Minecraft City/Building Critique - Apr 2022
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 06. 2024
- I review your Minecraft builds, giving lots of constructive feedback!
Join our Discord!
cubed.community/discord
See my builds here:
/ alpine.builds
Thumbnail by Tutuzin_HD13
--------------------------------------------------------
[Unfortunately, I'm unable to review every build on camera, so if I miss your build I'll try and put it in another video]
Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
0:30 Build #1 - Flatiron-esque Tower
0:52 Build #2 - Bay-Adelaide Centre, Toronto (I think)
1:21 Build #3 - Fancy Quartz Building
2:01 Build #4 - Twin Bridges
2:21 Build #5 - Brick City Building
3:26 Build #6 - A Well Colour-Coordinated City
5:37 Build #7 - Cozy Shop/Restaurant
6:27 Build #8 - A City of Mid-Rises
7:42 Build #9 - Cozy American Town
8:27 Build #10 - Sandstone Tower
8:56 Build #11 - Houses & Duplexes
9:51 Build #12 - A Very Small Skyscraper
10:18 Build #13 - Great Shapes, Great Textures
10:49 Build #14 - Dutch Mall
11:29 Build #15 - A Familiar City
12:18 Build #16 - Clean Gray Tower
12:44 Build #17 - Glass Office Tower
13:58 Build #18 - A Carrier of Aircraft
14:26 Build #19 - A Hand-Built City
15:16 Build #20 - The Perfect Survival Town
16:06 Build #21 - Bulgarian Apartments
17:31 Build #22 - How do you even do this lol
18:04 Build #23 - An Adorable Building
18:35 Build #24 - A Bedrock City
20:12 End
--------------------------------------------------------
Hi! I'm a Canadian Architectural Engineering undergrad student and make Minecraft building videos. My degree focuses on Structural Engineering, Heritage Conservation, Sustainable Building Design, and Architectural Technology.
--------------------------------------------------------
CubedPack, Optifine 1.14.4 required cubed.community/texturepack/
Cubed Community (play.cubed.community, Java 1.14.4)
--------------------------------------------------------
Alpine animations by Basti Designs: designs_basti?s=21
Basti's Twitch: / iamthebasti
Cubed animation by Jodixx
In-game skin made by Tarago
Extra clips from pixabay.com
Music from Artlist
--------------------------------------------------------
Business: alpine.videos1@gmail.com
Disclaimer: I do not hold a P. Eng. designation, I am in my fifth year of an Architectural Engineering undergraduate degree. Discussion topics on this channel are subject to errors. - Hry
Here are my builds (mostly) if you want to check them out: instagram.com/alpine.builds/
The inside of my builds look like trash help me
hi, i'm trying to bild a city but i don't know what build to put in the space i have, like a skyscraper, an house, so i want to ask: how do i know what to build and what the city needs?
Only a canadian can give a great advice and then apologize in advance in case the person gets offended
I try and give geniune advice, if I'm ever being too harsh please let me know! :)
@@Alpine1 You're good bro.
@@Alpine1 u are amazing I love your vids man :)
This community is so freaking talented wtf
After watching all of these builds, I have realized that I do NOT specialize in city building or urban planning, but hey, it’s cool to see these unique and impressive builds. I am much better at boat building
As a student of urban planning, I have some additional tips for the streets at 7:00...
#1 Yellow lane markings shouldn't be dotted, they should be continuous, and should divide the direction of traffic.
#2 The white lane markings should always be dotted unless you're building the road in a tunnel, or some other place where you don't want cars to change lanes. The white markings should be 3 meters long and separated by an 8 meter gap.
#3 For building road shoulders, I recommend using quartz stairs, with the lower step facing the edge of the road. This enhances the realism by making it appear that these lane markings are only half a block thick.
#4 Although having wide roads can enhance realism, 3 block wide lanes are perfectly reasonable, and are in line with real world safety standards. If you were building an interstate, 4-5 block wide lanes would make sense, but since you are constructing a human-scale mid-rise city, 3 block wide lanes are perfectly acceptable, as they would have the effect of reducing speed.
