Yea, and then to top it off, as you are arguing with him, a second nuclear blast occurs out the window. If anything is a “I told you so” moment to the boss, that would be it! Boss: 😳
It's crazy to see the shadows on the walls and concrete. Just to think - those people did not even know they died. One moment they were jumping rope, the next they are a shadow that will live on in our memories even 77 years later. To be honest, that is probably the best way to go.
Growing up through the cold war and the drills I often asked my self what I would do if I realized what was about to happen just before that moment. I have lived that moment many times in my mind, but obviously nothing compared to the real thing. Forward to 2023 and the current state of the world, I again relive the different moments in my mind. The strange thing is that I am not afraid of it any more.
@@axle.australian.patriot I turned 70 last month and was terrified through most of my childhood that there was going to be a nuclear war bringing all my childhood fears true. Like you I am no longer afraid of death, just in the manner that it may come. I found my father dead in his bed one morning, he was late for breakfast so I went to get him up. He just looked a little surprised. He had heart problem but made it to 78. I want to go like that, with that look of surprise as if to say "Oh it's time is it."
@@duster. I made my peace with death a long time ago. Not scared of it, but I don't go looking for it either lol At 57 I hope to have some years with my grand youngens first :) Can only hope we go in our sleep. For the nuc idea I hope I have enough time to face it and smile as my last human gesture :) > Walking down a street with my skin peeling off is not very inviting, I'll take the bright light thanks. > Reality is though, I'm out of range of any target sites, so I would be one of those dealing with the radiation aftermath of a MAD event. I was living in Alice Springs for a time, but Pine gap is far enough away to be out of the strike zone. A few other places were a bit iffy, but OK for now.
Japan officially recognizes two dual survivors but there were at least six people that are known survived both bombings and almost one hundred "affected" by both bombings. Survivors were ostracized and shunned, particularly women, so they were not inclined to come forward. There is still a great stigma in Japan regarding this.
10:04 This story is really incredible, what are the chances of surviving two nuclear explosions, surely very low and he lived to a very old age despite everything
@@KazooieX1 such bad luck tho.. man lucky he survived but imagine you get hit with a bomb so you go back to your home town to get away from the destruction... and then soon as you get there they hit THAT place with a bomb too and you get bombed TWICE. thats rough!
Well not really most modern nukes have multiple smaller warheads that split to cover a bigger area but those small warheads aren't much more powerful than these old ww2 nukes
@@terskataneli6457 not necessarily. Now a days we have things like the H-bomb and the tsar bomb. The capabilities to kill countless lives through means of single use warheads has only gotten bigger and bigger.
The bomb was also detonated 2,000 ft above the ground. This reduced the nuclear fall out but increased the lethality of the bomb over a wider area. Ground zero was just directly under the bomb.
Had they hit ground, these places would be nuclear wastelands. How much damage would be caused by exploding the bombs above ground was not entirely clear. Also consider had japan been more successful with their fu go balloon attacks, more would have died initially from incendiary bombs and later from plague and other pathogens. Japan was actively trying and planning to kill American citizens. It's shameful most Americans don't know this happened. Japans bioweapon and human vivisection experiments in China are also woefully under reported.
I remember watching another documentary on this and there was a similar story of two girls at a bank. I can't remember why they were there, but one of the girls who survived said that suddenly she was thrown into the walls and ceiling of the bank. When she came to, it was absolute disaster. She worked quickly to find her friend which she eventually did. Her friend, at the time, was still alive. She helped her up and they went outside but collapsed. Neither of them knew that her friend's back was broken. They sat outside waiting for help but her friend died from her injuries before the girl's father found them. There were other stories in this documentary, but I will mention one more that still haunts me. There was a family on the outskirts/outside of the city and the woman had just sat down at the table for breakfast with her husband, son, and daughter. Suddenly everything was gone. She woke up to see her house a pile of rubble and no matter how hard she searched, she could not find her husband and son. She found her daughter, but her daughter was trapped under beams and rubble. She frantically tried to get her daughter out as a fire started and began spreading. But no matter how desperate she was, she could not get her daughter out. She had to watch her daughter burn alive, screaming that it hurt and for mommy to save her. It was just horrific listening to this story.
@ellerj641 - Jesus Christ that's horrible. I couldn't imagine having to watch my Daughter burn in front of me like that. Crying out for me "to save her" because "it hurts". War is hell - Few create it - All suffer it.
I saw that documentary, too. I wish I remembered the name of it for you. I remember one lady said they had gotten flyers dropped on them that a bomb would be dropped the next day, but it never happened. The day after that is when the bomb dropped.
i have read extensively about the nuclear bombing and while you hint at it, the real damage in the moment of detonation was the heat, which as you point out burned people out of existence in microseconds. in one report, a box with a nail hole, 12 miles distant, acted as a lense and burned a hole in the far side of the wooden box, which speaks to the heat of the radiant energy. also, what saved so many, was that the ground was hilly, breaking up the blast wave. to the radiation, i'm not sure how long that is going to last. in war, people suffer . i had once a jacket i wore during my active duty time that said war is not healthy for children or other living things. truth is, we know more about killing than we do about living in peace. pax
My father was a B-29 crew member on Tinian. Had the bombs not been dropped, he would have had to take part in the invasion of Japan. Those who criticise the bombings today have the luxury of hindsight that those at the time did not have.
The bombs are justified. Japan started it in the most treacherous way possible, the US ended it. It shows how much Japan's leadership at the time cared about its citizens. And let's not forget the atrocities committed by Japan during the war. Japan was not the victim here.
@@Mutrinowell the Japanese were willing to surrender before the bombs dropped with the one condition that they could keep their emperor, which the US accepted anyway after the bombs dropped. So no the bombings weren't justified.
I'm not even Japanese and hearing the horrors that continued to happen because of that war still brings a tear to my eye. To think people still mess with nuclear booms now is scary.
@@AdamosDad no arming Hitler in the name of business, no genocide of any kind. Incredibly, that business has been booming since then. No greed, no wars; but sadly, no wisdom
If something like this were ever to happen to me I would want to be as close to it as it is possible to get - like right underneath it. I would not want there to be enough time for my brain to register what was happening.
True, but the atomic bombs were indeed the lesser evil. Part of the calculation was to apply the horrendous civilian casualties of taking Okinawa across the whole of Japan if a full scale invasion was needed, where primarily the Japanese troops forced civilians into attacks or high risk jobs, even high school girls and young boys, The Japanese troops also encouraged family suicides when it looked like the US would win, with Japanese Americans interpreters using loudspeakers to try to talk mothers holding babies and toddlers from jumping off cliffs, but many did so if the US troops couldn’t reach them (and there is film evidence of this and its aftermath). There is an interview from a woman whose family was given a grenade by their own troops to kill themselves, being told they would be tortured to death by American troops if caught, but she survived with shrapnel wounds. The first US troops gave her some bandages and water and pantomimed they had to move on, then the second took her to field hospital for treatment and fed her….which shocked her after the extreme war rations. But the treatment only made her realize her parents and sibling died for nothing. There also would have been many civilian deaths from starvation had the war dragged on, and it took millions of US food aid to prevent further famine in Japan at the end of the war…..which would not have been there had the Japanese government still been in power.
@@Itried20takennamesNo one asked about all of that it doesn’t change the fact that dropping an atomic bomb on an entire city filled with innocent people is horrific
@@Itried20takennames Would you be willing to sacrifice yourself and your family to possibly prevent further atrocities? I don't have any opinion of if this truly was needed or not, as I have not educated myself on the reasons why this happened. I am simply putting myself in the shoes of the hundreds of thousands of innocent civilian victims.
@@twistedbliss58 kind of like how the Japanese killed over twice the amount of people who died in BOTH nuclear bombs combined, in Nanking alone, by singular hands...all innocent civilians.
I cant imagine what it wouldve been like to live through those nukes, or hell, the 20's to the 50's in general. Talk about some massive butterfly effect RNG on whether you lived or died. Ive got massive respect and appreciation to everyone of all countries in that era.
Remember they attack the US we were gonna get slapped and do nothing. Not only that weeks before we nuked the city’s we dropped flyers telling citizens to leave cause we’re gonna drop a bomb and they didn’t believe it.
@@REVNUMANEWBERN Imperial Japan did have plans to and carried out bombing the US. See the FU Go Balloon bombs. Americans are lied to by ommission, and very smug in their ignorance.
These sorts of vids really make me wonder if it's better to be at ground zero, where you become a shadow etched on a wall somewhere (if you're lucky to be remembered), or 'survive' and be in lingering pain for the rest of your life. Everytime I come to a decision I hear something that makes me change my mind. The cheek of calling a weapon 'Little Boy.'
