I think arthur's inteligence goes over looked because he's loyal to a fault, and has self-esteem isues, if you read his journal youll see that he knew the bad on dutch and the dumb directions. Also he has better Battle IQ than the noise guy, dont bullshit me😂❤
Dutch isn’t in nearly as many fights as Arthur in this game alone. If this is the general division of labour then Dutch has less fighting experience overall just from being in less fights. Battle IQ goes to Arthur and it ain’t close.
@@Jester_Jingles having more experience in battle have nothing to do with battle iq, that counts as experience which still goes to dutch dutch also takes both iq and battle iq easily and it ain't even debatable, arthur's battle iq is very overrated
Dutch is stronger. And Dutch in fire fights is a psycho. Don’t forget Arthur himself said that Dutch taught him everything he knows. Dont forget either how insanely quick and accurate dutch shot Micah while holding Sadie, or Cornwall on that boat.
Arthur is way stronger, tf are you on about 😂. Also Dutch taught Arthur the basics, Arthur perfected them on his own. Also dead eye is quicker than Dutch. And don't even try and pull the "it's just a game mechanic" excuse. It's a game mechanic to show how fast and accurate Arthur is.
Punch fight 1-Mac Callander 2-Charles Smith 3-Arthur 4-Problably Davey Callander 5-John Gun fight 1-John Marston, possible Mac 2-Arthur Morgan,possible Mac 3-Micah Bell 4-Javier Escuella 5-Dutch
I think Dueling Skill goes to Dutch he did teach Arthur everything he knew when it came to weapons and reflexes should probably be equal they can dodge bullets coming at fast speed
For some reason I find this weird to say but somehow even when surrounded by police he somehow finds a way to get out of a situation with no troubles, it’s always someone else in his gang blowing there cover that usually gets them caught
@@Kapitalistyczna_Polska I'm not overrating dutch. It's not my fault you all overrate Arthur. Arthur literally struggled too lift a wagon wheel which is literally only 45 pounds. Also it was never stated he beat the legendary gunslingers. If it's not the story mode then it isn't canon. It's the players choice.
The reason Dutch kept Arthur around was because he was stronger and faster than him, but dumber. During rdr2, Arthur becomes smarter and demonstrates real leadership, not the flagshow Dutch constantly put on. That's a big reason Dutch and Arthur began to split. Arthur became a real leader, once he started thinking for himself.
Theres a scene in guarma where dutch says hell hold off the boats coming to shore at the bottom of the fort by himself. I think hes above bill and javier and just barely above charles. In my opinion tgis puts right below micah or maybe on par. John and arthur easily surpassing.
People saying arthur mids he high difs and maybe even loses if dutch has prep time we don't see dutch fist fight but he taught arthur everything he knows and he has the best aim in the franchise and we also don't really see him Quickdraw nor duel my point is don't underestimate dutch
Dutch is definitely taller than Arthur, but Arthur is built like an ox. Guy is pure muscle. Don’t get me wrong, Dutch is deceptively well built, but Arthur is the gang’s enforcer for a reason.
Dice doesn’t matter in a fight Tommy for example Arthur won against a 6 ft 6 inch giant (not sure it’s his actual height just making a assumption) but Arthur won and older is a down side he isn’t in his prime anymore
Remember, the boss always hires guys that are bigger and better than him but never smarter
damn.
damn.
fax
Double kill
@@Abby_MooreDutch and Hosea adopted Arthur and John when they were kids
Dutch’s main ability is that he can snipe people from miles away with his semi auto pistol.
aimbot lol
He got those overcharged rounds lol
fr
bro turned on the mod menu
I be sniping dudes with throwing knife’s as Arthur fr fr
Dutch's main ability:
" I got a plan "
Dutch's 2nd ability:
Having some GOD DAMN FAITH
@@soullessginger9912 and his third is Tahiti
“We just need one more score”
"This is the good one"
Intelligence goes to Arthur wdym
everybody gangsta until Arthur goes:
X X X X X
X X X X X
X X X X X
Dead eye is not like an special ability, is just describing how fast is gunslinger
Dutch probably the one who taught Arthur to shoot a gun
@@eagle6161he did but Arthur perfected his craft and obtained his shot speed with is integrated into dead eye the same for John Marston too
JUST REMEMBER, Dutch taught arthur almost everything he knows
Fr
But his attributes like his speed,strength and durability he earned all on his own Dutch can’t compete with his physical attributes
he aint beating arthur in h2h tho
Hes old
And Arthur surpassed him
If Arthur didn’t have tuberculosis he would have killed Micah in chapter 6
He almost won the fight even with tuberculosis which is crazy
@@mhoeditz2413 not just "almost win" he LITERALLY almost KILLED him
@@sicarius777yeah fr the pain in micahs face was real
Easily
@@mhoeditz2413that either proves how physically weak Micah was or how strong Arthur was
Shit goes harder than the brain damage Arthur gave to Tommy 🔥
Fr
bro arthur looks like a fucking beast in the first clips
i think that’s how he should’ve looked but the devs wanted him to look a bit more humane☠️
I think arthur's inteligence goes over looked because he's loyal to a fault, and has self-esteem isues, if you read his journal youll see that he knew the bad on dutch and the dumb directions.
