Para mim, Roger sempre foi o grande"criador" e Gilmor o grande "executor". Os dois se completavam e não sabiam... uma pena. Um abraço do Brasil para todos os amantes de Pink Floyd e que o mundo seja regido pela Paz. ❤️👍☠️🙏
I should have warn you about that you would want to watch the rest of the show. This was just the beginning of the building of the Wall. which in the middle the Wall is actually completely finish. This won many awards. you only can find a few bootleg videos of this. If you think this was big, you can see the one , '1990 The Wall Berlin". Roger said he would never do the Wall again until the Berlin Wall was tore down. ( where it was perform in front of an estimated 400,000 people. At a cost of over $ 1 million ). next cup of coffee will be the end of the concert the "Trial" where you will see how BIG it was.
This is the entire Wall double album performed live in its entirety. Roger toured the world with it in the 2000-teens. It remains one of the biggest most elaborate rock shows in history. A 35 ft high wall is built during the course of the show that spans the full width of the arena and/or stadium whichever the venue they're in, completely walling off the band from the audience by the end of the first act. It's just something that has to be seen to be believed. You can rent, buy, or stream this presentation of Roger Waters The Wall live to see the full show. (But you must listen to the album first!). One more point... Roger Waters does NOT own the copyright to all Pink Floyd music.They all have shares in the publishing but Roger Waters was given the rights to "The Wall" and "The Final Cut" their last two albums, as he conceived snd composed most of the material. And upon a condition of his leaving and dropping his frivolous lawsuit against the band.
Watch the whole show, definitely. I saw the film that had Roger Waters with various musicians at the Berlin Wall in 1990. The Wall is a great Rock Opera that has something to say about the way things are in the world.
This is the starting song also for album "The Wall", as well as the same name movie. You really have to see it actually, or listen to all the album from start to the end
I was very fortunate to see Roger 3 times while touring The Wall and it is without a doubt the most incredible show I've ever witnessed! It even beat seeing Pink Floyd on their '94 tour and I thought nothing would ever top that. You two should really watch the whole show, it's just amazing!
Waters é um gênio! Letras brilhantes. Criou conceito unico de shows. Um lutador antifascista. Vou assistir, novamente, seu show em Porto Alegre/Brasil. Obrigado Roger Waters. Obrigado MerchantofAlba
The biggest stage was in Berlin 1990 concert, which was performed right after the fall of Berlin Wall. Roger performed the whole album of "Pink Floyd The Wall" with many special artists.
A note about this tune: This song has two parts. Part 1 (this is the part in your reaction) is the album side-one opener and is titled "In the Flesh?"...notice the question mark at the end. The second part of the song is titled "In the Flesh"...without the question mark. Both parts sound really similar musically. Part 2(without the ?) has a backing choir to add emphasis to the words that Pink is speaking/singing. In the Flesh? is introducing the listener to Pink, the protagonist of the Wall. Pink is a big shot rock musician that has some serious psychological issues and the Wall album tells the story of how the events of his life has slowly led him to build a figurative "wall" around himself in order to isolate himself from others. The opening line "So ya thought ya might like to go to the show" is basically saying, "You wanna see the story of my life? It's f****d up, dark, and might not be what you expected to see, so put your seat belt on and prepare to have your mind blown." Then Pink calls for "lights," "sound effects," "action." "Drop it on 'em" is again saying, here it comes, hope you're prepared. As the story progresses, the listener does get to "find out what's behind these cold eyes" as Pink elaborates on his "disguise." By the time part 2 of the song comes around, Pink has went off the rails and is rapid mental decline. In the Flesh part 2 shows Pink as a wannabe dictator hellbent on eliminating everyone he doesn't like. The song makes parody of how easily a lathered-up crowd of followers will do anything it's leader demands of them. The imagery that the song intends applies to how a big time musician can easily work a crowd into a frenzy but it also is imagining how a strong-willed lunatic can manipulate his/her followers into doing anything asked of them.
Thank you, thank you for your patience and your ability to synthesize! I'll never understand why the "modern" reagents here on CZcams seem to esteem themselves for not learning anything "before" listening to a song ... let alone before listening to an entire ROCK OPERA!
