The story of Lut is not about gayness it's about rape
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- The story of Lut is not about gayness it's about rape 🙄. The great scholar of Tafseer Miss or Mister not sure what she wants to go by tells us that these patriarchal interpretations for 1400 plus years are are at fault and that him and her LGBQT league of experts have finally made a breakthrough. O ye and some of our shaikhs HAVE TO STOP SAYING WE ARE ONLY CONDEMNING THE BEHAVIOUR NOT THE ORIENTATION. COMMON BRUH! This is a half way propaganda to fool our Muslims. The action Is what gets the punishment but its what starts it that needs to be fixed in order to never get to the action.
Why not sponsor this video or other videos for 3 $ a month? Yes you can get the reward and help me educate people around the world 🌎.
Click / galromaani
or send via PayPal gibreelk@gmail.com
Order my NEW BOOK Journal of a New Muslim newmuslimjourn...
I don’t think you guys understand how dangerous of a time we’re living in as an Ummah.
All cause of America
Exactly. It terrifies me greatly, to be honest. Those muslim people who take quran as though it was a mere hystorical book. And simply interpret those ayah based on logical thinking. Geez. I’m scared.
@@khizerqureshi2492 No because of your own actions. Stop blaming everyone and everything, fix yourself.
@@elafzal5866 were talking about this video here dumbass. America spreads, encourages and influences the world to make it ok to be gay.
@@khizerqureshi2492 Actually I don't think that's fair to say. As I'm not American yet the ideology has permeated my culture too. And as the brother said before, Which I support wholeheartedly, we have a mandatory obligation to fix ourselves. It's about time each of us does this instead of pointing the finger. That hasn't helped anything in our age. Not in our age where so many are astray. Myself not excluded. May Allah guide us to truth and save us from that which harms us
If you read the Arabic verse, it explicitly says men approaching men for lust. Not rape. The word lust is used. "Shahwa"
Even you understand this fact.
@@testing-je7yz yes, even me...
a man approaches another man for lust meaning that he wants to rape him, theres no consent between those both men
Its shahwa,not love
@@arasmirvani9400 yes?
Who was the first person to say it was rape? Which desperate person came up with this idea to justify and create sympathy for an act that a whole city was destroyed. Also lut's wife who was a sympathiser was destroyed too with them. People need to wake up, it's the thought that becomes the action if you don't control it.
Jazak Allaahu khairen brother Gibrael to make it clear.
@Sasha Khan Have you read it? It mentions:
“Verily, you practise your lusts on men instead of women. Nay, but you are a people transgressing beyond bounds (by committing great sins)’”
[al-A’raaf 7:81]
Actual Quran quotes are in the quote marks.
@Sasha Khan
did you even watch the complete video?
that argument has been put to an end... Allaah said in the quraan why do you lust after men instead of women....
if you say it means, why do you rape men instead if women
do you think raping women for men is permissible?
@Sasha Khan Sister don’t let western hedonistic lack of morals make you question the truth in Islam. We understand the Quran and Ahadith according to the Salaf. The companions their students and their students. NaseehaSessions has a good vid on this.
Some coconut
@Sasha Khan did you even watch the video?
The person in the first video clearly had NEVER read the Quran. May Allah guide us.
Indeed true
or had preconceived notions and then reinterpreted the Quran
Ahmen the all Sick and Blind
And I couldn't tell for a sec if it's a boy or a girl.
@@xox8717 im still confused since i muted the vedio lol.XD
MashaAllah Tabarakallah!May Allah increase you in guidance, knowledge,wisdom,bravery and protect you.amin
Ameen
Wait his wife was a sympathizer? Not a betrayer? I thought she betrayed him when she saw the beautiful men (angels) in his house and told the villagers
@@kel8776 I am sure she tried to betray him and by the next motioning lud (as) and his two daughters were told by allah to leave. His wife and the rest of the town were destroyed.
Ameen
Ameen
Astagrifullah you cant argue with Allah s commandments. Without saying much on my private past (b4 i was muslim alhamdelillah) , this homosexual influence, especially now, is VERY strong. Its pushed on you everywhere to accept it as natural and even respect this lifestyle. Allah please guide us and protect us against the non belivers ameen
Ameen ameen ya rabb
Wdym before you were Muslim?
@@trajictempr8574 it means that he's a revert
@@theynish bruh so hes a non beleiver yet he asks Allah to guide him and protect him even tho he doesn't beleive in him
@@bad8905no my friend he is a believer, he said he was a non believer in the past but now he is a believer
The first person shouldnt distort the Quraan , the Quraan was already laid down as a guidance for over 1400 years ago , good job once again brother Gabriel
exactly how do you know that the quran hasn’t been changed by humans?