Also he has better Battle IQ than the noise guy, dont bullshit me😂❤
arthur is smarter than he seems sure, but dutch is still smarter, he takes both iq and battle iq
Dutch isn’t in nearly as many fights as Arthur in this game alone. If this is the general division of labour then Dutch has less fighting experience overall just from being in less fights. Battle IQ goes to Arthur and it ain’t close.
@@Jester_Jingles having more experience in battle have nothing to do with battle iq, that counts as experience which still goes to dutch
dutch also takes both iq and battle iq easily and it ain't even debatable, arthur's battle iq is very overrated
Nahh my mann Arthur is on a different level of Badassness 🗿🗿🍷😤🔫
wdym dutch looks better hes the only reason i played red dead
@@King_midas74you my friend, are a fish
Editor need a golden trophy 🔥
Dutch teached everything to arthur
Arthur took them to another level
"can't kill even a dying man"
Dutch is stronger. And Dutch in fire fights is a psycho.
Don’t forget Arthur himself said that Dutch taught him everything he knows.
Dont forget either how insanely quick and accurate dutch shot Micah while holding Sadie, or Cornwall on that boat.
Dutch isn’t stronger
You can’t teach strength and speed and stamina Arthur is just simple faster stronger more durable than Dutch overall
Arthur is stronger re look at rd2
Arthur is way stronger, tf are you on about 😂. Also Dutch taught Arthur the basics, Arthur perfected them on his own. Also dead eye is quicker than Dutch. And don't even try and pull the "it's just a game mechanic" excuse. It's a game mechanic to show how fast and accurate Arthur is.
Just cuz Dutch taught him, doesn't mean Dutch will be better everytime. There's a word called 'surpass', that's what Arthur did to Dutch
I’d give Dutch dueling skill, if you examine their dueling animations, you can tell Dutch has a more effective stance.
Fire edit
Punch fight
1-Mac Callander
2-Charles Smith
3-Arthur
4-Problably Davey Callander
5-John
Gun fight
1-John Marston, possible Mac
2-Arthur Morgan,possible Mac
3-Micah Bell
4-Javier Escuella
5-Dutch
We don't even know anything about Mac dafuq 😂😂😂😂
@@Americanfreloader varios dialogos no acampamento,inclusive um diz que ele enfrentou 15 marinheiros e ainda os venceu
@@Oliveira-tm9tn que?
Arthur would beat John in a gun fight. They always say Arthur is the best shooter in the gang
@@therealea5269 john 1911, 12 years older and experienced
Bro does the best edits i've seen.
THIS is such a fire edit my pal! 🔥🔥🔥
Amazing job on the editing you did absolutely amazing on it.
Arthur was some Kind of Western John wick...
I believe this man could've killed the entire Crew 🤷🏻♂️
Watch out the John fanboys are coming for ya☠️
Better*
@@JendagaAs someone who likes John more, I think 1899 Arthur beats 1899 John.
1911 John beats 1899 Arthur, though
@@Majin135 whatever you say pal
Arthur beat john rdr1 high dff@@Majin135
Great edit!
Dutch taught Arthur everything he knows, he raised him.
I found the legendary edition,
Dutch plan der Linde: “I hAvE a pLaaAAaaan Orthur.”
Son's never able to beat his father in any shape
"dutch help"
"no"
"that ra-"
"you won against me in edit"
W edit
Accuracy for Dutch is wild
Y recuerden dutch siempre tienen un plan
Strategy to Arthur, and intelligence
Arthur is a legend
Gun battle: Dutch
Melee: Arthur
absolutely people shouldn't underestimate dutch especially his gunslinging skill
@@Mr.Rendo1 hes terrible
crazy how John and Arthur surpassed Dutch as a gunslinger, and Dutch is fast as hell as a quick draw and has amazing accuracy
Arthur is the fkn lucifer because we control him💀
I think Arthur would win mid diff
Mid diff is a stretch
Absolutely not. It can't go any lower than high difficulty
@@Benny-jt9cj cry abt it
@@Dod.O39 not really.
True
“I have a plan…”
Aurther is the GOAT but dutch is really smart Broo🤠
imagine dutch in his prime tho
Aw man I wish I won..
I dont think arthur could physically make himself hurt dutch unlike what dutch would be capable of
I think Dueling Skill goes to Dutch he did teach Arthur everything he knew when it came to weapons and reflexes should probably be equal they can dodge bullets coming at fast speed
Do Arthur vs 1914 Jack
Arthur was basically the best gunslinger but he just became good after getting tubercolusis
song name plz guys
Has a plan-dutch
Song?
