How Bercow Changed the Future of Brexit - Brexit Explained
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- Until yesterday there had been rumours that May was planning to bring back her deal for a third meaningful vote. Then Speaker of the House of Commons, John Bercow, changed that. He declared that she wasn't able to bring back the same deal again without substantial changes.
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Follow TLDR on Instagram: / tldrnewsuk
Like TLDR on Facebook: / tldrnewsuk
Follow TLDR on Twitter: / tldrnewsuk
TLDR is all about getting you up to date with the news of today, without bias and without filter. We want to give you the information you need, so you can make your own decision.
TLDR is a super small company, run by one person with the help of some amazing voulenteers. We are 100% fan sourced with all of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corportations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, following and backing on Patreon. Thanks!
The longest video on CZcams of John Bercow that doesn't have him yelling "ODDER ODDER!"
DECENT
Audduh, Audduh
Big Mac large fries and a diet coke
explain @@suivzmoi
Orrrddderrrrrrr
I particularly enjoyed Bercow's reminder to May that she had previously disrespected Parliament.
Harold Bridges
That house of morons doesn’t deserve respect, let alone Berkrow himself
Also, that addition of "the largest defeat in parliamentary history" to the February vote. :D
@@yourmajesty8913 True, a country of fancy thieves
Mr Bercow disobeys parliamentary convention when it suits his remain views. Like when his own legal clerks told him he could NOT allow one amendment pro remain and disallow another that was pro Brexit.
Then suddenly , parliamentary precedent is THE MOST important factor. Even when it date from the 17th century!
How can you not see that this is corrupt? Utterly, totally put the bastard in prison, Tammany hall corrupt?
This is the true corrosive, toxic effect of the EU on society. Everything is now viable to defeat Brexit. Corruption, undermining democracy, a mad parliament imposing dictatorship. People talking denying suffrage except to the elites. For what? A trade pact with delusions of grandeur which has been on the slide for the last 10 years, unemployment, austerity, national bankruptcies, rise of extremist politics, and you would chuck our democracy under a fucking bus for THAT?
He even had to remind Parliament their actions directly affect everyone at 8:00.
It's like watching satire.
Whenever Bercow delivers a calm, cool, collected "order" instead of shouting it like a colonialist caricature, you know shit's getting real.
zeybarur He is giving a statement to the House. They are listening his statement so no need for him to shout “Ordah” lol
@Frontend Programmer I've seen clips of him shouting a few more times just to get his point across
@uaedaien all words are made up including (it appears your favourite) Social Justice Warrior, that's how language works... or shall we check in with you for your approval🤣
@uaedaien Just making fun of the way he shouts dude, don't be a snowflake...
@@up4itgal During his whole speech, the House was uncharacteristically quiet.
The speaker's right - you can't have double standards. The public isn't allowed a revote on Brexit. Yet the government keeps asking for a revote on essentially the same deal
agenderemryspaperart may is anti brexit
@agenderemryspaperart, May is nobody's "precious", especially not Brexit supporters. Her "deal" is essentially Remaining except worse. You need to let go of your assumptions about what other people think.
Remainers logic .
Gary Garratt the deal is the worst possible deal you could ask for. It’s objectively better to leave without a deal.
@Gary Garratt Capitalism will continue to have booms and busts. Anybody who missed that happening when we were in the EU had their heads somewhere far up their comfy middle class I'm alright Jack backsides. Boom and bust is what Capitalism does and we didn't vote to leave Capitalism.
John Bercow's quiet "order" at the end of his declaration is the greatest mic drop he has ever pulled off.
I recon he finishes every statment with 'order' makes a cup of tea... Orrrdaaaa. Bathroom break.. orderrrrr. Good night darling ORRRRDERRR!!!
Walks into his living room to watch TV, "DIVISION! Clear the lobby!"
"order" is a new "amen"
@@randomdaveUK Gets to his bedroom and shouts to his wife.... UNLOCK...
@@1942Grampz door or chastity belt?
British politics is like a football game. Someone makes a nice move and everyone goes "WEEEEEY"
I don't think any of our referees are that bent.
