The Hidden Meaning Behind AZKi's Name [Hololive/JShay VA]

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 08. 2024
  • without U / AZKi
    • 【1st ALBUM収録曲】without ...
    The secret meaning behind AZKi's name revealed. Now onto the other Hololive mysteries, like, what the heck is IRyS' last name.
    0:00 - Background
    0:58 - HoloTalk
    2:30 - The Song
    3:55 - The Meaning
    Holotalk Source:
    【HOLOTALK】With our 13th guest: AZKi! #HOLOTALK #ホロトーク
    • 【HOLOTALK】With our 13t...
    #AZKi #holotalk #hololive #vtuber
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 295

  • @JShayToo
    @JShayToo  Před rokem +496

    Don't worry, I'm not about to become a video essay channel. Video's voiced by me are gonna be extremely rare, because 1.) I still prefer clipping and translating 2.) This is more of an 'insurance' against getting hit with 'reused content' by CZcams.

    • @oak8194
      @oak8194 Před rokem +50

      I actually enjoy listening to you talking, though. I wouldn't mind more videos like this on this channel!
      Heck, you even sing well. XD

    • @Chronoxtriggers
      @Chronoxtriggers Před rokem +30

      I'd love to see some hidden lore or cool things that are easily overlooked.

    • @YY-wu7et
      @YY-wu7et Před rokem +30

      Can’t speak for everyone but I really don’t mind this type of content.

    • @pompow3828
      @pompow3828 Před rokem +11

      Nice to hear the voice behind one of my fav clippers. King cover when??

    • @rejoice182
      @rejoice182 Před rokem +5

      👍 all good, still enjoyable

  • @oak8194
    @oak8194 Před rokem +378

    I've always wonder why her name was spelt like that, but assumed she was just being fancy. I didn't expect such a thoughtful meaning behind it that linked into one of her songs!
    I'm so happy to see AZKi succeeded and grew to where she is right now.☺

    • @TheShiningEnergy
      @TheShiningEnergy Před rokem +19

      coincidentally, "From A to Z" is another one of her songs.

  • @JustChiaki
    @JustChiaki Před rokem +213

    Actually never really thought about the meaning behind her name. Most of their names usually have a deeper meaning, or something like a pun to them, but I always thought her name being "AZKi" was just a stylistic choice. Very interesting video! Wouldn't mind seeing more content like this in the future!

    • @JShayToo
      @JShayToo  Před rokem +34

      I didn't know until last year either. But never made a video on it because my main channel is pretty much only Korone and Okayu. This 2nd channel gives me a chance to experiment, and this was one of the first things I wanted to cover.

    • @JustChiaki
      @JustChiaki Před rokem +13

      @@JShayToo Like I said, definitely wouldn't mind seeing more content like this! Especially for talents like AZKi who don't get clipped as much.

    • @Spyduck
      @Spyduck Před rokem +6

      The stylisation point is also correct. For artists with a singular name - alias or real - they tend to remove/replace vowels and/or capitalise letters. For example, Fujihashi Asumi, writer of her popular song "Paku", stylises herself as "asmi", no capitals.
      AZKi and IRyS under go stylisation owing to their common ground as VSingers, only the method is different.

    • @anime_enjoyer5507
      @anime_enjoyer5507 Před rokem

      i mean it is something like a pun.. a well thought out pun at that

  • @Ice-mg5pr
    @Ice-mg5pr Před rokem +345

    I know you said you won't be leaning too hard into the video essay stuff, but I honestly think this was a fantastic video! We definitely need more "Vtuber historians" to provide context for certain quirks new fans may not be familiar with. It'd certainly be far more interesting than just reading it off a wiki page.
    And you killed it on the karaoke part, man. Loved the chill vibes and commitment to singing out the lyrics !

    • @SoraRaida
      @SoraRaida Před rokem +14

      An actual Hololive historian, not like those wannabe historians who just show Hololive talents real face as if it's something very deep 😒

    • @TrueScaryMJ
      @TrueScaryMJ Před rokem +5

      Depressed Nousagi was pretty good before he shot his career in the face. I'm honestly surprised he still makes videos after what he did

    • @kikitondo8390
      @kikitondo8390 Před rokem +3

      ​@@TrueScaryMJwell he already embrace his mistake and the bad image and stating to try be better. He won't deny what he do was wrong and asking for people forgiveness.
      He already hated by tenma, and many involved Vtuber, and he won't resent as it was consequences of his past act and move on.
      Unless his oshi pekora stated she hate DN, i think he will stay making content.

