Patient Has No Control Over Half of His Brain | House M.D. | MD TV
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
- Dr. House and his team treat a patient who previously underwent split brain surgery to help with his epilepsy but has given half his brain a mind of its own.
From House M.D. Season 5 Episode 24 'Both Sides Now' - House and the team are intrigued by Scott, a man whose left brain and right brain operate independently, leaving him with two distinct personalities and no control over some of his actions. As the two sides of Scott's brain struggle for dominance, his warring personalities make it increasingly difficult for the team to figure out what is causing the unique problem.
House (2004) Dr House, an ingenious and unsociable physician who flouts hospital rules, clashes with fellow doctors and his assistants as he comes up with controversial hypotheses about his patients' illnesses.
Stream full seasons of House M.D. on Peacock: pck.tv/39BlAG0
Watch all seasons of House M.D. here: www.justwatch....
Welcome to MD TV! A channel dedicated to your favourite medical dramas! Featuring iconic moments from House M.D., Chicago Med and more. Follow the professional and personal lives of the hospital staff, as you go a journey right from the very first doctor's call to the E.R and beyond. MD TV is packed full of drama, intrigue, and plenty of medical emergencies!
#MDTV #HughLaurie #HouseMD #MedicalDrama #MedicalTVShow
not gonna lie, but this concept that one half of his brain was "silenced" but is still trying to help out is so weird and so cool
This might be a silly question, but what made you start that sentence with "I'm not gonna lie"?
@@tymondabrowski12 I know about DID. I have a friend with MPD and I watch the CZcams DissociaDID. I like to read up about DID and watch interviews and stuff on it.
@@fromthegamethrone honestly, it's the first thing that came to mind so I wrote it. I almost wrote it again replying to this comment.
@@fromthegamethrone The same reason why they used "honestly" when beginning the sentence. Probably just got so used to starting sentences that way that it's hard to drop the habit.
@@hollanderson I did notice. Not judging OP as I don't know them! But I have found in my life people who start with "not gonna lie" or "honestly" tend to have trouble being believed, which usually stems from pathological lying. Again, no judgement on OP - could totally be a colloquialism.
I know this is a serious case but I can't help but love how wholesome the right brain acts, really trying to make the guy understand the deodorant is the problem and then starts being gentle when the girlfriend notices the problem
also the guy is a great actor
@@fig8man bro I just realised the actor just acted all that, he is fricking amazing
it was pretty sweet
@@fig8man yeah he had total mastery of the physical part - the arm seemed like he couldn't control it and that's while he's speaking, emoting, etc.
The hand KNEW what was causing the problem, and was desperately trying to get everyone to see that and stop with the wild goose chase...
i think the right hand could have done something different. since it can read it should have seen doctors so maybe instead of throwing things it could hold it shake it and the doctors. another idea is to actually draw the idea. skull for poison and deodorant for the subject.
@@takumi2023 Right brain is not logical, all it can do is throw away stimuli it doesn't like and punish whatever introduces that stimuli.
How it knew it didn't like it, I dunno.
@@iRazenrak The right brain get bad vibes from deodorant can.
@@bliss5297 didn’t pass the vibe check
So essentially the left brain has locked in syndrome, bar the use of a hand. Crazy cool concept
Everyone else is talking about the episode itself or the condition. I’m over here amazed the actor unbuttoned his shirt so quickly with one hand.
"Not my first rodeo" 😉 -Joey (Friends)
Saaaame. Watched that one twice when it came up. That was pretty impressive, lol.
probably director took the shot several times and he got used to it
@@princessblazena it’s definitely not what he said.
I remember learning about a case study in which spray deodorant killed a teenager. He was so obsessed with smelling good, he would go through a can a week. Once a day in a small enclosed space isn't good but isn't harmful. Multiple times a day in a small enclosed space is poisonous. If you use anything aerosolized, use it in a well ventilated area.
The problem isn't that people don't read warning lables, it's that they ignore them
I can't stand when someone sprays one of these next to me. Now I know my reaction is good.
A lesson that accute is no more dangerous than chronic. It's just faster.
@Samir Dončić As long as the windows are open, you should be fine. Just let your car air out.
This is true. I've heard of the same case, the mother was beside herself because she felt responsible for not stopping him. Made me change the way I use aerosols for sure.
Anyone noticed that the girlfriend "had the thought out of nowhere"? That's her right brain communicating.
😂😂
Dear lord
Oh no honey
Or it was the next part in the script
That's four of them in the room then!
