MISSHA New! Time Revolution The First Essence 5X Review & Comparison to Original Version
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 07. 2024
- Missha Time Revolution The First Essence 5X
At Yesstyle: ys.style/ziWnodXrHkb
Use Rewards Code NOBSBEAUTY for an additional discount!
Full Ingredients List: ** (Ingredients List on Yesstyle is for the Previous Version)**
Water, Glycerin, Propanediol, 1,2-Hexanediol, Niacinamide, Yeast Ferment Extract, Diethoxyethyl Succinate, Bifida Ferment Lysate, Sodium PCA, Butylene Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Adenosine, Xanthan Gum, Ceramide NP, Hydrogenated Lecithin
Previous Version Ingredients List:
Yeast Ferment Extract, 1,2-Hexanediol, Niacinamide, Bifida Ferment Lysate, Diethoxyethyl Succinate, Sodium PCA, Purified Water, Butylene Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Adenosine, Ceramide NP, Hydrogenated Lecithin
For more information on their fermentation process:
misshaus.com/products/time-re...
*******
Podcast Links
Apple - b.link/No_BS_Apple_Podcast
Google - b.link/No_BS_Google_Podcast
Amazon - b.link/No_BS_Amazon_Podcast
Spotify - b.link/No_BS_Spotify_Podcast
Stitcher - b.link/No_BS_Stitcher_Podcast
RSS - feeds.redcircle.com/671dd1b2-...
********
Sephora - fxo.co/1231867/sephora
Ulta - fxo.co/1231867/ulta
Amazon - www.amazon.com/shop/nobsbeauty
Yes Style - ys.style/kk2Vjrv798
Style Korean - www.stylekorean.com/?af_id2=no...
These are affiliate links if you purchase anything from one of these stores using this link No BS Beauty will make a small commission on what you buy.
********
I am proud to offer my very own beauty products at Amazon. We are starting small but hope to grow these offerings. Take a look and if you can pick one or two up, it helps keep this channel truly independent.
My Products:
No BS Beauty Travel Set - amzn.to/2PgPzFZ
No BS Beauty Airless Jars - bit.ly/2Ev6X6N or amzn.to/2RCEq4s
No BS Beauty Color Switcher - amzn.to/2RCEAJ6
See my own page on Amazon - www.amazon.com/shop/nobsbeauty
www.noBSbeauty.net
*******
My Patreon - / nobsbeauty
*******
PayPal Tip Jar - bit.ly/donate_NBSB
If you want to leave a tip ... Thanks!
*****
Since so many of you asked for it, here is a link to my favorite PH testing strips
amzn.to/33ojjIY - Jak na to + styl
Finally!!! So happy you made this video
You totally just saved me, I have been considering getting this toner on Yesstyle after reviewing the old ingredient list. Will definitely pass on it now. I think I’ll go for the Bonajour Green Tea toner. Thank you for saving me from regret lol, this video had perfect timing 🙏 😊
YES YES YES- the Bonajour Toner is so nice and super hydrating- I am loving it during the weather change right now! Will review it in the next week or so!
@@NOBSBeauty how can you tell if a product actually has the ingredients they say they use?
Same. Especially with Christmas around the corner. Not buying anymore.
Have you seen the new Time Revolution essence cream? Looking forward to your review!!!!
I think in Korea they tend to show an "active" ingredient first, even if it is watered down, because they treat this substance as a whole, so maybe in a new version they showed the ingredients in European/American way and that's why water is first and extract is fifth. Also that's why for example Artemisia Essence has one ingredient but in reality it's not just artemisia but water obviously and a few other additives. That's just my guess.
Exactly my thoughts. With 'ferments' and 'extracts' we don't really know how they are comprised, so in theory this one could contain more of the 'good stuff' than the previous version.
Good point!
I ordered the new version when it came out and only now got to actually using it. Tbh I didn't expect anything from it because this video was so negative and the people in the comments just agreed. But two days after using this essence I touched my face and noticed that my skin had suddenly become a lot softer and smoother. Then I started thinking "why is my skin suddenly a lot smoother?" Mind you, I'm a korean skincare junkie for ten years and I already tried everything under the moon from Korea, so it's not like I've been using crap and then immediately noticed a difference with a little bit of niacinamide and ferments. Then it dawned on me that the only thing I had changed in my routine was incorporating the Missha First Treatment Essence. It's also really weird that other first essences didn't do anything for me, like Scinic, Secret Key or Cosrx (even though I really love Cosrx as a brand and I've been using their products on and off for years). But the Missha Essence is a huge step above every other first essence for me. I've tried the old versions in the past as well and they were great but I had kind of forgotten about Missha because there are always new brands coming out.
