"If Bill Implemented It Will Wreck The..." | Reservation Battle Stokes Controversy In Karnataka
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- #congress #karnataka #bjp
The Karnataka Cabinet has approved legislation that will enable quotas for locals in the private sector in different roles and capacities, triggering a huge row in a city known as the Silicon Valley of India.
The move may also be illegal and unconstitutional. Previous attempts at such quotas in other states have been stopped by the Supreme Court
Tune in as Barkha Dutt speaks to,
Nizam Foujdar, Karnataka Congress
Surabhi Hodigere, BJP Karnataka
Sumanth Raman, Political Analyst
Mithilesh Kumar, Volunteer Citizens Movement
Sanjay Hegde, Sr advocate
Become A Mojo Story Member Now👇
CZcams/@mojostory
Welcome to Mojo Story, where storytelling meets truth-telling in its purest form. Led by renowned journalist Barkha Dutt, we're dedicated to bringing you narratives that transcend time and format.
From succinct 60-word snippets to immersive videos spanning up to 60 minutes, we explore the spectrum of human experiences and current events through a lens that prioritizes authenticity and integrity. In a world divided by polarization, we stand firm as a beacon of non-partisanship, refusing to be swayed by agendas or affiliations.
Here, you'll find content that goes beyond the noise, beyond the rhetoric, and beyond the confines of bias. We're neither 'Chamcha' nor 'Morcha'-we're advocates for the truth, champions of #PeopleFirst storytelling.
Join us on this journey as we navigate the complexities of our world with curiosity, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the facts. Subscribe now and become part of a community that values truth above all else. Welcome to a space where every story matters, and where the voices of the unheard are amplified.
Subscribe to us for more updates:
Follow us on Twitter:
X.com/themojostory
Like us on Facebook:
Facebook.com/themojostory
Instagram:
mojostory.in
Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization.
Does Rahul Gandhi knows Malayalam to fight from Kerala?
Does Sonia Gandhi knows Hindi ( Read and Write) .. no
@@manivannankannan4813as on today Italy madum is depending on ready made speeches prepared by some body.
Mohbbat ki dukan regionalism ke through pyar batte hue😂😂
Forget North Indians, how many Tuluvas and Kodavas can speak Kannada? Even someone like a Rashmita Mandana or an Aishwariya Rai can't speak Kannada even though they are from Karnataka.
Karnataka wants a Kannadiga first policy. Similar to what is seen in Europe and USA. They fear the loss of their common culture, their political power. There is also the matter cheap labour( whether white collar or blue). Karnataka isn't alone even within India. Haryana, Gujarat have also pursued such legislation. But at the end of the day the most important goal for India is economic growth, which creates hundreds of millions of well paying jobs. Reservation bills in India do not create jobs they only create Pooja Khedkars.
Kannadiga first if the company is owned and run by Kannadigas. It is rubbish to demand the same to an MNC who came to India hoping to harness the talent available in the entire country. Bangalore is such a unique place where talent of the entire nation is concentrated.
What about the Muslims of Karnataka, who do not speak kannada, don't want to learn kannada.
All these politicians know that as soon as this bill is passed and the bill goes to the court for hearing, the court will reject it, because it is against the Constitution and fundamental rights. And according to Article 13, if any law goes against the fundamental rights then the court can strike down that law. And it is not that the law makers do not know that this law will be repealed, but they will have an excuse to fool the public that we had tried but the people of North India and the BJP got that law repealed. Because they cannot blame the court as it would amount to contempt and no one wants to confront the court. So those who are working in Bangalore, keep working, don't be afraid. Such laws come every day and are repealed every day. Many states of India have brought such laws many times, and every time the Honorable Court has struck down such laws and reprimanded the government.
Your point is absolutely correct bro but it makes it unsafe to work in Bangalore
first comment i completely accede with.. brilliant
Problem is unemployment. Locals fear that cheap labour from other states will take over their jobs.
Yes, you have a right point.