You guessed correctly--the primary song-writer gets the rights. *The Wall* and *The Final Cut* are really operas built around very personal storylines conceived by Roger Waters. He was also the conceiver of the show's basic form. Prior to the first incarnations of the first version of the show (in the 80's), Waters had grown to dislike how audiences seemed more interested in spectacle than the music. The premise of 'the wall' itself, was to hide the band so people had no choice but to listen. As the concert goes, workman are building the wall higher and higher, blocking off the band, in alignment with how each song progressively builds up the protagonist's personal wall. Waters also feels that those personal walls weaken people, making us more susceptible to things like fascism or jingoism, hence his one character in the show. Also, the wall itself acts as a giant movie screen, where the effect is huge. They can project the wall onto the wall, and then show bricks dropping out, and it looks like the actual physical bricks are disappearing when they're not. In the end the entire wall collapses to incredible effect. The end of the concert is like no other, because there has been a storyline with a beginning, middle and end, so the finale is a climax to a story, not the most popular song. And the audience has a role in the show too. And it is a real wall and airplane. I've seen the show many times, and I actually have one of the 'bricks,' and you can see the marks from where the plane hit it.
I saw Roger Waters do the entire "The Wall" at Yankee Stadium in New York City a few years ago. It was incredible from start to finish. Almost a 2 hour show, very theatrical, and they built a giant wall and tore it down!
I watched his 30th Anniversary Wall Tour twice and was the best shows I ever seen. You folks don't understand the concept album and how it flows beginning to end. Watch the whole then comment
The Wall live is certainly a spectacle but you really have to listen to the studio album to get the full effect as the Floyd meant it to be experienced. The motion picture is also a good introduction. The concert musicians are top class but again, the arrangement is a tad off from the album. IMHO more “tinkering” detracts from the rawness of the studio engineered sound!
This might be heresy, but I also think the version of Comfortably Numb (on this tour I think) is the best. I saw The Wall performed by PF in 1981 and it was unlike any other rock performance I have seen since.
Everyone here has said everything, the plane by the way is a scaled down size of the real thing, and actually fly´s over the heads of the audience, The Wall...
I so wish you guy's will react to the entire The Wall album...do it in four parts if you wish but you MUST have the lyrics drawn up. It is an absolute MASTERPIECE!!! That was the first track of the album and it just gets better and better.
"The Wall" is a rock opera which tells the life story of a fictional rock star named "Pink". This is the opening song. It's bombastic, over the top, and a real spectacle... but it's also disturbing with fascist imagery. It's supposed to be unsettling - it looks like a Nazi rally. The viewer is supposed to be shocked and the singer (Roger) asks, basically, "do you want to know how I got like this?" The rest of the album shows how he went from a lonely child to a troubled teen, to a bitter adult who grew to hate his audience. "The Wall" album is a masterpiece of story telling... and you just reviewed the first chapter.
React to the Dire Straits song Brothers in Arms, but to the live version On the Night 1993, if you don't get excited about it and its guitar notes, you're not alive
Why not listen to the classic Floyd albums in their entirety? Listening to the tracks in the order they are supposed to be listened to, the only way to listen to Floyd. You cannot listen to the songs randomly, these are 'concept' albums, they tell a story.
If Waters had been a solo artist we wouldn't have the most beautiful Pink Floyd songs which are those written together with the others like: wish you were here, shine on you crazy diamond, comfortably numb, echoes, the great gig in the sky, us and them, dogs and others. We wouldn't have Rick Wright's sound, Gilmour's solos and voice. It would basically be a completely different band and the world would probably have already forgotten Pink Floyd like everyone forgot Waters' solo career. Waters is not Pink Floyd, his solo career is proof. His dark side version shows that that album without the others would have literally sucked even though it has beautiful lyrics.
@@Simone77777Roger is brilliant but he is a dark and troubled soul. His latest redux of "Dark Side of the Moon" is a perfect example... Dark, dreary, lifeless. Without the input and participation of the other brilliant musicians that were Pink Floyd, particularly David Gilmour's iconic voice and guitar, those amazing albums would sound NOTHING like how they turned out. And Roger likely would never have enjoyed anywhere near such a successful career.
Unfortunately, by writing an indisputable truth you created the beginning of Roger's haters gathering. I will never tire of pointing out that no Roger Waters admirer has ever allowed himself to denigrate David Gilmour or Rick Wright … and this, in my opinion, says a lot about those who think by rankings and echo the "newsagents" who gain from spreading and rekindling contrasts. What careers would they, all, have had individually without the overviews of the concept albums pursued by Roger?
