I clicked your link and cant join, due to low income (out of work) rigth now so sadly this will be the last I see from your channel... good luck :) and slava ukraine 💙💛
tbh they could have released one video with subtitles in all those languages. I don't know how it would get to the viewers of other countries which is why I can partially understand why they did that. But it also allowed them to monetize each country. I agree though youtube is ridiculous anymore!
CZcams has a a very legitmate, and very hard battle against AI. Scammers using AI to steal the work of other channels is a very common problem. And one hard to fight. Compound this with the fact that Russia will be doing its best to shut down this channel, using bots of its own. This is part of the war of ukraine.I don't blame youtube, but we must fight to keep this channel up.
Ukraine is loosing territory, and reporting such makes the channel "pro russian". The channel also gives information that MSM does not, and MSM cannot have that.
Google is violating its “don’t be evil” policy. It would seem they are too lazy to do the right thing, so they will let the bots decide to do the wrong thing.
@@vaevictis6990 Not only factual reporting. Countering Kremlin propaganda has become literally Russian Roulette. While as you say the platform is flooded with their propaganda and trolling. Basically shooting down the own defendants.
Only way this will change is if creators sue the platforms for failing to protect them ie. not following what the DMCA law actually says: that content must be taken down AFTER A COURT ORDER is issued, not before. The way DMCA is "applied" on CZcams assumes guilt before innocence. It is fundamentally illegal.
Yea I went and made a patron immediately. This is sorta the same shit that distrubed reality and disturban had but they didn't have their channels deleted
These channels are pure propaganda my friend. Every 2nd video has the name "Russian orc" in it. What do you expect?? Is it that difficult to be civil? Pro-Russian Ytube channels don't dehumanize people like this.
First, take a look. Ok, it is not a news channel. Next, is it an entertainment channel or a propaganda channel? ....... Then life is much easier for everyone. Now, take a note on the content. It is probably telling 1/5 to 1/3 of what's currently happening. That would leave you to dig up the remaining from other sources youself.
@@nuke_Godjira I blame Russia for invading another country. This channel will not be down for long, but Russians will be losers until there is no Russia
so you are saying Ukrainian government propaganda channels made youtube relevant? hahahahahahah some people are really living in an alternate reality. Oh boy I would love to be this stupid.
@@user-ms2sy4ld1bSame, they allow propaganda and disinformation to flourish, but if I post anything dispelling it, no matter how politely or factually, it gets deleted. The misinformation agent can even call me out, saying I'm running away, althewhile being completely unable to even reply that I'm not but being censored.
It seems to me that CZcams lacks the manpower to look into complaints individually. Instead they just shut channels off, if they get enough complaints. I'm currently a CZcams premium member, but I start to get tired of these occurences. If they can't hire enough personel to look into matters individually, I might just save up my monthly payment for something else.
@@RedRavenX1 What's wrong with that? He actually, he doesn't spread lies like most Russian Channels. Don't forget you started the War not Ukraine, Ivan
@@markwalton8644 No problem with that, just calling it objective journalism or “honest” is quite a stretch. Otherwise I follow closely the happenings in Ukraine and look forward to the Ukrainian victory. Why is everything so binary to some of you people, that is a bizzare way to think and live.
Would you expect anything less from big tech. They have carved out a position of power and will do anything to maintain and acquire more. Their acquisition of AI and other emerging technologies ensuring it remains in the hands of the few. The same corporate play book.
@@10jpmorgan you can't possibly be serious? The very first google result for "contact youtube" is their official site that handles stuff like this... its youtube / t / contact_us if even that is too much work for you. Also, why the hell are there 6 guys who agree with you? have you all never heard the phrase "looking things up"?
Best? Full of lies and bullshit? Anyway, it is not closing down, it keeps on living in our hearts.... Anytime ypu need, you can watch one victory report randomly.
This is an excellent information podcast and should not be removed. This author has short, concise, unbiased reporting. What the hell is wrong with CZcams? CZcams seems to have Russina and Chinese censors. I am a Canadian, whose grandparents immigrated to Canada from Odessa, who fled the Bolsheviks in the early 1900's. Slava Ukraine!
@@ralfjanser4733 how is he making more money tho? The people who want the info in English are hardly going to be watching the Thai or Hindi channels or vice versa. So surely all he is doing is making more work for himself with the translations and giving the same info to people who speak different languages. How's that wrong?
@@DraconimLtDon’t bother. I ran this account through our AI tool at work and it comes back as 78.2% chance troll, 82.4% chance ‘bad actor’ (as in troll or bot). If you respond to Vatnik bots they can tick that off their to-do list. Sometimes it’s important to explain to others why the troll/bot is wrong but usually it’s a waste of time. If you don’t have access to social media tools, just click on the account to see what else they’ve been doing. Usually they don’t bother to make stuff private so it’s quite clear they are evil.
@@ralfjanser4733Corporate channels like Disney have no trouble reposting the same content in different languages. Subtitles aren't enough, you need multiple audio tracks. CZcams should at least allow for one video per audio track, and they should consider adding a proper language support on their platform.
i mean first you need to have a foriegn power soft coupe your government to install a puppet that assaults their own people to start a war and refuse to negotiate conditions while international arms dealers rake in obscene profits and thousands of your country men die for nothing. probably not the best strategy
@@ralfjanser4733 No- the subtitles feature cannot be used, because the audio language is completely different. Creator would need a language audio track button to do the same thing that is being done now, NOT just subtitiles. Audio language track is significantly different than, and much easier to consume, than just text subtitles.