I never noticed the first thing we see him throw in the hospital is the deodorant can, and he throws it again and again.
well cause his brain sees it is a problem even though he wants to use it again and again goes to show that his brain knows the danger even though he does not know🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
First time he also says "we shouldn't read into that". Eventually they solve the case by reading into it.
@@bartk.2702 you gotta love that silent brain it had it all figured out before hand and they had to listen to it before they could figure it out🤣🤣🤣
It was too cute when his hand caressed her and 13 commented.
Imagine the hand first caressing her, then slapping her again
@@smittywerbenjj1 Now that's something to worry about 🤣
@@smittywerbenjj1 thats exactly what i was scared was gonna happen lol
Honestly it was pretty adorable lmao
@@Aemilius_Roswell Indeed
“We’ll just leave the three of you alone” 😂
Lord he smacked the soul Outta her
Yeah poor guy he didn’t mean it
His left hand may have thouht she deserves it 🤣
😂😂😂💀
😐
That it did!! I felt the draft all over here!!
Bro the patient acting to have a different brain is amazing, the things he does makes me believe he couldn’t control his right brain
Dude.... You just LITERALLY
******LITERALLY******
described the exact episode THAT EVERYONE WATCHED..... Jesus CHRIST
@@Supersquigi he's just complimenting the acting bro chill out
The patients acting is great he moved the arm very convincingly. it seemed alien like it was interrupting him It was very impressive.
Why they arent mentioning is that the separate halves can be potentially so developed that they can form beliefs of their own. They partly hint at it with the ending, but there are even cases of DiD and split brain patients wherein they appeared to have separate religious beliefs in different regions of their head
This is unrelated to DID. DID is a response to trauma not a separate individual in your head.
@@yossarian00 DiD and split brain are seperate. I only mentioned it because though DiD is caused by trauma as you said, it can also manifest in the form of either distinct personalities or in more extreme cases full distinct identities
My goodness. Both still had religious dogma?
Oh thats nothing - i know ppl that dont have control over their entire brain 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I had that problem
If you really thing about it, that's basically everyone.
Agree
I know people who pretty much don’t have a brain
😐
Its cute they stayed together:)very wholesome they got thru that issues together
What really killed me here was them talking about the patient in front of another unrelated patient. HIPAA violations, so many HIPAA violations in these shows.
House routinely breaks the law and this is the one thing that sets you off? Lmao
@@uncomfortableasian lol I know, I can't help it. I work at a pharmacy, HIPAA requirements were drilled into my head from day 1. It's also something every Doctor Reacts video for these shows can't help commenting on.
@@roselover411 I am just curious on whether it's entirely possible not to talk about it in front of other people. During my last vaccine shot at a pharmacy, there was another lady getting her meds and the people there were checking if she knows how to take it. I am pretty sure many waiting there could hear about the name of the drug and other stuff. How do you really not talk about it? feels almost impossible to me
@@kerstiny4698 I mean the main thing is not to reveal personal information about the patient. Some places are better about it than others, but if you give patient information that can be used to identify them aloud when others are very close by, that's a breach of information. In pharmacies they will sometimes ask other people to please back up and give others some space to make it harder to hear that personal information. You generally need a collection of information to make that happen, including name and birthdate along with other things. And what medication someone is taking is not enough to make that clear. Hundreds of thousands of people are on the same med, it's hard to identify specific people with just that information.
But in a hospital setting, you have a specific building there with a specific number of people and information about the case details of that one patient in front of another like that is a huge no-no. It's too easy to find out details when you have enough information like that, and also it's just gauche. Really? You're talking about how a patient died in your care in front of someone that's meant to trust you with their own life? Not the best practice, doc.
Like you can have a doctor tell you "I had a patient with this problem and here's what we did about it" and that's fine. That's got no personal details attached that you could use to find that person. But with the general way TV doctors talk around patients and families (you would NEVER talk about the healthcare of a patient in the middle of a hallway at a clinic or hospital. Never. You always do that in an enclosed room to help ensure patient and family privacy), there's so much procedure about that that is really wrong and would lead to endless HIPAA violations in the process. Healthcare workers (I'm a pharmacy technician, as it happens) go through extensive training to avoid that as much as possible. It's easier for TV to show them doing these things because TV doesn't actually have to imitate life that closely and the number of locations they have to use can really affect things, but it rubs me the wrong way whenever I see it cuz I'm so aware of the proper protocol for it.
@@roselover411 Ours is bad you can hear everything. I could hunt down anyone in the line if I wanted.
