Why Websites Ask You To Download An App

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 19. 01. 2023
  • Visit www.brilliant.org/TechQuickie/ to get started learning STEM for free, and the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual premium subscription.
    Why do websites constantly bug you with annoying requests to download their apps?
    Leave a reply with your requests for future episodes.
    ► GET MERCH: lttstore.com
    ► AFFILIATES, SPONSORS & REFERRALS: lmg.gg/tqsponsors
    ► PODCAST GEAR: lmg.gg/podcastgear
    ► SUPPORT US ON FLOATPLANE: www.floatplane.com/
    FOLLOW US ELSEWHERE
    ---------------------------------------------------
    Twitter: / linustech
    Facebook: / linustech
    Instagram: / linustech
    TikTok: / linustech
    Twitch: / linustech
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 665

  • @maacpiash
    @maacpiash Před rokem +243

    Web developer here. The libraries and build tools used nowadays to develop websites, or web apps (as I like to call it) can optimise them to the point where they can deliver almost all the necessary features of a native mobile app without significant performance drop. If a website pushes its users to install its app, it means the company behind the website definitely wants to track the visitors more closely.

    • @1nikolas
      @1nikolas Před rokem +8

      i was thinking the same. Almost all the APIs can be accessed through a browser now

    • @InfernosReaper
      @InfernosReaper Před rokem +9

      @@1nikolas It's been that way for a while, too, and most sites don't even do anything special that should call for an app in the first place
      It's all about screwing the users.

    • @mightycoderx
      @mightycoderx Před rokem

      PWAs are just like apps, they can access the file system and send notifications

    • @DarthGTB
      @DarthGTB Před rokem +2

      They purposely make a terrible job with their mobile web pages to force you to use the app for features too. My company has one app, but dozens of web apps for both employees and customers that were designed to work like an app (or else we would have to give macs to the developers so we could build iOS apps)

  • @blackraen
    @blackraen Před rokem +1401

    The real reason: It's easier to collect and harvest your data with a local app vs. a webpage.

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem +144

      And ensures adverts are less-likely to be blocked, and so they can bombard you with notifications

    • @ent2220
      @ent2220 Před rokem +81

      Exactly. "It has more direct access to your phone" as stated in the video is exactly why I don't want any apps installed. I'd rather use the desktop site if i have to and zoom in and out than use those cursed apps

    • @1IGG
      @1IGG Před rokem +3

      Exactly.

    • @sireuchre
      @sireuchre Před rokem +14

      It allows them to ask you for permissions of their own, rather than live within the permissions you already set on the browser, which means the browser is your first of 2 lines of defense of privacy and against malicious actions.

    • @Miwna
      @Miwna Před rokem +7

      The root reason is always money.

  • @PhillipParr
    @PhillipParr Před rokem +1132

    The problem is that most of the pushy ones are all just the website in a webview, making no difference at all. Most of the corps I've worked with are binning off native apps because it's cheaper for them to run a webview and slim down the app team. And possibly worse still - some apps have no website, so for example, when you're sat next to a 32" 4K monitor and get a bit peckish, Starship forces you to use their slow clunky app.

    • @gfrewqpoiu
      @gfrewqpoiu Před rokem +61

      And even for those webviews performance can vary wildly. Some you barely notice anything, some are god awful slow. Looking at you, Amazon.

    • @YounesLayachi
      @YounesLayachi Před rokem +59

      this is the LAST of the problems, users should not be forced to use an app, when an equivalent website exists or can exists.
      It doesn't matter how good or bad the app is, the entire idea is to not use redundant apps

    • @faealiciadotsys
      @faealiciadotsys Před rokem +54

      This problem is only compounded by the fact that most of these websites are so riddled with spyware and whatnot that, if removed, speed wouldn't actually be a concern and the site could load in a decent time even over a 2G connection or something. I remember when the EU first came out with the rules on accepting/denying cookies and all the commercial spaces scrambled to get their sites into compliance. Many of them took the most basic approach and just put up a barebones site sans the trackers at first. Being in the USA and loading those barebones sites either via adding "eu" into the url somewhere or by using a proxy made it just so much easier to browse the web for a while until they figured out how to re-add all that tracker bloat.
      I remember loading up the EU version of The Guardian at one point and it was lightning fast. Literally a fraction of a second on a 100Mbps connection on desktop. The US version of the site took at least two seconds. Both versions of the site looked and functioned the same. It was all tracker bloat. Even today, using EU versions of sites via proxies or whatever can result in better speeds and better privacy than those of us stuck in the "land of freedom" where corporations control our every step. Imagine the latency caused by the data having to go across the ocean and you're still loading pages faster than if you loaded the version stored on that local CDN half a state away. The state of web design and usage has been utterly ruined by corporations and the EU cookies thing *really* showed that off to the world.

    • @AdamOutler
      @AdamOutler Před rokem +8

      You should see what sensors are available without any permissions. Did you know they can read your battery, charger, alarm, and position sensors? They can tell if you're the kind of person who lays in bed using your phone all night, how much sleep you get, and if you only plug in your phone when the battery hits 10%.

    • @billyhatcher643
      @billyhatcher643 Před rokem +12

      i hate using apps now since phones no longer have external sd cards to store photos and videos means that ur seriously limited on how many things we can have installed on our phones

  • @thekingofawesomeness9173
    @thekingofawesomeness9173 Před rokem +325

    My favorite part is when they straight lock you out of the sight without logging in or using the app. I just leave every time

    • @Terandium
      @Terandium Před rokem +27

      Funnily enough, Instagram, Facebook and Twitter do this. As I have deleted my FB, Insta I barely use so im not logged in on pc. And Twitter im not logged in either

    • @sihamhamda47
      @sihamhamda47 Před rokem +2

      @@Terandium They do it for blocking any unknown stalkers who are attempted to explore someone's account without logging in

    • @kabiskac
      @kabiskac Před rokem +41

      @@sihamhamda47 they can just. Maybe. Make an. Account?