Unlike all of the players
It's 'hear'. As in 'hear, hear!'.
You're not supposed to clap in the House of Commons
@@Cunnysmythe its "Hear" as in *"Hear him!"
@@maicka4417 We're both right, 'hear, hear' comes from 'hear him'
Bercow the secret protagonist of this story
Secret pornographer more like..
Just remember who he is ,.... Bercow... don't trust the little bastard, he is up to no good, after all he is a remainer.
@@riotagus It's rather his advantage. :)
@@riotagus "I disagree with him, therefore he must be evil." Great job m8
@@xlkiritolx8156 Good thing he's not a politician then, isn't it?
My god. I am hooked to this like it is a TV Series. Can't wait to see the next plot twist.
Just as American politics is showing the world a TV show the British have to show them how it is done.
"Previously, on Brexit"
@@Krytern classic British theatre
Plot twist: Britain will never leave EU
@@Nikola95inYT sure do hope that is the next plot twists
Wow, there's *one* sensible, competent lawmaker in Parliament! Who knew??!
Really? Who? All a bunch of useless money grabbers.
@Frontend Programmer is that a bird? Is it a plane? No, it's the speaker!
Rees-Mogg?
@Colin Williamson well you don't have to look at bercrow much longer he retires at end if this parliament. New guy/girl from 01Jul2019.
Let's hope they have same balls to put in governments way to defeat brexit using the law.
They're actually easy to find really...watch the videos, and see who's ready to have an aneurysm bc they're reacting to the BS around them. :D talk to those guys!
He looks a little better now that he's got a solution. :)
ORDER! John Bercow is now the most popular person in the UK parliament 😂
@@IvO09
Salty much?
@@IvO09 more salty than the north sea
Actually,he is second most popular person in the uk
sadly, the hardline brexiters don't like him as they hold him responsible for blocking no-deal scenario
which is, of course, absurd, given that it was the House that voted for that, but it's not like logic and facts are common on the brexit side of the argument...
@Gary Garratt present your evidence for this accusation.
John "Big Balls" Bercow has absolutely destroyed May
Never seen that porn video
@@moodlampActual Gotta search for that one using Bing video.
@@moodlampActual well now you have
@@moodlampActual That would be the sub-genre 'horrorporn'.
Do you have a license for that?!
Can’t wait for this to become a Netflix show
Lost User They wasted “Law and Order” title for that series 😂
Airs everywhere except Britain, where parliamentary parody is prohibited
Law and Order U.K.
Yet another informative video. You have a 20th century approach to journalism. (And I mean that with the highest level of compliment). Thorough, considered, balanced/no agenda, no 5 word sound bites, and no music. Plus the key thing, you report an issue, rather than trying to create one.
Are you watching TV News? You could learn a lot.
"Here here"
@@Thisisaweirdthing2makeusdo reeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaarrrrrr
I have noticed they are slightly pro remain but it is much even than most other news on the topic that i have seen
@@Thegoldenhawkproject Not being neutral but objective is quite a feat to manage nowadays.
K05H you cant blame them much tbh the fact is there is much more bad news about brexit than good. On another point tho how bias is barecrow in your opinion?
Once you like him, you can't dislike him later.
He has the wildest ties I've ever seen in a guy in his position.
Thanks to Bercow, many people outside the UK have begun to take an interest in the affairs of the House of Commons.
But why should anyone want to dislike him later? Even if people don't like him, they surely must respect his intelligence, his command of language and his knowledge.
@@mfjdv2020 Even his biggest enemies respect him.
@@IvO09 Is Bercow jew?
The tie of order has spoken.
Jon Snow and John Bercow go to the same shop.
Right. You know this guy tries to wear the funnest ties that he can get away with.
Yes, and I've never seen him wearing the same tie twice; Dimbleby was the same, in all his years on question time you never saw him wearing the same tie twice either;. You wonder just how many ties these guys must own. They are the Imelda Marcos of ties.
If Bercow turned up in a bow tie one day the HOP would go into shock.
Am I the only one seeing Premiere Pro, In Design Audition and Bridge?
