The actors look exactly as I imagined the characters for many years, especially Stephen and his father. Fine acting, cinematography, music, everything.
Very true. It is hard to believe comments that are saying the exact opposite! Their writers either lack imagination or they don't know how to read---or both.
I wrote a screenplay adaptation of this book recently and just found this while researching whether or not it was already a movie and I must say I like mine better than this and still intend to make the thing
@@bisspappling it's a handwritten script project that I wrote in a notebook years ago, I don't have much faith in it but I do think it was a sincerer attempt to live up to Joyce's sense of humor than the movie in question. Haven't ever typed that one up because some of the scenes I added for the purpose of a loose adaptation are perhaps too ambitious with liberties taken, the main thing I liked about it was that I was trying to recreate Dedalus's Catholic school experiences from my point of view having done 7th grade at a Catholic school, and that I wanted to use the album And Don't The Kids Just Love It? by Television Personalities as the soundtrack.
@@april3945 Oh hey, didn't notice that was you who commented about this until now! Are you still trying to make a movie? I have a different screenplay I'm trying to make that could use as much help as I can get, it isn't a Joyce adaptation but there is a Joyce sketch in it at one point. Email me for more info
That beating with the leather strap by the sadistic priest was very mild. It was much worse than that. They were possessed and put all their force into it, bringing the leather strap right back. Six on each hand. Sometimes, on a Monday morning, the teacher, be he a priest, Christian brother, or lay teacher would whip the whole class. Most of them were psychopaths. Some teachers would fling the wooden duster at you. If you could not write with your right hand, they would tie your left hand up and force you to write with your right hand. Being left handed was looked upon, as being in league with the devil. Lots of children were sadistically beaten and sexually assaulted. Working class, or poor children, as young as seven and eight, who absconded from the school and the terror were arrested and brought to a children's court and then were sentenced and sent away to reformatories or industrial schools, where they were again abused by the religious orders. Child abuse was the norm. Successive governments knew the abuse was happening but did nothing. The Catholic Church and the Irish ruling class ruled the roost.
Rot. Joyce got an excellent education from the #Jesuits & used it to spit on them. Catholic schools continue to be much better than the state equivalent- I should know, I’ve worked in both.
They talk about the radiance that makes a thing a thing. We talk about bombs and social media. How far we have sunken. On the other hand, dude is really there in a rainstorm popping his collar like that.
Great adaptation however at the beginning states Parnell fighting for independence,not accurate he was fighting for home rule which is a completely different animal,
The movie is amazing, and I feel it is much better than reading the novel as the novel is more boring. This is an opinion so it's different from everyone.
@@McWizzillright, the Christmas meal argue scene is so boring here and I couldn’t believe they tone down so much on the intensity in the beating scene and when Stephen goes to see the rector
Noble attempt. But films deal purely in exteriors, and the Portrait is all about internal growth - from the kiddy prattle (‘moocow’) at the start to the detached diary at the end. That said, I’d love to see Fiona Shaw play Dante.
By Mercedes, one of the main characters in The Count of Monte Cristo novel. Also Mercedes is the symbol of beauty in Greek mythology, so the name has allusion in it. At least that's what our professor told us, we are studying this novel as an example of modernist fiction.
I 've quite enjoyed the attempt of recreating the thick matter of words into a digestible flow of images.Movies look always more like a synthesis of books and this is not the right way to look at them.
Too literal an adaptation and it focuses excessively on Joyce's intellectual curiosity and prowess. This makes for dull viewing indeed. A larger budget would have helped with more convincing scenes of the time (there is not a single one that doesn't feel constrained by money). Why not have used UCC, for example? The quad hasn't changed since the university was built, and this would have added some texture. Fine work by Bosco Hogan and even finer by the great TP McKenna, but half measures are the curse of it.
Reading of the novel gives me a lot of pleasures. This movie gives me sleep.
Yes
As a Joyce fan trying to learn Portuguese, this is perfect.
At the end of the film, I feel that the actor does show us what Stephen himself thought, and the building-up of atmosphere at last is good.
The depiction of he'll by Sir John Gielgud was iconic. Wonderful film...
Thank you very much Sir
I would rather use my ımagination than to see these actors act.
Omegalul bro
@@burakkahraman5887 g41
I agree.
Who's stopping you ?
Than to see 😂
The actors look exactly as I imagined the characters for many years, especially Stephen and his father. Fine acting, cinematography, music, everything.
Very true. It is hard to believe comments that are saying the exact opposite! Their writers either lack imagination or they don't know how to read---or both.
You know, I imagined Stephen more handsome and more cute than he
Thanks 4 d movie. Pls upload "Look back in Anger" if u can.
I love low budget movies
thanks for uploading it
I wrote a screenplay adaptation of this book recently and just found this while researching whether or not it was already a movie and I must say I like mine better than this and still intend to make the thing
good luck dude. this one is kind of a bore
This movie is available in urdu?
Where can i see it
@@bisspappling it's a handwritten script project that I wrote in a notebook years ago, I don't have much faith in it but I do think it was a sincerer attempt to live up to Joyce's sense of humor than the movie in question. Haven't ever typed that one up because some of the scenes I added for the purpose of a loose adaptation are perhaps too ambitious with liberties taken, the main thing I liked about it was that I was trying to recreate Dedalus's Catholic school experiences from my point of view having done 7th grade at a Catholic school, and that I wanted to use the album And Don't The Kids Just Love It? by Television Personalities as the soundtrack.