    • @facundootero7973
      @facundootero7973 Před rokem

      Twitch does it

    • @AndreasElf
      @AndreasElf Před rokem +10

      If they only block because you don't use the app on phone. Request the desktop version of the site and it should work.

  • @eldibs
    @eldibs Před rokem +356

    I remember a while back, the nagging "download our app" interstitial messages/ads got so bad that Google had to change their search results to punish sites that were using them. Remember clicking a link on Google, only to get a full screen ad suggesting the website's app, and when you close the ad it took you to the site's home page rather than the content you wanted?

    • @ZaHandle
      @ZaHandle Před rokem +21

      Twitter

    • @imnotdavidxnsx
      @imnotdavidxnsx Před rokem +20

      This still happens constantly

    • @swawif
      @swawif Před rokem +12

      Twitter actually have been pretty useable in web form. It's how I've been using it for a while on mobile.

    • @SoulDuckling126
      @SoulDuckling126 Před rokem

      Quora be like, but it's a horrible community of stupid people pretending to be smart so nothing of value loss.

    • @ZaHandle
      @ZaHandle Před rokem +10

      BTW there is nitter for browsing twitter without an account or app
      Very useful tool

  • @RobBulmahn
    @RobBulmahn Před rokem +385

    This completely ignores the fact that many of these apps are just wrappers for the same old website, and many of the benefits listed here of using apps apply just as easily to web-based systems (local storage, location, user preference tracking, etc.)

    • @stonebubbleprivat
      @stonebubbleprivat Před rokem +9

      Yes, service worker, offline-first cache strategy and push notifications, camera or bluetooth are also available. And coding an native app doesn't provide a speed advantage you notice for most apps.

    • @arjundureja
      @arjundureja Před rokem +24

      I think the main reason is to make you come back frequently. By having that icon on your home screen, you're more likely to open the app and use it. Compared to opening your browser and going to that specific URL.

    • @thewiirocks
      @thewiirocks Před rokem +6

      @@arjundureja Also, they can send you push notifications. Which shoots the probability of you engaging with the app through the roof.

    • @szymex22
      @szymex22 Před rokem +4

      @@thewiirocks websites can too with permission

    • @johnsmithe4656
      @johnsmithe4656 Před rokem +7

      @@szymex22 But we never give them that permission. It's new on the Web, it's the status quo with mobile.

  • @mind-of-neo
    @mind-of-neo Před rokem +78

    Whether it's for "my benefit" or not, i hate being told how to use a website or service.

    • @OrangoTheAndro
      @OrangoTheAndro Před rokem +4

      Pro Tip: Use desktop mode
      is pretty clunky but it works

    • @jamesphillips2285
      @jamesphillips2285 Před rokem +1

      @@OrangoTheAndro Problem is a lot of sites automatically redirect you to the mobile site if they detect a mobile browser.

    • @OrangoTheAndro
      @OrangoTheAndro Před rokem +3

      @@jamesphillips2285 No,
      In all browsers i've used there is an option in the 3 dots to enable desktop mode making websites think you're on an arm Linux computer with weird tastes in monitors

    • @jamesphillips2285
      @jamesphillips2285 Před rokem +2

      @@OrangoTheAndro TBF: Android IS a weird Linux distro with a weird taste in monitors.

    • @lottery248
      @lottery248 Před rokem

      the only exception is when you have never touched the internet before.

  • @necropolistc6357
    @necropolistc6357 Před rokem +223

    an app makes it easier to track your data than a web browser who's metadata you can delete, its all about that ad revenue and data stealing

    • @g0d638
      @g0d638 Před rokem

      No its not. Stop thinking everyone is trying to spy on you. the only reason companies push aps a lot is that they make it easier to sell you more stuff

    • @whyops9862
      @whyops9862 Před rokem +30

      @@g0d638 isn't That exactly the same thing as what he just said in the comment?

    • @DaveMcIroy
      @DaveMcIroy Před rokem

      A web browser is an app. 🙄🤡

    • @Stache987
      @Stache987 Před rokem

      What I dislike is either method asks my location when I try to visit either way, I have to change my location as my wifi connection at home is dynamic and served from 320 miles away, and not any of the more populis 4 locations 250 or less miles away.. my "brick and mortar" shopping is about 40 miles away, I have to keep a record of zip codes to change this EVERY visit.. and it's funny that ad servers embedded always offer as if I'm up in Minneapolis and I'm down off of I-80 in Iowa

    • @WhenDoesTheVideoActuallyStart
      @WhenDoesTheVideoActuallyStart Před rokem

      @@DaveMcIroy Are you being deliberately dense or are you just stupid? A web page can't control the web browser, and can't directly access your microphone, data, etc... it has to go through the web browser. Demanding you download an app evades all of these protections and gives them direct access to your hardware. It decreases your phone's safety so that they can gobble up more of your data and profile you/their customer base.

  • @chaosfenix
    @chaosfenix Před rokem +59

    And this is why I refuse to install most commercial apps on my phone. 80% of the apps I use are open source versions. The rest are apps that are harder to replace because they don't have good alternatives or tie into hardware that I have specifically purchased.

    • @USS_Sentinel
      @USS_Sentinel Před rokem +13

      Not to mention, a lot of commercial apps are simply piles of crap.