Adobe needs to sell that tie
“ A well-tied tie is the first serious step in life.” Oscar Wilde.
Everyone: You can't put that twice in this session, May!
May: *dissolves session*
Bercow: Order!
Hotel: Trivago.
Russell G I feel like the Trivago meme died a long time ago but some necromancer resurrected it like in MediEvil
Doubt may had the guts to do something as ballsey as that
They'd end up with less numbers in the house
Prorogation of Parliament is not the same as dissolution for a new election. It requires a majority vote of the Cabinet and all open motions, bills, and amendments will lapse (at a time when Goverment is already in a pinch to pass all the necessary Brexit legislation). Carry-over votes would be required for each to make it to a new parliamentary session which will only commence with a State Opening including a new Queen's Speech. Until then Parliament comes to a complete standstill (mere days before the current Brexit deadline of March 29).
Bercow put a stop to the political games. Good on him.
Your avatar needs to be a pattern on his tie.
No, he didn't. He just delayed the next round of the games to next week when May will return to the Commons with a slightly altered version of her bill.
@@stephenphillips4984
By law, as Bercow pointed out, it has to be *significantly* altered. He went out of his way to specify that.
@@festethephule7553 It has to be altered by convention, not by law. It's merely a parliamentary rule that the government can overrule, although that would be difficult, as it has not got a majority in the House of Commons. Yes, Bercow went out of his way to emphasize that. But many MPs suspect he used his office to stop the Bill being passed. That was possibly his REAL purpose in blocking it.
@@stephenphillips4984 That would only be the case if there were any chance of the bill actually passing, and I don't see that coming.
This is completely logical. No one, including May, must be allowed to browbeat or nag the MP's into submission by just repeating the same thing.
I just searched for the TLDR News for the Bercow breakdown and up pops the notification!
Nice!
Keep up the great content.
And don't forget to get some sleep!
*Noice
A smart man with superb command of the language and legal fact!
There's probably a hidden hand pulling his strings behind the scenes
@@raverhtid8966 Yes the reptilian lizard men that live underground. Also the Earth is flat.
Krytern, I wouldn't go that far, lizards and flat earth Hahaha. Most of the players in parliament are corrupt
@@Krytern Not really a rebutle but ok...
Absolutely agree. I'd like to add that his intelligence is outstanding.
A good clear statement from Bercow. I think he's a bit annoyed with May and her government abusing their power over parliament. He reminds me a bit of my mother when she was a working lawyer. She used to get angry with the police when they either abused their power or made technical mistakes which made her job as a defence lawyer too easy! She was on the police's side but couldn't allow them to get away with failing to do their job properly.
John Smith Well, if the police do their jobs properly and she did her job properly, it should all be for the same end goal of justice prevailing 🤷🏼♀️
It would require a very long thread indeed if every police officer related the abuse of power of barristers in Court.
Exactly. Watch John Bercow's Oxford Union address. He wants to hold Parliament to account, they are taking the piss.
She should have resigned or been fired as she could not do her job with an unprofessional and contrary attitude like that.
@@leatherandy No we're disappointed with the police making silly mistakes. The job of the lawyer is to win, the job of government is to make laws and to govern by them. Maybe we should be disappointed with government.
Bercow does nothing but his job, he's the most valuable person in our politics.
Let me guess, are you a remainer?
@@yourmajesty8913 let me guess? your a salty brexiter
@@balthiersgirl2658 I'm confused how the question asked makes em a "salty" brexiter
Love bercow, only parliament member I like.
My favorite Sitcom. I just love John Bercow
He’s literally the Dad who tries to keep the family together lol
He has a certain kind of charisma
@@Mr0Anonymous0 Yes, Satanic charisma.
orDEEEEER
Title it: Everybody Loves Bercow
“Speed has never killed anyone, suddenly becoming stationary… that’s what gets you.”
― Jeremy Clarkson
Clarkson said that? Ironic, in a way.
What has this got to do with Brexit ?
So speeding in a car in a school yard has never killed anyone but parking has? Aight...
JOHN BERCOW: A man of great integrity and enormously competent, and has a wonderful grasp of our beautiful language.