@@ralfjanser4733 "the translations where very ugly" - Not sure if you ever compared the english(!) language subtitles/closed captions with the original dialogue... And don't even get me started on when you are not a native speaker and try to make sense of what you hear! AI voice-overs are usually better to understand. This is a clear case of a very strict interpretation of the rules and guidelines (very likely without any human oversight so far) as a result of the constant massive targeted attacks on all pro-Ukranian channels we've been seeing for a decade now. So yes, someone needs to wake up asap!
@@ralfjanser4733 You seem to be very aware of the "real reasons "despite them not being referred to in the video. Methinks you are one of the bot controllers that formulated the attack and are now trying to sow disinformation
They also accept ads from scammers - when people report the ads they do nothing. I provided links, screenshots, etc over a month ago and the scam ads are still running...
If we learned anything from the twitter purchase, it's that these tech giants use the bots as part of their business models. They use traffic numbers to sell adspace, it would take a crazy billionaire to make them give up nearly half of their traffic. Bots are good for business if your business is selling clicks to idiots.
It's not a lunacy at all. It's greed. Stopping bots costs ressources means they have to spend money. And I'm afraid they don't close channels anymore, it would mean they have to pay humans making decisions. YT let algorithms make decisions. Also not malevolence but only greed, lack of imagination and stupidity. The times we are living in.
@@mellowmarkable Can confirm that, I have reported about dozen of scam ads and only one report was accepted as valid. Although it was exactly the same scam but with different ads. The system is not working well, mildly said.
CZcams.. This is a VALUABLE channel for up to the minute actual information about the ongoing war in Ukraine. Please do not delete it! We depend on it for information!
CZcams just doesn't care. It's tech support is infamous for doing nothing or dragging it's heels even when the claims and complaints are clearly false. Doesn't matter who you are or what you make, the only way I've seen that works with any sort of reliability is when much bigger creators take up the cause and make a social media stink about it.
@@andrewvelonis5940 At the CZcams website, top right corner of the window, is the user profile button. Click on that. At the bottom of the menu, click 'Send Feedback'. Paste in your complaint.
Yes ru have infiltrated the human aspect of the complaint process. Tiktok seems to have got on the case with this better recently. People foolishly thought CZcams was safer.
@@the_undead they do not even need to understand responsibility completely to see the risk of a overboarding censorship and the end of freedom of opinion.
You would think CZcams would not only have anti-bot systems in place, but would also flag channels for manual review because of the high likelihood of malicious attacks like this. But in the end Google priorises money above all else. Spending time on channels like this takes time away from their real money makers. React, prank, and influencer channels...
this isn't about this channel. this channel is reposted in many different languages. instead of subtitles the content of each channel is the same, in this way the same video was reposted 60 times. by reposting there was no further information added besides the fact that the translatiom where very ugly. this channel is a money making machine as he tries to multiply his income by each channel without giving any additional information. Keep in mind that such a behavior is not a support for ukraine it is only his personal way to generate income. That is No bot attack. It is simply a violation against the youtube rules.
@@ralfjanser4733 You know why it's posted in many different languages? Because people in other countries are interested in this war. And youtube subtitles are some of the worst subtitles for a video platform.
Right, itd be one thing if they were supporting creators like AT ALL. If youre not swimming in subscribers and ad revenue then they dont seem to care. I get its a gigantic platform thats hard to manage but clearly somethings gotta change
If Alphabet actually keeps doing stuff like that, they will be complicit with Russian cyberwarfare practices. Something that could land them on a sanctions list. We should all write our respective politicians.
Yes. Go for the unhinged politicians first. The ones that like to make headlines. Go to them, they're always looking for a fight. "Russians against Freedom of Speech" "Russians are taking over You Tube and denying Americans access to their favorite channels" Do it
Seems like he created multiple accounts posting the same videos. This is called "recycled content" and is against the rules. If MrBeast creates 50 accounts posting the same videos, his duplicate accounts would probably be banned too. You can't monetize recycled content. It is like making 1 video and spamming it on 50 accounts.
@@IEEEE50 Is it AI translated? AI voice? Should a same low effort video be translated into 20+ languages and put on 20+ accounts using AI? Can I repost MrBeast videos in German AI voice and make money off of that?
@@ProSePlaintiff The difference is hes not stealing someones content and translating it. Its his OWN content. Even if its AI thats no different from turning on Auto Generated Closed Captions
This is absolute BS, they shouldn't be taking down the best reporter on this platform. Thank you for everything you've done, and i will continue to watch on patreon.
Has anyone contacted the media about this? Does anyone here know someone in a news organization, who can contact CZcams’s media relations department? This is unacceptable.
Botfarms need to be reined in asap. YT is slacking when it comes to this. Half the internet is affected by this Kremin hybrid informational warfare strategy btw. Yes folks, this is part of an informational warfare strategy operated by Kremlin.
What a ridiculous ruling! This channel is the best daily news reporting from Ukraine anywhere on the web. With your connections and insights, your viewers can be far better informed of events in the war than they could by reading whatever occasional articles the main stream media outlets decide to publish. Please reconsider your decision CZcams. Let reporters report.