This is not their jobs.It is private jobs and companies will move out from Karnataka and then u will get no job😊
@@cod_mw5675abhe companies get cheap land and all facilities and u are saying its not their job , then who's job it is?? Ha
@@Unknownrace it's private job and they pay rent and tax which u grandu will not undetstand😁
@@Unknownrace It's Private job grandu not ur fathers property IoI
Without discussing with private companies, IT.... bringing law, Karnataka & Bangalore..will lose industries
TN is the most discriminatory state. I left my job in chennai and came to bangalore. I am a north indian
can you share your experience
Let central govt stop all exams in hindi and English. Conduct exams in regional languages. Indirectly central government reserving jobs to hindi speaking people and taking away all jobs of south Indians. If karnataka does it is not correct if CG does it is ok. What a nonsense.?
Great decision made by the Karnataka government. Every state must have reservations for locals atleast 50 percent otherwise the Northies will snatch everything by bribing or by other means from the South.
I'm also South Indian, A lot of South Indians work in North India also. Stop this nonsense.
@@cityrocks4josehow many South Indians don't lie
Will Dhruv randee open his mouth
One nation, one language. Make English the primary language. Remove the useless Hindi language.
No need to work from Bengaluru work from home 💛❤️
Andhra Pradesh welcomes you come to Vizag the city of destiny, no one will ask you speak the local language, live your own life peacefully a warm welcome to all people across the states 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Divide and rule move by Congress 😢
Even Dmk that clean bowled congress party from chennai In1966 didn't succeed in quota in pvt industries and IT sectors oened by north indians&foreigners.Even TNPL, thermal power projects, pvt industries owned by some Fmk leaders employed malayali, telugus, kannadigas, north indian as skilled management personnel and workmen .
Delhi people will say only delhi people will get job in delhi and pm will be from delhi.
Singapore has policy of any job published must be given chance to locals first.. instead of 50% or 75%, they should implement a rule of first interview option must be given to local. Corporate must show sufficient evidence if demanded
RAHUL Gandhi AUB KUCH NAHI BOLEGA?
The
North Indians have no jobs in their own States, so like
Bihar what is there.like this UP,MP and RAJASTHAN are all jobless. Let's try to get a chance to meet this.😮😮😮😮
It is only for Class D
😆😆😆I love the way the cowbelt hindi people having meltdown even intellectuals like Barkha dutt a zionists supporter, when non hindi states trying to set state domicile reservation in private jobs for native locals
Develop your states ask your governments , why people are coming to Karnataka and making traffic jams here
Benglooru kannada people even discriminate against North Karnataka people.
This is only Bengalooru ka Ra ve goondaism which is a CONgress supporter.
Move all industries to Tamilnadu from Karnataka 😂
Nobody goes there due to fear. Than 100% tamils will have jobs
horur amaravati
@@satyanarayan308 and yiu also move why delay
Ideally they want non local to learn kannada but in our day to day life, we meet either our office mates, family members, and friends. None of them enforce us to learn kannada and these are the people we spend 95-99% of our time. Now why would a non local learn kannada for some auto drivers who is gonna meet us for not more than 10-15 mins a day at most? But if you see this from outside Karnataka, I feel they should be given what they are asking for. They should also implement it in their colleges and make it irreversible 😊
Look at ur audacity… if ur living here for 20 odd years u should hav the basic decency to learn basic kannada
@@bharathsy how come, this can come to my audacity? People from outside might say that the main occupation in Bangalore is real estate, now seeing how much externals are bringing to your table, can you mind your audacity 😆 plus I have tried learning it with some simple words but still not enough that I can talk completely in English…plus do you guys know how many students come here to study? Will you check their audacity as well?
Kannada** not English
Every action has equal and opposite reaction? Planning Commission to NITI Aayog, IPC to BNS, CrPC to BNSS and IEA to BSA? Karnataka already form a committee to change in 3 new criminal laws?
it is possible with CBN but you AP people choosen wrong cm jagan reddy has cm you destroyed your own state, state went into 13 lacks cores debit. Ap people choosen voted jagan if not Ap would have been developed.
For manufacturing companies, Managers & above can be from All India.
There is no need to recruit outsider for Group-4, Group-3 & entry level Engineers.
