i would recommend darkening most of the characters, i understand how hard it is to actually match their skin tones in gacha but isabela is WAY to white
I love how Camilos, antonio and dolores skintone is kinda on point but the rest is straight up whitewashed. You cant use the 'They/I forgot' excuse cause you probably need to go back and forth to make the clothes and hair accurate. How can you forgot the the skintone when you kept on constantly looking at the face for the eyes and the color of it? That's extremely sus. You can indeed forgot some small details. Example for me is that i forgot about kazuha's tied hair behind him in gacha, another example is you forgot the earrings, Accessories is an ok excuse. But you cant just forgot about the skintone that easily when that's the most major thing you have constantly saw when looking at official arts/fanarts.
It was probably a mistake Edit:I was hoping they changed the skin colors as I have not checked but I have just seen they are the same,sorry for any misunderstanding
I wanted to comment that Isabelas skin tone is way darker then the one you gave her. I would recommend looking at official art for the actual skin colors :D ( plus some of these characters have wavy hair, so I would recommend using more canon hairstyles, I understand on how gacha is hard to work with especially with curly hair but I think you could do a bit better on the designs ) ( and everyone else’s skin tone may I add, sorry for not noticing! I just saw isabela and thought on how wrong the skin tone was, I didn’t even look that the other ones, thank you all for telling me :D )
I agree with this They should make the skin color darker Ik Gacha club doesn’t really have the skin tones of these characters but there are some that are closest so use that whitewashing is not okay.
Assuming gets you nowhere, act more normal. I’m not being offensive it’s just don’t say white wash. They’ll understand otherwise you’ll get people’s feelings hurts.
can you please make some of the characters darker or please check the original pallet skin tone or the reference? the reaction was good but not the character please don't whitewash them...
how did you look at these designs and think "yeah, these look like the madrigal family members!" 😭 ESPECIALLY isabela and Antonio. (im referring to the skin tones.)
Just a tip look up official art and try and match as close as you can bc multiple characters has darker skin tones then what you used tho Papa has the right skin tone in this video The video was pretty good besides that
Do better in the future, when you picked tiktoks you SAW the skin tones. When you made them, you probably had to look up references for the characters so you SAW the skin tones. Even Antonio (a dark-skinned afro-latino) is wrong. Whitewashing is also racism because you're erasing a character's entire identity. You're basically saying that they're not acceptable until they have lighter skin. The fuck?
But there is a reason. It's a "gacha style" Notice the pink outlines? A lot of people are doing this 'style' where white people are very light and darked skinned people are slightly darker, 'meaning' that they're black or darker skinned. Not a reason for 'actual' whitewashing, but to me I see them as they are in the tiktoks, so in my eyes they look pretty close. I'm not colorblind but maybe my eyes are weird.
@@angelinastuart6239 no the hell it’s not. the pink outlines have nothing too do with it none of them are that light. there’s a official color pallet and everything and julieta is no where CLOSE to that color so yea no excuses.
Yeah, someone else said they probably forgot about skin tones when adding all the cessories trying to make the outfits and such. Some are on point, but some are a little off. And it's also a new "style" to make characters this way, where white people are very white and dark skinned people are slightly darker and they all have pink outlines.
no, it's painfully obvious they knew what they were doing. they'd have to look back and forth from the ref pic and back to the character they were making, and in part two they still havent fixed the skin /nm
why is it so hard to match a skin tone? literally picking the skin tone for the character is the easiest thing? you’re whitewashing them and that’s not okay.