Joe Blogs was hacked a couple of weeks ago, and he made a video on how to contact a human in youtube. It may be worth checking out his video where he explains how he was hacked and how he was able to contact a real human. I probably would get it all mixed up if I were to try to explain what he said, and also I know I will have forgotten some key points too.
#CZcams #content #accountdeleted REPORTING FROM UKRAINE is a well-regarded new channel presenting valuable, original and objective content that abides by the rules, never showing graphic violence or insignias, never speading disinformation. This bears the mark of an attack, so we need to find ways to contact CZcams representatives of video creators.
RFU is my first source of honest and reliable information on news out of Ukraine. CZcams should stop being lazy and deal with its bot problem before needlessly attacking legitimate channels like RFU.
Go to the little gear symbol in the corner of the screen, scroll down to help and feedback, click on it and give feedback directly to CZcams. They will read and listen.
This channel is very well done and organized with high quality videos about Ukraine's fight against invasion. Are the pro-russian influencers complaining because they don't like the messages? It's a big loss for youtube if this channel disappears.
@@404killer I see a number of channels do the same thing and even then that doesn't explain why his main channel is targeted as well. This is just vatnik bots reporting stuff they dislike because it doesn't conform to the russian bullshit propaganda.
@@404killer Just imagine how much money Russian bots would have if Putin and pals hadn't embezzled the countries natural resources for 20 years - now instead of living like Arab Princes, they are reduced to sh*tposting for potatoes.
Ukraine supporter: "We are winning, Russia is being crushed" also Ukraine supporter: "We need your support, more money NOW or else the Russians will win"
Cause they automated too much. I guess if you let your content be moderated and curated by algorithms (and clickworkers) things spiral out of control quickly.
How is this great reporting? He only covers the good about Ukraine military situation and does not cover the bad side of Ukraine military situation (Like the ammo shortage for artillery and manpower shortage)
@@irenes.2807 You said great reporting, which means it must include both side perspectives, in this case, only ukraine perspective. This is what is bugging me. The biased.
Russian bots are manipulating the CZcams content too easily. I suggest a substack account and subscribestar account as well. Patreon is known to be influenced heavily by Rus sian and Chi ne se bots and has excessive censorship like YT.
They need to combat botfarms and mass bot reporting asap. It's even bigger than any free speech or monetization issue, bc it corresponds with those directly. Bot reports are not coming from real people, but YT can't identify them for whatever stupid reason.
🟠 Patreon: www.patreon.com/ReportingFromUkraine
I don't see a free option there :( Only 7-day free trial.
I clicked your link and cant join, due to low income (out of work) rigth now so sadly this will be the last I see from your channel... good luck :) and slava ukraine 💙💛
I have successfully joined the free version of this channel from the link above - LOOK HARDER - it is on the right-hand side of the page
consider looking into nebula, its a good streaming service.
@@davehrcfpv oh yeah, I did it! Had to click on the three dots on the right-hand side of the page, and then it shows "join for free". Thanks! :)
This channel is legit, youtube please don't shut it down.
This might be why Russia is targeting it.
Youporn was already down Warthog Defense but it was reinstalled, we could hoping only for the same.
@@KnightsWithoutATable precisely
CZcams SUCKS.
Support area code
650
Pre
253
Last 4
Zero to the fourth power
CZcams’s rules are ridiculous 🤦♂️
Not so much ridiculous but FAR TOO EASY to fool and FAR TOO DIFFICULT to call out wrong decisions MADE BY AI.....!
It's not even the rules, it's that they are constantly exploited by Ruzzian bots and YT does nothing about it...
@@Michael_CS615 their AI has names, Patel and Mahmud
tbh they could have released one video with subtitles in all those languages. I don't know how it would get to the viewers of other countries which is why I can partially understand why they did that. But it also allowed them to monetize each country. I agree though youtube is ridiculous anymore!
CZcams has a a very legitmate, and very hard battle against AI. Scammers using AI to steal the work of other channels is a very common problem. And one hard to fight. Compound this with the fact that Russia will be doing its best to shut down this channel, using bots of its own. This is part of the war of ukraine.I don't blame youtube, but we must fight to keep this channel up.
It is not the first time that Google chose to take channels that are critical to the leadership in Russia.
Everything is critical to Russia
CZcams removed literally every single russian channel about war or politics lol
@@Tpecep will there be any disadvantages?
@@Tpecep They didn't
Ukraine is loosing territory, and reporting such makes the channel "pro russian". The channel also gives information that MSM does not, and MSM cannot have that.
Google is violating its “don’t be evil” policy. It would seem they are too lazy to do the right thing, so they will let the bots decide to do the wrong thing.
LOL, that is way long ago they did that.
They took that sign down at their HQ a loooooong time ago.
google is doomed to failiure, they are too much obsessed with the ideology than the bussiness itself
@@richardb8104 Now they are part of the evil forces
@@lianyang8277 Jup
I'm afraid that we are losing the social media war while algorithms can be gamed this way. Media companies have to start taking responsibility.