@@Simone77777 « _… like everyone forgot Waters' solo career_ .» Why do you expose your opinion as if it were "the truth"? If you don't even know what Roger has done(*), and is still doing despite his age, it certainly doesn't mean that those who appreciate him are worth less than you and other haters who are always happy to express themselves "against". (*) czcams.com/video/NDTWsuyDYRM/video.html
@@Enrico.Sbardolini they all played off of and enriched each other's talents. Where would any of them have been indeed. They were, all four of them, a force much bigger than the sum of the individual parts.
I think from The Wall backwards they all have the same rights to play them. After the split Roger wasn't in Pink Floyd so he has no rights to those songs. That's my understanding.
As talented as he is or “was” I simply do not like him as a human being and wouldn’t give him one minute of my time. I absolutely adore the both of you though ❤
Roger Waters is a very talented musician and song writer, but his obsessive bigotry keeps me from ant appreciation of his music, he is a deplorable person regardless of any ability.
GREAT show featuring an all star line up with performers from around the world!! watch the entire concert "live from berlin". AMAZING production
This isn't the Germany All-Star show.
The entire show is absolutely incredible, absolutely otherworldly.... Had the DVD when it came out. Great reaction and thanks to both of you :)
Love Roger Waters voice in "the wall" he sound so mad and crazy, it's amazing
Para mim, Roger sempre foi o grande"criador" e Gilmor o grande "executor". Os dois se completavam e não sabiam... uma pena. Um abraço do Brasil para todos os amantes de Pink Floyd e que o mundo seja regido pela Paz. ❤️👍☠️🙏
I should have warn you about that you would want to watch the rest of the show. This was just the beginning of the building of the Wall. which in the middle the Wall is actually completely finish. This won many awards. you only can find a few bootleg videos of this. If you think this was big, you can see the one , '1990 The Wall Berlin". Roger said he would never do the Wall again until the Berlin Wall was tore down. ( where it was perform in front of an estimated 400,000 people. At a cost of over $ 1 million ). next cup of coffee will be the end of the concert the "Trial" where you will see how BIG it was.
This is the entire Wall double album performed live in its entirety. Roger toured the world with it in the 2000-teens. It remains one of the biggest most elaborate rock shows in history. A 35 ft high wall is built during the course of the show that spans the full width of the arena and/or stadium whichever the venue they're in, completely walling off the band from the audience by the end of the first act. It's just something that has to be seen to be believed. You can rent, buy, or stream this presentation of Roger Waters The Wall live to see the full show. (But you must listen to the album first!).
One more point... Roger Waters does NOT own the copyright to all Pink Floyd music.They all have shares in the publishing but Roger Waters was given the rights to "The Wall" and "The Final Cut" their last two albums, as he conceived snd composed most of the material. And upon a condition of his leaving and dropping his frivolous lawsuit against the band.
Watch the whole show, definitely. I saw the film that had Roger Waters with various musicians at the Berlin Wall in 1990. The Wall is a great Rock Opera that has something to say about the way things are in the world.
You guys need to just purchase the DVD of Rodger Waters the wall live!! It's a gigantic production just like the Pulse concert!!
This is the starting song also for album "The Wall", as well as the same name movie. You really have to see it actually, or listen to all the album from start to the end
Roger Waters - What God Wants with Jeff Beck on lead guitar is amazing.
Roger waters THE WALL is a full concert video of the album from the first song to the last in order. spectacular video,you will enjoy it ~!!
In the Flesh is the best concert i have ever witnessed!
Roger is a GENIUS.
I was very fortunate to see Roger 3 times while touring The Wall and it is without a doubt the most incredible show I've ever witnessed! It even beat seeing Pink Floyd on their '94 tour and I thought nothing would ever top that.
You two should really watch the whole show, it's just amazing!
I want to listen to The Wall now seeing that.
Great opening to a great live concert.
"Oh by the way, which one is Pink?"
Roger IS Pink.
Love your reactions!
Waters é um gênio! Letras brilhantes. Criou conceito unico de shows. Um lutador antifascista. Vou assistir, novamente, seu show em Porto Alegre/Brasil. Obrigado Roger Waters. Obrigado MerchantofAlba
The biggest stage was in Berlin 1990 concert, which was performed right after the fall of Berlin Wall. Roger performed the whole album of "Pink Floyd The Wall" with many special artists.
60 ft.high over 900 ft. long over 1 million $$$$$$$$$$$$ to put on at the place where the Berlin Wall stood.
This was my son's first concert. Had 15th row floor center stage. Great show no doubt.