    • @dragoxphere3341
      @dragoxphere3341 Před rokem +5

      @@TrueScaryMJ He wasn't very good even before that. It's just nobody else was doing them so the bar was low and there was nobody to compare him to

  • @HatredXChanner
    @HatredXChanner Před rokem +80

    I have always find the meaning of her not having U in her name explained in that music pretty genius.

  • @saltfisher
    @saltfisher Před rokem +11

    JShay karaoke let’s gooooo

  • @Lugia21
    @Lugia21 Před rokem +43

    This is why I loved AZKi since I first heard her and was very happy when she said she went with Route B and moved officially to Hololive, specially since she boomed really hard after finally transfering and starting to play games.

  • @Zeis
    @Zeis Před rokem +154

    Wouldn't "From Beginning to End, I will always be small without You" make more sense than "I, who is small"? Explains why the "i" in her name isn't capitalized, because U is missing. Thus - "I will always be small without U". She needs You/U/Us to be big/large/shining/herself.

    • @JShayToo
      @JShayToo  Před rokem +42

      Damn, that is actually a really good point. I had never considered that angle. If I ever remake the video or make a compilation of name meanings, I'll definitely go with this interpretation

    • @gorrgumbusenjoyer
      @gorrgumbusenjoyer Před rokem +5

      This actually makes sense. I thought it was more that if it were "I who is always small" would be more of a reflection of her beginnings in her journey as a music artist which is her dream, and "U" being a euphemism of herself meaning no matter how successful she has become now. It would never have happened without "U" serving as a reminder of her past of how much she appreciates herself aspiring to be who she is now and all the hard work she put through reaching this goal.

    • @mr.chubsgaming855
      @mr.chubsgaming855 Před rokem +2

      same thought. without US pertaining to 'U' , AZKi will probably quit in her journey being a vtuber.

    • @SelecaoOfMidas
      @SelecaoOfMidas Před rokem +5

      ​@@mr.chubsgaming855In other words, if she and the production team didn't go for "Route B", she'd have graduated a year ago as planned with the expiration of the INNK Music contract agreement. Now she's on "Route C" or "Gamma", with a major label deal with Victor Music alongside Sora-chan.

    • @bmonthatipkul
      @bmonthatipkul Před 11 měsíci

      Always though of AZKi as A to Z Ki… or a final version of Ki… the small i making the word Ki as Ki. I wouldn’t see KI as a word Ki. Never thought about without u thing since it would have been AZuKi.

  • @korinthian7313
    @korinthian7313 Před rokem +12

    Jshay2 Electric Boogaloo lezgoo

  • @Pyrocore77
    @Pyrocore77 Před rokem +47

    Dang, that's a lot deeper and more meaningful than I expected. I've had a hard time getting a grasp on AZKi up until more recently, so it's really interesting to learn this. Thanks for the video!

    • @JShayToo
      @JShayToo  Před rokem +6

      Same. She kinda flew under my radar too until she started popping off recently with her GeoGeussr streams

    • @benpurcell4935
      @benpurcell4935 Před rokem +2

      AZKi doesn’t get clipped often but when she does it’s a treat because it’s typically really cute or funny.

    • @129das
      @129das Před rokem +3

      AZKi was mostly a live concert singer so when C-19 came She lost almost her entire career when everything closed. She started a few gaming streams with Sora after it all closed down, also live youtube concerts(she did do before) and some Karaoke.

  • @HI-Box
    @HI-Box Před rokem +18

    I honestly teared up learning about the significance of her name and that song, AZKi deserves all the best man 🥹

  • @RecordToDeathToBoredom
    @RecordToDeathToBoredom Před rokem +12

    Okay now explain IRyS. Iris as in in the eye, IRS as in you pay taxes!!! Hope descends indeed.

    • @MrZestful
      @MrZestful Před rokem

      It's actually "y IRS???". You have to put y anywhere in between to avoid copyright!