Tech bros and companies need to take responsibility. They have been throttling factual reporting while allowing Russian propaganda thrive
@@vaevictis6990 Not only factual reporting. Countering Kremlin propaganda has become literally Russian Roulette. While as you say the platform is flooded with their propaganda and trolling. Basically shooting down the own defendants.
Only way this will change is if creators sue the platforms for failing to protect them ie. not following what the DMCA law actually says: that content must be taken down AFTER A COURT ORDER is issued, not before. The way DMCA is "applied" on CZcams assumes guilt before innocence. It is fundamentally illegal.
you still believe algorithms are not controlled...id rethink that
National states and international organizatrions need to step in because the Techbros won't do a thing
What the hell?? This is completely bullshit
CZcams has become a horrendous platform
@@jugo1944 Not CZcams this stinks of FSB infiltration to me!
Yea I went and made a patron immediately. This is sorta the same shit that distrubed reality and disturban had but they didn't have their channels deleted
@@Fenris77 all kinds of shit is censored on CZcams. They use any excuse to demonitize.
Someone should tell our respective official news sources and politicians.
I'm cancelling my CZcams Premium subscription and turning on the ad blocker until this would be sorted out. My means of protest.
Why do you even have a CZcams premium in the first place🤦🏾♂️
Quick Shatman, it is the virtue signal!
@@leighz1962 Sucking up to the big corpse, I see.
You were paying to watch youtube?
damn....
CZcams don't care , delete away🤣
Don't shut down!!!! CZcams!! No!!
why is this guy promoting terrorism?
CZcams this is a legitimate channel, do not shut it down as it provides us with valuable news.
Saying this here wont do any good. COntact CZcams, complain to them. Making noise is the only thing they might listen to.
Bravo, CZcams. I've never seen such lies as I've seen here.
@@NPSpaceZZZ You are gullible.
@@NPSpaceZZZ No, you're not just gullible. It's much worse than that. You are a slave of Putin.
You know we are doomed as a society when people believe that for-profit war propaganda is "valuable news"
If youtube won't host channels like this, then CZcams is making itself irrelevant.
CZcams is making itself complicit in russian crimes.
These channels are pure propaganda my friend. Every 2nd video has the name "Russian orc" in it. What do you expect?? Is it that difficult to be civil? Pro-Russian Ytube channels don't dehumanize people like this.
@@kacperzimowski4626 Sure my little Putintroll! 🤦♂🙏🤣🤣
@@kacperzimowski4626 womp womp in germany we call you rubelnutte
@kacperzimowski4626 Yeah, right, the Russians are the perfect example of "civil".
CZcams has almost no customer service. Cuts down on costs but creates so many problems :( I’ve dealt with it myself and it can be a nightmare.
This channel does not deserve to be shut down. CZcams don’t do this
First, take a look. Ok, it is not a news channel.
Next, is it an entertainment channel or a propaganda channel? .......
Then life is much easier for everyone.
Now, take a note on the content. It is probably telling 1/5 to 1/3 of what's currently happening.
That would leave you to dig up the remaining from other sources youself.
Pukin got his goons inside CZcams 😒
Always has
I can hardly make comments anymore. CZcams will not post them. What a shame.
Pukin gooned youtube :(
Or worse ... Republicans.
Why not he's got them in American polatics like Trump and Mike Johnson
CZcams - please make this right. It is channels like this that made CZcams relevant in the first place.
CZcams relevant? 😅
@@nuke_Godjira I blame Russia for invading another country. This channel will not be down for long, but Russians will be losers until there is no Russia
so you are saying Ukrainian government propaganda channels made youtube relevant? hahahahahahah some people are really living in an alternate reality. Oh boy I would love to be this stupid.
@@nuke_Godjira.... says the obvious ruslob troll who just found youtube 2wks ago 🙄🙄🌻🌻
Yeah yt isn't even watching the channel to see if it's appropriate to demonatise the channel it's all bots so we're all screwed
Don't shut down! CZcams aren't you for the expression's freedom?
Been watching this since everything started. Hes got catch phrases and everything! Its always concise and to the point! This is ridiculous
CZcams has become into such a lame place. Shame.
Don't think too hard, just take your opiate CZcams
@@user-ms2sy4ld1b Same, literally. This "family friendly" stuff is annoying asf.
Just saw plain evidence how they delete comments if you don't sort by most recent :(
@@user-ms2sy4ld1bSame, they allow propaganda and disinformation to flourish, but if I post anything dispelling it, no matter how politely or factually, it gets deleted. The misinformation agent can even call me out, saying I'm running away, althewhile being completely unable to even reply that I'm not but being censored.
yeah, have you noted the escalation in ads in the past 6 months?
CZcams, stop it! This is the most honest independent news channel of them all, I want to be able to keep watching it.
It seems to me that CZcams lacks the manpower to look into complaints individually. Instead they just shut channels off, if they get enough complaints. I'm currently a CZcams premium member, but I start to get tired of these occurences. If they can't hire enough personel to look into matters individually, I might just save up my monthly payment for something else.
No it objectively was not, it was primarily focused on boosting morale and support for Ukraine
@@RedRavenX1
What's wrong with that?
He actually, he doesn't spread lies like most Russian Channels.
