Best Budget Work Boot - Timberland Pro VS CAT - (CUT IN HALF)
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2024
- Check Out GearDryer and use the code "RoseAnvil" at Checkout - bit.ly/3BBcCVJ
Timberland Pro Boot Review VS CAT Boots Review - There is a lot of talk online about what the best affordable work boot is. In that conversation TImberland Pro and Cat boots get brought up a lot. People like timberlands because of the comfort and the name. People like Cat becuase of the price and some people consider them to be the best budget work boot. So today with the help of Nick at Stridewise we are going to cut them in half to see what's inside and which is the better work boot.
Buy here to support the channel:
Timberland 6” Pro - amzn.to/3LL1NoX
Caterpillar Second Shift - amzn.to/36iO7RP
Stridewise Channel - / stridewise
VIDEOS MENTIONED
Brunt Moc Toe Cut In Half - • Are Brunt Boots Just H...
Carhartt Rugged Flex Cut In Half - • Carhartt Should STILL ...
Rock Rooster Moc Toe Cut In Half - • The $128 Moc Toe Boot ...
Jim Green Razorback Cut In Half - • Best Thing From South ...
Nick’s Indestructible Boot - • Testing $1000 “Indestr...
Converse Boots Cut In Half - • Converse Boots Worse T...
Premium Timberlands Cut In Half - • Premium Timbs VS Basic...
ROSE ANVIL LINKS:
WEBSITE - roseanvil.com/?aff=17
INSTAGRAM - / rose_anvil
PATREON - / roseanvil
Timestamps:
0:00 Intro
1:26 GearDryer
2:56 Boot Info
4:50 Upper
6:13 Lining
7:40 Construction
9:27 Water Test
10:55 Outsole Info
12:19 Cut In Half
14:50 Analysis
#caterpillar #catfootwear #timberland #timberlands - Jak na to + styl
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Get a high quality wallet, belt or MORE in the Rose Anvil shop here - bit.ly/44jXLNu
Had my cat boots for about 6 years now. They're battered, scuffed and smell like hell but still solid as when I bought them. £50 sterling, worth every penny and I'll be buying them again.
dude clean your shoes, you could get a fungal infection. don’t be lazy about hygiene, part of being manly is having the discipline to keep your stuff proper clean.
@@desidia-VII His foot is one with the fungus.
I bought a pair of Cats and both of them ripped from the heel the same day, within a week of purchase. What's weird is that they didn't rip from the sole, but the leather ripped from an inch up from the sole. I got my money back when I returned them. They were not fakes.
@@kasperkosminen2679 Dodgy batch naybe
I do believe the Cat boots might last about 5-6 years, as for the smell, well after 6 years not sure there’s much you can do lol
I've worn both to work; the CATs were lighter, but the traction got significantly worse than the Timberlands when it was below freezing outside on pavement.
The Timberlands were more comfortable on concrete, but felt like lead weights. My insoles wore out pretty quickly, along with the inside heel area (I think that's probably due to my pronation/supination).
Overall, I'd wear the CATs on dirt, and the Timberlands on concrete
I buy the timberland pro insoles for my boots, regardless of the brand of boot. You must do a ton of walking if you are burning through their insoles like that.
Why would CATs they be lighter if per the weights given in the video the CATs are the ones heavier?
Bro if you think timberland pros are heavy you need to stick too tennis shoes because I just got some timberland steel toes and they are THE LIGHTEST PAIR OF BOOTS I OWN you wouldn't even be able to pick your foot up in a pair of whites or nicks😅😅😅
@@AppalachianTrailChopper I don't know the Pros but I do know the 6 inch Premiums and those are practically unwearable, unless you want muscles in your feet too, for whatever reason. Any other models are light, as they are streewear. Especially those with visible EVA soles.
@@Prosecute-fauciI wear timbs for work, they'll last just over a year before I need replacing them as the soles wear down FAST however I'm a binman walking 15-20 miles a day in them. I don't mind spending £150 a year on work boots as they're comfy and last waaayyy longer than what my company provide ( 3 months their boots last 🙄 )
For the waterproof test maybe you could get a dry weight of the boot filled with a rice-filled sock, let them soak in the water using the rice sock to weigh it down, then weigh it all again afterwards to accurately measure the water infiltration/absorption of the boot materials.
I’m actually impressed by this Timberland boot after seeing some of other cheap work boots that can’t justify the price points.
Damn, I wish I sat next to you in school man. 😄
bro is a genius
i thought rice doesnt absorb water unless boiled because you have to break down the cell wall?
Replace rice with super absorbent cotton.
@@Ilovepineapple Rice would be heavier and easier to prepare.
I can assure you guys, here in Ohio, construction absolutely continues through the winter LOL. I love my insulation! [and a pair of thin sweat wicking socks + wool socks] With that said, I wore TimPros all throughout my time working in construction, and I never noticed them getting too hot on 90° days. I mean, they're insulated so they hold a little heat of course, but they're certainly usable enough on hot summer days to justify getting insulated boots for the cold winter days. I've never been desperate to get a second pair of boots for hot weather use, though it would've been nice.
No complaints about Tim Pros though, they hold up well, are really comfortable, and I never thought about them until it was time to take them off - which is about the best compliment I can give footwear
Used to wear those CATs (non steel-toe version) as my everyday boots and both pairs I owned lasted an insane amount of time. Like, years and years. For the price they seem to be very high quality boots.
I’m in the market for CAT work boots (steel toe or composite toe), and reviews on their durability seem to vary. You wore Second Shift?
