Thank you so much Sarde, please continue to amplify all Palestinian voices. This episode is so important. We need to read more educate ourselves more, listen to people like Mr Khalidi more. Please keep it up Sarde, this is so valuable. Thank you from the heart as a Lebanese.
i had to take multiple pauses during this sarde due to the heaviness of each section...and i'm only 40 minutes in. here's hoping i get through this one without losing anymore hope. on another note: Sarde is probably the only visual podcast i watch all the way through instead of just listening to it cuz of its helpful visual aids and eng subs. props to the team o mabrook 3ala elplaque!
شكرآ سرده . اختيار الضيوف وجودة التصوير والمُنتاج والمواضيع المطروحه بتنافس بل تتفوق على برامج تلفزيونيه وقنوات كبيره استمرو وان شاءالله الكل بيدعمكم ومبروك درع اليوتيوب🎉🎉
Thank you Sarde for putting this together: I am going to forward it to friends who want to learn more about this issue. It's so helpful, honest, and sympathetic. Thank you for all of your videos, in fact, they are all incredible
Thank you so much for bringing Doctor Rashid to your show. Very well respected historian. He speak his mind, he will tell you if Palestinian leadership were right or wrong. As a Palestinian Americans, we are always proud of you Doctor Rashid
شكرا سردة على المحتوى؛ I finally subscribed I follow you on Apple Podcast and all the episodes related to Palestine were either educational or inspirational keep it going
Thank you for hosting such a renowned historian. Small correction/ clarification is due: While there are historical proofs that a Jewish temple existed in Jerusalem at one point during the Roman period, there is no evidence of its exact location.
Excellent episode! Prof. Rashid is amazing as per usual, and I was pleasantly surprised with the presenter, his questions are nuanced and insightful, knows what he is talking about, and lets the Prof speaks without incessant interruptions. Subscribed.
Thanks for this extensive and interesting interview. I do have a few points to add to Professor Rachid Khalidi. The first one is in regard to the late Chairman Yasser Arafat, who has gone through a long and difficult struggle against the Zionists Jews and Zionists Arabs as well. The first point is related to Arafat'speech the UN. It is important to learn what Arafat himself said about his trip to New York and who was supporting and behind such historical visit. Second, very few our so-called Arab leader betrayed the Palestinian cause and I am sure that you are aware of many of those leaders who were and still are "licking the boots" of the Zionists from Sadat to Sissi in Egypt to the kings of Morocco, Saudia, and the Gulf Emirates, just to mention a few. In the early 1980's, I met Dr. Edward Said, in Fargo, ND at NDSU campus, just after his return from his PLO meeting in Algiers then and in response to one of my comments by just shaking hands with me and a tap on shoulder then he simply said "Jazair Al Thawra". Years have passed since, and I am still thinking about what he meant by such a response. He was very cordial and had a pleasant smile on his face "Rahimahu Allah" - May he rest in peace.
Thank you for this amazing interview!! I am proud of the work the youth are doing to keep the voice of justice alive as well as our Palestinian history… May Allah bless you ❤
Jewish Colonisation Association was also preparing Russian Jews to emigrate to Palestine in “ farms” they had set up in Argentina, and the Ottoman Anatolia. Here they learned farming but also how to use weapons…
Very insightful listening to Dr. Rashid Khalidi giving a great overview of the history of Palestine and the zionist projet. I really enjoyed hearing that he believes that the zionist project missed its time ans came very late. That’s very true. I hope to see a world free from colonialism ans settler colonialism ideologies.
د خالدي قال ان الحركة الصهيونية اشترت ما بين ٤-٦% من اراض فلسطين والباقي استولوا علية بالقوة. البيع لا يؤدي للسيادة sovereignty واعلان دولة مستقلة. الكثير من العرب مثلا يمتلكون اراض وعقارات في اوروبا، هذا لا يعطي لهم الحق بإعلان دولة عربية ذات سيادة على ممتلكاتهم.