Don't forget you started the War not Ukraine, Ivan
@@markwalton8644 No problem with that, just calling it objective journalism or “honest” is quite a stretch. Otherwise I follow closely the happenings in Ukraine and look forward to the Ukrainian victory. Why is everything so binary to some of you people, that is a bizzare way to think and live.
this channel is literally propaganda machine
Would you expect anything less from big tech. They have carved out a position of power and will do anything to maintain and acquire more. Their acquisition of AI and other emerging technologies ensuring it remains in the hands of the few. The same corporate play book.
They are preventing "miss information" they say... more like what dont suit their POV
They don't have a point of view. But they do obey the orders of the CIA - and we should all know that the CIA promotes all US initiated conflicts.
CZcams. RFU is one of the best channels on the war in Ukraine. Closing it down is unconscienable.
Saying this here wont do any good. COntact CZcams, complain to them. Making noise is the only thing they might listen to.
@@Alexander_Kale I'd love to, but how do you contact CZcams?
@@10jpmorgan you can't possibly be serious? The very first google result for "contact youtube" is their official site that handles stuff like this...
its youtube / t / contact_us if even that is too much work for you.
Also, why the hell are there 6 guys who agree with you? have you all never heard the phrase "looking things up"?
Best? Full of lies and bullshit? Anyway, it is not closing down, it keeps on living in our hearts.... Anytime ypu need, you can watch one victory report randomly.
@@istinagy5835 Why are you even here if you value the channel so little? Weather too cold in Russia?
This is an excellent information podcast and should not be removed. This author has short, concise, unbiased reporting. What the hell is wrong with CZcams? CZcams seems to have Russina and Chinese censors. I am a Canadian, whose grandparents immigrated to Canada from Odessa, who fled the Bolsheviks in the early 1900's. Slava Ukraine!
Russian cyber warfare is what is going on, CZcams is using ai to monitor content, this is then attacked by Russian bots
this is not a ukrainian channel. It is a chinese channel posting nonsense.
@@ralfjanser4733 how is he making more money tho? The people who want the info in English are hardly going to be watching the Thai or Hindi channels or vice versa. So surely all he is doing is making more work for himself with the translations and giving the same info to people who speak different languages. How's that wrong?
@@DraconimLtDon’t bother. I ran this account through our AI tool at work and it comes back as 78.2% chance troll, 82.4% chance ‘bad actor’ (as in troll or bot).
If you respond to Vatnik bots they can tick that off their to-do list. Sometimes it’s important to explain to others why the troll/bot is wrong but usually it’s a waste of time.
If you don’t have access to social media tools, just click on the account to see what else they’ve been doing. Usually they don’t bother to make stuff private so it’s quite clear they are evil.
@@ralfjanser4733Corporate channels like Disney have no trouble reposting the same content in different languages. Subtitles aren't enough, you need multiple audio tracks. CZcams should at least allow for one video per audio track, and they should consider adding a proper language support on their platform.
Do a UKRAINE. Stand and Defend. I hope You will continue Stand fast
i mean first you need to have a foriegn power soft coupe your government to install a puppet that assaults their own people to start a war and refuse to negotiate conditions while international arms dealers rake in obscene profits and thousands of your country men die for nothing. probably not the best strategy
Au revoir et avec nos remerciemnts pour tant de services rendus pour la bonne cause !
This channel is completely legitimate. CZcams, do not demonetize.
Demonetize? They are deleting. They aren't the demonetizing they are deleting.
no its not
Wtf! Slava Ukraini! We will keep supporting
They don't want people to know whats going on
@jimbobhootenanny4440 sound dumb I thought that was only russia that didn't want their people to know the truth about what's going on in the war.
Why not support Ukraine instead of this parasite( who just steals from Ground News & posts as of his own content. Jesus, educate yourself.
Cda.
Supporting Ukraine is one thing, but supporting someone who makes $50,000/month from Patreon doesnt really need supporting.
@@destroyerdog Who do you think was controlling the bots. Please CZcams, give this channel a fair review.
Just taste and enjoy your own medicine.
look what we have here a little tankie in his natural habitat, cute
Thank god. I can’t wait till these messages are gone forever.
Why?
@@NorthernChimp Russian bot
Someone at the Alphabet corporation needs a big wakeup call.
@@ralfjanser4733 go be a vatnik somewhere else.
@@ralfjanser4733 No- the subtitles feature cannot be used, because the audio language is completely different. Creator would need a language audio track button to do the same thing that is being done now, NOT just subtitiles. Audio language track is significantly different than, and much easier to consume, than just text subtitles.
@@ralfjanser4733 "the translations where very ugly" - Not sure if you ever compared the english(!) language subtitles/closed captions with the original dialogue... And don't even get me started on when you are not a native speaker and try to make sense of what you hear! AI voice-overs are usually better to understand.
This is a clear case of a very strict interpretation of the rules and guidelines (very likely without any human oversight so far) as a result of the constant massive targeted attacks on all pro-Ukranian channels we've been seeing for a decade now. So yes, someone needs to wake up asap!
@@ralfjanser4733 You seem to be very aware of the "real reasons "despite them not being referred to in the video. Methinks you are one of the bot controllers that formulated the attack and are now trying to sow disinformation
The line is busy, they are in a call with Putler.
This is pure lunacy, YT has no interest in stopping bots but will gladly drop a genuine and extremely helpful channel.
They also accept ads from scammers - when people report the ads they do nothing. I provided links, screenshots, etc over a month ago and the scam ads are still running...
