The Warning "Choke" - ADK REACTS
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- Whether it be music video reviews, interviews with up coming bands in the UK scene, live performances, album reviews, topic debates or even challenges then we have you covered.
Andy, Dave & Kirk "A.D.K" set out to be just three guys with varying tastes in rock and metal that will give our honest opinions on tracks and try to discuss key points along the way.
They new album Error was named one of the best 50 rock albums of 2022 by Loudwire.
To paraphrase the question "Was there pressure to go that direction at a young age?" I think the only answer is you CANNOT fake this kind of passion and talent. This is the real deal
Thank you for reacting to the only popular music band I listen to. Since the late '70s, when I became disenchanted with popular music, I have mostly been listening to classical. But The Warning have hooked me their hooky old school riffs and actual sung melodies instead of screaming and growling. Every song is different, which is such a relief from the bands whose songs all sound alike.
Dany is a powerhouse of energy and in my opinion she has a powerful voice definitely made for the rock genre. Thanks Dave for introducing The Warning to others (subbed); hopefully, we get to see more reactions to TW. 🤘😎❤️⚠️
On target, ABJ! Dany works very hard and is an outstanding frontwoman, and I still think she is underrated by a lot of people who should know better.
Friends don’t let friends go through life without The Warning!
😂 I try to live by that rule.
@@abjbusti8586 Daily.
Las hermanas Villareal han formado una excelente banda. The Warning!!
It's quite eerie that one of the reactors mention what these girls would be like in 5 years. When Rudy Joffroy came aboard to manage this band back in 2017 (after their XXI Century Blood LP). Rudy made a video of him interviewing these girls (Dany was 17, Pau was 15 & Ale was 12). One of Rudy's questions was where do you see yourself in 5 years. Dany stated she hoped to be on a tour with Halestorm. Cause she really admires Lzzy Hale. Five years later not only The Warning was on tour with Halestorm. Lzzy Hale gifted a guitar to Dany on stage in Dallas, TX.
Dany has only gotten better on stage from the time I saw them live in April of 2022 until their last North American Mayday tour gig opening for Three Days Grace Nov 2022 in Toronto (watched the video).
All very true and on point, Kevin!
One of my Fav TW songs and a must for them to play live, shows off Dany's strong vocals and their true #1 hit so far, evolve can play catch up all it wants (I like it too)
Very enjoyable for 2/3 of the reaction! Just as a small correction, it's my understanding that their dad is not their manager. Their manager is the guy who talks on Dust to Dust, named Rudy. They negotiated for months to get the creative control you talked about. Daniela sings lead vocals on about 80% of their songs with Paulina (the drummer) taking lead on the remainder and the rest of the time doing backup vocals on most other songs, along with Alejandra the bass player, who only sings lead on one song that I am aware of. A great reaction by Dave and Kirk again, but when it comes to Andy, it's just apparent that there are reactors out there with more insight, more thoughtfulness, and just more talent, to paraphrase him. I was dumbfounded to hear him say that there are other female singers with more power and talent, when he didn't manage to name one female lead vocalist who also plays lead guitar who supposedly has more power and more talent. Andy is clearly holding the rest of your team back, and just routinely spouts negativity with no examples, context, facts, basis, or really anything to add other than random off the wall inaccurate criticisms that just come out of his behind as far as I can tell. This is about as gently and generously as I can put it. I have rarely seen anyone else as bad at this than him. Dave and Kirk, though, well done as usual, and keep hanging in there.
I can name 1 who can play lead guitar and sing, Moriah Formica from the band PLUSH, but I'm not sure about more power or talent, I like to think that they are equally talented and different style from each other, I hate comparing artist from each other, if you ask me, I always choose Dany, maybe I'm bias being a team Dany, but I don't really care, Dany all the way 24/7
Thanks for the feedback. Andy is a quite guy, even when he loves a song he rarely shows it. During videos he tends to just focus and make notes and try to give to the point feedback and what he thought, Kirk is an encyclopedia so he can tell you how each bands members dynamics work and the history of music and Dave well he just says the first thing that comes off the top of his gead and 80% of the time is accurate the rest of the time its nonsense. We wantedto put this group together as we felt the various characters would make for more interesting viewing than three guys that are similar. We tend to disagree on every song, there is always one of us that doesnt like hte song that was picked but we think that makes for healthier discussions. We do take feedback onboard and hope that subscribers will see that as the channel grows.
