BILLY JOEL - NEW YORK STATE OF MIND | REACTION (GREY OLD WHISTLE TEST)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
  • FIRST TIME WATCHING ONE OF BILLY JOEL'S GREATEST HITS "NEW YORK STATE OF MIND LIVE AT GREY OLD WHISTLE TEST
    Road to 100k Subs
    #billyjoel #reaction #newyorkstateofmind
    💰 SUPPORT/DONATE TO THE CHANNEL
    ►Cashapp: $ALJ83
    ►Paypal: paypal.me/Muge...
    ►www.buymeacoff...
    ►My Amazon WishList: www.amazon.com...
    THE GOODS!!
    amzn.to/3XKvXPz
    www.underlucky...
    temu.to/k/us5Y...
    📢 GET IN TOUCH WITH ME
    ►Instagram: / mugnifyreacts
    ►Twitter: / mugnifyrts
    *Copyright Disclaimer
    Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS*

Komentáře • 125

  • @jamishops
    @jamishops Před rokem +73

    Billy wrote this song in less than an hour. It came to him on a greyhound bus going up the hudson river line. He ran into the house and put it down on paper. One of his idols is Ray Charles and he was thinking of Ray’s singing when he wrote it. He actually named his daughter, Alexa Ray, after Ray Charles. Ray was very moved by the gesture and asked Billy to write a song for them to sing as a duet. Billy wrote “Baby Grand” and he and Ray recorded it.

    • @robinlathim8221
      @robinlathim8221 Před rokem +2

      Thank you

    • @robinlathim8221
      @robinlathim8221 Před rokem +3

      He got his start as the piano man.

    • @DevineMissMerlin
      @DevineMissMerlin Před rokem +6

      I love 'Baby Grand', because you can feel them playing off each other's love of music ❤

    • @dab_family9405
      @dab_family9405 Před 3 měsíci +1

      That is crazy, because when I listen to this song, I always think he sounds like Ray Charles.

  • @meditationlifeskills
    @meditationlifeskills Před rokem +41

    This is exactly why the 70's music is so good. Freedom to be who they were and create "their unique" music!

    • @TheJohnnywbred
      @TheJohnnywbred Před rokem +2

      This was actually true of cinema as well. It was a great artistic decade.

    • @Sunny-jz3dy
      @Sunny-jz3dy Před rokem +1

      Yes!!! A great ....great time for music.... or being an artist in pretty much anything.... during that time.!

  • @anotheryou218
    @anotheryou218 Před rokem +5

    Billy is New York! Great pick; he's one of the greatest and that's a cliche, but true in his case, The real deal; he's a shaper of our culture in the best possible sense. We can all be proud of Billy Joel.

  • @ThistleAndSea
    @ThistleAndSea Před rokem +25

    Mad respect for those artists who can do it live. 😎

  • @chris...9497
    @chris...9497 Před rokem +6

    Billy's father was a classically-trained pianist, though he left the family in New York early in Billy's childhood to return to Europe.
    Billy received classical piano training from the age of four, which he did not appreciate at first. Later, he grew excited about the music of the times: old-style early rock & roll, blues, jazz, etc. He especially liked Ray Charles, himself no respecter of musical genre boundaries; you'll notice, if you look at Billy's catalog, he rolls into quite a number of different musical genres.
    Billy was thrilled to write "Baby Grand" for Ray Charles and to have the opportunity to record it with him. Yes, Billy's daughter Alexa's middle name 'Ray' is in honor of Ray Charles.
    Ray Charles presided over Billy Joel's induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1999.

  • @user-pf7jm9go6o
    @user-pf7jm9go6o Před rokem +11

    In case you missed it, this was his tribute to Ray Charles, from the music to the sunglasses to the vocal style

  • @dennispitkofsky6026
    @dennispitkofsky6026 Před rokem +14

    richie was on fire on his solo even billy loved it

    • @seanscanlon9067
      @seanscanlon9067 Před rokem +1

      This performance was from 1978 and when Phil Ramone produced the first of many of Billy's albums, The Stranger the year before, he used the late jazz great Phil Woods to play the sax part on Just the Way You Are, with Richie having previously played saxophones on the Turnstiles album from 1976, where this song comes from.
      If you pardon the pun here, I think perhaps Richie has a sax to grind.