If we learned anything from the twitter purchase, it's that these tech giants use the bots as part of their business models. They use traffic numbers to sell adspace, it would take a crazy billionaire to make them give up nearly half of their traffic. Bots are good for business if your business is selling clicks to idiots.
They allow news chanels that have bots with false video footage and misleading titles that say "Russia was defeated" etc...
It's not a lunacy at all. It's greed. Stopping bots costs ressources means they have to spend money. And I'm afraid they don't close channels anymore, it would mean they have to pay humans making decisions. YT let algorithms make decisions. Also not malevolence but only greed, lack of imagination and stupidity. The times we are living in.
@@mellowmarkable Can confirm that, I have reported about dozen of scam ads and only one report was accepted as valid. Although it was exactly the same scam but with different ads. The system is not working well, mildly said.
CZcams do be acting like Russia and the CIA right now
CZcams.. This is a VALUABLE channel for up to the minute actual information about the ongoing war in Ukraine. Please do not delete it! We depend on it for information!
not reqally, it is a propaganda channel
Mostly propaganda. Watch History legends for actual reporting on the Ukrainian war.
@@cplcabs so hows the "Texas Freedom Front" going with "the America"
Dear CZcams, I’m not a bot, I’m a CZcams premium subscriber, and I find this channel very valuable. Fwiw
Stop subscribing, as I have done. I don't trust my money to a site this easily fooled by trolls.
lets create a movement to live youtube to other platforms
Me too. And like that commenter above this, I’m seriously thinking about what I’m getting for my monthly premium subscription.
Send the message to You Tube not here.
Likewise
This is fucked up, youtube putting itself on the wrong side of history.
CZcams takes down all political channels unless it’s high paying right wing propaganda media
Palestinian channels: first time eh
First day on the Internet?
CZcams just doesn't care. It's tech support is infamous for doing nothing or dragging it's heels even when the claims and complaints are clearly false. Doesn't matter who you are or what you make, the only way I've seen that works with any sort of reliability is when much bigger creators take up the cause and make a social media stink about it.
They aren't taking a side. Their algorithms are just getting exploited.
CZcams needs to create a standard way for translation accounts to work so they can't be flagged in erroneous judgements.
3 weeks later, and it still is online. Good!
Ask Professor Gerdes for help. He'll be there for you and do what he can. He's helped others in the same situation.
Hear hear
You need more upvotes!
Don't shut down this channel CZcams!
For those looking the "free" level is under the 3-dot menu on the right of the page.
Google this is outrageous!
Reporting From Ukraine is a true public service. CZcams, please check your facts and reinstate RFU channels.
Send your message to You Tube directly, no point saying it here.
no it is not
@@ArmySigs How does one accomplish that?
@@andrewvelonis5940 At the CZcams website, top right corner of the window, is the user profile button.
Click on that. At the bottom of the menu, click 'Send Feedback'.
Paste in your complaint.
If CZcams has a responsible leadership it will look for the problem INSIDE ITS OWN ORGANIZATION!
You see the problem here is you assume any silicon Valley company understands the concept of responsibility
Yes ru have infiltrated the human aspect of the complaint process. Tiktok seems to have got on the case with this better recently. People foolishly thought CZcams was safer.
There is nobody at CZcams its just an algorithm .
Might as well call itself sky net .
@@tonupharry As you have many instances in iura you should have here a thinking, welleducated person as last instance.
@@the_undead they do not even need to understand responsibility completely to see the risk of a overboarding censorship and the end of freedom of opinion.
Even as someone who doesn’t really support Ukraine, I really admire this channel. Unbiased news. Full rruth
Imagine not supporting people fighting a gnenoccide.
CZcams - this channel is legit. In many cases, it shouldn;t even be demonetized, let alone taken off.
You’re being hit by Russian bots.
Or maga bots.
I suspect the reason is more sinister than that - the Russian bots will be the fig leaf.
Probably some Russian engineers up the CZcams chain as well
They do seem to love silencing channels plenty and not letting us have reports without the mad censoring. @@geterpriffin
You would think CZcams would not only have anti-bot systems in place, but would also flag channels for manual review because of the high likelihood of malicious attacks like this.
But in the end Google priorises money above all else. Spending time on channels like this takes time away from their real money makers.
React, prank, and influencer channels...
CZcams DO NOT DO THIS!!!!!! This is insane !!!!!
this isn't about this channel. this channel is reposted in many different languages. instead of subtitles the content of each channel is the same, in this way the same video was reposted 60 times. by reposting there was no further information added besides the fact that the translatiom where very ugly.
this channel is a money making machine as he tries to multiply his income by each channel without giving any additional information.
Keep in mind that such a behavior is not a support for ukraine it is only his personal way to generate income.
That is No bot attack. It is simply a violation against the youtube rules.
@@ralfjanser4733 Thanks for clearing that up. The content on my channel is posting only once.
Probably the best to leave that shitty CZcams.
This is not the only channel CZcams behave like this....
@@ralfjanser4733 You know why it's posted in many different languages? Because people in other countries are interested in this war. And youtube subtitles are some of the worst subtitles for a video platform.
@@ralfjanser4733 bot, or a troll. people need to multiply their content to actually stay relevant to the algorithm.
its ukrover...
