEDIUM FOR CHEAP DREAM THAN BEEN MESSMERING IN BEAUTY OF BUDDHIS TEACHING WITHOUT ABILITY THAT JUST PLAGIARISM COPPY PASTE OTHER WESTERN BUDDHIS BLOG OR OPINION AND SELLING IT CHEAPSKATE CHEAPLY FOR SMALL MONEY FOR ADDS AVENUE.. ( Hopefully I'm wrong and you are not.... Please)
Really don't play or underestimate Vajrayana Buddhisme IT'S SACRED AND HOLLY THINGS.. YOU MAKE IT RIGHT CONGRATULATIONS ITS GOOD AND BENEFITING YOU 👍🙏🏆, YOU IGNORANT AND ACTUALLY MADE WRONG AND BAD ONE, CONGRATULATIONS IT'S REALLY BAD AND MISLEADING YOU TO BAD KARMA AND EFFECT... SURE BOTH CAN NOT HAPPENED INSTANTLY BUT THE KARMA ALREADY MOVE ON THE PATH LIKE AUTOMATICALLY TRAIN LINE..
We are blessed to have not one but two. Their wisdom and Knowledge will always benefit for the welfare of the Tibetan Buddhism.
Он один.
i think we will be blessed if we had two suns or we will burn to death?
It's a pity that one has returned to vulgarity and the other has been scandalized
Those who married n enjoy casual life is doubt
Namo Buddhay.
Deep inside their soul, they do know who they are. For the rest of us just accept them as it is, love & peace to all.
Души не существует.🤣
namo Buddhay.
Venerable Karmapa Rinpoche can manifest two bodies however in essence one soul…. ❤❤❤…
I humbly bow down thrice to both of Venerable Karmapa Rinpoches 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Namo Buddhay.
Both are respectful lama for us Buddhist we don't want fight like Muslim Christian or hindu
And there comes the discrimination 😂
Long life both karmapa.
Only bad thing is that one of the high lamas was not telling the truth ( Tai Situ or Shamar Rinoche) nothing wrong to test the hand write for authenticity when even Dalai Lama wanted to test the bones of the Buddha himself to scientific enquiry, and if you resist to a single test show you have some to hide; also one of the Karmapa fathered a child ( shown with DNA test) and have several accusations of sexual misconduct even to minors where the other just got married in legal terms without deceiving young ladies.
Toto je projev tvé mysli, který sám o sobě neexistuje🙌
all this sound like a huge BS to disgrace holy people..
Situ Rinpoche lied and didn't let the letter checked.
Shamar Rinpoche chose the right Karmapa.
It's all about power and possessions provided by Western riches who are tired of 1st world life and do something eccentric.
The fraud Karmapa is the one from Tibet
@@HealThyRealitytruth hurts common minds to whom logic is a long gone friend
There is a popular belief in Buddhism that reincarnate can be in three forms; mind, body and speech. so it isn't hard to comprehend two reincarnate of one superior being
just to support your view; body and speech together are rupakaya, mind is dharmakaya. so 2 is ok as well :)
If you ever meet with Thaye Dorje, there's no question anymore 🥰🥰🙏🙏
same If you ever meet with Orgyen Trinley, there's no question anymore
this. karmapa chenno
So who is real?
@@celestine.love88 Thaye Dorje!
@@Bernagchen_ he has wife and child..
His Holiness Dalailama already told us who is the KARMAPA, the only one. I don't believe anyone would understand better than him.
He was asked to confirm a recognition that he was told was unanimous. He did that, without being directly involved. Years later he also confirmed (more privately) that the other candidate was an emanation of Karmapa, when asked to do so.
Кто такой Далай Лама, чтобы говорить нам, кто Кармапа?🙄Шамар Ринпоче узнал Кармапу и сам Кармара узнал себя.
and why should anyone believe dalai lama and not beijing?. both are just political forces.
The Dalai Lama has no say in the Karma Kagyu Lineage. The Karmapa and Shamarpa are considered inseparable. Only Shamar Rinpoche has the right to recognize. The Dalai Lama was tricked into recognizing the Beijing chosen Karmapa . He was told all Kagyu regents were unanimous. Now Orgyen Trinlay has escaped his Gelugpa handlers , distanced himself from Tai Situ and reached out to Thaye Dorje. Let’s hear from them directly who is who and not the Gelugpa.
It's not Dalai Lama business to recognize everybody. He has his Gelug school and Kagu shouldn't be his business. It has always been Shamarpa's responsibility. It's that simple.
No problems if they are helpful n teach dharma n led the sentient being to the path of dharma..
if a blind perso tries to show others the way , both fall into a ditch.