Both cities would have been nuclear wastelands had the bombs not detonated far above ground. And the fact that more Americans do not know about Japans plans and attempted bombings of the US is shameful. fu go balloon bombs had little success at first. Image had they been more successful later in spreading plague and other pathogens. Many people, esp US and Japanese citizens, need to ''change their mind''.
The creator of the classic Anime BAREFOOT GEN depicts on the first OVA what he experienced when the Hiroshima bomb was dropped as he was one of the few survivors. The character of Barefoot Gen is basically him (the creator/author/director) showing what he described in actual interviews, essentially what he saw. It was horrendous but very detailed.
My dad was at both Nagasaki , and Hiroshima - he was also at the Marshall Islands tests , and cancer nearly killed him about 25 years later . Mum and the country , got dusted by the Btritish tests in South Australia , at Maralinga - her cancer was held at bay until about 15 years later , as hubby #2 , refused to allow her to do bher daily intake of an onion - this had started when she started to gestate myself . Those bombs are still killing people , as i also have cancer . There wont be another generation , for the abouve and other reasons , due to hatered of those who seek truth .
my Grandfather witnessed one of the bombs. 4/7 of his children had issues with cognitive functions or tumors. My mother was one of them that had a tumor form on her pituitary gland. Theory is that her father was affected by the bomb.
Our ancestors would never have believed what horror humans could unleash upon other humans. I ponder the future, somewhere there might be a tipping point of rationality.
Also, only a fraction of the warheads' payloads have contributed to the nuclear reaction. The bombs blew the material apart before the reaction took place fully.
Presumably for your situation, I've learned that people like you ignorant of any time of long-term pain suffering; having not experience a traumatic situation, can never truly understand the burden of primal fear and of any type. Why its conventional and easy for people like this to make callous, ignorant and unintelligent remarks pertaining to any person's or other life's plight of a peril-suffering experiences. So, I hope you don't get your wish in wanting to know it. I've had cancer twice and being around a lot of people living in a loge with tumors and a really nice man whose cancer is terminal made me truly have a lot of respect for life, be it human or any other living being as well as loving this planet and caring for anyone who has experienced a disease, or trauma-took a lot for me to talk about my cancer, and even bringing it up. It was a lot and words fail on how tormenting the treats where for a couple of years. As well as the bills and my and parents' emotions and trying to kill the disease. So be careful of your words and I've seen enough karma educed on people. I'm not religious but spiritual and respect the cosmos and what force people keep presuming to know in religion where. War is wrong no matter what side started it because people end up suffering and human beings have been at war since the stone age. I realized we are creatures of habits, good or evil. Evil is real and watching a lot of SICK videos of Physico paths, pedo and serial killers, be it eight-year-olds or adults, people our species can be so abnormally cruel and mentally ill and just gone. I hate watching these videos but knowing can always give you a window others reality in order to connect and better understand ourselves and those around us. Humans are meant to connect. That's the best of us where clearly, a lot of people, including yourself have yet to truly know how too and can say nature though cruel is a hell of an amazing, unfiltered teacher since human laws are not as true and just. We twist morality and logic and I'm a very prude person. My pride. Sorry for what typos I have but its best to be careful how you look down the plight of others in documentaries of this nature. Ignorance's and comical quotes you typed are not your ally. Grow up and learn to be a better person for yourself not become a part of the problem.
It's been pointed out that (at least until the atomic bomb) that humanity never developed a weapon that they didn't end up using. Even if we hadn't used the atomic bomb then, there would have been a proliferation of them later on anyway. Hiroshima and Nagasaki gave us very graphic and terrifying examples of how terrible nuclear weapons are. Consider then a war breaking out 10, 15 or 20 years later, where multiple opposing or hostile countries will have stockpiled their nuclear arsenals *without* understanding the horrors they would bring. Quite likely the planet would be a smouldering ruin now. We need to solemnly respect and remember the victims of these two cities.
The bigger lesson is that people who are supportive or even just complicit with the actions of their government are just as responsible for those actions as the few in charge pushing for war. Not to be uncaring for the mass suffering, but many, if not most rallied behind the Japanese emperor's decision to conquer China. Most were angry and belligerent towards the US in that it was actively helping the Chinese people protect their nation. Unlike ancient war when armies met on remote battle fields, modern war is hell. It takes the lives of women and children because the industry of war makes it's home in the population centers. If you are a worker in that industry, part of the price for your job is being a target in modern warfare. Not to mention that if you work in that industry, you are NOT truly innocent.
@@3DPDK You sound like you are using the argument "people who are supportive or even just complicit with the actions of their government are just as responsible for those actions as the few in charge pushing for war" as an excuse to support your/a government's actions. If so that would be pretty ironic.
@@bencarpendale I "sound like" I believe the people of a nation are ultimately responsible for the actions of their government and leaders. In the war between Japan and the US, there were Japanese that believed committing tactical suicide for the emperor's cause was an honorable thing. They were THAT MUCH in support of the actions of their leaders. If your government is doing something you disagree with morally, you are honor bound to what ever source you get your moral views to stand against it.
@@3DPDK Again, "I believe the people of a nation are ultimately responsible for the actions of their government and leaders" sounds like a general description of all peoples but you then talk solely about Japanese people being to blame for Japan's actions but not the Americans being to blame for the US's actions. I just find that strange, especially considering the nature of this video.
I feel so sorry for following generations that had to suffer. The hope that we are just here temporarily in this valley of tears makes existence meaningful. God is great, wish all humans to follow on His steps.
The world would be completely different had America and her Allies lost the war, but it is sad that a countries people usually suffer from the decisions of their leaders.
@@darlenelang3681 Japan's attempts at killing innocent town folks wasn't from lack of trying. They did manage to kill a few on American soil. Research the fu go balloon bombing. Plans were also made to spread plague and other pathogens in America and may have been successful if the war carried on. Japan's attempts at colonizing China, Korea and other parts of Asia led to vast amounts of towns folk getting raped, murdered and even used in horrific vivisection experiments. These people did nothing wrong but live in their countries.
@@tima.478🖨🕋⚀️🕋 SPACE FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY 72 404 ERRORS, NOT FOUND, SUPANOVA EXPLOSION 💥 IS NOW OPEN 🔓 BUT STILL NO ACTION FOR ME FROM DIGITAL PRINTING PLEASE SEND THIS POST BACK TO THE ADDRESS YOU CAN COLLECT IN YOUR EYES 👀 THE NEXT DAY YOU SHOULD DO ITS CLASS OF RA WHEN IT HAPPENS. YOU MAY HAVE TO GO DOWN AND ALL YOUR STUFF IS NOT FOUND ON MY END 🔚, WHICH IS WHY I'M NOT FOUND ON MY PHONE 📱 3
It's amazing how those things happen so long ago and so many people know about it and they still are working toward provoking another war just like that nuclear war that will melt people Like butter it's just sad that we don't have a world already filled up with bees and love I wanted to just treat each other with kindness
Vaporized within a certain distance. Only left a shadow on the wall that survived. Severely burned after that or radiation poisoning, days or month to survive.
NAZI GERMANY AND NAZI OCCUPIED EUROPE WAS ALLOWED TO SURRENDER WITHOUT BEING NUKED. AND THE WORLD IS STILL AT WAR. THE NUCLEAR BOMBING OF HIROSHIMI AND NAGAZAKI IS STILL A CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY.
@@brys5488 Believe it or not, it's actually relatively peaceful, compared to human history where constant wars and conflict were the norm. And just look at the cold war, it was cold because either side feared the unstoppable nuclear weapons that were quickly becoming more powerful. The ones that hit Japan were tiny compared to what was quickly being developed by USA and Soviets after WW2.
Thank you for posting, all the graphics and the cartoon characters tell the story. I would’ve preferred more pictures of people in their suffering stages and collateral damage. A lot more graphic pictures would better convey the brutality these two atomic bombs impact on mankind. If we don’t remember what happened most likely history will repeat itself. I feel the same way about the concentration camps of the second world war, the graphic pictures make a bigger impact and a soft presentation of cartoon characters. Most people don’t have the imagination to see how cruel war can be. Cannot take life for granted or think that this will never happen to us.
I have it on good authority, it WILL happen at least once more time in human history. The description of it was written roughly 2500 years ago, but the description could easily be about the human affects of the bomb on Hiroshima. This prophecy is about a specific ancient city in the Middle East.
nagasaki was bombed only because the original target for the second bomb was under cloud cover and the target point could not be located....the city to be bombed second was to be kokura.
The sad reality is that Japan was all but finished by July 1945, her navy obliterated and her airpower severely compromised. As an island nation, Japan was dependent upon import for petroleum and so many other resources. By August 1, 1945, they were isolated from the rest of the world and were doomed to lose the war. Given these circumstances, there would never have been a strategic need to invade Japan and put at risk the lives of a million allied troops or millions of Japanese civilians. There was also no need to drop the A-bombs either. These were meant as a demonstration of American military superiority in order to circumscribe Stalin's post-war land-grab ambitions. What a tragic passage in World History!
