Each time I open a Mephisto CZcams performance by a gifted pianist, there are always these kinds of comments: " the best performance ever". THERE IS NO BEST PERFORMANCE EVER. EACH GREAT INTERPRETATION IS VALUABLE. DIVERSITY IS GREAT!!!
Haha so true. There is no best performance except: Kissin in Prokofiev Etude op 4 no 3. Pompa Baldi Prokofiev Etude op 4 no 1. Kissin Balakirev The Lark and others
Потрясающее исполнение ! Ювелирная техника владения инструментом плюс исполнение, эмоциональное и экспресиивное и в итоге - шедевр ! Слушала и ловила себя на мысли, что пианист как будто с другой планеты. Браво !!!👋👋👋👍👍👍
Дмитрий, это уму непостижимо, как можно так здорово играть на этом рояле! Дима, твоя интерпретация блестяща, дух романтизма витает рядом с твоей головой и твоими пальцами, он движет твоей душой! Спасибо тебе за ту красоту, что ты умеешь нести людям! Слушать тебя- это восторг души и даже счастье! Мне уже почти 70 лет, но я в восторге от твоей игры. Ты чародей и чары твои прекрасны! Да хранит тебя Бог, дитя радости, красоты и гармонии!❤🎉🙏🙏👍
I don't mean to be a classical music elitist, and I know you mean well. However, it is quite rude to interpret the composer's ideas so bluntly. It is their music, but each performer plays differently. They all play so well, but there is not, in essence, an 'exact' way to perform! That is disrespectful to the composer.
@@fushifushi9441 I only meant what I said as an opinion, because the way I would interpret is the same way Shishkin interprets it. CZcams is a media platform where we are allowed to give our opinions freely. I do see what you’re saying, nonetheless. If I was in a circle of Liszt savants, I wouldn’t have spoken this way.
I have played this piece from 1977, and I have heard many professional pianists play it. But this performance is by far the best l have heard. This may be a legendary performance for many years to come.
I feel like he’s better at the light parts than the powerful ones, the build ups are lacking so I didn’t feel that explosive emotion usually expressed in this piece by some other pianists it stayed flat. But I loved the light softer parts very beautiful and cleaner than most I’ve heard
Why do they all skip the arpeggio which would be played at about 9:50? I realize that it is optional, and the only pianist whom I have seen play this part is Van Cliburn.
a gifted performance. I was spoiled by Rubenstein's interpretation and for years shunned the faster tempo of this song. It always felt rushed and even a bit showy. You definitely lose something when playing at the higher tempo, but over those years I've come to appreciate them much more, especially when done so well like in this example.
It's probably a very good performance but it's not really possible to tell when all the dynamics have been flattened out of it. Why anyone thinks that is a good idea defeats me completely. Does anyone have a link to a decent-sounding copy?
Do you mean it’s not the same as in the markings, or are you saying there is no change. Because he is changing from piano, fortissimo, and mezzo piano decently consistent . Or when the piece needs to change the dynamics.
@@aisareu *He* is, but whoever processed this recording has done their utmost to negate all the changes the player has put in, which seems tome to be rude, at the least.
so pushing and haste. has powerful energy and force but he didn't wait flow.. like berezovsky who rushing more than shishkin. i respect his perform but can't agree his music.
It do sound a lot more staccato-esque and I quite like but still some mistakes which makes me wonder how exatcly this is so extravagant to others. Curious only no hate
Magnificent Pianist....One Of The Very Greatest MEPHISTOS EVER Recorded ....SHISHKIN should win every competition but he has a MAJOR flaw...the visual movement of his mouth detracts TREMENDOUSLY from his Horowitzian Talent . It could ruin a great career ...AND IT IS VERY DISRESPECTFUL NOT TO WEAR A TIE 📣📣📣📣..fortunately these can easily be fixed !!……… I was lucky to have been a friend of Vladimir Horowitz back in my Juilliard Masters days in the 1970s.....and he would have raved for your wonderful Playing !!!!!!!!
This performance is brilliant, but I had to turn the visuals off because of the grimacing tension in this guy's mouth. Such a waste of energy. My personal favourite version is still that of Grynyuk (czcams.com/video/J2CWQKT3-34/video.html).
You cannot tell the difference between a SONG and a PIANO PIECE and yet, you have the nerve to judge this out-of - this-world performance 🙄. Absolutely ridiculous!
Each time I open a Mephisto CZcams performance by a gifted pianist, there are always these kinds of comments: " the best performance ever". THERE IS NO BEST PERFORMANCE EVER. EACH GREAT INTERPRETATION IS VALUABLE. DIVERSITY IS GREAT!!!
I agree.
Nuh uh🥰
This is the best comment ever... 😂
Haha so true. There is no best performance except: Kissin in Prokofiev Etude op 4 no 3. Pompa Baldi Prokofiev Etude op 4 no 1. Kissin Balakirev The Lark and others
The Mephisto Waltz is no match for this man.
5:27 ❤ you can create a whole story inside your head with these sounds❤❤ incredible
Incredible performance!Truly amazing!!