  • @lucabraga3471
    @lucabraga3471 Před rokem +24

    Billy Joel has made tons of great songs. You could react to his "For the longest time", "Leningrad" and "Honesty".

    • @cyb2191
      @cyb2191 Před rokem +3

      Would love to see "Leningrad" or "Downeaster Alexa", good Billy story telling songs

  • @robertusa1234
    @robertusa1234 Před rokem +4

    I’m from New York. We all love this song.

  • @marksanders8028
    @marksanders8028 Před rokem +9

    When it rains in New York it makes it’s own gravy.

  • @TexasMagnolia
    @TexasMagnolia Před rokem +17

    No better Songwriter and Composer! Next must are:
    The Stranger
    Scenes from an Italian Restaurant
    He’s lyrics are so amazing, always have lyrics pulled-up and Always watch live.

  • @dawnmarieallenkent2495
    @dawnmarieallenkent2495 Před rokem +4

    Billy grew up in Hicksville, Long Island NY. I grew up in Levittown right next to Hicksville.
    He had a tragic youth... and we all came him as one of ours! Haven met a Long Islander that doesn't ❤❤❤ him!
    His reference to China Town and Riverside is in Manhattan aka NYC.
    If you grow up on Long Island or the 5 Boroughs of NY City no matter where you end up... you'll FOREVER be in "A New York state if mind!!
    I Consider my self a Long Islander stuck in a New Jersey world.😉

  • @Steve-hq4fm
    @Steve-hq4fm Před dnem +1

    Ray Charles was a huge influence, and this song was written as a tribute of sorts to him. He sings it like he imagines Ray would sing it, and you can tell that very early on.

  • @suzie4417
    @suzie4417 Před rokem +10

    Billy is beloved in New York 💓 He is influenced by Ray Charles, Jimi Hendrix, Fab Four🇬🇧, he likes classical piano & brass. This song has been in movies that take place in NYC 🌃🗽 sitting in a dark, smoky club listening to the piano man 💥

  • @sharonoconnor2849
    @sharonoconnor2849 Před rokem +13

    Hey, The old grey whistle test was a uk tv music programme, there were lots of good stuff on there, I'd say people that truly appreciated music would watch it, you should probably check out more 😊 loving your channel ❤

  • @bobsteinzig
    @bobsteinzig Před rokem +6

    Ray inducted Billy into The R&R Hall of Fame

  • @lesblatnyak5947
    @lesblatnyak5947 Před rokem +5

    Billy was brilliant live, I was fortunate to see him 4 times in the 70s

  • @mustangman8517
    @mustangman8517 Před rokem +3

    Billy was born and raised in the Bronx, long Island NYC and made his start in small bars and clubs around the neighborhood

  • @shellygill5029
    @shellygill5029 Před rokem +3

    He's channelling his inner Ray Charles influence in this song. Billy Joel grew up in N.Y. and this song is all about that. The Hudson River line bus goes to up state N.Y. from N.Y.C..
    He mentions Chinatown in N.Y.C...in lower Manhattan. (downtown)
    This live performance is much better than the recorded version. More free and open with his style.

  • @jasonsomething6003
    @jasonsomething6003 Před 9 měsíci +2

    The SAX always did for me in this song!
    Billy Joel.. in a class of his own!
    peace

  • @otisyoung7061
    @otisyoung7061 Před rokem +2

    You're right right off the bat......Ray Charles big influence as well as the Beatles he has said

  • @Liz11679
    @Liz11679 Před rokem +5

    Nothing better in a song then a saxophone! That is Richie Cannata btw!...
    Also Joel's influences were Ray Charles, Beatles, Jimi Hendrix he was also influenced by Classical music!..

