The Execution of the Romanovs
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 10. 2020
- The most realistic recreation of the murder of the Romanov Royal Family ever made on video. Around 2.00 am on July 17th, Yakov Yurovsky, the commandant of the Ipatiev house, the “House of Special Purpose”, ordered the Romanovs’ physician, Dr. Eugene Botkin, to awaken the sleeping family and ask them to put on their clothes, under the pretext that they would be moved to a safe location due to impending chaos in Yekaterinburg.
The Romanovs were then ordered into a semi-basement room. Alexei could not walk down the stairs, due to a recent injury, and Nicholas carried him in his arms. Two chairs were brought, on which Tsarevich Alexei and Alexandra sat. The prisoners were told to wait in the cellar room while the truck that would transport them was being brought to the house. A few minutes later, an execution squad was brought in and Yurovsky read aloud the order of the execution given to him by the Ural Executive Committee. The Imperial family, Tsar Nicholas II, his wife Tsarina Alexandra and their five children Olga, Tatiana, Maria, Anastasia, and Alexei, as well as all those who chose to accompany them into imprisonment -notably Dr Eugene Botkin, Anna Demidova, Alexei Trupp and Ivan Kharitonov- were shot, bayoneted and clubbed to death. The massacre that took place was utterly brutal and lasted around 20 minutes,* before all victims were killed.
*Note: The murder in the video takes only a few seconds, but in reality it was a long and frightening procedure. It is described in all details in the book “The Romanov Royal Martyrs: What Silence Could Not Conceal”.
17 July 1918
Around 3.00 am, in the morning of July 17, Yurovsky with his men and Ermakov headed for Koptyaki forest, where a mineshaft was prepared for the disposal of the bodies. When they reached the forest and started unloading the bodies, Ermakov’s men started to ransack the pockets of the victims. Yurovsky threatened he would shoot anyone who stole anything from the bodies.
Yurovsky undressed the bodies and removed all the valuables that were found on them. He then burned the clothes. The men lowered the bodies into the mineshaft, which turned out to be very shallow. They decided to use explosives, so that the inner walls would break and cover up the bodies. It was already daylight. This didn’t work and Yurovsky decided that the bodies should be transferred to another place the following night. He then returned to Ekaterinburg to report to the Soviet.
18 July 1918
Yurovsky returned to the mineshaft around 4:00 am. By morning they had exhumed the bodies from the shaft with the intention of transferring them to a deeper mineshaft. [On the way, the automobile carrying the bodies broke down. The bodies were put on wagons and Yurovsky returned to the town on horseback to bring new automobiles.]* He returned to the forest at 21.30 pm with two trucks. The bodies were loaded on the trucks and headed for the mineshafts. It was after midnight.
19 July 1918
The trucks got stuck again in a swamp. [Yurovsky decided to burn two of the bodies and bury the rest right there. Maria and Alexei were set on fire while a pit was being dug.]* The bodies were then thrown into the pit, smashed and chopped with shovels, and finally doused with sulfuric acid. The pit was covered up, cross ties were laid on top, and the truck drove over it several times to level it. [Near the spot were the bodies of Maria and Alexei were burned, another pit was dug and the remains of the two children were laid in there.]*
*The facts described in the brackets […] are not presented in the video. A full detail account of all the facts is presented in the forthcoming book "The Romanov Royal Martyrs".
This video is produced as part of the project for the book "The Romanov Royal Martyrs”, which is an impressive 512-page book, featuring nearly 200 black & white photographs, and a 56-page photo insert of more than 80 high-quality images, colorized by the acclaimed Russian artist Olga Shirnina (Klimbim) and appearing here in print for the first time.
---------------- - ---------------- - ----------------
📖 EXPLORE the book: romanovs.eu/en-book
🌎 ORDER the book: romanovs.eu/online-store
🎵 THEME SONG: • July Winter Tears | Or...
---------------- - ---------------- - ----------------
Follow us on:
▶ CZcams: goo.gl/9c8ZEx
▶ FACEBOOK: / romanovroyalmartyrs
▶ INSTAGRAM: / romanov_royal_martyrs
I’m 3/4 the way through the book. All I can say is, get the book! It’s a well written masterpiece that carefully guides you through the entire story.
I want that book😊😌 my they all RIP🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🥺🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
@@reneerichburg1500 Yes. Get the book. It is a treasure that is well written. I have since finished the book and it is sourced from first accounts of the events. They were truly martyrs.
What is the name of the book?? I want to buy it
@@verborgenewahrheit1594 Thanks for your response. The link to their website is at the top of the comments section, after their commentary. Good read with breathtaking restored photos!
I just ordered it! Excited to read the whole story.
This tragedy happened almost a century ago. But here I am today, no relation, not born yet, of a completely different race, religion, color and culture and living thousands of miles away in Singapore but I feel the pain, agony, remorse and tears for them!
Same!
Been viewing these horrific reenactments for 2 days now and cannot come to grips with this very real portion of human history. The absolute terror and fear they must've felt upon realizing what was about to happen to them! Innocent lives, unprotected by current laws that existed for all and everyone--regardless! Shot, bludgeoned, stripped of clothing, chopped, burnt-- 1) fire 2) sulfuric
acid and finally, dynamite. If the executioners had any belief in G-d or goodness, enjoyed never again-- a full nor good night's rest, thereafter! Mental torture became their bedfellows! They carried out the deed and not the ones who gave the order. I hope and pray, that upon the death of those who gave the orders, we're met at Heaven's gate, by the Romanovs, with G-d Himself--watching.