Dude you totally white washed the characters they’re not that way have you even watch the movie and the literal videos that you’re putting on the strain
When Dolores came on the one with the song time for Africa in The song we don’t talk about Bruno she says do you understand with the other song Her lips looked like she said Africa if you noticed
okay, so i agree that they (i don't know creators pronouns) made their complexion too light which is a pretty big yet common mistake and if they watched the movie or atleast these tik toks they should have know their skin colour while making them, but some comments ale awful. i mean it's okay to say that their skin isn't the same as in movie but adding mean comments or saying that the whole video is ruined by that which is not true. video was amazing. finally another reaction video that have more than just youngest characters from "Encanto". also, look at the title, it says that this was just part 1, so i pretty sure that in next part skin colour will be fixed. also, i think that it's pretty unfair, that people hate videos where Madrigals skin colours are light, but like videos with them having really, really dark skin. like it's not whole family having dark skin colour, it's just Antonio, Felix, and Isabella having pretty dark skin colour. and last thing, to people that was literally hating, if you dislike this video for their characters, that they will probably gonna change, make your own characters and make your own video, instead of hating. to the creator i want to say that you did an amazing job. the only (in my opinion) but yet big mistake is skin colour Madrigals. i hope that you are alright and that you will continue making content. don't think about it much. everybody makes mistakes, even bigger than you did. can't wait for part 2. (also don't get me wrong, i know that whitewashing isn't good, but so is hate.) sorry for any misspelling, i'm from Poland and i'm still learning English
Saying its not that big of a deal is actually really degrading to POC. We have a right to be upset when people change a character that's basically the only representation we have and making them white as though there aren't many white characters already. I don't know your race, and I won't assume. But if you're white, please never speak on POC issues again if you're just going to support racism
@@fluffycloud9 I literally said I wouldn't assume and IF they weren't POC. I'm not assuming they're white, I'm just informing them of the issue with it.
my sister decided to tell me that Mariano’s mother problem raised him to think that is only job was to be handsome and get married which is why he immediately asked Dolores once he found out she liked him
ik everyone is saying this but make them darker. i understand that u were prob going for a “ lighter pastel cute “ sorta effect but you can still have that with darker skin.
i think Camilo and Pepa’s skin tones are good but the rest of the Family Madrigal’s skin tones are darker then that. Please don’t do this again, not because you’re obviously gonna get cancelled, but because it’s very disrespectful and racist.
![Abuela Alma React To Mirabel And Bruno (Bad Grammar Warning🙏) [GachaEncanto]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nXNb-_Ni6Uc/mqdefault.jpg)
i would recommend darkening most of the characters, i understand how hard it is to actually match their skin tones in gacha but isabela is WAY to white
Fr
Plus they have their skin colour in gacha club
They made her super white
Fr
WHAT ABOUT LUSIA
just saying, you should probably check the character's actual skin tones before making a character. they arent that white.
Just make the characters skin colour darker and they would look great!
Yea I think that to :D
There's a filter on top of the video maybe that made the colors look lighter?
Yes! Also love your prfp :)
@@Poopyesthuman Isabella is whiter than Dolores and in the movie she’s darker
@@Poopyesthuman i mean even the filter couldnt make them look that white if they were the right skintone
it was great! just please don’t whitewash 🎀
I love how Camilos, antonio and dolores skintone is kinda on point but the rest is straight up whitewashed. You cant use the 'They/I forgot' excuse cause you probably need to go back and forth to make the clothes and hair accurate. How can you forgot the the skintone when you kept on constantly looking at the face for the eyes and the color of it? That's extremely sus. You can indeed forgot some small details. Example for me is that i forgot about kazuha's tied hair behind him in gacha, another example is you forgot the earrings, Accessories is an ok excuse. But you cant just forgot about the skintone that easily when that's the most major thing you have constantly saw when looking at official arts/fanarts.