Thank you so much for your review !!! Im so incredibly grateful! May I ask do you have any pigmentation or dull skin? Did you find it helped with that at all? And the scinic didn’t help? THANK YOU!!! ☺️
My biggest skin issue is Hyperpigmentation and it's been a long struggle to deal with it. One other product worth checking out is the RNW Shining Toner- it contains many brightening ingredients that really help with dullness and hyperpigmentatiom.
@@paigeme886 Hi, I'm not sure if you're asking the creator of the video or me but in case you asked me, I'm going to answer too 😄yes, I do occasionally have issues with hyperpigmentation, especially during the summer time. The missha essence does help to even out the skin tone over time (and it's a little brightening) but it's not a miracle unfortunately. It's not going to get rid of old hyperpigmentation that has been there for months. But if you notice new hyperpigmentation forming after being in the sun too long, it definitely can help to get rid of it.
@@KatK61227 thank you so much! To be honest I was kind of asking both of you! ☺️ I’m so grateful for hearing how it worked for your skin! Everyone’s skin is so different and responds in different ways. Really thank you so incredibly much! I was looking to add one of the galactomyces essences and unsure which one at the moment! There is also the secret key, scinic etc ☺️ thank you again!!! I’m so grateful
@@NOBSBeauty thank you SO incredibly much! I checked it out and also your roundup on your favourite brightening products- currently can’t get regimen lab level serum so I’m a little panicked 🤍
Really enjoying physician's formula essence of healthy because it's a pretty affordable 95% Galactomyces Ferment Filtrate and I can find it in Walmart (though some I've visited haven't caught up to carrying it). Wanted to try this Missha toner in the past and almost bought it this month, but I'm glad I didn't buy it thinking it would be the same formula I'd seen in the past.
I’m loving that product, my first galactomyces ferment buy and I’m never looking back
when you mention how it stung a little bit in the first few uses, that hasn't happened to me with this, but did with the neogen real ferment essence and i actually had a mild tingling sensation the entire time i used it so i didn't enjoy it as much as this, which i find odd because in my view they are very similar products (at least based on the similarities of the INCI lists)
So i did research. They write yeast ferment extract as the first ingredient in korean. 효모 발효 추출물 = yeast ferment extract. But in english ingredients they write water first, then glycerin. So missha isn't dissapoint me yet
I also asked someone to post the ingredient list- and they put up a screen shot. I can’t read Korean but first ingredient in English was the ferment. I think I may still try this version as I loved the other.
Great review!! In would really love if you would review Lisa Eldridge’s velvet lipstick 💋
I've heard great things, going to have to check it out!
I'd love to see your opinions on YesStyle's best sellers list. You've probably reviewed them all but then I'd have to go through all your videos 😅
I got this for $18.99 on JOLSE during one of their many sales. It's okay but I prefer the ampoule version. My favorite first essence is still NEOGEN. I hope they never change the formulation!
The Neogen is a winner- and I love their serum version of it, too.
Not really a treatment essence, but I've started using the Haruharu Wonder sensitive black rice toner! I'm a fan!
The last version was a fave. Tried the neogen to see which I prefer. It was the missha. So was looking forward to finishing and reverting back. Oh well. I’ll just have to use up my neogen, and see what else there is.
Maybe try Numbuzin No. 3 toner?
@@LittleAmyHe - very good set of ingredients. Thanks for the suggestion. Have you tried it. Maybe Sarah can recite some Numbuzin
@@rebeccapinto9926 No not yet! I’m waiting until I’m close to finishing my current essence.
@@LittleAmyHe - well if you do take the plunge let me know. And I’ll do the same. Thanks for the tip. The ingredients look mega.
Yay!!! Super excited for this! I’ve only tried the 5x as I bought it on sale at jolse(where else nowadays!)for $20 and I thought it was a steal. Been lovely for the moisture barrier but i also don't know what i missed out on in the past lol. I wonder if they split up the ingredients in the "ferment" complex within the ingredients, as it still claims to have 97% of it. la neige does that too with the cream skin and the white tea extract ingredient. thanks for the comparison!!! ps i think the last version of the first treatment essence is available on iherb
At least you got it for a good price- It is still a good product, just not as good as it once was. It is still a good addition to a routine and will hydrate skin. I think I'm going to finish up the old version this fall/winter and save the new one for spring and summer.