Anyone with empathy can feel their pain and what a tragedy it was.
They were nice in this film. It was actually more gruesome than what they showed.
The scene showing the dog is really haunting.
Can’t call it execution. It was cold, cowardly, inhuman and an atrocity.
A ritual murder
In fact a murder... Im trying to improve Wikipedia replacing the word Execution with murder in the matter in fact...
@@MattiavonSigmund : There are different kinds of murder. Some are assassinations, and to be repeatedly shot for no reason would be called an execution.
@@elizabethpease947 Its murder, because it had no legal reason. See russian high courts deciaion in 2008
@@MattiavonSigmund : Murder is deliberately killing someone, with malice in mind, so I guess you could call the regicide of the Romanovs that.
Truly saddens me to know their final moments were so awful. The firing squad were cowards. To kill children.unarmed innocent people
It is truly disgusting. In some ways I can understand why some people think the Tsar should have been punished but not like that, not brutally butchered in such a sickening way. What did his children and the other individuals who are with them ever do to deserve to be mercilessly killed like that. Correct me if I'm wrong please, but didn't the family have pets with them when they were killed. I for sure remember hearing that they had a dog that also died with them. But I don't remember if I heard that a cat was also with them and died as well. Thank you. Can't wait to get this book and I hope one day it can be on audio too.
The children should have been allowed to live.
@@Lordhelmet667 i never come across such evil monsters in my life .. killing the children this way is unacceptable .. russia is a killing field
Putin is... Heir of Stalin and Lenin the killers of Royal family....
The Czar did NOTHING to be punished.. he was miso formed.. plotted against and used. ALL communism is a cowardly mercyless butchering regime. Its power to comrade 1 and murder all competition!
"The Romanov Royal Martyrs " is not just a book but a wonderfully written tribute to the last Tzar and his beautiful young family.
It breaks my heart that people could be this cruel. One day soon I hope to go and pay my respects and pray for their departed souls. 🙏🏼💜🖤
Thank you so much for the positive feedback! 🌼
So sad bless that family and glad they have been found and given a royal burial that they deserve and history of the family is recorded beautiful family
Ask THEM to pray for YOU... they've been canonized by the Russian Orthodox Church.
Agreed.
Beautiful family indeed. Ugly regime took over. Today a similar ugly regime is trying to take over the west. A regime with no morals and no sense of culture or tradition. Stand up to this evil my Euro friends!
"Forgive them God, they don't know what they're doing." That those guilty of the atrocity committed against the royal family are paying in hell. God save the Tsar! God save the Russian Empire! Embraces of a Brazilian Monarchist who was horrified by this event
Красивая величественная семья ❤
Очень красивый царь Николай.
Кроважадные звери, которые уничтожили невинных девушек, больного мальчика и всё это на глазах их родителей, эти звери горят сейчас в аду!
А останки Романовых нашли в этих лесах и с почестями похоронили рядом с их предками🌹 Благодарность тем, кто проделал эту великую и сложную работу👏
Приятно видеть, что кто-то еще ценит ужас этих смертей. Я боюсь, что партия финансировалась западными банками. Зло.
I am not Russian but my heart is crying. I don't know I'm crying watching this video. They don't deserve such horrible DEATH. GOD BLESS THEIR SOULS.
OUR LOVE AND RESPECT FROM THE PHILIPPINES.🇵🇭❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
we
are àlso
no
Russian
never
were The STory
very
touching
Basta con ser un ser humano normal para llorar frente a esta atrocidad sin nombre.
It was most hurtful for prince alexei he was very young and sick.
It was most hurtful for the girls as well. Children should not have to be harmed because of politics.
@@jennifernunez1443 True. Also children have no say in what family they're born into.
Young Alexei undersyood less. It's his Father ... Mother and Sisters who suffed most as they clearly understood just moments before being butchered what was about to happen.!
Hurtful all but yes, especially for the little one.
For all the kids. The parents, who had a lot to blame, got quick deaths while the innocent kids had long painful ones.
I'm pissed that none of the Romanovs' relatives - especially King George V in England - offered them sanctuary!
HE DID BUT THEN RESCINDED HIS OFFER FOR FEAR OF A PUBLIC BACKLASH
@@nicholassweazey987 hello! Have you read our book? Feel free to explore our book’s website: www.romanovs.eu/en-book Very best wishes!
Lindsay Gillis: King Alphonso XIII tried to get them rescued, but wasn’’t able to.
The Zionist communists would not want any claim to the throne. The intent was to rid the country of Its sovereigns and Christ. They failed
@@nicholassweazey987 goes to show, he wasn't much of a king then,doesn't it!?
He was a coward and is just as guilty; as if he pulled the trigger himself.
This happened so long ago but it makes me cry for them. What a horrible and needless tragedy.
Right?If the Tsar had just dissolved the Monarchy, it wouldn't have even happened, but he was determined to rule as an autocrat over the people of Russia whether they liked it or not, and that kept even his innocent family in the line of fire. It's truly a shame, a tale of incompetence and hubris that only ever brings about the death of innocents.