This was very eye opening.. I’ve listened to Professor Khalidi prior and he’s always enlightening on the Palestinian cause. I’m happy to see that you’re bringing this information onto the forefront on your show
Extremely informative podcast. Excellent as always Sarde 👏🏼 I just want to clarify something the professor said, which I think was inaccurate: he is right, the Saudi military did not participate in the 1948 war, but Saudi soldiers did; they traveled from the west coast to Egypt and fought alongside the Egyptian army; many of them were martyred and buried in Gaza (may Allah grant them mercy). Free Palestine.
I think this would have been a good question for the professor. I remember Dennis Ross part of the American negotiating team for Oslo said that Yasser Arafat was offered the 2967 borders for a Palestinian state and Arafat rejected it is that true
Not just him. Bandar bin Sultan has said the same thing and basically summarized the decades long "negotiations" with the palestinians as the palestinians always rejecting a deal only to come back years later and start negotiating for the previously offered deal that was no longer on the table. No single person has done more harm to the palestinian cause and torpedoed the palestinian state than Yasser Arafat. Followed only slightly by Hamas who killed any remaining hope for a two state solution.
@@fireboy1996there was never a 2 state solution Are u out of ur mind There’s almost 1 million settlers in West Bank that are only growing Israel has mores land in the West Bank than us
@@RiRi-ku6xz You didn't seem to understand what I wrote. No there hasn't been a two state solution because your incompetent leaders rejected peace offers time and time again only to ask for those very same deals years later, but they weren't on the table anymore.
As Israeli, this conversation was really interesting. But there's something missing. In Israel living today more then 7M Jewish (lot of them born here). What his proposal for nowadays.
مرحبا حلقة حلوة خاصة لمن لا يعرف تاريخ فلسطين يا ريت حلقة اضافية مع الباحث عن حياته ومشواره الشخصي والاكاديمي بفكر رحلة الباحث الخالدي هي قصة مل فلسطيني ونجاحه هو قصة كفاح طويلة وملهمة كنت بحب اعرف تفاصيلها وهو ينتمي لعاىلة الخالدي التي لها الباع الطويل ف ابراز تاريخ فلسطين شكرا ع استضافته
but there is some information Khailidi lacks, Palestinians had no choice but to create resistance in Lebanon/Jordan because they were beaten, killed since 1949 as refugees, i.e. long ago before the invention of army groups.
I don't get the idea that someone claim to have the right to a land because he is believed to be a descendant of someone who have lived on that land thousands of years ago It is compeletly ridicious
As Israeli, this conversation was really interesting. There is something missing, eventually right now there are 7M Jewish in Israel, most of them born here. What his proposal for nowadays?
@@gamerissues9614 It's seems that you never visited Israel... The only one Jewish country in the world not gonna fall... And you probably don't know the Palestinians...
@@gamerissues9614 I absolutely agree, nation built on hate cannot uphold itself. This is exactly the reason Israel flourish while the palestinians can't build nothing productivity...
Don’t forget to like and comment on this Ep! Censorship is REAL and we need your help to spread the word! ❤
Thanks for the work you do and great choice of guests
بدنا لقا مع بروفيسورة نادرة شلهوب. الفلسطينية الي منعوها تحكي بجامعة برلين و انا فيني اوصلكم معها اذا بدكم و شكرا الكم
Amazing Sarde!! I've read Rashid Khalidi and listened to a lot of his interviews/lectures but never in Arabic. Definitely one to share 🇱🇧 🇵🇸 ✊️
Yes same!
But have you read stories and gained knowledge from reading works from opinions from other people with a different perspective.
What? RASHID KHALIDI WOW WOW WOW WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW🎉 Thank you so so much. I will listen now but I had to share my excitement
Thank you so much Sarde, please continue to amplify all Palestinian voices. This episode is so important. We need to read more educate ourselves more, listen to people like Mr Khalidi more. Please keep it up Sarde, this is so valuable. Thank you from the heart as a Lebanese.
I can't wait for this one...joining you from Ramallah!!