  • @ed.z.
    @ed.z. Před rokem +2

    Billy is from Long Island, NY.

  • @TheGreatGig73
    @TheGreatGig73 Před rokem +2

    His daughter is named Alexa Ray Joel. The middle name 'Ray' is in honor of Ray Charles. One of billy's biggest influences.

  • @barbjustbarb
    @barbjustbarb Před rokem +5

    Check out “Prelude/Angry Young Man” from Billy Joel Live from Long Island in 1982. Any song from that performance would be worth your while. All the more stunning that he manages to play the piano so masterfully while his thumb is still bandaged from having been crushed in a motorcycle accident earlier that year.

    • @wendyranta
      @wendyranta Před rokem +1

      Love love love that song, the piano if unbelievable in that song!!

  • @pamelalaws7593
    @pamelalaws7593 Před rokem +1

    so glad I came across your cover? I'm 78 now and so wonderful to be able to visit and find others that have similar interests, likes and pleasures, And I have "hit the nail on the head" as my parents and others used to say when they found something great, or what they were searching for. I would say you appreciate quality pleasures with intelligence and feeling, yes, I'll be keeping an eye open on your travels on line..

  • @Sunny-jz3dy
    @Sunny-jz3dy Před rokem +1

    He started out in dive bars! Lol. I think it's what helped him write... piano man! He knew the atmosphere ....he knew the people... no matter which bar your in....you're going to have the same type of characters over and over again. I've seen it throughout the years... whether I was bartending or waiting tables.

  • @jacqueline4514
    @jacqueline4514 Před rokem +3

    Gives me goosebumps every time I hear it; the sound and lyrics embody NYC 🗽🗽🗽 Grew up in the Bronx and Brooklyn, and it never, ever leaves you. Next Billy Joel songs: "Miami 2017 (Seen the lights go out on Broadway)", "Big Shot" "The Stranger" ❤. Another great reaction!

  • @TheDivayenta
    @TheDivayenta Před rokem +2

    Whistle Test was a British TV pop music show. Billy grew up on Long Island, NY. He is a huge fan of Ray Charles- do you hear it? He and Ray have a fabulous duet together- Baby Grand.

  • @paulharbron8439
    @paulharbron8439 Před rokem +2

    You found a good one friend. I consider it to be one of the special performances on video

  • @piperbird7193
    @piperbird7193 Před rokem +3

    You would probably really enjoy "Scenes from an Italian Restaurant".

  • @jillk368
    @jillk368 Před rokem +2

    Root Beer Rag is cool. Just piano. Same show is a great set, too.

  • @rickward460
    @rickward460 Před rokem +5

    Nicely played Brother! There ain't nothin' blue about the Blues 🙏👍🐶😎🇺🇸

  • @ritathomas5167
    @ritathomas5167 Před rokem +1

    Like all band musicians, they come and go. I'm not sure how many of his band members today have been with him from the beginning, if any, but his band has always been so excellent! And Billy knows that. I read that during Covid lockdown he continued to pay all of his band because he wanted them there and ready when Covid eased up and he could go back to performing. That's a class act!

  • @bat_fastard4525
    @bat_fastard4525 Před rokem +2

    Ya had me at piano man.all time favourite song 🤣 . but I was definitely like umm not the best place to start but your going down that hole now 😂

    • @bat_fastard4525
      @bat_fastard4525 Před rokem

      N my doob always stays in the corner of my mouth lmao…am I that old uncle ..😢

  • @carriemichelle322
    @carriemichelle322 Před rokem +4

    Goodnight Saigon is about the Vietnam war. He had veterans come out and sing the chorus at every concert. So powerful! You'd enjoy it!
    Also been asking since your first live...
    Skid Row...Wasted Time. 😊

  • @user-or1ye3iz6d
    @user-or1ye3iz6d Před rokem +1

    Billy Joel "SCENES FROM AN ITALIAN RESTAURANT" and "Goodnight Saigon" are awesome 🔥🔥🔥

  • @mollysibley1412
    @mollysibley1412 Před rokem +2

    He re-released this song after 9/11 in tribute to NYC.

