Has France Reached a Tipping Point?
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 06. 2024
- Into Europe: On the 27th of July Nahel Merzouk was shot by a police officer, triggering several days of rioting in French cities. Why were these riots so different, and has French reached a tipping point?
Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction
01:27 The Banlieue
05:48 The Riots
© All Rights Reserved.
3D Animation Mel Wagner: melw.art/
Contact information:
Email: Into.Europe@outlook.com
Twitter: / europeinto
Patreon: / intoeurope
You skipped the part where he was pulled over earlier that day and led them on a long chase where he ran red lights, drove recklessly, and endangered the lives of other drivers.
And he was headed towards a school zone, I hear.
And you don't go through all this editing and leave things like that out by accident.
This guy is lying by omission.
Yeah so that justifies shooting the reckless boy? Here in India most police don't even have a gun. West has serious issue with police violence and immigration is a result of western colonialism.
you do understand that this doesnt matter?
@@glaucon522it does
We need to stop making excuses for people who refuse to assimilate. If you come from another country for whatever reason, learn the language of the land, learn and obey the laws, and act accordingly to the customs of that country. If they can't do that, then they should be sent back where they came from.
Exactly
@@eliranamar8497 But France weirdly (the only country in the world) ban people from practicing religion (you can’t wear hijab in schools, driving people to attend private religious schools with students from one background) and force you to undress in beaches and public pools. This is ridiculous. And needlessly increases tensions.
@@hus390 what increases tensions is a religion that never stops promoting itself, even against the laws. Islam creates tensions everywhere it does not rule the land. There's no reason why you should wear hijab as a child or teenager in a school. Promoting a religion is forbidden in French schools. It's the same rule if you work for the State, you can't promote your religion while at work. If you can't respect this simple rule, then maybe France isn't for you. There are 200 countries in the world, many of them Muslims.
As for the hijab while at the swimming pool, I agree it can be debated, actually France did not really ban it as far as I understand, but anyway, this is not the French way. We don't want Frankistan, we want France, is that a crazy thing ? Do Arabs want us to change their way of life ? I don't think so. So, why would everyone have the right to preserve their national identity and their way of life, except when they are from the West ?
First and foremost the people of Europe must accept their _own_ culture again, from which these laws and customs come from. We culturally cannibalize ourselves, making it easy for parallel societies.
@@Loxias1989 that is projection. it's the govt that enforce their laws upon people with religious principles, which has no place in a liberal democracy. now when they fought back against decades of systemic opression, you act as if you're the victim while still saying things like "if you don't like it, leave" which in itself a form of rascism which proves the statement in regards to collonialism in the video. the kid is legally a citizen, FYI.
they wear what they are wearing not for the sake of promotion. no one would go "oh look, a headscarf! that is so dope, how do i sign in!" they wore it for religious principles and it does not hurt anybody. funny that the same country complains how iran imposed dress code in public when it's doing the exact same thing.
I’m an Arab immigrant living in France and I can tell you the whole « we’re delinquents because we’re poor and forgotten » narrative is BS. French banlieues would actually be very nice places to live in if it weren’t for all the crime. Nice, renovated buildings, good urbanism, relatively good access to public services, affordable rent and shops… Way nicer than the shithole I used to live in in Lebanon. The problem is ideology, and the truth is many immigrants or descendants hate the people and the culture because they’re racist against French people because of religious and ideological reasons. If I were French I would honestly raise hell in the face of people who riot while they have access to the most generous welfare state in Western Europe (free healthcare, unemployment, social housing, family benefits, free education… even for foreigners !)
West must have the same backbone as China, where disorder has no place in their society
@@nonnoyobisnis8705You will never be a German
@@nonnoyobisnis8705 I'm not being funny. You aren't German. Being born in Germany does not make you German. If you aren't an ethnic German, you're not German. This isn't a hard concept, as it's one that the entire rest of the world understands.
@@Rildar German is a nationality and a ethnicity, Technically 2 different things at once.
@@randomperson-uj4bp Only ethnic Germans are considered actually Germans. Don’t try some silly civic nationalist argument, it won’t work.
Our existence is non-negotiable, and our ethnicity is not a title for non-Germans to appropriate.
in France, driving dangerously has become the new trend for these young people who respect neither the law nor their fellow citizens whom they steal, attack… and cases of car chases where drivers injure or kill pedestrians have unfortunately become frequent. A few weeks ago, an entire family was crushed to death by a driver trying to escape the police. A car is a potentially deadly weapon.
Before young people in France weren’t like this.
@@oie27They weren't algerian
If it's okay to murder minors in France, no wonder your trying to invade Niger. No shame.
So you are justifying police aggressive behavior?
@@Almunshi I think you should read or watch the entire video or something idk but in the comments there’s interesting info but I last commented here 3 weeks ago. But also France I’m in it right now and Paris is dirty and a guy said it was because of the death of the guy or something.
Hard to integrate people who are not interested in being integrated or actively work to undermine this system.
UK assimilates immigrants from very different cultures (like Muslim Pakistanis and Hindu Indians) much better than France does, why is that?
“When we hang the capitalists they will sell us the rope we use”. Joseph Stalin
Why are all these comments blocked?
or .. you could not kill people.
Is that how racists frame the situation? Thanks for letting us now.
As one commenter put it, France has had another country living in it with different beliefs that regards the Republic as an enemy.
That regards French people* as an ennemy.
Yes, many people don't want to accept the fact that the biggest racists in France are in the immigrant community. They have zero desire to integrate society, and look at locals as inferior
so it's a civil war then?
We have that in the UK as well, I suspect it's a European thing.
👍
In a normal world a 17 year old isn’t driving a 70,000 euro Mercedes…. Without a license
The cop did the right thing getting rid of a 17 year old known criminal in a 70000 euro car 👏👏👏👏
Moving to a country with a totally different culture and refusing to accept and conform to it doesn’t constitute proof of a colonial and racist history; simply means those people are living in the wrong country.
But France weirdly (the only country in the world) ban people from practicing religion (you can’t wear hijab in schools, driving people to attend private religious schools with students from one background) and force you to undress in beaches and public pools. This is ridiculous. And needlessly increases tensions.
True
this comment is a proof of the statement "societies like france that have collonial past were and will remain rascist"
Most of these people are 3rd or 4th generation french citizens.
Their parents and grandparents fought for France in the war and literally rebuilt it after it.
And they also came from the former French colonies.
Rioting is a French national sport so these eruptions are no surprise.
Sounds like modern day colonialism....
You didnt get the full story about Nahel. Car with Polish registration tables and didnt stop on multiple police barricades and almost ran over civilians on multiple occasions.
Police officer should have never been arrested.
That's beside the point. The video is not really about the incident but about the riots and the social context in which they take place.
The video is a complete lie 🤣
@@adrien5834it’s very important, the video makes it sound like the kid is an innocent angel
@@anntakamaki1960He could be the devil himself, if it wasn’t him, some other kid was going to get shot and we would be at the same situation again. Nothing on the background has changed.
This is the exact problem in the US. Tictoc videos show 1% of the situation and that goes viral. The truth is MOST AMERICAN POLICE OFFICERS are awesome individuals who would give their lives for the idiots who are depicting them as evil racists. Wake up you idiots. YOU WILL REGRET YOUR FOOLISHNESS!!!!!
Europe is finally having to deal with the same issues we in the US have been dealing with for a long with with criminals/gangs (but has been escalated over the last decade with blm encouraging riots/looting/etc)
@Bendwow
we already have those problems but countries like Sweden keep it a secret, already in the 90s we had places we try stay away from because was criminal people having control of those places, but to rest of world we portray us as some kind of Utopia but it getting harder to keep a secret as it indeed escalates
It's not about "how France relates to newcomers", but "how newcomers relate to France".
One big mistake is present in this video. The "banlieues" were not designed for workers from the colonies but for the emerging middle class. My grand mother lived in one of those for well over 40 years.
But then the government decided to push for single home family residence in the 70s, which attracted those middle class people and left only poorer people. From then on it spiraled out of control until only the poorest remained. And then new economic migrants found that only there could they find housing.
EDIT :
Here is a documentary on those banlieues for those who speak French : czcams.com/video/zR_jxCANYac/video.html
I live in France but I never knew that, it’s pretty interesting
Regarding the push for single-family housing, that trend is being reversed slowly right?
Though single-story buildings for families remain very prevalent to this day
It seems the push for single family housing units always produces some kind of unaffordability crisis in housing markets. Here in the US, such a zoning policy has caused problems as well. It's most notable in California. I do wonder what caused what in this case, though. Were conflicting values intrinsic to the migrant community at fault or is poverty at fault for a lack of integration?
I see both points still a 3 way war concerning Civilization issues that being France 🇫🇷 shows the whole world the sickness in society...
“Death is the solution to all problems. No man - no problem”. Joseph Stalin
@@lemomar we got that taught in geography class :)
You failed to mention at the beginning of the video that the suspect almost killed a few people driving at high speeds through resdential areas and was shot on the second time he was pulled over.
Precisely Matt
not surprisingly his mother didn't teach him any good.