SOMEONE ELSE REUPLOADED IT
THANK YOU
By far my favorite performance, he even had time to scratch his nose at 8:35
Man I love this video, thanks for uploading it!
Я бы даже не отказался выпить с этим чуваком
I’ve been looking for this performance for so long. Thanks for uploading it! Not sure why it was taken down in the first place
this is the best performance of this piece no doubt
Потрясающее исполнение ! Ювелирная техника владения инструментом плюс исполнение, эмоциональное и экспресиивное и в итоге - шедевр ! Слушала и ловила себя на мысли, что пианист как будто с другой планеты. Браво !!!👋👋👋👍👍👍
How come the whole pianistic world doesn't know this brilliant pianist?!
Ask Vlad.
I prefer much more the new generation of pianists like Shishkin, Kobayashi rather than Horowitz or Rubinstein
Veramente Mephisto! Fenomenale!
Beautiful coherent musical phrases and interesting mood changes.
Дмитрий, это уму непостижимо, как можно так здорово играть на этом рояле! Дима, твоя интерпретация блестяща, дух романтизма витает рядом с твоей головой и твоими пальцами, он движет твоей душой! Спасибо тебе за ту красоту, что ты умеешь нести людям! Слушать тебя- это восторг души и даже счастье! Мне уже почти 70 лет, но я в восторге от твоей игры. Ты чародей и чары твои прекрасны! Да хранит тебя Бог, дитя радости, красоты и гармонии!❤🎉🙏🙏👍
Woaaaah! This is the best interpretation!❤❤❤❤
My favorite performance of the Mephisto Waltz! Thanks for reuploading.
7:55 😱😱
8:15 - 8:37 - that’s exactly how it should be played :) thanks for uploading this! it’s been so long since I’ve listened to this version.
Most important, it gave him enough time to SCRATCH HIS NOSE at 8:38 (the only part where I can tell him to hold my beer!)
I don't mean to be a classical music elitist, and I know you mean well. However, it is quite rude to interpret the composer's ideas so bluntly. It is their music, but each performer plays differently. They all play so well, but there is not, in essence, an 'exact' way to perform! That is disrespectful to the composer.
@@fushifushi9441 I only meant what I said as an opinion, because the way I would interpret is the same way Shishkin interprets it. CZcams is a media platform where we are allowed to give our opinions freely. I do see what you’re saying, nonetheless. If I was in a circle of Liszt savants, I wouldn’t have spoken this way.
@@scorpioxrocky Thank you for the clarification!
wow. stunning.
Finally, it's back! The most extraordinary performance of Liszt's Mephisto Waltz I have ever heard! Thank you for re-uploading it!
This is best than many great pianists performances
@@ArthurCz-A990 Yes it is! No question about it!
Listen please also Alexei Sultanov
@@sondraolden5656 I listen to Sultanov a lot. His performances break my heart. I love him!
@@PhillipLWilcherespecially his Rach 2.
8:32 this harmony!
Power of C major
Mephisto is a...Demon..
lol...Dmitry ( the One and Only Dmitry) can play in a " devilish" way ...listen to the " staccato" ...FORCE ..ENERGY ...WOW
N. Economou's is very fiendish too!
like his unique interpretation and I'm jealous of his fingers, optimal for piano
Yes! Huge hands, perfect for Rachmaninoff!
And Liszt 🤓
Omg! Thank you for uploading this performance! I was wondering when I couldn't find this exact performance by Shishkin.
Thank you to upload one more time. It was impossible to find it anymore. ❤
This is a beast of a performance! Such a beautiful, controlled touch of the keys.
Слов нет!!! Одним словом -- Блестяще !!!! Спасибо !!!! Брависсимо!!!!❤
와 이거 없어져서 존나 찾았는디 거의1년만에ㅡ찾았다 😢😢😢😅😊❤
This is the best performance of this piece, ever ... PERIOD!!! Bravo Dmitry!
I am so glad it has re-appeared at CZcams! It's the most extraordinary thing!
Daniil Trifonov
@@Favrach1 you must be joking
@@jacoblehrer4198 no
@@Favrach1yunchan lim's was alot better than trifonov s
I really love the part around minute 8. Came here because of a small clip from this part.
Absolutely amazing, thanks for uploading
Quel niveau !
Bravissimo 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
amazing !
I have played this piece from 1977, and I have heard many professional pianists play it. But this performance is by far the best l have heard. This may be a legendary performance for many years to come.
What about Horowitz and Pletnev ?
Fantastic performance. When I first heard the audio I thought it Khatia Buniatishvilli
This guy plays a lot clearer than her
omg this is epic!
*Beautiful! And the performance was good too.*
Ur a god for reuploading this
Thanks
Breathtaking performance. Ouf! Wow! OMG!
And such sensuous lips ❤
Thanks
True artist.
Не со всем можно согласиться, но ... смело и профессионально!
7:55 is inhumane
Complimenti grandissimi!!!
❤❤❤
sultanov killed this piece....but this is a good recording too
Together with Horowitz and Pletnev
8:00
Yeah, i think this is the scariest part to be played from the whole score. His speed and accuracy here beyond normal human haha
😐😬😐😬😐😬
Congratulation!!
