Lodgy VS Mobilio VS Innova VS Ertiga VS Xylo VS Aria VS Evalia VS Enjoy | Autocar India
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 05. 2015
- Autocar India¹s Renuka Kirpalani and Kartikeya Singhee test an entire segment to find out which MPV makes the best family car. The Renault Lodgy takes on the Toyota Innova, Honda Mobilio, Maruti Suzuki Ertiga, Tata Aria, Mahindra Xylo, Nissan Evalia and the Chevrolet Enjoy in this mega comparison test.
Autocar India is your one stop source for test drive reviews & comparison test of every new car released in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content including podcasts, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Visit www.autocarindia.com for the latest news & happenings from the auto world.
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
G+: plus.google.com/+autocarindia1 - Auta a dopravní prostředky
The segment where it’s tough for the cars to survive 🤪😂
Cars survived from past - Innova and ERTIGA 🤣😂
Xylo is still underdog... do not underestimate Xylo! No SUV or MUV has such comfortability like Xylo has...
First duster and now lodgy, i think renault is doing a good job. Their cars were criticised for poor interiors, after sales service and ride quality and now they have improved everything. I own a duster awd 110 ps which is the best in terms of everything one could possible imagine. Be it fuel efficiency, space, ride quality, off road presence, gearbox or looks, it is an excellent SUV. I also managed a test drive of lodgy last week. I was thrilled. Like she says in the review, the drive is very enjoyable and the cabin does remain silent even at high speed and the engine wont stop you at all. I loved lodgy. Way to go renault. Autocar, good job with analysing all these MPVs.
3
Innova is better car overall... its a premium car with premium features,best in comfort ,best in safety only thing I noticed its price would be some lesser ... I have my innova.. love u
Innova is the premium, and it has the best engine, just think a 2.5l engine gives a mileage of 13 where as other cars give 17,18 with 1.5l engine. innova gives the best safety, and the service cost of innova is cheapest among its rivals. innova can run about 6-7lakhs without any problems. there is no competition for innova till date
Dear Reviewers,
Ertiga is top selling MPV today. People are not blind to buy Ertiga just like that. Mobilio & Lodgy I hardly see on roads and they are struglling to sell it and compete against Ertiga.
Ertiga is the top selling MPV because its Maruti so its obviously value for money, good mileage, easy maintenance and good resale value. It has practicality but it is certainly not the best.
Ertiga sells just because its cheap & after that it has nothing
Nice one
Yeah you are right ertiga is certainly best package and has a very good resale value....
What a logic 😁👌
Innova is one of the best and the most trusted car among all these other new babies
Indeed INNOVA is itself a brand
I love xylo.....i owned it for 3 years.....such a comfortable car for long trip....(trichur to Chennai -700 kms)..... it's really a vfm car😍
You can buy 2 ertiga's for the price of one Innova. Now you can buy 3 ertiga's for the price of one innova crysta. The fact that its still competing with innova itself makes it a winner. Kudos to MSIL a practical and great product and is priced very well too. Also add to that the MSIL after sales service, no wonder its selling in good numbers even today.
Yes and you can bounce like a ball.
The Ertiga's structure is very instable. I really hope Maruti starts to build strong cars for our market. The thing is only Maruti can build strong cars as people buy them even if they have to pay a small premium over other brands. Still Maruti makes them with cardboard like build quality. Sad, Ertiga is a perfect car for my family. We just cannot consider it when we take safety into account.
@@9392388886 yes
xylo has the best third row and powerful engine
the mobilio sells about 400 units per month on an average,renault does a 300,innova does around 5000 and ertiga around 5500 units.Basically the best of the lot is no doubt innova but it is expensive. So for me the winner has to be ertiga.Good car,great price and the engine never feels stressed on the highway till 140 kph
agree
I agree with you bro i have drived it since i have a mobilo and innova
That's because Maruti is cheap.. Costs less but servicing of Honda is not as cheap as Maruti..i have driven ertiga and the power is very low compared to mobilio
Shubhang Dharwatkar f
Yeh
I am amazed with the visibility of mobilio
Renault lodgy is the clear winner good in price very smooth to drive and good for long journey ...main important thing average of this car 20 plus ..i m using renault lodgy from one year this is the best 8 seater 7 adults and one child
@Nikhil Please share your experience with us. I am confused with Lodgy vs Honda BR-V.