@@loafy1349 because it doesn't get 7 updates per month like the bible
@@loafy1349 we very well know for the fact, no quraan differ from one to another
Who is your lord grave first question
@@radialvaris9054 wife back door not allowed ect
Ppl lie to justify their desires
Right. When they don't condemn the desire or inclination it's like saying "it's ok to want to murder somebody in a gruesome manner but the action is impermisisble" No. Both are wrong and must be prevented.
Absoluteley right. But you can't assume someone who is so sick, will ever be fully healthy. Yeah they have to work on themselves, but you cannot assume they will ever be perfect. It's like people with severe mental disorder will get better but never be fully healthy you know. I think we should condemn the action and say the intention is sick, but don't condemn the people if they try but cant get their intentions fully healthy...
What abt psychopaths or sociopaths who are muslim with bad thoughts but they try to not show it in their actions
So we need mind police ?
@@sadiaahmadzai6607 there is no sin on the insane until they regain their sanity, so if you are a truly psychopathic person you may be insane and gain no sins
it's not like that. we don't kill or hurt anybody it's other people who does that to us. Doesn't matter how hard we try, we are not attracted to females. many people have suicided cuz of this because it not not accepted by society or Allah :( even if they marry.. they just pretending to love their wife and leading her life into false love which is harmful and sad for both of them. Really wish Allah accepts us who we are.
I understand where brother gabriel is coming from. If you don't condemn the feelings or desires in regards to the orientation inside you, how do you recognise that this is a problem in itself and you have to strive to change this. If we continue to accept that the feelings inside you cannot be changed, then we will not persevere to correct. We need people who stop sugar coating and say how it is
Absolutely spot on!! Imagine, anyone can be like; I have a tendency to want to murder someone everyday but I don't have to work on getting rid of that thought because it's wrong as long as I don't act upon it it's okay because that's just me..what????
@@MAhmed-zs2vp ikr. Dumb society and dumb people. No wonder the world is so messed uo
The feelings can't be changed, and frankly they are none of your or any one's business.
As long as people don't act on irrational feelings, they are safe.
Just like the irrational feeling of wanting to m*rder someone because your angry exists, other things exist too.
Actions are what you're accountable for.
@@DiamondsRexpensive no feeling an be stopped if u keep on praying and asking Allah swt to take it away and protect me from bad thoughts.
100% agreed, one follows the other, thoughts lead to action. One must learn to master and control their thoughts in order to master their actions
Sexual orientation isn't voluntary and isn't just an "idea" in your mind. It's an automatic response. I don't experience anyyy sexual attractions towards women (opposite sex) whatsoever, yet I do experience sexual urges towards men. How prayer and tazkiya are goina fix this? Orientation means *to whom* are you attracted. It isn't simply a thought, you won't reallly understand this until you're exclusively attracted to the same sex as yours. I quote "oh, it is easy for the one who stands outside the prison-wall of pain to exhort and teach the one who suffers. " -Aeschylus
Big up brother romaani, mashallah one of the realist Muslim brother on CZcams he ain’t here to please people apart for pleasing Allah. Keep up the good work my brother Alhamdulillah your a real gangster may Allah protect you and your family. Real bad man 👊🏿 mashallah
3ajib how these people can publicly challenge Quranic verses and then also try to act as if they are muslims... really diabolical
They are ckryptojhewus, please forgive my misspelling, it is intentional for good reason.
Subhan Allah the ayat are clear. Allah cut off any way to re-interpret these ayat knowing that these deviants will come later and try to misinterpret
Jazakallahu kheiran for clarification and May Allah protect all of us and guide our children Amiin
Blurr out the person in the beginning please.
What even is that??
He's a man no worries
Mashallah we need more people talking about this! Great video!
In regards to the beginning of the video, All the scholars have said acting on homosexuality was haram. There wasn't and isn't a difference of opinion. Imam Abu hanifa was born less then 100 years after Muhammed SAW passed away. The Islamic fiqh, understanding and influence was still very strong and they said it was haram. Almost a thousand and half years later, people want to say otherwise.
JazakAllah khair brother for keeping it real!
Jazakallah
Thank you so much
I really hope and wish everyone would understand this
Inshallah
Quran 27:56: "Do you lustfully approach men instead of women? No, you are an ignorant people."
Quran 81-82: "You approach men with lust instead of women. No, you are a people who go beyond the limits."
there, fixed your doubt
فَمَا كَانَ جَوَابَ قَوْمِهِ إِلاَّ أَن قَالُوۤاْ أَخْرِجُوۤاْ آلَ لُوطٍ مِّن قَرْيَتِكُمْ إِنَّهمْ أُنَاسٌ يَتَطَهَّرُونَ }
But the only response of his people was that they said ‘Expel Lot’s family from your town. They are indeed a folk who prefer to remain pure!’ from coming unto the rears of men.