And he didn't even have a driver's licence
@@hlonydlamini4496 And how in the world was he driving a Polish plated vehicle, I'm sure he had all the papers insurance/reg etc for it?
kid was an asshole but everyone loses their minds because of perceived racism...
“This is not a normal world, it’s France.” Most true words I’ve ever heard
yep... im french and i can absolutely confirm that france is not a normal place...
So why people are seeking shelter in France rather than staying in their good countries 😂
This was not normal for France just 50 years ago.
Theres a certain epidemy going on involving a type of person who behaves like a criminal and acts like he or she never did anything wrong. Unfortunatly this is being heavily abused by people who know that they can avoid justice just because of the labels they carry, because in the grand scheme it would make the host country look bad.
Whats even worse is i cant say it with more direct words because it would attach negative labels to me.
But im sick of living in denial when for the past 2 decades ive strongly felt the consequences of this epidemic.
Same thing in the United State, if your a thug, criminal, gangbanger , drug dealer, and you end up getting kill by police because of your criminal active , your made into a martyr, and then a Saint, and then celebrated. it's more about the money - I always said I wonder if george floyds family would want him back alive or the 20 something million they got for for wrongful death lawsuit that the city minneapolis payed out? My dad use to say if want know the truth follow the money.
What if France disallows unskilled workers from having more than 1 or 2 children, and gets rid of speculation & house building regulations & excessive private ownership of land then things will get better.
White People are so arrogant.
As a Nigerian, one thing just puzzles me. Why doesn't France take a heavy-handed approach to dealing with these people? They have no issue using their military to "safe-guard" their former colonial territories in the Sahel. So why not apply that same heavy-handed approach and remove the criminals in their country?
@@MisterX-ij7dw Wow, that is really sad. So France just created a mess that they were too dumb to see happening and now they can't fix it? Really sad.
The French are weak.
Because that would to electoral losses, and renew of riots, so the state will not shot its electors.
Typically the army is not used as an additional police force. Just doesn't look right in democracies.
@@madma11 Well the U.S, Mexico and and Britain have used militaries in the past to quell riots.
Would’ve saved a lot of riots in France.
This is why I want my country, the Czech Republic, to oppose the new migration pact like Hungary and Poland.
Eventually the EU are gonna destroy all Eu countries and wipe out their cultures .
It is neccessary. I live in Vienna and some districts are already completly lost. Vienna district 10 for example. Go there and you will see
@@Markus-xm4zv you guys shouldn't distribute them across Europe, kick them out instead.
Demand a referendum about it but fast. The EU is pushing the mandatory quota again.
Keep them OUT...!!!!!
It just goes to show that multiculturalism does not work. Us Native Americans have this saying, "You lie with dogs, you get flees." And here in the states we tell people that if they don't like the way things are done here in the United States then we will help you pack.
France can't integrate these people. They are from a totally different background. Religion, their level of compassion, level of cooperating, etc are different, and at different levels. You can put Koreans, or Japanese, or Chinese in France in their own sector of the country and you wouldn't have these problems. It is not the fault of the French government.
It is not a failing system, these people are failing to become French.
They're not 'failing' to become French. They have no desire, and have never had the desire to become French (or Westernised).
no the failing system is that there's still people of the system, maintaining a system that keeps the floodgates open towards Europe.
immigration without integration is simply invasion
@@MarekzAnglii Then stay in your country then. I am not saying change your culture, but if you at least do not make an effort to fit into the norms of your host country, leave and go to your original county. Immigrants are the intruders here one thing we must not forget.
@@MarekzAngliiThen...don't go lol. Mi casa tu casa, but respect the rules of the host.
@@MarekzAnglii This, I believe is true.
It is not my country‘s responsibility to take care of another countries citizenship. It’s a privilege to gain citizenship to another country not a right.
Aren't most of those people born in France?
@clarry1324what's funny about being Arab ?
Most of those people are fleeing regions that were destroyed by the military and economic actions of the french government, aiding them would be the least they should do
I should not have to pay for the sins of colonialism. A child should not have to pay for the sins of their father. I think most are children of immigrants that came to France. They all come from a different cultural background with different values the children actively choose not to participate in French society and be law abiding. Again it’s not my responsibility conform to foreign culture. They should participate and conform to French culture.
@@leoskiii5860 the mention of them refusing to be law abiding citizens is simply a racist talking point. The insurgence of crime within their communities has nothing to do with their cultural and ethnic background and everything to do with the refusal of french society to allow them integration. Their schools are underfunded, they are more likely to be rejected when trying to rent a home or when taking a lone to buy one and they are also likely to be rejected from job applications.
Also, no you might not be directly responsible from the crimes of colonization and military action perpetrated by your government. However, you are a direct beneficiary of them so if you actually oppose such things then it would be a in your best interest to actually try and help these communities instead of simply expecting them to act as if they were not being actively disadvantaged by society as a whole.
It is not a failure of the French to accommodate foreign culture, it is the failure of foreigners to accommodate French culture. It is not the responsibility of the French to integrate them, it is their responsibility to integrate. If they do not want to, they shouldn't expect to be treated as equals. Égalité works both ways. Second, this and pretty much every other police shooting has a single common denominator: Running/resisting. It is not the police who need reform, it is the public. They can't get it through their heads that if they run, and the police have to chase them, they're going to get hurt. The cops aren't just going to let them go. That would be anarchy. When they get caught, they need to give up. The rest of us have had enough of this. People are tired of having their tax money spent trying to get foreign cultures to behave. Enforcing the law is not repression.
Twisting the facts to make this savage look like some innocent child.
There's no excuse for this chaos, violence and destuction of public goods. I'm ashamed of what happened in France. I'm ashamed of the fact that the people were defenseless against this mindless mob. And I lose hope in the future of the entire Europe when I see how they wipe their feet on our culture, our order, our rules.
vive la revolucion
Well well well... 😂 The rooster has come to lay it's eggs..
@@clem2874 ...in your mouth.
@@clem2874
You mean "The demented retards are smashing up the country that took them in".
Weren't there problems earlier with a law that didn't allow citizens to record the police while they abused demonstrators - French demonstrators.
Hi everyone,
It has come to my attention that the footage I included of the fire at the Alcazar library is fake (and actually is of a Manilla library).
There was actually a fire at the library and it was broken into, but the footage I included is misleading.
Apologies for the mistake.
Hugo
Source: www.boomlive.in/fact-check/viral-video-marseille-alcazar-library-france-fire-philippines-manila-video-social-media-22455
You might want to pin your above comment.
@@entreprenerd1963 Better if he pinned the other comment where he expanded on topics. Honestly who cares if that was the actual fire. The fire did happen regardless and that is conveyed.
Yes. I noted that. You need to edit and replace. Also - police ARE, not IS.
Your entire video is full lies, fake news and right wing propaganda debunked a million times.
I visited France in 1989, when the USS Theodore Roosevelt undertook the ship's first Med cruise. At the time, some things I experienced opened my eyes quite a bit...like the Arab quarter in Marseilles (or was that Toulon? I haven't been paying enough attention to France since then, which was a mistake. I really enjoyed learning how to pronounce my family name correctly (I have French ancestry), but didn't appreciate the two different thieves who tried to rob me, especially the one that followed me toward where the ship's boats landed. Some French sailors, celebrating one of their number's finishing his navy enlistment rescued me, probably saved my life. I drank with them until it was time to get back to the ship.
Seeing this stuff makes me sad. It's clear the French people have made some terrible mistakes along the way. I hope it doesn't tear the country apart.
But the only problem with your story us that crime has declined since 1989. That's the case in most western countries, the streets are far safer now than 30 years ago.
it's very simple, muslim ideologies are the opposite of France. The French are pioneers of science and human rights, land of great philosophers and artists.
@@XxMusclecarsxXonly for the French people of course, they wouldn't dare to help their colonies or pay back Haiti for revolting for their own freedom from slavery
@@XxMusclecarsxX What about Vietnam?
@@BlunderCitycrime has declined 😂😂😂
Sure.
It's like this in a lot of European countries, not just France. Our politicians have experimented with multiculturalism/diversity for about 60 years and now we see the consequences. Crime, economic inequality, segregation, cultural differences and riots is a result of this.
"this is not the normal world. this is france" something that memers and documentary channels can now agree upon
Fr*nch
The animation at the start of the video is highly problematic. The car was not stopped by the police officers, Nael was chased by the police, almost killing two people and only stopped because the road was blocked by other cars due to a red light stop. As soon as the cars moved, Nael accelerated the car and pushed the officer aside, which was leaning on the A-pillar.
This can be seen at the end of this video: czcams.com/video/0iKi0InP6Os/video.htmlsi=_NpQQVov50e4umdS&t=217
In your video you make it appear that Nael was shot in a random police control, which is not true. Everywhere in the world police officers take their guns after a chase, not only in Paris.
Interesting link
@@slc.images Interesting indeed. With all the proof clearly visible.
Sorry but the ONLY justification for use of deadly force by police is in defense of self or others. That is the law in the US and European countries.
Thank you. It was very odd how the "car attempted to drive away". Cars don't drive themselves. I didnt know the story but that sentence points out that there's probably a lot more to the story than most people want to consider. The media chooses problematic stories like this bc it's sooo stupid easy to make us fight amongst ourselves.