*I'm not a Tory member but I prefer him as a PM over other Conservatives in the House.
@Who Where odorrrrre
I just think he wears very fancy ties. They are always so colourful.
@looes74 looes74 I cannot imagine Trump doing a "Prime Minister's Question where he is obliged to face the likes of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or Nancy Pelosi. That will be more entertaining than the most entertaining SNL skit. 🤣 A guarateed weekly dose of cringy comedy at the expense of the entire nation.
@@JesseMiddletonUK trump x cortez is my favourite anime ship.
Trump doing a weekly PMQ would be horrible. Half the non-answers would just be "That's Fake News", and people might actually vote to keep him in office purely for the weekly entertainment. I wonder if doing the complete opposite would actually have a positive impact; News stations, comedy shows, etc. completely ignoring Trump and his rididulous statements, tweets, etc. Alas I think the news cycle is too far down the rabbit hole to come back up now...
May can't hold parliament hostage, her deal was rejected twice.
It was always going to be hard appeasing everyone. They can still call his bluff and have 3rd vote. If May can get the DUP on board and a few renegade brexiteers it could pass. That's not to say the EU will even allow us to extend after the 29th.
@@ADZ01982 They will find it hard to hold a vote in the house of commons if the Speaker will not table the motion.
@@ADZ01982 EU is still giving them more than enough time, that's why a second referendum is needed, there are those who want to leave and those who don't and the difference isn't that sparse.
A May from the past, tying the hands of the May of today.
Indeed, also failure of next May!
Dont trust even your other pastly century self
Goodness me, yes, I hadn't even made the link!
"We didn't have any forewarning" - WTF? They had since April 2nd 1604! :-)
I love how it isn't proper. Not illegal or anything, just not proper.
That's because the Erskine May are published guidelines, not law.
I dislike that his robe thing isn't symmetrical
Any thoughts on his tie? My assumption (Boris Johnson) is that the hair "style" is the current trend.
@@drmodestoesq Messy hair for a messy time. He's got some colorful ties, none that I find particularly stylish though.
I like how the tie he's wearing is the sequel to the tie he wore during the flashback.
you dont want to see the original trip! it was a baaad trip!
@@drmodestoesq Tradition holds that each new speaker is dragged to his place by his hair. Bercow may believe mussed hair to be part-and-parcel of the office.
Brexit has produced more loopholes than my grandma’s quilt club
The Man deserves a medal! I don't see it as either a leaver or a remainer move - it's just common sense and pragmatism - both of which are quite uncommon in the British Parliament.
Or any Parliament, really...
I haven't .. combed through the whole width and range of British press over this case, since I value my sanity too much. But I'm imagining that not all of them would mention that Bercow of course would be completely out of line - if - he had made a ruling on this without being prodded to do so by a member of the House. And that the reasoning behind the ruling is at least as important as that the precedent for it exists. I mean, in normal circumstances, everyone would see right away that the ruling was not made at a very early time in the process, or as a response to May fielding the proposal, so that it's not actually hostile to the government in that sense, or in any sense, far from it. In the same way, the ruling could have been made much earlier, had that been appropriate like he says, if he wanted to actually sabotage the government. While the "annoyance" with the government just comes from them pushing until a ruling would have to be made -- which then really is running the clock, just as the opposition has accused them of, which prompts the request for the ruling.
So Bercow neither helps or sabotages anyone, but simply produces a ruling on request for an item brought up by a member. That he does this without sounding like he's about to fall asleep is undoubtedly also to the benefit of everyone.
He is even wearing a cape like batman.
Or Pinochet 😁
@@LawrenceTimme I had to google him, but lol ur right :P
Boy Wonder
:)
Or Batcow.
Such a meaningful and proper manner of explaining a convention by what can be considered the best speaker so far in the UK
There seems to be a lot of disagreement on wether there should be a second referendum. Maybe they can have a referendum on wether there should be a second referendum?
