SONY 24-70 GM II or SIGMA 24-70 - Which should YOU buy?!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 07. 2024
  • The Sigma 24-70 or the new Sony 24-70 GM II.... $1000 difference in price but which should YOU buy? In this video we compare both lenses with a variety of tests and examples.
    Sigma 24-70 - geni.us/sigma2470
    Sony 24-70 GM II - geni.us/sony2470GMII
    Use code ‘CHRISB50' at checkout to get your first month of Epidemic sound for FREE as well as 50% off 1 YEAR when you sign up for an annual personal subscription
    0:00 - Introduction
    0:35 - Autofocus test
    0:58 - Footage Analysis
    1:14 - Underexposed Focus test
    1:32 - Lens Design
    2:01 - Minimum Focus Distance
    2:12 - Lens size and feel
    2:36 - Lens Features
    3:13 - Aperture ring settings
    4:06 - Manual Focus features
    5:16 - Weather Protection
    5:26 - Focus Breathing
    8:48 - Sharpness
    9:07 - Sharpness test/Pixel Peeping
    10:35 - Outro
    LUTs I use to grade - geni.us/phantomluts (get 15% OFF with code 'Chris'
    30 Days FREE music for YOUR Videos: geni.us/epidemiclink
    Download my A7IV Settings - geni.us/A7IVsettings
    Book a Coaching Session - geni.us/coachingwithcb
    GEAR I’M USING IN 2022 (Amazon affiliate links)
    CAMERAS
    Vid Camera - geni.us/sonya7siii
    B Camera - geni.us/S-FX3
    Stills and C Camera - Sony A7IV - geni.us/A7iv
    Old Full Frame Cam (still good!!) - geni.us/SonyA7iiiCB1
    Cheap APSC Cam - geni.us/sonya6100cb
    Drone - geni.us/mavicair2cb
    Best BTS Cam - geni.us/Insta36amz
    BEST BUDGET LENSES
    50mm - geni.us/sony50mmF18cb
    24mm F1.8 - geni.us/viltrox24mm
    85mm F1.8 II - geni.us/viltrox85mm
    (all in one -) Sigma 24-70 - geni.us/sigma2470
    LENSES I USE
    Best All round lens - geni.us/sigma2470
    Real Estate Lens - geni.us/Sony1635F4CB
    FAV Lens EVER - geni.us/Sony24mmF14CB
    The BOKEH lens - geni.us/50mmf12
    Close up lens - geni.us/sony90mmmacro
    B Roll Beast Lens - geni.us/Sony85mmF18CB
    Sharpest Lens - geni.us/Sony55mmF18CB
    Zoomy Sniper Lens - geni.us/sony70200f4cb
    CAMERA ACCESSORIES I USE
    Ninja V - geni.us/ninjavcb
    FAV Portable Light - geni.us/p1vloggercb
    A7iii EyeCup - geni.us/Eyecup
    A7iii Grip/L Bracket - geni.us/a7iiilbracket
    MICS I USE
    Vlog Mic - geni.us/rodevideomicrocb
    Podcast/CZcams Mic - geni.us/sm7cb
    Camera Mic - geni.us/smic2cb
    BAGS
    HUGE Backpack - geni.us/lowepro450awCB
    Travel Bag - geni.us/peakdesign20l
    LIGHTING
    Main Studio Light - geni.us/aputure120dcb
    Studio light Dome - geni.us/lightdomecb
    Budget Light - geni.us/godoxsl60
    Budget light Dome - geni.us/neewerlightdomecb
    Battery powered Light - geni.us/aputure60xcb
    Spotlight Zoom (for pattern on wall) - geni.us/spotlightminizoom
    All gear I use: geni.us/amazoncb
    Wedding Gear I use on Kit: kit.co/chrisbrockhurst
    #sonya7siii #sonyfx3
    FOLLOW ME
    Instagram: / chrisbrockhurst
    Twitter: / chrisbrockhurs
    AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE
    Some of the links used in the description will direct you to Amazon, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
    SPONSORSHIP/COLLABS
    For collaborations, sponsorships and business enquiries email us here: Chris@craterr.com
    If you have a question or want to chat, use the Instagram or Twitter links above, thanks!

Komentáře • 279

  • @chrisbrockhurst
    @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +35

    Before the barrage of ‘Dust’ related comments. My copy is one of the originals, has plenty of visible dust inside it yet I have yet to see a trace of this on any photo or video shot for the last 2 years. If that doesn’t do it for you, the link to the Sony is in the description box 😋

    • @thatcrazydutchguy9824
      @thatcrazydutchguy9824 Před rokem +5

      If you contact sigma they'll switch out the housing for free. No dust issues after that

    • @tqlla
      @tqlla Před rokem +2

      The Dust comes in from the back of the front lens element holder. I used electrical tape around the back of my Front lens element holder to keep the dust out. Its not noticeable.
      If you take apart the lens to clean it, there are spacers to separate the front element. You can remove them, and dust wont be back. People have said the spacers have not affected the IQ.