I think you linked the wrong video, or are you just trolling o.0
I keep reading France does not do what needs to be done to integrate the youth from the suburbs but I struggle to see how neighbouring do anything more for minorities or against territorial inequalities. Especially when it comes to education, a topic I know a bit about (I was a teacher in France and now work in research and higher education in Germany), I am starting to get a bit angry when my country gets the blame, when the French teachers are recruited in national standardized examinations and then allocated nationally (while the Germans can choose an area within their land and will never have to move for the distance of Lille to a suburb Marseille for the sake of equality), when specific education zones have been created to increase pay, allocate more means, reduce the number of students per class in the said zones, when until recently (this is sadly changing) free and public education was seen as the quality one, and up to some noticeable exceptions private schools were less reputed, when end of cycle exams are national and anonymous to avoid geographical discriminations (like an Abi from Berlin not being as good as one from Bayern), when University is literally free for low and even middle income families (not even "almost free" like a few hundreads euro per semester, truly free), when especially related to the cost of living, the grant system for students is one of the most generous in Europe, and not a single cent has to be paid back by the end of your studies, when entry to most university tracks is still not selective etc. My point being not that my country already does everrything it should, but that the bias in the way its actions are reported are bordering disinformation and slander.
Simple techniques to avoid getting shot by police:
1) Don't be a criminal thug
2) Don't drive recklessly, OR without a license
3) Don't try to run over the police while there is a gun pointed at you
4) Know when you are caught, and COMPLY
And I'm sorry this mother lost her son. But he was NOT a 'good boy'. Maybe if the people who 'well liked' him had been harder on his dumb ass to stop doing dumb shit he might still be alive today.
I would love to see a video on how immigrants from different parts of the world integrated in Western European societies. Immigrants from Eastern Europe and Asia seem to integrate faster and better than others (with exceptions of course). Maybe willingness to integrate and culture itself really has something to do with it, even though media tries to throw the guilt on the Police, state, society, colonialism and everything else.
It's supremacy thinking.
@@jameswang362Its realistic thinking.
Chinese people in Paris protested for feeling not protected by the police against thiefs
and also read Liu Shaoyao police killing by police and the aftermath.
An immigrant is always an immigrant if you are not wealthy, in that case you become an "expatriate" ;)
Wouldn't look too good for middle eastern and east african migrants.
Integration is a myth and a disgusting word. The word expatriate was invented to spare white immigrants the inconvenience of dealing with terms like " Integration". Come to Switzerland and you will conclude that most white immigrants are not integrated and have no respect for local values and culture. In fact, a huge number of those white immigrants see swiss culture as inferior to theirs and as " a primitive culture of farmers". This is debatable of course like anything else.
As an immigrant who live in the US, I'm very grateful to be here and will never do anything to jeopardize this country. We have to protect it.
Right? Like, it’s so easy to just… not lead police in high speed chases and break the law repeatedly
Completely different societies
❤
I wish that the french police had as much respect for laws as you do.
The problem is, most first genearation immigrant are like you, those rioter are French and most of them are going through an identity crisis, they don't feel French, they are pushed away by a noisy minority of racist people, they harbour resentment for the country and its colonial past and are treated as French in their country of origin... It's a complicated issue, to fix it both party will have to compromise and I think it might be too late already.
France should go all the way to protect it's catholique roots.
Next time your car gets stolen, call a 3D video producer to make a video about it instead of calling police.
Your wrong, the 17 year old is a known offener with 15 Police records in France. There was a chase before the fatal shooting without driver licence. In France, you have to be 18 years old. During this chase he almost hit several passers-by. Therefore, the Police didn't want to let the offender get away a second time, that's my interpretation.
The revolt has broken out in France, because the mother of the murdered 17 years old on Twitter has called out the revolt! After two days the revolt spread to Belgium & Switzerland in Lausanne.
The current incidents from Eritrea-Festival in Gießen-Germany are a first taste of what awaits us If we continue Like the last years. It took thousand policemen to bring it under control.😢
Two days ago the Hungarian Police arrested 22 non EU migrant at the Border & seized 28 rifle's + ammo. They wanted to storm the EU external border. In Europe all normal Media are silent.
Tey killed an 80 year old priest in the church in France & set the church afterwards in fire. You can see in a video how they stop a truck because a white man is driving it, they pull him out and beat him up extremely brutally. It almost looks like they kill him but there is no further information about the truck driver. 😔🥺
There are masses of videos of the incidents, after 5 days of revolt over 4000 Cars we're set on fire.
You can see the many videos at the YT channel Deutschland Kurier, the first video ist one week old.
Facts.
Stay strong, Eurobro
Proof: Trust me bro.
Yup. He was a criminal
@@manazon6945 Keep telling yourself that buddy.
The truth is, he was Algerian, he was a Muslim, and he was a child.
Your police instead of shooting the tires, shot a kid just because he was a minority from a specific religion and place.
That's all we see and that's all we know about the Racist and Islamophobic France.
Nahel had his whole life ahead of him, police shot him just because he was Algerian Muslim kid.
France wants to be like Child shooting Israel.
Europe is like a person clinging on to a phone which becomes more and more unusable by the day. Only when it gets to critical conditions does it seem anything will happen. Seems pretty close though. Or someone on the titanic when its half sunk in water. Maybe half the people will die before its over.
The main problem is that the parents of the 3rd generation immigrants have absolutely no desire to discipline their childeren, they are actively refusing to adjust to the lifestyle and culture of not only the French people. But the European people in general. This has been going on since the 70's. Therefor creating a loop of unborn generations of immigrants who will eventually act the same way their parents did. I know 2nd generation immigrants in Belgium who do not speak a single word Dutch or French.
Fist off all extremely unlikely that you know 2nd gen immigrants that don’t speak a word of one of the official languages of Belgium, unless they 1. Are dead and mute 2. live completely secluded, don’t attend school and don’t watch TV, and if that is the case then obviously they are an extreme outlier, but guess it helps with the narrative you are trying to push. As for 3rd gen immigrant parents having “absolutely no desire to discipline their children” unless youve lived with many families or there’s been an in-depth study that has concluded that claim, I don’t see how you can honestly make such a statement with any level of accuracy, the fact that you would make such a claim is very telling.
Clearly your whole comment is hyperbole and unsubstantiated statements dressed as “facts” to push your clearly anti-immigration/Muslim narrative. At least be straight up and honest, having a position of “it’s my country/culture and I don’t want them here” is much more respectable than trying to coat it in fake, so easy to see through anecdotes.
Some even stated that there is no need to integrate because the European are dwindling in numbers.
But no matter how one sees it, the fault lies with the typical post-war boomer libtard mentality.
France basically bullied the annexed Algeria for circa 150 years.... Even with brutal oppression in the 60's while the Beatles were touring...
Sure. That's bad, right.
But who the hell in their right mind thought it was a good idea to suddenly allow such huge numbers of the people you oppressed to simply go to France as if that would give NO problems whatsoever???? That's ridiculous.
And what's going to solve this problem???? More immigration??? They haven't even integrated the previous "batches" let alone allow even more people who literally aren't exactly keen on the West and its values.
That's just asking for trouble.
The people of France are the victim of their own idiot government.
Wow you can talk😂
proponents of "multiculturalism" have lied to these people, pretending that they could live successful lives in Europe while fully holding on to their own culture, and that any resulting drawbacks would be due to "racism".
Europe is done for letting those 🧔🏿♂️ people in your country is a huge mistake
This has gone on for too long in the United States as well everyone knows. I am so sad to hear its also happening in France.
USA has been going through so many immigrants for 200 years+
It’s not the immigrants that are the problem but the security at the southern border
imagine a world without cellphones , we wouldnt even know about this
The cause of this problem is straightforward. They allowed people to emigrate to their country not because they wanted to be French, but to supply the owners of the production with cheap labor. They never intended to become French, will not ever become French and its likely forbidden by their culture to become French. The solution is straightforward, but likely the will to implement it is lacking. This problem extends to many countries that are allowing massive migration due to globalism and not because they want to be citizens of their host countries. Many first world countries will descend from safety and security to third world nightmares.
They arent here to supply Europe with cheap labour. Most of them dont even have jobs and are just sucking money from our system instead. Thank God Denmark handled this situation pretty well.
Agreed. Corporations and Industry pushed their agenda on getting cheap wage workers thru flooding the Supply side of millions of low-middle wage immigrants into France to keep Demand low snd therefore lower wages. It benefits corporation’s financially and wrecks Frances culture from within.
The immigrants get exploited by the big corporations, and the citizens of France get the consequences of big business greed. Only the Corporations come out unscathed for the Win. Its mostly a Lose-Lose-Win situation overall.
While language, religions, jobs, training, social integration programs, colonialism, racism, name descrimination, etc ALL play a part to varying degrees, the politics, elites greed, power, selection of high-risk immigrants (incongruent with Frances beliefs, core values, ethics, etc), that dont assimilate for multiple reasons, leading to this being a losing cause for everyone in the bottom %90% of wealth in France.