CZcams, please reinstate the RFU channels.
This is exactly the reason I dont pay for youtube. Nor do I watch their ads. The channels I want to support pay directly like this one.
Everything in thé CZcams evolution nowadays is disgusting...
Right, itd be one thing if they were supporting creators like AT ALL. If youre not swimming in subscribers and ad revenue then they dont seem to care. I get its a gigantic platform thats hard to manage but clearly somethings gotta change
Same here. I buy the odd coffee or pay creators on Patreon but NEVER will I give money to YT
@aqidon yup, same here. provide a working service or get pirated and f'ed. don't care at all. do your damn job, your only job.
This is disgusting, the work you do is invaluable! @youtube I'm cancelling my subscription!
Im switching to rutube. Russian platform.
Sure you will... :)
@@nisselarson3227 I did and it worked…boo hoo Ivan. Cry harder…
@@brianconnelly7823 Whatever makes you sleep better, FRITZ.
@@nisselarson3227 Eller ska vi säga AHMED.
Thank you for your reporting and good luck!
Do NOT shut this channel down!!
this guy is not news, he is a propagandist. Russia has been kicking Ukraine ass.. but not if you ask this guy
CZcams this is legit, please don't ban them! Have a human look at it please!!!
CZcams is not legit anyway....
Saying this here wont do any good. COntact CZcams, complain to them. Making noise is the only thing they might listen to.
It seems that youtube have to said "we have to look on both sides"
@@mangles1044 in your fever dreams, maybe.
@@Alexander_Kale Idk man I'm just guessing
If Alphabet actually keeps doing stuff like that, they will be complicit with Russian cyberwarfare practices. Something that could land them on a sanctions list.
We should all write our respective politicians.
I am drafting my letter now. Looking forward to seeing Pichai in Zuckerburg's hot seat.
Actually you are right - the EU should be looking into that. Clearly Russian influence at work on all these channels that have been hit
Laughs in republicans
Agreed see my stockholder plan comments
Yes. Go for the unhinged politicians first. The ones that like to make headlines. Go to them, they're always looking for a fight. "Russians against Freedom of Speech" "Russians are taking over You Tube and denying Americans access to their favorite channels" Do it
CZcams is such a mess. This is a very useful and legitimate channel.
sounds like skill issue
thats what im saying
Nearly 500 k subscribers! CZcams wake up, one of the best channels for real information on Russian INVASION OF UKRAINE!
Seems like he created multiple accounts posting the same videos. This is called "recycled content" and is against the rules. If MrBeast creates 50 accounts posting the same videos, his duplicate accounts would probably be banned too. You can't monetize recycled content. It is like making 1 video and spamming it on 50 accounts.
@@ProSePlaintiff If its translated content its allowed. lots of huge companies have multichannel networks which just recycle content but translated
@@IEEEE50 Is it AI translated? AI voice? Should a same low effort video be translated into 20+ languages and put on 20+ accounts using AI? Can I repost MrBeast videos in German AI voice and make money off of that?
@@ProSePlaintiff The difference is hes not stealing someones content and translating it. Its his OWN content. Even if its AI thats no different from turning on Auto Generated Closed Captions
@@IEEEE50 But the problem is youtube doesn't know that so he has to inform them
This is absolute BS, they shouldn't be taking down the best reporter on this platform. Thank you for everything you've done, and i will continue to watch on patreon.
It's on you now, bro
Gotta keep us informed.
@@JkDibine it's on all of us to Patreon
@@DanHalper true
BEST
lol , best fake news reporter....
Has anyone contacted the media about this? Does anyone here know someone in a news organization, who can contact CZcams’s media relations department?
This is unacceptable.
I want to know Daily where is the whole front line on a map.
Russians are doing it unfortunately. We stand with you and Ukraine 🇺🇸🤝🇺🇦
Unfortunately for Russians we stand even more by Ukraine now.
No we don't, do not talk as we as many don't stand with Ukraine
@@tazsar3204 Russian trolls are not included in the "WE" - debunks that exception
@@tazsar3204well most of us do, you can join the army and live in Russia.
Botfarms need to be reined in asap. YT is slacking when it comes to this. Half the internet is affected by this Kremin hybrid informational warfare strategy btw. Yes folks, this is part of an informational warfare strategy operated by Kremlin.
What a ridiculous ruling! This channel is the best daily news reporting from Ukraine anywhere on the web. With your connections and insights, your viewers can be far better informed of events in the war than they could by reading whatever occasional articles the main stream media outlets decide to publish. Please reconsider your decision CZcams. Let reporters report.
CZcams, this is legit stuff. Don't let bot reporting destroy your platform ffs!
Don't delete this channel. Its quality material!
Maybe Professor Gerdes and Jake Broe can help.
Watch. Jake Broe is next.
Joe Blogs was hacked a couple of weeks ago, and he made a video on how to contact a human in youtube.
It may be worth checking out his video where he explains how he was hacked and how he was able to contact a real human.
I probably would get it all mixed up if I were to try to explain what he said, and also I know I will have forgotten some key points too.
Defo get in contact with these three channels others suggested
CZcams, this is a legitimate channel - do NOT shut it down!