    • @iris4547
      @iris4547 Před rokem +1

      this was great back in the prime years of windows phone. so many of the major players didnt develop an app for windows phone but then along came a 3rd party that made apps that were an order of magnitude better than the official ones. so for most apps the best experience of the 3 platforms was on windows phone. its a shame it didnt last.

    • @KofolaDealer
      @KofolaDealer Před rokem +1

      @@iris4547 It's the same today, all of the apps I use are third party except the microsoft ones which are fine

  • @YdenMk-II
    @YdenMk-II Před rokem +51

    That brand awareness thing is a very traditional trick. Back when I worked at Target, the employee training said we should ask if customers wanted a Target card because they wanted people to have the brand visible whenever the person opens up their wallets.

  • @dside_ru
    @dside_ru Před rokem +93

    Websites *can* in fact store stuff locally as well as send notifications when they aren't running. There's a whole concept of PWA, basically apps running in browsers. So I'm with the "can't-adblock" theory 🙂

    • @iris4547
      @iris4547 Před rokem +2

      ive never actually bothered to look into ad blocking on my phone, but surely there is a method similar to the hosts file in windows that can do adblocking system wide?

    • @dside_ru
      @dside_ru Před rokem +2

      @@iris4547 there's private DNS (on Android anyway), which is largely equivalent to the hosts file. But there's only so much that can do. An ad served from the same domain name as the useful parts would still make it through, as by blocking that you'd break the app.

    • @dside_ru
      @dside_ru Před rokem +1

      So apps that connect to 3rd party ad networks can be kinda cleaned up this way, but apps by companies that serve you ads of their own (upselling you on their own or affiliated more expensive plans or extra services) cannot.

    • @neoney
      @neoney Před rokem +1

      I wish they could. iOS has no push api support still.

    • @dside_ru
      @dside_ru Před rokem +2

      @@neoney (sighs) well, yeah. There are no modern browsers on iOS at all. Add that to the list of reasons to force third-party app installs unto Apple devices. Let's see what's about to go down in the EU!

  • @ashgaming8176
    @ashgaming8176 Před rokem +31

    *when a website tells you to get the app but it's not on the platform you're using*

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem +2

      Maybe stop using Windows Phone, Blackberry or Nokia Series 40 or 60 thesedays then?
      Or on PC, make sure you're not visiting the mobile-version of the website?

    • @sharoyveduchi
      @sharoyveduchi Před rokem +6

      @@dftfire I want options OTHER than android and iOS
      Also this happens with people using ARM SBCs like Raspberry Pi. Some websites see you're using an ARM CPU and they ask you to use an app.

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem

      @@sharoyveduchi That may change now that Apple have moved macOS devices to ARM. (Though you can run iOS and iPadOS apps on a mac, so I guess they could offer you the app)
      Windows 11 can run Android apps also.
      You could just install a browser extension that would make your header and user-agents report to be a non-ARM platform too.

  • @BakersTuts
    @BakersTuts Před rokem +6

    The worst is when you download a company’s app, and when you click on a link or something, it opens up an in-app browser of their mobile website anyway. Like wtf dude. What’s the point of an app if it just opens a mobile browser inside the app.

    • @BakersTuts
      @BakersTuts Před rokem

      FYI it’s my mobile carrier that does this when I click on “view data usage” or “view bill” or something like that

    • @mearetom
      @mearetom Před rokem +2

      I agree, It's pointless and "lazy"

  • @Lurker-dk8jk
    @Lurker-dk8jk Před rokem +36

    It's funny when you install an app that only sends you to a webpage to do the thing the app should be doing on its own.

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem +2

      Sometimes that is due to rules about what Apple or Google permit in an app

    • @taradid409
      @taradid409 Před rokem

      CVS did that's me and I'm like why the fuck do I have this app if you're sending me to the webpage and then I dunciad. And now I don't download any apps that people ask although I didn't really before. Although that take up space on your phone they clog your screen. And their bullshit. I wish there was a way I could prevent them from asking me to add their app.

  • @TonyP9279
    @TonyP9279 Před rokem +35

    The worst thing I hate about apps is that some of them force you to update before you go any further. Yes, I know some will inform you that an update is available but will let you use the old one for awhile, but others will just stop working until you update. Guess when this usually happens...right! When I'm at the checkout line where I need to use it then.

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem

      By default, iOS and Android update apps automatically, in the background, when your phone is on Wi-Fi. If you turn that off, you will have to manually look for updates. That's not really the app makers fault then, surely?

    • @ent2220
      @ent2220 Před rokem +10

      @@dftfire Yes it is because the devs are the ones who have made it so that you must be on version X.X to run their app. I've had apps that have been on a version that was 2 years old and they still worked.

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem

      @@ent2220 Yes, but if the app had auto-updates in the background, you wouldn't then have an issue when you next opened it. Sometimes apps have security issues and cannot allow users to remain using an older version forever, or the older version is not compatible with a newer Android or iOS release. If you want to update apps manually, when you say so only, that's your choice but you must expect some apps to eventually not work

    • @rocketman7334
      @rocketman7334 Před rokem +2

      And the absolute worst case is... when you need the app to work right then & there, the app won't work until updated, and something is keeping you from updating, like having OS software that just became marked "obsolete," or no longer supported by the app developer.

  • @nikzuLP
    @nikzuLP Před rokem +42

    Slight correction: It is possible for websites to send push notifications too, just like apps can.

