The Tragic Story of The 'Hidden Kennedy' | Rosemary Kennedy, Forced to Have a Lobotomy

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 06. 2024
  • We all know the tragic stories of John F. Kennedy and Robert F. Kennedy but surprisingly few know the story Rosemary Kennedy, the 'secret' Kennedy sister who seemed to have it all but was forced by her father to have a lobotomy and then was hidden away from the world.
    Her mother, Rose was forced to delay giving birth to her with her nurse even pushing Rosemary's head back into her mothers birth canal. This action would have a profound effect on Rosemary's life. It stopped the new born from getting enough oxygen, causing damage to her brain.
    This manifested in Rosemary being slower to walk, slower to talk and doing poorly in school. She was a happy and vibrant child but this wasn't enough for her father who demanded much of all his children.

Komentáře • 5K

  • @kayejohnson3000
    @kayejohnson3000 Před rokem +1196

    What was done to Rosemary was CRIMINAL, first by the nurse, then by her own father! That man was a monster!

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Před rokem +16

      Facts! 💯

    • @christophermiller159
      @christophermiller159 Před rokem +12

      Yea he was!!

    • @itsjorgeroblox1779
      @itsjorgeroblox1779 Před rokem +66

      He got karma though, he got a stroke and was unable to walk or speak. Exactly what happened to Rosemary, unable to walk or speak. He got his apple

    • @anndillard8681
      @anndillard8681 Před rokem +2

      Same was done to my mother - by the same dr.. read DADDY THROWS ME IN THE AIR - memoir/self-help

    • @mikeborgmann
      @mikeborgmann Před rokem +12

      ​@@itsjorgeroblox1779yeah but he had his stroke late in life, she was a young woman with her entire life ahead of her....

  • @Mrs.TJTaylor
    @Mrs.TJTaylor Před 2 lety +7934

    He couldn’t legally kill her, so he did the next best thing. What a monster. And all to avoid the embarrassment of having an “imperfect” child.

    • @user-yd4nk4lm6s
      @user-yd4nk4lm6s Před 2 lety +54

      You shouldn't oversimplify a difficult situation. This is how people behaved in those days. Read Larson's book on Rosemary for a more balanced and fair narrative.

    • @foxwyrick1
      @foxwyrick1 Před 2 lety +475

      The procedure he forced on her was bad enough but to abandon her afterwards was appalling. He couldn't face up to his mistake. A decent human would have, but he wasn't decent to begin with.

    • @GlennaVan
      @GlennaVan Před 2 lety +61

      The only good thing is that he, a Nazi sympathizer, didn't send her to Germany for their experiments!

    • @nuthinbutluv4u142
      @nuthinbutluv4u142 Před 2 lety +132

      @@user-yd4nk4lm6s Kathleen knew better, as did her siblings after his death. No, not EVERYONE behaved this way.

    • @angidaminescu1340
      @angidaminescu1340 Před 2 lety +277

      @@user-yd4nk4lm6s are u joking?? Oversimplify??? He ruined her life!! The procedure he did to her and then hiding her as far as possible from all the family and friends,was nothing short of killing any chance of a normal life she could have had.That is far and beyond monstrous to be done by your own father! Are u actually trying to find excuses for what that sorry ass of a man did?! I don't care he was a successful loved business man,he was a lousy, horrible, monstrous father! He was trying to be better with the others because he had a gain.
      They were bringing him the White House and that is no little thing.
      I feel sick just to think what a disgusting creature of a man he was.

  • @BunnnyMocha
    @BunnnyMocha Před rokem +1759

    This actually made me weep. Imagine destroying the life of your eldest, most beautiful daughter simply because she's incapable of meeting your standards. Then imagine having the audacity to tell your son that the most important role above being the president was that of a father, yet you failed at being one yourself. What a joke. That monster wasn't a father, he was a sociopathic incarcerator.