You’d have to watch the wall film
His concert in Berlin when the wall came down is amazing
A note about this tune: This song has two parts. Part 1 (this is the part in your reaction) is the album side-one opener and is titled "In the Flesh?"...notice the question mark at the end. The second part of the song is titled "In the Flesh"...without the question mark. Both parts sound really similar musically. Part 2(without the ?) has a backing choir to add emphasis to the words that Pink is speaking/singing.
In the Flesh? is introducing the listener to Pink, the protagonist of the Wall. Pink is a big shot rock musician that has some serious psychological issues and the Wall album tells the story of how the events of his life has slowly led him to build a figurative "wall" around himself in order to isolate himself from others. The opening line "So ya thought ya might like to go to the show" is basically saying, "You wanna see the story of my life? It's f****d up, dark, and might not be what you expected to see, so put your seat belt on and prepare to have your mind blown." Then Pink calls for "lights," "sound effects," "action." "Drop it on 'em" is again saying, here it comes, hope you're prepared.
As the story progresses, the listener does get to "find out what's behind these cold eyes" as Pink elaborates on his "disguise." By the time part 2 of the song comes around, Pink has went off the rails and is rapid mental decline. In the Flesh part 2 shows Pink as a wannabe dictator hellbent on eliminating everyone he doesn't like. The song makes parody of how easily a lathered-up crowd of followers will do anything it's leader demands of them. The imagery that the song intends applies to how a big time musician can easily work a crowd into a frenzy but it also is imagining how a strong-willed lunatic can manipulate his/her followers into doing anything asked of them.
Thank you, thank you for your patience and your ability to synthesize!
I'll never understand why the "modern" reagents here on CZcams seem to esteem themselves for not learning anything "before" listening to a song ... let alone before listening to an entire ROCK OPERA!
You guessed correctly--the primary song-writer gets the rights. *The Wall* and *The Final Cut* are really operas built around very personal storylines conceived by Roger Waters. He was also the conceiver of the show's basic form. Prior to the first incarnations of the first version of the show (in the 80's), Waters had grown to dislike how audiences seemed more interested in spectacle than the music. The premise of 'the wall' itself, was to hide the band so people had no choice but to listen.
As the concert goes, workman are building the wall higher and higher, blocking off the band, in alignment with how each song progressively builds up the protagonist's personal wall. Waters also feels that those personal walls weaken people, making us more susceptible to things like fascism or jingoism, hence his one character in the show.
Also, the wall itself acts as a giant movie screen, where the effect is huge. They can project the wall onto the wall, and then show bricks dropping out, and it looks like the actual physical bricks are disappearing when they're not. In the end the entire wall collapses to incredible effect. The end of the concert is like no other, because there has been a storyline with a beginning, middle and end, so the finale is a climax to a story, not the most popular song. And the audience has a role in the show too. And it is a real wall and airplane. I've seen the show many times, and I actually have one of the 'bricks,' and you can see the marks from where the plane hit it.
du génie du début à la fin !
Spectacular... wait for Confortably numb !
Definitely watch the full film in surround sound and in 4k etc.
I would recommend reading the storyline of The Wall before hearing more songs ,,,,They make more sense when you know what is happening ,
That was the first song of The Wall. 25 more songs to go in the concert.
This is only 1 song from the whole concert. You need to watch and listen to the whole concert
They build the wall during the concert !!!
Roger Waters, the creative genius and real force behind Pink Floyd!
Please try the whole concert , amazing.......
You should get a copy of this full show to watch even if u can’t react to it . The show is something else .
Yee-hah. What a concert!
See this live... so good.
only the intro remember lol
I saw Roger Waters do the entire "The Wall" at Yankee Stadium in New York City a few years ago. It was incredible from start to finish. Almost a 2 hour show, very theatrical, and they built a giant wall and tore it down!
its hard to enjoy just ONE song - the whole album is a musical experience !! (the movie is even better)
I watched his 30th Anniversary Wall Tour twice and was the best shows I ever seen. You folks don't understand the concept album and how it flows beginning to end. Watch the whole then comment
The Wall live is certainly a spectacle but you really have to listen to the studio album to get the full effect as the Floyd meant it to be experienced. The motion picture is also a good introduction. The concert musicians are top class but again, the arrangement is a tad off from the album. IMHO more “tinkering” detracts from the rawness of the studio engineered sound!
This might be heresy, but I also think the version of Comfortably Numb (on this tour I think) is the best. I saw The Wall performed by PF in 1981 and it was unlike any other rock performance I have seen since.