All four Daughters and the Boy were Gorgeous
Angels in earth and now on heavens!
And they were completely innocent!
Bolshevik rats killing innocent children.
@@mesias6412 its disgusting, rotten soulless blood bags
@@RomanovRoyalMartyrs Dear Friend boldly reveal the truth that Demons only reason for Death of Russian royal family.
How could you kill such an innocent family when they did nothing wrong to you!!!! My heart is in pain!! R.I.P. Romanv’s
not so innocent....
The children are innocent. They didnt deserve to die because of their parents’ mistakes
The question still in my head HOW bloodrelatives all over the whole Europe allow this to happen and even look silently participate in it??? How they could live after that? And WHY NOW THAT MANY INFO arises on Romanov's history and murder in all the media? Where have u been these 100 ? As many as social media on Windsors family ... If it is a plan - than it is a disgusting plan...
juice
You might want to pick up an actual history book and read up the so called innocent romanovs. You statement is truly idiotic and ignorant.
The film was somewhat accurate. It didn't show the really brutal parts where the girls had jewelry sown in their garments which acted like a bullet proof vest. The beasts ended up beating to death with rifle butts.
They actually stabbed them with bayonets and killed them.
It also shows the girls with long hair.
Their hair had been shaved off when they were sick with measles.
By an account i read over the weekend, their hair would have just about reached their shoulders.
There's only so much violence you can show in a CZcams video before it gets demonitzed
Was nearly a century ago this atrocity happened but watching and reading it feels like yesterday. My heart aches for the whole family😥😖😢😭. Father, unto your hands may you received their spirit. Grant them peace, love and happiness. This world is not forever and they had lived it to your purpose. No more can they hurt. 🙏
Hello, Lavinia! Thanks for watching and for sharing these wonderful thoughts here with us! We recommend this video, as well, from our channel: czcams.com/video/IC-D1dZKoCI/video.html 🌷🌷
Such lovely words, God bless you
Yeah happened in the nineties
Youre a kind hearted
My Great Grandparents escaped Russia, He was a Military Atache' for Czar Nicholas, they escaped to America, via Europe to Denmark. Many of our Family too, were executed or Enslaved by the Communists. May they all Rest In Peace with God.
Yes there were many victims of this inhuman regime. Ukraine, Poland Hungry, chekoslovakia and on and on. History just keeps repeating itself. It is impossible to wrap your head around this kind of evil. Thank God your family was able to escape. I never even heard of this until recently.
COMMUNISM is a Terrible thing.. it is nothing more than a lincense for government to kill its citizens by the millions.
This is very sad history indeed, especially knowing that the Romanovs were killed by fellow Russians. Not an external war, but internal conflict
@@taxol2 No, the Bolsheviks were Jews not Russians!
Thank God they were able to escape!
This is so depressing. What monsters would do something like this to innocent children. I would've understood if it had just been the Tsar and maybe the Tsarina but the kids, come on. No child deserves a miserable death like that. RIP Romanovs
We don't really know what happened to the executioners who murdered the royal family but perhaps they were also brutally killed by the Germans when Hitler ordered the invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941. Around 26 million Russians were killed in WW2.
Pray for us, Holy Romanov Family.
Very well acted, but you know it was much worse than this. I've wondered if these people had any inkling of death around the next corner. May they all rest in peace and sing with the angels.
THEY DID NOT EXPECT DEATH and least of all in such a monsterously cowardly way. The Czar was in fact waiting for word of theur rescue plan. They had no idea EVERY COUNTRY + ALLIE had betrayed or turned coward on them. The Czarina (his wife) was the Grand Child of Queen Victoria...and her mother was Alice ..daughter of Queen Victoria. Her Father was Grand Duke of HESS.
@@RedGuardYF nah Lenin and Stalin are in there
@@r3v773 Luke 13:2-3 (KJV) And Jesus answering said unto them, Suppose ye that these Galilaeans were sinners above all the Galilaeans, because they suffered such things?
I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.
Romans 3:23 (KJV) For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;
Romans 5:12 (KJV) Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Romans 6:23 (KJV) For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Revelation 20:14-15 (KJV) And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death.
And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.
Revelation 21:8 (KJV) But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.
Romans 5:8 (KJV) But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.
John 3:16-18 (KJV) For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.
For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved.
He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.
Acts 3:19 (KJV) Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord;
Romans 10:9-10, 13 (KJV) That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.
For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.
@@RedGuardYF The fact that you wish hell on someone explains why you are a fan of communists... You are usually really awful people.
During the last Divine Liturgy served in the Ipatiev House the priest said that an atmosphere of gloom pŕevailed and the Grand Duchesses wept quietly throughout the service. They had an inkling that something was afoot.
This show is so realistic I felt like I was there. The Czar and Czarina were spoiled, elite, out of touch with their people and under the spell of a madman. But they were not evil. They certainly did not deserve death, and especially not the children. The love they had for each other and their courage at the end all things will be remembered throughout the ages. I wonder who they came back as.