@@scecilyI suspect the design has changed. I've had 2 pairs of CATs for more than 6 years and they're easily the most hard-wearing shoe I've owned.
However, mine look much thicker than the one shown in this video - much more like the Timberland. It seems from the website that the ones I have were discontinued.
So if you read rave reviews about CAT boots, just be aware that people who've owned them for several years might be talking about a completely different product
@@alxdrmnc thanks for the reply! Thankfully, my husband has found that CATs work better for him than the Timberlands he had. Curious to see how long they will last!
My father used to work for Caterpillar at their headquarters in Peoria Illinois. He was in advertising and his boss was in charge of CAT branded merchandise (toys, shirts, hats, and shoes). At that time all CAT branded work boots were manufactured by Wolverine Shoes.
The Timberland Pro for me has been a complete success in the field. I’m a general contractor, outdoor guy and live on a farm. I’ve work all kinds of boots and there are by far my favourite. They look clean and classic and yet can handle so much. They wear far beyond their weight class. Seriously impressed and now wear these as my go to work boots everyday.
I even had an exceptionally good experience with Timberland Canada. I was just under 1 year of use when I noticed the upper separated from the sole. After sending photos Timberland sent a brand new pair of boots under warranty. They have my loyalty sealed with that gesture.
Lastly in terms of fit and comfort... steel or alloy toes can often be a sock killer. And when you wear nice Marino wool socks this can be a big suck. My hard toe Blunnies left dozens of sad socks to be relegated to the bottom of the drawer until I learn to darn. These Timberlands have not done that. In fact they are incredibly comfortable and I was not surprised but very appreciative to see that indeed the centre of this boot has so much absorption. Great flex and comfortable bed allows for happy wearing all day. Thanks for the review well done!
I wear boots literally every single day and have for almost 15 years and I swear by timberlands. They're not just "good for what they are" as some try to suggest in defense of their insanely overpriced boots, some of which you see on this channel. They're genuinely good quality, comfy and reliable footwear. I've worn them in as cold as -19 degrees and as high as almost 110, in both wet and dry, and after 9 years did I have to replace them, only after the sole wore through
Idk man. Those were my stompers and have you ever tried a thorough good? Those boots feel close to the same to me just better in every way. Safer too
CATs are workhorses. Great durability and comfort for the price point. I had a pair that I loved and wore almost daily for six months. I sacrificed them to a family member who works in landscaping, after her dog destroyed her boots. She got another year out of them, and they’re still not in the worst shape considering. Unless you need the waterproofing, I think CATs are an excellent buy.
"Moisture wicking anti-smell" being on a product means in practice "This product is made of a particular type of durable polyester that traps moisture and that bacteria LOVE, and we don't even think we could sell it without a special breathable weave, and coating it in a temporary coating of antimicrobial silver, the odor was SO bad".
It usually means the exact opposite of "This product has less smell than competitors" or "This product has less smell than the products you got 20 years ago".
I have worn CAT for years. Always sprayed them with a hiking liquid from a camping shop to make them waterproof. Never had wet feet.
I'd like to see a comparison of women's and men's versions of work boots. I've seen what at least appears to be some pretty big difference between the two for the "same" shoe
those are some cute bangs!
Yes that's a good idea ! Lot of time i buy men boot.
Good idea, gender boot discrimination could be a news headline.
Great video idea
I agree, I was surprised to see how woman’s boots often have inferior soles ( the material) that don’t have hardly any stiction compared to the mens version. In general they seem to be made cheaper except for certain brands which carry the same model for both sexes.
Can we get some videos on the standard issue boots for the military. The Bates (US Navy) they issue at boot camp are terrible and I'm curious to see how bad they are. I know a lot of guys at work who are looking for better option. Plus I'm curious how the other branches standard issue boots stack up.
Great idea
Best pair of boots I've ever worn were British Army-issued Altberg Jungle Microlites - I'm still wearing Altberg, they're so comfortable. The wet and cold weather ones are just as good. I've had Timberland and Caterpillar in civilian life and they're OK, but nowhere near Altberg. I probably prefer the look of Caterpillar, but Timberland has the edge on quality and slightly better comfort.
I just hope this effeminate high energy guy doesn't do any more videos
I'm on shore duty so I don't need steel toe boots so I wear the Oakley boots
Dawg just get some danner reckonings
I bought a pair of CAT back in 97 and still wear them today. Don't know if the quality was different at the time, but they are just indestructible. The model is different from the one from the video, but I bought them something like $70 back then. I've been wearing them time to time during winters for more than 2 decades. I also have a pair of Timberland but I doubt they will stand 25 years
I have them too! Very strong boots at the time, the leather was genuine!!
I also have a pair of Cats from 97/98, and while they are very sturdy, the sole of one unglued itself around 2008. Still love them.
I bought the cat boots twice. The first time I had no issues no leaking no discomfort and they lasted almost a year. So when I bought my second pair I didn't make it 50ft in the rain and my feet was soaked and something in the heel area that caused me to have severe discomfort. So I returned them thinking that pair was faulty and got another pair. Unfortunately they did the same which was disappointing because I really liked my first pair and was affordable. What a difference a year makes. And even now after only wearing the second pair for no longer than a month my heal still hurts. I've never tried the timberlands I don't like the colors offered. Just so everyone knows the ones I had wasn't steel toe and was suppose to be waterproof. Same name boots without steel toe.
You sure they werent fakes?