I don't care he is Chinese or what as long as good teacher he have my respect
Since we don't have the ability to see who is a Karmapa, we follow who our teachers follow. If he inspires you to practice, it's all good.
We don’t have the power to tell who’s the real karmapa so let’s just end this whole mess . Two of the heart sons recognised the two Karmapas and we should respect it. The two Karmapas met and have a good relationship. It is the people below who are constantly at each others throat. Instead of pinning against each other we should work collectively to return the once powerful Karma Kagyu lineage to its original glory. Karmapa khenno
Это точка зрения основана на чувствах, но не на преданности и ясности.Кармара только один, и у Шамара Ринпоче есть власть его узнавать.
@@user-jg7so4pm3xEgo. Všechno je projevem naší mysli, který sám o sobě neexistuje a nesprávně jej chápeme jako objekt🙌
unabhängig davon, ist für mich , der vom Dalai Lama anerkannte der authentische Karmapa
May All Beings be free from Attachment and Aversion. Pray 🙏.
May All Beings find happiness and the cause of happiness.
May All Beings be free from sadness and the causes of sadness.
Understanding this, then where is the problem. Pray 🙏
😮😮😮
So be it, may all sentient be blessed and be free from negative emotions and suffering 🙏
Respect and love for both Karmapas. May they live long and their wishes be fulfilled. I had the good luck, that my teachers told me from beginning, that Karmapas have many emanation and their is not about of wrong and right. Now both has meet and give advice, not to discuss, because this is not helpfull for the dharma practice. So even if sombody is devoted to only one of them, the instruction is clear.
Lesson: We must visualize and treat all sentient beings as Buddha, instead of speaking ill of others.
if all beings are buddha we do not need karmapas and rinpoches anyway :D
@@lordofdalords When we all can perceive sincerely everyone else as a Buddha, but if we have defilements? At least speaking from my own experience as a sentient being.
One who's chosen by our Lineage leader HH Sharmapa is to be followed. All high practitioners
I am from Bhutan and in Bhutan the term for father is “Apa”. My name is Karma and my father is the real Karma-Apa.
We both respect both karmapa , and historically, there are some situations where you sometimes have two reincarnation.
ya when you are confused to decide.
the real dalai lama is watching all this bull shit and he isnot pleased
@@lordofdalords stop assuming start doing some homework
@@taidelek9994 who is assuming that there are two incarnations of same karmapa here? If we were not assuming there would be only one karmapa .
Both are real karmapa❤❤❤❤ long live both karmapa
Why this old contraversy is being ploughed back again and again?
There is no new important information or insight in whole this video except reiterating what is already in public. domain.
This body of assortment of explanations, clarifications, claims and counter claims and others has not helped to resolve unwanted and unwarranted so-called Karmapa contraversy. So is the real purpose of recycling?
I only have a comfortable impression when I see and hear Situ Rinpoche and "his" Karmapa. Although I don't know if this young man can reach his full potential under the current circumstances. The former one was outstanding in every concern. This is a viewpoint from outside - I'am christian 😊
Not problem don’t worry
We respect both of them. Can be rebirths of Body,Mind, Sprite🪷.
I’m follower of both Karmapa 🙏✨🙏✨🙏
I strongly believe one is reincarnation of mind & other is speech 🙏
The up-date situation is that the two Karmapas have met few years ago and they respect each other so much .
Instead of the out-dated ridiculous controversy , they are now united and turn the Dharma wheel together .
Это влажные фантазии всяких приспособоенцев с поверхностным взглядом, они встретились, уважают, работают, но более этого это ничего не означают.Кармапа только один, Тринле Тхае Дордже.
the real karmapa doesnt want to debate and the fake one is scared to debate . hence they decided to respect each other and move on . Its the disciples who are being fooled.
The fact is somebody try to split the Karmapa lineage by creating the dispute of the two Karmapas .
However , when the two Karmapas grown up , they are proved to be highly enlightened lamas who have the wisdom to unite together n lead their disciples to move on
@@lordofdalordsso who is real
The Great Masters like Jamyang Künste Wangpo , does not have a long lineage history like the Karmapas, but was very respected by all the religious schools of Tibet. Many Rinpoches like the late Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, Dzongsar Khyentse Choeky Lodre and more were his reincarnation and all of them worked togather for the benefit of all sentient beings. It is a great tragedy that Karmapa’s regents were unable to choose the same path…
If you pronounce the names your almost a perfected bring!
Это не предмет демократических выборов и оценочного суждения, это то как есть на самом деле, и это - вопрос samaya.17 Кармапа только один.