I don't think it was the intent in the build, but just a comment abt dotted yellow lines: where i live, a dotted yellow line indicates a section where overtaking is allowed by crossing onto the other side
Cool video ! Was nice to see all types of building styles, with different texture packs and sizes 👌
Is this the OG or the 500th clone?
@@atharva_kari I got clones ? 😳
@@crackodawn7425 in the discord lol
So, Alpine, I have three questions:
I watched your video on curved roads and I wanted to know how I could make a longer or more gradual curve, possible even diagonal?
I also wanted to know how you make good interchanges.
And finally, what are your tips on building interstates or highways?
Same. I have my own method i've haphazardly developed, but i want to hear what a real engineer thinks
That's my city on the thumbnail OMGGGGG!!!!
Great work!
I’ve been watching since you were under 10k and just started watching again for tips on building in different games. Thank you 🙏
Tip on texturing (I'm not that great, but I have tips):
My first tip is doing gradients. It's one way to do gradients. If you watch Grian, the Minecraft CZcamsr that does hermit craft, he does gradients. It's a really nice way to make the eyes go up on the building and back down.
If you're doing the scatter method, if you want to have moss, make it go from the top if you have trees or something, but if you don't, start at the bottom as if it's like vines growing up in the bricks. If you want to, fill the whole wall, then where it feels repetitive or plain, add detail (texture) to it. It's about trial and era. You wanna have the right amount. Not too much, not too little.
Hopefully you understand. I'm not too good at explaining things. Especially when I'm not too good at it myself. Love your content. Keep up the good work!
I am confused as to who you are talking to
@@aspectenario I was talking to Matt... He wanted to know texturing. Watch the video...
Who is this Grain character?!
@@imstqtic 😮
Auto-correct really messed it up
love the way u didn’t discourage a newer builder in #19, instead giving advice so that they could further their builds.
Been on a minecraft binge and my guitars getting restrung tonight so these videos while im on minecraft help alot👍👍
I’ve really enjoyed this video and your series of this so far! You should definitely continue it. Also, if I’m not asking too much, I was wondering if you could possibly make a video about building realistically believable vehicles (without using mods)? I’ve installed your Cubed Community’s resource pack, and am excited to see what I could make of it!
The two bridges (twin bridges, 2:01) are the Brooklyn Bridge (brown) and the Manhattan Bridge (green) in NYC, they are right next to each other IRL and span the east river. I'm from NYC and I can say they look pretty accurate!
I'm not good at texturing but you can use WE to do it for you, with for example //set 45%materialX,35%materialY,25%materialZ. That randomly mixes the texture using several block types at the same time. Saves a lot of work if anything.
You can vary the number of blocks and the percentages. It works with any command where you set or change a block (e.g. //replace etc.)
I made #17 - thanks for the feedback, looks much better now! :D
Great video! Love seeing all the different builds and what you think of them as well. That first "flatiron" building looks like it's US Steel Tower in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. I think it's still the world's tallest flat roofed building..?
Awesome video as always! I have a question, can you possible make a video on highways? Mostly on what to do and what not to do.
A fantastic video as always 😀
Because you wanted to know how to structure a wall.
Go with a few blocks that you want to use that go well together. After that you could do it with World Edit and then make some fields with the same block out of the random pattern. Otherwise you could do it without worldedit and do the same
Great video! There are lots of lovely builds here.
My city is in the thumbnail
Hey i built build #20 #23 thx although that build #20 is looking a lil meh to me now used a little much diorite
Hi, I'm the person who built #9 and #11 theres 2 different texture packs actually. The small houses in the hills, and the rowhomes were on a pack called TRS v2.4.0, and the main st and the duplexes were on a pack i somewhat made called BMC v1.0 (Block Mason Community), thanks for the compliments on the main street :)))
The window trims are I think crimson fence gates so they have to be w/e'd to be permanently on.