👍👍👍
love you
메피스토 왈츠의 교과서
I feel like he’s better at the light parts than the powerful ones, the build ups are lacking so I didn’t feel that explosive emotion usually expressed in this piece by some other pianists it stayed flat. But I loved the light softer parts very beautiful and cleaner than most I’ve heard
中村紘子さんは表舞台に帰ってくださることはないのかも知れません。今の日本のピアノ界のレベルは幻想即興曲が弾けたら、自称ピアニストで良いと思います。毎日何事も一流を祈っています。
Послушайте как играл Алексей Султанов этот вальс в отборе на конкурс Ван Клиберна.
Безвременно ушедший ГЕНИЙ.
Да,я вот сравнила сейчас.. у Алексея там столько оттенков с ума сойти просто...
Ну и Алексея интерпретация круче и сложнее , что уж говорить 😊
@@sondraolden5656да уж никто не сможет сыграть Мефисто так, как Алексей
Studeert 48 uur per dag?
Why do they all skip the arpeggio which would be played at about 9:50? I realize that it is optional, and the only pianist whom I have seen play this part is Van Cliburn.
今のピアニストのトップは内田光子さんらしいですが、私とは何の関係もありません。昔の大音楽家は今でもお元気な方が多いと思います。規律正しい生活が健康を支えていると思います。音大、芸大に行ってもものにならない人ばかりです。私は20歳代の時、軟弱過ぎましたが、今は学会員になられたアマラウ、ビエイラさんにお会いしてみたいです。
1:02
7:15
0:03 2:43
a gifted performance. I was spoiled by Rubenstein's interpretation and for years shunned the faster tempo of this song. It always felt rushed and even a bit showy. You definitely lose something when playing at the higher tempo, but over those years I've come to appreciate them much more, especially when done so well like in this example.
It's probably a very good performance but it's not really possible to tell when all the dynamics have been flattened out of it. Why anyone thinks that is a good idea defeats me completely. Does anyone have a link to a decent-sounding copy?
Do you mean it’s not the same as in the markings, or are you saying there is no change. Because he is changing from piano, fortissimo, and mezzo piano decently consistent . Or when the piece needs to change the dynamics.
@@aisareu *He* is, but whoever processed this recording has done their utmost to negate all the changes the player has put in, which seems tome to be rude, at the least.
6:57
2:44
1.56 William Kapell
5:23
1:49 he made a few mistakes in a row omg
alright go on do that section better and the rest the same as him
He's young, this is live, and those mistakes didn't detract from the performance.
@@snakely it was a joke bro
It’s not noticeable anyways, what’s the matter of correcting his mistake if it’s not noticeable?
@@kukikukic5539🙄
WOW!!!!!! Who is this!!!! Liszt reincarnated.
これはあの難しいメフィストワルツではありませんか。結構難しい曲だと思います。
Dont try this at home
😂
Rofl.. 😂😂😂😂
so pushing and haste. has powerful energy and force but he didn't wait flow.. like berezovsky who rushing more than shishkin.
i respect his perform but can't agree his music.
It do sound a lot more staccato-esque and I quite like but still some mistakes which makes me wonder how exatcly this is so extravagant to others. Curious only no hate
Damn the speed tho 😅
It sounds a tiny bit too rushed in some sections... good performance overall though!
Magnificent Pianist....One Of The Very Greatest MEPHISTOS EVER Recorded ....SHISHKIN should win every competition but he has a MAJOR flaw...the visual movement of his mouth detracts TREMENDOUSLY from his Horowitzian Talent . It could ruin a great career ...AND IT IS VERY DISRESPECTFUL NOT TO WEAR A TIE 📣📣📣📣..fortunately these can easily be fixed !!……… I was lucky to have been a friend of Vladimir Horowitz back in my Juilliard Masters days in the 1970s.....and he would have raved for your wonderful Playing !!!!!!!!
This performance is brilliant, but I had to turn the visuals off because of the grimacing tension in this guy's mouth. Such a waste of energy. My personal favourite version is still that of Grynyuk (czcams.com/video/J2CWQKT3-34/video.html).
정말 별로다 진심. 곡해석을 정말 못하네요. 마을 술집이 전혀 떠오르지 않아요.
피아니스트 개인의 해석이니 존중해야죠 ㅎㅎ
You cannot tell the difference between a SONG and a PIANO PIECE and yet, you have the nerve to judge this out-of - this-world performance 🙄. Absolutely ridiculous!
곡에 의미가 정해져있는게 아니죠. 곡은 음표들의 조합일뿐 그 속에 담긴 의미를 느끼는것은 듣는 사람 나름입니다. 당신이 뭔데 이 대단한 연주를 폄하하는지 모르겠네요
이런 댓글을 달거면 그냥 댓글을 달지 않았으면 될건데 아님 장난으로 단건지 모르겠지만 당신이 쳐보세요 이게 곡해석 하는 게 얼마나 어려운건지 이거 읽고 나서 기분이 좀 나빴다면 죄송합니다
마을 술집이 떠오르진 않지만, 메피스토(악마)가 상상되네요.
특히 7:53 부터는 악마가 웃으면서 유혹하는 것만 같음.
7:34