@@april3945 Oh hey, didn't notice that was you who commented about this until now! Are you still trying to make a movie? I have a different screenplay I'm trying to make that could use as much help as I can get, it isn't a Joyce adaptation but there is a Joyce sketch in it at one point. Email me for more info
I'm reading the comments before watching and they are confusing me
I would say #TheDead is probably the best film of Joyce’s work. This book & Ulysses are unfilmable.
i wish timothee chalamet would play as stephen in a new adaptation
Yes!
absolutely not..
@@AbrasiousProductions Why not? He's perfect for the role
Is there a movie without subtitles? I can't find it anywhere but I need it for my presentation....
The novel is a philosophy
Dream Theater, and the genius of Kevin Moore brought me here.
What artist he hasn't drawn a single picture in the whole film.
he's a writer
That beating with the leather strap by the sadistic priest was very mild. It was much worse than that. They were possessed and put all their force into it, bringing the leather strap right back. Six on each hand. Sometimes, on a Monday morning, the teacher, be he a priest, Christian brother, or lay teacher would whip the whole class.
Most of them were psychopaths. Some teachers would fling the wooden duster at you. If you could not write with your right hand, they would tie your left hand up and force you to write with your right hand. Being left handed was looked upon, as being in league with the devil. Lots of children were sadistically beaten and sexually assaulted.
Working class, or poor children, as young as seven and eight, who absconded from the school and the terror were arrested and brought to a children's court and then were sentenced and sent away to reformatories or industrial schools, where they were again abused by the religious orders.
Child abuse was the norm. Successive governments knew the abuse was happening but did nothing. The Catholic Church and the Irish ruling class ruled the roost.
I do love that he sounded just like how I had imagined while reading: like a pervert
Revolting 🤮, feel sorry for the kids who had to undergo that😢
Rot. Joyce got an excellent education from the #Jesuits & used it to spit on them. Catholic schools continue to be much better than the state equivalent- I should know, I’ve worked in both.
They talk about the radiance that makes a thing a thing. We talk about bombs and social media. How far we have sunken. On the other hand, dude is really there in a rainstorm popping his collar like that.
Book or movie? I pick book 😊
Did they not have lights for this production!?
Great adaptation however at the beginning states Parnell fighting for independence,not accurate he was fighting for home rule which is a completely different animal,
The movie is amazing, and I feel it is much better than reading the novel as the novel is more boring. This is an opinion so it's different from everyone.
Not true. Joyce's writing had me laughing on practically every page and I haven't even become slightly amused while watching this yet
I Am Will lol yes like I said it’s just an opinion and everyone experiences it differently
@@McWizzillright, the Christmas meal argue scene is so boring here and I couldn’t believe they tone down so much on the intensity in the beating scene and when Stephen goes to see the rector
What does the colour 'white' stand for in the novel A Portrait of the Artist as a Young
Man ?
Stephen is much better in my head
5:15 i died
Meme material
Noble attempt. But films deal purely in exteriors, and the Portrait is all about internal growth - from the kiddy prattle (‘moocow’) at the start to the detached diary at the end.
That said, I’d love to see Fiona Shaw play Dante.
I hate when the teacher beat him 💔💔 such an innocent boy 😒😒
This attempt of providing the novel a visionary aspect is one of the greatest failures I've witnessed so far!
In fact, it is a flawless movie; I just wish the print were better.
Piyush Mathur
Wrong way round.
Not a good story still have to watch for educational purposes 😒
DRUGS AND MUSIC
What’s ‘not good’ about it?
You have to understand it before you judge, I always say read twice, gain more
Stephen’s definition of beauty inspired by whom?
By Mercedes, one of the main characters in The Count of Monte Cristo novel. Also Mercedes is the symbol of beauty in Greek mythology, so the name has allusion in it. At least that's what our professor told us, we are studying this novel as an example of modernist fiction.
@@hamzasatBloom at #Yale feels Stevie/Joyce was influenced by #WalterPater.
I 've quite enjoyed the attempt of recreating the thick matter of words into a digestible flow of images.Movies look always more like a synthesis of books and this is not the right way to look at them.
Too literal an adaptation and it focuses excessively on Joyce's intellectual curiosity and prowess. This makes for dull viewing indeed. A larger budget would have helped with more convincing scenes of the time (there is not a single one that doesn't feel constrained by money). Why not have used UCC, for example? The quad hasn't changed since the university was built, and this would have added some texture. Fine work by Bosco Hogan and even finer by the great TP McKenna, but half measures are the curse of it.
is the subtitles portugese?
Yes.
what do Stephen and Dedalus stand for?
Too quiet.
what are they drinking?
This movie ruined the perfect image of the characters in my head
54:25 oh sweet Jesus , this beautiful creature would be my wife and I'd still be a priest and she'd be my priestess hahahaha
Note to self: Resume from 15:00
He captures the tension and the cynicism, but he's got no grasp at all of joyce's humour.
🙂🙂🙂🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂
Yelpazeyi geniş tutmakta fayda var. Her kesimden abone lazım :D
Are the subs portugese
Yeah most probably
Langi nin videoları niye kalktı
46:19
اسخف رواية
منو عندة فلم مترجم
زهراء ههههه همزين اول مره اشوف واحد معلق ع هذا النوفل ولو قبل سنه بس متذكرين لكيتي قصه مترجمه
@@voodoojr6016 انت هم مالكيتي مترجم
what the puck....is that a very boring and awful bcccc