@@bloodydiablo666 I cant say forsure they weren't fakes . All 3 pairs were ordered through home depot website so who really knows guess its possible. The first pair I bought I wore the soles off of them but the 2nd and 3rd pair was crap. Something in the heel wasn't right and for the waterproof I walked about a football field on pavement during a slight rain and my feet was soaked. I don't know what happened like I said my 1st pair was great lasted alittle over a year so I'm not sure what happened in that time could have been fake never crossed my mind.
The Timbs are way..better..i got cheap cats.made in india....that hurt my heel...i patched in heelprotectors..now they ok..but Timberlands are way better but more expensive. 🤔
I actually have the timberland pros but with the steel toe. I would have to walk almost ten miles a day on rock and gravel with them and they’ve held up for over four years. This place also got super hot like a heat index of above 120 so they did get hot but it wasn’t unbearable. I like them, but I did get the wide version so it might be better for my foot to spread out with all of the walking. They have a good amount of flex and support, on top of the already pretty good protection. I can’t afford super expensive boots so I don’t know what I’m missing but these things are 10/10 indestructible and great for walking.
Yeah man, I love them. I've put tens of thousands of miles on 10+ pairs over the last 20 years. While I've tried more high end boots, I've always came back to the Pro steel toe 8". I gave up looking for better awhile ago, in my opinion they could be worse & they'd still be pretty good.
I have the full grain mocktoe and the leather is beautiful after it is conditioned.
How did they go for waterproofing? And were they warm enough in winter?
@@inspectorrex1696 I'm in Buffalo N.Y. and wear them all year. (8" steel toe) I'm never hot in the summer and never cold in the winter.
The waterproofing is excellent, for awhile. For me that's about a year or so of hard use. Regular applications of silicone spray work well. It's a suede like leather and as they get scarred up and worn, they do get a bit spongy. They'll maintain solid water resistance with applied silicone. Working in wet slush for prolonged periods, or other similiar tasks will leave you wet, but not any more than any other boot. In my experience, and from all the guys I've worked with, for a boot to be truly waterproof, it's gotta be rubber, to an elevation greater than the whatever you're in. Otherwise there's just various shades of water resistant.
Boots are about the most subjective thing I can think of and everybody's got their own opinions.
For me, they're very comfortable all seasons, and nimble for an 8" steel toe boot.
My only complaints are they're not made domestically & while the sole wears very well, and provides excellent grip in the winter...they really hold onto clay/mud.
I wore a pair of suede Timberlands I got in 2017 all the way through high school and into college until the heel completely wore out. Took them to the local cobbler last year for a premium leather lined interior and they are good as new. The natural rubber sole has still held up all these years. Best $160 boot you can buy in my opinion.
Short story: Love my CAT's, great value, great all around work boot, would buy again, would recommend!
Long story:
I've had my soft toe CAT Second Shift's for about 4 years now, and they've been going strong. Got them for just under $80 on Amazon, and couldn't be happier with the value. They were fairly uncomfortable at first to break in, had to massage them a little and wear them on and off, but after about 2 weeks or so, it wasn't a problem. They are definitely firm under foot, but definitely supportive and comfortable enough for a full workday. They currently fit me like a glove, with a little more wiggle room I'm used to in the toe, but it doesn't bother me and actually makes them comfier the wear. Lacing system was a little odd at first, feeling like the laces started too high and that I couldn't tighten further down the boot, but proved to be a non-issue. You can really snug them up like how I prefer, or wear them loose, comfortable either way. Love the fact that the top has two sets of speed hooks, makes taking on and off quick, easy, and customizable. Leather has held up great, very resilient to abrasion and kicking around, has seen everything from mud, dust and dirt, to pool cleaning chemicals, to automotive fluids, and etc. Only cleaned them and conditioned them a handful of times, and they clean up pretty well. Kept out the water well enough to get rained on or step in shallow water for a bit, but would soak thru over time. Would usually dry pretty quickly though, and never experienced any bad smell, just your typical used shoe smell. Outsole has good grip, is flexible (after breaking in), stable, and has plenty of tread, and never tore any chucks out. The stitching on the toe has definitely done it's job and won't let go of the outsole, even with the bottom of the toe clearly worn down.
Only real gripes: On one of the boots early on, the upper separated from the cushioned cuff by the eyestay, glued and sewed it back together, has been holding ever since. Other boot began to do the same at about the 3 year mark, but haven't bothered to fix it, and frankly hasn't affected the boot or fit negatively. Laces lasted about a year, but that's not a big deal. Back of the heel wore thru at about the 3 year mark, but hasn't caused any discomfort. Welt started to separate a bit from the outsole on the instep on both boots exposing the midsole, probably around the 3-3.5 year mark, makes the bottom of the boot waterproof for about 10 seconds, still works just fine in the dry.
All in all, would absolutely buy again, assuming they haven't cheaped out anything in the past 4 years. Would definitely recommend if you don't mind a firm foot bed. Also, it's a good looking work boot in my opinion. This boot definitely deserves the CATERPILLAR name, and the cute little embossed bulldozer on the outside of the heel!
Your comment is so long and boring couldn't finish reading it......
@@PGee. it's almost like I gave the option of reading a short and sweet comment on the boot, and then a more personalized account and review of it for those who care to know. Sorry you feel that way though.
@@12superaslan yeh nah still don't care....
@@PGee. again, sorry that you feel that way. Glad to see you muster the strength keep commenting though, given how much you don't care. 👍🏻
Do you consider having them resole?