If China and India started an immigration program of millions of people, there would be similiar ideological, race, language, problems and corporate greed would be overcome loyalty to the nation to get cheap labour etc.
@michaelredman5750
The cause of the problem is call karma
You call your country first world country but the fact is you guys are thieves and rape's make colonial in Africa, Asia,south America for century, what goes around comes around
Mass deportations. If you are muslim, you must go.
I'm Canadian and I've visited France more than a few times. More than once I've been assaulted and harassed by African immigrants on the street trying to take my money from me. I'm a 6ft man, I couldn't imagine what I would have done if I was a smaller woman, those guys are fucking strong. Unregulated mass-immigration means you get desperate people who don't care about the culture they've willfully opted into joining, they only care about their next meal. It's not bigoted to want people to respect the culture and the language that was in place before they got there. If I moved to Germany, or Vietnam or Mexico, you bet your ass I'm learning the language and the culture and not pushing my own BS onto locals. I'm certainly not expecting to carve out my own piece of another country and make it little Canada, like people seem to feel it's appropriate to do in my country and other western countries. It's such an offensive idea. In Canada, our culture of kindness and friendliness is practically gone. I live on a street where most people are East Indian or Asian. I used to walk down the street and smile at everyone and say hi, now I don't. Why? Because I've learned it's now rude to smile at East Indian women. Part of THEIR culture. So now I don't smile at people anymore. I don't greet people anymore. I don't even acknowledge these people, because they don't acknowledge me. When I do, I get blank stares and awkward looks. It makes me sad that I don't even feel like I live in a community, I feel like I'm simply tolerated in a neighbourhood that doesn't want me there.
French is being slowly phased away in Canada as more people arrive here who do not care about Canada's bilingualism. They don't care what Canada stands for, and some of them have the audacity to move here, transform entire city districts into the country they MOVED AWAY FROM, and still call white Canadians who've been here longer than them, "Colonizers". (SURREY AND BRAMPTON)
Don't let France become Canada. I support immigration, but regulated immigration. Protect your culture. The countries these people come from would NOT tolerate any other cultures, white or otherwise, to set up shop in their neighbourhoods and replace their historical culture with a foreign one. It's rules for thee, not for me, and if you don't agree with it you're far right and a bigot.
I hate this world.
The 'inhabitants' will never assimilate because, just as in the UK, Germany, Italy, France, etc... they "don't want to." In most western countries - but in particular France - they've had 50+ years to get their act together, but they still haven't assimilated or wished to integrate and many, to date, don't even speak the native language. Also, the younger generations already born in their 'host' countries are worse and create even more problems than their parents or grandparents did before them.
The partial cause was/is arrogant governments always thinking "they know better" than the millions of ordinary people, who constantly warned them of future cultural clashes, if mass migration from diametrically opposed cultures continued. Especially a culture which has a different legal system (Sharia Law) incorporated within their already strict and rigid religion.
And now... here we all are!!!
Thing is, those who make said decisions have no skin in the game.
The fact that the uk can have a primeminster from an immigrant population and no one cared just shows the difference in the two countries immigrant populations. Blacks and arabs seem to have no political power other than propping up macron.
You're talking nonsense. I don't know a single second generation immigrant who doesn't speak French. Also, French is the language of the countries these immigrants come from so that makes no sense.
Also, the immigrants from the old Indochina (Vietnamese, Cambodian and Laosian) also don't culturally integrate yet they are the least criminal communities in France with rates of criminality that is way lower than the local population.
The real problem comes from the culture of the Neo-Marxist Left since the 1960s, it encourages ethnic groups (and women) to radicalise and to see themselves as oppressed of the big bad white coloniser (or Patriarchy). This current has evolved to be what we call "woke" today. This is a political movement that actively promotes the hatred of the West. This more than anything else is the justification for the violence and we are condemned to it for as long as the Left controls the institutions of civil society.
"the immigrants from the old Indochina (Vietnamese, Cambodian and Laosian) also don't culturally integrate"
lmao
they take French names, and are often catholics.
You"re saying nonsense @@BlunderCity
@@bunkerkorpf1440
Most 2nd generation immigrants from everywhere take French names and frankly, it's completly irrelevant. Religion is not a sign of integration, we are not a religious country.
I am originally from the UK and have been living in France for 15 years, I'm now 28 years old.
From my perspective it seems to be a problem of ethnic background and the fetishizing of being a gangster that are the root causes of the problem, these people have no interest in integrating into French society they would rather take advantage of the welfare benefits that this country generously provides and give nothing back in return.
These people grow up in an echo chamber reinforcing the idea that they are victims and that their violent actions are justified.
You don't hear about Vietnamese or Indian immigrants or other European immigrants causing these problems
it's in vast majority caused by the Algerian, Marocan and African immigrants.
If these people reject French society they should be deported back to their country of origin and maybe they can be happy there.
I'm not racist I work with people from Burkina Faso, the Ivory coast every day and they are some of the most polite hard working and friendly people I have ever met.
They call these neighboorhoods "open air prisons" except they can leave whenever they want and do whatever they want
the riots should be taken as a lesson that having millions of people come in over a small period of time who have completely different cultures is not a good idea
...and putting them all in the same place.
It would technically be possible if they spread them out far and wide so that they are an actuall minority which has to fit in. All those solutions this guy presented are useless because it's still a ghetto which supports salafism, crime and violence.
Correct!
well if France didn't ruin their ethnic homeland they wouldn't have had any reason to come to France in the first place like Algeria they committed genocide on Algerians because they wanted independnece and around 1.5 million Algerians died and it also doesn't help the fact that France has a history of screwing with Islam which isn't exactly a good thing and they also, for example, get half their light bulbs from niger I believe or idk it was a long time ago I read this but at the time 90% of the said country didn't have electricity and the fact that France secretly control the economy of most of their former colonies in sub-Saharan Africa and killed a few good African leaders which would've meant less immigration to France also doesn't help so u should know France itself is the root problem.
At least without integration programs. Some cultures tend to adapt better than others
@@jjeverson2269 people from cultures that adapt do not need integration programmes. A person that needs an integration program is a person that should never have been allowed to enter in the first place.
Thank you for this video. As an american who lives in France for some years now it is hard for me to understand the violence towards the french government / police. I feel as an immigrant to any country you must assimilate to the local culture and language and not expect it to change for you.
As a Frenchman who emigrated to the US, I share your opinion. Cultural assimilation is key, but this does not mean losing your original culture, in fact having two cultures makes your life experience richer.
@@MichaelGioanNOT if ur Running-Away, from ur original(Homophobic, Misogynistic, etc-etc)"culture" .
@@manueldumont3709 Every culture, even of there are aspects you don't like, has things of value that add richness to life. Don't throw out the baby with the bathwater.
@@jenniferpearce1052 I've heard, that there are(Self-loathing & SADistic)-WOMBan....Way-Out
@@jenniferpearce1052Go Live in(the recently muslim-Majority US city)-Hamtramck....u'll See, that they've Already begun, Persecuting the LGBTQ+ Community(who, aKIN to u, also Stood-Up, for Muslims) .
You forgot how the cop was almost dragged along and had to act fast before becoming a victim of this reckless driver who was on the run from police.
It's very complicated when it comes to migrants ... almost all countries with migrants are facing such issue. That's why countries are becoming more strict and protective nowadays
Not with all migrants tho, if you have the same race/religion/culture/languege you can blend in really well, anything else but that, well we all know the results...
This happens evrywhere btw, its normal for people to stick with whats familiar to them, but when theres no effort to assimilate with the local populus over time you risk ending up with rifts like these.
well how about you give migrants the chance to benefit from the society they now live in instead of just handing them the low wage slave work?
Why would they feel welcome in any country of the EU?`Especially the low working class families?
Education system for the most part garbage. It benefits only the ones that have a stable houshold and you can expect the kids to behave they way the school wants.
If they got problems there a higher educated famility has ressources and knowledge to combat these things.
If you are a migratn worker that doesnt know the langauge too well, has low education, low income and cannot steer through all the hurdles of their new location without help what do people expect.
You cannot just put all the people in ghettos and then hope they figure it out themselves. Are you out of your mind?
Indians and Chinese are rather well integrated and grateful, so not all migrants are hostile.
Countries have hosted migrants for decades, the UK, Germany and France have hosted Chinese, Indian, and south east asian migrants for decades and they've integrated phenomenally, the problem started with the arrival of migrants in 2015 who have a completely different culture and philosophy, hold their religion over the constitution of their host country and refuse to integrate.
Easy solution is to send them home
I think we need to stop making excuses for folk that refuse to assimilate. My mother moved to the uk when she was 18 from Malta. We all moved to Malta when I was 13 and I had to learn to assimilate. I then came back to the uk at 27 and worked my way to prosperity. Migration works amongst similar cultures, not hostile ones.