    • @pearlseashell
      @pearlseashell Před rokem

      Exactly and joe was the reaon why his son John f kennedy,went on and got 2beautifil woman killed whom he had an affsire with during hid presidency!
      I remember watching a program about marilyn and that lady and where it started

    • @ann-carolinemorner6405
      @ann-carolinemorner6405 Před rokem +22

      He was just a little upstart. He managed to become ambassador to the UK just in order to have his wife and daughters presented at court.
      Poor Rosemary, she would have been much happier as a cottager's wife back in Ireland.

    • @BTSArmy-ge5gf
      @BTSArmy-ge5gf Před rokem +1

      He was actually an amazing father by all accounts

    • @nadiajurasek186
      @nadiajurasek186 Před rokem +62

      @@BTSArmy-ge5gf Give me a brake !!!!
      He was a monster !!!!

    • @BTSArmy-ge5gf
      @BTSArmy-ge5gf Před rokem +2

      @@nadiajurasek186 Not really, he did everything correctly... the only mistakes made were by the nurse during birth, and the doctor screwing up the lobotomy

  • @atiqahdiyana5665
    @atiqahdiyana5665 Před rokem +536

    As horrible as this story is, I genuinely feel uplifted by the fact that all her other siblings did what they could to rectify the situation and tried their best to push forward future support for people similar to their sister. She didn’t deserve what her father did to her. But I’m at least glad that it started awareness among the future generations over it

    • @razor1uk610
      @razor1uk610 Před rokem

      ..then years later Regan defunded asylum's and rolled back a lot of supporting institutions, bills & amendments relating to mental & physical health, because apparently Christians are supposedly really caring, just like Rosemary's Natzi father

    • @jessicamarie8299
      @jessicamarie8299 Před rokem +16

      It’s still heartbreaking this poor girl had suffered from the minute she was born. 😢😢

    • @sandrap629
      @sandrap629 Před 9 měsíci +2

      Did it

    • @Ladybhive71
      @Ladybhive71 Před 3 měsíci

      ​@@jessicamarie8299💯

  • @elmienliebenberg9145
    @elmienliebenberg9145 Před 2 lety +11243

    I completely broke down seeing the photos of Rosemary as an elderly woman slumped down her chair. What her father did to her was unforgivable. She was awake for the whole torture. I will not justify that barbaric act by calling it a medical procedure. It was a savage experiment.
    More people must know about this. Thank you for telling her story.
    Thank you for the 10k likes 🙏

    • @ascent8487
      @ascent8487 Před 2 lety +558

      I think he was too ashamed to ever face her again. Or rather to truly face what he’d done. First, it’s possible that without the nurses horrible instruction to her mother, she’d have been born with no issues whatsoever. But even with cognitive disabilities, she had a chance at a happy, fulfilling life. He stole from her what potential she had.

    • @TheAvprobeauty
      @TheAvprobeauty Před 2 lety +280

      lobotomy wasn’t even developed by a doctor it was originally created by a salesman
      disgusting the giles of man

    • @lostboi210
      @lostboi210 Před 2 lety +102

      Oh hes in hell right now answering for all his horrific transgressions

    • @angiebrown1729
      @angiebrown1729 Před 2 lety +34

      The medical folks still do surgery's while the patient is still awake.

    • @klarabarunovic9841
      @klarabarunovic9841 Před 2 lety +74

      I wouldn't call it savage,that is too nice of a word

  • @rustinstardust2094
    @rustinstardust2094 Před 2 lety +19551

    The one thing I find most impressive here is that despite how strict the father was with his children and insistent they be perfect and make the family look spotless...as soon as he died they went and got their sister and completely involved her with the family. I'm glad they were able to think for themselves.

    • @tiredtears4177
      @tiredtears4177 Před 2 lety +685

      She lived near me for a very long time. Even the driveway to the home was like a mile long to hide the house she stayed in

    • @sophiizplace
      @sophiizplace Před 2 lety +510

      Yea He wanted them to be so perfect he ruin a blessing God had given..because despite her being held inside the womb for 2 solid hours she still grew up to be a beautiful woman. But even after surviving that kind of childhood trauma, that wasnt good enough for him. So what she was slower?. ( because of that stupid nurse) she was still out in the world being.. " normal!...and then she was.. WOKE,,,during that heinous procedure?...He let Dr, Frankenstein
      experiment on his child, just because she was merely (in this case )..most likely on the spectrum. Smh...