@@dariosatira8170 By the way, from what I've seen, Moriah and Dany are friends, one time I spotted her hanging out by the side of the stage while the Warning was playing Evolve in one of the last Halestorm tour concerts. They both are great... Im also in Danys team.
The Warning have just finished touring with Three Days Grace in Canada a few days ago, Dany was invited to sing Painkiler with them several times, also Barry their guitar player played Choke with them. It was great, you should check that out!..
@@francisconavarro669 I know they are friends , they are both very talented , and to Moriah, I call her little Ann wilson , but still there something about Dany that I love, you can say X factor . yes I saw the toronto show, Dany without her guitar, singing choke , just wow, she's the best frontwoman for me , then again, I'm may be biased because I'm team Dany since day 1
They have 2 managers, Rudy and their father.
As a first time for 2/3 of you, I get it. One song doesn’t necessarily summarize everything. As was stated, they have a varied amount of material on ERROR and other albums, and hopefully this leads to a second go round which can be used to compare. as for me, I think their talent at their age is both astounding and promising. 🔥🤘#NumberlyGarfs
The Error album is an excellent work by a high-quality Rock group like The Warning, excellent lyrics and intelligent messages like the Choke theme, on the Error album, Pau shows us his talent to hit the soul with his interpretations and Dany shows his energetic voice, his good riffs and his melodic and beautiful solos, Ale his great bass line of excellent quality, there is no one who performs live and composes the volume of quality songs like THE WARNING
I think 'Evolve' or 'Disciple' would have been a better choice if you are reviewing things that are closer to metal. Also, Dave, I was surprised at your comment about Dany's open mouth when The Charismatic Voice, for example, just recently praised her for that exact thing in her reaction to 'Evolve'.
i think its a personal comment, Dave mentioned it in some of his earlier reactions to the band on his channel
Julia, a friend of the charismatic voice, also mentioned something in this regard.
More from *The Warning guys!!!* 😎👍 ⚠🔥⚠🔥⚠🔥⚠🔥
Dave is correct, it’s all them with no influence from the label, complete creative control was a big part of the 5 album deal.
5 albums is ALOT, they can easily be in their 30's by the time that deal is over.
@@eduardoescobar1906 A live plus a acoustic album could would make it 3 including Error. From what I’ve observed theirs plenty of material in Pau’s pool of talent.
I’d like to hear all these other singers that are better😅
After you get all 5, I’d like to see who can play the guitar as well as Dani AND still sing.
Then I’d like to see not just how well they can sing AND play, but also have the same energy and passion as Dany.
Dany is one of one.
Yes, not to mention running a lot of the band functions behind the scenes as well. The comment you're referring to I agree was ridiculous.
The way the rhythm guitar drops out in the second verse and she plays those little melodic bits is very clean. Perfect songwriting.
Their manager is Rudy "??" Not their dad. Their biggest influence is music to start was classical piano lessons.
All could play piano by 6yo. Their family watched classic rock concet videos. They fell in love with the video game "Rock Band" Ale was only 3yo. She watched to start. Later Danny wanted to play a real guitar. He dad she had to try for 6 months if he bought her one. She said her fingers hurt so bad she wanted to quit with in a week. She promised.
Dad notices Pau's coordination and asked if she wanted drum lessons.
Ale started learning bass at 7yo.
She was covering the Muse cover "Hysteria" at 10yo.
Correct, Gary. :)
Thanks for the reaction! Good job, guys..
I think the "sound" aspect is the influence of the producer, David Bendith. While I like all of Error, and maybe I'm showing my age and tinnitus (did I mention I saw Black Sabbath 2 nights in a row back in '79?), but Bendith added some extra guitar distortion on some of the overdubs to add an ambiance that I think don't help the end product. They just muddy the sound, in my opinion. Still good stuff, though and I'm looking forward to where this ride takes us.
I have to agree with some other TWA posters, Choke is good, but Z, Evolve, or my fav Animosity will give you more about what they can do.
I'm not into that ultra high gain stuff as well. But they are experimenting. Good on them. Hopefully they'll find a middle ground that will suit my aging ears 😂
It's not that I don't like their new songs but that high gain guitar sound, to me, sounds a bit cold. It kind of reminds me of those transistor driven sounds back in the 80's and 90's. In this case it seems to be a song-based choice and it fits.