Ha, smart thinking, Daniel Huisman. When I try to make a choice about if a 2nd Referendum is valuable and proper, I always end up with one and the same conclusion. The leavers will be very sure of themselves when the vote is for leave and the remainers will sulk for the remaining days of their life, trying to make life miserable for the leavers. The British people love a diet of inhibition and passive agression, to me a recepee for a slow motion failing society.
Haha, nice one Daniel :-)))
@@devonseamoor But supposing a second referendum results in a majority voting to remain?
Ah, we'll get a team together to create a committee to look into this and write a report on it. 👍
Opul3nce is this what they call Project Fear?
You are doing a great job, Mr Speaker John Bercow
This isn’t exactly a surprise though? I think everyone already knew they wouldn’t be able to steamroll their deal through the house over and over and over until it got through
Good riddance, hopefully we can revoke article 50 and not have to deal with No Deal, soon enough.
@Lee Holdsworth Yeah, you do. Firstly because despite what breixteers say you've always gotten various special treatment, secondly because your economy would be knocked down to the point you wouldnt be a considerable world power anymore
yeah, parliament's response that they 'had no forewarning' is bollocks. This is law, not something made up by the house. Ignorance is not an excuse, especially if it's ignorance of the law as prime minister of the country :)
Ginger Jesus .. The democratic vote was leave .. you cannot simply dismiss the vote because you don't like it .. Tough crap my friend .. Why don't you leave and go somewhere like North Korea if you hate democracy so much ..
Nathan Carignan .. the vote was LEAVE.. you cannot simply dismiss it because you don't agree with it .. is that how it works ?? .. do the exact opposite to what was voted for.. hmm so if Labour won the general election..that would be dismissed and second place party would take power ... hmmm ..I don't think so .
I love Bercow's ties
I still think that Bercow saw your vid and article and decided to act :D
Great job man, now get some friggin sleep :D
Yeah; when I saw the Bercow clip on the news, I was thinking "hey, that's like the EXACT thing that TLDR News said might come into play.". I hope TLDR news had a celebratory drink after that before they resumed their suddenly hectic schedule.
God bless speaker John Bercow, the rational adult in the house of commons.
The ONLY rational adult in Parliament.
Make him PM
No the ONLY adult in parliament
He didn't need to shout "Order!" cos everyone agrees with him about May spamming parliament with votes on her crap deal.
There is no other deal on offer. Who thinks otherwise is delusional. Just saying.
He did say order at the end of his speech. Sadly TLDR News cut it before that.
@@Piecemaker1975 True, the EU has the UK over a barrel. If other countries had left it'd be one thing, but with mainland Europe absorbing much of the UK's financial sector there isnt much incentive not to let the UK economy crash and burn
@@Piecemaker1975 agreed, it's No Deal or No Brexit
May is the only one actually doing anything
Erskine May is the basis for many parlamentary regimental laws worldwide! it's heartwarming to see it being enforced!
The speaker is the best person of the house.
Hands down no contest
What about Dennis Skinner?
Bercow is a sexy boi
@@IvO09 Oi, ye got lost within the timestream while travelling from the 1930s? Sorry chap, but yer thinly veiled remarks have no power here. And now chop chop back to 1932, will ya? :D
The chair: “ORDER! MOTHERFUCKER!”
The house: “ORDER!!!!!!”
as I see it, it is not the speaker who is the problem, he just follows the rules, the UK big problem is that MPs can not make a decision, they behave as indecisive children, but take a decision,
Deal or No Deal or stay in EU!
It is like hearing and looking at a kindergarten
Bercow for doing his job well !
It's an impossible decision to make, when considering the hard border of northern Ireland.
There's no way to win. Either there is free border crossing, and thus brexit is irrelevant, or there isn't and the bombings resume.
I honestly see this spelling the end of the UK as we know it. Specifically Scotland leaving and Northern Ireland joining Ireland.
The problem is actually the executive. Beholden to the DUP and fanatical ERG Brexiters to stay in power and keep the party together, May and her cabinet have been putting party above country for two years.
Im Scottish and we've had enough of all this crap
Oh, sweet child of summer.