  • @mikebird3529
    @mikebird3529 Před 10 měsíci +2

    Billy Joel was channeling his best Ray Charles. Love you brother keep it up.

  • @bobsteinzig
    @bobsteinzig Před rokem +2

    Cold Spring Harbor was Billy's 1st album. The studio sped up the sound to make his voice higher. he left. Clive Owen resolved the issue but did not want to use his band. then Phil Ramone did The Stranger one of the greatest albums

    • @seanscanlon9067
      @seanscanlon9067 Před rokem

      Not trying to be dick here, but I think that you mean Clive Davis from Columbia Records.
      I only say that, as I am from London in the UK and Clive Owen is a British actor.

    • @bobsteinzig
      @bobsteinzig Před rokem

      @@seanscanlon9067 yes Elton Johns guy

  • @seanscanlon9067
    @seanscanlon9067 Před rokem +1

    The Old Grey Whistle Test, rather than grey old. It was a long-running, about 30 years, music show that was on the BBC here in the UK.
    From Wiki:
    According to presenter Bob Harris, the programme derived its name from a Tin Pan Alley phrase from years before. When they got the first pressing of a record they would play it to people they called the old greys - doormen in grey suits. Any song the doormen could remember and whistle, having heard it just once or twice, had passed the old grey whistle test.

  • @wildmanmoon
    @wildmanmoon Před 12 dny

    Billy pulls out all of his inner Ray Charles vibe for this fabulous song. I’m a Philly guy so it’s hard for me to get behind New York (it’s a sports thing) but this song almost makes me want to switch over. ALMOST!

  • @greendragonpublishing
    @greendragonpublishing Před 6 měsíci

    Ray Charles was one of his heroes - and he recorded a song with him, My Baby Grand. Joel named his daughter Alexa Ray after Ray Charles.

  • @elaines5750
    @elaines5750 Před rokem +1

    I believe the sax player's name is Richie Cannata? He's amazing.

  • @TexasMagnolia
    @TexasMagnolia Před rokem +2

    Billy Joel and Elton John….Genres All Their Own!

  • @ukiahsguitarsolos3436
    @ukiahsguitarsolos3436 Před měsícem

    Beautiful song.

  • @guyturbide6348
    @guyturbide6348 Před rokem +2

    🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
    Great reaction 👏👏👏
    Another great song that you gonna enjoy is by
    "ST-PAUL AND THE BROKEN BONES "
    The live studio version is
    🎵 Grass is Greener 🎵
    Keep the good work my friend ✌️ 👏 👍🏻

  • @5850terry
    @5850terry Před 2 měsíci

    I love this song.

  • @justkaron
    @justkaron Před rokem +1

    This is Billy's straight up tribute to Ray Charles. LOVE me some Billy Joel.

  • @kevincosta9228
    @kevincosta9228 Před rokem

    "You need an new alternator..." Thanks a lot, you made me spit my beer all over the monitor. LOL

  • @williamlovett619
    @williamlovett619 Před rokem +1

    An absolute gem

  • @roberttaylor7064
    @roberttaylor7064 Před 6 měsíci

    The old grey whistle test was at The BBC Studio in The U.K.

  • @douglasennis7291
    @douglasennis7291 Před 11 měsíci +1

    He's from Long Island 😎👍🏻

  • @shenebraskan4945
    @shenebraskan4945 Před rokem +1

    Great job on these Billy Joel reactions. Subscribed.

  • @anthonyhitchman9789
    @anthonyhitchman9789 Před rokem +1

    I love this song. But like you it’s the first time I’ve heard this. And I was a great fan of old grey whistle test. He never ceases to amaze me. Great review watched quite a few of yours lately and have enjoyed all them. Keep it up❤

  • @alphapockets
    @alphapockets Před rokem

    My mom has been obsessed with billys original saxophonist (here) for literal decades. She always said there was nothing like his solos

  • @redrum482
    @redrum482 Před 11 měsíci

    Billy is an amazing composer. Amazing performance. Great reaction!