Tanwîr al-Miqbâs min Tafsîr Ibn ‘Abbâs
{ فَمَا كَانَ جَوَابَ قَوْمِهِ إِلاَّ أَن قَالُوۤاْ أَخْرِجُوۤاْ آلَ لُوطٍ مِّن قَرْيَتِكُمْ إِنَّهمْ أُنَاسٌ يَتَطَهَّرُونَ }
(But the answer of his folk was naught save that they said: Expel the household of Lot) Lot and his two daughters: Za'ura and Raytha (from your township) Sodom, (for they (forsooth) are folk who would keep clean) they exonerate themselves from sodomy!
@@hassan333wayh💜💜
excellent EXCELLENT points and so TRUE.
may Allaah Subhaanahu wa Taalah give us ilmun nafiun. aameen
My Allah SWT, grand you jannah for this beautiful explanation of nafs, Nia and the actions. Thank you a lot
Can you put the captions in quotes ("") along with this emoji ->(🙄) ?
so that people might not misunderstand .....(they might think that the video caption (without quotes) itself... is your opinion 😅)
I think what the shiekh from the one path network was trying to say is that it is not a sin to have that feeling or thoughts rather the action counts as the SIN. As for the feeling, it is wrong and work should be put in to fix it to lead a pious life but the feeling and thoughts can't be counted as sin. As four your point about the deeds being based on intention, I completely agree with you. Our scholars have been focused so much on convincing people that homosexual ACTS themselves are wrong and sinful, which these people have made permissible for themselves, that they forgot to think about the other aspects of it, i.e focusing on the Thoughts. Great job Shiekh, You need to be heard by more people.
yea monks also have feeling but they overcome it (a bit off topic thou)
@@15.azamsiddiqui54 i don’t think they overcome it
Bro why are people making their version of Islam? Like it’s soo simple to follow what is already
May Allah forgive and protect all Muslims dead or alive and grant us jannah by His mercy Aameen yaa Rabb🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼
May peace and blessings of Allah be upon our beloved prophet his companions and entire household✨✨✨
Ideal, clear point of view. Thank you very much, Mr. Gabriel
Quran
. "Verily, you practice your lusts on men instead of women. Nay, but you are a people transgressing beyond bounds (by such sins)."(7:81)
The bible
Do not lie with a man as one lies with a woman; that is detestable" (Leviticus 18:22) and "If a man lies with a man as one lies with woman, both of them have done what is detestable. They must be put to death; their blood will be on their own heads" (Leviticus 20:13).
I don’t think these ppl have read the Quran or the Bible because both of these books CLEARLY condemn homosexuality in more places than just the story of Lut.... so what’s the argument against the other verses...? 🧐
I have to disagree slightly brother. A person who has these inclinations cannot be sinful for simply having them- that's the meaning of condemnation. If you tell them you are condemning what they feel inside you will push them away and they will feel emotional and think their very existence is considered wrong, they will turn to the mainstream LGBT crowd who will not only accept them but also encourage them to act on their nafs.
Instead we should acknowledge that the inclination is there and is a test from Allah. The solution is to build Taqwa, come closer to Allah, control that inclination and not feed it. And the reward will be even greater in the Hereafter inshaAllah.
I think your point is that controlling the inclination and not letting it control you is right. My issue is just with the word "condemning what's in the inside" this has the tendency to push people away to the LGBT community.
you are separating intentions and action, which is something you should not do. If someone is intent with the fact that "they are born like that" or "that's how they feel" its only a matter of time before these thoughts ruin someone and they do the sin. At the end of the day that is a feeling that they are talking about. Its like someone saying "I don't feel that getting married is for me ", that will soon turn into fornication. Then what will people like you say, turn away? you have to deal with the problem where it stems from. There was a hadeeth of the prophet(PBUH) of 2 people who wanted to kill each other. They had the INTENT and 1 of them did kill the other. But they both went to hellfire. When asked why the victim also went to hell, The prophet(PBUH) said that he had an equal amount of intent to kill the other guy its just he got killed first. This means the intention and thoughts count as sins brother. This means that Allah knew if the victim did see him, he would surely have killed him first. so thinking of such acts like homosexuality and saying that's how I feel Will indeed lead you to sinful acts which makes the thought sinful. And Allah knows your intentions regardless if you get a chance to do the sin, and that makes it a sin upon you if you have those intentions because it shows your are not pious and pure and respecting Allah's boundaries. And Allah knows best
@@loeymohamed7703 I think I've already mentioned that the intention has to be controlled.
@@loeymohamed7703 so Allah made homosexuals for failure?
@@eduardo42897 no rather Allah made us and we all have our own obstacles that we must fight on a daily basis, to each their own. Some people drink and try their best to stop. Same with homosexuality, it is something that has to be reflected on and understood that it’s not the right thing to do. The seuxaul act and the thought
I think what Gabriel is trying to say is to hate the intention and try to change it and not think “ ok there’s nothing wrong with me” when there is and it need to be fixed, also you said something about pushing them away and I disagree we don’t hide the truth or sugar coat it for other people’s feelings, yes it should be said in a certain way but we shouldn’t hide the fact that the intention is wrong and should be changed and not just suppressed, if they get upset and leave we have done our job that’s on them.