@• J U P I T X R • sarcasm
literally speaking facts
Fr and how can u forget that Antonio is a dark skin character or Isabela is darker than most of the madrigals
@loopy 👾👾 sarcastic
We’ll, Pepa seems on point, but yeah, I agree, most of the madrigals that weren’t on Pepa’s side of the family were clearly white washed
why is isabela so light
Why is felix not there
its really not that hard to try and match the skintones of the characters and not make them white
It was probably a mistake
Edit:I was hoping they changed the skin colors as I have not checked but I have just seen they are the same,sorry for any misunderstanding
@@kiracandy715 how? none of them are white but tia pepa and she’s not extremely white either
@@Mikaelaramirez.commmm yes
@@Mikaelaramirez.commmm yes? it’s been shown in the official art
@@Mikaelaramirez.commmm yes because there’s a fvcking color palette made by Disney
I wanted to comment that Isabelas skin tone is way darker then the one you gave her. I would recommend looking at official art for the actual skin colors :D ( plus some of these characters have wavy hair, so I would recommend using more canon hairstyles, I understand on how gacha is hard to work with especially with curly hair but I think you could do a bit better on the designs ) ( and everyone else’s skin tone may I add, sorry for not noticing! I just saw isabela and thought on how wrong the skin tone was, I didn’t even look that the other ones, thank you all for telling me :D )
I just wanna ask but genshin? Sorry if i insulted you somehow
@@imamsodead5170 what
i think they meant gacha lol
@@imamsodead5170 my bad! It autocorrect to Genshin lol.
its not only isabellas its mostly everyones
Mirabel, Julieta, Abuela, Isabella, and Luisa are too light. Don't whitewash them. It's not ok.
I agree with this They should make the skin color darker Ik Gacha club doesn’t really have the skin tones of these characters but there are some that are closest so use that whitewashing is not okay.
antonio too
Antonio and Isabela mostly
Don't whitewash characters
Ain’t no way you didn’t purposely make them straight up white
They never learn
@@camieki3419 IKR
@@camieki3419 fr
Bruno dancing in the background while dolores was talked ng abt him was amazing.
Right!? xD
HAHAHAHAHAH ikr
He vibin
And he was in the walls hearing everything XD
Please don’t whitewash! The characters have darker skin tones
*Please don’t whitewash the characters, it’s disgusting*
Assuming gets you nowhere, act more normal. I’m not being offensive it’s just don’t say white wash. They’ll understand otherwise you’ll get people’s feelings hurts.
@@louvine5352 if they did try their best to match the skintones they would have atleast matched the darker skintoned characters
@@louvine5352 Isabella is almost as dark as Antonio, and she is completely white in this video.. also antonia is Wayyyyy darker
@@cherryblossomssx
It’s not assuming, it’s blatantly obvious
@@louvine5352
I apologise for my rudeness, I was having a bad day. But it isn’t that hard to get a skin two that at least resembles their actual skin
All the characters but pepa are supposed to be darker… Isabella, Dolores and Antonio are really dark
Bro pls make the characters darker like pls look at a reference photo
Please don’t text it so mean-
@@littlelilly3438 sorry I’m just angry, lots of people whitewash them and don’t do anything about it
@@100pyy6 oh-
@@littlelilly3438 its not mean? its literally racist when theres this many comments and the creator is ignoring it, open ur eyes 💀
@@vvi95a yeah
can you please make some of the characters darker or please check the original pallet skin tone or the reference? the reaction was good but not the character
please don't whitewash them...
how did you look at these designs and think "yeah, these look like the madrigal family members!" 😭 ESPECIALLY isabela and Antonio. (im referring to the skin tones.)
But she/they still kinda whitewashed the characters
@@TrulySerena ?? yes i know?? thats what i was commenting about??
@@qtwynnie_ Oh well maybe you should've told them that it's not right to whitewash the characters skins
@@TrulySerena thats what i was insinuating???
@@qtwynnie_ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ᵐᵃʸᵇᵉ
Seeing the characters skintone in this video is my nightmare
same smh
NDJRNKAJFBDN THE WHITE WASHING???? ISA AND ANTONIO ARE LIKE THE DARKEST CHARACTHERS HOW DID U 😭😭😭❓
dont whitewash . you know there all darker than that
Again with the whitewashing! Seriously people it’s not that hard to get skin tones right!
bro hes
yes*
All of them(except peppa, pepa pls how do i write her name) have dark skin
Just a tip look up official art and try and match as close as you can bc multiple characters has darker skin tones then what you used tho Papa has the right skin tone in this video
The video was pretty good besides that
All of the characters are super whitewashed, fix it.
I was okay till I see that you have white wash them.. Way to ruin this whole thing
IKR 💀💀
why are they white
Pls don’t white wash character PLEASE
Why are they lightskin💀
I would recommend darkening their skin-tones they're way to light.