That is a theory that later generations like to subscribe to. The reality is that the people of Japan at that time were told never to surrender and there is no fate worse than being taken captive by the allied forces, whole families were committing suicide. Japan was and still is a resource starved island, most agree that they would not stop their original doctrine. No one liked the idea, but after millions of people had already died in the war, they needed to put an end to the potential millions more being killed. The only things that are certain, are the things that happened, not what could have happened.
@@Brutalgruve While it is true that the Japanese people were told never to surrender and being captured was a fate worse than death, seeing that they were land-bound on their own island-prison, exactly what would have been their strategy had we simply blockaded and used attrition as the weapon of choice? Professional historians are not simply content to study the things that actually happened. We also study the options available to the leaders of the time and the rationale for their choices, providing us with key insights into the mindsets of those same leaders. Speculative analysis provides valuable thought experiments that can yield equally important information from decisions not taken.
@@alexandergroppe448 I stated my point, and then you stated yours, again, it is clear you missed my point Blockade? Go back though history, before WW2 and after, where has that tactic ever worked? You can create generations of oppression and radicalize the half informed. I am moving on; you get a free last word.
That dude is hardcore, I've called off sick for a headache lol. Also, IDC what their justifications were, it was evil to drop weapons like that on civilians, and it's evil to still have those weapons and continue to threaten to use them today.
just remember that prior to the 2 bombs going off, America had been firebombing the cities of Japan for at least 4 or 5 months using napalm and incendiary rounds. It was only due to the Japanese resiliance and the fact that the Amercians wanted to "try out" their new bombs that the two cities were targeted. In a way it's fortunate that only ~1M lives were effected physcially from the blasts, as just as it was stated in the vid, had a drawn out war happened millions more could have been effected on both sides.
You're literally trying to rewrite history. Japan was given the chance to surrender prior to the bombs being dropped. They refused. They refused to surrender even after the first bomb was dropped in Hiroshima. The Japanese government just sat while its people suffered. Thank whatever powers be that the demon core was never dropped on Japan. Because the third bomb that was planned made the first 2 look like kittens. And let's not negate that the US had stayed out of this war until Japan attacked Pearl Harbour and slaughtered 2,403 innocent people. I'm not condoning what wa done to Japan or to the Japanese people who lived in the US. But let's not rewrite history like the US was just having a pissing contest with the world
@@ximar0ckstrx So everything that I mentioned was factual albeit I didn't mention the 3rd bomb. Did the fire strikes happen. Yes. Did the Japanese government continue because they thought they were resilient enough. Yes. (however futile it must have been. FYI they didn't surrender at that point as this was like running away and be seen as dishonourable and shaming ones honour is the biggest no-no even in modern day Japan, which you can be sued for.) Just because you add more information on top of what was already provided doesn't mean the original statement was false.
Sadly, some Japanese stigmatized those visibly burned or injured in the atomic bomb attacks, or even just there….with some rejecting them as marriage partners due to largely exaggerated fears of infertility or birth defects, and some employers refusing to hire them, believing they were bad for morale and were a reminder of defeat customers would avoid.
It's sad that this happened, and i have mixed feelings as I have relatives on four sides of this issue. So first my Mom is Korean, and at the time of the bombing, the Japanese oppressed koeea as a colony and treated Korean people like shit. So I don't see japanese as innocent as everyone else does, because they treated the people they invaded like they were wirse than feces. On another hand my great grand uncle, to be able to secure a future for his family left Korea and became a Japanese citizen, so he's a zainichi, and they were treated very badly, and had to hide their Korean origin during that time, but at the same time, they were terrified when the bombs dropped, even from Tokyo where they lived, so they fles to thier home in Kyoto, i learned this from my Aunty. But as a person of native Hawaiian ancestry, I feel aa if the USA didnt drop those bombs there would have been no stopping the Japanese from taking over Hawai'i and I don't know how they would have treated those of us who are indigenous to Hawai'i. The USA has only caused harm to our home, and treated us as if we don't matter, turning our homeland into an ecological disaster, but i don't know if the Japanese would have done any better. Nut as a Black American don't feel either way. As human life was lost, and its sad, but so many more would have been lost if the USA would have chosen a different route. I have all these mixed feelings, and perspectives as someone who is mixed or has connections to these different cultures. I just wish that the powers that be of today would get rid of these weapons! They don't just destroy, they poison the land and make it uninhabitable for centuries!
US' record on Hawai'i is shitty. From a European perspective I'm glad USA ultimately stepped in an defeated fascism on both sides of the globe. No one else could have done it and the bombs on Japan were justified. The imperial army butchered its way across China and SE Asia, leaving 12m people dead. Many of whom were women and forced labor. Most of them killed with shovels and bayonets. Losing on every front in the summer of 1945 Jp was unwilling to surrender unconditionally, as Germany had to as well.
its not a matter of justification at all., conflict has little to do with justice just like shock & aww has little to do with being fair... this simply isn't a single answer question.,.. this is a set of events , not just a couple of baddabooms ... body count wasn't the only consideration.,. it was a no prisoners game to them unlike the germans... and At the end of the wars Japanese soldiers at prisoner of war camps were told to behead, stab or shoot the 100,000 or so remaining Allied prisoners the moment an invasion began, they also told civilians to commit suicide, which many did..
The shadows don't mean that all of the atoms of a human disintegrated and sticked to the stone in the background. Some of the atoms did it but human bodies were left mainly whole after the blast, ofcourse in a horrible condition.
I wouldn't be so sure. Look at some of the military tests: You can see the steel ropes that hold the bomb in place being vaporized in a tiny fraction of a second, from the extreme burst of gamma radiation. Even metal basically just turns into gas/plasma at the center of the explosion. Edit: Though I would add that at that distance, there probably wouldn't be a wall left either, so the "shadows" were likely all further away.
stories from my late father about how Japanese soldiers treated people during its occupation .. hear enough of those stories and then you decide whether or not it was justified to throw out those 2 bombs .. all these were ancient histories .. I am 100% not judging .. water flowed under the bridge .. but .. what my father saw when he was much younger during that time crushed my bone ..
Concerning the question possessed by the author of this video, would fewer people perished had the atomic bomb not be used in the closing chapter of WW2? An answer to this question will always be, at best, speculative. Remember, the times were quite different from today. Most people is this generation were tired of this terrible global war. I remembered so well how my parents who were of European descent never wanted to speak of this time as they had witness so much pain and suffering back then. In defense of my parent's and their generation, I don't think most people back then really knew just how destructive this bomb really was and all the horrible side effective as we now know so well today. Maybe, the better question here should be; have we grown any wiser never to use this terrible weapon again on humanity? Deep in my heart, I truly hope so!
I have heard arguments from both sides. I do know this: if Truman had not given the authority to drop the two bombs and the Allies did invade the home islands of Japan, the survivors families in the US would have had Truman hauled out of office on a rail. We have to remember we were at war. In the Command structure there are two facts: #1; in war, people die. And fact #2; command cannot change rule #1.
Let’s not forget the atrocities that Japan had committed during WW2. Japanese were ruthless to the Koreans and the Chinese. Does it make right no but that’s war , where the generals that start it are safe but the soldiers and civilians pay the price.
That this serves as a harsh lesson to prevent humanity from ever dropping these bombs again. I feel for the scores of innocent people (and all other creatures) that lost their lives, may they rest in peace. 😞
@@vhamusanda No nuclear bombs but plenty of incendiary balloon bombs aimed at America. Had the war gone on, bioweapons spreading plague would have been used as well. Japan was ruthless and did not care if they murdered civilians for their benefit.
Millions fewer died because of the two atomic bombs which were dropped on Japan because Japan started a war against a nation with the resources and capabilities to end a war that they didn't start in the first place. My own aunt by marriage was a Nagasaki survivor. Her family never blamed the United States for resorting to the atomic bombings.
When one was much more than “warranted,” but further (LIVE!) experimentation was desired, a second bomb was dropped… A third bomb (named??) was planned for bombardment, but was not used, saving further deaths of infants, children, teachers, grandparents and other non-combatants. Paul Tibbetts the completely remorseless and unapologetic American pilot who dropped the first bomb on Hiroshima, Japan, named his plane in honor of his mother. Can you imagine Mrs. Tibbetts, in the days, weeks, months and more following that ushering in of atomic warfare, proudly proclaiming, “That’s My Boy!!” as if he’d hit a home run to win a big…game…or found an actual cure (Not Cause!) for cancer . . . ?? Paul Tibbetts could’ve been pictured on a WHEATIES cold cereal box. He could have endorsed chewing gum, cigarettes, automobile tires, and even…life insurance. Cynical I am, but tiny children died of dehydration, their skin hanging as shredded sheets . . . I am alive, speaking… They are dead and without voice.