  • @honestabe1940
    @honestabe1940 Před 15 dny +1

    When you think you have something to say: Think again.

  • @garywyatt5670
    @garywyatt5670 Před 10 měsíci

    I saw an interview once where Billy expressed that this was a kinda respect to Ray Charles who was a big influence in his early music. If you close your eyes you can here the Ray influence in his delivery.

  • @marilyn4917
    @marilyn4917 Před rokem

    Love your appreciation for the music of that era. What a great time!

  • @musicairplanes4884
    @musicairplanes4884 Před rokem

    I saw Billy at the Forum in Inglewood many years ago. He made the place feel like a small jazz club. Pretty amazing.

  • @Tommy-wm8gi
    @Tommy-wm8gi Před rokem

    Watch him and the band in prime. Live Long island. Watch the whole thing and enjoy! Love your channel. Keep digging

  • @gillian5005
    @gillian5005 Před rokem

    Billy is the real deal! ❤

  • @guyhenderson405
    @guyhenderson405 Před 9 měsíci

    Funny you mention Ray Charles, they did a duet together "Baby Grand." Worth a listen/reaction.

  • @gilevin100
    @gilevin100 Před rokem

    Amazing performance....excellent reaction!

  • @Vmcf1968
    @Vmcf1968 Před 5 měsíci

    makes me want to go listen to some jazz. i need marsalles

  • @jnagarya519
    @jnagarya519 Před 5 měsíci

    He's talking about OTHER people needing holidays. Then he talks about other places he's been. But he's all about New York.

  • @robinbeers6689
    @robinbeers6689 Před rokem

    I love that lyric bit, "I don't have any reasons. I've left them all behind". To me that says I don't have to explain anything or justify anything to anyone.

  • @brendaclark8344
    @brendaclark8344 Před rokem

    The Grey Old Whistle Test was a BBC series.

  • @joelspaulding5964
    @joelspaulding5964 Před 5 měsíci

    At 4:12 the bridge- Think only Ray Charles during that part. Spooky good.

  • @Tommy-wm8gi
    @Tommy-wm8gi Před rokem

    Billy obviously dealt with demons earlier on. Listen to " captain jack". But came up obviously into doo wop and other great musicians and vocalists. I always have listened to everything he has done. Admire that when the Big label took notice and said we want to sign you and put with all the top studio musicians. He said " the whole band is the best and have ridden in vans and played dive bars for years stuck wt me believed sign us all or screw you!

  • @joelspaulding5964
    @joelspaulding5964 Před rokem

    When he sang "Daily News......." That was ALL Ray. The vibrato- full clone.

  • @mishkamoto999
    @mishkamoto999 Před 2 měsíci

    ❤❤❤

  • @txheadshots
    @txheadshots Před rokem

    He got his start.... as a Piano Man... he lived that life for a while

  • @jnagarya519
    @jnagarya519 Před 5 měsíci

    OLD Grey Whistle Test -- a British TV music program.

  • @JackMorganEFLavandowska

    Would super recommend watching his episode of Inside the Actors Studio, which as of this date is still available on CZcams in it's full length. He talks a bit about his influences and also talks a lot about music theory. He's very funny but also incredibly informative and a great teacher, talking through the different parts of his songs. Truly love his work :)

  • @kimking6036
    @kimking6036 Před rokem +1

    Billy has a lot of different sounds and types of music. He writes his own music and lyrics. He got his start in piano bars. That's how he came up with Piano man. All the people in the song are real. Check out that song, You may be right, Uptown girl and River of dreams

  • @greglambert998
    @greglambert998 Před 11 měsíci

    Billy Joel is from Long Island New York.

  • @charlesdavis7461
    @charlesdavis7461 Před rokem

    Used to love going to the what we called lounges to hear the music, never say Billy Joel lol.