I like that they agree to share
Much work to be done
Can they overcome the oppression the Chinese give them continually
And be happy in all circumstances
I think so ha
Namaste namasta namakusa
Ogen Tenlay dorjey is not from Bajing he is from Tibet .....
Karmapa recognised by His Holiness and Tai Situ Rinpoche is the genuine one. However, we also respect the other one too.
There is only one Venerable Karmapa in this world. Each incarnation of Karmapa will leave a prophetic letter to his disciples, asking his disciples to find the reincarnation of his soul boy. The guru of the 16th Karmapa was Tai Situ Rinpoche. After Tai Situ Rinpoche death, Tai Situ Rinpoche reincarnated and became a disciple of the 16th Karmapa. After 16th Karmapa death, the 16th Karmapa reincarnated and became a disciple of Tai Situ Rinpoche. , that is, the 17th Karmapa Ugyen Trinley Dorje. This is the history of the Kagyu lineage.
It's really sad 😢 to see such a disgusting caption like who's real karmapa
Karmapa is a Buddha.
He can manifest many emanations for the benefits of all sentient beings.
16th Karmapa as being a omniscient cleary knew about the future.
Its all play of Karmapa to benefits us..Have a pure perception towards both Karmapa..and you will receive blessings of Karmapa..
Stop this useless fighting about Karmapa.
Karmapa knows well than ignorant beings like us.
Karmapa Khenno❤
the sun sets in the horizon,
the fools keep arguing about the length of their shadows,
soon darkness comes and takes them away,
they neither saw light nor its beauty,
neither did they take a single step towards their destination.
The title "Bejing Karmapa" is misleading! seems to imply that Ogyen Trinley Dorje has a connection with the Beijing Gov. He was recognized as the Karmapa by Beijing more for the title influence and he was invited to visit Beijing twice. However he chose to leave China for better religious development and Dharma activities. He was questioned, searched and raided by Indian gov. because they suspect that he was a Chinese spy. Ogyen Trinley Dorje never lose his mind and hope on people. When he left China, he left a note saying that his leaving is not to betray his country and nation, that he will find back the black hat and some Dharma tools left by the past Karmapa. Sadly because of this controversy, he hasn't been able to achieve his goal in order to return to his homeland. From all this challenges and passing thru, I greatly admire Ogyen Trinley Dorje as the unsurpassed lineage leader in my heart! The only other one who has the similar experience is the Dalai Lama.
actuelly we have 3 karmapa now. we got one karma in sherpa too.
Lol
the overfeed one?
Urgyen thinley dorjee
Hellow fake news 🗞️
It was 1994, an attack on KIBI, Karmapa Internation Buddhist Institute located New Delhi, during the Karmapa enthronement ceremony, it's not in Rumtek.
Secondly you added The Shamarpa's video clip without captioning, people like to know what he was saying.
Don't spread fake news ✖️
Ogyen Thinley Dorjee Karmapa
I believe in this statement 💯🙌🙏 11:25...
Hey, this is cool. How did you put a quote of timestamp in your comment?
One is recognised by Sutu Rinpoche and another one is recognised by Shamar Rinpoche.
Both Rinpoche have long authentic historical importance.
Any one who says true or false must be spiritually achieved wisdom.
I will not be surprised if there are another ten more Karmapa incarnations!
Они не равнозначны.Один из них сам является Кармапой, и за ним было слово.
But whose responsibility among these two to recognize Karmapa? That's right - it"s Shamarpa's job and nobody else.
@@Dakiharu those who support Shamarpa Rinpoche and another who supports Situ Rinpoche.
Both groups are pointing to each other and trying to authenticate one ianother.
In realiry both are pulling the leg of Karmapa institude.
If there are any one who can defame Karmapa institude and linage. It is these two group trying to support respective Rinpoche. Not knowing that their love, respect and belief is doing more harm than good to Kamtsang Sect.
Let there be hundred more Karmapa. As long as they serve people it is ok.
Your belief and respect for Sharmapa will invite more accusation from another group.
Wake up! This is 21st century. Be more civil. No more arguments.
I am not Kagyuepa. But I respect both Karmapa Rinpoche. I am doing what every Kamtsang follower should be doing.
We r really lucky to have spiritual leader like karmapa and of course I believe in both karmapa 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺
🤣Если Кармапа сказал, что он в 17-м воплощении только один, то ты не слушаешь его.🤣
Both ❤️❤️❤️
Person like us can't confirm who's real . if faith is perfect than dead dog teeth can be converted to Budha ringsel , like that if our faith is pure than they both can real . Its depends on our point of view 😇 namo budhey
There's always been 1 buddha, in one generation..