@@NOBSBeauty how do you know of the product is using the ingredients they say are in the bottle?
Amorepacific does not own Missha. Missha is owned by Able C&C.
Yeah they own sulwhasoo
I have a bottle of the earlier version open now -- glad I didn't reorder yet. Oh well, when a toner is close but no cigar it ends up in a spritzer bottle. Maybe Secret Key will work as a replacement...?
I know Penn Smith Skincare has said Secret Key is a decent dupe for the SK II.
Oo wow you just saved me $40, I really thought of getting it this morning since I love the 4th generation so much, but to know it's water down now makes me sad, I think I will stick with Benton fermentation essence or the one from purito, a lot of people recommend the secret key one but for my skin I don't see any good result besides hydrating.
I was also torn with the one from Secret Key- it was okay, but I didn't find it as beneficial as some other ones I've tried.
Please review nuria skincare and mother dirt
Last week I ordered the Numbuzin no. 3 essence from yes style. Have you tried it?
I don't know which version I tried, but it was a game changer. I bought it again and it did nothing. Why mess with a good thing? I know the answer is $ but I hate that. Ugh. It *was* so good! 🧡
Isn't it a shame when brands do this. It just makes me so sad. Their older version was a great alternative to SKII but not any longer.
Thanks 🍁🍂❤️!!
Hey! I wanted to ask what would be an affordable alternative for the FIRST essence, I capitalize FIRSt since I learned that they are the different kind - extremely light and liquidy with the function to help the following skincare to absorb and I know Missha is at least belonging to that cateogory, could you recommend another that is considered first treatment essence?:)
The problem in winter is gel moisturizers aren't doing well for skin , can you please review some thick moisturizers for oily acne prone skin?
I'll be thanks ❤️
Definitely will work on this idea- winter is so tough on skin. Someday moving somewhere that doesn't get so cold would be wonderful
@@NOBSBeauty Hello Sarah. As usual, I always learn something from your videos … thank you. Oh, BTW, come on down to San Antonio, TX … it doesn’t get very cold here and “winter weather” is short here, PLUS, we would love to have you, your hubby and Lincoln here! 🤗
I've still got a bit left of the previous version and really like it and this seems underwhelming in comparison. I might go back to the Neogen Rela Ferment Essence instead
The Neogen Essence is absolutely wonderful- and I'm so glad they didn't add tons of fragrance to it like they do some of their other products. It definitely would be in my top five ferments. Their Serum version of it is wonderful as well- went through several bottles of it, which means I like it a lot.
Same problem I had with this essence. Few days it stings and then after a week it stop stinging.
Missha is notorious for revising their products. I don’t use them because they’re not cruelty free, but I just got my Dr. Ceuracle Kombucha Essence, so I’m happy! ❤️❤️
I wish Missha would leave a few of their best sellers alone- their Ampoule changed and they added tons of fragrance to it, such a bummer.
I wonder if the ferment can actually survive travelling to its destination country ✈️
Will we ever get to meet the cameraman? I love that he films you and he has a wonderful voice. :)
I'll have to ask him, he's pretty shy! 😀
Yes!! A video with cameraman!!!
@@NOBSBeauty Shy men are the best. :)
A cheaper alternative is the Scinic FTE. Same amount of product for about $20 or half the price of Missha.
Oooh yes- the one from Scinic is amazing, and more similar to the original Missha that I loved!
The 5th gen is just not hydrating as the first one :( so disappointing
Salam pH dəyərini deyə bilərsiniz mi Rx 4 də dimeticone yox idi bəs bunda? Almağa dəyərmi
I agree with you on the 5th generation version. Disappointed with it myself. They water down the 5th gen. You pay more for water an glycerin. I continue to buy the 1st gen regardless.
Hi! Where do you buy your Missha first gen version from? Thanks!
I got this 5x too and was confused. The ingredient decks on the box is different from their website. On the box, the yeast ferment extract is listed 1st, bifda is 5th, and water is the 7th. On the website, water is 1st. Don’t know which to believe 🤔
That is interesting, on the box for mine water is first. I tend to go with what the box/packaging says. Sometimes brands make different versions of the same product for different markets. I wonder if that's what's going on here.