    • @bostonblackie9503
      @bostonblackie9503 Před 2 lety +322

      The complete Kennedy clan are wrotten to the core!

    • @sophiizplace
      @sophiizplace Před 2 lety +76

      @@bostonblackie9503 I heard that...History has added a few question marks also....

    • @jaynehogue2459
      @jaynehogue2459 Před 2 lety +468

      They should have done that and involved their sister before the father died. That to me is cowardice that they didn't

  • @rare1walking
    @rare1walking Před 2 lety +105

    I have a sister who was given a chemical lobotomy to silence and discredit her for telling a Policeman who called the family home that yes, sexual abuse was indeed going on there. My sister Lisa is very intelligent, served in the military and has had 2 children. She has Aspbergers, and was driven to the local Utah hospital and drugged in a Psych ward. My Mother and youngest sister drove her there. She is now like a vegetable in an institution. I can't understand her, as she has no teeth. She can write, as I found out when I visited her.
    Several Utah doctors were involved. The Mgr. of the current Care Center didn't seem to care about her history. I doubt law Enforcement would either, based on past experiences.
    My Mother is now deceased. It has been a heartache for years. My sister stayed in that State, as her two children live there. The attitudes of my siblings have been appalling.

    • @TannaBerensen
      @TannaBerensen Před 11 měsíci +17

      I'm so sorry to hear that. I can't believe that was still legal. Don't give up trying to get her justice. Bringing these things to light is very important to spark change.

    • @shelley1004
      @shelley1004 Před 2 měsíci +2

      Did they give her a certain prescription that did it? On purpose or. I’m sorry to hear about this well people
      Still get commited for minor infractions and gaslighting families.

  • @victoriajohnson1117
    @victoriajohnson1117 Před rokem +228

    It's so sad how they treated this beautifully, sweet lady. I can't believe he did that to his daughter. Embarrassment from a child with a disability is a special kind of evil.

    • @marlenanapier3186
      @marlenanapier3186 Před 9 měsíci +3

      truth

    • @marlenanapier3186
      @marlenanapier3186 Před 9 měsíci

      the matriarch also said that when her other daughter and son in law died in plane crash that it was DIVINE INTERVENTION for marrying outside her FAITH! i hate the kennedys.

    • @kellyshomemadekitchen
      @kellyshomemadekitchen Před 3 měsíci

      Very true but society, especially the upper echelons, was completely different back then. It was a disgrace to have a disabled child and the Kennedys were definitely not the only family to hide away a handicapped child. Not justifying their actions in any way, just pointing out what a different world they lived in compared to now. However, I do feel they redeemed themselves somewhat by creating the Special Olympics.

  • @JP-sb6ll
    @JP-sb6ll Před 2 lety +7883

    I’m not surprised by Rosmary’s father’s actions towards her. The whole thing about him being a Nazi sympathizer was a dead giveaway, of what kind of human being he was.

    • @lesliesmith5797
      @lesliesmith5797 Před 2 lety +135

      Not a good one, that’s for sure.

    • @jasperhorace7147
      @jasperhorace7147 Před 2 lety +135

      @@lesliesmith5797 And a religious bigot into the bargain.

    • @margiemasih990
      @margiemasih990 Před 2 lety +23

      Nazi..

    • @mblmbl1574
      @mblmbl1574 Před 2 lety +121

      Who doesn’t go visit their ill daughter - ever again???? Horrible people.

    • @lighthouselaura4324
      @lighthouselaura4324 Před 2 lety +36

      Hugo boss, seamens, bear asprin, fanta, ford, ibm, vw & numerous insurance companies all became huge by supporting Nazi. Prior to The invasion of Poland lots of people supported the Nazi movement. Then they began to realize what was happening (minus the xamps). Also the world was antisemitic for thousands of years, so the propaganda wasn't unusual. Still today people are anti zion. Saying that has a control all the money- same old shit.
      The reason your awake during brain procedures, is because u need to talk during it.