You are Clear Like Water ...and I really Like It About you Brother ♥......Jazakallahu khayran, lots Of Love Brother , May Allah Grant You Jannah !
Ameen
You are so right brother. This is complete nonsense. You need to control your behavior and actions.
I think the sheigh is referring to attraction which cannot be helped but thoughts can be worked on. I'm attracted to women, but I should try and focus to keep my desires under control by not fascinating over women or having impure thoughts. But attraction cannot be controlled. The nafs are desires which we need to try and control by being aware of them and not acting on the desire. There is no sin on having desire because we are human but what makes us different is the ability to not act on those desires. Just my opinion... Shukran for the videos
Very well said brother. I agree with you 500%.
He's mentioned good points in advising people, tazkiyatun nafs and naseeha
I am a revert. Before I made hijra out of the US I sat with me mother (I thought she was still a "Christian" but found out that night she was now an Athiest; she supports LGBT) who argued that the story of Lut AS in the Bible was just about pedophilia- adult men fornicating with boys.
So I went to the Greek Bible on Bible Hub and I showed her the Greek that shows it is talking about "Males" going to "men (adult)" rather than "Females"- in Greek. And then I found the word for young boy and what-not and showed that the words don't match up to prove her claim.
And then she mocked Prophet Lut AS because, in the Bible, after he left his hometown his two daughters took turns to make him drunk and then raped him so that they could conceive because there were no other men around.
And I told her that this is within the Bible, but nowhere does it exist within the Qur'an.
Her response is that she doesn't need the Qur'an because she is satisfied with her "romance books". She has read these so much my whole life that she neglected being a wife to my father and a mother to me my entire childhood.
It is sad to see people make arguments without research (something she taught me to do when I was younger) and then reject the Qur'an illogical and ignorantly.
Her claims that the old "patriarchal" and sexist interpretations are invalid and the new modern on is more legitimate. Especially since we are more "woke" now and words change meaning over time.
wow thats crazy. do you still talk to her??
May Allah guide her.
What is a" romance books" ?. And it's crazy how society is going backwards instead of forwards and. Claim this is "progression" .
@@xixizizi6970
Fantasy novels about a man and woman falling in love, sometimes written with sexual details.
@@asiyaheibhlin ohhh . Those things. Ah yes. My friend's used to write about them and used to tell me to read 'em . I used to refuse tho.
"Do you approach men with desire instead of women? Rather you are a people behaving ignorantly".
Surah An-naml, ayah 55
Fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 never ends for disbelievers
It's like "lose your Imaan and become a Murtaad, just don't tell anyone and you will still be a Muslim". What a nonsense argument. Being a Muslim is all about what is in your heart. The action comes later.
God bless you Gabriel
•The Quran is intricate precise and complete. There was never a need to change not even a syllable in the Quran as it’s the word of Allah (SWT) any alteration in the religion is prohibited. (This is a sign of the final hours.)
I HAVE BEEN SAYING THIS FOREVER. It will never be "its how I am, its natural". This is because the verse on Lut(PBUH) in the Holy Quran mentions homosexuals saying "approach" in arabic that means to get closer. Allah is conveying that its not just the physical approach but the thought of approaching, because he didnt use the arabic word for literal going towards. But this is not the point. My point is for the people who say "I was born like this" or the imams who say the feeling is not condemned. IT IS! If Allah is the all knowing and he created you in such a way that would make you feel aroused towards the same sex, why would he do such a horrible thing to the people of Lut(PBUH)?? OBVIOUSLY because he did not create us this WAY. ALLAH has made it a sin and punished them for what they did and saying that he made you this way would presume that you are saying Allah has made a mistake. who has made a mistake, you or your creator? Truly Allah is all knowing and ever wise, and he did not make you that way and you are the mistaken ones, your influenced by gay acts and relationships all over the internet and in our faces because of the internet since young and this affects you mentally so much that you start to like the same sex and think its ok. May ALLAH help this ummah. amen
Your right, but i think approach means the sexual act. In sura 2 222 also uses the word approach (i do not know if it is the same arabic word) for the sexual act with mensturating women. I do not say that the gay feeling is normal, no certanly it is sick, but I do think that it is a little far stretched to interpret that the feeling is menchend because of the word "approach". Again the feeling is wrong also, but I do not think that the evidence can be this word. Please correct me if it is not the same word in arabic.
I'm pretty sure people are accountable for their actions, not what they think about.
English is not my mother tongue, but what Im perceived by the Seikh said regarding "inclination" is that its okay to have uncontrolled thoughts that cross mind that just "came out of nothing". But I admit that he should add the notiom that these thoughts are NOT to be followed and indeed we should do istighfar in that case.