Please do them in order or you are missing it!
Everyone here has said everything, the plane by the way is a scaled down size of the real thing, and actually fly´s over the heads of the audience, The Wall...
I so wish you guy's will react to the entire The Wall album...do it in four parts if you wish but you MUST have the lyrics drawn up. It is an absolute MASTERPIECE!!! That was the first track of the album and it just gets better and better.
YOU NEED TO REACT TO THE FULL WALL ALBUM PLZ!!!!!
"The Wall" is a rock opera which tells the life story of a fictional rock star named "Pink". This is the opening song. It's bombastic, over the top, and a real spectacle... but it's also disturbing with fascist imagery. It's supposed to be unsettling - it looks like a Nazi rally. The viewer is supposed to be shocked and the singer (Roger) asks, basically, "do you want to know how I got like this?" The rest of the album shows how he went from a lonely child to a troubled teen, to a bitter adult who grew to hate his audience. "The Wall" album is a masterpiece of story telling... and you just reviewed the first chapter.
React to the Dire Straits song Brothers in Arms, but to the live version On the Night 1993, if you don't get excited about it and its guitar notes, you're not alive
We have two 'Brothers In Arms' reaction. Please check in our videos. Thanks for watching 😀
good song ! Please comment on U2 - October/Bullet The Blue Sky (Live in Paris 2015), it's worth it!
Please react to Pink Floyd Breathe studio version and A Saucerful of Secrets Pompeii version!
Young lust - pink floyd pleaaaassseeeee
His father was killed i the world war II when his plane was hit by the enemy forces so...
Roger Waters IS Pink Floyd.
Why not listen to the classic Floyd albums in their entirety? Listening to the tracks in the order they are supposed to be listened to, the only way to listen to Floyd. You cannot listen to the songs randomly, these are 'concept' albums, they tell a story.
Roger Waters is Pink Floyd !
If Waters had been a solo artist we wouldn't have the most beautiful Pink Floyd songs which are those written together with the others like: wish you were here, shine on you crazy diamond, comfortably numb, echoes, the great gig in the sky, us and them, dogs and others. We wouldn't have Rick Wright's sound, Gilmour's solos and voice. It would basically be a completely different band and the world would probably have already forgotten Pink Floyd like everyone forgot Waters' solo career. Waters is not Pink Floyd, his solo career is proof. His dark side version shows that that album without the others would have literally sucked even though it has beautiful lyrics.
@@Simone77777Roger is brilliant but he is a dark and troubled soul. His latest redux of "Dark Side of the Moon" is a perfect example... Dark, dreary, lifeless.
Without the input and participation of the other brilliant musicians that were Pink Floyd, particularly David Gilmour's iconic voice and guitar, those amazing albums would sound NOTHING like how they turned out. And Roger likely would never have enjoyed anywhere near such a successful career.
Unfortunately, by writing an indisputable truth you created the beginning of Roger's haters gathering.
I will never tire of pointing out that no Roger Waters admirer has ever allowed himself to denigrate David Gilmour or Rick Wright … and this, in my opinion, says a lot about those who think by rankings and echo the "newsagents" who gain from spreading and rekindling contrasts.
What careers would they, all, have had individually without the overviews of the concept albums pursued by Roger?
@@Simone77777
« _… like everyone forgot Waters' solo career_ .»
Why do you expose your opinion as if it were "the truth"?
If you don't even know what Roger has done(*), and is still doing despite his age, it certainly doesn't mean that those who appreciate him are worth less than you and other haters who are always happy to express themselves "against".
(*) czcams.com/video/NDTWsuyDYRM/video.html
@@Enrico.Sbardolini they all played off of and enriched each other's talents. Where would any of them have been indeed. They were, all four of them, a force much bigger than the sum of the individual parts.
I think from The Wall backwards they all have the same rights to play them. After the split Roger wasn't in Pink Floyd so he has no rights to those songs. That's my understanding.
After the agreement out of court, Waters gained all rights of The Wall and Final Cut and Algie the pig.
As talented as he is or “was” I simply do not like him as a human being and wouldn’t give him one minute of my time. I absolutely adore the both of you though ❤
Thank you 😊
Roger Waters is a very talented musician and song writer, but his obsessive bigotry keeps me from ant appreciation of his music, he is a deplorable person regardless of any ability.
roger trash unic music best is want god want 3 the flecther and perfect sense
This is actually "In The Flesh"...the second part "In The Flesh?" was on disc 2 and later in the film.