    • @m-stat9
      @m-stat9 Před 11 měsíci +4

      dust issue has long been solved - since serial 55641775.

    • @SevenSinsPhoto
      @SevenSinsPhoto Před 7 měsíci

      @@m-stat9Sadly this isn’t true, I just purchased one with serial number starting with 574 and new out of the box there is 2 small specks of dust behind the front glass.

    • @m-stat9
      @m-stat9 Před 7 měsíci

      still true. Updated design doesn't mean there will be absolutely zero issues, just far, far less. Mine is still fine. @@SevenSinsPhoto

  • @JoshStreetDesign
    @JoshStreetDesign Před rokem +174

    "...massive difference in sharpness..." LOL, bro it's barely visible, ESPECIALLY when 99% of these photos are going to be seen on a tiny smartphone screen. None of my clients are blowing my stuff up on billboards and using a loupe to examine sharpness. People need a reality check when thinking about spending their money.

    • @stfu6397
      @stfu6397 Před rokem +8

      Exactly

    • @dottorcarlone
      @dottorcarlone Před rokem

      Absolutely agree, what a bullshit ahaha “massive difference in sharpness” what a giant pile of bshit! The difference it s absolutely subtle and 99 percent of people couldnt tell. Is the sony worth 1000 more? Absolutely not! It s not justified by image quality!

    • @marisoldeoliveira4838
      @marisoldeoliveira4838 Před 10 měsíci +14

      I was debating wether I should get sigma or Sony GM II.. I think your comment has convinced me to get the sigma

    • @rafikz77
      @rafikz77 Před 5 měsíci

      Agreed

    • @yspegel
      @yspegel Před 3 měsíci

      Well, first of all I wouldn't recommend spending 1000 and sure not 2000 dolar/euro on a lens for pictures mainly for phone.
      Other then that I fully agree with you, yes there is a difference in the contrast, something you would take in consideration if price difference were 100 dollar or less..... but a 1000.... Sigma puts Sony to shame here big time and I love Sigma for doing so!

  • @JsGarage
    @JsGarage Před 2 lety +87

    The sigma is so good for the money. One of several reasons I returned my R6 and went Sony A7IV back in late December.

    • @DB-lr6kl
      @DB-lr6kl Před rokem +2

      That’s my current predicament

    • @alexanderthomas962
      @alexanderthomas962 Před rokem +1

      Yeah just sold my r6 as well

    • @IgorDoval
      @IgorDoval Před 11 měsíci

      What about the lack of image stabilization with the Sigma? Does the ibis on the 74 do a good job with it?

  • @MattQuattro
    @MattQuattro Před 2 lety +23

    Thanks for this Chris, really great comparison of these two! I went with the Sigma because that price difference was just too big to justify the Sony. Plus for me, I’m using the 24-105mm most of the time as a better workhorse lens but a 24-70mm f2.8 is still good to have.

  • @joel.wuestehube
    @joel.wuestehube Před rokem +3

    It's just amazing. Nearly every time I looking into a new specific gear purchase you answer the exact questions I have to make a educated decision.

  • @AaronWilhite
    @AaronWilhite Před 2 lety +3

    Quite literally looking at the differences and this video popped up. Great timing and great video Chris!

  • @azeraven
    @azeraven Před rokem +3

    Hey great Comparison! But did you compare the Active Steadyshot with both Lenses? I currently own the Sigma 24-70. But it didnt work good with active steadyshot on my A7iv. Is the 24-70gm II better in stabilisation? Thank you!

  • @waynebelfast
    @waynebelfast Před rokem +1

    Fantastic video. Way more useful than other comparisons I’ve watched. (Sorry it took me four months to get round to it)

  • @Premier_lawns_official

    Chris this is the first video I have watched over yours, very helpful

  • @bala1000mina
    @bala1000mina Před 3 měsíci

    Thank you so much Chris for the informative and helpful comparative review! God bless and good luck!

  • @touchtennis
    @touchtennis Před rokem +1

    How has this only just come up on my feed?! Great vid mate.

  • @lorenzo4262
    @lorenzo4262 Před rokem +2

    Hello, and between the sigma and the new tamron 28-75 G2 ? In terms of optical quality (sharpness)?

  • @SJtoday52
    @SJtoday52 Před rokem

    This video did a damn good job showing me I need the Sony. I can actually see a difference in your video side by side.

  • @daaddyo1249
    @daaddyo1249 Před rokem +8

    For anyone watching with a7iv, fx30, a7siii or fx3 just be warned that active stabilization DOES NOT work as well on 3rd party lenses as it does on sony lenses, didn't want to believe this until I got a sony lens... their is quite a difference with the sony being more stable.