  • @NYMusic89563
    @NYMusic89563 Před 2 lety +5444

    The lobotomy is the worst thing that’s ever happened in medicine in my opinion.

    • @Dina52328
      @Dina52328 Před 2 lety +438

      Also the Thalidomide drug that caused horrible deformities in newborn babies in the 1960’s. What a catastrophe for the babies that survived. How sad.

    • @discogoth
      @discogoth Před 2 lety +225

      And the Twilight Sleep that was very common during birth in the 1910s when Rose was born. The medicalization of pregnancy and childbirth has been an absolute disaster.

    • @catphat7912
      @catphat7912 Před 2 lety +147

      It was disgusting thinking that jabbing and cutting the most delicate organ in the body well fix any problem someone has. many where basically turned into mindless vegetables but without this gruesome medical “treatment” we would not know as much about the brain then what we do now. knowing different parts of the brain do different things like the frontal lobe is in charge of memory and thought process the back part of the brain is in charge of vision but without knowing this, many medical conditions like epilepsy would still be a mystery to help a great example of this there was a little girl with severe seizures so doctors carefully take out half of her brain but because of learning from the past the little girl no longer had seizures and is fully functional without any physical or mental issues the medical field holds a horrible and gruesome past but without that past we would not be to where we are now

    • @ruvimbomichellemuzheve4531
      @ruvimbomichellemuzheve4531 Před 2 lety +147

      read into what they did to slaves 10000x time worse

    • @KIRKSHINTATURNIPSEED
      @KIRKSHINTATURNIPSEED Před 2 lety +184

      If you think thats the worse in medicine read the book medical apartheid - black women were experimented on in horrific experiments

  • @AurielArts
    @AurielArts Před rokem +133

    My great Aunt was given a lobotomy and institutionalized for how she struggled. After being misdiagnosed for over 30 years, I found out I was on the Autism spectrum and most likely she was too. Both sides of my family have this. They made her worse and my life (and my family’s) would have been massively different if we had all known sooner. At least these days more and more is coming to light.

    • @girl1213
      @girl1213 Před rokem +15

      Lobotomies are the reason my grandma never got my dad diagnosed. She feared the institutions and for good reason. I don't blame her for covering up Dad's Asperger's syndrome as "being painfully shy" since it was her best defense against those who did not understand there was nothing wrong with my dad, just that he was different. Dad didn't even know until I was diagnosed at age 12 and Grandma finally opened up about it. Answered a lot of my dad's questions about himself.

    • @emilypharr2454
      @emilypharr2454 Před 11 měsíci +2

      I have an autistic son and I believe that Rosemary was autistic the way that she is described before the lobotomy. So sad!!!

    • @robblequoffle8456
      @robblequoffle8456 Před 11 měsíci +2

      Imagine having a needle jammed in your brain, all because of a mild mental deficiency/disorder

    • @nmc1859
      @nmc1859 Před 8 měsíci +1

      My great aunt was also. It has drastically affected the way my family dealt with things.. a lot of secrecy and brushing things under the rug. Of course I feel for this great aunt I never met .. I pray her soul is resting in peace.

  • @ladygrey4113
    @ladygrey4113 Před rokem +81

    It’s lovely that her siblings once they realized what happened to Rosemary they worked hard to make sure what happened to their beloved sister wouldn’t happen to someone else

  • @sofie5619
    @sofie5619 Před 2 lety +2956

    ”She was pushed back up in the birthcanal where she stayed for 2hours” How does this sound like a good idea? Insane! 😳😖🤢🤮

    • @nancyhopple8138
      @nancyhopple8138 Před 2 lety +49

      Babies are killed before birth every day.

    • @queerlibtardhippie9357
      @queerlibtardhippie9357 Před 2 lety +485

      @@nancyhopple8138 And how is that relevant to the babies who have to suffer permanent damage because of incompetent "medical professionals?" Things that are dead do not suffer. Things that live remember suffering.

    • @ashashraa6579
      @ashashraa6579 Před 2 lety +61

      @@queerlibtardhippie9357 So because they're dead and can't remember, it's justifiable to end their lives in the first place? What kind of effing logic is that?