🇵🇸❤🇵🇸
برافووووووو، برافووووو برافو مليون مرة يا الله شو بتنحبوا على هيك لقاء و كل لقائاتكم و اختياراتكم
This was a fantastic episode, sending you love and well wishes from South Africa 🇿🇦❤🇵🇸
Best wishes to the people of South Africa 🇿🇦🇿🇦
@@Rabolisk thank you appreciated ❤
Thank you South Africa. All the respect and love to a nation, far in geographical distance but borders us in humanity and justice and gratitude
@@Santino369 thank you for the kind words. Hoping and praying for Palestine ❤🇵🇸🇿🇦
i had to take multiple pauses during this sarde due to the heaviness of each section...and i'm only 40 minutes in. here's hoping i get through this one without losing anymore hope.
on another note: Sarde is probably the only visual podcast i watch all the way through instead of just listening to it cuz of its helpful visual aids and eng subs. props to the team o mabrook 3ala elplaque!
Wow great Sarde thank you Professor Khalidi for being objective and honest
Thank you Sarde Family for the great interview. I remembered beloved late mother's Auntie was killed at the King David Hotel in 1946! Get well, Medea.
من فلسطين تحيى سردة❤
شكرآ سرده . اختيار الضيوف وجودة التصوير والمُنتاج والمواضيع المطروحه بتنافس بل تتفوق على برامج تلفزيونيه وقنوات كبيره استمرو وان شاءالله الكل بيدعمكم ومبروك درع اليوتيوب🎉🎉
Thank you Sarde for putting this together: I am going to forward it to friends who want to learn more about this issue. It's so helpful, honest, and sympathetic. Thank you for all of your videos, in fact, they are all incredible
Thank you so much for bringing Doctor Rashid to your show. Very well respected historian. He speak his mind, he will tell you if Palestinian leadership were right or wrong. As a Palestinian Americans, we are always proud of you Doctor Rashid
كتيييير شكرا . سردة اليوم على قد مانا عميقة على قد مانا مهمة . شكرا معين لاسئلتك و لضيفك المفكر المهم و الشاطر بالسرد.
Thank you for this informative conversation. A big fan of Mr Khalidi.
First time actually listening to Khalidi, he's absolutely brilliant.
شكرا للوعي اللي بتنشروه
كل الاحترام والتقدير ❤
حلقة رائعة كالعادة وكنت بتمنى ماديا تكون موجودة، الله يقومِك بالسلامة ❤
شكرا سردة على المحتوى؛ I finally subscribed I follow you on Apple Podcast and all the episodes related to Palestine were either educational or inspirational keep it going
شكراً كتير للحلقة وشكراً لكل من موجود في السردة🍉🍉🍉
I was wondering if/when you would get Rashid Khalidi on the podcast, very happy you did!
Sent this to my mom to watch :) really great questions and interview!
The best! Thank you for this episode. I am sure it’s going to be amazing and very informative
You guys are amazing. This is my favorite podcast and the episodes on palestine and Palestinian authors= historian are just amazing
a must-see for anyone interested in Palestine.
We should make a new Declaration and give them Britain.
No Germany. The Germans will worship them in few years.
I love how you are supporting Palestine.. Godspeed
سردية رائعة من الاستاذ رشيد الخالدي يشكر عليها،
Brilliantly executed interview!!! ❤❤ no doubt in my mind 😊
This Sarde gave me so much hope ! ♥️ The last chapter of Zio-nism !! 🎉 🎊 يا ويليييي
Can’t wait thank you Sarde 🥰🥰
Thank u for hosting such an intelligent man
Thank Sarde team for this important episode 👏🏻👍🏻
Very interesting sarde. History is the key to understand what is happening now.
Thank you!!! Left me feeling better than any other other interview since the latest round of genocide
God, I can't wait to watch the whole sarde 😊
Much needed info at that time of history 👌🏻❤️
شكرا جزيلا على السردة المنوّرة. اضطررت لمتابعتها على اجزاء لكون الموضوع عميق وبدها تركيز القصة.
Respect, great interview! Always good to hear from Prof Khalidi. Keep up the good work guys, love from Turkey
Good episode, thanks for having ustadh Rashid! How is Medea?
ياريت كمان تكملوا جميلكم وتعملوا حلقة مع د.طريف خالدي 🙏
Great work .. i've learned a lot in this episode thank you ❤❤
Amazing interview, as every single one Prof. Khalidi gives on the topic. What an honest, truthful voice. Thank you guys for bringing him!