What is the hogus bogus gibberish trash that you wrote that betrays the severe damage that you suffer from in your prefrontal cortex to the extent that you hardly have a vegetative mind to live with that is why you are writing laughable foolishness. What evil spell are you talking about miserable fool, wake up. What are you talking about, wake up. What spell of an evil man are you talking about; the Czar and Czarina were great people their only fault is that they were too gentle and never knew how to use force when they should have like their predecessors, instead the Czarina during WWI opened a section of the winter palace and transformed it as a hospital to treat wounded soldiers and she used to do that herself with the oldest three young grandduchesses healing her and that was at time when no other royalty anywhere thought of doing anything like that. As for the Czar he used to lead the army himself at a time when all other royalties were hiding in their palaces as the war was raging throughout Europe. Stop repeating the satanic lies of the marxists like an idiot.
@@vahrheit9996 blah blah blah.
The Czar, at least, is certainly debatable. He took up the mantle of unelected absolute Monarch despite knowing he was incapable of the job, because he believed that much is his "divine birthright" to rule over others without them having any say. His incompetence was already getting innocent people killed before he was even done being coronated, and judging by his callousness, you can't even call him a benevolent dictator, either. he was a good family man, maybe, but that doesn't absolve him of his tyranny and crimes against the people he ruled over.
@@CABRALFAN27 I do agree with you on Nicholas. He was pathetically unfit to rule.
Who they came back as? There is no such thing as reincarnation. It's a myth.
Breaks my heart endlessly of the Romanovs murder. Rest In Peace. I’m so Happy you are in heaven now though and are in absolute joy with our Savior and Lord and Father Jesus Christ!💛✝️🙏🏻☦️
I don't know why my chest hurts so much and a tear suddenly came out on my eyes. I feel so bad and pity those kids😢that Family had a horrible destiny on the hands of those people who were greedy of power😔😢
Truly a tragic story! Here's another video that follows their last days: czcams.com/video/DD_xdwbV8-I/video.html
Communists are so evil.
i can feel their pain, one of the saddest part of history!
@@RedGuardYF shush commie
The music is so beautiful. Breaks my heart. What a tragedy..
The music is called "please don't cry" by David Fesliyan of Fesliyan Studios... N I cried too... 😭
I would most love to have the monastery singing from the first part.
From The Royal Family and Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn to Br Jose Munoz Cortez. The Russian church endured persecutions and evils comparable to the cruelest of Pagan Rome. Yet has only gotten stronger in the faith!
May Russia never have such evils befall her and her faithful again.
May all the Russian Martyrs be in peace and pray for us all! ☦️
@Shiraz Adams : Why do you believe that?
I believe Western Jews also wanted tO destroy the Russian Ortodox
@Shiraz Adams Yes, You are right 👍
@Shiraz Adams no, only the Bolsheviks wanted to, the West was busy with World War One📚
@@elizabethpease947 because he's either a Communist or a Turk
Of course I knew what was going to happen--anyone who knows even a little about the last Tsar knows, but I cried when their murders were depicted. Those poor children. Even when I read books 📚 (novels or non-fiction) the tears flow 😢. So very sad.
It would have been great if at least the kids survived, but given that they were a tight-knit family, it's good that no one survived to live without the others. RIP
Heartbreaking and saddest part in our history, Romanov family very beautiful children they are now happy together in heaven.RIP🙏⚘🇷🇺🇵🇭♥️
Imagine being woken up from sleep just to be brutaly killed how monstrous
It's 2021 May 18... Tears roll off my cheeks as this story ends my day, how cruel this world is and has been to so many innocent lives. May they rest in peace. Such a terrible tragedy. 😓
I don't have strenght to watch a video talking about this horrible event, probably the worst crime in human history made to a small group of people, but im sure it's a video very well made, as aways...
It's tragic, but I don't think it's the worst crime in history, ever heard of Adolf Hitler???
@@madambutterfly7513 I wrote "human history made to a small group of people" for a reason
@@madambutterfly7513 you mean the guy who fought agaisnt the murderers of these children? that guy hit ler?
@@madambutterfly7513 There is plenty of evidence suggesting that the Bolshevics were not better than the Nazis and in fact, these two totalitarian ideologies committed atrocities at the same level of horror. If you're really interested in learning more and finding out the truth then just do your own research instead of trying to "educate" others about Adolf Hitler's crimes as if you're the only one who graduated from highschool.
the russians monarchs are strikingly beautiful than the british royals
Yes, much more beautiful and handsome. However, they are related to the English monarchy. Queen Victoria was great grandmother to Tsar Nicholas' children. His son inherited hemophilia B from the English side of his family, specifically Queen Victoria, who also passed it on to her son, Prince Leopold, who died of it at age 30. Further, the children were half-German as their mother was from Germany. All European royal families are related one way or the other.
@@evamarek5205 Queen Victoria was Alexandria's GrandMother, yes therefore the children's Great Grandmother.
They were all inbreed...thats why the boy was sick..
@@trivo8380 The boy got Hemophilia B from his great grandmother Queen Victoria. She gave it to her son Prince Leopold who died of it at age 30. There was no hemophilia in the Romanov family until Alexei's mother was wed to his father. She was Queen Victoria's granddaughter.
@@trivo8380 They are all still inbred today. Though marrying people outside the royal family helps make the gene pool much more diverse.
This was no execution...it was Martyrdom. I have a hard time watching this.
I do believe all 11 were received directly into heaven.
Such a beautiful family My heart aches hearing the story Even the animated version brings tears to my heart
The Royal family said No when the Romano’s asked fo😢asylum. True story.