@@iami3rian394
I wonder, would there ever be a chance for a United Ireland joining with a post UK Scotland? They've got a mutual hatred of England (lulz) and larger countries have economies of scale and clout. It would seem reasonable to me, a Canadian, but is perhaps redundant if they are both in the EU by that time anyway. Just a thought.
Why does may get 2 votes and maybe a 3rd but the British people only get 1
Don't you see the bright future after no-deal brexit?
cause the powers that be dont like EU sniffing their noses into their money laundry.
Because the people voted for option A and option B. May is trying to haggle option A to be as much as option B as humanly possible and being told no every time.
And that is IGNORD
blue boy I’m American so I definitely haven’t been following Brexit as much as you guys but what is the issue with having another public referendum? It seems like Parliament can’t decide on their own. The people have a much better knowledge of what Brexit means now.
If there was a referendum, you could give the people options like:
No Deal Brexit
May’s Deal Brexit
Negotiate with the EU on a different deal
Remain
ORDAAAAAAHHHHHH!
ORRRDAAAAAAAAAHHHHH!
ORRRDDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHH IN THE COMMENT SECTION!!!!!
@@butterflysrage hello, yes, Pie and Mash please.
Russell G 😂
Bercow: ORRDAAAHHH!
People: We would like one brexit please
John Bercow goes to a restaurant.
Waiter: "What would you like to order?"
JB: "Order! Ordeeeer!"
"That's MY word, you can't... Oh, sorry, it isn't my word anymore. I gave it up when I resigned." (Sad Violin music)
Government that refuses to let the people have another vote wants to keep asking the same question over and over in parliament until they get the answer they want.
You have my thanks! Breaking this down to 10 min, which is enough to provide important information but not to long to become boring.
"The government gave a slightly grumpy statement to the press about not being given any forewarning"... the fact that it's been part of parliamentary law for over 400 years wasn't warning enough?
@john daly the economic game of chicken May was playing I'd guess
Also, this WAS the warning. They could have just denied the motion when the government tried to introduce it.
It's a British attitude I find, often shown in all walks of life: instinct driven decisions without foresight, hindsight and self-examination in sync with ignorance. Neanderthalers. It's why there's such drink-drug-abuse I believe.
@@devonseamoor Says the American, I presume?
The government will grumpy say they had no forwarning about the consequences of Brexit either.
Brexit is as confusing as Bercow's tie choice
I think that tie is classy and beautiful.
@@Muenni It might be classy in the Circle of Clowns.
Nah mate, Bercow's tie choice is straightforward: he's having a laugh.
The bold fashion choice of... squares.
NO. THE SPEAKER DID HIS JOB !!!!
Woman from the U.S. here. I'm rooting for you Britain! Stay strong and I'm sure you can right this chaos. This Bercrow guy seems pretty reasonable and I've grown very interested in your government. Stop Brexit! 💖
Hold on, stop brexit? You realise that’s the opposite of what everyone is (supposedly) trying to do, right?
“The plebs love when their betters fight. It’s cheaper than the theatre and the blood is real” - Marcus Brutus, Rome
#4 on trending! I feel like this is where this channel's now gonna take off. Well deserved too. Keep up the good work TLDR.
A point of ORDAAAH!
What he said was entirely in order.
May has deliberately avoided proroguing Parliament - because she doesn’t want a Queens Speech.
Which would get voted on.
Parliament has been in continuous session since June 2017
(There was no State opening or Queens Speech In 2018)
@Agent J I'd like to know that too.
2nd April 1604. What a good day that was!
They first tried to establish the ruling the day before, but no one was taking them seriously. They had to make a point and voted on it a second time :^)
Eh. A little cloudy.
@@TimThomason well this is Britain. Had drizzle too
Exactly 362 years prior to my birth. 😀
James the first has saved us
Isn't this ironic. When mp's vote the result should be respected. What about the referendum?
They're trying to go through with the brexit, aren't they. Apart from the fact that it was nearly a 50-50 and many of the brexiteers acted on misinformation...
So what do you even mean?
@@glom168 You mean, many of the referendum voters voted in accordance with misinformation.