Now a days, Companies are preferring outsiders to exploit more
It is right move by Karnataka
This is all about Mohabath kaa Dukkaan & Procting the Constiution Enjoy
Karnataka is for kannadigas💛❤️
Sonia gandhi 🇮🇹 italy
😂😂
Just another state in India
Telangana also required same system, mostly jobs taken by Andhra people in hyderabad, many telangana unemployed people are working in gig companies
Different case when it comes to Hyderabad in respect to Telangana and Andhra as Hyderabad was the capital for both states! All of Andhra’s resources too was used to build Hyderabad as the IT hub but now the capital belongs to Telangana. Suddenly can’t treat Andhra as outsiders when they were equal participants in building Hyderabad!
@@ASeeker-9999 already 10 years completed, more how many generations jobs will be taken
@@prashanth1882 You think capitals are built in 10 years?? It takes decades!!
I acknowledge Kannada culture but I refuse to be forced to learn it. If I am not forced then I will go ahead and learn it out of the inquisitiveness of finding out the gems hidden inside the books and culture. No babu is going to decide whether I am going to be employed in bangalore and then with his stinky breath and fat belly ask me to shell out another bribe along with all the other bribes I have to pay for, for eg., rto, bbmp, traffic cops, to cops for filing an fir, to the government babu who ask for money for attesting. This government even surpassed my bar by taking bribes from water tankers. So for all I care, for me, my respect is for Kannadigas but just as they don't like it when they are forced into something, nor do I. A green eyed bill against the people who work in Bangalore is neither doing any service for the kannadigas or Kannada nor will it be of any use to Bangloreans. 20% of state gdp comes from IT alone and this is leaving out the ITES, ancillary bussiness, sustenance and transportation as well as real estate. Even wanting to pass this bill puts the government in a suspect position. They have not taken back the bill but merely shelved it till it rears its ugly head in the background of linguistic terrorism and activism which is already prevalent in Bangalore and rest of Karnataka. Unfortunately, the people of Karnataka, whom I respect and count myself among, must not allow this government to tear us apart for votes. Even if the government t had brought the bill and passed it, it would have been thrown out by the courts. All this government wanted to do was to have done the drama, told kannadigas that they had been stabbed by the courts and then went ahead and started architecture their new evil designs. Disgusting. They pitch us common folks at each other and we like fools (me included) jump in and say and do unthinkable things with just the excuse of what we love and are passionate about in this case the language Kannada. By the way, I am a bengali who speaks 6 languages, writes 4 of them amd does not know how to write in bengali but tried learning Kannada at a basic level at the age of 40 and failed to make much success as much as my effort to learn bengali at this age because at my age I have just lost the ability to learn anything. I still forget the way home from office and use Google maps. The twisted roads that make up bengali and Kannada are way more complicated but fortunately better understood by AI translator apps. By the way, good apps for learning kannada or for that matter bengali are simply not there. Maybe siddharamaiah can work on getting the apps out of the babu app machine factory and getting some real professionals work on an AI based Kannada learning app. Then he would not have to get non kannadigas beaten up by random people for not speaking in Kannada and stirring up these troubles for everyone.
They don't have the guts to implement this law. Gutless Congress govt, bloody chors. Shameless.
My respect for kannadiga people has gone
What abt ppl who have properties here but donot know language...should we just leave Bangalore?
Yes
What else can you expect from congress other than the politics of divide and rule
Already divided into languages castes religion race ….every where locals are hired why Karnataka be the exception???
The Real problem is underdeveloped Hindi Belt States.This BHIMARAU States dont give jobs, welfare and infrastucture to hindi speaking people. So this Northis are capturing jobs in Southindia and asking Southis to speak garbage language like hindi.
Ok
Which garbage language you speak...racist southie
Soniya gandhi 🇮🇹 italy
😂😂
Have we really ascended such heights of Bharatiya Intellectual Brilliance that after "Poleryjaysun" of all Bharatiyas on the basis of Rileejun we could miraculously halt the process when it came to other aspects of diversity ? Good luck with the "One of Everything" Fillojophy !