This atrocity alone only reinforces the need to ban atomic/nuclear weapons. Living in peace may be a lost cause to some, but we shouldn't stop trying. We all come from the same progenitor, regardless and should live in peace and harmony. 🙏🙏
That was sad... I wasn't even thought of at that time but still, Imagine though. Henious Crimes and Atrocities that got committed during that War were Mind Blowing and today our Government could do So Much Worse to another country if they really wanted too but still, I will not pretend that Japan was a Victim during that time nor will they ever be. They attacked Innocent Americans on American Soil as well as our Military and paid the price for it. The War Crimes Japan committed during WWII is unspeakable to this day. Regardless, it was still sad because Innocent People that had no part in that War still died because of the type of Leadership Japan had at the time...
The 3d animation is a bit eerie, the characters are often wearing weird clothes (like 13:09 the girl in Chinese dress), or the rooms are too modern, I know this is nitpick, but it feels weird for a video with this serious topic. Still a great video.
The question at the end of the video reminds me a lot of the trolley problem, you would rather kill a couple hundred thousand intentionally rather than be forced to kill millions
Can you call it a 'trolley problem', when US killed couple hundred thousand in Japan AND, later, killed millions in Eastern Europe, Asian and Middle-Eastern countries? ^_^
Kind of, but in this case, the majority of people who'd get killed during an invasion would be consenting to it. I mean, there's a difference between killing a soldier who wants to either attack you or defend his country, and killing a mother with her children.
@@anatolydyatlov963 If the Americans had invaded Japan, Japanese woman and children would have been mobilized. They were already being trained for it. An once Japan was defeated how many people do you think would have committed suicide?
@@samkramer7406 nobody said that madness but that attack was on the military not innocent people sitting in their homes and at work who had nothing to do with the at on Pearl Harbor.
My Grandpa fought in the Pacific. He was a Senior at West Point when Pearl was attacked. He saw literal Hell on earth. He escorted McAuthor. He retired a Brigadier General after the Cuban Missile Crisis. He avoided the topic of what he saw and did. But he made one thing clear. The bombs were a necessary evil that saved more lives then they took. He……made peace with the Japanese after the war. “The Japanese committed horrible war crimes and attacked Pearl Harbor. We dropped two nukes on them. As far as I am concerned we are even. I have made peace with them and have nothing but respect for the people and nation of Japan”. The only story he told me in detail was how a Japanese sniper killed a buddy of his by shooting him in the head thru a ships porthole (they were close to shore) when his friend was on the toilet. “I heard the shot, ran down, and kicked in the door. My friend was pretty bad at both ends. Based on what I saw on the toilet, that (Japanese) sniper may of done him a favor”. Told me it when I was 11ish after I took to long in the bathroom. I figured out Grandpas war trauma was bathroom windows. His customer house had no bathroom windows (or so glazed over they may as well been solid walls). When he visited us he would only used the downstairs windowless bathroom. Dad confirmed this was true, but told me to NOT say anything about it. I have told the full “The Shit and the Sniper” story to a few home owners and Air B&B people who have windows over/near the toilet. Most get all bug eyed:😳. Yep. My Grandpas buddy RIP. May Grandpa RIP. Buried at West Point with full honors. I just wish he told me more stories. But apparently remembering what he experienced was very painful for him 😞.
The U.S. knew the Japanese were going to attack at Pearl Harbor and they let the attacks happen so the U.S. could enter WWII for geopolitical reasons. There is no fucking way that Pearl Harbor can compare with the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Truman and the people who worked on the bombs like Einstein and Oppenheimer were war criminals.
The nuclear shadows really creep me out for some reason…I don’t know why. Maybe it the extreme conditions required for the phenomenon to occur. I see dropping the bombs on Japan in WWII as a necessary evil. The lives lost if the war had continued would have greatly outnumbered those that were killed by the two nuclear bombs.
Seriously? The most appropriate 3D model you could find for use in a story about Hiroshima is a waifu with a miniskirt the size of a belt? Jeeze Louise these AI generated CZcams channels are getting obscene.
Can you imagine surviving a nuclear attack, go into work, just to have you boss to call you a liar!
Yea, and then to top it off, as you are arguing with him, a second nuclear blast occurs out the window.
If anything is a “I told you so” moment to the boss, that would be it!
Boss: 😳
Me: "Im gonna go to sleep at 2 AM"
CZcams: "What Happened to The bodies after the hiroshima bomb exploded"
It's crazy to see the shadows on the walls and concrete. Just to think - those people did not even know they died. One moment they were jumping rope, the next they are a shadow that will live on in our memories even 77 years later. To be honest, that is probably the best way to go.
My thoughts exactly.
I remember something like that at Sea World when I was a kid.
Growing up through the cold war and the drills I often asked my self what I would do if I realized what was about to happen just before that moment. I have lived that moment many times in my mind, but obviously nothing compared to the real thing. Forward to 2023 and the current state of the world, I again relive the different moments in my mind. The strange thing is that I am not afraid of it any more.
@@axle.australian.patriot I turned 70 last month and was terrified through most of my childhood that there was going to be a nuclear war bringing all my childhood fears true. Like you I am no longer afraid of death, just in the manner that it may come. I found my father dead in his bed one morning, he was late for breakfast so I went to get him up. He just looked a little surprised. He had heart problem but made it to 78. I want to go like that, with that look of surprise as if to say "Oh it's time is it."
@@duster. I made my peace with death a long time ago. Not scared of it, but I don't go looking for it either lol
At 57 I hope to have some years with my grand youngens first :)
Can only hope we go in our sleep. For the nuc idea I hope I have enough time to face it and smile as my last human gesture :)
>
Walking down a street with my skin peeling off is not very inviting, I'll take the bright light thanks.
>
Reality is though, I'm out of range of any target sites, so I would be one of those dealing with the radiation aftermath of a MAD event.
I was living in Alice Springs for a time, but Pine gap is far enough away to be out of the strike zone. A few other places were a bit iffy, but OK for now.
Yamaguchi must be the only person who had two nuclear bombs dropped on them. Plus he survived both. Amazing.
Japan officially recognizes two dual survivors but there were at least six people that are known survived both bombings and almost one hundred "affected" by both bombings. Survivors were ostracized and shunned, particularly women, so they were not inclined to come forward. There is still a great stigma in Japan regarding this.
I would rather die immediately without even knowing than to survive this
10:04 This story is really incredible, what are the chances of surviving two nuclear explosions, surely very low and he lived to a very old age despite everything
Probably the only immediate witness of both we know of, poor man.
Tsutomu Yamaguchi he's the only person to have survived both atomic bombs.
@@KazooieX1 such bad luck tho.. man lucky he survived but imagine you get hit with a bomb so you go back to your home town to get away from the destruction... and then soon as you get there they hit THAT place with a bomb too and you get bombed TWICE. thats rough!
Incorrect. There were 165 documented nijū hibakusha, or survivors of both detonations.@@KazooieX1
These bombs are quite weak compared to modern nuclear weapons
Smh 😲
That's terrifying to think about. I pray that we never use nucs again or our civilization is over.
Well not really most modern nukes have multiple smaller warheads that split to cover a bigger area but those small warheads aren't much more powerful than these old ww2 nukes
@@terskataneli6457 not necessarily. Now a days we have things like the H-bomb and the tsar bomb. The capabilities to kill countless lives through means of single use warheads has only gotten bigger and bigger.
No shit Sherlock
The bomb was also detonated 2,000 ft above the ground. This reduced the nuclear fall out but increased the lethality of the bomb over a wider area. Ground zero was just directly under the bomb.
Had they hit ground, these places would be nuclear wastelands. How much damage would be caused by exploding the bombs above ground was not entirely clear.
Also consider had japan been more successful with their fu go balloon attacks, more would have died initially from incendiary bombs and later from plague and other pathogens. Japan was actively trying and planning to kill American citizens. It's shameful most Americans don't know this happened.
Japans bioweapon and human vivisection experiments in China are also woefully under reported.
Could you imagine a bomb being g dropped onto a city that you just entered and when you get home you see another blast out of nowhere?
ever heard palestine? its happening now take a look
I remember watching another documentary on this and there was a similar story of two girls at a bank. I can't remember why they were there, but one of the girls who survived said that suddenly she was thrown into the walls and ceiling of the bank. When she came to, it was absolute disaster. She worked quickly to find her friend which she eventually did. Her friend, at the time, was still alive. She helped her up and they went outside but collapsed. Neither of them knew that her friend's back was broken. They sat outside waiting for help but her friend died from her injuries before the girl's father found them.