@@anitastanley8986 The Prime Minister told George V that he couldn't have the Romanovs in England. And the king of England has no real power. He is ceremonial. It didn't make any difference anyway. The children had the measles and couldn't be moved. And the Tsar refused to leave Russia. Also they were under heavy guard at the Alexander Palace near St. Petersburg. They would never have been allowed to leave Russia.
@@SymphonyBrahms Thank you.
It wasn’t an execution it was brutal massacre
tankie : but romanov kill many ppl
@@cat3784 The children didn't!
@@dianetheisen8664 communist not care. if they need to kill you, you must be killed even if you're baby or in your mom womb.
they will do anything to make their agenda works
@@cat3784 Oh I get it but don't like it. Thanks for responding to my comment.
Heart wrenching 💔
I could not watch the whole video. By wachting I feel like a witness standing on the side while not doing anything to help Them.
Those moments must have been, they are no words. For a family so close knowing that they were unable to protect each other probably made it so so much worse
Exactly how I felt can't imagine the horror the parents felt yes there's lots of horror stories like this I know x all of them won't be forgotten x
Oh yes...you want to charge through the screen & stop this horrible atrocity. Yet their tragedy over 100 years past, brings us together in love & admiration for the Royal Martyrs.
@@venusrising6554 I always feel that way whenever I watch a documentary, movie or read about a horrible crime. I usually end up wishing I had a time machine too.
😭
Eternal rest grant unto them ,on, Lord ,and let the perpetual light shine upon them . May they rest in peace. Amen.
Saints Now!!!!
Amen.
This is brutal criminal..RIP to Tsar Nickholas and family.God still with you and family..
Bolcheviqs will NEVER be forgoten by this
Or forgiven
I visited St Petersburg in July 2019 and among all the stunning & beautiful historic places I was also able to see the family’s remains final resting place (Peter & Paul Cathedral), a hunting and sad experience. Is hard to stand there and not to think about the madness of such a brutal act. Fanaticism of any kind, overall religious & political will convert regular men into beasts.
So sad. I haven't read the book yet, but their murder is senseless and so sad. What could have been
Thanks for watching, Kimberly, and for your comment here! If you eventually do get the book, you will be extremely surprised by its content! In the meantime, here's another recommendation from our channel: czcams.com/video/IC-D1dZKoCI/video.html
I seen this before but this time they added the screaming........... it’s just too painful to watch this time 😞 What horror they went through before their deaths 😭😞Dear GOD in Heaven 🙏🙏
It's not exactly correct, it took them 20 mins to kill everyone apparently because of the incompetence. They had to wait for smoke to clear because they had old gunpowder, they were told to use bayonets and stocks of weapons part way through because it was to loud and the diamonds were deflecting the shots as well and even that didn't work on everyone. Some of the kids had to be shot again in the head.
Noah, what you say is unclear toe. I DONT UNDERSTAND WHAT you're saying.
@Noah Scheid Anastasia did not escape. Anna Anderson's DNA did not match the DNA of the Romanovs. She was a liar. Don't believe that Anastasia survival crap.
And the wall behind them was much more “torn apart” than that.
Romanovs were such a beautiful family they didn't deserve to be Killed with such brutality and cruelty by the Bolsheviks. It's a touching emotional video
This is very sad, they were a very good family
@Blue Toile ...Or should I address you as Blue Toilet. Only Communist propaganda tells people that the Tsar was corrupt and unfair. In truth he was a kind and decent ruler, and at the time the revolution started, Russia was not the backward economy as the world had been told. It was overall the best economy in the world and had grown, mostly for the benifit of the poor during The Tsar's reign than in any other time in Russian history. Question.... What happened to the poor people the Bolshevics claimed to care about after the revolution. I rest my case. Unless of course if you say something stupid.
@Blue Toile Hellbound Communists die many deaths
I agree. Good family, terrible rulers who lost touch with reality. It was too late for them to fix what they and their fathers have done. Unfortunately, did not acknowledge the time and rapid need for a change
@@RedGuardYF no. Luckily the Romanovs didn't do that
@@RedGuardYF not really didn't do anything as bad as Lenin and Stalin did since they're dirty Communists
I dont understand how they do this.i am shaking of anger sad and anger,why kill the whole family?if 1 made mistakes,why dont just kill 1 instead of whole family.very bad
So that the monarchy ends. So that none of their children would be able to continue to rule.
It is awful to see your dad disempowered unable to protect his family.
That's beyond me. My heart cannot stand these cold-blooded - brutal murder scenes.
Thank you RRM project team for sharing this with us as a reminder of what humanity should NOT be; Vicious, Ruthless, Cruel, Ferocious, Barbarian GANG like the Bolsheviks and their like!
such act of murder of people who lust power and filled with greed is inhumane,
royal or not they do not deserve this!!!!History will never forgive!!!
May the Russian Imperial Family their loyal servants,and all the victims of Communist Bolshevicks get the justice they deserve May all of them rest in Peace...
NICHOLAS ,ALEXANDRA, OLGA,TATIANA,MARIA, ANASTASIA and ALEXIE PRAY FOR RUSSIA and the rest of the world...
ANTIFA are the same as the Bolsheviks
@@voodootrucker1896 That's right wing crap.