    • @HANKBRAVO81
      @HANKBRAVO81 Před 5 měsíci

      Is this legit? I’ve not heard of this before. I had the A7iv with Sigma 24-70 and was pretty damn impressed. I did come from the A7iii though😅

  • @cyvidal10
    @cyvidal10 Před rokem +3

    Any news if Sigma is planning on releasing a version 2 of this Art Lens 24-70mm F2.8? Thanks

  • @SimsekStudio
    @SimsekStudio Před rokem

    Quick and informative! Thank you!

  • @jardine6183
    @jardine6183 Před 11 měsíci +6

    Sigma is awesome great lens specially on budget but considering even a slight sharpness from sony is massive on the output of the image. specially when working with clients you want to deliver a great sharp photo. in the end it will really depends sometimes its really hard to notice unless you pixel peep. 1000$ more is to have better weight/sharper image/lots of extra packed on the lens. i'll go for sigma for now then get a sony when the time is right might wait for a next version of it see how it goes. we can always add sharpness on post production editing.

  • @willbrink
    @willbrink Před rokem +4

    I wanted the Sony G master, can't justify the extra 1k price tag. The Sigma is a heavy beast of a lens, but screams high quality and I do 95% still photos vs vids. None of the added features on the Sony I needed. Biggest concern was the glass/quality if the photos. The vid: the Sigma was actually a bit cleaner, the Sony had better skin tones. Both seemed equal in terms of auto focus tracking. That was a useful real time comparison there. Was a tint bit disappointment that the Sony was sharper, but is a cooler color (cold?) to the Sigma, so that seems the balance Sigma was going for. My brain always tells sharper is better but the overall impact of the Sigma perhaps more pleasing.

  • @TheAk2912
    @TheAk2912 Před rokem +8

    After watching this video literally 2 times a day for the past week, I finally pulled the trigger on Sigma. Super excited for it.
    thank you Chris for putting this together

    • @bondgabebond4907
      @bondgabebond4907 Před rokem

      Same here. Once you get the lens, you wonder why you spent so much time watching these videos. It''s a great lens, very sharp and versatile, plus that $1,000 I didn't have to spend felt good. Heck, the Sony 35mm 1.4 GM costs more than the Sigma zoom.

  • @karledwards
    @karledwards Před rokem

    Hey! I see you're using the DJI mic now... You gonna do a review soon? Wondering if they fixed the radio interference issue when using an external lav mic...

  • @EddieInzauto
    @EddieInzauto Před rokem

    On the focus breathing test, the image on the right had much nicer colors on my opinion. Can you recall if that is a camera setting or could the fairly big difference possibly be attributable to the lens coatings? Which camera body was on the left and which was on the right?

  • @Tolete00
    @Tolete00 Před rokem +2

    My question is: Why in the B&H page both lens it said for Full Frame format but GM said Sony EF and Sigma Sony E? I have understood when it say Sony EF (mean Full Frame), and Sony E (mean APS-C version)... Can someone explain it to me please, i'm very confused right now. 🤔 Sorry if my English is not well. 😅

  • @dee-deeoverton1300
    @dee-deeoverton1300 Před rokem

    Do you have a link for the camera grip you use? The link in the description is for the bracket?

  • @MichaelWarthStudios
    @MichaelWarthStudios Před 2 lety +3

    Good comparison video, Chris. I keep feeling like I don’t need a 24-70 due to my favorite primes but then the money starts to burn a hole in me pocket.

    • @JonasBecker
      @JonasBecker Před 2 lety +3

      I love my primes, using 24, 35 and 85 regularly, but the Tamron 28-75 is so darn versatile for when I need it. Especially on lower budget videos where I don't have the time to switch lenses on the gimbal

  • @janein6491
    @janein6491 Před 11 měsíci

    What Sony cameras compensate for the focus breathing with the Sigma ?

  • @musings2134
    @musings2134 Před 10 měsíci

    Do you have the images uploaded somewhere publicly accessible?

  • @jeroenvdw
    @jeroenvdw Před rokem +3

    I'm hesitant to buy the one or the other for weeks now. I'll mainly use it when traveling and the weight of the Sony is more appealing to me. Also more features ofc and a tad sharper. But €1300 more expensive than the Sigma lens... Resell value might be higher on the Sony after a few years though.

  • @mercsport
    @mercsport Před 6 měsíci

    Interestingly for me Chris, is the fact - whether knowingly or accidentally - you've produced some reasonably good 3D stereo vid's in your chapter on focus-breathing. If familiar with cross-eyed viewing of stereo pairs it was a cinch to view, despite the exaggerated depth due to excessive lens separation. A rare treat for me, though, for I've watched far too many comparison vid's where the vloggers have missed the opportunity to set their cam's perfectly aligned and sync'd, one to the other. Well done you!