There were other stories in this documentary, but I will mention one more that still haunts me. There was a family on the outskirts/outside of the city and the woman had just sat down at the table for breakfast with her husband, son, and daughter. Suddenly everything was gone. She woke up to see her house a pile of rubble and no matter how hard she searched, she could not find her husband and son. She found her daughter, but her daughter was trapped under beams and rubble. She frantically tried to get her daughter out as a fire started and began spreading. But no matter how desperate she was, she could not get her daughter out. She had to watch her daughter burn alive, screaming that it hurt and for mommy to save her. It was just horrific listening to this story.
@ellerj641 - Jesus Christ that's horrible. I couldn't imagine having to watch my Daughter burn in front of me like that. Crying out for me "to save her" because "it hurts". War is hell - Few create it - All suffer it.
I saw that documentary, too. I wish I remembered the name of it for you. I remember one lady said they had gotten flyers dropped on them that a bomb would be dropped the next day, but it never happened. The day after that is when the bomb dropped.
i have read extensively about the nuclear bombing and while you hint at it, the real damage in the moment of detonation was the heat, which as you point out burned people out of existence in microseconds. in one report, a box with a nail hole, 12 miles distant, acted as a lense and burned a hole in the far side of the wooden box, which speaks to the heat of the radiant energy.
also, what saved so many, was that the ground was hilly, breaking up the blast wave.
to the radiation, i'm not sure how long that is going to last. in war, people suffer . i had once a jacket i wore during my active duty time that said war is not healthy for children or other living things. truth is, we know more about killing than we do about living in peace.
pax
Let's hope that it's never repeated.
My father was a B-29 crew member on Tinian. Had the bombs not been dropped, he would have had to take part in the invasion of Japan. Those who criticise the bombings today have the luxury of hindsight that those at the time did not have.
The bombs are justified. Japan started it in the most treacherous way possible, the US ended it. It shows how much Japan's leadership at the time cared about its citizens. And let's not forget the atrocities committed by Japan during the war. Japan was not the victim here.
if any other military had harnessed the bomb besides the US, the world as we know it would be gone gone.
@@Mutrino Everyone, including them, know that very well. That is why Japan is a great ally today.
@@Mutrinonukes arnt justified. Ever. Thousands upon thousands of innocents were needlessly slaughtered. For. No. Reason.
@@Mutrinowell the Japanese were willing to surrender before the bombs dropped with the one condition that they could keep their emperor, which the US accepted anyway after the bombs dropped. So no the bombings weren't justified.
I'm not even Japanese and hearing the horrors that continued to happen because of that war still brings a tear to my eye. To think people still mess with nuclear booms now is scary.
back in the day the Japs were very nasty people towards westerners......
Russia, North Korea, China, the USA and more: No one is willing to put down their swords because of an ideology.
@@scott7937 a hole.
@@scott7937
Is that idiotic response to the OP's genuine comment of concern meant to be humorous?
yes@@skateboardingjesus4006
I will never stop this visceral feeling of deep sadness when I hear of events like this, even after hearing of them many times over.
Same 😢😢
If this bumbs you out, you should check out what they did to Nanjing.
No Pearl Harbor, no Hiroshima, no Nagasaki.
@@AdamosDad no humanity
@@AdamosDad no arming Hitler in the name of business, no genocide of any kind. Incredibly, that business has been booming since then. No greed, no wars; but sadly, no wisdom
Going to work after your city has been destroyed by a bomb is wild af
Boss: Why are you late for work?! Worker: Sorry sir, I was nuked... Boss: A likely excuse! Don't let it happen again! Get to work!!
Then happens again.
If something like this were ever to happen to me I would want to be as close to it as it is possible to get - like right underneath it. I would not want there to be enough time for my brain to register what was happening.
The things that human beings can and will do to their fellow human beings are abhorrent. I feel so sad watching things like this.
True, but the atomic bombs were indeed the lesser evil. Part of the calculation was to apply the horrendous civilian casualties of taking Okinawa across the whole of Japan if a full scale invasion was needed, where primarily the Japanese troops forced civilians into attacks or high risk jobs, even high school girls and young boys, The Japanese troops also encouraged family suicides when it looked like the US would win, with Japanese Americans interpreters using loudspeakers to try to talk mothers holding babies and toddlers from jumping off cliffs, but many did so if the US troops couldn’t reach them (and there is film evidence of this and its aftermath).
There is an interview from a woman whose family was given a grenade by their own troops to kill themselves, being told they would be tortured to death by American troops if caught, but she survived with shrapnel wounds. The first US troops gave her some bandages and water and pantomimed they had to move on, then the second took her to field hospital for treatment and fed her….which shocked her after the extreme war rations. But the treatment only made her realize her parents and sibling died for nothing.
There also would have been many civilian deaths from starvation had the war dragged on, and it took millions of US food aid to prevent further famine in Japan at the end of the war…..which would not have been there had the Japanese government still been in power.
@@Itried20takennamesNo one asked about all of that it doesn’t change the fact that dropping an atomic bomb on an entire city filled with innocent people is horrific
@@twistedbliss58 It's horrific, but it stopped the war. Japan did some horrific things too.
@@Itried20takennames Would you be willing to sacrifice yourself and your family to possibly prevent further atrocities? I don't have any opinion of if this truly was needed or not, as I have not educated myself on the reasons why this happened. I am simply putting myself in the shoes of the hundreds of thousands of innocent civilian victims.
@@twistedbliss58 kind of like how the Japanese killed over twice the amount of people who died in BOTH nuclear bombs combined, in Nanking alone, by singular hands...all innocent civilians.
Glad to see you on my youtube feed again, your vids havent popped up for like 6-8 weeks for me
@5:50 I like how the roar of a plane w/ 4 propeller engines is just a jet plane flying over.
You didn't answer question about the sake alcohol and radiation.
The thought of ones body just evaporating like water that scared me besides that very good video thank you for posting it.
I cant imagine what it wouldve been like to live through those nukes, or hell, the 20's to the 50's in general. Talk about some massive butterfly effect RNG on whether you lived or died. Ive got massive respect and appreciation to everyone of all countries in that era.
Remember they attack the US we were gonna get slapped and do nothing. Not only that weeks before we nuked the city’s we dropped flyers telling citizens to leave cause we’re gonna drop a bomb and they didn’t believe it.
And just think, it's NOT like the same or similar could be done to the U.S.
@@REVNUMANEWBERN Imperial Japan did have plans to and carried out bombing the US. See the FU Go Balloon bombs. Americans are lied to by ommission, and very smug in their ignorance.
Depends on context and who's writing the history.
@@REVNUMANEWBERNThat's nieve at best to assume.
These sorts of vids really make me wonder if it's better to be at ground zero, where you become a shadow etched on a wall somewhere (if you're lucky to be remembered), or 'survive' and be in lingering pain for the rest of your life. Everytime I come to a decision I hear something that makes me change my mind. The cheek of calling a weapon 'Little Boy.'
Great name though considering the bigger one was to come
Both cities would have been nuclear wastelands had the bombs not detonated far above ground. And the fact that more Americans do not know about Japans plans and attempted bombings of the US is shameful. fu go balloon bombs had little success at first. Image had they been more successful later in spreading plague and other pathogens. Many people, esp US and Japanese citizens, need to ''change their mind''.
I knew an American POW survivor of the Bataan Death March. I have zero empathy for the survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
The creator of the classic Anime BAREFOOT GEN depicts on the first OVA what he experienced when the Hiroshima bomb was dropped as he was one of the few survivors. The character of Barefoot Gen is basically him (the creator/author/director) showing what he described in actual interviews, essentially what he saw. It was horrendous but very detailed.
Humanity needs to respect its existence, before our addiction to crime, conflict and war, erases our very existence.
My dad was at both Nagasaki , and Hiroshima - he was also at the Marshall Islands tests , and cancer nearly killed him about 25 years later . Mum and the country , got dusted by the Btritish tests in South Australia , at Maralinga - her cancer was held at bay until about 15 years later , as hubby #2 , refused to allow her to do bher daily intake of an onion - this had started when she started to gestate myself .
Those bombs are still killing people , as i also have cancer . There wont be another generation , for the abouve and other reasons , due to hatered of those who seek truth .
Namaste dear one.
I'm so sorry. ❤
How was he at all three? He’s Japanese? How did he get to the last test?
Good tale but I’d love to know how he was at all 3 no Americans were in the Japanese cities and no Japanese were in the marshals
So sorry to hear he was at 1 or 10, a complete nightmare for anyone to go through, my heart breaks for every single person affected. ❤
my Grandfather witnessed one of the bombs. 4/7 of his children had issues with cognitive functions or tumors. My mother was one of them that had a tumor form on her pituitary gland. Theory is that her father was affected by the bomb.
I'm so sorry, that had happened to your family 😢
What is amazing is that my mother was able to have 2 daughters even with the tumor with some medication!@@sumperjump8353
Our ancestors would never have believed what horror humans could unleash upon other humans. I ponder the future, somewhere there might be a tipping point of rationality.