It's was on server I made a long time ago but I took the map off cus I really didn't like the city anymore so it's gone to time
Anyways ty for adding my submissions in
I love your houses, it reminds me of Troy NY.
if youre talking texturing in terms of flat walls or walls that can feel very plane. i get a selection of blocks that are the same color/ feel then fill my hotbar all the way with them in an order then every time I place a block o just flick the scroll wheel selecting a new block. really great way of randomizing a flat wall. there are also programs you can get to auto scroll so you can place massive walls quicker with this technique.
The third one is an 18th to 19th century design found in Britain and France.
Nice vid! 👍
Yeshhh new video!
Lord daddy alpine 🙏
I think the big church part was a inspiration from Notre-Dame
It’s cool that you don’t show just the cool and impressive builds and city’s :)
*cities
What mod do you use to get the tables and other items like furniture
You did terraining for under building but could you do terraining for parks or hillsides
#6 For The Win! Credit to me and my boy VivdKj ! ❤️
Man, I want to showcase a mountain villa.
It might be underwhelming but I am trying pure vanila
you should review something of a soviet origin i think that would be cool to see some Soviet architecture
nice video
I'm Canadian too I live in Vancouver Canada
I feel offended you called the most ICONIC NAVY F14 TIMECAT AN AIRFORCE F15. But no all jokes aside great video love the reviews keep up the great work!
Oh noooo I swear I had till it right! It’s even worse since I’ve spent a lot of time around aircraft 😬
what shader are you usually using in minecraft?
Can you make an Football/Soccer Stadium in your city?
Ver cool
alpine banger
The first one is the UPMC building in Pittsburgh or at least somewhat like it someone already probably said that but just wanted to let you know
Where do you get these textures and shaders
I think the church is a replica of St. Patrick's Cathedral in NYC.
Was that inside Dupont Station Entrance?
10:19 looks like we aboutta argue whether the walls are blue/black or white/gold
lmao
It’s blue
I’m so glad to finally see some pocket edition in here
@ 5:56~ its stripped logs not prismarine
is the first one the US Steel building in Pittsburgh?
aka the “UPMC building” for everyone else
I wish I was good at building modern. I'm only good at fantasy and medieval
This is your sign to start practicing. First you gotta suck at something to be sorta good at something
I'm bad at building full stop. Lol
I'm bad at building full stop. Lol
I'm good at Renaissance/Baroque style buildings. Rarely tried other styles
im the opposite i cant build medieval things at all but good at modern builds
I challenge you to build a building in a default textures
You vs pippenfts this is a good competition
I made it!
I'm wondering what country is your city located in?
18:49 look at the bottom left in the background. See the white car? It's a SUUPRAAAAAAAAAAAAA
The texture pack might be cocricot (theirs also a mod)
YOOOOO my build is in number 5 YAY
also i made it on a server so it's litterly vanilla
I'm starting a city default
Could you add another island then put a zoo pls
Name of the pack in Duplex
Great video. sadly my house wasn't in the video. maybe next time ?
I’ll try my best! I have a lot of builds to get through
Didn't the alpine reviews your builds channel get removed?
It did! I’m taking a break from build reviews while I get my content strategy organized
Ahhh ok, good luck with that 👍 can't wait for more videos 😀
One sec i though it is minecraft buildings but then it poped it a real world lol
Hi. Long time no see
Hello!
there is a child, running down the sidewalk young hearts they can get wild, better hold their hand for a little while
Are horror builds acceptable?
i made build #7 and the whole area is a clothing store 💀 the first photo is the checkout area lol
Oh that makes sense! I think the angle was throwing me off
Build #15 is a bedrock world.
My builds are much better, empty plots are the best
Ik you've disgussed it time to time, but I thin, you should still do a quick bedrock review to satisfy bedrock players like myself. Even it's low quality and on like a tablet, that'll satisfy us, if you recive hate or something, you could always delete the video lster. Thx if you read this :)
Please answer me