It’s not a refusal to assimilate. The country is and was already being prejudicial to them. How can there be 4th/5th generation of migrants and they haven’t assimilated? It’s not their fault, it’s because they’ve been segregated for all their lives. They were treated differently all their lives, there’s no surprise they’re also acting differently
I think it just takes time, my parents are russian from latvia and my dad surrounded himself with Irish friends and coworkers while my mum surrounded herself in Russian people like herself, it’s been 24 years since they’ve moved you can tell my dad has defo picked up some Irish things especially in language(fully fluent in English and has picked up a few things from the Irish accent*) while my mum hasn’t learned a lot of Irish culture things and the language, having a pretty good understanding of English but still the vowels are off and the, a and an are still a mystery to her. My dad assimilated but my mum refused to but after living in Ireland longer than her home country it’s definitely rubbed off her, when she speaks Russian she uses some English words(even tho she actively tries not to) she has an Irish boyfriend(yes I do have two Christmases) and when I was younger she used to cook Irish food like a full Irish breakfast or shepherds pie(technically people in the uk eat it too but shh). Personally I’m probably both russian and Irish: Irish around the lads, russian around family that type of thing
Was your mother Christian?
Assuming so, do you think that she would have left her religion if that was a requirement for 'assimilation' the country she went to?
Import the 3rd world, you become the 3rd world.
@E57det7I she has always remained Catholic but different Christian denominations can easily assimilate in other societies that were traditionally Christian. One of the big issues we have is unassimable religions like Islam.
“But this is not a normal world. It’s France”
Best quote I’ve ever heard😂
Are we forgetting the shooting officer was dragged a meter or so before he did? He almost got dragged along and possibly killed in the escape.
A few things you did not mention. The driver was known to the police as a criminal AND the expensive car had foreign plates. I don't know about you but if i was an officer and saw that kid without a driving license driving a such a car.. it would raise my eyebrows. Maybe that's why he was asked to step out of the car.. refusing the officers request/order would significantly escalate things.. ANYWHERE in the world. Everything else is just an opportunity for everyone to "never let a crisis go to waste".
None of that justifies the use of lethal force.
@@adrien5834almost murdering several citizens and then spreading off again when told to stop absolutely does.
@@jrcreator2257 Cool story. Source for this nonsense?
As someone who has been arrested before( For petty bullshit that didnt even warrant being arrested), I can attest to how refusing a cops orders will instantly escalate the situation. I say this as a White guy in his early 30s. Just for trying to reason with the cop while trying to hopefully not be arrested, I made the situation go from fairly calm to somewhat heated and was being told that if I dont start walking his way, I'm going to find out what being tazed is like.
Me and my friends all did what he said after that, but my friend got threatened with being tazed again for simply walking in front of the squad car while I was being cuffed. Things were fine so long as we just did as he said and didnt make him uneasy, which wasnt that hard. Sadly many young people love to refuse, run and fight cops after being told to just comply, thus they get shot or fucked up by the cops. Had me and my friend resisted and fought the cop over the situation, theres a chance we;d have been shot or beaten up. The difference is that many minorities choose the risky choice and refuse to follow any order given to them. Thus leading to police brutality or them being shot.
Also, be sure to include the fact that he led them on a chase earlier that same day where he was driving erratically and endangering innocent drivers lives.
The police officers did not lie about their claims, the officer who shot was on the hood of the car that was accelerating when he fired the shot, if that was legally self defense is not up to me.
It's the family's lawyers who leaked the (probably cut) video and claimed the police report was false.
There is another video from a vehicle forward where we can clearly see the position of the officer on the hood, making that little 3D reconstruction at the start misleading
Leaning on the hood for a better kill shot of a teenager you mean . Why lean on the Hood
If they can get the propaganda edit out to the public before the actual context is released most people will pick a side and refuse to change their views. You see it constantly in the states.
You have to take into account that they decided the narrative and direction before it even happened.
The officer shouldnt be on the hood of a car with a gun drawn.
I too would probably drive off if someone pulled a gun on me.
Force should be met with equal force. As Nahel had no gun drawn, the police officer had no right to draw his. He wouldn't have been in a position where he needed to "self defend" if he hadnt aggressively hopped on the hood of a car (a very dumb move for anyone in any situation) or drawn his gun.
You can't claim self defense in response to someone trying to flee from your attack stance.
They are just cheap labour so their life doesn't hold any value if one gone another will replace it.
Good content and presentation, liked and subbed, but...
check your audio levels for different clips, did you even watch it a final time (with someone not involved in production) before publication?
+ cam shakiness when filming you
We all know the real reason was someone got killed for jumping a red light, mounting the pavement almost killing a pedestrian and a cyclist in a car with no insurance and false number plates, so the teens decided to smash everything up and steal what they can. They don’t care about the kid, even his mother was dancing in the street. It’s always a certain type of people that cause this mayhem
Wasn't the guy that was shot driving recklessly almost crashing into two Police cars and almost hitting a pregnant woman? That is kind of an important part to leave out? A bit biased, no?
Yes, but outrage at police does well with the CZcams algorithm, & cops “shooting an innocent child who happened to be driving” is a great captivating intro which is bound to get people’s blood boiling
The guy making a video looks like a f jew
As far as I know there isn't much proof of that.
However in the end the simple main point is that the guy did stop. And a gun got pointed at him.
So do you have any proof of anything you just stated? Because as far as I'm aware non of that happened.
@@atomic4650 No, it will be release during the court case if the officer is charged.
just like with George, everyone is omitting the part that happened with Nael before the killing. What did they do?
He didn’t have a driver’s license. He was driving illegally He was confronted and told to exit the car. He didn’t comply.
Everything after that is interpretation.
No one ever shooted me at a police stop. Maybe because :
1 - I don't have a 15 cases of crime offense in my past.
2 - I don't drive a stolen car with plates changed endangering other people / cyclists and committing several violations.
3 - Nor did I do the same thing in the past (several times).
4 - I don't drive under drugs ( and I don't push them)
5 - Maybe most important: IF AN OFFICER COMMANDS YOU TO TURN OFF THE ENGINE AND KEEP HANDS IN SIGHT, I OBEY.
Clear enough ?
Europe should stop offering citizenship and offer only visa like UAE and Saudi Arabia. After retirement employees can go home but not able to own property.
Local citizens can own the properties and rent out to migrate workers so that they can fill safe.
...but they still can marrying locals women and ask them to embraced islam
As a French citizen I would say that the reason of all of that is because thé population of france refuses to work.
These police shootings would not have happened if we had actualy capable police officers that are not stupid.
the same goes for most other jobs for example if you go to a store to buy something the workers are usally very stupid, and end up charging you extra money for no reason and cant give you refunds.
this could be fixed if the government would do actions but like the usual the french government is extremely lazy and only really cares about staying in power and getting as much money as possible.
I am Belgian. A neighbor of France. Here we have the same problems with migrants from African and Arab countries. They really don't integrate. First they come here. They expect that we pay for ever to live free here. Rape our woman because for a Muslim a rape with a non Muslim is not a rape. Whenever you speak up against this you are labeled rasist. How come he was driving in a car this expensive and under age. And a person only starts filming something when there is something going on. But what happened before the filming. The only thing that the European union government dictators are doing is to get in millions of people who will never ever integrate..... And this will only lead to more of this and eventually civil war.
Your opinion on North Africans political sentiments, although good natured, is deeply uninformed and naive. They fundamentally hate France. Importing millions of Algerians, who still harbor animosity after the Algerian War for Independence, was an asinine French policy decision. I’m not against immigrants, but specifically importing immigrants from countries where antagonistic feelings towards French society are pervasive is just foolish.
It’d be like if Japan imported million of Chinese people who still have a memory of the Rape of Nanking after WWII. It shouldn’t take someone with a PHD in political science to determine that arrangement is going to lead to excessive levels of cross ethnic/cultural tensions.
The French people and Algerian French stock are victims of the French government with their multi kulti open border shenanigans.
Charles de Gaulle was right.
This is the best comment so far :0
He omits the ethnic factor. Its not even about history. Its racial.
Was the teenager heading towards crashing into a crowd? The police are 100% correct stopping this teenage criminal.
he was 17 so not allowed ta drive yet driving a yellow muscle car, he was speeding in a bus lane when the police noticed him, they signaled for him to stop and he ran so they gave chase. This lasted around 25 min during witch he almost ran over 3 people. He had to stop because there was a traffic jam he didn't do so voluntarily.
So yes I agree with you he had to be stopped no matter what. Also the cop claims he was aiming at the legs not torso and it's possible in the video you can see the barrel of the gun was aiming low, the cop was braced against the car and shot only when the teen tried to accelerate to run away and just as he fired the shot he was projected backwards by the car accelerating so ti's possible that the shot simply ran wild.
Some criminals are also playing golf in my cup tea.
Oh..maybe they are good criminals while others are branded criminals to make us hide..
Thank you for the information.
So from the start we are just assuming it wasnt in self defense
"When in Rome, do as the Romans" is relevant here. Immigrants wishing to live in a new country bear the first responsibility of trying to learn the language, history, and culture of the place they wish to move to. On the other side of the equation are the locals who should greet the newcomers with open minds and open hearts. Integration may seem simple in theory, but it is quite challenging in practice. It helps for the people groups to have as much in common as possible. This is one huge reason why immigrants from Muslim nations have had such difficulty assimilating.