Tim Pros here (full tan not Nubuck). They have been waterproof and have held up remarkably well. Extremely comfortable. The insulation has not been a problem whatsoever. Highly recommended.
Timberland pro are by far the most comfortable boots I’ve worn on the job site.
Idk if its intentional that the cat is sitting with the CAT or just pure gold coincidence 😂😂
It's always cool to see the inside and know what you're really standing on but every time, it hurts a little to see potentially a good boot get ripped up. Sometimes you need a necessary evil to find the right boot
8:24 Well he ordered a cat!.. so the cat came up! 😹😹😹
Had some cats for about 4 years now they’re surprisingly comfortable after broken in
They’re one of the only pairs of boots I have that won’t tire my feet after walking all day
For the price they’re amazing
They’re a little rough now since I use them for work and on my days off but they clean up nicely
I highly value a Goodyear welt because in my experience they hold up a ton better. I like the Caterpillar design better but I know Timberland boots tend to be really comfortable and long lasting for what they are. I would love to see you review a pair of Ever Boots "Tank" boots. I bought a pair and have been super impressed with them so far.
I've had two pairs of CAT boots in recent years - the Generator and the Endure. Both were very comfortable, but didn't last as long as other similarly priced boots that I have used. I've had the same job for over 15 years so I feel that my expectation of a boot's longevity for my work is realistic. I generally now stick to Timberland Pro and Keen.
your longevity expectation is a bit exaggerated
@@TobyMcguarro It is? I'm not sure how you would come to this conclusion since I didn't specify how long I expected them to last. I just said that they didn't last as long as other boots have. Unless you are being sarcastic implying that they shouldn't have even lasted as long as they did...?
@@brendand3600 The 15 years at the same job you mentioned seems irrelevant unless that's your actual expectation for how long a boot should last.
I like Keens because they're comfortable but honestly I have never owned a pair of Keens that lasted in real work for longer than 6 months without disintegrating. That's why I buy them used, I know I'll be replacing in 6 months so may as well save a buck.
@@gorkyd7912 It is relevant because I've gone through many pairs of boots in that time and since they've all been put through the same use, I know when my boots start wearing out before they should be.
If you are often switching jobs and/or types of work, a particular pair of boots may last only a few months at one job, but a few years at another. Much harder to get a sense of durability/longevity in that situation.
I'm also well aware that just because you've had a good or bad experience with one model from a particular brand doesn't mean that all models from that same brand will yield the same results. Companies change hands, manufacturing facilities etc.
@@brendand3600 Makes sense. So how long should a good pair of boots last?
Timberland is now my go to work boots. I use to wear keens due to it being much wider, but after awhile I liked the comfortable feel of Timberland. Haven’t gone back to Keen since.
I found the tims too narrow
Try the wide.
Weston does put out one of the most informative footwear videos out there. All from cutting them in half. Thank you.
I wrote it with a translator
I am Korean.
I help my father with his farm work
On average, Asians have wide feet
The red wing boots didn't fit my feet very well
But Timberland fits well
The leather is soft and feels great to wear
I thought Timberland was the fashion shoes of rappers
But my perception changed after I wore Timberland Pro
This is like a poem
I've been waiting for this video. Lots of mixed reviews on reddit about the caterpillars so I waned to see your full breakdown. Thank you making this happen. Keep up the good work!
As someone who's owned 3 one lasted 5 months before the mid sole didn't exist under the ball of my foot the second leaked on the third week and the third pair which were excavator xls both boots fell apart on the heel counter
CATs are great, comfortable, a lil heavy maybe (i mean they're steel toed, what do you expect)
My only complaint is that the hooked eyelets and massive laces have tripped me and caused me to fall hard onto concrete and asphalt multiple times.
If you use the hooks and tie them tight, you'll probably be fine, but if not: bend them, remove them, and/or relace your boots unless you want to eat shit.
I am a tech at a CAT dealership and some years ago I had a pair of CAT boots. They were, the most rough, uncomfortable, relentlessly rigid boots I've ever worn. The shock absorption was poor enough that my knees were sore. They were very tough-looking which is likely why I bought them ( I was in my twenties). I moved on to what turned out to be a terrific model of Red Wings which they quit making a few years ago, much to my dismay.
I have had both brands before and I would go for the Cats any day. Timberland's soles are a death trap over wet tile (at least the model that I had, which claimed that the sole was made out of recycled bottles) also the insole was soft, way too soft to give a proper support the the body causing me knee and ankle soreness. Cats on the other hand were firm but confortable and the style was better
Wet tile?! Theyre rugged outdoor boots bruh
@@CANControlGRAFFITI My insulated timberland boots with aggressive outdoor tread pattern performed poorly on wet tiles, I am shocked.
What Cat boot are you talking?
I just want a waterproof and slip, oil resistance boot.
I have both brands. The timberlands are very slippery
@@CANControlGRAFFITI that´s the worst part. You feel secure and invincible on your rugged boots, but as soon as you enter a coffee shop for a break you bang you head on the floor. They were also slippery on wet rocks, and even wet weared asphalt. Basically any wet surface was dangerous. The Cats never gave me that problem, they had way better grip
I've used the timberland pro hypercharge, and it's amazing. I used it in a factory job in a walk in blaster, and I used it for 18 months and it could do it again.