Kinda weird that a sexy anime babe shape was used to represent a victim suffering massive radiation exposure and burns.
I appreciate your hard work and dedication. Thank you.
This just shows how terrible humanity can be
Yup. Look up Unit 731. There's a reason why the Chinese hate Japan.
@@4thlord51Or search how many civilians have been killed, attributed as 'collateral damage' by the Americans in dozens of countries after WW2
Depends on your point of view .. Dragging the war on and on ..killing millions more.. or doing this which "saved" countless others
@@kittyhawk9707 that is correct but I mean it’s terrible that there even was war in the first place. It’s just so terrible
@@4thlord51 And Korea and all places Japan colonized. Japan also tried their best to bomb the US with limited success.
The shadow of the old lady with the walking stick carrying her groceries is sad.
Also, only a fraction of the warheads' payloads have contributed to the nuclear reaction. The bombs blew the material apart before the reaction took place fully.
Me, just hit by an atomic bomb.
Boss: Can you still make it in to work?
You: not funny as 3rd person is childish.
Presumably for your situation, I've learned that people like you ignorant of any time of long-term pain suffering; having not experience a traumatic situation, can never truly understand the burden of primal fear and of any type.
Why its conventional and easy for people like this to make callous, ignorant and unintelligent remarks pertaining to any person's or other life's plight of a peril-suffering experiences.
So, I hope you don't get your wish in wanting to know it.
I've had cancer twice and being around a lot of people living in a loge with tumors and a really nice man whose cancer is terminal made me truly have a lot of respect for life, be it human or any other living being as well as loving this planet and caring for anyone who has experienced a disease, or trauma-took a lot for me to talk about my cancer, and even bringing it up.
It was a lot and words fail on how tormenting the treats where for a couple of years. As well as the bills and my and parents' emotions and trying to kill the disease.
So be careful of your words and I've seen enough karma educed on people. I'm not religious but spiritual and respect the cosmos and what force people keep presuming to know in religion where.
War is wrong no matter what side started it because people end up suffering and human beings have been at war since the stone age. I realized we are creatures of habits, good or evil.
Evil is real and watching a lot of SICK videos of Physico paths, pedo and serial killers, be it eight-year-olds or adults, people our species can be so abnormally cruel and mentally ill and just gone.
I hate watching these videos but knowing can always give you a window others reality in order to connect and better understand ourselves and those around us.
Humans are meant to connect. That's the best of us where clearly, a lot of people, including yourself have yet to truly know how too and can say nature though cruel is a hell of an amazing, unfiltered teacher since human laws are not as true and just. We twist morality and logic and I'm a very prude person. My pride.
Sorry for what typos I have but its best to be careful how you look down the plight of others in documentaries of this nature. Ignorance's and comical quotes you typed are not your ally. Grow up and learn to be a better person for yourself not become a part of the problem.
@@SephirothWaifu It’s literally part of the video…
Love all your videos ❤
And these were basically prototypes compared to the nukes that came later. Good lord.
All you can really say is these people didn’t know what hit them. Today we know and that creates horror and fear.
For someone who does visual Fx for both film and television, I found this very well done. Very professional.
really, i found it long winded and BORING...
It's been pointed out that (at least until the atomic bomb) that humanity never developed a weapon that they didn't end up using. Even if we hadn't used the atomic bomb then, there would have been a proliferation of them later on anyway. Hiroshima and Nagasaki gave us very graphic and terrifying examples of how terrible nuclear weapons are. Consider then a war breaking out 10, 15 or 20 years later, where multiple opposing or hostile countries will have stockpiled their nuclear arsenals *without* understanding the horrors they would bring. Quite likely the planet would be a smouldering ruin now.
We need to solemnly respect and remember the victims of these two cities.
ive been watching this channel for years now. always love the content
This is a reminder that it's always the innocent who suffer...
The bigger lesson is that people who are supportive or even just complicit with the actions of their government are just as responsible for those actions as the few in charge pushing for war. Not to be uncaring for the mass suffering, but many, if not most rallied behind the Japanese emperor's decision to conquer China. Most were angry and belligerent towards the US in that it was actively helping the Chinese people protect their nation. Unlike ancient war when armies met on remote battle fields, modern war is hell. It takes the lives of women and children because the industry of war makes it's home in the population centers. If you are a worker in that industry, part of the price for your job is being a target in modern warfare. Not to mention that if you work in that industry, you are NOT truly innocent.
@@3DPDK You sound like you are using the argument "people who are supportive or even just complicit with the actions of their government are just as responsible for those actions as the few in charge pushing for war" as an excuse to support your/a government's actions. If so that would be pretty ironic.
@@bencarpendale I "sound like" I believe the people of a nation are ultimately responsible for the actions of their government and leaders. In the war between Japan and the US, there were Japanese that believed committing tactical suicide for the emperor's cause was an honorable thing. They were THAT MUCH in support of the actions of their leaders. If your government is doing something you disagree with morally, you are honor bound to what ever source you get your moral views to stand against it.
@@3DPDK Again, "I believe the people of a nation are ultimately responsible for the actions of their government and leaders" sounds like a general description of all peoples but you then talk solely about Japanese people being to blame for Japan's actions but not the Americans being to blame for the US's actions. I just find that strange, especially considering the nature of this video.
I feel so sorry for following generations that had to suffer. The hope that we are just here temporarily in this valley of tears makes existence meaningful. God is great, wish all humans to follow on His steps.
The world would be completely different had America and her Allies lost the war, but it is sad that a countries people usually suffer from the decisions of their leaders.
The horror that these people endured . Is unimaginable😢😢😢😢😢
Much like the horror that the more than 2,400 sleeping Sailors and Marines felt in Pearl....
@tima.478 yes I agree but thrse wete innocent children and town folks. They did nothing but live in the wrong country
There are no winners in war people are affected for years after and the environment is badly damaged damaged the whole world is affected
@@darlenelang3681 Japan's attempts at killing innocent town folks wasn't from lack of trying. They did manage to kill a few on American soil. Research the fu go balloon bombing. Plans were also made to spread plague and other pathogens in America and may have been successful if the war carried on.
Japan's attempts at colonizing China, Korea and other parts of Asia led to vast amounts of towns folk getting raped, murdered and even used in horrific vivisection experiments. These people did nothing wrong but live in their countries.
@@tima.478🖨🕋⚀️🕋 SPACE FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY FREQUENCY 72 404 ERRORS, NOT FOUND, SUPANOVA EXPLOSION 💥 IS NOW OPEN 🔓 BUT STILL NO ACTION FOR ME FROM DIGITAL PRINTING PLEASE SEND THIS POST BACK TO THE ADDRESS YOU CAN COLLECT IN YOUR EYES 👀 THE NEXT DAY YOU SHOULD DO ITS CLASS OF RA WHEN IT HAPPENS. YOU MAY HAVE TO GO DOWN AND ALL YOUR STUFF IS NOT FOUND ON MY END 🔚, WHICH IS WHY I'M NOT FOUND ON MY PHONE 📱 3
It's amazing how those things happen so long ago and so many people know about it and they still are working toward provoking another war just like that nuclear war that will melt people Like butter it's just sad that we don't have a world already filled up with bees and love I wanted to just treat each other with kindness
Russia hasn't learned anything. Why start a fascist empire and attempt to conquer other countries after WW2? This isn't going to end well.
Thanks for the heads up
Vaporized within a certain distance. Only left a shadow on the wall that survived. Severely burned after that or radiation poisoning, days or month to survive.
The intro went from 1 to 100 real, real quick
Those two atomic bombs are the reason why he haven’t yet had a third war world.
NAZI GERMANY AND NAZI OCCUPIED EUROPE WAS ALLOWED TO SURRENDER WITHOUT BEING NUKED.
AND THE WORLD IS STILL AT WAR. THE NUCLEAR BOMBING OF HIROSHIMI AND NAGAZAKI IS STILL A CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY.
What exactly do you call the current state of the world? War is all around us. Just hasn't hit home yet.....yet!
@@brys5488 Believe it or not, it's actually relatively peaceful, compared to human history where constant wars and conflict were the norm. And just look at the cold war, it was cold because either side feared the unstoppable nuclear weapons that were quickly becoming more powerful. The ones that hit Japan were tiny compared to what was quickly being developed by USA and Soviets after WW2.
Thank you for posting, all the graphics and the cartoon characters tell the story. I would’ve preferred more pictures of people in their suffering stages and collateral damage.
A lot more graphic pictures would better convey the brutality these two atomic bombs impact on mankind.
If we don’t remember what happened most likely history will repeat itself.
I feel the same way about the concentration camps of the second world war, the graphic pictures make a bigger impact and a soft presentation of cartoon characters. Most people don’t have the imagination to see how cruel war can be. Cannot take life for granted or think that this will never happen to us.
Do some searching then! there's LOTS of other videos.