Anne Isopod isn’t it misinformation though? Be it a single bus or a day time TV campaign repeating its rhetoric it is still misinformation that will have been seen by thousands.
“Lying and covering up what the EU does” is misinformation.
Stating facts and figures that aren’t true or regurgitated to fit a rhetoric is still misinformation.
However pleading to a sensational national pride, isn’t misinformation but it is a deadly tool that politicians use,Usually with bad intentions.
There’s just as many misinformed and ignorant people on the remain side as the leave, of that you can be sure.
I literally just searched for this news from TLDR News and it just came out!
Check A Different Bias channel. That guy is properly informed and it releases videos even three times a day. Probably a remainer but far more knowledgeable.
Dunno why everyone is saying this is blocking Brexit. He simply saying don't submit the exact the same deal again! Given he classed the second vote as it being "substantially different", it doesn't seem to take many changes.
The problem is that what TLDR said, it may require renegotiation with the EU. And the EU may not be interested in more talking before the deadline in june.
yes ..but the clock is ticking ..there is no guarentee the EU will allow an extension.. this has put a spanner in the works ..
I m not even British and I have known that rule. So it’s nothing obscure he brought up
Not only is it a rule in the British Parliament but it is a rule in pretty much every parliament and every sort of committee where you have motions etc. It's just sensible.
@@20quid Well unless it's a parliament in the EU then you just keep making the same proposition until you get the right answer.
@@VinceTenia Do you have any evidence to support this or are you just making up fake news like every Brexiteer I have ever spoken to?
@@20quid he's just making shit up.
@@20quid "Every Brexiteer". You know them all so well? 20quid? Try 5 bob note.
Seems quite ballsy. Well done Mr. speaker.
Great video! Can you do one on Northern Ireland specifically and how much the open borders impacts on the EU's decision for Brexit
I think you'll find he's done several on that issue.
@@SaturnusDK I know that it has been brought up in several videos but as someone who lives there I want to know about the DUP influence on the decision and I just find it would be helpful for someone to break down what's going on in a country that's parliament hasn't been in action for three years
200 people of government disliked this video.
well played Bercow
So apparently 1844 isn't enough notice for this government... 😸
1604, bercow just invoked a rule older than most modern countries.
@@spawnof200even older than the UK herself
@@cynic5537 older than GB too infact
I like how the tie he's wearing is the sequel to the tie he wore during the flashback.
No deal please! Get on with it.
I really appreciate your videos, and the effort you're putting in. Thanks to you I have some insight into what is happening with Brexit, as before I have stumbled upon your channel, it was really difficult to understand it. Thank you
Will someone please adjust his robe? It's driving me crazy!
And that silly tie!!!!
Omg me too
Style?!!!@no bot
The speaker did not change anything. He merely enforced an establish rule of Parliamentary procedure. A procedure that May & co should have been aware of prior!
I just love his ties
You should consider putting subtitles on the Parliament clips. It is quite difficult to catch everything said for non-Brits.
The speaker followed precedent, clearly laid down in Erskine May, the rules of the House; he could do nothing else.
Hear, hear! What a man is Bercow. Everytime I learn something new about him, I find him to be better than before
Great video 👍🏻 could you do one on why even though it seemed that parliament had voted to take no deal off the table completely, it seems still to be very much on the table. Cheers
HA! Great observation, reminds me of that boy calling "Look, the emperor has no clothes on", shattering all pretence in the audience around him.
Simple - that vote was only an indication of parliaments' inclination on the matter. It did nothing to change the fact that, without an extension to Article 50, no deal is the legal default which happens on 29th March.
Ah I see, cheers kvsm
oh, now it all becomes clear. I always thought he was yelling "HODOR" :-D
Bercow did not change anything.
It is a long standing rule which broke May's misbegotten tactic. A tactic based on intransparency, ambiguity and dereliction of securing parliamentary support in due time. It was clear from the beginning that such an approach will fail in the UK. As the UK is a parliamentary system. Did the Prime Minister not know that ? Or did she really think that she will be able to put forward the same motion again and again until the result will please her ? By Jove, what an uninformed person !
What a guy! Love from Holland across the North Sea.