  • @vincentewen
    @vincentewen Před 2 lety +9

    Do you know if there will be an newer version of the sigma ? Like Sony did with the 24-70 II?

  • @OfficialDJTazer
    @OfficialDJTazer Před 4 měsíci

    4:08 can the camera not be on auto aperture with the Sigma and therefore record from inside to outside?

  • @Kommentaraccount
    @Kommentaraccount Před rokem

    Is that shallow depht of field in a product video necessary? In your headshots i am always searching for the focus point. Still a good comparison though ;)

  • @Reviews4fun1
    @Reviews4fun1 Před rokem +2

    I bought the a7iv for that Sigma lens. It’s so good and an obvious choice. Unless you’re a pro shooter getting paid a lot for gigs, then I might consider the Sony for a little weight savings.

  • @AndyHuneycutt
    @AndyHuneycutt Před 2 lety +1

    How many scenes are you going to use in this video, Chris?
    Chris, “All of them!”
    Ha ha, nice job! Really enjoyed all the different scenes and angles and how you worked it all together. Well done.

  • @lorenzo4262
    @lorenzo4262 Před 8 měsíci

    which body have you used for comparison?

  • @SergeyKonkov
    @SergeyKonkov Před 2 měsíci

    How about barrel/pincushion distortion on the sony? On my sigma at 24mm on full frame its significant. Lens correction in LR has to be applied to every image, where straight lines bending a lot.

  • @alhOOO2O
    @alhOOO2O Před rokem +4

    In your sharpness tests, you didn't state what aperture you were shooting at, only the focal lengths - also it would be helpful to have a comparison at different apertures. Sony might have the edge at 2.8, for example, but the Sigma at 5.6

  • @alejandrodiaz4631
    @alejandrodiaz4631 Před 2 lety

    Bro, sony AIII plus 24-70 Lense GMI for 3000 euros is a good price nowadays to pay? thanks bro.Great video

  • @northparkfilms3045
    @northparkfilms3045 Před 2 lety +16

    Great video as always Chris. Honestly I own neither but if I had to get one it would be the sigma. For the price but also maybe it's just me but I love the warmer and contrasty image that sigma puts out. The aperture ring is nice to have but everything else feels a little unnecessary to me.

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety

      Yep! I hear ya, each to their own. The cost isn’t worth it for most

  • @MohammadHishamudin
    @MohammadHishamudin Před 2 měsíci

    Hey chris, I just want to say about the smooth and tight.
    Smooth is for fast shooting range, for exp u zooming in and out faster for the object (not smooth for video)
    Tight is suitable for video shooting (for a smooth video zooming)

  • @adrian_de_graaf
    @adrian_de_graaf Před 2 lety +4

    As if you read my mind, bro! Thank you for this video!
    I was on a holiday recently and I was too busy changing lenses when I thought: I need a good 24-70mm when I'm taking photos in and around a city/ town/ village.
    I love my 20mm G, 24mm GM and 35mm GM; but I am still drawn towards a good 24-70mm!

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +2

      24-70 is the perfect walk about lens

    • @justinavila1320
      @justinavila1320 Před 2 lety

      Having all Sony and great GM glass are you opting for the GM II?

    • @2000sidhupunjab
      @2000sidhupunjab Před 2 lety +1

      You need a Sony 24-105 G F4 Lens.

    • @Reviews4fun1
      @Reviews4fun1 Před rokem

      When I run primes (on my crop bodies) I bring two mounted bodies so I don’t fumble with lens changes. When I run a zoom, it’s usually on my a7iv.

  • @daran0815
    @daran0815 Před rokem

    Autofocus when tracking for photo is a very different animal from autofocus during video. The former is more difficult to test, but it is where e.g. the eye is or isn't in focus during rapid movement of the subject (e.g. someone riding a bike). The latter is artificially slowed by the camera and big differences would be unexpected.

  • @gunn1ng
    @gunn1ng Před 2 lety +21

    Awesome video Chris. Even though standard zooms aren't really my bag, I am really happy with my Sigma 24-70mm Art. It does lean a little warm as you say, which is easy enough to fix in post. The Sigma 24-70mm also has a wonderful character that I can't quite put my finger on in it's image quality. I always know the images that I have taken with that lens. Maybe the new Sony is a little sharper if you are pixel peeping, but sharpness isn't everything and I feel like you get 95% of the new Sony performance with the Sigma as shown in your video.

    • @pughenry1588
      @pughenry1588 Před rokem +1

      Exactly! My Sigma has a very special look that is instantly recognizable. I love it.

    • @jwilliams1563
      @jwilliams1563 Před rokem

      Sigma has that warm sharp but not to sharp 3d look I used to associate with pictures from canons 5d mark 2. Its awesome for weddings.