So like we suddenly feel upset when we encounter our Boss in the office and we thought bad thing about him, I dont think thats a sin. What important is the next step: to follow that upset feeling like by making plan of making his Boss day's bad (which is a sin) or to do istighfar and being husnuzhon (which is an achievement of passing the test)
These people change the Quranic interpretations to satisfy their needs! Homosexuality is prohibited in Islam and in all religions! 🚫
He didn't say "if that's eho you are"
Sexual orientation isn't voluntary and isn't just an "idea" in your mind. It's an automatic response. I don't experience anyyy sexual attractions towards women (opposite sex) whatsoever, yet I do experience sexual urges towards men. How prayer and tazkiya are goina fix this? Orientation means *to whom* are you attracted. It isn't simply a thought, you won't reallly understand this until you're exclusively attracted to the same sex as yours. I quote "oh, it is easy for the one who stands outside the prison-wall of pain to exhort and teach the one who suffers. " -Aeschylus
Most people quite don't understand orientation / sexuality and saying it's just a desire is BS.
Finally I got the answer.
Jazakallah Khire Brother Gabriel✨. May Allah SWT bless you abundantly. Ameen✨
I agree with what your saying and I know what your trying to say, but if you have the feeling you don’t just sit like that that’s not what the sheikh was saying ofc you control and work on your inside but you aren’t punished for things that are in your head.
One path network absolutely exposed them
Falsehood has no root to stand and hold on.
Truth hurts
Truth is sour
God bless the righteous ulama and teachers
SO what are you supposed to do about the feeling to get rid of the feeling? Someone help
This chap is making sense. Thanks brother.
The first individual clearly has no knowledge of the Quran! As always May Allah reward you immensely for speaking truth and not watering Dow the religion !
Great video, very much needed. 👍
Dangerous times these days, may Allah guide us
No, the people who believe the Qur'an without questioning anything are dangerous. Many gays take their own lives because of sicko extrimists like in the video above
Jazakhulah khair may allah swt reward you and bless you . I agree with you brother gabriel
Among the Jews are those who distort words from their [proper] places [i.e., usages] and say, "We hear and disobey" and "Hear but be not heard" and "Rāʿinā,"[1] twisting their tongues and defaming the religion. And if they had said [instead], "We hear and obey" and "Wait for us [to understand]," it would have been better for them and more suitable. But Allāh has cursed them for their disbelief, so they believe not, except for a few. [2]
QS. An Nisa': 46
English Shahih International.
Brother Gabriel is a very good brother ma shaa Allah👍👍👍👍👍
ITS HARM FULL STOP
The last brother is 100% right.
Non can change the inner manhood.
You are right my brother Gabriel. But as far as I understand, most scholars do not imply their acceptance of the inclination by saying so, but instead they mean that as long as you curb your lust and not act upon it you are not to be condemned. But indeed explicit clarification of this point was needed given that people who follow their lust blindly are even inclined to manipulate Quran and the hadiths. Of course they would not hesitate implementing the same tactics on statements coming from Islamic scholars.
The sinners source was no where, they didn’t show any type of proof to back up their claims. And when the sheikh was correcting them, he came with proof to back up his claims.
From Quran:
1- "Verily, you practice your lusts on men instead of women. Nay, but you are a people transgressing beyond bounds (by committing great sins)" [Qur'an 7:80-81]
2- "Verily, We sent against them a violent storm of stones (which destroyed them all), except the family of Lut (Lot), them We saved in the last hour of the night." [Qur'an 54:34]
3- "And (remember) Lut (Lot), when he said to his people: 'You commit Al-Fahishah (sodomy the worst sin) which none has preceded you in (committing) it in the 'Alamin (mankind and jinn) [Qur'an 29:28]
4- "And (remember) Lut (Lot), We gave him Hukm (right judgement of the affairs and Prophethood) and (religious) knowledge, and We saved him from the town (folk) who practiced Al-Khabaith (evil, wicked and filthy deeds). Verily, they were a people given to evil, and were Fasiqun (rebellious, disobedient to Allah)" [Qur'an 21:74]
From Sunnah:
I-Jabir" said that "The Prophet (pbuh) said: "There is nothing I fear for my ummah more than the deed of the people of Lut(pbuh) (Having intercourse with same sex)." (Narrated by al-Tirmidhi, 1457; Ibn Majah, 2563, Sahih by Shaykh al Albani Rahimahullah in Sahih al-Jami', no. 1552).
2- Ibn 'Abbas said: "The Prophet (pbuh) said: "... cursed is the one who has intercourse with an animal, cursed is the one who does the action of the people of Lut(pbuh)." [sex with same gender(Gay, lesbian)] (Narrated by Ahmad, 1878. This hadith was classed as sahih by
Shaykh al-Albani in Sahih al-Jami', no. 5891).
3-Ibn 'Abbas said: "The Prophet (pbuh) said: 'Whoever you find doing the deed of the people of Lut, kill the one who does it and the one to whom it is done." (Narrated by al-Tirmidhi, 1456; Abu Dawud, 4462; Ibn Majah, 2561.