Could you review and compare Numbuzin No. 3 toner (or any of their products) to older versions of Missha’s please? Thank you! ^o^
Ooh yes, will be reviewing that one asap, very excited about it!
@@NOBSBeauty Yaaay! I’m so excited!!!
Hi Sarah I used the previous incarnation and really liked it, so that is super disappointing - a touch of the FAB issues going on here perhaps? My other favourite first essence is the Neogen micro ferment essence, so I hope they haven't messed with that one. I won't be buying this new version of the Missha, as I don't need a watered down product tbh. This more expensive first essence step is something I usually turn to in the colder months, as I feel it does help further layers to penetrate slightly better. They're not an inexpensive product category and should have a better INCI list than a regular toner. They are often a very watery consistency, but that's due to their place in your routine - first after cleansing. All in all a real backward step for them. This and the bb cream were the only Missha products I used, as most of their products are fragranced (bb creams I can tolerate a little fragrance, as they over all other skincare including spf). Best wishes.
It is a bummer- I wish brands would stop messing around with great products- but they just cannot help themselves I guess. I keep finding more and more FAB products that have been changed for the worse. Just testing their Ultra Repair Face Moisturizer and they also changed that one. They stated they had to change them for legal regulations in new countries they are selling it, but I have to wonder if that will make them as much money as they will lose in the US and other countries that used to love their products...
Gahhh it’s time to order new a new essence since I’m on my last backup of Neogen. Do I change or stick with a what I’m using??
The Neogen is fantastic- I totally get the struggle! Another good one worth checking out is the one from Scinic- the Facial Treatment Essence- it is very similar to what Missha used to be.
I think "filtrate" is a workaround to make "95% water + 5% ferment" sound more desirable and make INCIs appear minimal. But tea is a filtrate and so is coffee.. u can say "coffee" or "water, caffeine etc...". It's just a way of writing the same thing. It'd be nice if they wrote percentages down: expresso and American coffee are both filtrates but they are not the same ;) Here SK2 is expresso and this is Starbucks let's be honest.
ps. it is possible that version is the American version and that is why the inci was rewritten to meet the USA standards... maybe they had to relabel for the American market
you explained that well!
Very good explanation- I totally understand the coffee comparison (is it okay if I steal that from you in the future?!?!)!
@@NOBSBeauty sure! But I mean there are lots of tricky terms that the industry uses to allure us haha ;) ..extract for instance but in this example it's not just "filtrate" but also "fermented". I mean that does not mean much if u think.. wine and vinegar are both fermented grape juice. Yogurt is fermented milk and blue cheese is fermented milk... what is the enzyme used to ferment the solution? For how long was it fermented? Under what conditions? U can say fermented galactomyces so it reads like sk2 but then just the smell of sk2 tells you it's a very different sort of concentration (filtration) and fermentation right? I am not promoting sk2 eh?! just using it as an example as Misha's sold as a dupe. In two INCIs u may find the exact same wording for two totally different products.
I've been using this toner ( OLDER VERSION) a few years know...specially in the summer...I pair it next with the red Algae essence...enough hydrating, at least for me, during the summer...Missha has really nicely products BUT sadly too much fragrance....this product used to be a " dupe " voor the SK II....
I tried the red algae essence a few times but darn, too scented... if they made at least a majority of their products fragrance free they could become a favorite brand of mine.
@@NOBSBeauty ❤ HI Sarah. .... I don't notice any fragrance in the red essence from Missha...anyway, check the new video from Odile on the " myth " of a 10 skin care step routine for k beauty 😉
@@NOBSBeauty I think the essence doesn't have Fragrance, which is good but the serum does
You're so right. Very disappointing. What are the other alternatives to this type of essence, which contains fermented ingredients?
I think my other two favorites are the Neogen Dermalogy Real Ferment Micro Essence and the Scinic Facial Treatment Essence.
As a long time customer, I'm disappointed by recent changes Missha has made to their lineup and to their formulations. Missha is similar to many Asian companies in that they frequently change or 'upgrade' formulas. Another gripe, many products I've used throughout the years, formerly available in the US, are no longer available for sale but are overseas for the European or Asian markets. I'm definitely in the camp of "If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it."
The Missha Time Revolution First Essence's original formula contained both niacinamide and Licorce, and it had ferment as the first ingredient. It was a beautiful hydrating step before my next treatment product or my sunscreen that produced visible brightening results.