BR-V seems better look then Lodgy.
yeah please how about mtc cost
ertiga is the best because of the price factor and vvt engine can deliver 140 km/h
and super car . i think ertiga and innova are best than any other in the list .
Now they both are brothers
I had this trepidation that you might miss out on some points but you both are excellent reviewer thankyou for being at auto car india
When Dont u Autocar reviewers are not saying about safety in any reviews? , I do think leaving out tata aria and mahindra xylo is not far when u have innova in top 4 , the mostly pricey car here is innova , (what u get )- good comfort and reliability and space , (what u lose) - too pricey , less safety , less fuel efficient , noisy diesel engine , out dated performance.
Tata aria - prices less when compared with innova, but what u get in aria is - reasonable comfort , higher fuel efficiency than innova , best highway cruiser , good amount of space , best equipment list , best and top safest features , and a part time 4 wheel drive system , projector head lights. What u lose is - reliability , ASS
Mahindra , lodgy and mobilio comes under same price tag , in these three
More space - xylo and mobilio
Best seats - lodgy and xylo
Comfort - xylo and lodgy
Fuel efficiency - mobilio and lodgy
Best performence - lodgy 110ps and xylo
Best highway stability - mobilio and lodgy
Then comes ertiga and enjoy , ertiga is the true value for money package
Ertiga - good comfort , good highway stability , good fuel efficiency , good amount of space , has good amount of safety features , less pricey , good ASS .
Enjoy - less pricey and good amount space and reasonable fuel efficiency
Nissan evalia - buy who has to do more commercial work and best city 7 people carrying mover and but long travel ?????
So here we are , people who want reliability and comfort and doesn't want to drive over 100 kmph buy innova but is too pricey , people who is going to clock more kilometers soon and want to travel long trip and want best safety , best highway cruiser , nice comfort , good amount of space - buy aria but its not as reliable ( up to one 1/2 or 2 lakh kilometers ) as Toyota and ASS are not as equal as maruti , buy ertiga if u want to carry 7 people with least boot space and good value for money ( least price tag) , the lodgy and mobilio are fan buying vehicles who love their brand and lodgy wins in comfort and mobilio wins in fuel efficiency , other than this all are same in both vehicles , xylo who want an SUV look and good comfort and space
Always the Autocar shows are against the Indian cars, especially TATA Cars ....
Kunjamma Kadavil because they make shity cars
my father has a 15 year old tata indica and it runs well
ertiga is a small car dosent have decent space
@@ateetbhagia6394 now they are back in track 💥🔥
IN MY PLACE, Speed and Maneuver (I guess i spelled it wrong) isn't something to be given a BIG deal with. It's comfort and safety that counts a lot, so as the Boot Space and amount of passengers. I'd go with innova all the way. (There's a 7 seater option if you want it)
Good comparison aci. I think lodgy could actually give a tough competition to its competitors. A test drive made me feel that way.
AutoCar should make an another video like this...
Bcas now there are newer models like Ertiga facelift, Innova facelift, Honda BRV and the game changer Kia Carnival
Honda BR-V is discontinued.
being a middle class person majority of people look for
1) price
2) space
3) mileage.
4)mantinence
all of the above
Then you need to choose Mobilio
ertiga is quite good in the city
Yeah all were different and some pros and cons may be you guys should recommend these points to manufacturers and they will improve further ..anyway you doing a gr8 Job Autocar India
Renault Lodgy failed only because of quirky exterior styling especially at the back. With a good design it would have been a blockbuster. Renault just ruined their own party.
Ertiga is best in highways n in price also...Best car 🚘!!!