Do better in the future, when you picked tiktoks you SAW the skin tones. When you made them, you probably had to look up references for the characters so you SAW the skin tones. Even Antonio (a dark-skinned afro-latino) is wrong.
Whitewashing is also racism because you're erasing a character's entire identity. You're basically saying that they're not acceptable until they have lighter skin. The fuck?
there’s literally no excuse for julieta,mirabel and isabella’s skin tone.
But there is a reason.
It's a "gacha style"
Notice the pink outlines? A lot of people are doing this 'style' where white people are very light and darked skinned people are slightly darker, 'meaning' that they're black or darker skinned. Not a reason for 'actual' whitewashing, but to me I see them as they are in the tiktoks, so in my eyes they look pretty close.
I'm not colorblind but maybe my eyes are weird.
@@angelinastuart6239 no the hell it’s not. the pink outlines have nothing too do with it none of them are that light. there’s a official color pallet and everything and julieta is no where CLOSE to that color so yea no excuses.
Don't forget Antonio
@@che730 so I guess my eyes are weird?
Love ❤ the intro I know everyone is asking for this but could you make there skin color darker
make their skin tones darker
Please stop whitewasing them its not ok so please fix it
AAAAAAHHH IM CRYING WHY DOES ANTONIO HAVE TO LOOK SO CUTEEE
1:38
Me:who noticed bruno in the back vibing
You probably did not intend this to happen, and i really hope that you didn’t, but their skin tones are much lighter than the original character.
Yeah, someone else said they probably forgot about skin tones when adding all the cessories trying to make the outfits and such.
Some are on point, but some are a little off.
And it's also a new "style" to make characters this way, where white people are very white and dark skinned people are slightly darker and they all have pink outlines.
no, it's painfully obvious they knew what they were doing. they'd have to look back and forth from the ref pic and back to the character they were making, and in part two they still havent fixed the skin /nm
You should darker there skins colors ( no hate tho) great video other then that 😁
why is it so hard to match a skin tone? literally picking the skin tone for the character is the easiest thing? you’re whitewashing them and that’s not okay.
the designs r so accurate :O
I can't wait for pt.2 :D
1:35 Bruno just dancing in the background 😭👍🤣
Your intro is EVERYTHING
ANTONIO IS SO CUTE😭
Love intro 💜
why is isabella literally the same skin tone as me shes so much darker what-
1:40 his family telling abt him : mean while with him vibing in the background 😏😂😂😂 ft:bruno
I love how smooth the intro is great work!
Remind me when part two comes out pls 😙
1:51 her singing bruno: vibing
you made their skin tone too light
Ma'am you are whitewashing the characters please do it right next time
Antonio and Camilo is so cute!!!!
Remember don’t whitewash characters!
Praying that everyone falls asleep quickly and has a peaceful sleep. Hope you all wake up happy and well rested 😘😘😘😘
At 0:30 I realized that there hugging there self-😭
On dolores' first edit it looks like she said africa lol
When it said it’s time for Africa man that fit it so well lol 1:35
I know right
Can’t wait for part 2!
why are they whites
on 1:39 I just love how the song IS perfectly synced on dolores m o u t h-
Can you make a part 2
For Antonio can you do the go little rockstar pleaseee it’s so cute
Everyone in love with Bruno
Me in love with Camilo
Actually Camilo I’d the common one to be liked more Bruno fans are in second
@@NO1Elisekinnie true
Bruno Madrigal is better
1:19 is nobody gonna question the song 😀
1:39-1:40 is like in a right timing it also sounds like she is saying it
Dude you totally white washed the characters they’re not that way have you even watch the movie and the literal videos that you’re putting on the strain
When Dolores came on the one with the song time for Africa in
The song we don’t talk about Bruno she says do you understand with the other song
Her lips looked like she said Africa if you noticed
"tíã pepa looking at her children and seeing that they have brown hair dark skin"
Pepa:......