No matter what, history always repeats itself.
I have it on good authority, it WILL happen at least once more time in human history. The description of it was written roughly 2500 years ago, but the description could easily be about the human affects of the bomb on Hiroshima. This prophecy is about a specific ancient city in the Middle East.
@@3DPDK
Damascus.
@@scottzehrung4829 exactly.
nagasaki was bombed only because the original target for the second bomb was under cloud cover and the target point could not be located....the city to be bombed second was to be kokura.
Christ, what a thumbnail 😱
I unsubscribed because of it, do better riddle.
@@brianng5875Came here to say that too, ridiculous
The sad reality is that Japan was all but finished by July 1945, her navy obliterated and her airpower severely compromised. As an island nation, Japan was dependent upon import for petroleum and so many other resources. By August 1, 1945, they were isolated from the rest of the world and were doomed to lose the war. Given these circumstances, there would never have been a strategic need to invade Japan and put at risk the lives of a million allied troops or millions of Japanese civilians. There was also no need to drop the A-bombs either. These were meant as a demonstration of American military superiority in order to circumscribe Stalin's post-war land-grab ambitions. What a tragic passage in World History!
That is a theory that later generations like to subscribe to. The reality is that the people of Japan at that time were told never to surrender and there is no fate worse than being taken captive by the allied forces, whole families were committing suicide. Japan was and still is a resource starved island, most agree that they would not stop their original doctrine. No one liked the idea, but after millions of people had already died in the war, they needed to put an end to the potential millions more being killed. The only things that are certain, are the things that happened, not what could have happened.
@@Brutalgruve While it is true that the Japanese people were told never to surrender and being captured was a fate worse than death, seeing that they were land-bound on their own island-prison, exactly what would have been their strategy had we simply blockaded and used attrition as the weapon of choice? Professional historians are not simply content to study the things that actually happened. We also study the options available to the leaders of the time and the rationale for their choices, providing us with key insights into the mindsets of those same leaders. Speculative analysis provides valuable thought experiments that can yield equally important information from decisions not taken.
@@alexandergroppe448 I stated my point, and then you stated yours, again, it is clear you missed my point Blockade? Go back though history, before WW2 and after, where has that tactic ever worked? You can create generations of oppression and radicalize the half informed. I am moving on; you get a free last word.
When the story is told in Japan, the characters used in this animation is also anime...
That dude is hardcore, I've called off sick for a headache lol. Also, IDC what their justifications were, it was evil to drop weapons like that on civilians, and it's evil to still have those weapons and continue to threaten to use them today.
If I do get radiation poisoning I will take the easy way out. Radiation poisoning death is absolutely horrifying.
just remember that prior to the 2 bombs going off, America had been firebombing the cities of Japan for at least 4 or 5 months using napalm and incendiary rounds. It was only due to the Japanese resiliance and the fact that the Amercians wanted to "try out" their new bombs that the two cities were targeted.
In a way it's fortunate that only ~1M lives were effected physcially from the blasts, as just as it was stated in the vid, had a drawn out war happened millions more could have been effected on both sides.
That's not really correct.
@@sarahabenara4398 Research the March Firebombing Campaign of WW2.
You're literally trying to rewrite history. Japan was given the chance to surrender prior to the bombs being dropped. They refused. They refused to surrender even after the first bomb was dropped in Hiroshima. The Japanese government just sat while its people suffered. Thank whatever powers be that the demon core was never dropped on Japan. Because the third bomb that was planned made the first 2 look like kittens. And let's not negate that the US had stayed out of this war until Japan attacked Pearl Harbour and slaughtered 2,403 innocent people.
I'm not condoning what wa done to Japan or to the Japanese people who lived in the US. But let's not rewrite history like the US was just having a pissing contest with the world
@@ximar0ckstrx So everything that I mentioned was factual albeit I didn't mention the 3rd bomb.
Did the fire strikes happen. Yes. Did the Japanese government continue because they thought they were resilient enough. Yes. (however futile it must have been. FYI they didn't surrender at that point as this was like running away and be seen as dishonourable and shaming ones honour is the biggest no-no even in modern day Japan, which you can be sued for.)
Just because you add more information on top of what was already provided doesn't mean the original statement was false.
Sadly, some Japanese stigmatized those visibly burned or injured in the atomic bomb attacks, or even just there….with some rejecting them as marriage partners due to largely exaggerated fears of infertility or birth defects, and some employers refusing to hire them, believing they were bad for morale and were a reminder of defeat customers would avoid.
It's sad that this happened, and i have mixed feelings as I have relatives on four sides of this issue. So first my Mom is Korean, and at the time of the bombing, the Japanese oppressed koeea as a colony and treated Korean people like shit. So I don't see japanese as innocent as everyone else does, because they treated the people they invaded like they were wirse than feces. On another hand my great grand uncle, to be able to secure a future for his family left Korea and became a Japanese citizen, so he's a zainichi, and they were treated very badly, and had to hide their Korean origin during that time, but at the same time, they were terrified when the bombs dropped, even from Tokyo where they lived, so they fles to thier home in Kyoto, i learned this from my Aunty. But as a person of native Hawaiian ancestry, I feel aa if the USA didnt drop those bombs there would have been no stopping the Japanese from taking over Hawai'i and I don't know how they would have treated those of us who are indigenous to Hawai'i. The USA has only caused harm to our home, and treated us as if we don't matter, turning our homeland into an ecological disaster, but i don't know if the Japanese would have done any better. Nut as a Black American don't feel either way. As human life was lost, and its sad, but so many more would have been lost if the USA would have chosen a different route. I have all these mixed feelings, and perspectives as someone who is mixed or has connections to these different cultures. I just wish that the powers that be of today would get rid of these weapons! They don't just destroy, they poison the land and make it uninhabitable for centuries!
US' record on Hawai'i is shitty. From a European perspective I'm glad USA ultimately stepped in an defeated fascism on both sides of the globe. No one else could have done it and the bombs on Japan were justified. The imperial army butchered its way across China and SE Asia, leaving 12m people dead. Many of whom were women and forced labor. Most of them killed with shovels and bayonets. Losing on every front in the summer of 1945 Jp was unwilling to surrender unconditionally, as Germany had to as well.
The horror of this is UNIMAGINABLE!!!!! My mind boggles!!
Read about fu go balloons and unit 731. Pretty boggling as well.
its not a matter of justification at all., conflict has little to do with justice just like shock & aww has little to do with being fair... this simply isn't a single answer question.,.. this is a set of events , not just a couple of baddabooms ... body count wasn't the only consideration.,. it was a no prisoners game to them unlike the germans... and At the end of the wars Japanese soldiers at prisoner of war camps were told to behead, stab or shoot the 100,000 or so remaining Allied prisoners the moment an invasion began, they also told civilians to commit suicide, which many did..
the fact that any of us at any moment could have this happen...
The shadows don't mean that all of the atoms of a human disintegrated and sticked to the stone in the background. Some of the atoms did it but human bodies were left mainly whole after the blast, ofcourse in a horrible condition.
I wouldn't be so sure. Look at some of the military tests: You can see the steel ropes that hold the bomb in place being vaporized in a tiny fraction of a second, from the extreme burst of gamma radiation. Even metal basically just turns into gas/plasma at the center of the explosion.
Edit: Though I would add that at that distance, there probably wouldn't be a wall left either, so the "shadows" were likely all further away.
stories from my late father about how Japanese soldiers treated people during its occupation .. hear enough of those stories and then you decide whether or not it was justified to throw out those 2 bombs .. all these were ancient histories .. I am 100% not judging .. water flowed under the bridge .. but .. what my father saw when he was much younger during that time crushed my bone ..
it's beyond belief....we need this update to contemplate. believe....i have no faith......wars are everwhere. here it is quiet.....now.
It's too terrible for words. But so is what the Japanese did to our Prisoners of War.
Concerning the question possessed by the author of this video, would fewer people perished had the atomic bomb not be used in the closing chapter of WW2? An answer to this question will always be, at best, speculative. Remember, the times were quite different from today. Most people is this generation were tired of this terrible global war. I remembered so well how my parents who were of European descent never wanted to speak of this time as they had witness so much pain and suffering back then. In defense of my parent's and their generation, I don't think most people back then really knew just how destructive this bomb really was and all the horrible side effective as we now know so well today. Maybe, the better question here should be; have we grown any wiser never to use this terrible weapon again on humanity? Deep in my heart, I truly hope so!
I have heard arguments from both sides. I do know this: if Truman had not given the authority to drop the two bombs and the Allies did invade the home islands of Japan, the survivors families in the US would have had Truman hauled out of office on a rail. We have to remember we were at war. In the Command structure there are two facts: #1; in war, people die. And fact #2; command cannot change rule #1.
#3 Japan butchered its way across China and SE Asia. By the time the bombs were dropped 12m people were dead. Killed with bayonets and shovels mostly.
