Dry vs Wet Aged Steak What’s Better? Very Surprising Results!
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2022
- I took two ebony Angus sirloins the same size. I took one out of the bag and left one in the bag and placed them in my dry ager for 30 days to see the difference.
The results were slightly surprising!
Follow me on Tiktok and Instagram for daily food videos -
Tiktok @andy_cooks
Insta @andyhearnden - Jak na to + styl
Hi 20 yrs exp west aussie artisan butcher..ill have a crack at answering one of the questions. . the reason for the tenderness of dry aging. Decomposition.. we can safely do this without salts etc because we control all the factors that let bacteria grow .effectively curing it like jerky. Also the "purge" is called metaglobin its type muscle blood its actuall different to arterial blood or hemaglobin. Its slowly pulled out of the meat because its under vaccum.However if you hung the body for a week or 2 in the chiller before breaking it down and vaccum sealing you would still lose weight over the whole body as it drys in the chiller but less in the purge under vaccum for the same 30 days almost zero.. i personally go with 4 weeks max 6 weeks vaccum sealed any day . For flavour texture tenderness and weight loss. Also nicer/easier to prep trim and slice. . There. Novel done.
Finally an authentic cooking channel on CZcams! Exactly what I’ve been wanting. Thank you for this content Chef!!
And we got to see his Boning room. I just call mine my bedroom.
yes! no flashy bullshit or stupid overacting.
The garlic powder comment was firmly directed at Guga / SVE 😂
You've got a really nice presentation style - Really chill, informative and very very easy to watch. Keep it going!
real pros don't need bombastic presentation to make some really great content :)
@@ElBach1y so much better than Jamie Olive oil
This looks amazing and I love the commentary that Andy gives. Keep up the great work!
As a fellow chef, really enjoying your videos, keep up the good work mate! Hoping for more informative videos like this one
Yes, Id love to see the same type of comparison between completely fresh-off-the-animal and straight-from-cryovac bag, too....
That garlic powder comment was a fatal blow to Guga 😂
Emotional Damage!
When Guga dry ages beef, especially high quality cuts, he just does Salt and Freshly Ground Black Pepper.
@@deanwilliams2374 Heart attack pictures, fatty foods is animaIs cIogged arteries, hard arteries, PH 5, no fibre🧟♂️🦠🍔🥓🥩🍗🍳🧀... 🤮. Vegans don’t stink. PH 7 , plants have fibre ✅😉, vegans are peaceful, Peer review science. Actual pictures of the heart. czcams.com/video/15wgYsToORM/video.html !!! czcams.com/video/pFPFnhfuLrE/video.html Vegans don’t have this problem because that is the animals. Vegans don’t get clogged arteries, 4% cancer if you’re vegan. Meat based diet 51% death rate. That is extremely high for a frigging burger etc. Gorillas in the wild, have 1 percent cancer. And they never ever eat animals !!! Peer review science !!!!
CZcams delicious vegan food. Time to change ✅❤️😉
@@niko_pdx 6 hours !!!! 🔴🦌. 5 days or more sitting inside your stomach puuuu-trifying !!! No fibre if you eat animals in their secretions !!! Timelapse. czcams.com/video/lmSrUvgWiqE/video.html .... 🤢🤮.. That’s why I am vegan !!!! Your teeth are flat 😬. And your stomach is very very long, “combined length of the small and large intestines is at least 15 ft in length”. We are herbivores. The ape family. ✅❤️😬💪🦍 GorilIas never ever eat animals, they are huge !!! 98.6% the same as us !!! And I’ve gotten bigger and stronger and fitter on a plant based diet. Scientific fact !!!! Fat deposits clog the arteries, eating animals and their secretions. Deodorant mask the symptoms but the shoes and socks and armpits.. 🍳🍖🍔...🦠🧟♂️👕🧦🥾🤮...
@@VeganV5912 wow, great addition to the conversation!
I’ve always wet aged my wild game - venison and goat .. I find there is less wastage which is critical on a smaller animal .. great vid with spot on to the point delivery 👌
wild goat or domestic? Grass fed?
@@spinningbackspin wild mate
@@greatdividehunting7887 Oh lovely!
Dry age is NOT worth it, gets too smelly & you lose too much mass in water along with the trimming you have to do!
IF you have a DOG, puppy will LOVE you for it! LOL!