    • @TheBrain2K
      @TheBrain2K Před rokem +14

      Websites nowadays can also request location data, use mic/camera, etc. (all based on permissions set per website, just like with apps).
      There are basically no reasons (from a user perspective) for apps that are just a frontend alternative to a website.
      Yes, their laggy/messy "fully responsive" UI layouting will maybe run an order of magnitude faster if it's not running in a browser. But that doesn't change the fact that it's three orders of magnitudes too inefficient to begin with...

    • @user-jz8po2eu2d
      @user-jz8po2eu2d Před rokem +3

      not yet on iOS

    • @ikuturso7570
      @ikuturso7570 Před rokem +2

      @@user-jz8po2eu2dThey have "worked on it" for years if I recall right. I quite often wonder what the software engineers at Apple actually do...

    • @thedopplereffect00
      @thedopplereffect00 Před rokem +1

      But you have to opt in instead of opt out

    • @MysteriousMusician33
      @MysteriousMusician33 Před rokem

      @@ikuturso7570well that is very often a downside. As someone working in a phone store, there are so many people getting scammed or having their phones flooded with spam and adult content because random websites they visit get notifications. The use case is fairly limited and the risks are high. I doubt apple wants to add that as a feature.

  • @kuromiLayfe
    @kuromiLayfe Před rokem +94

    Sadly CZcams never got the message that an app is supposed to run better then the website… issues with the app version not on the web version (extra buffering, lower amount of buffering, app not utilising cookies or cache to show accurate ads or suggestions, lower quality videos, PiP functionality only works if it feels like it, notifications sometimes delayed by 10-80 minutes…)

    • @zaubermaus8190
      @zaubermaus8190 Před rokem +19

      the fact that the app functions vastly different than the web version is even worse...

    • @gus473
      @gus473 Před rokem

      CZcams runs great on my Pixel 7, and it was almost as good on my old Moto G4 Play.... ಠಿ⁠_⁠ಠ

    • @sanekibeko
      @sanekibeko Před rokem

      I had a ton of issues with the iOS and Android CZcams app back in the day. Now I use Kiwi with an Ad Blocker lol.

    • @YounesLayachi
      @YounesLayachi Před rokem +2

      most big corp apps are trash by design. See twitter, the website puts the app to shame

  • @alexatkin
    @alexatkin Před rokem +7

    What really winds me up is how a lot of sites that DO have a usable website, have also switched it to function more like the app, making it an inferior experience to what they used to be.

  • @actiasselene773
    @actiasselene773 Před rokem +12

    For me biggest advantage of using browser instead of dedicated apps is to take advantage of adblocker installed to browser (using firefox mobile). Most apps are full ads nowadays.

  • @heclanet
    @heclanet Před rokem +12

    The reason is to "accept permissions" for your whole life!
    When on a website one can refuse the use of cookies

  • @anewbimproves5622
    @anewbimproves5622 Před rokem +84

    All of those benefits to the user can be done in the browser with a combination of Responsive Design, the various browser apis, and Local Storage.

    • @nicolaicornelis2853
      @nicolaicornelis2853 Před rokem +5

      Not really. Sure, some apps would be just as good as a website, but definitely not all.

    • @JaredMeadows
      @JaredMeadows Před rokem +14

      I was thinking the same thing, all these points WERE true many years ago, but today, you can install a responsive web page as a full fledged app, receive notifications, the works...

    • @Janiik
      @Janiik Před rokem +4

      @@nicolaicornelis2853 its the opposite. the only apps that you truly need are those which run offline or are messaging apps. just look at PCs from 10 years ago, there was no CZcams or Tiktok App and it still worked fine.

    • @nicolaicornelis2853
      @nicolaicornelis2853 Před rokem +1

      @@Janiik It's not. There are so many things you just cannot do with a browser - or that if you do, you're going to have worse results. I've done both, and I can tell you with no uncertainty that native apps are far superior to websites for many cases.

    • @Janiik
      @Janiik Před rokem

      @@nicolaicornelis2853 still waiting for examples

  • @seadeep42
    @seadeep42 Před rokem +12

    All the disadvantages are because Apple consciously chose to make their App store better than Safari.
    Web push notifications, PWAs with offline support, Add to home screen, Web bluetooth are all a thing but Apple chooses to not support them or make them worse because they don't get a 30% from websites.
    Open Web Advocacy is fighting to change that.

  • @damionknt
    @damionknt Před rokem +16

    what i hate is a site trying to get me to download their app when im on my desktop . doesnt happen all the time but enough to make me wonder what they are doing lol

    • @dftfire
      @dftfire Před rokem

      If you have the web browser window resized very narrow, it sometimes assumes the width means you're on a mobile device. Or you could have a browser extension that is causing it

    • @AndreasElf
      @AndreasElf Před rokem +1

      Don't think I've seen this.

  • @LadyRenira
    @LadyRenira Před rokem +9

    Even better is when it redirects you to the app you already have installed and doesn't allow you to open it in the browser at all, then the app continues to fail over and over. Looking at you, Best Buy and Newegg.

    • @USS_Sentinel
      @USS_Sentinel Před rokem +3

      This is why I use the desktop websites. The apps are GARBAGE.

    • @CreativityNull
      @CreativityNull Před rokem +2

      Yup, especially if it's like a product link and then it just takes you to the main page, hell I've had Newegg do that when trying to open their app notifications.

    • @ireallyreallyreallylikethisimg
      @ireallyreallyreallylikethisimg Před rokem

      That is so fucking stupid 💀💀

  • @asiano3385
    @asiano3385 Před rokem +3

    That is why I use desktop mode on phone whenever it is possible. I hate mobile version of web pages... also because they are sometimes very limited.