In Karnataka, people have to be careful against congress government. another attempt to divide Hindus on the basis of linguistic boundaries by the Karnataka congress government. I love kannada but pulling language to jobs in private sector will break the states working class people along language lines, will see the demise of Bangalore and many other industrial hubs in Karnataka and will be detrimental to the people dependent on the growth story. it is unfortunate that Congress has decided to this for narrow gains and this cabinet approved bill should be struck down. it will be difficult for many parties and MLAs to vote against an emotive issue but in the long run people have to understand that this can neither be implemented and nor should be. Forcing a language and using it to create a divide amongst people is not the work of a government. Force has never produced any results. The soft power of Kannada is more than enough to ensure that the beautiful language Kannada is spoken and loved by all in India. Work against this bill and make representations and creat3 narratives so as to cause a failure of this hair brained idea and I stead we must work to popularise Kannada and produce high level content in Kannada that is understood and loved by Kannada learners. creating unrealistic laws will dishearten everyone including Kannadigas and non Kannada speakers alike. its like cheating both the kannadigas and non by creating unreal populist laws that can neither be implemented and nor should have been tried. It's failure is a win for Karnataka
Congress is dividing north and south as Rahul said so stupid
None on the panel actually understood the labour bill movement..it wasn't about culture or language..it was about a part of job reservation to the locals and not total reservation.. unemployment is the major major issue in the country itself..it's only fair to ask for a job share in the market or investors😂
There should be a 100% reservation in MP and MLA election for the local candidates, they how have studied in the constituency and should be in the constituency for 15 years with outbreak and should know the language and should have their mother in-laws in the same constituency form 15 years.
What about the Muslims of Karnataka, who doesn't speak kannada at all, are they not eligible for jobs in Karnataka.
Local means Indian, in the era of globalisation local doesn't matter they are taking foreign project
Good decision 💛❤️
I am a kannadiga,born and brought up in Karnataka. , I have never learnt kannada in school at all.
That's your fault
@@boss9801 ಬಡ್ಡಿ ಮಕ್ಳ shove up your jobs, up yours. I am happy and prosperous in other state.
When politicians can't give jobs what they do is implement reservations🥴
It company need english language ..not kannada ,Tamil or hindi...when they cant compete with north Indian ...they start crying...just like neet exam...😂😂😂
Plain and simple this would be struck down by the courts......
Please implement this so that the companies start moving to other states.
To where? UP, Bihar or MP? 😅😂
@@kkvjkumarGujarat Maharashtra WB Orissa etc etc
@@ujjayanbhowmik8259 yeah, MH, GJ & WB has a lot of educated people.
I’m not sure about Orissa though. It’s not a BIMARU state, so I believe the literacy rate would be high.
None of the states you’ve listed made any attempts to woo the IT companies in B’lore. See what Chandra Babu Naidu of AP did. So the chances of what you mentioned happening is very slim.
@@kkvjkumarjust implement grandu and u ppl will be jobIess faster😂
@@cod_mw5675 grandu means what? Let me guess…you’re a Brahmin from one of the cow belt states. So you’ve a backup job…go naked and beg for petty coins. Good for you!!
100% reservation in such jobs for Brahmins. On top of that 10% reservation everywhere else. Sky falls if someone else is getting some reservation!
In a democracy you can't force to speak this language taht langauage this is against idea of democracy
Does Hyderabad has similar policy? I doubt the state is also ruled by congis, i have a doubt they will implement that there only... Its time cities like Ahmedabad, bhopal etc to take advantage of this and get companies for all
What if we start not using made in banglore product , they give land for money kandada peole already earning lot by giving house in rent , langauge 'gundai' must be stop barkha's agenda is language division ...
Guys guys guys let's focus on work from home jobs
He is stammering without clear knowledge i see how much skilled he is mistamilesh 😂 disparity discrimination on locals is going on from 4 to 5 decades...we follow mumbai city model.
If you want heterogeneous society there is place for that that's there is 50 or 70 percent reservation. If they wanted they would order 100 percent reservation
Please agree with tamil guy pls go to tamilnadu lets hope no discrimination happens 😂 atleast 10%
Muhabbat ki dukan
Hegde is isn't this intolerance n fascism.
Bharka I speak 6 Indian languages. The prime resentment most South Indians have against the north is their absolute hostility to speak any other language other than Hindi. This is the issue.
Jai sidramayya💛❤️
It tech do not vote so they will get such divisive government
Cm dy cm can't speak decent English bloody shameful