  • @lynneharty9966
    @lynneharty9966 Před rokem +3

    Chris, I bought the Sigma to replace the Sony I had that broke (and the repair shop was going to charge stupid money to fix it, and I needed it right away). I'm pretty happy with it in most cases, but feel like it does more perspective warping whenever I'm shooting pretty wide, such as photographing someone in a room - the walls are more curved that I ever remember happening with the Sony. Have you or anyone else noticed this? I've been thinking of selling the sigma and getting another sony for this reason. Thanks.

    • @liljoe23la
      @liljoe23la Před rokem +1

      Yes I have the same issue when I shot a wedding last week. The distortion is pretty noticable at 24mm but you can always fix it in post.

  • @PhilofBristol
    @PhilofBristol Před rokem +4

    I tried the Sony at a wedding when I hired an A7iii after my old A77ii broke down. It was good, but I wasn't convinced that it was £1,000 better than the Sigma. I have had several Sigma lenses, including an A-mount 70-300 APO that I've had for 18 years.
    I have no regrets whatsoever about saving £1,000 over the GMII lens.

    • @Ange1ofD4rkness
      @Ange1ofD4rkness Před 10 měsíci

      Literally sounds like my scenario. My a77 Mk II is quickly showing it's on its last legs (just doesn't auto focus, and other signs). The Sigma I am looking to be my lens (to take the place of what my old 16-50 I loved)

  • @iambrandonscales
    @iambrandonscales Před 2 lety +2

    I have the Sigma 24-70mm and love it, it simply gets the job done! Would love to try the Sony one day!

  • @killerphotos
    @killerphotos Před rokem

    I have now had 2 versions on the 24-70 GM II, that squeak when pulling focus quickly, pretty loudly. I have yet to see it mentioned anywhere else. Anyone else's 24-70 making noises.

  • @johnwilkinson9194
    @johnwilkinson9194 Před rokem

    What's the FPS on an a9/a9ii or a1?

  • @bobdragon7887
    @bobdragon7887 Před 2 lety +8

    If you have the budget, you would definitely go with the GM one. It is incredibly light compared to sigma one. This is a huge plus for me and IM is also better overall.

    • @m-stat9
      @m-stat9 Před 11 měsíci +3

      695g vs 830g is not ‚incredibly‘ more light, lmao.

    • @serge.y
      @serge.y Před 10 měsíci +3

      @@m-stat9 Yes and no... I feel like if you are using gimbal a lot it's quite a big difference! Handheld - not so much. In fact handheld feels better when it's heavier. (personal preference)

  • @user-st5sc6vm5y
    @user-st5sc6vm5y Před 6 měsíci

    At 5:30, which side belongs to which lens?

  • @jordandouglas3772
    @jordandouglas3772 Před 2 lety +1

    This is where I’m stuck at, I just purchased the Sony a7IV and I’m starting my video business and I know the 24-70 would be a really nice all around lens ! Thank you for this video !!!

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +2

      For starting budget the sigma will do nicely

    • @2000sidhupunjab
      @2000sidhupunjab Před 2 lety +2

      If you don't need ultra low light performance, Sony 24-105 G lens is a better choice.

    • @jordandouglas3772
      @jordandouglas3772 Před 2 lety +1

      @@chrisbrockhurst Just ordered it 🤙🏽

    • @DB-lr6kl
      @DB-lr6kl Před rokem

      @@2000sidhupunjab really? Why ?

    • @2000sidhupunjab
      @2000sidhupunjab Před rokem

      @@DB-lr6kl OSS and longer range, F4 is totally fine with newer bodies and their low light capabilities. I find F2.8 neither here not there. Get F4 zoom with F1.2-F1.8 primes and you are set. F2.8 always keep you longing for more.

  • @iGeng
    @iGeng Před 7 měsíci

    I have the Sigma but the weight and more importantly, lens creep made me pick up the Sony 16-35mm F4 PZ when I got my Ronin RS3.

  • @yspegel
    @yspegel Před 3 měsíci

    Just got to LOVE Sigma for this, they really keep competitiveness in the lens market. Something anyone on a tight budget has to appreciate. I'm going to buy my first full frame camera and this Sigma will be on it 😁

  • @BreadCatMarcus
    @BreadCatMarcus Před 10 měsíci +2

    Been using my Sigma for a couple years now and love it. My only reservation is the Active IBS for the A7Siii. For my work, i do a lot of handheld and the camera struggles with IBS on non Sony lenses. Anyone experience both of these lenses while using active IBS on the A7Siii? Any big difference like people say?

    • @amohammed5181
      @amohammed5181 Před 6 měsíci

      Can anyone second this please? Having the same dilemma. Have sigma but heard there is a big diff with ibis steadyshot. I like to film a lot handheld.