  • @gringo5282
    @gringo5282 Před rokem +8

    Websites can send push notifications to your phone just like a normal app. They can also access your camera, sensors, filesystem, etc. Additionally, they are able to cache data locally so the next time you load the site it displays content much faster than it would the first time. Hell, you can even add the website to your home screen like a regular app. Clunky websites aren't necessarily an issue with the browser, but is more often than not attributed to poor optimization. For most use cases such as social media, shopping, or news, a PWA works just as good as a regular app. I would go as far as saying that for the most part, traditional apps that don't perform any special operations are obsolete.

    • @johnsmithe4656
      @johnsmithe4656 Před rokem

      But the marketing strategy isn't obsolete. $$$$$$$ 🤑

    • @gringo5282
      @gringo5282 Před rokem

      @@johnsmithe4656 From a corporate perspective, you are very much right. However, for most consumers, getting tracked more and making it harder to block ads isn't necessarily a reason to download an app.

  • @t2dev
    @t2dev Před rokem +5

    Making it easier for apps to data mine your personal information and other data you don't want to share.

  • @14croper
    @14croper Před rokem +37

    I was watching this video and also I got a notification on my phone that an app was not responding. I just can't get over how hilarious this is.

    • @oeufleau8543
      @oeufleau8543 Před rokem

      Typical android user

    • @johnsmithe4656
      @johnsmithe4656 Před rokem

      @@oeufleau8543 Typical Windows Phone user

    • @mohsinuddin7049
      @mohsinuddin7049 Před rokem

      You must be using a cheap Android phone (no offence). iPhones are incredibly fast and well optimised. Their apps never stop responding.

  • @jandraelune1
    @jandraelune1 Před rokem +2

    You forgot to mention that using an app requires you to create an account and login. What you don't want to do either but just browse for some quick news.

  • @ChatBot1337
    @ChatBot1337 Před rokem +7

    Some sites make it almost mandatory. Off the top of my noggin, Home Depot and Lowes to a lesser extent have an awful mobile browsing experience, but their apps are a breeze. Amazon, while not bad on a browser, is much more betterer on the app.

    • @GameCyborgCh
      @GameCyborgCh Před rokem +4

      I wish they would get it in their head that everytime there website needs more than 1 click to access what you want to see, a lot of people will just leave

    • @flameshana9
      @flameshana9 Před rokem

      @@GameCyborgCh They don't mind, and in fact they prefer that. Customers that are picky are not good customers. They have so many people coming to their site/app they can actually kick out the ones they don't want.
      Small companies don't have this luxury so they aren't as aggressive.

    • @ChatBot1337
      @ChatBot1337 Před rokem

      Disagree. For any company to bend over backwards for that one extra sale and not simply optimize their online presence so they can weed out picky customers is insane. I can walk into most corporate stores with a product they don't even sell and get some store credit. Kroger used to do it, Costco did it for a long time and still might, Sam's and Walmart do it as of a year or so ago (this according to friends and family that work at these places). Incremental sales, i.e. the candy bar at checkout, are a huge thing. But they don't care about their website being difficult because it weeds out the quitters? No shot.

  • @stevedotwav
    @stevedotwav Před rokem +4

    If their website is that poorly written, i don't wanna try their app

    • @flameshana9
      @flameshana9 Před rokem +1

      "But this works better in our app!"

  • @harshbarj
    @harshbarj Před rokem +4

    I don't mind asking. I do mind when they disable the use of a webpage and DEMAND you use the app. But that's what desktop mode is for.

  • @bluuscreen6533
    @bluuscreen6533 Před rokem

    Love the work y'all at LMG do, great quality content, thank you! If you are looking for another Techquickie topic, I've always wondered what exactly is going on under the hood when you click "perform maintenance" on Windows with each generation?

  • @chrisogrady28
    @chrisogrady28 Před rokem +2

    When downloading an app it should give an auto-delete option such as 'after this use', 'after 1 day', 'after 1 week'. Etc

  • @ProjSHiNKiROU
    @ProjSHiNKiROU Před rokem +1

    The annoyance of website apps is the greatest when I’m just Googling for information on my mobile browser.

  • @LilSesh
    @LilSesh Před rokem +4

    You know what makes websites faster? Programmers who give a crap about what they are doing, and maybe even know a little bit about it too.

    • @WhenDoesTheVideoActuallyStart
      @WhenDoesTheVideoActuallyStart Před rokem

      But that costs money, and today companies want free lunch/rentism, profiting without spending almost anything.

    • @ent2220
      @ent2220 Před rokem +1

      I can confirm. Everyone in my field just takes pre-made stuff and their code is bad even with that. I on the other hand love to do stuff my scratch and my code is always as optimal, bullet-proof and easy to read as possible. My stuff always runs really good and no glitches. I've had stuff released still on version 1.0 because there is nothing that needs fixing.

  • @Dominus_Potatus
    @Dominus_Potatus Před rokem +3

    In short, they want to profile you and sell your usage to ads company

  • @RageQuitSon
    @RageQuitSon Před rokem +25

    A pizza app refused to function because I had a remote access app installed... So I refused to give them anymore money.
    My bread machine makes pizza dough. I'm enjoying this turn of events. (It was the papa Murphy's app so I had to bake the pizza anyway, not much more work to make the dough too)

    • @mokisan
      @mokisan Před rokem +1

      What fr? For me they cause issue if its rooted

    • @USS_Sentinel
      @USS_Sentinel Před rokem +9

      I usually just call pizza places myself. Fuck apps.

    • @RCmaniac667
      @RCmaniac667 Před rokem

      @@mokisan magisk hide don't work?

    • @mokisan
      @mokisan Před rokem

      @@RCmaniac667 ya thats what I have to do. And even magisk hide is bit iffy. Because many apps scan the app list then you have to hide the app and all shenanigans.