  • @PythonRiddler
    @PythonRiddler Před rokem +64

    Damn, I love your voice, and you may consider it sub-par singing, and in context it may be true, but I actually liked it alot. Also i feel like I somewhat heard of this before about AZKi's name, but now I understand it even more. I love wordplay. Anyways that's Inaff text, can't wait till the next video.
    Edit: would it make sense if I said that out of clippers I watch you are my oshi in the same sense of how the hololive idols are our oshis?

    • @JShayToo
      @JShayToo  Před rokem +14

      Ahahaha, clipper oshis XD Seriously though, thanks for sticking around around and the incredibly kind words

  • @shubtakkorathinasapostle1159

    the singing caught me off guard, it wasn't bad at all.
    incredible video from start to end. this community really needs more people who can pick up on and share these small but meaningful tidbits

  • @friendlypunk8975
    @friendlypunk8975 Před rokem +7

    THIS IS SO COOL. Thanks for the video JShay!!!!!

  • @WindStreak_
    @WindStreak_ Před rokem +22

    Thank you for explaining! I didn't notice that her name had a hidden meaning at all. I'm glad that you are trying out some different things, I hope it helps with preventing demonitization from CZcams. Also, your singing wasn't bad at all man!

  • @IceBloo
    @IceBloo Před rokem +26

    Great work, JShay. Wouldn’t mind more videos like this.

  • @Absolute__Zero
    @Absolute__Zero Před rokem +9

    I'd like to imagine AZKi is so good at precisely guessing locations because of how 'connected' she is with everyone

  • @TheJadeknight7
    @TheJadeknight7 Před rokem +8

    I wasn't expecting a karaoke section, lol, but it's a really neat explanation. I'm gonna go listen to AZKi's songs now. 👍

  • @Leonlion0305
    @Leonlion0305 Před rokem +8

    Wow, this is actually a really well made video explaining the entire meaning behind AZKi's name.
    ngl even the singing part is pretty fun to listen along and not cringing to me.
    You said you wouldn't do more, but I actually would look forward to similar content.

  • @AurisChannel
    @AurisChannel Před rokem +9

    If only there were any alternatives to youtube, they'd never get away with this vague "reused content" policy and terrible customer support.
    Anyway, thank you for not giving up on your doggo clips! I also really liked this new listenable format!

    • @JShayToo
      @JShayToo  Před rokem +3

      Yeah, worst of all, it seems to strike at random, but thank you for the kind words and glad you enjoyed!

  • @Felder93
    @Felder93 Před rokem +5

    The legendary JShay karaoke

  • @Bird.jp_Love-English-Fixes-plz
    @Bird.jp_Love-English-Fixes-plz Před 8 měsíci +4

    Even as a Japanese viewer of hololive, I never knew AZKi’s name had such a thoughtful deep meaning.
    thank you for your hard work of making this informative video, and great singing as well!

  • @P4brotagonist
    @P4brotagonist Před rokem +11

    This was a pretty cool video actually. I wasn't expecting this, but it was interesting and seems like you were really passionate about making it.

  • @332Valentin
    @332Valentin Před rokem +13

    Amazing video, karaoke part took me by surprise lol. I really like these type of videos they are quite refreshing :)

  • @ayabahollow1204
    @ayabahollow1204 Před rokem +6

    I always thought that her name was a fancy version of azuki (red bean, iirc) because of her color palette (black & red/dark red). But it actually has a beautiful meaning behind it.
    It's nice to have a vtuber essay about something that's not drama or something bad. I'd like to see more vids like this.
    Also, I demand a karaoke stream from you, JShay.

  • @gutsbadguy50
    @gutsbadguy50 Před rokem +13

    We can always use more vtuber lore explanations! Lots of them have names that mean things in japanese that the average kagainikki wouldnt pick up on.

  • @realQuestion
    @realQuestion Před rokem +7

    Love AZKi's stuff. She's worked with some excellent lyricists, but the ones where she wrote them herself are also really good

  • @TallulahSoie
    @TallulahSoie Před rokem +6

    AZKi is brilliant. Can't say it any better than that.
    I was always curious about this and I'm amazed the meaning is so deep. Amazed, but not surprised. So many of her and original HL songs are so personal and "heavy." Emotional when you learn the stories.

  • @kokonotsuu7
    @kokonotsuu7 Před rokem +4

    The intro is pure perfection

  • @AnimeMotorsports
    @AnimeMotorsports Před rokem

    I love this!! 💜 I'm glad you didn't decide to remove the karaoke part, looking forward to the next video!