I love your cat so much, thank you for not kicking them out when you film. seeing them in your videos brightens my day.
about 6 months ago i got a pair of Thorogood boots from a thrift store, the soles were trashed but the upper in really great condition after i cleaned and conditioned them. I took them to a cobbler to have them resoled and he did a horrible job resoling them, he sanded through atleast 30% of the welt, even sanding through some of the stitching. When I saw them and told the owner I'm not paying for that, he said that's fine and apologized for the crappy job his cobbler had done but he also said usually it wouldn't be a big deal since most guys are bringing in work boots and don't care what they look like as long as they work. I ended up contacting Thorogood and they said they could resole them with the sole of my choice it didn't have to be that Cristy sole and put on a new welt for $155.00
I had the Timberland Pro's for 2 weeks before they fell apart on me. Once I moved up to the Timberland Boondock Pro's with the toe caps, they've been amazing and are going on 3 years of use still holding up.
What fell apart?
I run mine hard doing carpentry construction, having owned 10+ pairs, and I've yet to have any failures before a year. Even then it was just waterproofing and generally beat down after a however many thousand miles.
@@adamjames1375 Bending before the toe box creased so badly each upper side split. I figure it was probably just a one off issue as people I knew had them and theirs didn't do it. None the less, I gave Timberlands another shot but moved up the line and am still superbly happy.
I used to live and breathe Redwing for work boots (28 yrs in concrete as a Mixer driver/ concrete pump operator). I switch to the Timberland Pro Boondock boot in 2015, and have never looked back. The comfort and durability have me recently purchasing my 9th pair. Concrete is brutal on leather, and to reliably get 1 to 1.5 seasons from the Timberland Pro Boondock has made me a loyal supporter of this boot.
Had a pair of CAT steel-toes for several years when I was in school. I got them for $60 through a screaming deal on Amazon. They absolutely MURDERED my feet after working in them for a day. Once I graduated and got a real paycheck I treated myself to a pair of Thorogood Moc-toes.
I also had the Timberlands from this video in a soft toe. Those were tremendously comfortable and I wore them for years.
That's a funny story.
Back in 90's, CAT was the top in France. Timberland became popular few years later.
Loved this video! Boots keep getting more expensive and they aren't getting any better so you have more and more people buying with budget over performance. Good to see where those intersect. Thanks guys!
I had multiple pairs of the CAT second shift boots before I could afford Redwings. They are a great boot for the money, very durable. They can be water proofed by applying mink oil every few months. Not the lightest or most comfortable, but if you're looking for an affordable boot that just works, you can't go wrong with the CATs.
I had the Timberlands, and after a year, the uppers still had plenty of wear still in them, but the soles wore down to the point where they started letting water through. Fortunately, I got them for half price, so I was happy enough with them. And I will buy them again for that price but definitely not $150.
Nick is all over my favorite channels these days! ❤️
My last two pair of boots were Tim Pros, and for the last 4 years I've been wearing CAT Excavator XLs, working in the construction world. They've held up and worn like iron, however the sole is starting to detach from the welt up front, and tear in the back. I've neglected the hell out of them too. I'm going back to Tims for my next pair (Gridworks Moc Toe), and will likely be buying Red Wings or Thorogoods for my casual pair.
I worked as a Carpenter and these CAT boots lasted me for about 9000 work hours, before the outsole cracked. I have to say that for the money they are really fine boots.
I am on my second pair of CAT Second Shifts. I just water proof spray them every few months to keep them waterproof.
I always really loved my caterpillars after break in. Only complaint is my wide feet require finding wide boots, which used to be more difficult than it is now
I wear CAT as they are much cheaper than Timberland where I live.
5 years and still going strong.
Oh and mine are a waterproof model
So, I know this is a bit of a stretch out of your area of expertise... But I would love to see you cut up Pleaser and Hella Heels pole dancing boots to see what's inside them. I have the 7 inch Hella Heels and I'm honestly shocked by how comfortable and sturdy they managed to make a 7 inch platform heel. Not sure about how it would go over with your demographic and they're not leather or anything but I am soo curious.
Analyzing quality stripper shoes should be a thing Bc we be okay our feet just as much as anyone else.
Can I ask how it is a stripper wound up on a video about boothough about boots like men's working boots
I use that exact same model of CAT boots for my work. They are good for now. Even in NYC winters, they are okay, although need insulated socks for freezing temperatures. They held up pretty good even after 1.5 years.
I'd love to see you cut the Timberland Boondock (comp toe) in half. I've been wearing my pair daily for 2 years in -20 degree conditions. The soles have finally cracked, but they lasted longer than I thought!
I wore CAT steel toed boots on the production line at Honda. They were perfect. They wore well and didn't break down very quickly. I think I got about 9 or 10 months out of a pair before I needed to replace them. That seemed perfectly acceptable considering the miles I walked in them every week and the chemicals and agents they came in contact with. Plus, they were very reasonably priced.
my low profile cat steel toes lasted 4-5 years. every day exposed to engine coolant, engine oil, gas, xylene (paint thinner), zinc paint, rattle can paint etc. and i only got rid of them last year cause the inners were shredded through bad already. I was super impressed by them but am now gonna try a pair of timberlands and see how i like them
I have that exact pair of Cat boots. In fact I am on my third pair at this point. I work in a shop environment and they hold up really well considering the cost. The issue that I always eventually run into is sole delamination, but this is after a couple years of hard use so I'm not complaining. I would definitely recommend these to anyone looking for a budget steel toe boot.
Love my Cat Revolvers. I spend long days in them on stone, concrete, and dirt. On their 4th year and going strong, the soles show little wear other than some cuts and gouges from kicking shovels and walking on sharp rocks and bits of metal. I clean with saddle soap about once a year and follow up with a little bick 4 then mink oil for water resistance. I brush when I remember to, and use a boothbrush to wash mud out of the stitch when needed. The leather is holding up great and looks better than when new.