Such a sad episode in both Country's History.
Back then- 'yo look that cloud looks like mushroom!
Now- 'i am mentaly stabl- oh look, a civilian airliner'
Sad events,,,,,very sad.However, the Japanese people should have extracted a very valuable lesson out of this unfortunate set of circumstances .
No Pearl Harbor, no Hiroshima, no Nagasaki.
"Just because technology is improving doesn't mean our humanity is." -John Lovell (Warrior poet)
Let’s not forget the atrocities that Japan had committed during WW2. Japanese were ruthless to the Koreans and the Chinese. Does it make right no but that’s war , where the generals that start it are safe but the soldiers and civilians pay the price.
That this serves as a harsh lesson to prevent humanity from ever dropping these bombs again. I feel for the scores of innocent people (and all other creatures) that lost their lives, may they rest in peace. 😞
Japan started it and bear the responsibility.
@richardstrongismokecigarsa7215 how many nuclear bombs did Japan drop?
@vhamusanda what does that matter dummy ?
@@vhamusanda none, they did worse... they did nanjing, pearl harbor and the list goes on....
@@vhamusanda No nuclear bombs but plenty of incendiary balloon bombs aimed at America. Had the war gone on, bioweapons spreading plague would have been used as well. Japan was ruthless and did not care if they murdered civilians for their benefit.
Millions fewer died because of the two atomic bombs which were dropped on Japan because Japan started a war against a nation with the resources and capabilities to end a war that they didn't start in the first place. My own aunt by marriage was a Nagasaki survivor. Her family never blamed the United States for resorting to the atomic bombings.
Great video, wish it was longer... also was hope for a Christmas related video not something horror.
We have to rethink again
When one was much more than “warranted,” but further (LIVE!) experimentation was desired, a second bomb was dropped…
A third bomb (named??) was planned for bombardment, but was not used, saving further deaths of infants, children, teachers, grandparents and other non-combatants.
Paul Tibbetts the completely remorseless and unapologetic American pilot who dropped the first bomb on Hiroshima, Japan, named his plane in honor of his mother.
Can you imagine Mrs. Tibbetts, in the days, weeks, months and more following that ushering in of atomic warfare, proudly proclaiming, “That’s My Boy!!” as if he’d hit a home run to win a big…game…or found an actual cure (Not Cause!) for cancer . . . ?? Paul Tibbetts could’ve been pictured on a WHEATIES cold cereal box. He could have endorsed chewing gum, cigarettes, automobile tires, and even…life insurance.
Cynical I am, but tiny children died of dehydration, their skin hanging as shredded sheets . . . I am alive, speaking… They are dead and without voice.
bro said double it and give it to him💀
Imagine using the “nuclear bomb” excuse for being late to work…twice!
This atrocity alone only reinforces the need to ban atomic/nuclear weapons.
Living in peace may be a lost cause to some, but we shouldn't stop trying.
We all come from the same progenitor, regardless and should live in peace and harmony. 🙏🙏
It would have been worse if we didn’t drop them. A million marines would have died with many millions more japs.
Christ the thumbnail gave me goosebumps!😱
yeah its fucked up clickbait that would hurt people who actually know about this.
@RiverRockXIII yea, seriously, the thumbnail is pretty insensitive...
Surprisingly inappropriate, considering the whole focus of the video is respecting individual victims' stories.
That was sad... I wasn't even thought of at that time but still, Imagine though. Henious Crimes and Atrocities that got committed during that War were Mind Blowing and today our Government could do So Much Worse to another country if they really wanted too but still, I will not pretend that Japan was a Victim during that time nor will they ever be. They attacked Innocent Americans on American Soil as well as our Military and paid the price for it. The War Crimes Japan committed during WWII is unspeakable to this day. Regardless, it was still sad because Innocent People that had no part in that War still died because of the type of Leadership Japan had at the time...
The problem is , Those at the top Love Power and that is All There Is!
The 3d animation is a bit eerie, the characters are often wearing weird clothes (like 13:09 the girl in Chinese dress), or the rooms are too modern, I know this is nitpick, but it feels weird for a video with this serious topic. Still a great video.
Nuclear bombs are evil as hell and unjustifiable. Their children’s children suffered.
Those two bombs saved millions of people's lives.
@@strategygalactictf , defend your point. I really would have to disagree so let's hear your logic
@@iuse9646 It ended with Japan surrendering.
The question at the end of the video reminds me a lot of the trolley problem, you would rather kill a couple hundred thousand intentionally rather than be forced to kill millions
The ultimate war crime as we understand them now.
Can you call it a 'trolley problem', when US killed couple hundred thousand in Japan AND, later, killed millions in Eastern Europe, Asian and Middle-Eastern countries? ^_^
Kind of, but in this case, the majority of people who'd get killed during an invasion would be consenting to it. I mean, there's a difference between killing a soldier who wants to either attack you or defend his country, and killing a mother with her children.
@@anatolydyatlov963 If the Americans had invaded Japan, Japanese woman and children would have been mobilized. They were already being trained for it. An once Japan was defeated how many people do you think would have committed suicide?
Wander if one could ask ChatGTP to tell a story, in the artistic style of Riddle :D
This just might be the most horrific act of cruelty upon human beings in the history of the world who had nothing to do with Pearl Harbor smdh.
No you're right. Lets ask them who was responsible while we're getting shot at and pick out the bad ones.
None of those people were in the military and none of them had any control over what their government was doing. They died for nothing
So the cruelty that the Pearl Harbor soldiers and their families should not be taken to account.
@@samkramer7406 nobody said that madness but that attack was on the military not innocent people sitting in their homes and at work who had nothing to do with the at on Pearl Harbor.
@@samkramer7406 we know who was responsible the military of Japan not the citizens who never attacked Pearl Harbor.
You know, I like your videos but this one thumbnail seems to be in bad taste.
This is the grim reality of world war 2. It must be shown in earnest so that this never happens again.
You’re a baby or something??
@@notacat7127 he's right,grow up
Welcome to the Internet Grandma
@@isaiahjalloh8152 yes he should grow up and stop being scared of something that can’t hurt him. Cry more tears
When I was watching this video a day before I was watching Oppenheimer and ya he did regret it
im like paying no attention to anything in games. 😂 crazy how much facts there is
War truly is hell.
They thought they wanted to play.
We were not playin.
My Grandpa fought in the Pacific.
He was a Senior at West Point when Pearl was attacked.
He saw literal Hell on earth. He escorted McAuthor. He retired a Brigadier General after the Cuban Missile Crisis.
He avoided the topic of what he saw and did. But he made one thing clear. The bombs were a necessary evil that saved more lives then they took.
He……made peace with the Japanese after the war. “The Japanese committed horrible war crimes and attacked Pearl Harbor. We dropped two nukes on them. As far as I am concerned we are even. I have made peace with them and have nothing but respect for the people and nation of Japan”.
The only story he told me in detail was how a Japanese sniper killed a buddy of his by shooting him in the head thru a ships porthole (they were close to shore) when his friend was on the toilet.
“I heard the shot, ran down, and kicked in the door. My friend was pretty bad at both ends.
Based on what I saw on the toilet, that (Japanese) sniper may of done him a favor”.
Told me it when I was 11ish after I took to long in the bathroom.
I figured out Grandpas war trauma was bathroom windows.
His customer house had no bathroom windows (or so glazed over they may as well been solid walls).
When he visited us he would only used the downstairs windowless bathroom.
Dad confirmed this was true, but told me to NOT say anything about it.
I have told the full “The Shit and the Sniper” story to a few home owners and Air B&B people who have windows over/near the toilet.
Most get all bug eyed:😳.
Yep. My Grandpas buddy RIP.
May Grandpa RIP. Buried at West Point with full honors.
I just wish he told me more stories. But apparently remembering what he experienced was very painful for him 😞.
The U.S. knew the Japanese were going to attack at Pearl Harbor and they let the attacks happen so the U.S. could enter WWII for geopolitical reasons. There is no fucking way that Pearl Harbor can compare with the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Truman and the people who worked on the bombs like Einstein and Oppenheimer were war criminals.
The nuclear shadows really creep me out for some reason…I don’t know why. Maybe it the extreme conditions required for the phenomenon to occur.
I see dropping the bombs on Japan in WWII as a necessary evil. The lives lost if the war had continued would have greatly outnumbered those that were killed by the two nuclear bombs.
Yamamoto would've saw to the amount of lives lost if the bombs weren't dropped. And he was in a position to do so.
Yamamoto was shot down in 1943
@@vladimirpoutine7522
Kew acho bangladesh theke..?
Perfect example of F* around and find out......
Seriously? The most appropriate 3D model you could find for use in a story about Hiroshima is a waifu with a miniskirt the size of a belt? Jeeze Louise these AI generated CZcams channels are getting obscene.