Good job DPA❤
Hi Guys! Dave, I am kind of disappointed that you chose Choke as the song to introduce your friends to The Warning. It was the first single released from their first major label album, but hardly representative of the band, IMHO. I think Choke is the most "radio friendly" of their new songs, but far from my favorite on the new album. I would have gone with Disciple, Error, or their reimagination of Enter Sandman.
I like your format here, and I hope you all do more of The Warning for your friends! Thanks, Dave!
When they are on tour Ale the Bassist sings the Drowning part. They are Amazing . Dany is 22 and Pau is 20 and Ale will be 18 in 5 days .
Gotta do another. I suggest one of the live session videos of "Evolve," "Animosity," or "Z." That way you see the best of a live performance and a studio performance. You want a guitar riff that's hooky? Evolve is the song.
I agree the studio live version of Evolve is outstanding, and Error is excellent as well.
Dave, I remember back years ago when your channel had less than 200 subs. I suggested you react to The Warning "Dust to Dust. Here you are showing others this amazing band. 👍
I remember that well
I like the way you present your opinions, it was interesting to listen to you discuss the song. I'd much rather people be critical and have something interesting to say than just drivel on about nothing. I think people sometimes mistake criticism for attacking something the viewer likes, so some people may not appreciate what you have to say, but I enjoyed it.
I don’t mind different opinions, some we can respectfully disagree with and that’s fine. But a reviewer also has the obligation to back up their opinions which very little do.
A good reviewer will give examples as to why they believe a certain thing then back it up. Doesn’t always mean we’ll agree but at least it’s respectable.
Someone correct me if Im wrong but dude didn’t give names of people better than Dany. Even his own partners were dubious of his claim. It would’ve been a more substantial opinion if he followed by stating who was better and giving examples as to why.
Not to be critical of a different opinion, simply giving a review of a review. Nor am I angry or dismissive of his opinion, I sincerely wanted to know more that’s all.
@@andgar923 , you're correct about everything you've said. Inaccurate and uninformed criticism is obnoxious, lazy, smug and irritating.
Dany needs more power in her vocals? If she did, NASA would be using her voice to get the next rocket to orbit the moon. This song needs a hook? That's all they do is write great hooks. Anyway, to each their own.😊
Yep.
Agreed 👍🏻
You can hear and see how much work Dany put into her singing. Very good technical abilities now and of course natural development due to aging. That goes for Pau and Ale as well. It's more obvious on Pau's side, since Ale shows more restraint. I still hope that she will open up a little more. I love it, when I see the sisters smiling at each other on stage ❤
Check "Z" and "MONEY" so good.
I really don't see where they got Evanescence vibes from watching The Warning, as they do not sound symphonic at all. I personally am not a fan of reactors that keep trying to say this band sound like that band, but if we have to, I would say that they are the closest to Muse.
I agree that The Warning are nothing like Evanescence.
enable translator button please greetings from Argentina😀
Funny that they both mentioned Evanescence as an influence but I've never heard DPA mention it once (although I'm sure Dany admires Amy Lee's voice).
Creo que esta es prácticamente la única canción que puede recordar a Evanescence. No hay que tomar la parte por el todo.
A good way to tell if someone has no idea what they're talking about is if they say everyone sounds like either Alice in Chains or Evanescence.
Yeah, except for creativity and paying attention to details, they are nothing like Evanescence.
Rudy and Dad are co-managers.
Great reaction, fellow. In my opinion, rock n roll is all but gone. Gone are the days of bands that survived decades of years of awesome music, expect your Metallica of this world. For me, the question is, are they creating something that relevant for today? Can they survive time in the music industry? Are they getting better as time goes?
As a rock n roller for over forty plus years, there hasn't been a group that's caught my attention in the last probably ten years or more. In my opinion, there only getting better as time goes an time is all we have. 🤘
Much less a power trio which has always been rare.
@Jean Kutzer well a this point, you either like or not. With the notoriety and exposure, their getting it matters little whether they are or not. My point is there making awesome rock n roll music, and they are young and talented.
You either like them or you don't, and if you don't, that's okay. We learn to move on. There have been many groups I've moved on from.
Queen of the Murder Scene is a masterpiece.
Are you crazy ,she has one of the best voices. Name 5 better. There is a vocal coach with over a million subscriber's who jaw hit the floor the floor the first time she heard Dany sing.