Anyone else notice the perfect the lip sync is an the first edit of dolores
okay, so i agree that they (i don't know creators pronouns) made their complexion too light which is a pretty big yet common mistake and if they watched the movie or atleast these tik toks they should have know their skin colour while making them, but some comments ale awful. i mean it's okay to say that their skin isn't the same as in movie but adding mean comments or saying that the whole video is ruined by that which is not true. video was amazing. finally another reaction video that have more than just youngest characters from "Encanto". also, look at the title, it says that this was just part 1, so i pretty sure that in next part skin colour will be fixed. also, i think that it's pretty unfair, that people hate videos where Madrigals skin colours are light, but like videos with them having really, really dark skin. like it's not whole family having dark skin colour, it's just Antonio, Felix, and Isabella having pretty dark skin colour. and last thing, to people that was literally hating, if you dislike this video for their characters, that they will probably gonna change, make your own characters and make your own video, instead of hating. to the creator i want to say that you did an amazing job. the only (in my opinion) but yet big mistake is skin colour Madrigals. i hope that you are alright and that you will continue making content. don't think about it much. everybody makes mistakes, even bigger than you did. can't wait for part 2. (also don't get me wrong, i know that whitewashing isn't good, but so is hate.)
sorry for any misspelling, i'm from Poland and i'm still learning English
Saying its not that big of a deal is actually really degrading to POC. We have a right to be upset when people change a character that's basically the only representation we have and making them white as though there aren't many white characters already. I don't know your race, and I won't assume. But if you're white, please never speak on POC issues again if you're just going to support racism
what comments aren't true??? all of them are mentioning the skintone, which you agreed with..
@E .A Who said they weren’t POC?
@@fluffycloud9 I literally said I wouldn't assume and IF they weren't POC. I'm not assuming they're white, I'm just informing them of the issue with it.
@E .A I know, I’m just saying just in case they are POC
OOOHHHHH you know brazilian if you know im happy :)))))
littearly how the hell did you look at these characters and think they are white
I CANT SAY WE DONT HAVE A HOUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JEEZ FATHER
this was awesome and funny just make the skin colors darker you earned a new sub
Hi
I'm crying with happiness, she/he presented a Brazilian video
Its so cool right?!
Wait you are a brazilian too?
@@juliodasorte8881 yea?
my sister decided to tell me that Mariano’s mother problem raised him to think that is only job was to be handsome and get married which is why he immediately asked Dolores once he found out she liked him
Pt 22
Their reactions were good I loved them 😊
Good job 👌🏻
You might have Accidentally white washed Isabella
6-11-22 awesome
Lmao-
I guess there's another Racistbae we just found... 💀💔
Oh, that's why I learn English. ( Yes, I'm from Russia) Thanks for that beautiful reaction.
Boi why they white
Boi where is felix
Whitewashing go brrr
But seriously, its not that hard to make the skin tone darker
This person literally full on broke their brain and literally clicked “whitewash”
Guys if you are saying she's white washing them no she isn't she probably didn't notice it was white while making the characters
Or she took a screenshot and it was white so I think she just go with it
*everyone just talking abt there skin color*
*me : This vid amazing but if this took u long time , pls get sum rest :D*
You cant just ignore the comments
Can you fix Camilo٫Mirabel٫Julieta٫Abuela٫Isabela please ?
Good video but please make their skin color darker :)
Pls tell me you called the grandma abuela and not alma like everyone else ive watched ps i love the intro
i didn’t even realize Isabella was there at first…??? 😐
you deserve a subcribe of 100M
No she whitewashed all the characters she deserves no subscribe
She literally white washed almost all of them-
ik everyone is saying this but make them darker. i understand that u were prob going for a “ lighter pastel cute “ sorta effect but you can still have that with darker skin.
they prolly were but also isabela is whiter then maribel
i think Camilo and Pepa’s skin tones are good but the rest of the Family Madrigal’s skin tones are darker then that.
Please don’t do this again, not because you’re obviously gonna get cancelled, but because it’s very disrespectful and racist.
Plz I can’t wait for part 2:0
En isabela te faltó el color de piel ,pero está bonito el vídeo!