To begin with, many of them do not want to merge and blend into the larger society. They actually want to CHANGE and transform their new home into a Muslim society! In fact, their religion COMMANDS them to proselytize and either convert or KILL infidels. And anyone who is not Muslim is an "infidel" according to the tenets of their religion. Compare and contrast this with immigrants from Asian nations (that are not Muslim) who have adapted far better over the years than immigrants from Muslim nations. This is not conjecture. This is a fact.
So what is the solution? Perhaps hard-core Muslims should not be allowed to immigrate to a predominantly Christian/Catholic nation if they refuse to embrace some level of flexibility and compromise. Like oil and water, any attempt at blending and permanent integration may ultimately be doomed. History bears witness to such failures.
Your arguments are not just and not correct about Muslims migrants ,you claim they want to push their religion on others by force ,in fact this is a Christian tradition who Christianised agrica and indians in America
Well, France brought them over, this issue of mass migration of Muslims into Europe is a huge problem, as their main aim is to have children with European women and have more kids with them , use them as breeding grounds. They also want sharia laws in France, they are obsessed with. The uk is facing the same problems
@@user-tt8yj7vm3m Pushing islam onto other people by force is in the teachings of islam as I understood and also read from my history books. If you read his comment at all you would understand that muslims don't want to assimilate into larger society and follow its norms and instead use force in countries with other religions and norms to push their religion onto others without respecting people of other religions nor the country's laws.
isn't it true for both Christian and muslims? the difference here is the "education". muslims are still heavily educated by Islamist doctrines, if they were to get education in a civic society and understand that by keeping others happy they can stay happy too.
@@user-tt8yj7vm3m Al.Quran(3:28), jihad and so on. In today's day ad age, christians don't do that anymore, and almost no one thinks that this was ok.
As an American this feels really familiar.
reminds you of BLM maybe ? yes I'm French and have been following that closely and it looks very very similar indeed.
Its not the same when it’s literally your fault. Your ancestor brought slaves against their will to the Americas, then you stole half of Mexico. You can’t cry about multiculturalism if you go and start forcing people into it to begin with. You made your bed ages ago.
Not similar at all..BLM are not immigrants.
@@JezaGaiaidentical, the thugs want want want more
The difference is the black people in your country arrived almost at the same time as the European descendent Americans, what they are trying to achieve there(not particularly fan of the liberal methods they are using) is common sense. What is happening in France and Italy is complete madness, illegal mass immigration, and failure to integrate.
It is about time for France to admit that they will never integrate those people and to ship them back.
Thank you. Thoughtful, and well presented. Earned a like, and a subscription.
Having two separate cultures trying to reside side-by-side in the same country has never once worked out in history. It has only ever ended in separation, or... worse.
Exactly
The real problem is how France is not trying to assimilate immigrants. They should be tougher around that.
Same problem with India beacuse of muzlims
Why they do in many other countries including USA, Russia? The problem is the government is a racist one openly. That makes it not workable.
I agree, let me precise :
Having separate cultures succeeded in the Roman Empire quite well - the Pax Romana was ensured by crucifying whole cities in case of rebellion.
This was very well done. I think the fact that the collection of racial and religious data for French citizens is forbidden should have been mentioned as well. The lack of census data means the French have no data to support the needed policies.
Right, and they don't collect that data because it's deemed "racist".
What do you mean by "race" and how should this help any policy? There is enough data that shows living conditions in the mentioned areas. Politicians need to address these issues instead of ignoring
This is extremely cringe. We do not need a data driven approach, common sense and wisdom are just fine.
@@EuroAfrican Such ignorance. Without information, you cannot determine the next best course of action. You'd be working in the dark.
If it is known what is and what is not a banlieue based on geography I would think the data you refer to is not important in this context
In America, shooting a suspect who is attempting to flee in a vehicle is absolutely justified. This is because a suspect fleeing in a vehicle constitutes a threat of death or great bodily harm to members of the public. Another commenter mentioned how the young man nearly killed a few pedestrians as he was fleeing, before he got shot, and that proves my point exactly.
Also, France expecting immigrants to adopt French culture and integrate into French society is also completely justified. If you like a country enough to live there long term, you shouldn't have a problem integrating yourself into their system.
And you said 23% of Muslims and 20% of those born to foreign parents as if that was a large amount, but it really isn't. That means a minority, LESS than 1/4, of these groups actually agrees that France and other colonial societies will remain racist.
Being a first generation immigrant, I don’t understand why you come to a country with no intention to integrate? My parents were immigrants from Eritrea, they stopped by turkey and Greece before settling in Norway because dictatorship. They learnt the language, the culture, interacted with locals, worked hard and now they work in the medical industry and just bought a house. As they say, when in Rome do as the romans. Is it truly that hard?
Moslems are wild
The stress put on religion is misleading. These problems are linked to a "thug culture" very close to that in the United States with the complete disrespect for private or public property, glorification of materialism, practice of extreme violence for petty reasons, lack of culture/education/pursuit of productive endeavors. The youngsters who are engaged in this criminal behaviors don't have more than a shallow religiosity and they completely disregard any moral teaching. It is the same thing as with the shallow Protestantism of African American in US gangs or the shallow Catholicism with latino gangs.
I believe you and that's what I think too after watching this.
Simlar thing with chinese and mongolians in korea or Vietnamese and koreans in japan. Despite having no relgious difference they failed to integrate them
America is an immigrant nation, its issues are more based on a culture that embraces inequality, violence and all but worships guns.
the problem is that the different religion creates a culture of separation that makes it more likely that young people don't integrate. the culture of violence is furthered by the ethnic differences and the other cultural issues. the stress on religion as a subpart of culture in general is therefore appropriate.
Religion may not play a major role in what someone does in his everyday life anymore, but is sure is crucial to someones morals, being related with the culture they come from and their way of life. Everywhere in Europe you can see that areas where muslims are a large minority there are many problems regarding integration . The fact is most of them dont want to integrate. Also just like the word integration states, the one who immigrates must adapt to the way of life of the country (For france that is laicite, irreligion in public, and respecting freedom of speech) not the other way around.
This is no different than what happened to Rome…
Decadence brining in foreign labor, divisions within the existing society, and ultimately a collapse.
The US isn’t that different from France.
Exactly, after Rome conquered Egypt as a breadbasket, there was even free bread for the foreign slaves and the growing underclass. The rich welfare state attracted more and more migrants from the Levant and North Africa, while the actual Romans had fewer and fewer children. Emperor Augustus even tried to encourage the patricians to procreate with a bachelor tax. None of it worked. History repeats itself because human nature remains the same and our collective memory only goes back three generations.
Oh fuck here we go again with the "omfg this is like Rome!!!!!!! Omfgggg" armchair """""historians""" bringing their very limited knowledge and anachronisms to any discussion they can get their greasy hands on
I wholeheartedly agree that the Cura Annonae (wheat for the male citizens, not slaves) caused the collapse of Rome because of"muh socialism" despite the fact it predates the fall of Rome by more than 400 years and funnily enough only ended around the time of the collapse of Rome.
Same bullshit with the Lex Papia Poppaea (bachelor's law) that van Rensburg called an attempt to boost Rome's demographics even though the law is mostly centered around social standings and marriage. Ironic enough the laws that predate that one concern wider citizenship for other "Italians" that aren't Romans.
Sorry for my aggravated writing style but I'm just so fucking tired of this garbage where somehow 1st century or 3rd Roman practices or laws caused the collapse of Rome hundreds of years into the future and it always ends with the "strong men create good times create weak men blablabla" untill we just go "migrants bad" when Rome's glory days were absolutely build on the free travel of goods and persons.
@@vanrensburgsgesicht4048 augustus died 400 years before rome's collapse (western rome to be specific), and there was no such thing as "actual romans", rome didn't see north africans any different than gauls or illyrians or greeks or italians, they were all romans.
THIS! ^^^
@@vanrensburgsgesicht4048 Huh? Rome had 1 million people at its peak, the "actual Romans" were having plenty of children. Additionally, at the time Roman wasn't just people who lived in the city of Rome, everyone within the empire was Roman.
10:16 this is false.
That library video is not from France. That is actually a postal building in Manila, the Philippines, and the footage is from one month ago.
If France had just taken in Latin American workers, they would have avoided this. Latin Americans assimilate and the shared Latin culture and languages (French, Spanish, Portuguese) would have made the Latin Americans becoming French in a generation a breeze.
Looking at the situation in France 🇫🇷, I believe that Spain 🇪🇸 has been able to better integrate the immigration that has been arriving in our country in the last thirty years. Although it is true that the situation is not perfect either (especially in Catalonia, where tensions are taking place), but having less volume of immigration than France, it is possible that they adapt better. In addition, many of the immigrants come from Hispanic America, with which we have common historical, cultural and linguistic roots.
You don't need immigrants in the first place. Demographic problems are solved by increasing birth rates, not by dying out and giving your land to foreigners.
So, basically compatible cultures. And that is the root cause of the problem. When the culture is similar enough, there are not that many issues expected.
You compare apples and oranges.
Secondly. Interviewed migrants DO NOT IDENTIFY AS A FRENCH.
You left out another common factor - religion!