    • @johnsmithe4656
      @johnsmithe4656 Před rokem

      @@USS_Sentinel I use web sites. Thing about the phone is you often don't know the deals ahead of time and don't get special offers for being part of their little business cult.

  • @ninjal7588
    @ninjal7588 Před rokem +1

    Worst part is when websites do this when I am on a desktop and their website is only an ad for the app, can't do anything on the website and it's not like they have a windows/macOS app.

  • @quasigod1083
    @quasigod1083 Před rokem +4

    With modern PWAs websites should be capable of running nearly as well, but many companies are choosing not to make use of this

  • @sireuchre
    @sireuchre Před rokem +7

    Let's talk about how the apps love to ask to take over basic functions of your phone (at least on Android), like being your Home Screen or Messaging app. Once they do that, you'll be bombarded with ads and notifications to a degree you've never seen before, and they have access to basically everything you do on your phone or store on your phone. The 'use our app' culture is supporting a lot of scummy exploitative behavior.

    • @HibiTeamQueso
      @HibiTeamQueso Před rokem

      I have all notifications off except from Whatsapp. Best decision ever

  • @meqativ
    @meqativ Před rokem +3

    1:38 * cough* discord *cough *

  • @nikatto8
    @nikatto8 Před rokem +1

    And advertisement on CZcams have this too, "This is the app your phone is hungry for" weird

  • @diggingattycho7908
    @diggingattycho7908 Před rokem +2

    How many apps can you put on your phone? It seems to me after a while this would get a little nuts.

  • @elbiggus
    @elbiggus Před rokem +2

    With a few exceptions most apps are just a browser that only allows you to visit the specific website minus useful features like multiple tabs, bookmarking, translation, etc. If a site nags me too often to use their app (or enable notifications, or sign up to a mailing list) I will just stop using it...

  • @apenguin7779
    @apenguin7779 Před rokem +7

    They would probably be better off not doing this. Most people would respect them more for not doing this.

    • @johnsmithe4656
      @johnsmithe4656 Před rokem +1

      But they'd make less money so no. Do it. Doitdoitdoit!

  • @Sylkis89
    @Sylkis89 Před rokem +1

    You absolutely can make a web page feed notifications yo your browser even if the page is off, assuming your browser allows for it and that this functionality is not switched off. I used to get double notifications that way a lot back in 2013-2018 era before I bothered to learn to block it and then bothered to actually block it on every new phone I'd get

  • @imagineeelego
    @imagineeelego Před rokem +1

    As a web developer, I know about the large amount of apis which can make your website a near native app. And many companies should use these features.

    • @shezzor
      @shezzor Před rokem +1

      Completely agree but companies care less about the user experience and features to the control a native app provides.

  • @anonymouschicken20
    @anonymouschicken20 Před rokem +9

    I just want the website but OH, THERE IS AN APP UGHHHHH. Like my iPhone has enough space for gajillions of apps.

  • @ekauq2000
    @ekauq2000 Před rokem +22

    I had a thought about this, with the issues with app reviews from both Apple and Google, and wanting to have purchases on mobile, would Floatplane benefit from being a PWA instead of a dedicated app?

    • @InventorZahran
      @InventorZahran Před rokem +5

      iOS doesn't handle PWAs very well... Which is ironic when you consider that the first iPhone didn't have an app store (or any means of installing third-party software). Steve Jobs and his team thought PWAs with shortcuts on the home screen were better than native apps, so they told developers to "make iPhone-shaped web pages that look and behave like apps" (not a direct quotation). But this system didn't work very well, and the second version of iOS introduced the App Store.

    • @MarcusH...
      @MarcusH... Před rokem +3

      Video streaming pretty much always works better in apps on mobile devices though. I prefer using my web browser over an app for most things, but if i'm gonna watch streamed video on my phone or tablet i always prefer an app

    • @thewiirocks
      @thewiirocks Před rokem +1

      @@InventorZahran There are a couple of PWAs I use on iPadOS, including Visual Studio Code. Seems to work just fine as long as the site is properly built for it.

  • @prototypedenNIS
    @prototypedenNIS Před rokem +1

    I recently got an A7 Lite Tab.
    It automatically brought over the apps from my phone.
    I had noticed about running out of storage on day 1, "maybe delete some photos."
    APPS... Few things actually HAVE to be an app but every company is pushing you to have this bloated software.

  • @rvmiv_
    @rvmiv_ Před rokem +1

    The next site that blocks my view to get me to download an app is getting perma-blocked by my adblock

  • @unvergebeneid
    @unvergebeneid Před rokem +4

    "assuming you haven't opted out"
    TikTok has entered the chat.

  • @vladislavkaras491
    @vladislavkaras491 Před rokem

    Thanks for explaining!

  • @amitgirimaji
    @amitgirimaji Před rokem

    Atleast single channel who still makes short and crisp videos

  • @dave0smeg
    @dave0smeg Před rokem

    Apps are still chock full of adverts. Usually trying to get you to install another useless app, or the advert in the linking script is so badly/maliciously written it crashes you phone.
    I had one card game that secretly installed a gambling app from the advert playing in the linking script.

  • @lottery248
    @lottery248 Před rokem

    the other reason is to lock you into certain features. apps cost certain portions of your memory limit of your phone, meaning you must delete certain if you want new ones but full. there are also certain services asking you to create account to use it at all. if you are an addict to mobile games, you often see gigabytes of total data needed per *single game,* so it does affect you and its endurance.
    i have been using microSDs for my phone multimedia and to backup almost everything in my PC, especially my livestream replays. today's specification standard is nearly as fast as common internal storage, but they are dropping it from phones anyway because cloud is "more profitable per gigabyte month".