  • @velociwaffle
    @velociwaffle Před rokem

    Great video! More Holo video essays are always welcome!

  • @Mati-kun
    @Mati-kun Před rokem

    Thank you for the video. I enjoyed this small yet important analysis.

  • @shoutenry
    @shoutenry Před rokem +3

    JSHAY2 KARAOKE?! lessgoooooo

  • @yamiRic
    @yamiRic Před 9 měsíci +2

    Come for Azki lore, stay for JShay karaoke

  • @CageNightwind
    @CageNightwind Před 9 měsíci +1

    IDK how I am subbed to you and still missed this one. Thanks for this 'offbrand' upload because it's something I was always curious about.
    Cheers!

  • @neetworawry8728
    @neetworawry8728 Před rokem +1

    That karaoke part was great, I can see myself doing that whenever I listen tk Suisei and Irys song . Lucky to have found your channel, cool voice as well, I hope you do a bit more of these informative essay video.

  • @RC10000
    @RC10000 Před rokem

    Loved the video man!!! Thanks for the explanation!!! I'm bamboozled fr

  • @konnir8980
    @konnir8980 Před rokem +3

    Kudos for doing something outside the confort zone. Thx for explanation.

  • @infinathan443
    @infinathan443 Před rokem +3

    Amazing video dude! Love your clips and I wouldn't mind more of these video essays either. Especially if they're about Hololive history.
    Also new Holostar EN member?! Fr tho that singing was nice.

  • @Himemiya_Chikane
    @Himemiya_Chikane Před rokem

    This is super clever. Thank you for explaining!!

  • @copperchef.
    @copperchef. Před rokem

    This is a great video. Thank you for the info.

  • @ArseneaLupin
    @ArseneaLupin Před rokem +1

    Top tier content, honestly this kind of videos is good for new fans who had many questions about Hololive talents. Also, you have a cool singing voice my dude.

  • @squaminator
    @squaminator Před rokem

    thanks for the deep dive, that was really cool

  • @Raugornauth
    @Raugornauth Před rokem

    This was great! I enjoy learning things like this about artists I enjoy. I would love to see more videos like this if you have any more subjects you'd like to talk about.

  • @user-ss2wd5we3i
    @user-ss2wd5we3i Před rokem +2

    I almost shed a tear because it is so sweet ❤

  • @Jeremy_Fisher
    @Jeremy_Fisher Před rokem +3

    Very interesting. Thanks for the explanation!

  • @mjc7745
    @mjc7745 Před rokem

    Glad the algo took me here. Thanks for MORE translations!!!

  • @RandomGuy0987
    @RandomGuy0987 Před rokem +2

    Appreciate the translations, love the clips. Nice karaoke too dude!

  • @khalildefrias8049
    @khalildefrias8049 Před rokem +1

    That was great! I hope you and murasaki ringo keep making this type of lore content, very cool

  • @sora1172
    @sora1172 Před rokem

    Just want to say thank you for everything you do with your translations and these videos. I can honestly say without your channels I wouldn't have fallen as far into the rabbit hole as I have. You are one of the pillars of the translation community for me. Also your singing was very enjoyable to listen to and I am eagerly awaiting a cover from you! Once more from the bottom of my heart thank you for the incredible work that you do.

  • @chubgp8009
    @chubgp8009 Před rokem +1

    A really enjoyable video mister jaytoo

  • @scarletsky4486
    @scarletsky4486 Před rokem

    I've watched your clip videos since the early days, and if I remember correctly it was where Korone become champion in Apex for the 1st time back in 2020. Nice to see you're branching out from the usual content. We need more of this kinda video essay for Holomem lore or heck even past events that happened for that matter. Life getting busy again post Covid, I don't have time to keep up with everything that happen in Hololive since 2022, and would be nice to see a commentary video with clips of events that occur in that year from time to time.
    P.S. I missed your outro bgm.

  • @Megawott104
    @Megawott104 Před 8 měsíci +2

    Her name is pretty much an ARG, what the heck!! xD
    Thanks for making this vid, man; I love trivia like this!

  • @luancaqu
    @luancaqu Před rokem +1

    I was always curious about her name meaning and now I’m glad I get it. Excellent work, thank you a lot!