I recently finished reading your most wonderful book, thank you. I have shown it to all my family, friends and passers-by (if I am sitting in a park reading) - especially the magnificent collection of coloured photographs.
The descriptive characterisation of each of the family members was brilliant and uplifting; the political developments as Nicholas was betrayed by traitors and cowards, dramatic and moving.
The description of the murders of the family and their retinue was gut-wrenching and sickening - it is impossible to comprehend that such anti-human evil can and still does exist and thrive.
I do have just one major concern. I was left quite flat with the closing tribute by Sir Winston Churchill, “perhaps the greatest statesman of the twentieth century”.
Firstly, I didn’t think it was much of a ‘tribute’:
• “to the supreme responsible authority belongs the blame or credit …”
• “In spite of errors vast and terrible …”
and secondly, having researched the despicable Churchill, I would not attribute the word ‘statesman’ to this often drunk and belligerent schemer and warmonger. Without his perseverance on behalf of his financial handlers (eg Henry Strakosch and Frederick Lindeman) there would have been no WWII. Mention of his name does great discredit to the memory of St Nicholas II and his family, and I hope you might consider revising this last page in future editions.
Thank you so much for your positive feedback, Julius! We appreciate the time you have taken to give us this detailed review! It is really rewarding to hear back from our readers that they liked the book! Our best wishes to you!
Are you really blaming World War II on Winston Churchill? How about Hitler? Or Japan?
'Father forgive them for they know not what they do'. The parallels between the life of Tsar Nicholas and his family and the life of Christ is what defines this tragic event and stands forever as a beacon and lesson for all mankind - but again 'there are none so blind as those who will not see'
Wonderful thoughts, Geoffrey, you are very right. Thanks for sharing!
RIP ROMANOV FAMILY
That's beyond words...My heart aches for them...but why call a murder an " execution"?
😥😢😭😭😭😭😭
I Agree.. the Butchering and murder of this beautuful family was a horrible and cowardly thing to do. Lenin abd his cronies were evil scheming bastards! The changed to course of tge most powerful nation as well as other nations. Today..communism under disguise of socialism in American has replaced democracy. I expect the worst. Already jyst like the Bolshivecks (Leninsm) the democrats in USA are plotting to destroy...illuminate Trump and everything he stood fir including his supportors!!
@@mmartin7483 Sie haben so recht,Hintergrund sind immer DUMMHEIT und EITELKEIT !!!
Shame on the English king George V who would not take in his cousin the Tsar and the family because of politics.
@@mmartin7483 The Democrats are nothing like the Bolsheviks. And Trump is a liar and a con man. He is a disgusting leech on society. You have been fooled by grifter Trump and his crooked associates.
Tsar Nicholas thought they would be treated decently by the revolutionaries - after all, they were Russian, too. He was rather naive. One day he controlled all of Russia - the next day he was a nobody. What a stupendous irony. His English cousin should have saved the family. It's not the first time a friend has acted disloyally. Remember Neville Chamberlain - he turned his back on Czechoslovakia. Remember Jimmy Carter - he turned his back on the Shah of Iran. Remember Nicolae Ceausescu, the Romanian ruler. One day he was in control of his country and the next day he was running for his life - running from his own people. Remember Benito Mussolini... the list goes on.
yes, the list goes on and on and on.....
King George V could not bring them to England because Parliament forbade it. The English king has no real power. All of the power rests with Parliament.
What is so appalling is that absolutely no one in Russia has apologized for their murders. It does not matter whether it took place 100 yrs (or more) ago, or yesterday. This was an atrocity. Until this apology is heard and felt, Russia will always be a lawless state, a country of criminals.
Beatification of the family is not an apology.
To whom does Russia owe an apology and for what?
Country of criminals is USA.
Perhaps the Jews should apologise. Bolsheviks were Jewish.
And more recently RF could apologise for invading Ukraine.
@@fimack8279 Lenin was not Jewish. And most of the Bolsheviks were not Jewish. Watch out. Your racism and hatred are showing.
I am not Russian but it haunted me…I have researched and watched some videos about the tragedy…I have no word to describe…
How brutal!
Thank you for sharing this 🥀
You are so welcome! Thanks for watching! If you are interested in the truth about the life and death of the last Romanov family, as well as to what really took place in Russian during that turbulent era, then we highly recommend our book, which offers previously unpublished materials strictly from primary and archival sources. Our book brings to light a multitude of unknown and unrevealed facts, which evince that many truths remain silenced or distorted to this day. If you like to learn more, you can visit our official website: www.romanovs.eu/en-book
So heartbreaking.. my heart is crying for them :( i hope they're in a good place and happy for they're all together..
RIP
Nicholas II of Russia
(1868-1918)
Alexandra Feodorovna
(1872-1918)
Olga Nikolaevna
(1895-1918)
Tatiana Nikolaevna
(1897-1918)
Maria Nikolaevna
(1899-1918)
Anastasia Nikolaevna
(1901-1918)
Alexei Nikolaevich
(1904-1918)
Eugene Botkin
(1865-1918)
Anna Demidova
(1878-1918)
Alexei Trupp
(1856-1918)
and
Ivan Kharitonov
(1872-1918)
Tears in my eyes and a great pain in my heart, a hundred years later
That's totally horrible.