Everyone is real karmapa just keep your karma clean and pray only to the ultimate god
If you get time plz need to update on this 🙏
Om mani pa da mi hum
I don't see why both can't be the Karmapa. At the enlightened level, you can manifest as many forms as you want.
Also, centuries ago, the 18th Karmapa was prophesied to manifest two Nirmanakaya forms. Technically, these guys are the 18th Karmapa, as one Karmapa died as a small child, before he could be enthroned.
I just don't think it's a big deal. What kind of people are they? is a better question.
There is no such thing as real or unreal. In another word there is no such thing as unchanging Entity. Every thing is impermanent. In my opinion whoever proofs to be rendering the greatest service to Dharma and sentient beings, that can be consider as the real karmapa. After all, the title Karmapa means one who performs, enlighten karma or activity for the benefit of others on the behalf of all the Buddha’s and Bodhisattvas. I think this the strongest criterial.
there is no thing as death and life its all illusion according to buddha . so can anyone kill anyone else?
Нет, указанное - это чувства и предмет оценочного суждения.Кармапа - это конкретное воплощение, и в 17-м он - только один.
Thank you so much xx
Rinpoche's are all about avatar reincarnation, who says there cannot be two reincarnation at the same time? Whom ever you are getting wisdom and knowledge he is the real karmapa. I'm getting from both so both are karmapa for me.
We should be respect both of Rinpoche🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
The real KARMAPA is the one who is recognized by The great His Holiness The 14th DALAI LAMA 🙏
Настоящий Кармара только тот, кого признал Шамар Ринпоче.
@@lhundrupdorjetulku7084it’s not about Kagyu, Nyima or Sakya. We lost our Country to China. We are here because of His holiness bless.
Why should it be so? It has never been his business to recognize Karmapa.It's Shamarpa's job.
Karmapa Kheno 💕💕💕💕💕🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
As a Tibetan and a buddhist, I think there isnt a real or fake reincarnation. It’s a belief which has been going on for centuries and no matter what people will believe in reincarnation based on their reasons. So, the reincarnation is not important, the important question is how it’s going to effect the Tibetan Buddhism.
Is it not true that great wisdom beings as Karmapa can have more than one incarnation at the same time
@@niiwin6595верно.И второе из них - Шамар Ринпоче.Больше - нет.
even belief systems should make sense to common sense and logic. just blindly following what others say is the one thing buddha tried to warn about. He was against all superstitions but now buddhism has become pile of beliefs and superstition only.
Yes the important thing is really, how each is effecting Tibetan Buddhism and serve for sentient beings. 👍
most r made up too.
Reincarnation can be many. But I wonder why High lamas were not clear on This particular issue. They are supposed to be enlighten who can't be confused. But here one reject the other's...
Karmapa thinley theye dorjee khenno🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
That's the one with the kind face, right?
For those who do not know abt Tibetan Buddhism or it’s politics, the ‘2’ Karmapa controversy emerged from 1 man greed n ego. He was the shamarpa who died few yrs ago n thaye reincarnated him with the birth of his son. For this, there is no coincidence that the real Karmapa stands above all politics n is the one that is recognised n backed by both the Dalai Lama and Sakya Trizin.
You speak the truth. Thank you.
Both are real Karmapa🙏🙏🙏🙏
Little knowledge is dangerous! 🤌🏼
czcams.com/video/CA6QFN8Lzz0/video.html
If you need the Internet to "tell you" who the real Karmapa is, then you're following the wrong path.
When a great being dies, he can be reincarnated as 3, once each for body, speech and mind. So the question is not why are there 2, the question is where is the 3rd. ❤
just to support your entry further, there are high lamas who reincarnate in 5 people: body, speech, mind, qualities, activities.
There is another sherpa karmapa in sikkim so whom to believe I think is all about power n money
The true Karmapa will Manifest by the Power of his Realization and smash the schism which exist in the precious kamtsang Lineage. He will do it with his miracolous Power. Take care for unitiy, peace and friendship and heal the Karma kagyü Lineage. So 2 candidates we have to wait for until 1 of them hast the kindness tu cure these problems... i forgot bot are just Substitution
The one is enjoying wife life n other is pure
Like at a time a twins babies or many can be born like split into two like right person at right places it can happen i think
I don’t have nth bad to talk bout China recognized karmapa but as a kagyupa Thaye Dorje is my root guru
You see , isn’t it good this way.? We have 2 gurujis teaching us
I believed both long live karmapa Rinpochen la
Matter is Tibetan matter. Outside interference is regretted.