Jhazakallahu Khayran Brother.
Mashallah very good important point. The intention is more important than the action itself. The people who say Islam has nothing to do with your thoughts but has something to do with your actions actually don't understand that Islam came to purify the our harts in first place.
having desire of doing something haram is not ok in Islam, we should know that.
Gay or Straight... We have to control our lustful thoughts... When we have such thoughts we have to steer our minds away from that & Do productive activities or have good thoughts...
Constantly say:
La Hawla Wala Quwwata Illa Billah
She is twisting it.
If you had murderous thoughts but at the same time feared Allah you would do your best to suppress them and get rid of these thoughts right? Cause you know if you don’t you would act on it…same principle applies to homosexual thoughts…may Allah protect us
next week: tafsir with mickey mouse.
Allahu ul musta'an
Lmao
I agree with you brother, imam probably didn't word it accurately enough. He actually tried to say that the inclination or the impulse is involuntary. This is true about the first appearance of the idea or thought, but then what do you do about that thought in your mind is the action of your heart, either you take refuge or you explore it further which increases the probability of acting upon it.
Their tongues will burn for saying slander. Why do people try to justify what Allah made haram? Why are they changing the teachings of Allah and his rasul. Indeed a severe punishment is waiting for them.
Thank you for making it clear
She is lost her mind. May allah guide her.
Islam is the most logical and reasonable religion. The question that comes into play is whether WE are willing to give up our EMOTIONS to accept the truth.
I advise you check Hadith 5590 in Sahih Al-Bukhari and it’s explanation + exceptions in regards to musical instruments’ prohibition
may Allah bless you
The sheikh point from one path network was good but the ending ....really needed criticism..
Can you upload subtitles to the video please?
Self claimed experts,,, and self claimed PhD degree’s,,, singing it 365 just to get Zombism going.
They do nothing but distorting the meanings of the Quran, we take the meanings collectively from all the verses talked about those people and then to what the Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him, and then the companions of the prophet who existed in the time of revelation and spoke excellent Arabic and understood the Quran in the right way.
We live in dangerous time man
Look at her eyebrows 😂😂😂😂
What "purification" will change the sexual attraction to the same sex?
It won't change anything tbh ; it's just a way of suppression.
I understand the need to respond bother. May Allah bless you but could you blur the woman put?
I had a gay Christian uber driver once explain this to me. He said the scripture said nothing about homosexuality. I asked him to elaborate he said the story has nothing to do with homosexuality.
Thats what happen when you ignorant to study and came out your own interpretations about verses in quran
Assalamu 'akaykum
Maybe you should put quotes around the title or make it clear that this isn't the view that you hold
Maybe do that for other videos with similar titles as well
The Q in LGBTQ stands for Qawmi Lūt.
Rasuallah said that Allah has forgiven this Ummah for whatever comes to them. Akhii Shytaan also whispers to people. He needs to control inside and outside.
Well said
Not them twisting the words of Quran 💀
This is right way to say it.jezakellah
Imagine trying to distort allah words into saying it was about only rape
ZazakAllah Khairan!
2:36 exactly Same thought came in my mind few days before.
Actions are like water in a pot and the desires are like fire beneath it. Your desires(orientation ) boils your actions and make it visible to the world.
Remember brothers and sisters,Qur'an and sunnah always the guidance for us muslim.. Story of luth based Qur'an and sunnah already told us a lot about how Allah and Prophet condemn the action. May Allah guide us into the right path.
Explanation to verse 7:81 or the "Anti-gay" verse.
People often bring up verse 7:81 with out any context to show why the Quran forbids gay people and thinks that gay sex is haram, I'm here to give the full context and show why their wrong.
For those who don't know, verse 7:81 say's something like "Indeed, you approach men with desire, instead of women. Rather, you are a transgressing people." Which sounds bad alone until you actually take into full context what it means.
The verse is talking about the village of Lot who were actively RAPING men, not just having sex with them (a major problem in the world back then as both the Romans and Greeks were known to rape other males). As in their lust had become so overwhelming that women weren't enough anymore, they had to attack visitors (a big no no in Islamic culture) and rape them even though they where guys. The people of Lot where so depraved that they literally tried to rape angels before being wiped out so it's a warning against the depravity of rape instead of homosexuality in general as no where in the Quran, unlike the bible, does it say anything against gay sex.
The verse literally right before it say's something like (plenty of translations but roughly) "How do you commit such a horrible that NO ONE/THING BEFORE YOU HAVE COMMITTED". This can't mean homosexuality as we know homosexuality in animals does exist and homosexuality was very well known to just about every person on the planet as shocker, gay people have always existed. Historically speaking, the Code of Hammurabi , which ordered society in most of the Tigris-Euphrates Valley for more than a thousand years, has nothing to say about homosexuality. The laws of Eshunna and Egypt are also silent on the subject with us knowing that there were ancient Egyptian gay couples including a Pharaoh who was more then likely bi. The Hittites forbade father-son relations, but that was part of a general rule against incest. The Assyrians thought it shameful for a man to repeatedly offer himself to other men, and also prohibited men from raping males of the same social class, but all other male-male sexual relations were ignored. These are all states that were around centuries before Sodom and Gomorrah were apparently destroyed destroyed. The much more rational explanation would be they made an entire society based on rape of men and other "abominations" to a point where they would kick people out for wanting to stay "pure" (line 7:82), something that no group of people before them have done.