    • @user-yd4nk4lm6s
      @user-yd4nk4lm6s Před 2 lety +137

      It was for money. The nurses were instructed to do this for the doctor to arrive and collect the bill.

    • @alinagongu3824
      @alinagongu3824 Před 2 lety +21

      @@user-yd4nk4lm6s you are so, so right and smart!

  • @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796
    @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796 Před 2 lety +5605

    Rosemary’s sister Kathleen “Kick” Kennedy worked on a newspaper at the time of Rosemary’s lobotomy. She’d researched lobotomies, and said anxiously to her father, “Dad, this isn’t what we want for Rosie.” He ignored her.

    • @REALcatmom
      @REALcatmom Před 2 lety +245

      If only he’d listened!

    • @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796
      @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796 Před 2 lety +664

      @@REALcatmom Isn’t it sad? And Rosemary was not really all that mentally impaired. That was demonstrated in the diaries she kept when the family lived in Europe. It was whispered, when Rosemary began to leave her school unchaperoned, that her father’s greatest fear was that she’d get pregnant.

    • @REALcatmom
      @REALcatmom Před 2 lety +62

      @@lesliegoodman-malamuth9796 I’d also read that.

    • @indiatastic
      @indiatastic Před 2 lety +22

      i thought he never told anyone??

    • @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796
      @lesliegoodman-malamuth9796 Před 2 lety +18

      @@indiatastic Word leaked out…

  • @DoeBoy999
    @DoeBoy999 Před rokem +118

    One thing I find really distasteful is how a bunch of grown adults that were her brothers and sisters never said 'to hell with fathers wishes'. How can you not see one of your brothers/sisters for decades because pops sent her away somewhere? I find that terribly bizarre and there must be something that is being left unsaid about the whole thing.

    • @NebulaBull
      @NebulaBull Před rokem +33

      The siblings were so busy growing into adulthood and trying to appease their father, not to mention the growing tension with Germany, The siblings did try for 10yrs to find out what happened and wanted to see her and though it took ten plus years they found every detail and told the true story and did so much till this day for mental and physical disabilities

    • @angelsgranny
      @angelsgranny Před rokem +19

      There's definitely more to it. Much more.

    • @julierobinson3633
      @julierobinson3633 Před rokem +34

      I thought that, but what you have to remember is that they were his kids, he had worked on their minds since they were born. In some ways it's like abused wives, they mentally cannot stand up to their husbands. He had clearly terrorised and manipulated his children all their lives, he obviously encouraged their competitiveness by withholding his approval and affection unless they pleased him. He GROOMED them to never go against his wishes. And don't forget they were a very religious family, the Catholic church will have been drumming 'honour thy father and mother' into them since early childhood too...

    • @eldupont3095
      @eldupont3095 Před rokem +12

      It's not like they knew where she was; I can't imagine I'd have been able to find her if I was in their shoes

    • @libertyann439
      @libertyann439 Před rokem +10

      He kept it from them. Remember, most of them were kids themselves.

  • @janisyoung9682
    @janisyoung9682 Před rokem +36

    Such a beautiful young lady! It was terrible to do that to her. It was also terrible for him not to discuss the operation with her mother. He really was a monster!!!

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Před rokem +3

      He didn't even tell her daughter what he was going to do to her. I don't believe in hell, but if there is one, I sure hope he's burning there!

  • @franchescamarcelle1819
    @franchescamarcelle1819 Před 2 lety +1935

    Sad thing is before this barbaric procedure, there was really nothing wrong with her. She was just a little slow to learn, she could have lived a perfectly normal life, but people (in this case her father) were so ignorant back then.

    • @kenseym5272
      @kenseym5272 Před 2 lety +207

      Her father was a monster all around.

    • @michellemelville8979
      @michellemelville8979 Před 2 lety +4

      Society in general were ignorant. Mental institutions at the time were still barbaric. The era of hiding people away who might tarnish a families good name.