    • @noahmonte8581
      @noahmonte8581 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@amohammed5181 sony lenses work better with active stabilization on my 7siii

  • @ArtsyAllAround
    @ArtsyAllAround Před 2 lety +1

    Great timing! I was just thinking of getting a 24-70 soon.

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety

      Tough decisions ahead

    • @yamatosan565
      @yamatosan565 Před 2 lety +1

      @@chrisbrockhurst Youre doing a comparison video that shows its not worth to buy the sony but then you giving this comment saying its tough decision xDDD yeeehh

    • @Donbros
      @Donbros Před 2 lety

      @@yamatosan565 bro but its gm. He obviously talks about resell value far in future

    • @rollymartha
      @rollymartha Před 2 lety

      @@yamatosan565 🤣

  • @MediaBear
    @MediaBear Před 9 měsíci

    Replace “clicky” with “detented” ftw ;)
    Another great video bud.

  • @arwennstory9737
    @arwennstory9737 Před 6 měsíci +1

    with all the features of the newer Sony lens, I think reasonably its only about 200-300 dollar more expesive than the Sigma. So in the end I bought the Sony 😊❤

  • @DavidStella
    @DavidStella Před 2 lety

    I guess if one’s shooting with a Sony A1, perhaps it might make sense to grab the Sony, if high frame rate for stills is a priority. But man, it’s still close.

  • @pughenry1588
    @pughenry1588 Před rokem +5

    I was one of the first to get the Sigma when it was released and it’s been my most used lens since then. There is a very special “look” to the Sigma images that is very pleasing for both landscape and people images. It’s very, very close to my 35GM and 50GM lenses. And that’s really saying something because those two lenses are incredible!

  • @JayStoneEnts
    @JayStoneEnts Před rokem +1

    I have the Sigma, its identical image wise, but it isn't great in terms of sealing, had mine 6 months and its riddled with internal dust (doesnt affect the image much), not great! I don't use it in dusty conditions if anyone asks, no more dusty than day to day use. Will be selling cheap to get the Sony sadly.

  • @ronaldt3422
    @ronaldt3422 Před 2 lety +2

    I was very tempted to get the Sigma. The only single reason why I ended up getting the Sony is the weight. I carry my camera on a sling and heavy gear can take its toll on my back when I'm travelling.

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +1

      Yep, weight is going to be a big factor for alot of folks

    • @everkikomoo
      @everkikomoo Před rokem

      For quality in video specifically low controlled light with face closeup you think sigma is fine ?

  • @dathofilms
    @dathofilms Před 2 lety +2

    Outstanding review

  • @0123456789jad
    @0123456789jad Před 6 měsíci

    does the Sony also have vignette?

  • @360fullhd
    @360fullhd Před 2 lety

    0:30 what is the name of L shape cage for fx3?

  • @MODESTYXO205
    @MODESTYXO205 Před 2 lety

    Would you recommend the Sony 24-70ii over the 16mm-35 for documentary vlog work to pair with my Sony a73

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +1

      24-70 is way most versatile than the 16-35 for doc work. 100%

    • @jayauleeno6897
      @jayauleeno6897 Před rokem +1

      16-35 in APS-C video mode give you an another 17-18mm long = 16-52mm but in doucmentary work 24-70 will be excellent :)

  • @TheArtofLight
    @TheArtofLight Před 2 lety +12

    Awesome video Chris! I'd just like to add that this specific Sigma lens tends to have a dust problem. Granted I live in a desert but its the only lens I own where massive dust specs have somehow managed to get caught on several glass elements well inside the lens.
    Otherwise, its my number one favorite lens to use. I love the warmer tones that I get out of this lens over the cooler colors coming out of a Sony lens. The Sigma is a near perfect choice for me..just wished it was better weather sealed.
    Cheers!

    • @thomas.kovacik
      @thomas.kovacik Před 2 lety +9

      Sigma updated the design! I forget what serial number marks the change but mine is the newer one- I’ve filmed in the desert with wind, film at the beach and I haven’t had any dust

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +5

      Yup this ^

    • @rgbman01
      @rgbman01 Před 2 lety +15

      This was fixed quite some time ago and is no longer an issue. If you're shopping for a used one, look for serial #'s after 55641775.

    • @SimonBauer
      @SimonBauer Před rokem

      I had this issue with the 50mm its the only thing that makes me hesitant about buying another one!! they dont weather seal it :(

    • @SimonBauer
      @SimonBauer Před rokem

      @@thomas.kovacik oh god whats the model # ahha

  • @DarelBah
    @DarelBah Před rokem +1

    What i can not figure out does gm2 optical stabilisation vs sigmas not existing os makes substantional difference?
    Have to make a decision before black friday but this rabithole is way too deep.