Now people will often say "if it's bad raping man then it's ok if we rape woman right?" well no. This is because when you take it with the previous verse and the verse after it, it's clear that these people wanted the pleasure of doing something that no other group of people had ever done which was the mass rape/normalization of rape of men. It's absolutely horrible but the rape of women was a lot more normalized back than and so wouldn't fit with the previous line of them doing something that no group of people/creatures had ever done before. That also explains why they didn't except Lot's daughter (which could be interpreted as him trying to save them because the angels didn't take to kindly to wanting to be raped) as they got their rocks off by doing what no other people had ever done which was to mass rape men, not women which again, is also disgusting but a lot more normal back then.
To go more into Islamic history courtesy of u/cold-blue, The grand mufti of the Abbasid caliphate in the mid-9th century, Yahya ibn Aktham, was a known homosexual, and viewed a few verses through the gender/sexuality lens.
One of them was the verse where Allah says He prepares males for some, females for others, and mixes the males and females. I’ve read that ibn Aktham once said that this verse confused people because it alludes to sexual preferences. He also said that the heavenly cupbearers mentioned in the Quran are sexual rewards like the houris. (Whether or not homosexuality is allowed in Jannah was debated, and some came to the conclusion that it is, and the only reason it isn’t in this life is because the rectum is dirty.)
The Ottoman empire, the last caliphate of the Muslim world, not only didn't care about gay people (unlike the Europeans) but actually had art depicting it.
Another is al-Razi. While he didn’t outright say that homosexuality is allowed, he allowed gay couples to be together sexually so long as they didn’t have anal sex. He was concerned with homosexual men committing suicide over their innate feelings and said that if there is risk of that, and the man cannot change himself from homosexual to heterosexual/survive in an opposite-sex marriage, he may be with his beloved (a man) so long as he does not transgress the limits (in his opinion, anal sex).
One of the transmitters of the Quranic variants we have today (of which Warsh and Hafs are two) was a man named al-Kisa’i, who was also a known homosexual. So one of the seven qira’ats came from a gay man.
There was another man ALSO named al-Kisa’i, who was a historian in 1100 CE, and he said in his Stories of the Prophets (Qiṣaṣ al-'Anbiyā') that the people of Lut were specifically MEN WITH WIVES who raped other men, not homosexual men, lining up with what we know historically.
And speaking even more so on the physical element, the male "gspot" is actual in the anus which even if you find gross, is a design of Allah and not a flaw. Why would he do that if homosexuality is a sin?
The reason homosexuality is so hated in the Islamic world is none other then the heretical Salafi and Wahhabi movements (actually considered heretics for most of the time they were around including their top scholars, not my opinion, and the only reason their not now is because of British) and because of Europeans as homosexual relationships were generally tolerated in pre-modern Islamic societies, and historical records suggest that these laws were invoked infrequently, mainly in cases of rape or other "exceptionally blatant infringement on public morals". Public attitudes toward homosexuality in the Muslim world underwent a marked negative change starting from the 19th century through the gradual spread of Islamic fundamentalist movements such as Salafism and Wahhabism, and the influence of the sexual notions and restrictive norms prevalent in Europe at the time: a number of Muslim-majority countries have retained criminal penalties for homosexual acts enacted under European colonial rule.
People often only bring up verse 7:81 and don't bring the verses directly previous or after it nor does it take into consideration the histography of their actions and the verse. It would be like me saying a book said "...kill all black people." but not elaborating and saying that the line previous to is says "These people were so horrible that they would regularly chant..." and the line after it is "I can't believe they would say/do something so disgusting." with the entire context of the book being that they would kick out anyone who didn't want to kill all black people. They only say's that the book said to kill all black people. It's very disingenuous to say the least.
To further prove my point, the word "sodomite" is often used to mean the rape of another person through the ass, not consensual sex between the two. If you google "sodomized" than you'll see rapists, not a loving consensual couple. Even the Arabic words for "sodomite" and a gay person is different as sodomite is literally translated into "lut" well a gay person is translated into "shakhs mithliu aljins".
To get more philosophical about it, sex is not some fetish which just develops in people, it is the most primal human desire that a person can have. So why would Allah make a group (there's homosexual animals as well) a certain way and then say not to follow the most basic desire they'll ever have right after wanting food and water but then say the rest of that group can follow that desire after they get married? People can control their desires until marriage as the Quran makes clear, they don't just never have sex. So why would it be any different for a gay couple? This is like saying that sex with it self is haram.