  • @blturner83
    @blturner83 Před rokem +2

    Browser APIs exist for nearly all the "native" features mentioned here, camera, notifications, location, etc. A web browser is just an "App." Trying to distinguish between web sites and apps this way is at best outdated and at worst, disingenuous.

  • @DarkWorldQ8
    @DarkWorldQ8 Před rokem +1

    I really dislike how certain websites I visit a few times a month for a minute or so keeps pestering me about downloading their apps, I'm just gonna use the website for a minute or two. It doesn't matter why they want us to download their app, if I wanted to download the app I would've downloaded it. For some strange reasons, some websites run much better than their awful apps.

  • @t400ml
    @t400ml Před rokem

    1:40 I've watched so many videos of yours that I can immediately detect when you're about to throw in your advertisement so my hand instinctively reach for the mouse and click forward like 1 min. lol

  • @kbhasi
    @kbhasi Před rokem

    Websites forcing me to use their phone app just to view one single article, then that app forcing me to create an account, makes me wish there was a cloud-based virtual Android phone or tablet I can download the app into that's isolated from my real phone without having to deal with Android's multi-user feature not allowing me to share apps and other data across user accounts.

  • @justion337
    @justion337 Před rokem +1

    The worst is when it's a website you use a lot and you hope the app is faster, but the app ends up being the exact same as the website and just as slow. I'm looking at you Best Buy and McMaster Carr.

  • @aweisen1
    @aweisen1 Před rokem +1

    3:09 Raising Cane's baby!

  • @privettoli
    @privettoli Před rokem

    Many companies convert their browsers apps into what looks like native apps. There are technologies available that preserve performance cross platform, it depends on skill and whether there's an existing app or a brand new one is being developed.

  • @TAP7a
    @TAP7a Před rokem +1

    Guesses:
    - monitoring+tracking
    - performance measures of an app team finding out they’re superfluous

    • @TAP7a
      @TAP7a Před rokem

      Oh and doing actual app things like video streaming and full screen games I guess

  • @DaveMcIroy
    @DaveMcIroy Před rokem +1

    Apps from websites are ALWAYS crap. Less functions, harder to navigate etc..

  • @the7observer
    @the7observer Před rokem +2

    company: please download our app! / subscribe to our newsletter!
    me: *proceeds to stop using the website*
    company: *surprise pikachu face*

    • @flameshana9
      @flameshana9 Před rokem

      They actually like seeing you leave since you're not open to giving them everything they want. They prefer people who are mindless drones who obey and open their doors, locks and wallets as soon as they're asked.

  • @mz1929
    @mz1929 Před rokem +2

    Then why do the Webistes often work better and have more options and features than the Apps do?! You often have to use the website anyways, or turn on Desktop mode

  • @Quantum-Bullet
    @Quantum-Bullet Před rokem +3

    My iPad has a too old IOS version and I cannot update CZcams anymore, and that app says it needs to be updated. So I am forced on the brower; Fun fact: I can drag the video slider to the end on ads skipping them in second there!

    • @VitalVampyr
      @VitalVampyr Před rokem +1

      The 32bit iOS version of CZcams worked for years without any updates. It probably still would work if CZcams didn't decide that it was vitally important to hide the dislike counter.

    • @Quantum-Bullet
      @Quantum-Bullet Před rokem

      I was able to click on a video before the pop-up leading me to the app store and it would run the video fine.

  • @theskyblockman
    @theskyblockman Před rokem +2

    This is really accurate, It has been proven that an app using deep linking (from web browser to app essentially) has an 6X higher conversion rate than the same app without deep linking, this also boosts app downloads by 6%.

  • @StephanLiebenberg
    @StephanLiebenberg Před rokem +1

    Got a notification just as you were talking about notifications. Thought for a second CZcams added the ability to vibrate the phone

  • @GreyBBDvids
    @GreyBBDvids Před rokem

    Recently I been unstalling apps and adding a homescreen shortcut to the website making it like an app experince to save storage space on my phone.
    Amazon, Uber Eats and even CZcams so far. I know for CZcams I am loosing features as a creator, but as a person viewing the video and shorts it is good.

  • @BrownFoxWarrior
    @BrownFoxWarrior Před rokem +1

    Everyone wants *their* app downloaded, which clogs your phone, which then the solution is to "buy a bigger phone", and the cycle continues, which is why I refuse to give up my phone with a micro sd slot despite my family insisting I "upgrade".

  • @MartinBalle7
    @MartinBalle7 Před rokem

    Some sites like autodoc (car parts in Germany) will automatically open your app store (in my case android) and find their app so you just have to download it. It will also open in the app if you have it on your phone.

  • @tonymouannes
    @tonymouannes Před rokem

    Another issue with app is the extra memory it takes and all the updates. It makes no sense to have an app for every website, especially places were you only read article or services you rarely use.

  • @Voltaic_Fire
    @Voltaic_Fire Před rokem +2

    How about they work on the website instead of using it as an excuse to violate my privacy.

  • @ElectronicInspiration

    My least favourite example of this is the youtube studio app. "The experience is better in the app" 🤓! Basically half of the functions of the website are removed or really cumbersome to access. That's why i always have "request desktop site" enabled

  • @Capt-Intrepid
    @Capt-Intrepid Před rokem +1

    I don't want a separate app for every company. That's why they invented a web browser.