    • @gemwebb
      @gemwebb Před rokem

      What did you choose?

  • @Fernando.Vivanco
    @Fernando.Vivanco Před rokem +1

    Whew! man, I was sweating right before 7:30. I thought the clip on the right looked so much better, sharpness/contrast and skin tone. But then I thought.. oh no.... that's the Sigma and I just bought a Sony GM today :( Then I could not find which one was which (because he pulls the title quickly) and then I finally saw it => One on the righty is SONY. THANK GOODNESS.

  • @raprein3
    @raprein3 Před rokem

    06:23 I would just like to double check, to me it looks like the sony (right one) is considerible faster/accurate in autofocus than the sigma (left). Or does this have to do with the camera that the lens is on? I am asking as nowadays you can get a second hand sony 24-70 for the same price as a new sigma 24-70 and I wonder which one I should buy for both video and photography

  • @TheOneMonk
    @TheOneMonk Před 2 lety

    Fab review. No need to upgrade, as the differences are not relevant to me.

  • @Unfilterd
    @Unfilterd Před rokem

    Excellent video

  • @firpofutbol
    @firpofutbol Před rokem

    I like the color from the Sigma better. A great value if you ask me.

  • @whatsinamind4766
    @whatsinamind4766 Před 2 lety +5

    Chris, for me it was very obvious that, with the test of the focus breathing, the one on the right was the GM II. It was much faster in the sharpness and keeping the sharpness on your eyes. It sticked like magic and also the colors are fuller and more real to me.

    • @sticky1212
      @sticky1212 Před rokem

      Ha, well, are you sure? The image on the right had the sony sitting in the video. That means the other one was on the camera. Unless he had two of each lens which seems unlikely. Plus every comparison had the sigma on the right. Chris?

    • @mistermyxpyx
      @mistermyxpyx Před rokem +1

      @@sticky1212 The video with Chris focusing on his eyes has the Sony on the right, Sigma on left (see caption bottom of video): czcams.com/video/3sbklGkdbHY/video.html
      The video of the boxes and lenses on the table swaps the lenses around, with the Sony on the left, Sigma on right (see caption bottom of video): czcams.com/video/3sbklGkdbHY/video.html

  • @alezcoll
    @alezcoll Před 11 měsíci +2

    The Sigma is so close that I can't even find a justified reason to spend a thousand dollars more on the Sony. Now I want to see if it's worth upgrading my Sigma 28-70 (C) to the 24-70 (A).

  • @2020videography
    @2020videography Před rokem

    Image stabilisation??

  • @davidmarshall5665
    @davidmarshall5665 Před rokem +2

    I love sigma gear but it’s not g master. The video produced much better colours, deeper blacks and the focussing was faultless whereas the sigma focussing was a bit soft and definitely had less contrast. Now we come to the stills, again the sigma was good (bang for buck) but the sony was razor sharp and those were only short distance shots, I would dare say that shot over 20m will be substantially sharper on the sony. So…. Are a professional shooter? Is there a monetary value to your art? If the answer is yes to any of these questions the answer is obviously the 24-70mm g master by the facts figured in this video which is a great video I just think you don’t give the sony as much praise as you should alternatively to giving the sigma the praise it deserves.

  • @RobJorg
    @RobJorg Před 8 měsíci

    2 things i missed in your video.
    1. resale value of a sony G lens versus a sigma
    2. sigma doesnt do 30 fps on a sony A1, Sony lenses do.
    nice studio and good video.

  • @SaxSpy
    @SaxSpy Před 2 lety

    Sigma has a dust issue but i still love it. the GM tight would be nice since the sigma will fall out when upside down doing top doen shots so i have to tape it

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +1

      I need to get mine sent in for dust removal, that being said. It’s never impacted the quality of image

    • @lax123rock
      @lax123rock Před rokem

      Not on the new lesn I believe.

  • @thegeneral123
    @thegeneral123 Před 2 lety +6

    In before all the "Sigma lens has dust issues" yes the early production models did and this was resolved. I've had mine for over a year, it's an updated model and it has no more dust inside it than any other WR lens I use. Also Sigma UK confirmed they will strip and clean this lens free of charge even if it's a grey market product and out of warranty as they accept there was an issue. Yes, I have one and am very happy with the Sigma.
    I bought the Sigma before the Sony was an option. The Sony is clearly a better lens but considerably more expensive.
    If I had all the money in the world I'd buy the Sony. I don't, so the Sigma would still be my choice.

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +2

      2nd’d

    • @sasqwatch35mm
      @sasqwatch35mm Před rokem

      Can you please tell first four numbers of your lens' serial number? I've heard rumors that this issue has been resolved starting from S/N 55641775 , thanks

  • @mohsenfarahani4440
    @mohsenfarahani4440 Před 2 lety +1

    Apperture ring, or that rediculous ring speed switch are not acceptable reasons to pay sony lense double as much Sigma. I'll go for Sigma strongly.