Son vs Dad
If dutch was in his prime, he would probably win
Es tan inteligente que destruyo su propia banda
For some reason I find this weird to say but somehow even when surrounded by police he somehow finds a way to get out of a situation with no troubles, it’s always someone else in his gang blowing there cover that usually gets them caught
Who, Dutch? Because that's not entirely true. In many occasions he was responsible for many failures.
Song name please??
I HAVE A GODDAMN PLAN🥭✨🥭✨🥭
Arthur Morgan melhor atirando do velho oste
W
Nahhh give that endurance to Dutch, outlived everyone except the Marstons
Arthur>>>>>Dutch Mid Diff.
Arthur>>>>>John High-Extreme Diff.
Arthur>>>>>Red Harlow Extreme diff.
Nah
Arthur beats Dutch Mid-High Diff
Prime John beats Arthur Mid-High Diff
Red Harlow beats John High-Extreme Diff
Faxx
@@Aclipso Nop.
@@W3ggyOriginal bro, Johns draw speed Is 50 milliseconds he wins
@@Aclipsoarthur was the faster draw in the east
Arthur Mıd-Hıgh Diff
Dutch wins in a gun fight but not in a brawl.
nah
@@sockpenguin WDYM nah? Dutch literally has the best accuracy out of any gunslinger and he's a strategist. Arthur has nothing on dutch besides speed.
Bro, Why are you overrating Dutch
@@Kapitalistyczna_Polska I'm not overrating dutch. It's not my fault you all overrate Arthur. Arthur literally struggled too lift a wagon wheel which is literally only 45 pounds. Also it was never stated he beat the legendary gunslingers. If it's not the story mode then it isn't canon. It's the players choice.
@@idk...416bro overrated Dutch
The reason Dutch kept Arthur around was because he was stronger and faster than him, but dumber.
During rdr2, Arthur becomes smarter and demonstrates real leadership, not the flagshow Dutch constantly put on.
That's a big reason Dutch and Arthur began to split.
Arthur became a real leader, once he started thinking for himself.
Accuracy Arthur and low-mid diff
Idk but I feel like Arthur was in mortal kombat
You betrayed me dutch you did
Theres a scene in guarma where dutch says hell hold off the boats coming to shore at the bottom of the fort by himself. I think hes above bill and javier and just barely above charles. In my opinion tgis puts right below micah or maybe on par. John and arthur easily surpassing.
yes Arthur 🥳
I don't know... Dutch is the one who raised Arthur and made him... strong... so... he might be stronger himself...
People forget dutch prob teached arthur how too shoot and dutch has insane accuracy
what kind of text did you use
People saying arthur mids he high difs and maybe even loses if dutch has prep time we don't see dutch fist fight but he taught arthur everything he knows and he has the best aim in the franchise and we also don't really see him Quickdraw nor duel my point is don't underestimate dutch
Gg dutch
But Dutch need money 😢
And remember,he have a plan
Everything that has to do with intelligence goes with Arthur, Dutch proved to be an idiot from chapter 3 to 6
Arthur would probably win in hand to hand combat, but Dutch would win in a gun fight
B b but dutch has a plan
I think Dutch physically stronger than Arthur because he is bigger and older. My opinion
Much bigger as well. Dutch is like 6.2 Arthur us like 6.0
Dutch is definitely taller than Arthur, but Arthur is built like an ox. Guy is pure muscle. Don’t get me wrong, Dutch is deceptively well built, but Arthur is the gang’s enforcer for a reason.
Dice doesn’t matter in a fight Tommy for example Arthur won against a 6 ft 6 inch giant (not sure it’s his actual height just making a assumption) but Arthur won and older is a down side he isn’t in his prime anymore
Nah arthur beat tommy who has to be 6'4 and over 240 pounds and beat someone who is at least 6'8
@@tiesjaja2938Taller and bigger are two different things. Arthur is bigger than Dutch, Dutch is taller than Arthur.
Accuracy Arthur
Battle iq Arthur
whats dutch doing about this :
XX
X
X X
X
X
EDİTOR NEED A OSCAR (REALYYYYY)
Mid diff or mid-high not more than that
I had a plan Arthur
Has a plan
This is nothing but 📠 Ive played red dead redemption 2 enough times to know this is 📠
Dutch clear
@@Unknown97149no😂 arthur negs in gunfight
Maybe Arthur is better than me but i got a plan
Dutch wins because he had a plan
Speed and skill go to Dutch but 🔥
i think aurther would've had better accuracy because of dead eye
i have a plan! score goes 11.8
Juegazo
Actually dutch is not experienced because he fell into the trap of Micah
Song name?
Disaster
Iq goes to arthur easily
9999like?
My like:10.000
fire but skill goes to tahi- i mean dutch
The boss is never as good as the ones below him.
Wrong, Dutch will destroy Arthur because he has a Plan and Faith.
I am pretty sure Dutch would win in a gunfight but not in a brawl
Where is Tennis Boat Dutch
music name?
Disaster
Disaster