    • @lukasribin4168
      @lukasribin4168 Před 2 lety +7

      I mean..that’s putting it lightly, there was very clearly something wrong via the brain damage she initially incurred as a result of the botched birth, to dismiss that is to dismiss a tragedy in and of itself, she had other privileges that allowed mitigation of that fact, but that’s not to sweep it under the rug. The point is not that she had no prior issue, the point is that what started out as an accident, ended up in a purposeful and cruel procedure that stole even more of her mental capacity to the point she could not even enjoy her previous privileges and mitigating factors, her situation was made so much worse, it should have been left alone in the least.

    • @themaskedtalker2171
      @themaskedtalker2171 Před 2 lety +69

      Friendly reminder, people used to think smoking cigarettes was healthy back then.

    • @annelieseharrison9027
      @annelieseharrison9027 Před 2 lety +54

      Eugenicists still think the same today. They have not changed.

  • @patsysolatzzo2962
    @patsysolatzzo2962 Před 2 lety +4808

    Rosemary is the reason why Britney Spear’s situation scares me. When someone has enough power and money who is anyone else to stop their power over their children…absolutely saddening.

    • @PrincessDie187
      @PrincessDie187 Před 2 lety +37

      Totally

    • @henri7054
      @henri7054 Před 2 lety +38

      This is flippin so sad a life ruined over pride 😢

    • @jn8922
      @jn8922 Před 2 lety +92

      Exactly. Its like a horror movie. All you need to get locked up in a mental asylum is someone in your family saying you're insane. Its horrific. And like the doctor and the sick nurse, there could a cruel sick psychiatrist out there willing to just sign away and have you committed. The more you protest, the more insane they'll say you are. It chills my blood.

    • @amberagain3487
      @amberagain3487 Před 2 lety +26

      Britney posts videos of herself dancing in her mansion and vacationing in the tropics lol I can’t see their situations in the same light

    • @patsysolatzzo2962
      @patsysolatzzo2962 Před 2 lety +84

      @@amberagain3487 are you not following her situation? Britney Spears had been in a conservatorship for over a decade now. She has no control over her image, her work, or social media. She has a team that was managed by her father who was controlling her every move from making her preform world tours when she didn’t want to, barring her from marriage and having children, and keeping her in her home under supervision. After her public meltdown, her father took control over her entire life and brand. She can’t even see her kids that that back up dancer has custody of. She’s not vacationing and dancing in her mansion. Her dancing for a large part of the past 3 years have been a call for help. She was begging her fans who have zero power to help….in a desperate attempt to spotlight her situation. Most people saw what you did but people who followed her knew something wasn’t right…her dancing became vacant and her captions became cryptic. Now, everything was revealed to the courts that everything fans have been speculating is factual. She is completely a slave to her own brand being abused in plain sight. Which is horrorfying because someone like you sees what you commented but the reality is far more bleak.

  • @honestlyyours1069
    @honestlyyours1069 Před 2 lety +55

    I know from my friend's experience that if you have a severe disability and grow up in a family where one parent sets high standards for the children, it's very frustrating if you can't achieve those standards. Rosemary must have been quite upset and frustrated at not being able to do the same kinds of things as her siblings. That poor woman never had a chance, especially after her lobotomy.

    • @prossiearinaitwe4768
      @prossiearinaitwe4768 Před rokem

      He caused the curse to his own family by destroying ReseMary’s Kennedy life.

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Před rokem +3

      The doctors that botched it should have been charged for neglectful practice and had their MD's taken from them. The whole incident just boils my blood! 😡

  • @renpilak6048
    @renpilak6048 Před 2 lety +51

    It is so heartwarming that her siblings loved her dearly despite of her father’s cruelty!

  • @digitalsoop
    @digitalsoop Před 2 lety +2766

    What the nurse did to Rosemary is still happening TODAY. My sister was forced by the head nurse to hold her baby in the birth canal because the doctor wasn't there yet. By the time the doctor had arrived the epidural had worn off, and it was now an emergency birth. The doctor was absolutely furious with the nurse, berating her through the entire birth. It was traumatic for everyone involved and it's lucky that my niece has shown no lasting side effects now that she's 3 years old.
    I hope that the nurse lost her job, but I doubt it. I can't understand how a team of nurses trained in neonatal care can't deliver a baby and keep it stable until a doctor arrives, and would rather risk injuring or killing the baby by delaying a birth that has already started.