You are right, Brian. No question.
Thanks
Record company agreed to their terms? So they turned down an advance then? If so good for them. That's very rare. I know Jewel turned down an advance on her first contract and she was living in her car
Guys, DPA FOREVER, no question, but have You ever heard Larkin Poe?
I was introduced to Larkin Poe when they on the Rock Legends Cruise in 2020. I caught their first performance and became an instant fan. They played on three different days, and all performances were intimate and great! Rebecca's voice is amazing as is her guitar work. I highly recommend them!
@@knavekid Imagine this 5 on stage, together! Heaven😇
Choke is waaay better live.
The Warning aren't heavy metal.
If you are into music you should have the flexibility to listen to different genres & accept diversity from all over the world.
Exceptional music is exceptional music.
The guy who was skeptical about Dany's vocal would probably find Dylan, Beatles, Dire Straits a waste of time.
One thing we find is that we have different tasdtes between the three of us and we agreed from day one that we wouldnt say we enjoy songs just to keep viewers happy. It's a challenge as when you do a reaction the people that watch that reaction will generally always be fans of that band so they never want to hear someone doesnt like the band or the musicians etc. We tend to just look at it that we all have different tastes in music and everyone is free to feel how they feel about songs and share their thoughts, same as the viewers are free to express in the comments section. Cheers for the comment
@@adkrockandmetal Totally agree about everyone having different taste in music.
That's why my earlier comment that to one of the reactors Beatles, Dylan, Dire Straits are a waste of time. As is Dany's vocals that has been praised by many experts (not by blind insular fans as suggested by you) as perfect for rock. Not heavy metal but rock.
@@MrSudeepdas Its dave from the channel, i agree, i love Dany's vocals although when i saw them love for the QOTMS album i thought she was over projecting and it came apparnet that as they had been given bad vocal technique advice they were doing that. I think since then they have all really worked on that ellement of the craft to perfect their vocal abilities.
@@adkrockandmetal True. Since they started so early both Dany & Pau were very raw in terms of vocals. Off tune even.
Dany has improved by leaps and bounds with more work & coaching on her vocals. As had Pau. The Pau of 2014 & the Pau in Revenant are totally different.
Hm, Andy seems a bit underwhelmed and distracted, and his microphone sucks... Btw, David's not much better... And for sure there are "better" singers than Dany at the time, but "more range, more power, more talent" ? Seriously? Name one singer similar to Dany at age 21 (or something like that), playing lead guitar while singing something comparable! I'm curious...
Quendras, I agree that Andy is a terrible clueless reactor, but to be fair, Dave is excellent, and in fact, this reaction was his idea in the first place, as he loves The Warning, so I suggest that he's quite a lot better.
@@mikeg.4211 My complaints were strictly centered on his audio quality, nothing else ;-) And maybe it's just me - not being a native speaker and listener...
@@quendras7953 , ah, fair enough! 😊👍
One of my least favorite Warning songs
And yet it's great!
get rid of Andy ....please
Never, he's our ray of sunshine that keeps Kirk and Dave smiling
Avoid this channel.
Thanks for the constructive feedback
@wkjacobs3893
Without a doubt, the least "likable" song of The Warning. TWA is going to kill me for saying this, but I never liked Choke. I agree with you guys, the song is sooo 'Evanescence'.. The only thing I like about Choke is Pau's beautiful drum fill and maybe Ale's bass line (not the best either). Anyways, there's nothing written about tastes... Salutti a tutti🤘
Sorry to not agree with, but for me "Choke" has the capability of running up and down on the radio. Still, it's not their best song in my opinion.
You can like what you want. I am not too keen on 23 but I am sure its somebodys favourite.
@@booradley8895 That's true, man!
@@detlevschwalm6327 That's fine bro, I like it when we all have different tastes or opinions. Can you imagine how boring this world would be if we all liked the same things?.. Cheers!
@@marionardechia1579 That I can agree to. I felt a little provoked by the "without a doubt", but as you said, we all have different tastes and opinions. Have a nice day.
i disagre ;they are not prodogies ; they have worked hard and is wy they are soo seareous 😍Aly is the least seareous of the three , Dan is seareous but has ta adress the crowd and charming ;PA is from another planet is my best guess 🤩aahakhahahkahhaha luv these Kids