Thank you for hosting such a renowned historian.
Small correction/ clarification is due:
While there are historical proofs that a Jewish temple existed in Jerusalem at one point during the Roman period, there is no evidence of its exact location.
thank you for this valuable piece of media. I'm writing my thesis on Palestine and this has rlly rlly helped
Excellent episode! Prof. Rashid is amazing as per usual, and I was pleasantly surprised with the presenter, his questions are nuanced and insightful, knows what he is talking about, and lets the Prof speaks without incessant interruptions. Subscribed.
Thanks for this extensive and interesting interview. I do have a few points to add to Professor Rachid Khalidi. The first one is in regard to the late Chairman Yasser Arafat, who has gone through a long and difficult struggle against the Zionists Jews and Zionists Arabs as well. The first point is related to Arafat'speech the UN. It is important to learn what Arafat himself said about his trip to New York and who was supporting and behind such historical visit. Second, very few our so-called Arab leader betrayed the Palestinian cause and I am sure that you are aware of many of those leaders who were and still are "licking the boots" of the Zionists from Sadat to Sissi in Egypt to the kings of Morocco, Saudia, and the Gulf Emirates, just to mention a few. In the early 1980's, I met Dr. Edward Said, in Fargo, ND at NDSU campus, just after his return from his PLO meeting in Algiers then and in response to one of my comments by just shaking hands with me and a tap on shoulder then he simply said "Jazair Al Thawra". Years have passed since, and I am still thinking about what he meant by such a response. He was very cordial and had a pleasant smile on his face "Rahimahu Allah" - May he rest in peace.
Thank you for this informative and excellent Sarde .
thank you so much Sarde for inviting the best scholar and spreading knowledge and high quality conversation.
Thank you for this amazing interview!! I am proud of the work the youth are doing to keep the voice of justice alive as well as our Palestinian history… May Allah bless you ❤
thanks a lot for every who worked on this
guys please do not stop.
حلقة رائعة وممتعة ومفيدة جدا. شكرا لكم.
Amazing and very informative ♥ Love from Tunisia
What a great sarde with a greatly informed, academic and inspiring individual like Professor Rashid!!! Learned so much today 😃
Enjoyed it ❤
Jewish Colonisation Association was also preparing Russian Jews to emigrate to Palestine in “ farms” they had set up in Argentina, and the Ottoman Anatolia. Here they learned farming but also how to use weapons…
Thank you for posting this ❤
Thank you
Very insightful listening to Dr. Rashid Khalidi giving a great overview of the history of Palestine and the zionist projet. I really enjoyed hearing that he believes that the zionist project missed its time ans came very late. That’s very true. I hope to see a world free from colonialism ans settler colonialism ideologies.
د خالدي قال ان الحركة الصهيونية اشترت ما بين ٤-٦% من اراض فلسطين والباقي استولوا علية بالقوة. البيع لا يؤدي للسيادة sovereignty واعلان دولة مستقلة. الكثير من العرب مثلا يمتلكون اراض وعقارات في اوروبا، هذا لا يعطي لهم الحق بإعلان دولة عربية ذات سيادة على ممتلكاتهم.
This was very eye opening.. I’ve listened to Professor Khalidi prior and he’s always enlightening on the Palestinian cause. I’m happy to see that you’re bringing this information onto the forefront on your show
شكرًا قد الدنيا
Thank you for this very interesting episode! It was great to hear the perspective of an American Palestinian/US-based historian during these times...
Cant wait ❤
Rashid Khalidi , is a political science professor at University of Chicago , he was a host at Public Radio , in the 80's and 90's .
Mabrouk
Wishing u the million.
Very interisting Sarde ,thank you
Love you guys
Prof. Khalidi is the best.
Read 100 Year War on Palestine.
You are just amazing guys!
I visited this office at Columbia University when Professor Edward Saeed was occupying it.
Great. Always keep talking about Palestine 🇵🇸. The main and the only Cause.
Freedom for Palestine and Gaza
🍉❤️ what a great episode
WOW! Sarde just went on another level… thank you so much and i wish you more luck! If i were medea i would be jealous as well 😅
Great podcast! Keep up the good work guys !