  • @KoKey-hd4bm
    @KoKey-hd4bm Před rokem +8

    I always imagined you as the messenger of the dog god, but now we know that you have a deep voice and that you sing well... Incredible!

  • @mikwing17
    @mikwing17 Před rokem

    Such a beautiful name.
    Got immersed during your karaoke time that I didn't get to try understanding the lyrics so I had to rewatch it again.

  • @NONIWDD
    @NONIWDD Před rokem

    Damn, thats actually some really good singing if you ask me, looking forward to more videos in the future!!!

  • @Rem1xDave
    @Rem1xDave Před rokem +1

    I like your version!
    Thank you for the fun video 😊

  • @commentofthis
    @commentofthis Před rokem +1

    Eyy, you got a nice voice there..😆
    Looking back, she is indeed quite literally always sings solo, and somehow you can almost always feel that loneliness whenever you listen to her old songs, quite an oddly interesting feelings really..
    Now, since she's already contributed as the former (presumably) only Vsinger under INNK, it may also adds to her unique existence as the 'not-so-new' member of Hololive, cmiiw

  • @tadanossan4865
    @tadanossan4865 Před rokem +4

    so in a nutshell her full name is AZKi without U, meaning from the first (A) to the last (Z) I'm just a little person without U, and you cannot understand that without listening to her song, she's just so brilliant! this reminds me of Risu's song, Alice&U where you can also read it as ARisu and U
    btw nice clip bro!!! i have no problem with this kind of narrative clip

  • @nanamikasumi2273
    @nanamikasumi2273 Před rokem

    Yooooo i hope this video blows up this is a really cool vid

  • @Monafide3305
    @Monafide3305 Před rokem

    That was a lot more interesting than I expected!

  • @maybeso5710
    @maybeso5710 Před rokem +2

    Nice singing 👍
    And nice video, definitely gonna check out AZKi now

  • @40wink
    @40wink Před rokem

    Throughout the video it went from what I thought was simply a good bit to a very meaningful message. Thank you for the explanation and don't worry about the karaoke. It was a more fun alternative to just reading 😊

  • @Crasuk
    @Crasuk Před rokem +5

    I like this kind of content and wouldn't mind if you do more videos like this :-)

  • @Cheintz88
    @Cheintz88 Před rokem +3

    This was really interesting, I hope you do more if another topic interests you.

  • @AlmRodail
    @AlmRodail Před rokem +1

    Great video, and you absolutely smashed that karaoke!

  • @mikebmcl
    @mikebmcl Před rokem +3

    Thanks!

  • @Frank22lol
    @Frank22lol Před rokem +3

    Videos like these are definitely needed in the community. It's so hard to look for specific content or references nowadays. I would like to learn more about the talents, their "lore" (not the supernatural one but about their career as a streamer) and don't have the time to look through all vods. Clips are usually just funny moments and don't do rhis kind of explanation. Kiara has a wonderful series of videos where she explains stuff like "the usuall room" and "Australia".

  • @klbs2k5
    @klbs2k5 Před rokem

    This is very interesting, also you nailed that karaoke part man, xD.

  • @Limbo08
    @Limbo08 Před rokem

    This was a interesting video, hope to see more like it!

  • @dkahardian9153
    @dkahardian9153 Před rokem +1

    at around 5:30 5:35 some clips from hololive old members flashed in my minds and make my eyes a bit watery.
    some of them like: suisei (journey of struggle before joining hololive and the moment she made into "the first take"), miko (cry with yagoo about quiting), and last but not least, sora's history and journey.
    Hololive is an agency full of history that if written, its felt like a novel with a long and ongoing series. with roller coaster mood.
    from beginning till the end, without U, i will always small.
    from zero to hero, no. from a particle of dust to a star. a shining bright star.
    A Shiny Smily Story of their Bright Parade.

  • @treechat8397
    @treechat8397 Před rokem +2

    Thankyou!

  • @hiiragihasmanywaifu
    @hiiragihasmanywaifu Před rokem +2

    That's why i love AZKi and her music, this made me want to deeply think more of the lyrics of her other songs
    really amazing vid
    Also great singing there, u actually hit the notes well

  • @EntidadLibre
    @EntidadLibre Před 10 měsíci +1

    Thank you for singing it, JShay!! As a singer, I get emotional whenever people do it, even if they aren't pros. And thanks for the explanation. If I needed a reason to love AZKi more, is this one.