My man Eugene Schwartz making his legendary cameo in this clip with absolutely zero context. Fantastic performance
For a medical show, cant believe how creative each was
"I'm an oncologist" Imagine hearing that 💀
Perhaps the world’s weirdest love-triangle? LMAO. 😂
half of boys brain gave in to the intrusive thoughts
i'm surprised house didn't spend any time with this guy
I literally cannot control my brain at times due to my medical condition. I've written a 16 page paper, walk to work, cooked food, took a shower, etc all blacked out due to my neurological condition. I joke saying "I guess this is what drunk is like. Doing stuff but not in control or remember it". Will say creepy at times.
I hope I don’t offend you when I say how fascinated I am by that. I’d like to ask what you have but please don’t feel obligated to tell me, no matter what the reason may be. I’m sorry you have that though. It must be stressful and terrifying at times.
This is similar to a case of a woman whose epilepsy was treated by surgeons disconnecting the right and left sides of her brain; she found herself reaching for things she hadn’t chosen to pick up and her hand became almost independent.
(note: I’m not a doctor; I learned about this case from an Adam Curtis documentary)
Like and Octopus. It's arms reach and grasp independently.
Not "similar" - it's the same thing. Severe epilepsy is still treated this way today, in rare cases, and the resulting "split brain" patients are extremely valuable for neuroscience and neuropsych research
Hand: throws deodorant away
Patient: we shouldn't read into that
Hand (in adams family): "let me tell u a story about my cousin hand..."
When he slapped her I thought of how we would call that in Jamaica: "Him shot har a box". I felt that right through my phone screen lol
This hospital is amazing, it manage to find every unique condition in the world within 8 years.
Because of House.
Wouldn’t be an interesting show if all the patients had the common cold
This reminds me so much of the split brain video of CGP Grey, love it.
😐
I love CGP Grey
Can we pretty please get a neurologist’s reaction to this video?!
I've always thought the actor playing the patient is adorable.
And the girlfriend is gorgeous too
He's definitely a cutey but he's no Chase 😘
"I didn't hit her, my left hand did". It would be harder to justify more serious actions with such justification
Gonna be difficult to prosecute someone's mute brain half
He’d have a medical reason. It doesn’t mean there wouldn’t be repercussions. Most likely he’d have to live in a facility under supervision of medical staff, until they could be 100% sure any treatment they gave him would work to control the issue- not unlike when someone is liable for a crime due to mental illness.
This is from the fifth season finale episode 'Both Sides Now'.
Bravo to Ashton Holmes for his excellent performance in this.
"I'm not a discourager"
I'm coughing from laughing at that so much XD
Anyone else think the actress playing the girlfriend would have made a great MJ in Spiderman?
I just love this actor, I wish I saw him around more
I love how he said "daisy chain" and no one really mentions that. You all would be laughing or disgusted. 😀
That is actually pretty clever, considering there are "three" of them in that relationship.
A woman who thinks the stars are God’s daisy chain…
Before some of us got into using it on a degrading women way with the phrase, people used it for actual daisy necklaces
?
A daisy chain is a self cycling system
This will sound weird I really like the idea of a individuals brain partly having control over part of the body itself, it’s like talking to yourself but you are actually talking to yourself
hes a good actor
Imma call this "Venom Syndrome" 🙃👁
venon can talk in his head but this one can't and no super powers only thing is having a mute friend always there
This is probably one of the 1st few episodes I watch and motivated me to watch more, still favoruite episode
"Yup, I did it again" seriously, when are his coworkers gonna figure this out
So I am confused... Right brain is not on the right side. ... Why is right brain on the left side... I just was so confused.
It's not that the right brain is on the left side. It's that right brain controls the left side of the body because neurons from each side of the hemisphere goes across to the opposite side of the body to supply it. It's a weird system but pretty cool.
We need longer videos.
ive seen alien hand syndrome. the man either doesn't have it or he barely has it cuz usually you lose control over part of your face and sometimes even you're entire right/left side of the body.
Of course he doesn't, he's an actor who doesn't have the condition. He can only do the best that he can to imitate it for the show.
bruh imagine that. thatd be spooky af one side of your face is neutral and the other is grinning madly
Sure, the didn’t check his cosmetic products first thing 😂
This is a real concept in biology, you can google it. If you split the two halves of the brain, they can function but the two hands for instance would get often in the way of each other, as the brain halves are not communicating with each other anymore. Also, it would be very difficult to make a decision as each half pulls you into a different direction. In order for us to function normally, the one brain half is always silenced, meaning that there is a clear "boss half" having the upper hand.