@@SkyrimCZtutorialsno, the French are trying to assimilate them and erase their culture. The riots might not be justified but the attitude of the french government is the one to ultimately blame
Hi everyone,
I wanted to adress the feedback that I have been receiving and mention a point of difficulty I had with making this video.
In the introduction, I made the decision to describe the video of the incident, without going into the details of the chase that happened before it. I thought it would be enough to provide the context of the riots, but this was obviously a mistake on my part. This in no way justifies the shooting, but the description of the chase might have added nuance to the story which instead seems like a description of an 'execution'. This was not my intention and I will make sure that future videos have the appropriate amount of context when talking about incidents like this one.
This was quite challenging to produce a story for me since it is about people which have more nuance than volumes of natural gas, and the provenance of solar panels. It was quite difficult to give a place accurately to two notions, so I thought I would expand on them in this comment.
The first was the idea of race, for which I personally am stuck between two rival schools of thoughts that correspond roughly to the Anglo-American/French divide on the issue. I find that the Anglo-American perspective of racializing everything is problematic from both an ethical perspective and also a very simplistic. This way of looking at social problems, which also stems from the US’ own history of racial relations, that it then projects on other countries fails to acknowledge differences in culture, social conditioning and ultimately the role of individuals in shaping their own destinies. However, I also believe that the French perspective of refusing to see race, is somewhat in denial about the role that it plays in profiling and defining the people from the banlieue.
Instead, I tried to find a compromise which I think is a better reflection of the complexity of this story and issue, where race is but one of the items (and markers of identity) that leads to but also makes visible the rift that I talk about in the video.
The second issue that I found hard to capture is the anger of the people in the banlieue, and while I talked to people coming from there in making this video to try and capture the difficulty of living and coming from there, it is something I believe could have been done better justice in the video.
I look forward to reading your comments and criticisms on this approach and am curious for any feedback you may have.
Since I recorded this video, this great column came out on opportunities for foreign born people in France, and I think that fits in nicely with the conclusions of the video on opportunity (although it should be considered alongside the high unemployment numbers France has had over the past 40 years): www.ft.com/content/25eda9f0-8bd3-41e1-948c-89cc7c0ec66e
On another note, I had two technical difficulties with my camera which resulted in a bit jittery footage, and had to rerecord my conclusion, which I will look to address in the next videos!
All the best,
Hugo
you are peddling the narrative that because of racism it's ok for people rob, loot, and burn. Criminal elements run with that narrative and it encourages them. The remedy for criminality is the law, and quite frankly people in the banleiu are not are not an oppressed minority. Uiygars and Tibetans in China are an oppressed minority. People like you need to rethink other the FN will get elected, and then we have gone from the frying pan and into the fire.
They wanted that kid for a long time, this wasnt just a incident on his own.
Keep reinforcing this idea it's "systemic racism", which is just a far left talking point not even shared with 20% of the population. These people seperate themselves than whine about the conseqeunces of that seperation. At this rate any form of tolerance for ANY type of migrant / assylum seeker will dissappear in Europe, we can see the rise of the reactionary right. Because idiots like you keep making excuses for their own behavoir.
Obvious things left out of this video like Leftists always do : The Crime rates, The self reported rates of national law above religious law etc etc.
If you people want us to be racist that badly, just say so, because if you know European history, you know damn well that if we want to be racist, we'll genocide entire nations.
Here in the Republic most of the police are unarmed the armed ones have an escalation policy of not needing to use force, then if needed pepper spray then if needed taser then if needed gun small extendable baton is somewhere before that point
Your above comment is also a good candidate for pinning!
I actually didn’t realize that protesting was a big thing in France.
The problem is some cultures cannot be integrated into western civilisation: and we keep importing more and more of them.
Its odd how immigrants to France and most other European nations. have this expectation of " Opportunity" and when this opportunity doesn't appear they then feel the need to express their anger through violence, rioting etc. Odd though, in the lands of their birth/ancestry the same opportunities were unavailable to them yet they never felt the need to cause excessive violence/ rioting to bring about change. They just chose to bugger off. I wonder why?
they feel that they are entitled to those opportunities because of their struggles. I believe there is a sunk cost fallacy here at play.
Opportunity always open if you want persue it. Look india, and east asia migrant, they can stand in top. Where the other just want use wellfare for their. And think nothing to get more civilize and they want other people submit to their culture
Actually the middle east has been filled with riots and unrest, have you heard of Arab spring or the civil wars in Africa and Middle East (syria, iraq, lebanon)?
@@aoeu256 Quite true. However when they realise it's futile, they head for Europe where they expect their hosts to bend and flex to suit their every whim.
Odd how it is just some migrants, belonging to one specific religion, who feel this way.
The police didn't lie the video wasn't leaked but rather just released.
So here is some of the info we already know and has been released.
- 5 minute video of the dash cam has been released of a wild chase where Nahel almost kills a pedestrian and a guy on a bicycle before coming to a stop in traffic.
- Sound experts have isolated and shown that the officer did not shout "im gonna put a bullet in your head" but he did says "cut engine cut cut"
- He wasn't shot in the head but chest
- Video footage that hasn't been released: various security cameras of the chase. no body cams where present as it hasn't been signed into the law yet.
- The cop who shot Nahel was decorated twice for his bravery during the Bataclan terrorist attacks and another attack.
- The cop was also in a special forced unit before for counter terrorist, in his defense he could have simply taken a more aggressive stance as he did fend off a terrorist attack before.
- Nahel driving away before the shot was fired (very important!)
- Nahel was no saint as he was known by the police from previous encounters
- Nahel had 15 criminal convictions on his juvenile record.
- Nahel had another pending conviction in September to appear in court but failed justice system in France set him free each time.
- He was driving a stolen Polish rental car.
- He was driving without license or insurrance.
Now a lot of people try to victimize this criminal, and demonizing the police officer.
Wake up people, the mother of Nahel on public TV had requested for a witch hunt for the cop and his family, yet why isn't she in jail ?
Also the mayor got attacked in his house and his wife was hospitalized, yet i hear nobody about these things...
The family of the cop had to go in hiding, their house have been burned down etc...
Yeah let the media and people victimize the criminals and blame the cop, sure and let me know how that will work out when your kids are getting run over by these criminals.
Let the criminals and their families start a riot to burn your schools, shopping malls, libraries, public transport, cars, houses, businesses down...
I left Belgium 15 years ago because back then in my city migrants where already creating trouble and the justice system did nothing.
Yes. Indeed.
It's going to get worse in Europe except in Hungary and Russia and possibly Poland and Italy. You might want to start learning another language.
Garbage . Pepper spray or Taser .
I hadn't heard this yet. Thanks for providing context. These issues are very complex and sad. I hope there is a way to resolve these social problems.
I reckon part of the problem is we in Europe (and in the UK on the other side of the channel) import a lot of stupid ideas from across the ponds
Race relationship is one of them when we in Europe have a very different historical context than America on those issues
Thanks for the video 🫶🏻
If you go somewhere, you follow that place's rules and culture, not the other way around.
As Milton Friedman suggested, you can have either mass immigration or a social welfare, but not both.
Diversity is good, diversity is a strength, diversity is what makes the Middle East so peaceful: czcams.com/video/j140pNFThoc/video.html
I would not call the middle east "peaceful"...
@@theemperor-wh40k18 i would not call the middle east "divers" eighter.
@@weedling3552 It is diverse enough to be in never ending ethnic conflicts.
I'll take the social welfare state on behalf of the citizens for that state.
Similar situation in Hungary with gypsies.
They live in poverty, mostly in eastern subursbs, they have lost their jobs with deindustrialisation, and now live in absolutely bafflinf conditions.
Would love a video about them
No is because they are gypsies
Whole Eastern Europe has unsolvable gipsy problem with symptoms you described.
Look up how most gypsies lives when they go back to romania, i've never seen such big houses and so many xpensive cars before...
@@RogueSecret just want to remind people that Romanians are not Gypsis :)
@@maksimmatkun9227 The issue is not unsolvable, the issue is that gypsy communitites that are bad, even by gypsy community standards are excluded due to their actions, Eastern Europe as a whole has a history with gypsies and unironically those who live in ghettos are shunned by other gypsies as criminal/unfavourable, also there is a social dynamic with Sinti language and local vs non-local/nomadic gypsies that is usually not discussed when westerners speak about this. Same with Poland and muslims
There are several things I never got about France while living there. Small cities. Lyon has as many inhabitants as Hannover and Hannover is for me as Berliner quite the provincial city. Only one main train station that closes at midnight. Laughable compared to Berlin with trains coming and going all night long at three train stations. But during the day - military guys with long rifles at the train station. While in Germany the military is prohibited by interfering within the state (only exception : natural catastrophes) in France this was usual.
It felt completely strange. I have lived in Berlin my whole life. I have been at places in this city, alone as a young woman - nothing ever happened. In Lyon I could barely walk the street at 10pm without being followed by creepy guys, asked whether I am a prostitute or whether I want to buy drugs. And this was one of the best universities in the country. Feels like going to Havard but the second you step out from the campus people try to molest you. And that in such a provincial city!