  • @sanguis77
    @sanguis77 Před rokem

    I am so glad to see another translator who also sings. I hope this is a regular thing now

  • @isaacshepard1474
    @isaacshepard1474 Před rokem +1

    That's so sweet, just when you think AZKi's already as sweet as can be she always proves you wrong

  • @mentecato666
    @mentecato666 Před rokem +6

    Really good video! I like her singing, but I don't know much about her, so this was very helpful on understanding her!
    Based singing btw 🎉

  • @lupusdaemon6015
    @lupusdaemon6015 Před rokem +1

    Woah! I had no idea it was so deep. Very clever wordplay across two languages. Thanks for the explanation!

  • @malerra
    @malerra Před rokem +1

    Wow, great explanation.

  • @davidwusoftdev
    @davidwusoftdev Před rokem

    I never thought about her name having a meaning behind it. Wow, that was deep!😲
    Thank you for making this video! 😊

  • @maxterhex
    @maxterhex Před rokem +2

    Hey, our lovely ramen chef finally reveal his voice >.

  • @AzureR7
    @AzureR7 Před rokem +1

    Epic video!

  • @BringerOfPlenty
    @BringerOfPlenty Před rokem

    After that Holotalk episode I listened to the song +others and became an AZKi fan

  • @Derpmind
    @Derpmind Před rokem

    A very interesting topic, with a nice bit of singing, too!

  • @holofanlee
    @holofanlee Před rokem +2

    Been a huge fan of AZKI from the day I fell into the rabbit hole. I really love learning all these details about her. She really puts so much thought into her lyrics and songwriting. And the fact that she writes most of her music and lyrics herself makes me even more impressed. As a Pioneer I can't thank you enough for making this video JShay!!!!!!

    • @SelecaoOfMidas
      @SelecaoOfMidas Před rokem

      Considering where AZKi started from, this is a great continuation of her journey through music. From Touhou doujin music projects to now, she's earned her place and success. Always glad to support people like her when possible.

  • @azazelleblack
    @azazelleblack Před měsícem

    You sound pretty good in the karaoke part! I didn't know about your second channel here!

  • @omenofthephoenix
    @omenofthephoenix Před rokem

    I thought your singing was great. also i didn't expect to cry from this, maybe it's late and my eyes are tired... but still an emotional meaning to the name. Thanks for sharing

  • @prowse321
    @prowse321 Před rokem +1

    Thanks man

  • @pitori.
    @pitori. Před rokem

    You SLAYED the karaoke part and i don’t even know you!

  • @lemao2222
    @lemao2222 Před rokem

    well, you got me applauding irl, so you did great by my reckoning!

  • @TheRealVordox
    @TheRealVordox Před rokem +1

    Our tiny red bean, a strong bean, but a bean nonetheless.
    Thanks for spreading out the lyrics of her earlier song~

  • @Xandrez192
    @Xandrez192 Před rokem +2

    I actually loved the karaoke part, real creative way to actually show off what you're talking about in the video without needing to drop a "Pause here and go listen" in the middle. Plus, karaoke's about having fun, right?

  • @halo2d
    @halo2d Před rokem

    That was a fun unexpected karaoke moment. thank you JShay

  • @NinjaPopeXue
    @NinjaPopeXue Před rokem +3

    W-Was JShay best idol all along!? But seriously, it does take a lot of courage to put yourself singing out on the internet. Plus I've always appreciated your translations, which are accurate but aren't worded too literally, making it easily digestable for a Western audience.

  • @HydrengeaEdelweiss
    @HydrengeaEdelweiss Před rokem +3

    Amazing singing dude 🌽😭🌽 Also, now I'm wondering if there are similarly deeper meaning at IRyS lowercase y.

  • @hakerooni
    @hakerooni Před rokem +1

    boy howdy! Definitely gonna be breaking out this fun fact amongst friends

  • @YourAverageLurker
    @YourAverageLurker Před rokem

    Thank you for the singing lol, it was a pleasant surprise!

  • @primeknight7531
    @primeknight7531 Před rokem

    bro... I've been wondering about that but kept forgetting to research about it! thank you for the explanations and your voice is too good! when original?