Lol damn his left hand went all Mike Tyson on his girlfriend for a second
I feel so bad at cracking when the hand slapped her, I did it the first time and every time I rewatch this epeisode
I saw a movie about "alien hand syndrome", but they didn't show the same symptoms in "District 9".
Good one! :D
RIGHT brain, LEFT brain
Was all that shaking in the original? It gives me motion sickness.
His hand was like a dog that knew there was a problem but can’t express itself
All these brilliant doctors and none of them thaught to give the left hand a pen and paper to actually communicate
Is this how how Bo Burnham got some of his material?:)
We'll just leave the three of you alone! House taught them well, they all will forever be a bit like House. A bit sarcastic, an everybody lies!
As much as I love this case- I have a hard time believing that a neurosurgeon would go through with such a complicated and life altering surgery to split his corpus callosum (the fibers that allow the left and right hemispheres to communicate), without ruling out every single possible cause of the seizures, including potentially toxic chemicals.
“You’re dissing the right hemisphere?” is only a quote that you would ever hear from this show.
I wonder how accurate this is?Or if the hole episode is a reference to Dr Strangelove ?
split brain surgery has happened sad part leave half the person dead no alien arm stuff everything house shows is based in real medical text. some licence is taken to make it more dramatic.
oh no is a real syndrome all right, really freaky, saw a guy in the news once that had it, had to apologize contantly for groping women on public transport and stuf
The whole left/right brain has been proven false. Different regions of the brain are associated with different things but there is no such thing as having a left brain or a right brain. Both sides work in tandem.
@@Ikajo you're woefully uneducated. Yes they work in tandem, but they are separate and observably separate. It's why to treat certain brain conditions, they will sever the connection
@@Ikajo you can survive with only partial brain
At the last part of this, the right side of the brain was like “I just wanted you to stop bringing that type because my vessel was being poisoned. Now that you finally understand, I’m grateful.”
It’s AMAZING how many rare one in a million cases just walks in to that hospital……
they doesn't just walk in, most patients get there after several doctors, can be sent from other areas and they go through the selection process. There is and episode about a man who didn't make it into the selection meeting House. They not just randomly stumbling to a House - his team is looking for cases like this and House chooses to engage only with the most complicated ones.
@@alatielinara or……house is on a coffee break and by accident hear about a sick baby……..but ok
It's scary but objectively one part of your brain/body is just trying to survive like a domesticated organism. It would retaliate if it sees a threat, it would be tame if they're trying to help, it cooperates and coordinates.
It has no access to your conscious thoughts directly but can use all 5 senses, weird but ok. That's why they gave out instructions like why not say it out what you will do so your other side will understand.
The duality of humanity
Two halves, one whole
Conscious, subconscious
Logical, creative
Thinking, feeling
Both in tandem, working together, faltering never until separated.
You are, literally, two.
Brooo. First comments. Funny to see views accumulate so fast. Love this show to the max
Your not first lol
I thought the left hemisphere of the brain controlled the right half of the body, and vice-versa. Which should include which eye each hemisphere gets signals from, no?
Drs in Canada would be like "you're walking and talking so you can go home, take a Tylenol and rest if it gets worse come back" no way they would give anyone a scan if they were like that🤣
I keep hearing about this allegedly superior Canadian healthcare but I keep hearing anecdotes about the system being very full there and doctors not prioritizing patient care.
you forgot about the 6 month wait time to purchase the tylenol.
He comes in bleeding from his eye. That usually indicates something a bit worse than a cold.
@@spacebound1969 The 6th highest cause of death in canada is euthanasia because doctors just don't feel like treating patients.
Or if you don't want to wait a year to see a specialist, they'd probably just prescribe euthanasia (you can get that with no wait I hear).
LMAOOOO This is exactly how I feel right now, no one would ever believe me. This is crazy bro
😐
what
This more common as a delusion than a medical condition
I don't believe you either.
What is the obsession for vomiting or spuing blood in some of these... it's like always a thing.
Honestly props to the actor this was a neat performance
3:20 Taub "this is so cool" 😭😭
Sorry but the hands just hilarious
I wish my right hand was that smart
Ah the great US of A: where the people are resistant to regulation and so next to no chemical is banned from everyday use
This is literally the most inaccurate med show I've seen lmao
1:03 anyone know what's up with the shakey cam? It's really hard to focus on anything else now that I've noticed it. Is it a stylistic choice for the episode or something?