Great interview 👏
I can't believe I witnessed a genocide of Palestinians in my life time
Extremely informative podcast. Excellent as always Sarde 👏🏼
I just want to clarify something the professor said, which I think was inaccurate: he is right, the Saudi military did not participate in the 1948 war, but Saudi soldiers did; they traveled from the west coast to Egypt and fought alongside the Egyptian army; many of them were martyred and buried in Gaza (may Allah grant them mercy). Free Palestine.
Right of course glory to the martyrs
But the point is countering the narrative that their were 6 ORGANIZED MILITARYS
كانو افراد و ليس جيش سعودي منظم
Loved this episode.
Love Sarde❤
ارسلت الحلقه لصديقتي الايطالية
Mille mercis pour cette belle émission, elle a l'air d'une conférence d'histoire très très très riche, thank you so much
Is this content in English ?
sharing this far and wide to my friends across the States. thank you for the great history lesson! 🍉
Shu ya3ne? Medea couldn't join the call from her bedroom?
إنتو مستقلين ولهيك بحبكن و بحب هالمكان لتغذية عقلي و توسيع آفاقي و شعوري إنو اي! لسا في ناس ما بتروح مع القطيع قبل ما تفهم ليش وكيف❤
I think this would have been a good question for the professor. I remember Dennis Ross part of the American negotiating team for Oslo said that Yasser Arafat was offered the 2967 borders for a Palestinian state and Arafat rejected it is that true
Not just him. Bandar bin Sultan has said the same thing and basically summarized the decades long "negotiations" with the palestinians as the palestinians always rejecting a deal only to come back years later and start negotiating for the previously offered deal that was no longer on the table. No single person has done more harm to the palestinian cause and torpedoed the palestinian state than Yasser Arafat. Followed only slightly by Hamas who killed any remaining hope for a two state solution.
@@fireboy1996there was never a 2 state solution
Are u out of ur mind
There’s almost 1 million settlers in West Bank that are only growing
Israel has mores land in the West Bank than us
@@RiRi-ku6xz You didn't seem to understand what I wrote. No there hasn't been a two state solution because your incompetent leaders rejected peace offers time and time again only to ask for those very same deals years later, but they weren't on the table anymore.
سلامتا 🙏🏻
As Israeli, this conversation was really interesting.
But there's something missing. In Israel living today more then 7M Jewish (lot of them born here). What his proposal for nowadays.
مرحبا
حلقة حلوة خاصة لمن لا يعرف تاريخ فلسطين
يا ريت حلقة اضافية مع الباحث عن حياته ومشواره الشخصي
والاكاديمي
بفكر رحلة الباحث الخالدي هي قصة مل فلسطيني ونجاحه هو قصة كفاح طويلة وملهمة كنت بحب اعرف تفاصيلها
وهو ينتمي لعاىلة الخالدي التي لها الباع الطويل ف ابراز تاريخ فلسطين
شكرا ع استضافته
Thank you sardé ❤salemtek Medea
شكل الاستاذ مرهق. الله يشفيه 🤲
but there is some information Khailidi lacks, Palestinians had no choice but to create resistance in Lebanon/Jordan because they were beaten, killed since 1949 as refugees, i.e. long ago before the invention of army groups.
1:34:22 ماشي بس الادارات الأمريكية مش كلها زي بعضها.
لا والله كلها وجهان لعملة واحدة خاص
بالسياسة الخارجية
I don't get the idea that someone claim to have the right to a land because he is believed to be a descendant of someone who have lived on that land thousands of years ago It is compeletly ridicious
Good job
As Israeli, this conversation was really interesting.
There is something missing, eventually right now there are 7M Jewish in Israel, most of them born here. What his proposal for nowadays?
@@gamerissues9614
It's seems that you never visited Israel...
The only one Jewish country in the world not gonna fall...
And you probably don't know the Palestinians...
@@gamerissues9614 I absolutely agree, nation built on hate cannot uphold itself. This is exactly the reason Israel flourish while the palestinians can't build nothing productivity...
Mouin why didnt u ask about ICJ and South Africa