@DMSProduktions dry age further than 15-20 days is simply put a fetish. Flavour develops very well in this timeline, after that it gets very distinct, and you have to be lucky enough to afford trimming. Experimenting is good 😉
Thanks for taking the time to make this video. It's was very well put together and informative.
Would be interesting to know how much water was lost during the cook? I wonder if the wet aged steak lost more during the cook and the overall wastage is more comparable to the dry aged?
I'd bet the wet age did lose a bit and by the time its all said done they probably were pretty dang close in weight from raw to dressed and cooked. Although I would guess the wet age still retained a bit higher of a percent overall.
You can see in the video that the dry age is a lot dryer than the wet aged. During cooking they both probably lost similar amounts of moisture, so the wastage is not comparable.
I too wondered if dry aged losses less on the cook than wet
@@Chroniknight less, but probably not in large amounts
Love the recipe videos and shorts but this was super cool as well. Hope more of them pop up :)
I always wet age my briskets for 30-45 days from pack ..never fails ..Im smoking 2 briskets for my restaurant tomorrow ..love the video and I wish I had a dry ager!! Great work chef
Love your long videos! keep it up!
Wonderful video! Love to see more of these and others similar. Beautiful art work!
I always wondered what the difference was. Thanks for clearing that up! Love your channel!
Hell, the first honest and fully professionall video about dry aging I have seen. I've been dry aging steaks for quite a while now, but this video is simply excellent.
Thanks mate !
Have you not seen Guga Foods?
@@artrocious Of course I have, I am a Guga Follower since his beginnings. But to be honest, Guga has always pushed the Umai Bags. Never really heard from him that 30 Day dry aging is not really worth it, when you take in account the amount of loss and gains (for an average cut of meat). I still dry age my steaks, and will continue to do so, all I am saying is that I like the honesty in this Video from Andy. No advertising, straight honest opinion.
@@denzelmaniac well guga did say that you won't see dry aged steaks in restaurants due to how much they will lose from it.
@@chairforce664 that makes no sense, since every steakhouse today has dry aged on their menu. It costs more, that's all.
I’ve been waiting for a video like this!!
That was informative. Thank you Andy
Thanks mate, nice presentation.
Great video Andy. I really enjoy your content.
Great review! Thanks!
Thanks for watching!
Awesome channel - would love to see more of these type videos/experiments!
Brilliant video. Learnt a lot. 🙏
Fascinating insight! Thank you Chef, Andy 👍🏽👊🏽✌🏽
Great Video Andy. thanks
You can minimize waste by dry aging on the bone. The bone not only keeps the beef from flattening out too much while aging but it reduces the loss and pellicle on a whole side. You also want to keep the fat caps as generous before aging as well because fat will discolour and get funky quicker so you want some buffer. 45 days is usually the sweet spot for dry aging and they definitely need to be cooked for a shorter period of time than a normal steak.
Butter dry age is another way
@@asdas4312 thats not dry aging since the meat isn't exposed to oxygen. It's closer to curing.
I live by a big n old butcher shop. Whenever I cook one of their really aged beef…I just don’t care for the taste. What you call funky I call ewww. No thanks. I like my steaks without so much aging.
Totally agree. Just tastes rotted to me, not at all desirable.
Love your videos mate awesome to see your career and skills
Another great video!! And the grill marks on those steaks were spot on!!🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩
Thanks 4 info; learned a lot
love your vids dude
10:45 calling out Guga hahahah
Great stuff, chef!
Totally spot on 30 dry aged is minimal. Had a 100 dry aged at Hereford Beefstouw in Melbourne that's about as far as I would go. Again thanks for your fantastic knowledge chef and look forward to more videos.
Thanks mate 🙌
I think 60 day is very nice and 90-100 becomes something else entirely but is probably also my favorite.
At my work we have two big dry aging cabinets and at some point we made a test with letting a loin hanging in there for over 150 days. I wouldn't say it was inedible, but certainly not suitable for most tastebuds. Very funky, kinda cheesy with milkynotes.
@@andy_cooks
@@McShag420 Heart attack pictures, fatty foods is animaIs cIogged arteries, hard arteries, PH 5, no fibre🧟♂️🦠🍔🥓🥩🍗🍳🧀... 🤮. Vegans don’t stink. PH 7 , plants have fibre ✅😉, vegans are peaceful, Peer review science. Actual pictures of the heart. czcams.com/video/15wgYsToORM/video.html !!! czcams.com/video/pFPFnhfuLrE/video.html Vegans don’t have this problem because that is the animals. Vegans don’t get clogged arteries, 4% cancer if you’re vegan. Meat based diet 51% death rate. That is extremely high for a frigging burger etc. Gorillas in the wild, have 1 percent cancer. And they never ever eat animals !!! Peer review science !!!!