🙏🏻
Super
Wow
2
17 Karmapa
Karma
Zen
Kul
Lepo
Super
Govor
Havala
Slovenija
Buddha
Buddhist
🧘🏻♂️🪷🧘🏻♂️🪷
👍🏻
🙂
🫶🏻❤
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
The topic shifts from Karmapa to rinpoches and eventually lineages. People really have nothing to do with teachings 🤦🏻♀️
Both they came in different form according to for living being
Both are great gurus
I respect of them
Both are real
If the prediction. letter/ letters were forged, as I suspect they may have been., I would expect
the mashembo inauspiociosness we have in the lineage now.
You can take a Tibetan out of Tibet, you can never take away their appetite for feudalism
"Beware of worldly monks attached to large monasteries "
Milarepa
" A thousand Songs "
Actuall there were 4 candidates at one point. Not sure what state of play is now.
What has happened to Tai Situ Rinpochela? He has bad health? He stopped making postings on his CZcams.
both are real karmapa
The real KARMAPA is the one who is recognized by His Holiness The 14th DALAI LAMA 🙏
Who told u that dalai recognise is real Karmapa.u have read history of Karmapa then u will know who is real karmapa. Karmapa and Shamarpa are like father sons. If there is Shamarpa then only Shamarpa can recognise Karmapa The other Rinpoche are not allowed to do it.
@@jorlek3468 this is my opinion not yours and i believe Ugen thenlay dorjee.
If you believe in other karmapa,you believe I don't have problems.
Thanks 👍
@@phuntsokbhutia60 u have to read history to know about Karmapa
Both the karmapas are spiritual leaders ,we should respect both of their ideals
Who is the real Karmapa? It depends on whom you ask. If you ask the disciples of Danish Guru Ole Nydahl or if you ask the Dalai Lama.
Dudjom Lingpa took rebirth as five different people.
Just forgot to add that just one of the said karmapas is raping nuns
Why does karmapa need a watch on his hand? It's a thing that he shouldn't pay attention to it ?
Believe what you want.But this has nothing to do with Sakyamuni.Personally I believe in peanut butter.
Both can be Karmapa as we know how in other way or only one is Karmapa or it's just Chinese tatics to rule over Tibet. We all know after Dalai lama Karmapa is the most influence Buddhist leader in Tibet.China doesn't want to free Tibet (so they have to keep this leader under them under their control as of to control whole Tibetan and also to make sure that this religious leaders dont get involved in politics) but Which they were unable to do so on H.H Dalai lama and Karmapa. So after Karmapa also fled to India this drama of new Karmapa started. That's my point of understanding in Chinese politics. Keeping aside this politic things if they claims him to be Karmapa and is doing good for sentient beings and practicing Buddhism then good. As we know Karmapa can manifest in many forms maybe he can be one,maybe not we never know.
Probably the one without the rape charges against him.
Let's be clear about those charges! They were made by Chinese-sponsored Chinese women without proof. Pure slander and propaganda by Beijing to discredit HH Ogygen Trinley Dorje who heroically escaped from Chinese-occupied Tibet.
Spurious charges are not fact.
No one can judgement or recognised by peoples we are all a reincarnated
I find prediction letters quite suspicious.
Reincarnation is politics, not reality. Since there is no self there is nothing to be reincarnated but the non-dual life energy itself, which is the same in all living beings.
Where is the third Karmapa? There should be one each for body, speech and mind of previous Karmapa
Whoever the karmapa is, they are neither wrong nor right. The real Buddha is within you and take care of yourself. Don’t fight over judgment and comparison, all we need is to be awakened and one who can watch everything. We need to focus on truth not the worldly materials.
Both are Karmapa. That’s enough.
I’m still confused 😕
In 21 century, people sending man in moon and will be sending man to the Mars. I can not comprehand believing in two Karmapas. It is only believed by those who still, think, that the earth is flat, and the Lamas have pure hearts. We lost our country, because of such unbelievable interpretations.
what about other rinpoches and tulku ?
you haven't covered the 3rd Claimant to the throne i.e. Sherpa Karmapa who resides in Sikkim
There is a third Karmapa who has been kept secret since the recognition…And I truly believe Buddhas can come in 1000 forms 1000 universe 🙏🙏🙏
that will be the sherpa karmapa >?
ཀརྨ་པ་ཨོ་རྒྱན་ཕྲིན་ལས་རྡོ་རྗེ་ལ་ན་མོ། 🙏🏻
ཀརྨ་པ་ཨོ་རྒྱན་ཕྲིན་ལས་རྡོ་རྗེ་ཞབས་པད་རྟག་བརྟན་གསོལ Long life Karmapa