So early it can only be watched in 360p :D
Miguel Ángel Luque Martín : Thought it was my internet
oh good, it's not just me. I thought my PC was messing with me.
You can re-watch it at 144p.
@@evthink personally, I think its time they released videos on VHS, by post.
You lucky duck
Bercow didn’t change the future of Brexit, the rules did.
Bercow is, however, a representative of the rules.
Pretty sure parliament could happily ignore the rules if they weren’t reminded
It's a lot to ask, but if we can borrow this guy for a year, he just might save the American republic...
Trump: I'll declare an emergency to...
Bercow: OOOOORRRRRRRDAAAAAAHHHH!
Kit Thornton - Nah thanks... America is doing great.
I don't think I've ever seen the entire house this quiet
It's also amazing that after having lost to everyone, May acomplishes the feat of even losing Bercow's patience. The feats of this woman!
Yes, and she wears such silly shoes on her feats.
Like Corbyn said...S#%^d woman.
Luis Dias Is there any significance to her necklaces becoming larger. I think it’s a symbol of some kind.
Glenda Kirby probably nicer than your shoes
@@yourmajesty8913 Damn that was weak lol
A great Parliamentarian. Well done from New Zealand.
Vid starts at 0:18
The deal and all are pretty cool but look at that tie! Snazzy!
Isn’t it ironic that May won’t call a second referendum but she will continue to call for her deal until she gets the result she wants.
Rules for thee but for me..
@Old Monty "Are you sure?" basically a proper etiquette ignored because of some high-horse morale ideals? And what the hell is so wrong of making sure? Is your democracy and people that weak minded to be so easily swayed that it incite some radical extremist movement?
@Old Monty
But why can May have as much repeated votes as she likes?
And why can she delay a vote for months knowing she will loose it?
@Old Monty
The referendum showed a very close call.
The UK is divided to the core about this matter.
And yes, leave means a fundamental change to society, remain a continuation of the current situation.
The leave camp is divided in protectionists and globalists, two contradictory standpoints, and remain sits in between.
So in fact there is no majority at all.
That is why the government should have looked at consensus, what policy can get a very wide support in the population.
They did not.
What I think is the most impressiv:
a news reporter made a difference.
If Theresa May does finally resign, I hope Bercow gets to be PM. He seems like a good lad.
Sorry it doesn't work like that
This is why i get my news on CZcams . Goodjob
He can never keep his jacket on proper
I love yer profile pic I reconize the British stick drawing by cpg grey
Lol
@@stormlecat6421 i commented on his video that he should make shirts of it lol
He's taken lessons on looking dishevelled from Boris Johnson.
@@vladsnape6408 That fellow looks as if he doesn't know what a comb is. And his clothes are terrible.
can we just talk about how the cameraman really doesn't need to move like he's filming life on earth and just keep it still tho?
Speaker Bercow lays down the law!
Bercow is brilliant. As are his ties.
Can we just initiate article 61 of the Magna Carta if that's still around?
It's rare for me to reply on comments here, but I believe it's necessary this time. I have read your views on the current situation that we've been dealt and fully respect the opinion. Going back to your point on invoking article 61 of the Magna Carta...I can firmly declare myself and the entire country; halfwits and a bunch of zombie-like buffoons with no grasp of the actual turmoil we are in, if we ever revisited that time. It would be a step backwards in search for hope rather than the answers we so desperately need right now.
Just to put this out there, the European elections are in May (23*-26*), Mrs Theresa May wanted her deal to be accepted before April, giving the country some time to stitch up the last bit of loose ends with the European Community. however, she's had a Parliament with no bravado to save our country, so they all bottled it entirely...on a nationwide emergency. over the last two years it seems they've all been blindfolded by the Europeans and told to open them when Mr. Donald Tusk claps his hands.
I would not envy John Bercow's position nor wish to ever sit in that chair, but I respect the gravity and extreme challenge involved in the expectations his job.
No deal is going to happen 👍
I hope the EU say no extension to article 50. No deal.
MaccaBackPacker agreed
Awesome job you're doing here mate! Congratulations and keep it going!