CZcams delicious vegan food. Time to change ✅❤️😉
Great explanation and experiment. Learn something from you every show. Thanks Andy
Excellent again. Thanks Andy.
Thanks for watching!
Cool man… I’ll be a long time viewer, that’s for sure. I’m in Melbourne too actually. Good to see another NZ fella up this way. Keep it up 👍🏼
Hi Andy, great vid. Would be interesting to see a longer age around 60 days and the flavor comparison.
Awesome vid. Informative.
Nice one Andy very good information
Love this guy! Thanks Chef!
Love your content chef
You have the best job in the world. Testing tasting cooking. Perfecting things to make peoples dining experiences memorable. Great job chef.
I know this was posted a year ago. But, I cannot thank you enough for your thoroughness and honest evaluation.
Beautiful. Thank you for your insight Chef. all love and support from The PNW.
Great content, would love to see a video on improving cheap cuts like rump and gravy to enjoy steak on a budget?
Great Video!!! Really appreciate the honest opinion. Any tips on dry aging in the bag without having a dry aging refrigerator?
From what I’ve seen, you can’t dry age in the bag. Dry aging involves losing the moisture and it can’t evaporate in a sealed bag. Most restaurants in the US that dry age have special coolers with moving air at a constant temp.
With aging the muscle cells will be releasing enzymes that help break down the meat and make it softer. This was really interesting; I was surprised the wet aged steak wasn't a little funkier than the dry aged.
Thanks 🙏
@the reason The amazing, wonderfully tasty controlled decomposition. All the best things are fermented/aged.
I always find the wet-aged beef to have a metallic (iron) taste to it. To me it is borderline inedible. I really enjoy dry-aged beef from 45-50 days. That range seems to be the sweet spot to my palate.
I didn’t know you could use the trim. I’ve wanted to dry age for a while, but hate the idea of wasting the trim so I’m glad I’ve learn how to use it in a resourceful way.
So I work in a butcher shop and I enjoy cooking at home. I've done a few experiments in my time, and I definitely agree that I prefer wet aging over dry aging. I don't like the taste of dry age and I feel the wet age is more tender and juicier.
That being said, I definitely like garlic powder on my steaks 😂 But I'm really glad you didn't use any pepper. I don't believe pepper has any place on beef.
Also, I don't agree with resting steaks. Something larger like a brisket it's necessary, but on steaks I feel you lose too much heat and don't actually get enough benefit to be worth it. I like my steaks hot.
Overall, excellent video. Your descriptions were spot on and your process and record keeping helped convey just how much loss there was.
Pepper steak:Am I a joke to you?
So I recently wet aged some AAA sirloin caps from costco. I had bought a cryobag of 2 and tossed it in the chest freezer, pulled it out to the fridge to thaw for portioning. Between being lazy and busy I decided to try wet aging it another 4-6 weeks beyond the 2-4 weeks you would get meat from the store at.
I opened the bag up and processed them earlier this week, I can say it was well worth it. It has this light kinda funk or ferment thats fantastic.
@@durstroyer3924 Costco is a scam.
This was an epic and yummy experiment 🙌🏽🙌🏽 More please 🤤
Well done Andy great content 👏🔥
Great Job!
Love your videos and how factual they are.
Possibly the most informative video you have done mate. Excellent 👌 thank you!
Andy! Great video, very well explained and executed! Peace! ❤
Great job Andy
Well Done mate
When doing comparison like this it would be nice to see the « normal » one in your test. For taste difference. Then again to see for a restaurant if it’s worth doing it ! Great content ✌🏼
guga food 😂
@@CoolPanda_LOL That guy loves to "keep it simple"
I was wondering how you were cooking so often in a state of the art kitchen and beautiful ingredients! That’s epic sounds like the dream job!!
Thank you chef
Good work!
My mouth is watering!!
Great video! Many thanks for sharing this with us.
I try, and dry age any steaks that I do. Usually for about 7 days.
Where I live the standards in good restaurants has fallen.