Their ampoule was almost an exact dupe to Estee Lauder's Advanced Night Repair. That formulation has also changed. Fortunately, I have a few backup bottles of the old Essence Gen 4 formula in the economy size but I think it's time for me to start researching a replacement.
I couldn't agree wtih you more- it gets so tiring to keep finding amazing products then have them change them a year later. I loved that ampoule dupe- really wish they wouldn't have changed that. That change also added a ton more fragrance. I've been trying to test it for my review but it is just so scented I can barely get through using it for more than a couple days in a row.
@@NOBSBeauty I know, right? I wondered if it was my imagination that more fragrance was added to the ampoule but once my skin was on fire and super red, that was a good indicator.
I'm not the sexiest of customers, but I'm a loyal customer (I'll tell a friend!) and practical by nature. If there's too much gimmick, I head elsewhere with my dollars. Thanks for the great content! And your pup (German Shorthair pointer?) is super cute! We had rough coated collies and beagles growing up.
I feel the same exact way their first versions of the ampoule and treatment was so so good to my skin. If you ever find a replacement I would loveee to know as well as the new versions are heavily fragranced or lacking compared to the past versions of the products!
I thought you don’t believe in washing off remaining makeup debris with toner since that just means your cleanser doesn’t work. I personally can not tell the difference between the 4th and 5th version. I feel like you’re biased from the ingredient list. I think they’re just listing their ingredients a different way
Bummer! I have one more bottle of the old version after I use up the Artemisia one I'm using now but after that I'll probably go back to Secret Key. On an unrelated note Odile (who works in the Korean beauty industry) made a post explaining how Purito's new sunscreen is not sold in Korea and therefore no longer subject to their standards/regulations!😳
Very disappointing!! I have the old version and will not be getting the new one. Thank you for the information!! 💖💖
The Missha TR Essence was a fave for years. Even through the reformulations I still enjoyed it. But this new formulation sounds like such a downgrade. So disappointing 😭😭😭
can't judge a product without trying it yourself though
This is so unfortunate to see. The change in the formulation mostly being water and glycerin is so disappointing. I still have a bit of the old version left, and I probably won't be trying the new formulation.
I recommend sticking with their Artemisia essence and Red Algae Essence.
I wanted to re-purchase the red algae one but it isn't on yesstyle anymore 💔😭 loved that one...
@@MarissaCooperButPoor I adore it. It's really great for my dry skin especially during the winter. I've never used yesstyle before. I just order from their site.
So annoying when brands reformulate a great product and make it just average . . .
I know, it is so sad, Missha seems to do this every few years. I'm still sad about all the products First Aid Beauty changed.
@@NOBSBeauty First Aid Beauty won’t get another penny of my money. Shameless.
💠
You should learn What Ingredients List writing system on korea and Chinese
They switch to international ingredient writing system so they can sell on China
The old version use korean writing system so The ferment is on the top of list (fermented+water)
While the new version write based on the real weight of the ingredients list so Water is weight separate from the ferment
Please you Spread misinformation to other
I appreciate your candor
Another reformulation I guess Missha is going to break the record 😂
My alternatives are:
Cosxr: galactomyces toner (95% petira)
Succin: First treatment essence (90% petira)
Neogen: dermatology real ferment micro essence
Secret Key: galactomyces essence
Love everything on your list! I need to do an alternatives video for this- the Scinic one is amazing, and of course the one from Neogen Dermalogy is amazing, too!
The RX version is better, than the new 5x version
The saying is that if your nose itches, you’re going to kiss a fool. At least, that’s what I was always told.
Lol! Love that saying!
Girl I feel like they are just taken all these good products and f..... Them up talking about renewed updated updated to what a crappy product that was once amazing I so hate when these companies do this especially the ones that don't bother to tell u they are changing ur favs and lead u on to think it using the same till u discover something is just not right.
🧡🎃🧡
Sorry, not 1st! Running late cuz it's my Birthday 🎂
Happy Birthday 🎊 🎂 🎉
Happy birthday 🎉
Oh no! I love for the Time Revolution Moist, it’s so important in my skin care. I hate when they change the ingredients. 🥲
And here i was thinking of trying it after my neogen essence 🥲
The Neogen Essence is amazing!!! Maybe try the Scinic First Treatment Essence- that one is pretty good as well!
@@NOBSBeauty Thanks for the recommendation! And the review! I didn't even know they reformulated the version that everyone talks about