  • @troutboynz
    @troutboynz Před 7 měsíci

    Awsome! One thing however... The Sony works so well with "active" stabilisation... the Sigma does not.... VERY noticeable on native vs non-native lenses.

    • @amohammed5181
      @amohammed5181 Před 6 měsíci

      Hey bud, this is the comment I've been looking for. Could you send over some test shots? I have the sigma but recently been shooting a lot of handheld. Heard sony lens with active steady shot ibis works amazing.

  • @AdheensSan
    @AdheensSan Před 2 lety +1

    24-70 GM II fantastic, but i can't afford it. So, I'll go with Sigma :)

  • @Anywaywellmadeit
    @Anywaywellmadeit Před 2 lety

    Gm ii is fantastic one

  • @botremedia6514
    @botremedia6514 Před rokem +1

    Idk, I know Sony is a big brand but I think were giving them too much credit when it comes to the focusing test in the beginning. The sigma seemed slightly faster with focusing but thats just me.

  • @PeteBreen
    @PeteBreen Před 2 lety +1

    Tried to sign up for Epidemic promo - code isn't working. Looking at the Sigma lens though. 👍

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +1

      Gah! Thanks for letting me know. Personal plan?

    • @PeteBreen
      @PeteBreen Před 2 lety

      @@chrisbrockhurst Yes - personal plan.

  • @user-qi7lw2rh1y
    @user-qi7lw2rh1y Před 6 měsíci

    I always find it interesting when the people say, "if you have the budget". I had the budget for the GM but still opted for the Sigma because the differences of the 2 are so minimal that they can't be deciphered by the average client. Why pay $1k more? A decision I would still make a year later. The Sigma is an OUTSTANDING professional lens.

  • @JeffBarnhart
    @JeffBarnhart Před 2 lety +1

    I have the sigma and it’s incredible. The only complaint is I have after a couple of years using it as my primary lens…. weight.

    • @chrisbrockhurst
      @chrisbrockhurst  Před 2 lety +1

      You’ll appreciate the weight of this then.. does that justify the cost though 🤨

    • @baotranphotography
      @baotranphotography Před 2 lety +2

      it's actually lighter than the GM 1

  • @Donbros
    @Donbros Před 2 lety

    Focus breathing is similarish but maybe sony just a bit more

  • @dailan.0589
    @dailan.0589 Před 11 měsíci

    would love to own sony, is just incredibly expensive compare to sigma. great video

  • @tobifolorunso9193
    @tobifolorunso9193 Před rokem +2

    The sigma is a lot warmer than the Sony, which I personally like

  • @ORodTech
    @ORodTech Před rokem +2

    2 things i learned about this video:
    Keeping my Sigma 24-70 F2.8
    There IS A MANGO FLAVORED BUBLY!! WHAAAATT!!!!

  • @MrLordofcoffee
    @MrLordofcoffee Před 3 měsíci

    For me in the UK in 2024, the difference in price for the preowned sigma and preowned sony GM (NOTE: NOT the GM ii) os very small, Sony is maybe £50 (80 bucks) more expensive. Should I go for the GM when the difference is that small?

  • @souljah45
    @souljah45 Před rokem

    I own the Sigma 24-70 2.8 and I love it, especially for the price... Its heavy AF though. I just wish sigma would make a Sony e-mount 70-200

    • @jeroenvdw
      @jeroenvdw Před rokem

      Imagine the weight of the 70-200 from Sigma lol. They are known to make super heavy lenses.

    • @marcelmartins74
      @marcelmartins74 Před 9 měsíci

      In December

  • @troymclean9301
    @troymclean9301 Před rokem

    Nice comparison. Just can’t see or come up with a $1000 benefit. Will use those $$$$ towards another lens.

  • @DevAcharya
    @DevAcharya Před 2 lety +1

    what a timing !! im looking for a 24-70 instead of 28-75,

  • @thilinaalagiyawanna3680
    @thilinaalagiyawanna3680 Před 8 měsíci

    Thank you

  • @Thechicagolion
    @Thechicagolion Před rokem +1

    can I use it for my a6400 ?

  • @jwate
    @jwate Před 3 měsíci

    During your ad the GM looked more magenta and sharper compared to the sigma. The sigma didn’t look bad though.

  • @drum4519
    @drum4519 Před rokem

    Wow I thought Sigma was Sony because I thought it much sharper in the auto-focus comparison video Wow Sigma is much better I should buy Sigma for color and auto-focus too Thank you.

  • @SimonBauer
    @SimonBauer Před rokem

    Going with the Sigma :)

  • @Puppetsinmyhead
    @Puppetsinmyhead Před rokem +1

    All the art lenses are warmer.