It's not just this site, other milbloggers have also felt CZcams/Google breathing down their necks. What is happening and what are they up to?
they did the same thing about 2 years ago, removed around 9k channels that reported on the war
#CZcams #content #accountdeleted REPORTING FROM UKRAINE is a well-regarded new channel presenting valuable, original and objective content that abides by the rules, never showing graphic violence or insignias, never speading disinformation. This bears the mark of an attack, so we need to find ways to contact CZcams representatives of video creators.
It's not new, I've been enjoying this channel for ages.
It seems CZcams decided that "we have to look at both sides"
RFU is my first source of honest and reliable information on news out of Ukraine. CZcams should stop being lazy and deal with its bot problem before needlessly attacking legitimate channels like RFU.
This happened a while back to Warthog Defense.
Go to the little gear symbol in the corner of the screen, scroll down to help and feedback, click on it and give feedback directly to CZcams. They will read and listen.
This is one of the best channels covering the war in Ukraine! It must stay on CZcams!
It's a biased one sided channel, that's exactly why it's being shut down.
@@roman9762 Dah comrade
I filed a complaint with CZcams. If enough people complain then maybe they will reverse the decision.
How do you do that?
Would you kindly list the steps/keywords you used? If more people follow your example, perhaps RFU and its other channels can be restored/saved.
If by complaint you mean suggestion I doubt it will be treated serious enough
@@GuardianR105 I just did via the menu button, then "Send Feedback", lets hope this is resolved soon and will not happen again.
HAHAHAHA no.
This channel is very well done and organized with high quality videos about Ukraine's fight against invasion. Are the pro-russian influencers complaining because they don't like the messages? It's a big loss for youtube if this channel disappears.
Has been reinstated.
We need Channels like this, this is a disgrace
Wtf. Freedom of speach!
Disgusting Z bots at CZcams
Leftists and other wretches run YT!
Google: the new Facebook.
@@404killer I see a number of channels do the same thing and even then that doesn't explain why his main channel is targeted as well. This is just vatnik bots reporting stuff they dislike because it doesn't conform to the russian bullshit propaganda.
@@404killer let's take a look at your comments and post history, shall we?
@@404killer Just imagine how much money Russian bots would have if Putin and pals hadn't embezzled the countries natural resources for 20 years - now instead of living like Arab Princes, they are reduced to sh*tposting for potatoes.
Yet again CZcams is supporting the wrong side. We really need a CZcams alternative.
Hey CZcams, RFU is a legitimate channel, don't shut it down!
Exactly!
CZcams is not operating ethically!
We need this legitimate reporting, youtube, please allow it to continue.
Saying this here wont do any good. COntact CZcams, complain to them. Making noise is the only thing they might listen to.
Dear you tube, this is a wonderful channel - informative and detailed. DO NOT DELETE!!!
Ukraine supporter: "We are winning, Russia is being crushed"
also Ukraine supporter: "We need your support, more money NOW or else the Russians will win"
i don't think he's saying his reporting is winning the war
Isn't there any way that we can contact youtube about this?
CZcams, removing this is a disgrace
CZcams, this is an excellent and informative channel. Do not shut it down. It provides legitimate reporting of the news.
Disgraceful..how will we know what's going on ! Or is that why ? Sincerely all the best from the UK
How do we sign into the free version of patreon
What is youtube thinking?
This is by far the most accurate channel for information from Ukraine
Why does youtube not stop bots and activists?
Cause they automated too much. I guess if you let your content be moderated and curated by algorithms (and clickworkers) things spiral out of control quickly.
It’s one of the best propaganda channels for Ukraine. If you want to see real information watch Military & History.
Not Thinking owners must be ruzz orc bots 🤯🤬
Sorry this keeps happening. Your great reporting is obviously a big threat to bots trolls and propagandists! Stay strong. Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦 🥰 🖖
How is this great reporting? He only covers the good about Ukraine military situation and does not cover the bad side of Ukraine military situation (Like the ammo shortage for artillery and manpower shortage)
@@bendiewan3791 Cause anyone could go to those other sites if that's what they want.
@@irenes.2807 Then its not great reporting after all
@@bendiewan3791 He's doing something right if he bugs you this much
@@irenes.2807 You said great reporting, which means it must include both side perspectives, in this case, only ukraine perspective. This is what is bugging me. The biased.
YT is becomming more cencorious by the month. It really wants people to move to alternatives...
I hear of this over and over again. I just don’t understand why CZcams does this.
This is a disgusting act on the part of CZcams. Sadly this platform is imploding, thank goodness for Patreon. Stay strong, you got this.
Russian bots are manipulating the CZcams content too easily.
I suggest a substack account and subscribestar account as well. Patreon is known to be influenced heavily by Rus sian and Chi ne se bots and has excessive censorship like YT.
Lol you will say everything happens bcz of Russian bots, including your existence 😂
Support Ukraina!
Support channels that do!
Slava Ukraina!
💙💛💙💛💙💛
Lmao
is there a way u can use the different voiceline feature to upload different languages to one channel?
Corporations need to seriously step up and help preserve social media integrity. SLAVA UKRAINI 💛💛💛💛💙💙💙💙
They need to combat botfarms and mass bot reporting asap. It's even bigger than any free speech or monetization issue, bc it corresponds with those directly. Bot reports are not coming from real people, but YT can't identify them for whatever stupid reason.