So you will have to go a distance to find a good place. Sadly economics has forced many places to take short-cut's which has affected the food.
Cooking dry aged meat. You could try this method. Do not pan fry.
"T" Bone Steaks, 4"/100mm thick.
Trim excess fat off, before dry aging. 7 days minimum. Salt the fat only.
Brush with oil. Do not cut off the hard crust*, or fat before placing on the coals of a cool fire. (*This is the best bit).
Do not season. Cook slowly.
Have a "Chef's test one" going as well. To test as you go along, with a nice coldy of course.
Lightly season. Rest for at least 15 minutes. It will be Yum Yum.
Kind regards, and greetings from Africa.
a weight comparison of the cooked cuts would've been interesting. Love your work.
3:11 "Boning room" . Hehe
I learned that wet aging was done mostly because of production. Meat purveyors could sell more beef meanwhile having it age in a cryo-bag en route to a customer. Dry aging was the norm prior to mass production. But it seems in the past 10 years hipster cooks have led a resurgence in dry aging. Currently with both aging systems it all depends now (as you mentioned) in what kind of restaurant you're operating. Your wet age had a loss of around 30% while the dry aged had a loss of over 50% (give or take I don't recall the numbers) Also dry aging takes space and extra equipment. Its quite possible to age a sub primal for 10 days to allow for moisture to evaporate. Anyways its up to the restaurant owner on what theme they want. Thanks for the great video Chef Andy cheers
Thanks mate! I don’t run a restaurant, I run a test kitchen
@@andy_cooks I know Kilcoy you mentioned it. I was just saying if someone had a restaurant....etc. something they need to remember for food costs and yield percentages. I have a restaurant in Korea.
The explanation about why its more tender. (Sorry my English aint perfect)
The enzyme does a chemical\mechanical process of decomposition (basicly breaking apart). This process doesn't require oxygen or temperature to happen but those 2 assist of course.
What happens is that while the process is going the fibers of the muscles break apart on a molecular level, unlike raw or wet age where the fiber stays intact.
So It seems like its all the same to both kinds but if u look under a microscope, the dry age meat fibers will be broken to many pieces and there for it will be more tender than intact fiber.
To summarize why they both as tender, the process dont require any environment to be happening so it happened on the wet aged steak as well only a bit slower.
I guess in 30 days there aint much of a gap but a 60 days dry age steak is nothing to be compared to as it comes to tenderness.
I hope i helped. You can ask me anything you wanna know guys.
Peace
That kitchen is clean af
Great video Chef!! IS 30 days aged the longest you go for dry aging , are there any exceptions for going longer and does that depend on the cut?
I've done a couple of dry age at home, with the membrane bags.
I think I went 45-50 days and they were amazing.
I will add, using the trimmings with some fresh mince made the best burgers I have ever tasted.
I used to. it's very expensive long term. what's way cheaper is buying Kombu from an Asian grocer and soaking it, wrap your meat and that's it. the seaweed dries on so you cut your steaks and then trim the edges. granted you cannot keep the edges like the bags can but volume is greater and the flavor is amazing. the Kombu has MSG that naturally permeates the cut of meat.
I threw all of my trimmings away. Didn’t read up on what to do with them. Now that the rib roasts (prime rib) I was using now costs me $30.00-$40.00 per pound I haven’t done any more. Maybe now that I know I don’t have to throw it away I can justify it again. It did make the best steaks I’ve ever eaten.
@@rustbucket9318 be careful though. Although you can use the trims they are still full of bacteria.
You supposed to use them as a seasoning to the main mass that you are making burgers from.
Also, burgers made from it cannot be kept more than 24h
@@daganattias274 Thank you. I will also do a little research before hand.
@@rustbucket9318 6 hours !!!! 🔴🦌. 5 days or more sitting inside your stomach puuuu-trifying !!! No fibre if you eat animals in their secretions !!! Timelapse. czcams.com/video/lmSrUvgWiqE/video.html .... 🤢🤮.. That’s why I am vegan !!!! Your teeth are flat 😬. And your stomach is very very long, “combined length of the small and large intestines is at least 15 ft in length”. We are herbivores. The ape family. ✅❤️😬💪🦍 GorilIas never ever eat animals, they are huge !!! 98.6% the same as us !!! And I’ve gotten bigger and stronger and fitter on a plant based diet. Scientific fact !!!! Fat deposits clog the arteries, eating animals and their secretions. Deodorant mask the symptoms but the shoes and socks and armpits.. 🍳🍖🍔...🦠🧟♂️👕🧦🥾🤮.