In terms of sheet space offered, isn't lodgy more sensible if you want to buy utility specific MPV? The 56 seat combinations as mentioned in aci's other review says a lot!
ertiga is faster in plain road but rocky road ertiga is slower but ertiga is comfortable than any car
Lodgy best looking
Mahindra xylo is best, always loving it in mpv's section, it's better than innova that's for sure :-)
The innova seems old school, but i think it is still the king of MPV, as it got ladder on frame chassis, it heavy, but you know, its much stronger, even in crash it could resist much better than monocoque like the rest, and could repaired seperately, we are in India and think about that, it got the largest engine but very basic, and reliable, the rest makes better or same power and torque, but the are modern engine using high compression injector to make that much power, and its really complicated and expensive to repair...And last i am in Leh ladakh, and here our no. 01 taxi is INNOVA, its easy to start in winter sub minus 20 degrees, it is rugged, and reliable, only problem is its ground clearance at the top, the front bumper touches even we try to cross some small potholes....Good luck toyota.....
1.Ertiga
2.Innova
3.Aria
4.Lodgy
5.Mobilio
6.Xylo
7.Enjoy
8.Evilia
Innova the legend
Requested to upload video on Mahindra Marazzo.
waiting for suv comparison nd reviews
Lodgy is the best
Innova is still the MPV to buy,Tried and tested .Great after sale service, Excellent Resale value .Lodgy does not have wide service network expensive spare parts.
Only Innova and Ertiga models survive as of 2019 😎
Even the lodge.
Lodgy is discontinued now
this time Renault lodgy can be the game changer in the MPV segment
+Tapan Bhanot you're wrong...
+Tapan Bhanot no doubts that lodgy failed on launching but when you compare lodgy with its competitors then lodgy is more spacious, comfort, safety and lot more. Renault lodgy failed coz of their poor marketing and branding strategies!
i vote for the maruti ertiga,honda mobillio,tata aria and the nissan evalia
Even in mobilio the third row can be up which can add plenty of space
Very informative..... Great work guys..... Thanks for this... Much appreciated your efforts...
bahut bahut dhanyabad...for this knowledge...
Enjoy is best
Loddgy = good mileage, good space, premium interior, less price , also good brand compare to innova.. But still innova is best in mpv segment . I don't understand why? If any one knows pls reply me
TOYOTA INNOVA DIESEL 2.5Z IS THE KING OF THE ROADAND MARUTI SUZUKI ERTIGA IS THE CROWN PRINCE KING OF THE CITY
Lodgy is best car for indian roads
Ertiga is the overall better package...
Tata aria with 4x4 capability compare to others
Innova is best in interior and feel rech
my innova has a reverse camera too
innova was a successor to the qualis.but I think they messed up . they should have given next gen qualis instead.
Xylo is the king
nice video u kno what u can fill ton of passengers in lodgy with the luggage the lodgy will not let u down but there is lack of service center n all thats why people thinks 100 times before go for it other wise its a brilliant machine but here the practical mpv will be HONDA Mobilio its the most practical car u should go for and if u have money u can afford the maintainance costs n all things then nothing doing just go for INNIOVA that will be best choice the toyota engine lasts long
The point of buying MPV's is passenger comfort. Most owners will sit-in the back seat. They will look for space, comfort, silence, good suspension, good interiors, decent features. They won't bother about the quality of driving. That's why I think Innova and Lodgy are excellent. Ertiga is shit, Mobilio is okay. Innova has the best interiors but Lodgy is cheaper. I think it's a tie between Innova and Lodgy
Innova is the best at all the time
Always innova was the best car ever
Best mpv ever
where is this video shot?
Tata aria,maruthi ertiga,chevi enjoy,mahi xylo are the top 4 in terms of value for money proportition
I own a Ford eco sport but I had to go to a trip to Kerala from Mumbai I always wanted to drive my car but we had 6 passenger's so I got my cousins innova 2015 model it was like a luxury from the backseat but it was a terrible mess at the cockpit lacking some torque I guess compared to my eco sport and I struggled innova to get above 90 where I could get above 120 in Coimbatore roads in my eco sport I think this issue is solved in the new innova crysta
Go for xylo
very informative
innova might be a pricier but its the value for money best in class safety, infotainment,space ,innova the best
I loved the lodgy, very spacious and looks good. Handling wise also the review suggests that the lodgy is a winner.
ABS EBD on all variants? wow! Lodgy is champion here. Talk about safety lads! Saftey First!
compare the cars of hatchbacks with jazz,polo,i20 elite,etc..
Nice detailed review of all the MPVs, very good job auto car. Lodgy does score more than the others in the group although Mobilio is not that bad either.