How can anyone harm another human being like that????
Heard of the Nazis? They were as bad as the Bolsheviks.
More So How can they Hurt Women & Children Completely Heartless.
Hello from Florida. My heart aches for the Romanovs, the last Czar of Russia, and also for their servants and for the Prime Minister at the time. No justification to be murdered with such cruelty. I can’t help but wonder what Russia would be like today. I hope we can learn from the past, live in the present, and hope for the future. Although, I’m an agnostic, I hope for a better Middle East
Killing children ,let alone the parents..was a abomination.
Actually, just Anastasia and Alexei were children, or less than 18 years of age.
@menkrep1337 bot under the russian constitution of 1906, the age of majority was 16 years, so just Alexei was a minor. But regardless of the age, murder is not a good thing to do.
Not to kill a dynasty of oppressors is the abomination.
@@r3v773 The russian revolution that actually overthrew the czar occurred in 1917 and it was not lead by the Bolsheviks. This was the actual revolution and it brought the semi democratic provisional government under Alexander Kerensky to power. This revolution is the actual revolution that ended czarism and had the family put under house arrest. The Bolshevik coup actually occurred against this provisional government some years later. Thus, the Bolsheviks weren't responsible for ending czarism and the resulting Bolshevik government was not an actual representative of the Russian revolution or the anti-czarism movement of Russia. They overthrew the provisional government, the legitimate child of the Russian revolution. Furthermore, this so called "dictatorship of the proletarian" was responsible for thwarting a rising democratic state that would have matured under the provisional government in the 1920s. This would have led to an established Eurasian democracy in our day.
Lenin came sometime after the revolution has occurred, bought the allegiance of the local council of workers in moscow through his speech "all power to the council (soviets)" (he had been known as a dissident for some 20 years by then but he was not the only figure in Russia at the time) and through their help carried a coup d'état against the provisional government a few years later. This triggered a civil war in Russia and the Bolsheviks organized an army out of their followers and actually took power after some 4 years of fighting various armies. So they were usurpers who took power through a coup against the actual child of the revolution, the provisional government, and through a civil war against the various armies that arose due to that coup. And conflating their ghastly rule to justify the other ghastly rule of the czar is historical dishonesty that forgot the promise of the semi-democratic provisional government. You should compare the provisional government with the czar. And then compare the provisional government with the Bolsheviks. And the Russian revolution gave mandate to the provisional government who promised elections and parliamentary rule not to the autocracy of the soviets or the czar. There is no doubt in the mind of all the Russian people who carried out the first actual revolution (majority of them have no involvement with lenin and his entourage, an impossible proposal in a national revolution) and installed the provisional government that the czar and his family deserved nothing less than execution. And they gave their allegiance to the provisional government not the violent Bolshevik mass murderers who ruled by cowering and dismantling the provisional government first and then the people next.
So what basically happened in Russia goes something like this
- Ghadafi(the czar) was overthrown and the UN backed government got installed in Tripoli after a revolution of the Libyan people. This government had plans for elections and had the support of the majority of the Libyan people. It was semi democratic at best and Libyans believed ghadaffi deserved his fate(I personally dont think ghadaffi was as bad as the czar but I am not Libyan so I can not know deeply) Forget about US intervention in our allegory also. Two years later Isis took over libya through a coup and we can guess how bad this would be if decades passed. People like you will then say ghadaffi was good. This is really what happened in russia.
This beautiful family should not have been denied asylum
Blame the Parliament. They have all the power, not the king. They told King George V no to asylum for the tsar.
Uma execução covarde contra a família Romanov, o que as jovens e criança tinham a ver com a luta pelo poder do Estado. Uma chacina imperdoável!🇷🇺🇧🇷
I could be wrong but I think my family is related to them through marriage. It’s absolutely sickening that my own relatives could’ve possibly saved their lives but didn’t.
Yes, his cousin , king of england, told nicholas no. I wonder what ended up happening to him?
@@janebogdanski3555 The king of England does not have any real power. The power is held by Parliament. And they told King George V that he couldn't bring the tsar to England. The last powerful kings of England were during the 1600's. After that they lost their power to Parliament.
I'm choked with tears streaming this was really hard to watch to the end ,may god rest their souls .What a horrible way to die.They must have gone through hell and I can't begin to imagine it.Its just heartbreaking.It was evil truly barbaric what they did to that beautiful family.💔💔
🙏🏻💔
Very very sad! Many years but they are Unforgettable! 😭😱🇮🇹
They murdered 11 beautiful souls that day. May they rest in peace.💔😢😭🌹🌷💜💙💚💛 .Thank you, God Bless😉💜
What brutality! What senselessness! What inhumanity! May the perpetrators of this unspeakable violence continue to be meted unending Divine Justice. May the innocent martyrs enjoy glory in the presence of God.
Do you mean the tsars? They were the murderers
How do men who do such things live with themselves
Because they please not God and are cortrary to all men.
shelia roach: Some of the assassins did cry after the actual executions.
@@elizabethpease947 who?
@@willtheperson7224 : I don’t know them by name, but after they killed the people, they ran out of the cellar gasping for air, getting sick to their stomachs and crying over what had just taken place. Some of them didn’t want to bury the Romanovs, either, but Yurovsky would have killed them if they hadn’t.