Probably someone bootlegging it through the TV...
It's not the text is still
Plus the you would see the outside of the TV too
I think it's a stylistic choice, to emphasize that there is another "presence" watching what's happening. The jerking between people, the quick panning when the hand throws stuff, it makes it look like we are watching through the hand's view point from a third person. Or I'm completely wrong and it's just crappy editing
It's in this episode that House slowly realises he is having a mental breakdown.
Donny tried to slap out her soul with that one
Right brain KNOWS things that we aren't consciously aware of. I have noticed it multiple times in my life. Not to this guy's extent but still that was enough to observe. Something that I currently remember - I have noticed myself touching some random part of my body totally out of nowhere, and finding a bug or a mosquito there. I didn't see or feel a thing, didn't even sense it, didn't even consciously make the choice to move my hand and touch that part of the body. It was as if my hand was on auto pilot mode.
There is something sinister
Quickly taking hold of me
Misfortune coursing through my veins
Attacking my anatomy
I think these bones have a mind of their own
I can feel them shift and feel them disown
If you wrote those lyrics yourself, that's pretty good! :)
“Nobody knows what it’s like to be me!”
Dude you can’t just go around throwing things and slapping people whether you control it or not
He's Lowkey Doctor Octopus Minus The Remaining 3 arms
I just watched a clip about that old man at the end of the video.
That’s the great Carl Reiner, one of the funniest, most brilliant people in entertainment. His son is Rob Reiner.
The way he smacked her i would’ve been sooo mad like excuse you
The actor really made it seem that his other hand was truly with its own mind. Reminds me of that movie Idle Hands.
The brain is a fascinating thing. It's the most complex computer we've encounter... up to now. We'll see where we are in a few years with AGI. I would imagine this was a challenging but fun role for the actor to play.
why didn't this half of the brain use a tablet to refer to deodorant
gah so cool, love this episode, buut... if it knew the deo was such a problem, did it not know that any sooner? did he have to wrestle with it to apply the stuff multiple times a day?
God I love redhead women.
It's the colour I wish I had. Sadly I'm a brunette. Spent several days at hair salons trying to get my hair to be red. For some reason my hair doesn't want to be red. I've spent a couple of thousand pounds in hair salons trying to get red hair but according to several hair dressers my hair doesn't absorb hair dye. Even bleach didn't change my hair.
@Anna Tribe Don’t change your hair. I was born with flaming red hair and it browns out as we get older. My father had the same thing. It’s more of a chocolate color now. So you being a Brunette is fine. My wife is a Brunette and I love the hair color of brown. Reminds me of some oaks I grew up with. I’m sure your hair color is lovely.
a show about not having control of your hafe wood be cool
I was hit in the head 5 years ago at work.
Smacked behind my right ear. Now deaf in that ear.
I don't remember any of that so it doesn't bother me.
But what I think is interesting is the change in my
personality. Because of what my neurologist calls
"brain sloshing" the top center front part of my brain
was damaged. That area would normally control or
suppress impulsive thoughts and behavior. I used to
be quiet and withdrawn. Now I'm friendly and find it
hard to keep my mouth shut. I'm compelled to
approach strangers and start a conversation if I can.
Man how he slapped his GF was unreal !
Bruh we just learnt about Split Brain today, very interesting to see that Sperry 1968's research methods applied here
The hand keeps throwing that deoderant
Y do most patients have to vomit blood seems like the most common symptom?????? It's like click bait in a gross way!!!
9:21
That was cute
So how did the episode end?
It was actually said at the end of this clip - the patient suffered with alien hand syndrome, Scott (patient), is really suffering from a reaction to an ingredient in the industrial-strength antiperspirant he uses
@@martwyMozg Thank you 😊 I must've missed that part. 👍🏻
@@k8tina no worries - sometimes in those episodes diagnosis was weirder so I see how confusing it might be when we watch just a part of episode :) hugs
If u have Prime u can watch all seasons. It’s very addictive
House admits himself to a psych hospital.
An anime: parasyte. Its going to grow eye later.
ayo what my man limon zerga doin there
I had to go to hospital because of antiperspirant that was working too well. I was in a new country with extreme heat. I worked in an environment without air-conditioning and played basketball for a couple of hours each day right after work. It got bad.
But but what happened is this just a clip?! Where's the full ep?!
I wonder how "self love" feels to him.
title is kinda miss leading since its the brain thats in control.