Not perfect, of course. Cracked the welt (plastic) at the toes a little by kicking rocks (to shed dirt and mud), fixed with boot glue and changed my habits a bit and they've been perfectly fine since. I wish the material over the heel counter wasn't plastic. It's cracked up, but hasn't impacted wear or comfort though. Would definitely buy again.
Timb pro Pitbosses were my saving grace working in a machine shop and later a lumberyard in NY during those nasty Polar Vortex winters a few years back.
Love your content you make choosing a good boot a lot easier. On the other hand it sucks that people have to go thru all this just to know what's good or bad. I wish boot company's were more honest about what they make. Idk
That Hawk brand at Boot barn has some cut aways in store to poke at.
I have the steel toe timberland pro and they're great. Really solid and comfortable.
good to have the team back, great video
Been waiting for this video. I'm totally biased towards the Timberland boots lol. I used to buy the black 6inch direct attach boots when I was in the ope industry. I'd always get two to three years out of a pair before they were ready for the trash. Timberland 6inch Direct attach boots are always comfortable and in hot weather I never had an issue with them. Good boots for the money.
Would love to see ya cut open some Military boots. I've personally worn a pair of Danner Rivot military boots daily since my last deployment in 2012. Best boots I've ever worn. But in general, I've always found them to be a nice mix of cheap, comfortable, long lasting and easy to wear compared to many other normal work boots I've owned.
Great review! The Cat Colorados have no steel toe, similar to the Timberlands you tested. I work in Construction and I can attest for the commfort of Caterpillar boots and steel toe sneakers. I got some Cat Power Plant, a bit more expensive than the second shift (for boots that will really get trashed) and they are more waterproof.
I've actually had both of these or at least a version of both. I'm currently using the slightly more expensive version of the timberland pros and I've previously used these exact caterpillar boots. I had no problems with either of them but I do like the timberlands a bit more and that might just be because I was able to get a perfect fit because they make these things in an absurd number of sizes. It's kind of crazy how many options there are, whereas the caterpillar ones. I really didn't have that many choices and I ended up with a boot that was about half a size too large and arguably about half a size to narrow
A couple of other things about my timberlands versus these. I am fairly certain I have a steel shank in mine as well as mine is stitched down and I don't think it's injection molded but it may be kind of both. I also got a very thick layer of foam that's visible from the outside as opposed to these where they're just covered in rubber and I don't think I have nearly that much insulation
All of these stories about guys wearing out new boots in 6 to 12 months. Back in my day - when we walked 12 miles to school in the snow - I wore my boots until the sparks from the acetylene torch burned through all of the stitching and then I riveted them back together until the burn holes got too big (true story). Then I walked 20 miles home in the rain.
Request: Non-slip or slip resistant-soled shoes for kitchen/hospital workers. (especially smooth toe oxfords.) Thanks!
I second this. It’s very difficult to find 1) a nonslip that is actually nonslip 2) lasts more than 6 months 3) are comfortable after a double. Great recommendation, Eric!
In most of Canada it’s winter half the year so yes we like a good insulated boot.
When I was a rookie in construction I use to buy the timberland pro resistors they use to leave my flat feet aching 😫 thank God for thorogoods
I've been wearing Timberlind Pro (Endurance) work boots for several years now because they were one of the only options I found with steel toe, AND puncture rated steel shank. I work in tree service and we have some crazy huge 3+inch thorns around here(AZ desert) that will puncture normal soles and tires. The boots hold up well for me under pretty hard use. I replace the insole after 4-6months and after a couple insoles I just replace the boots ~every year. I think the foam mid-sole just breaks down and I have ankle/knee issues from youth sports injuries. When my ankle starts hurting all day I swap the soles, or replace the boots and the pain goes away for another 3-6months. I've gone through 4-5 pairs of these in the last 4 years and never had issues with the outer/upper. just break down the midsoles doing 5-10miles a day 7 days a week. So performance seems good for me given the price. Maybe I could try swapping the undersole out for 2xinsoles after a year but for $150 I just replace them and keep working. I do also wear these boots for climbing work, both pruning and removal. they hold up well to the abrasion and wear of climbing trees and are fine standing on tree spikes too, again I have the steel insole plate which must help with the rigidity there. They are HEAVY though with the steel toe and shank. I'm trying to find some lighter boots for daily wear and keep my current near new Timberlands for days I know we have huge thorns in store.
Please make a video on the Redwing Supersole original. My grandpa, dad, and uncle have all worn them as their go to farm work boots for years and I got my first pair for Christmas this year.
Wore a pair of of 8 inch direct attach steel toes for literally everything I did for over a year before they wore out. Really awesome boots and were super comfortable. Would you ever do a teardown of the 8 inch timberland boondock? Almost every contractor where I live wears them.
Is very interesting about the Timberland PRO because it is one of the most comfortable boots i have (the shoe box) but at the same time one of the most stiff and strong feel. But i really love it. I dont know if standing all day long in a workplace would be the perfect balance. About the height of the boot is not for looks. If you step on dirt, open fields, debris, etc. it really makes you feel protected for nails, rocks, snakes, scorpions, and things that you can trip on (higher boot less block the movement if you trip) No complaints at all, Love Timberland boots!