They are all Hellbound Losers
This is why I hate the communism. Why did the Soviet murder the Czar and his family? Let them leave Russia. What a coward behavior of the Soviet.
A crying shame what happened to this Family.
What's the name of the CD which contains the Chorus Music played on this documentary ? Clearly it's Russian Ortodoxian Music but , what's the name of the music and the Choral ?
i could never imagine the pain of watching your own babies being murdered before your own eyes. watching the videos of the children playing as babies and toddlers has me weeping.
Or seeing younger SIblings(Like a Sick Brotha) be Gunned down along with your Mom & Fellow Siblings As there Terror-Fillied Scream's are Silenced 😞.
Pray for us my most holy cousins! May your memories be a blessing and may we never forget!
I'm not sure why? But I've always thought of these royals for as long as I can remember watched TV films read about them followed Anna Anderson story too that poor family its so sad what happened to them royal or not I can't imagine the horror of it! God bless them x
They killed the whole family because they don't want any survivor otherwise one of those girls or their only brother will pay back this in years to come, it's very very sad very emotional.
This was so wrong 💔 why couldn't the Romanov Royal Family live in Exile.?.😢 The Killers didn't even know what they were doing it took them forever to kill everyone in the family how cruel and unnecessary. 🕊
Many of the killers were apparently blind drunk
@Blue Toile ....The actual order to murder the Tsar and his family came from New York Banker Jacob Schiff, Lenin and Trotsky had no say in the matter. Schiff is the same person who had Trotsky as a personal guest in New York City before the revolution, before giving Trotsky 20 million in gold and making sure his puppet, President Woodrow Wilson got him his passport and all the necessary paperwork to get him to Russia for the Revolution. Schiff is also the person who arranged a 200 million dollar loan to Japan to fund them so they could fight against Russia in the war in 1905, ironically when they attempted the first revolution. Do you smell a rat yet? Furthermore, they never intended to put Nicholaus on trial, because they would have had to prove him guilty of something, and he was guilty of nothing. Communists find you guilty with the media they control, so anything they do is justified.
That’s what the solution was to try. No one wanted the Imperial family in their country because of the war. Most were able to live in exile. It wasn’t just Nicholas and his family. The Bolsheviks were after all Romanovs.
@@debbieanne7962 you would have to be drunk or insane to do what they did
@@Tboy439 What a bunch of anti-Semitic crap. Seek counselling.
Watching all the way from Jamaica, i feel so down after witnessing so much violence towards women snd children. What did they do??!! May they rest in peace
Exactly! The children and the servants, down to the pets, were all innocent 😇.
my heart aches for the Romanovs.
The knowledge has come to me and I am deeply saddened by what happened to the Romanov family and how it connects to what has been happening around the world for many years and it's always coming back to haunt us.
Yes, sad, but true: people, especially those in power, it seems do not learn from the past.
So Heartbreaking 😢. May their soul rest in peace. 🙏🙏🙏
What a tragedy in so many ways. The coward deed of Stalin should be ponted out. King George's contribution must also be remembered.
It was Lenin, not Stalin who ordered their deaths. And the British kings have no real power. The power rests with Parliament. George V was told by the Prime Minister and Parliament that he couldn't bring the tsar to England. And they have ruled England since the 1600's, not the king.
E muito triste ve uma família que tevê um fim triste nas mão de assassino.
Their royal relatives could have done something to help them , but they chose to ignore them and left them on their own.
King George V had no power to help them. All the power in England is held by the Parliament, and Parliament forbade the king to help them.
I watched this on Netflix. It is very sad. All the daughters wear their diamonds beneath their clothes, the bullet doesn't kill them directly, but they were shot repeatedly untill death.. 😭
This is so heart breaking...💔
Is there any information of the theme song between 8:40 to 12:39? I enjoy it very much and would add more joy to me of the title is known.
O que assistimos foi filmado no dia que aconteceu? Ou é filme?
Malditos los que asesinaron a esta familia y que sus generaciones reciban la maldición eterna así como a todos aquellos que planearon este horrible crimen
Hope to see these put into a movie so that the world would see how evil communism is
What a Beautiful and Wonderful Family ❤️💕 Rest in Peace 🙏
Esta parte me estremece de dolor cuanto siento todo las penas que pasaron pero entregandose a la voluntad de Dios a quien amaban
They are all so beautyful and gorgeous
Was this re-enactment filmed in 2019? Where was it filmed? It looks like 1920's era filmmaking. The choice to do it silent movie documentary style was very powerful especially no voices until the screams.
What was written on the wall at 7:13 ? Did the assassins leave writing behind after their cowardly action?
Hi! You can read our article on this, on our book's website: www.romanovs.eu/murder-room-inscriptions
I would like to know, too. I was hoping that there would have been a translation, but no.
i watched this with tears in my eyes. with anger throughout my whole body. just look at those revolutionairs starting off “the great revolution” by first of all already murdering innocent children. what has that revolution given us, other than tirans as our leaders. it still kills innocent children to this day. the girls, the beautiful boy. all innocent. all violently murdered. the anger i have towards this is unimaginable.
rest in peace, beautiful souls. may god protect your souls in heaven🙏
земля вам пухом. господь бог любит вас, аминь.
Боже, какой ужас, неужели это все было!?