The funky taste from aging is a little of an acquired taste.
Definitely
For me once u had that flavour nothing else satisfy me. Its weird. That almost rotten taste blew my mind, nothing else would satisfy me as dry aging. So weird.
@@sebastionjunior4125 haha for me it’s the opposite. Maybe I just don’t eat it enough.
@@sebastionjunior4125 it’s an acquired taste. Not for everyone. Just like everything else expensive lol. Blue cheese. Most fermented stuff.
Just say you can't afford steakhouses
Sounded like a shot at Guga Foods with the garlic powder
Andy you are phenomenal chef
Thank you 🙏
if i wasnt already hungry enough, I'm blimmin starvin now!
Very interesting stuff!
That's probably the most genuine opinion
Honestly i like these longer videos more than your shorts. Also would have been nice to see compared to just a normal steak with no aging at all.
55 days is my favorite. On a thick cut, like Wagyu, I love 21 days.
The quickest 14 mins 48 seconds in my life. Well done. 👏👏👏👏👏
I think Based on my experience trying 30 Day dry aged 45 day dry aged and 120 day dry aged Ribeyes I'm going with the 120 days it has great beefy flavor and melts in the mouth , however in saying that wet aged doesn't add much flavor and really doesn't effect the tenderness so I'm not a big fan , please note only my opinion and we All have are preferences 👍
Not a huge steak eater myself but it was such a fascinating topic that I watched it anyway. Great video.
There is an in-between option though with the aging bags
I eat steak quite frequently since I'm on a carnivore diet, and I have gotten into the habit of coating my steaks with koji rice and letting it sit in a small refrigerator for five to ten days on top of a rack, turning it over every day or two. But I don't bother cutting off the surface before cooking, and it definitely has an added flavor to it, but one I find rather pleasant. I'm not sure if that flavor is the same as what you get from dry aging, but it does lose weight and look rather similar. Only downside is that if you don't scrape the koji rice off at the end thoroughly, the crust can burn rather quickly, especially if there isn't enough oil on the pan.
I’m hungry now. Thanks for this
Andy I love the channel! You make cooking so easy. Could you possibly do a beef stroganoff 👍🏻
Thanks! I’m posting one to TikTok this week
damn an executive chef! That’s amazing hopefully I can get to that title!
Thanks for a great presentation. Can you explain how you age your beef, under what conditions - temperature, humidity, etc?
Thanks again.
Love the slight dig at people who say they're keeping it simple.
Nice video l learnt a lot
controlled decomposition is my theory why dry aging works. My brother is a Salt and Pepper purist. My mom taught me how to make steak and she marinades it in Worcestershire sauce and McCormick Grill Mates Montreal Steak seasoning. It's not simple and wouldn't do that to a dry aged steak but it does give a nice flavor to a steak as well as provides a nice color. Showed somebody a steak I made that way once and they said it was burnt till I cut it open and they saw that it was rare. I prefer my mom's method because that's how I grew up eating steak. My brother does fad diets for so long that he cut out a lot of things our mom taught him when it came to cooking albeit he is still a good cook. I just won't touch his spaghetti because he uses jar sauce that he just heats up and Prego at that.
Thanks for confirming a suspicion of mine.
Great stuff!
Did you disposed of the wet aged trimmings; or did you save those for burgers as well?
When you do a dry aged burger, how do you determine the ratio of fresh meat to pellicle?
Does the 80/20 fat ratio change?
Couldn’t agree more with your garlic powder rant
This guy is not only a chef he is a butcher look how he cut those steaks almost millimetre perfect 6.50 time 10 out of 10
the dry aged cooked faster because it was a 200g vs a 300g steak too
You can mince it or just sweat the flavour out. But pasterization is no longer enough - gotta use curing salts and that is not really good for burgers that are cooked at high temp.
I wet age most of the time and then cut it to serving size and pop them in the fridge over a salt bed for 12 to 20 hours. works very well.
nice video man
As a man who have watched 90% of steak videos on CZcams I would like to say “well done”
No, no! Rare side of medium rare is the way to go! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤪
You have a great job
Great video. I knows it's from months ago. It just popped up on my feed. I also,didn't think I was going to have a elliptical fit.from camera switchs
Great video