I have the timberland pros soft toe but with a full grain leather. I chose that because I learn more towards a boot that I can more property clean and treat. I’ve had the boots for about a half a year now and I’m a fan. I like the quality for the price. Classic style. I’d recommend them.
I've had a pair of CAT books for over 20 years and they are great. For climbing up onto heavy machinery the better support of the steel mid sole is great, particularly when the steps don't allow any support on the heel.
Love mine but they are heavy
@@jeffjohnson6181 they are that. Bought mine direct from William Adams (Cat dealership) before they were a thing.
I'd love to see you cut some (more) dedicated hiking boots, especially from brands like Alpina that are a lot cheaper than the big name brands, but seem to make solid boots nonetheless. I want to know if they're cutting corners somewhere.
Thanks for this! I am looking for a new pair of winter boots. I do a lot of walking, not wearing this for a job but still like to be comfortable and warm. Also something somewhat stylish is always a plus! I am in the market for new winter boots. This video basically convinced me to get Timberland Pros!
I was waiting for a cat and timberland pro cut in half, great video!
I have the Cat second shifts rn, so I'm very interested you're covering them. I am pretty satisfied but it's only been a month of every other day use
I have also had timberland pros but can't speak to their comfort bc their women's size was straight up too narrow for me. I didn't realize I could just get small men's sizes at that point
How are the Cats holding up?
I've worn Cats for work for years , been great for me , I usually resole with a Vibram sole when the original sole wears out, they've always been excellent value and comfortable. The lining quality has gone downhill in the last few years , the Nylon texture visible changed and now doesn't last as long, but still good for the price just a shame they aren't as good as they used to be.
Hello , can you tell me if the vibram sole Is it slippery compared to the caterpilar sole? thanks
@@EDCwhistlesSCRATCHCARDS Hi I find the Vibram Commando sole is less slippery than the original Cat sole, both are good tho' so just which ever you prefer.
@@ianwalker4803 Super thanks , now i will resole my Dunlop nevada with that soles soon ! Greetings
I watch both your channels.great review and video
I’ll own the caterpillar watershed for about 8 years now and they hold up great…
They’ve been worn basically the whole year and have to deal with a prosthetic foot which stresses shoes heavily.
Maybe they Where made to a higher standard but they are a bargain for what they cost me back in the day.
Ill love mine and as long as they serve me, i will wear them and if they give up in 10 years or so, theres the exact same pair in my locker just waiting to accede.
I am pleasantly surprised about the quality of the Timberlands in this video. I have had this idea that their a name first brand with so-so quality. But it seems like they offer a decent boot for a decent amount of money, and a name for fashionistas as well...
everyone keeps parroting that too, they're a cheap boot and they're reasonably priced
They fall apart in 3 months…
@@bionicmanspeedruns you're probably right.
@@CANControlGRAFFITI that is what I would expect. So you are saying that this video doesn't give a good picture of the quality of those boots?
It really depends on what you're buying them for. For a wildland firefighter, they're trash. For a code inspector, they're overkill. Lack of a steel toe makes them useless for most commercial construction and industrial fabrication jobs, so I'm not exactly sure who they're made for, but if you occasionally work outside in a cooler environment, and need some ancle support and traction on moderately rough terrain, but do more standing than walking, they'd probably be okay for a year or so. They're no Nicks or Whites, but most people don't have a job that really requires a $350 to $700 pair of boots. Even a good pair of Red Wings will probably cost $50 to $100 more, which to me is worth the price, but not to everyone.
I've owned both and I feel the timberland boots are more comfortable but the cat boots seemed to not tear as much. Both made it past the 1 year mark.
I'm glad you did a video about the Timberland Pro Direct Attach boots. There's not many videos covering that line of boots. I think I'll buy some if the full grain brown ones. I have a pair of the distressed leather premiums and a pair of black nubuck basics.
I've bought expensive boots and I've bought cheap ones. They both only last about 1 year. Too many things are overpriced these days.
It’s funny - I enjoy seeing you cut the boots in half but I feel like it’s such a waste when you cut through the laces. “Save the Laces!”
Funny that, I kind of feel the same about that.
He can also just use is bandsaw instead of the knife. Makes a cleaner cut.
I can vouch for caterpillar all day.
I have had those exact pair and once you get them worn in you will be feeling like they are a part of your feet.
And their entire range of of leather work boots that are a little more expensive than the 2nd Shift are the first shoe that my size 12 foot has ever felt good to walk in.
As a home improvement contractor I do a lot of kneeling and scraping of the toe of the boot getting up and down. I had been a Wolverine buyer for many years but decided to try the Timberline pro's. Seemed to be a very well made, comfortable boot for the money but within a very short time the very thin toe leather had worn through making them unusable in wet weather. Going to Redwings or Thorogoods mock toes next pair of boots!
I would love to see you review some Crispi Guides and Kenetrek Mountain Guides. These are the two most popular mountain boots and I believe that a review and cutting them open will benefit a lot of people.
I'mma guess the timberland pro is better. Given I own some timberland pro boondocks I might be biased. And I'm always a little reluctant of big name companies that branch out into boots, but not visa versa. For some reason good boot companies almost always make great clothes when they do.
At end of the video, I'm actually surprised cat was better than I'd expected.
Yeah all my coworkers wear the boondocks and love them. Groundskeepers / Equipment Operators
I got a pair of boondocks myself and I love them. Been wearing them a year and still has plenty of life in them. If you want a good work boot you can’t go wrong with timberland pro. Come to think about it this is my second pair of pros and going to get another pair.