  • @brianmatthews1736
    @brianmatthews1736 Před rokem

    Among his earliest influences, Joel cites Beethoven, Chopin and Debussy, along with the great American composers, Copeland, Gershwin and Ellington. His more contemporary influences include Dave Brubeck, Ray Charles, Otis Redding, The Beatles and Jimi Hendrix.

  • @KimbaLoveAdams
    @KimbaLoveAdams Před rokem +6

    He's American. There is no UK anything. It was a choice.

    • @elaines5750
      @elaines5750 Před rokem +3

      The Old Grey Whistle Test is in the UK which is where this concert was taped.

  • @Tommy-wm8gi
    @Tommy-wm8gi Před rokem

    Scenes from an Italian restaurant

  • @TheDivayenta
    @TheDivayenta Před 10 měsíci

    This is an homage to Ray Charles. ❤

  • @jasonlengyel1104
    @jasonlengyel1104 Před rokem

    Back when live shows were as good or better than the radio version.

  • @riccardoangeli802
    @riccardoangeli802 Před rokem

    Per Piano Man la musica in gioco facile 🎹👏Talento ...

  • @LtFrankDrebin100
    @LtFrankDrebin100 Před rokem

    Ray Charles is his favorite artist.
    Cab Calloway is Janet Jackson’s.
    Those are 2 facts I know for sure.

  • @kathleenmayhorne3183
    @kathleenmayhorne3183 Před 5 měsíci

    He tryed to do this as Ray Charles would have.

  • @1bigrowdy
    @1bigrowdy Před 11 měsíci

    Until the Night is the best song you never heard from him

  • @paul2862
    @paul2862 Před rokem

    I'm pretty sure Ray Charles was one of his influences--too many similarities to ignore. As long as you're doing musicians from that era, you should check out Van Morrison, who was also heavily influenced by jazz:
    "Tupelo Honey" (czcams.com/video/3DbTIKHYwog/video.html) --probably his most well-known song.
    "And It Stoned Me" (czcams.com/video/AYqJtqyeilE/video.html) --the reference to "Jelly Roll" in the song is about Jelly Roll Morton, one of Van Morrison's jazz influences.
    "Cyprus Avenue" (czcams.com/video/dlMjmXb69NI/video.html) --off of one of his earliest albums, my personal favorite among a huge catalogue of great songs.

  • @Ray-gf4vf
    @Ray-gf4vf Před rokem +2

    billy is from long island ny. thats his start new york

  • @jnagarya519
    @jnagarya519 Před 5 měsíci

    He's from New York.

  • @localhoast2009
    @localhoast2009 Před rokem

    Ray Charles was a major influence for Billy

  • @barbaralevel7225
    @barbaralevel7225 Před rokem

    You should actually watch his videos when he is older. He is even better. He did concerns with Elton John. I think I saw a video with him and Ray Charles playing and singing.

  • @goolah13
    @goolah13 Před rokem

    Mr Ray Charles

  • @pete3883
    @pete3883 Před rokem

    No, he is the influencer.

  • @lorilxn1597
    @lorilxn1597 Před 10 měsíci

    He married super model Christie Brinkley

  • @Jessedog11
    @Jessedog11 Před rokem

    please turn your volume up. its hard to hear the song

  • @toddnesbitt3113
    @toddnesbitt3113 Před rokem

    Corner of the lip is patented…Uncle

  • @annheckenbach9396
    @annheckenbach9396 Před 9 měsíci +1

    I find constant interruption annoying. Perhaps rwo or three brief comments, you know? That's what I have seen those who do that seem to stick around. People who watch reaction videos are really into music, they want to hear comments, absolutely, two or three are good...just not constant pauses.

  • @amys.4951
    @amys.4951 Před rokem

    I think you'd really appreciate Billy Joel and Elton John playing together. They're pretty magical. czcams.com/video/WLMWGJ6I-mo/video.html