Later the "terrorist attacks" came. I brought a SIM card in France and had to show my ID. Later they introduced that crap in Germany as well. I was like "WTF?" and the guy at the shop apologized like "It's the law, terrorism etc". Steel spiked fences at kindergardens. Video surveillance everywhere. Apparently the insurance for the student dorm included a terrorist attack insurance. What is wrong with that country? I expect gang violence and shootings in some big cities in the US which is known for being a third world country when it comes to societal cohesion but France?
And why do these terrorists always choose some tiny villages for their attacks? I don't know whether I should cry or laugh when I read about some "terrorist attack" in some village no one can locate on the map.
In the past these people were called lunatics or mentally ill. Like very ill. Nowadays the leaders cry terrorism at every occasion and expand state security. And handle it as inefficient as it gets. A colonial power which manages its colonies like crap and only as wastedump for uranium. A state managed economy run partly by idiots. Sometimes I wonder how Europe can still compete in the world. Tons of potential wasted. But also amazing science and amazing people from all over the world. If the French could overcome their racism and classism and just join hands with the people from former colonies they could perform economic miracles.
Concerning the terrorists - intelligent terrorists buy their SIM cards in Africa or the Middle East without showing their ID and use encrypted communication. And secure end devices.
TBH. We've had the same issues here in the UK, especially in London. The last riot was in 2011.
London is now leading the world in the number of stabbings.
I firmly believe that France needs to confront its contradictory stance towards immigration and cultural and religious diversity. It's crucial that the French authorities acknowledge the presence of these societal issues rather than maintain the illusion that France is an untouched paradise where such problems do not exist. Sweeping these problems under the rug or being in denial about their existence is only a temporary solution; inevitably, these unaddressed issues return with greater force.
French society must be willing to engage in open, public dialogue about these complex challenges. Instead of maintaining an elevated or detached perspective, it's essential to ground the discussion in reality, recognizing the issues for what they truly are. It's only by confronting these realities that we can hope to devise comprehensive and effective solutions. Recognizing the problem is the first step towards resolving it, and in doing so, upholding the ideals of 'liberté, égalité, fraternité' on which France prides itself..
You can’t compromise with people who hate France, that hate French people, that hate French culture, and that don’t call themselves or see themselves as French and never will.
These people need to be deported immediately before France becomes a failed state.
It's the same here in the UK. The rapid demographic change destabalises the culture and when the imported folk are actively hostile to the native population then there is only one way this eventually turns out. But the powers that be seem to be actually orchestrating the destruction - it's not occurring by accident and they're making laws and policy to accelerate the migrant tide rather than moderate it to something survivable.
@@dallassukerkin6878 They will turn the UK and France into the very 3rd world lawless failed states that they ran away from.
It will sadly never happen, because both politicians and a good portion of the population prefers to ignore the problem, mostly due to social pressure
Regurgitating one cliché after another will not solve this problem in France. In my humble opinion, impressive word-salads hardly ever help, since the purpose of communicating word-salads is to make it look *as if* someone intelligent is attempting to offer a solution.
I believe the French have tried hard to integrate immigrants into French society and it has worked for the first generation. However, their children the second generation seem to look back to their country of origin and become far more religious than their intergrated parents were. Thats where the problem lies, in the younger 2nd generations failure to intergrate.
second and third yes, when asked they'll say they are Algerian not French or Moroccan or whatever the country of their grandparents and they'll also happily say they hate France.
So do most other Europeans though :b France is nice, the French are sometimes not. Meme done now
What are the boundaries of "integration"? I have just consulted my Oxford English dictionary and it is very vague (ie ending racial segregation). It is a word that is open therefore to the interpretation of individuals with a myriad of worldviews and expectations. Usually anything that is integrated becomes a part of the original ... but where does this leave "diversity" (our greatest strength)? How can people be both integrated and yet so diverse at the same time? As an indigenous Briton, I do not want anyone to be integrated or assimilated, as I like my people the way they are. The truth is, of course, that immigration is done for immediate economic reasons, and the managerial class has then had to come up with a noble-sounding mythos behind what they do for their own short-term gain. Before you know it the "newspeak" propaganda is being used by everyone, and most people aren't bright enough
or are simply too busy living their daily lives, to pick up on the double-think involved in these cobbled together narratives. Integration means the death of diversity.
@@JezaGaiaI'm British, but wherever I am in the world I'll always be British ... I just love my people and culture, and would never want to be anything else. I was born and live on the other side of the world, but I'm not Maori and never will be. Perhaps the Europen concept of multiculturalism is a flawed ideology. Nature dictates that we stick to our group to ensure our group's survival. Western Europeans have adopted a maladaptive ideology, which will ensure their destruction. As a set of peoples we are in the middle of our own mass extinction. What is happening in France is only the beginning of the end and there is only so much each of us will see in our respective lifetimes. The liberals have taken us normal people with them against our will.
@@matronofmercia5891 Stop being hysterical. These are problems, but every era has had problems. Europe overcame the bubonic plague, the crusades, two world wars. This is pretty minor shit compared to problems faced in the past. In fact, it's interesting how Europe is seen as peaceful part of the world at this point. That is a relatively recent development, Russian war in Ukraine non-withstanding. Europeans have been fighting each other almost constantly since the dawn of time up until the end of WWII.
Well done. Highly simplified analysis
Listen, I get that France may have a policing culture issue similar to the US, but the "victim" being a f-boy and being killed while actually committing a crime and attempting to evade/escape law enforcement does not make for a good argument.
It's not the car that attempts to drive away, it's the driver who attempts to escape arrest
His little recreation also ignore that the cop that fired his gun was leaning on the car and was carried with it even after he shot.
@@TheThirstyOtter When I get pulled over next time for a traffic stop I will try your logic .
I did not stop and pull over because I do not trust police trying to pull me over .
@@Crashed131963doesn't make the reason false, it just means you want to ignore the cause and focus on symptoms. Be human.
@@TheThirstyOtter The kid had already been arrested multiple times.
Caught drug dealing, using fake car plates etc.
Also if you think attempting to "evade arrest" when they are leaning on your car pointing a gun at you is a good idea, you are a moron.
Escaping arrest shouldn’t be punishable by death sentence right there and then.
Hol' up. The guy who got shot had a long rap sheet of driving illegally, evading arrest, and a couple other things. He should have been in jail already. And when a cop points a gun at you and says, "Stop," and you try to drive away hitting him with the car in the process, especially under totally justified circumstances like this, it's not murder: it's called winning a darwin award. THIS IS NOT MURDER! In fact if you look at the video, the cop was actually trying to aim for his leg, but because this idiot nudged him with a 2000 pound weapon the cop's gun was knocked higher and the moron died, then the tribal folks decided it's time to flip over cars and create the caliphate. And yes, France is over the tipping point by a long shot - they are flooded by hostile, radicalized populaces. You can talk till blue in the face about the history and how things COULD HAVE been done better, but this is the fact now: demographic clash that will become existential, if it isn't already.
From all the Reports and Stories of France lately Social issues appear to be the Origin of this Problem . Governments and Politicians are Responsible for Controlling Social Issues. Police with Guns is merely a Bandaid always has been always will be
@@Saffsa leftists will exhaust as many fancy words as they can before they will admit a threat posed by the other. To them dilemmas are either civil, coming from other westerners, or have no relation to culture or nation at all. And it's seen as hierarchy and not hypocrisy so there's no point in arguing.
Yeah would also say the police officer is not at fault.
How can someone expect him to aim "better" while getting pushed away by a car....
Thanks Barbara Spectre and Co .
Research who's funding NGOs like IrasAid .
In my opinion, these are two different worlds. And neither one nor the other is to blame, but together they don't work.
On the one hand, you have an ordinary Frenchman who is used to living in a western society of a rich country, and on the other hand, you have someone who came from a distant, poor country, mostly with a poor education, to seek happiness and a better life in that western, richer society. This is where two worlds collide. Starting with culture, religion, customs, beliefs and who knows what other things that somehow dictate the everyday life of each of us.
When you come to live and work in another country, you must be aware of all the things mentioned above and learn to accept those new things that appear and happen in your life.
Unfortunately, a lot of migrants, unable to adapt to a new way of life for various reasons, end up in, I'll call it, ghettos, which are like their mini-states from which they fled. I assume that there are different reasons why it is like that, but one of them could be the inhospitality of the natives, the French, towards those people. After some time, aversion towards them is created because the new arrivals increasingly turn to illegal activities and crime because they are not accepted. Over time, an ever-widening gap is created, which eventually breaks and these fractures are created.
I think France is on the brink. Sparks appear everywhere and it takes very little to turn into a blaze. I also believe that after Jacques Chirac, France does not have a real president and, above all, a capable president.
In the end, I have to say this: We all know that France is a former colonial power that did who knows what to other countries. If one Belgium and its king killed a few million Africans because of chocolate, we can only imagine what the stronger colonial powers were doing in those unfortunate times. A lot of mistakes were made in the past that today come to be paid for in a different form. Everything is returned - everything is paid for.
Thanks for this explanation, I appreciate it.
Even the Middle Eastern countries cannot deal with the Middle Easterners...
Its a choice to call it a "parallel economy" and not just what it is: crime