  • @parthgarg4906
    @parthgarg4906 Před rokem

    Don’t run out of ideas please. I love this channel. Find ideas or ask from the viewers. Make videos on printer or smthng. Or tech history

  • @billyhatcher643
    @billyhatcher643 Před rokem

    i only play a few gacha games on my phone i rarely use apps to order food and if i do its usually pizza hut the rest of the stuff i want i just drive to the restaurant to order my food i cant trust the app to do the thing i want to order properly

  • @SunnyZ
    @SunnyZ Před rokem +2

    If you haven't got a functional website, you will never get a cent from my wallet.

  • @oksuree
    @oksuree Před rokem +1

    I fall into the category of people that did already know everything in this video, but what can I say, I'm a simple man. I see tech quicky, I clicky

  • @johnny-becker
    @johnny-becker Před rokem

    My own mother said it best. "If I kept every single one of your school papers, I would have school papers all over the house. No phone, tablet or computer can handle all the company's apps. As a rule of thumb, if the company has a website, why would I download the app? Then again, with a ever growing abundance of old cell phones that work only on Wifi, maybe I should look into filling up those old phones.

  • @moe200609
    @moe200609 Před rokem +6

    Meanwhile: Progressive Webapps with local storage, push notifications and access to nearly every phone sensor: Am I a joke to you?

  • @androidlogin3065
    @androidlogin3065 Před rokem +1

    And what do you think about a shopping web page that asks you to install it's APP and after you install it you see that APP is *only* a web browser that access it's web server the same way you access it from a PC ?

  • @wolfrig2000
    @wolfrig2000 Před rokem

    When a website puts that pop-up and tries to force you to use their app, you just don't use that website, backup to Google and find one that doesn't do that. You're voting with their paychecks, and when they lose enough money they'll realize their flaw and stop or not realize and go out of business.

  • @Appfel
    @Appfel Před rokem +1

    Often apps are just a tiny browser running the website. Good thing, I downloaded the app in those cases

  • @dustinlang4327
    @dustinlang4327 Před rokem

    And this is why I purposefully go out of my way to avoid apps on my phone. Especially CZcams, it's simply pathetic and the only benefit it gives you is being able to see chat in a stream. Infuriatingly annoying to the point where I made sure to uninstall everything I could and borderline jailbreak new phones to put these trash apps in my glass orb.

  • @Jagi125
    @Jagi125 Před rokem

    I did learn that apps are coded for performance. I'd never thought it being the case, considering how slow a 2 years old smart phone works. I guess, they aren't slow on purpose, and big companies give their best, so that you don't need to buy a new model so frequently.

  • @anaccount2681
    @anaccount2681 Před rokem +2

    I delete apps that notify even after closing and turning off notifications. I avoid them, constantly.

  • @Pest789
    @Pest789 Před rokem +1

    Remember when smart phones were new and people wrote apps that did cool shit for the fun of it? I thought phone apps were amazing and awesome and they would change the world. Now you'd pretty much have to break my arm, waterboard me, and threaten to harvest one of my kidneys against my will to coerce me to install your app. Companies are assholes.

  • @RavishankarRaghavan
    @RavishankarRaghavan Před rokem

    I have seen more instances of bad apps that perform terrible when on phone than their own website. So using apps is not going to give better performance.

  • @CoolJosh3k
    @CoolJosh3k Před rokem +1

    And then there are those companies who make an app that is actually worse than the website.

  • @TheSakuraGumiLTD
    @TheSakuraGumiLTD Před rokem

    I hate when clicking a link in a app brings me to a sub browser… If I need to return to the app to get information for the link I’m now in, I lost everything I’ve done in that link… now, I click the link, copy the address then go into my web browser to paste it there so I don’t lose it.
    I then have to go to the web version of email apps in a phone to complete some copy and paste tasks I can’t in the app…

  • @GSBarlev
    @GSBarlev Před rokem

    3:49 Ooh... Insomnia cookies. I always forget they deliver.
    (kinda demonstrating your point...)

  • @shadamethyst1258
    @shadamethyst1258 Před rokem

    "Ads loaded from some far away servers" - if you want a snappy website, then don't add ads to your website..? Native ads are laggy too, although browser ads are impressively poorly optimized.
    "A webpage that isn't well written" - I mean, the native app is subject to the same quality requirements for it to run well.
    "Apps can store vital informations on your phone locally" - So can webpages, with proper caching or with the local storage API. I guess the advantage here for native apps is that they can store DRM-ed content locally with the knowledge that the operating system will seal those files away on unrooted devices.
    Some companies just re-package their website as an electron app for android. So besides giving it an actual icon and easier access to the device's APIs, there will be no performance benefit.

  • @scottbutler5
    @scottbutler5 Před rokem +1

    I think there was an editing flub in here, you mistakenly listed "makes it easier for site to access your camera and other sensors" under the list of benefits of using the app, instead of under reasons to never download the app never never never never.

  • @spark_coder
    @spark_coder Před rokem

    Love the star trek references... 3:33

  • @c0de99
    @c0de99 Před rokem

    Personally, whenever i browse the web on my phone and get to a website that requests an app to continue, i block the website and never visit it again, ever. This is especially annoying when i read news articles in the morning while i drink my coffee. I go to an article that i would like to read, start reading it only to suddenly have a popup that tells me that i need their app in order to continue reading. What the f***? Piss off with you website and app then. Even worse are those site that require you to also pay to finish reading an article! Very annoying.
    Not to mention that most apps are really bad and they are just like web browsers. Whats the damn point? ...

  • @thetshadow999animates9
    @thetshadow999animates9 Před rokem +6

    Because they want to make their relationship with you something more

    • @flameshana9
      @flameshana9 Před rokem

      Friends with benefits indeed. Just not many benefits for you, only for them.