Finally, people often forget the fact that Allah is an all loving and all knowing being so why would he make certain people that he hates or want's other people to hate aka be "phobic" of when in the Quran it's made clear that we should be loving and affectionate? Now even if after all of this people still believe homosexuality is haram, Allah is said multiple time to be all loving, all understanding and all forgiving so as long they are good people and don't commit a truly horrible sin (shirk aka worship of other false gods, rape, murder, hurting others, you know, the classics) Allah will inevitably forgive them for giving into their most basic human desire especially if it's with a loving partner with in a marriage so why would anyone else have a problem with them?
I'm not gonna add a tl;dr because I worked waaay to hard on this for it be condensed into a few sentences and I really want people to read it and fully understand where it's coming from.
If you read the verse before this you'll find that it's mention that they were doing an immoral act that others previously were not involved in , and specifically mentions it in the next verse that they LUST over men .
Why would people interpret a verse to mean r*pe , and come up with backstories about them first raping women then they wanted more and started raping men.
My brother if a person wants to interpret a verse by bringing in things that sound compelling but is baseless within the deen then you get people that blow themselves up or people who say that only alcohol is haram but weed , meth , heroine, etc are halal or having relations with animals is not a problem etc .
To understand the context ones should understand the word Al 'aalamiin meant. Nouman Ali Khan explained in a good way to understand the world al 'aalamiin ini tafseer of surah Al Fatihah.
Fyi, Al 'aalamiin means the worlds of people's.
Al-Kahfi 18:1
ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَنزَلَ عَلَىٰ عَبْدِهِ ٱلْكِتَٰبَ وَلَمْ يَجْعَل لَّهُۥ عِوَجَاۜ
English - Sahih International
[All] praise is [due] to Allāh, who has sent down upon His Servant [Muḥammad (ﷺ)] the Book and has not made therein any deviance.[1]
and this is what Allah says
Al-A'raf 7:80
وَلُوطًا إِذْ قَالَ لِقَوْمِهِۦٓ أَتَأْتُونَ ٱلْفَٰحِشَةَ مَا سَبَقَكُم بِهَا مِنْ أَحَدٍ مِّنَ ٱلْعَٰلَمِينَ
English - Sahih International
And [We had sent] Lot when he said to his people, "Do you commit such immorality as no one has preceded you with from among the worlds [i.e., peoples]?
العلمين
@@spiderspider1384 read my reply brother
You are the best example of the people who will follow the masseh Al dajal at the end of time
People like you who re-interprit the quran just so they can't lust how much they want
And also are hadeeths out of question??
And saying that the verse only talks about rape is fucking stupid because it doesn't and the context doesn't say so + are you saying quran said then it's ok to rape women?
I think while you are right so is the sheikh bc it goes without saying that control of the external action means internal control.
Sad sad sad what lead son of Adam to this situation Allah guide them
I don't know if i completely agree on this point akhi. For example drinking alcohol, no one will ever claim that this is in someones genes or that he is born on wanting to drink alcohol. But if someone really wants to drink alcohol and he enjoys drinking alcohol and at the same time knows that it is haram so he refuses to drink it, why would this then wrong? Yes ofcourse he will need to try and purify his inside and try to lessen the desire but him recognising that it is something bad and trying his best to not fall into into it is a very good thing imo. Dont you agree?
Just a sidenote, i dont think that the people which are saying that "Allah created you this way" mean that Allah created them as homosexuals, i think that they are trying to say that the شهوة which they have or the desire to do this is something which Allah is testing them with. There is no such thing as a gay gene as you said. BarakAllahu feek
Please do reply to this comment brother Gabriel, Jazak Allah Khair
You cannot have the desire inside your heart and not act on it. Willpower and self control can only take you so far. If the desire is always there, you will always feel the need to do it. Then maybe during a bad day, you acted upon your desires. Many people suffer from addiction because of this. The control their action for a long time, they even count the sobriety days and wear it as a badge of honor, but then suddenly life strikes them hard and they fall back to their desires. I have seen it happen before. Some do succeed in controlling their action this way, but they actually succeed because they have found a cure to the desire, not because they successfully kept their desires at bay. The best way to cure is to heal the source, not the symptom. And in this case, the desire is the source, the action is the symptom.
@@Zoro-wp7fu i strongly disagree, i had a strong desire to listen to music since i grew up listening to it but 5 years ago i stopped listening to it all together. The desire to listen to music is now much lower and most of the time i dont even think about it, but sometimes when i hear it (in a situation where i am not in control) the desire comes back. Does this mean that i will act upon this desire? Absolutely not by the will of Allah and i have proven it for the last 5 years.
But i agree on the point that you need to work on your inside otherwise you will probably fail, thats why i said that a person needs to be convinced himself that the action itself is wrong. When someone can convince themselves and counsiously stop doing the act, thats when they will become succesfull in sha Allah.