Esses carros tem que vim para o tal Brasil
Renault lodgy!👍
The Renault is the winner,maruti suzuki ertiga should work on the body,back side is way low and small.bring the Toyota hiace.
Can auto car tell me/or guide me about the performance of AC because in my test ride i feel AC not so effective and more noisy . Interior plastics are not so good like switch of light at the roof. Auto car please comment.
please include safety point..
make a comparison with toyota fortuner mitsubishi pajero sport and isuzu mu-x
xuv is missing?
Please make suv's comparison
MORE STYLISH, PERFOMANCE, FEATURES FOR ERTIGA IT IS ALSO A SUV I CHOOSE
Very good review
Hey guys please include the efficiency of the car too
any car cannot be beaten innova my experience l have innova 2015 zx 2.5
Hi renuka mam i am big fan of your channel autocar...📯🚘📯🚘🚘
innova is best in this segment.second xylo.
Hi, I am planing to buy Ertiga cng (9.5L) and same time looking for resale option as well as mony concerns. Planned to buy in festival time. But, Just got offer on Honda mobilio for resale i-vtech V (2014 - 20k running - 6.00L). Should I go for Mobilio or stick with ertiga cng. Running is not much 10000 per year. Can someone suggest me..? bit confused..!
need suv battle reviews
i bought renault lodgy 6 month back it really great car... soomth engine great pick up and average worth for money
Nikhil Gorantyal Are you still enjoying?
please compare baleno and brezza both pro and con..
So please compare the innova and ertiga
What would you say about the driving and handling of lodgy as an MPV? Is it anything like Duster?
better than duster
Which one is best 7 sitter car out of Datsun Go Plus, Maruti Suzuki Ertiga and Renault Lodgy for traveling 250 km daily on National Highway. And also provide good safety, be in budget, provide comfort for long distance and provide good mileage.
Ertiga is best and will be the great SUV soon
Lodgy defeated innova..! what's else to say?!
Chinmay Khedkar o
Nice review
Ertiga would have been the best one for Egyptian market except for terrible delay in delivery.
Yet the Innova is not available in our market due to the huge taxes on engines over 1.6 L.
Honda Mobilio isn't available also as Honda dealer is also the agent for Toyota, yet they provide Toyota Avanza only.
Lodgy is available only in Manual transmission, which is not promising for crowded city drivers.
conside all factor while giving such review. Ertiga and Innova which are loser are selling highest in segment. avg sale of 5000 per month. where as ur winner is not even able to sale more than 1000 per month.
pls watch the video again . u couldn't figure out exactly
+Raj Shekhar R u From Autocar? All your comment favours them.
Abhishek Panchal i dont feel so ! Which comments ?
Abhishek Panchal ertiga and innova aren't losers they got 3rd and 4th respectively . That's why i said watch the video again
+Raj Shekhar Ok got it. I just want to say that Auto car must have not consider some point which are very important for Indian customer. One thing which I found it is, feel inside car. Interior of Innova and Ertiga is so much better than Mobileo that u feel like u should own one. (I have not checked Lodgy yet). If I am going to buy car I am not going to check 0 to 100 or in gear acceleration. I simply check the feel offer by car while driving. Cost and easy of maintenance and mileage. If I remove the honda badge from Mobile, I bet it won't sell even 500 cars per month. It is simply selling on good will created by Honda City.
for working class, I guess Ertiga will give value to your money
review for best suv cars under 15 lakh
Lodgy looks really weird.Mobilio looks good
Nice victory from Dacia
Compare innova and honda mobilio
innova is the best no one can beat it in that segment
But after all only two marketleaders servive in the market Ertiga and Ennova
toyota innova should be the winner. best in mpv segment.
since starting of video they gohave decided to whom to make winner so they start making impartial between other car and lodgy.
+Zakarya Shaikh Why? Because you have to pay a lot or because it is heavy to drive with a decade old design? No thanks. I guess you are not used to change.
I am A fan of innova
Ertiga is just an overgrown hatch (and priced like it) and mobilio is an estate (streched hatch-estate). Lodgy's non adjustable middle row is not very practical. You guys should have loaded em up with atleast six people on board for the test.
Nice
Innova the best MPV and successful MPV in the market