"Vice versa" (actually french for "the other way around")
@@CartoonWeasel well thanks for the grammar correction. My auto correct appreciates it to the fullest.... And I don't speak French, so yeah 👍.
I used to work at Cat headquarters assembling large wheel loaders with access to the Cat safety store and every boot they offered plus some other brands they offered in their safety program. Nearly every new hire, myself included got Cat branded boots for their first pair because of the name…being a gung-ho new hire plus they offered them at about 50% off. And that was back when working there meant something. The employees who actually put their boots to work threw them away and went back to the store for the Carolinas or Georgia boots they offered secondary to their own brand even though they didn’t offer the same discount. Then again, I have two pair of Tims and those hurt my feet after some time as well…and that’s just casual use. Being in manual labor my entire working life, I’ve gone to wedge soles and haven’t looked back but boots are very subjective.
In my experience w/ the Timberland Pro series, (and other direct injection molded sole boots as well) is that walking on an abrasive surface like rough unfinished concrete all day, will quickly wear through the hard-rubber coating of the outer-sole (especially if you tend to drag your heels in your stride, as you walk). Once through the hard outer coating, pretty much all water resistance is lost. Depending on the individual of course, this can be achieved in as little as a few months or so. They did used to have a lifetime warranty on them, which if sent back to the manufacturer, would be replaced in full. IDK about anymore
I remember being a boy in NYC 20 years ago
My parents bought me CAT boots that looked just like Timbs
I was laughed at and made fun of for half the school year by half the school
Again this is NYC were talking about, wearing anything other than Timbs (especially in the early 2000s) was sacrilege
Needless to say, today all I wear is Timbs
Garbage bro , Americans are not so smart you eat to much hamburgers 🍔
@@bilocanmursi584
I will lodge these Timbs between your teeth
This is so strange with America, i live in sweden, no constructionsite in the country would allow you on site with a pair of them boots. We have like acidresistant rubbersoles, steeltoe, "step on nail protection", anti slip soles, it's like your stuck in the 70s or something. Who goes to work wearing what we use as autum shoes on a weekend. i understand the concept of like factory worker or something using this in america, but here. whenever u start work where u can't have your day to day shoes. u get like workshoes like i described earlier. For free from your employer. that is suited for the work your going to do. like a new pair each year. This is so strange to me...
Yeah, we don't want that nanny state bs. That's why construction costs 3x more and takes 2x longer over there. You need to pay 3 losers to stand around with clipboards. Btw, we have resistant soles, nail protection, steel toes, and all the same stuff. Not everyone on a construction site needs uncomfortable steel toe boots. Not every contractor is hanging iron.
Portugal is the same , once i forget their steel boots in home , they lent some steel caps with elastic to put on the tip of the sneakers, i drive only pallet bikes in the warehouse back there .
@@littlejackalo5326 Yep, no nanny state, no health insurance, and cardboard houses which fold over when it's a bit windy! Good for you guys!
Good stuff guys!! I'm not sure if you already do this but I think using a hydraulic press with a gauge to test composite/steel toe strength would be a great way to add to your testing procedures.
I own 2 pairs of Cats, one of them re-soled, the oldest one is over 10 years old... they've kept my feet very safe, they get pretty comfortable with time, they are warm enough for non freezing temperatures and not hot at all in the summer, I'd totally recommend them even for the same price as the Timby, unless you really need a totally waterproof boot! Cats are splash proof and you won't get wet if you submerge your foot in a puddle for a few seconds, actually I've worked in very wet places and never got a drop of water in my socks wearing them.
Carhartt is honestly overpriced and trash nowadays.
Both are junk
I did just over a years work in the cat boots. My failures were:
leather split almost immediately at the edge of the steel toe on one side.
Insole crumbled. At first it seemed like it was molding to my foot better, but soon there wasn't much padding left so I had to replace it.
Waterproofing didn't last. Within a few months both boots leaked along the welt near the arch, even in wet grass.
Leather began to crack at the toe crease. I work in lots of dry dirt and dust and squat and kneel a large portion of the day so that was probably inevitable.
Welt began to crack. The storm welt piping especially but the rest of it is starting to go.
That's not to say I didn't like them, they're still my daily wear shoes now that they've been replaced at work. Super comfortable now and the leather still takes a shine pretty well. Sole wore well too.
We're they Caterpillar second shift? Or another model?
@@yuridaman Yeah second shift. It was the same configuration as these ones.
Great job guys,,, and Hairless Kitty,,,, I’m owned both,, for work,,, and always have gone back to the Timberland’s…. They last longer, more comfortable, and are waterproof…. 🙃
I love both your channels this was really interesting. And I also love the cat! Can’t get enough of the cat
My first pair of caterpillar steel-toe boots is 10 years old now and still in good shape. I can highly recommend them and bought a second pair.
Got to get the Timberland mock toe PRO for Moctober!
I own this model of timberlands, and I can report they are extremely comfortable. I have worn them every single day, for 12+ hours a day, walking in them 5+ miles a day, in rain, shine, rugged terrain, nice floors, and everything inbetween. They have been my daily driver for 10 months, and I felt no fatigue with them after an 18 hour shift (granted I use a custom insole). The only problem is that the stitching on the outside is starting to wear out and open up, and the outsole is completely destroyed, with many crevasses that leave the foam exposed. The insulation does not pose a problem to florida heat in my experience.
If you want a cost effective work boot, I highly recommend the timberlands. Local shoe stores and repair shops might have a pair they are willing to negotiate the price on, I got mine for 120 ;)