    • @YaakovEzraAmiChi
      @YaakovEzraAmiChi Před 2 lety +19

      Yeah if any nurse told that to my child's mother at labor I'd tell them to f8ck off. Especially since knowing better.
      I'm sorry for all those who trusted medical professionals only to be betrayed and done for the worse

    • @TheLeastOfficialOfBros
      @TheLeastOfficialOfBros Před 2 lety +298

      If you’re having a baby without the doctor present and the head is already starting to crown, the nurse better get ready to catch the kid. Wouldn’t it have been better to actually deliver the kid even if the doctor wasn’t there?

    • @EnDB
      @EnDB Před 2 lety +68

      Even though they know it's dangerous, they're more worried about the possible aftermath. They don't know how to stop hemorrhaging, repair perineal tears, or exactly how to correct dystocia. Besides that, many nurses don't have liability insurance coverage like a doc does

    • @digitalsoop
      @digitalsoop Před 2 lety +122

      @@EnDB i assume, then, that if the baby or mother is injured while delaying a birth because the doctor isn't there, the liability would be on the hospital or the doctor. The baby can still be injured or killed while in the nurse's care if the mother is forced to keep her baby in the birth canal because a doctor isn't there. So is the liability only shifted to the nurse once the mother gives birth? What if the mother can't stop her labor even though the nurses are demanding it? Would the nurse be liable for injuries if she had to forcibly keep the baby from being born?
      It seems to me in a scenario where the baby is already well down the birth canal and no one knows how long it will take for the doctor to arrive, then the sensible option would be to birth the baby. You're at risk for liability for injuries to the baby or the mother either way at that point, right?

    • @EnDB
      @EnDB Před 2 lety +15

      No, at that point they aren't in charge. If they take charge and tell her to push, they assume responsibility from that point on.

  • @courtneyfox2497
    @courtneyfox2497 Před 2 lety +3263

    How could they do that to a birthing mother ! And that poor child. People are so cruel and ignorant .

    • @DylanRomanov
      @DylanRomanov Před 2 lety +252

      I was horrified hearing that, In what world does it make sense to prevent the baby from coming out?

    • @courtneyfox2497
      @courtneyfox2497 Před 2 lety +123

      @@DylanRomanov I know right ! That's just so shocking . Thank God thats well known now. When birth became controlled by doctors mortality rates sky rocketed of mother's and babies . They didn't know back then they had to wash their hands and these doctors would go straight from patient to patient even autopsy's to delivering babies with no washing hands or gloves or anything. Also the chainsaw was invented to aid in childbirth! Some gruesome birth history for your day 👀👀

    • @emw5
      @emw5 Před 2 lety +84

      @@DylanRomanov it happens here in America disproportionately to BLACK & BROWN women

    • @pepperprovasnik
      @pepperprovasnik Před 2 lety +9

      Mine was born that was too. It happens more than you think

    • @pepperprovasnik
      @pepperprovasnik Před 2 lety +75

      @@emw5 it happens in the US to poor women. Of ANY color.

  • @Courier_Jackalope
    @Courier_Jackalope Před rokem +7

    If a nurse tells you to "hold it", closes your legs, or tries to push your baby back in the birth canal then you need to get the hell out of that chop shop.

  • @Pride369
    @Pride369 Před rokem +101

    Mother not seeing her child for 20 years? What a stone hearted woman she was!!! Even animals don’t abandon their cubs.

    • @rachaelwelch
      @rachaelwelch Před 11 měsíci

      Well actually animal mother's will abandon their infant. If an infant is weak, small or defective, mothers will instinctively abandon or cull the animal to concentrate their resources on the stronger babies that stand a greater chance of surviving

    • @mmgs1148
      @mmgs1148 Před 10 měsíci +12

      What are you talking about? Never heard of shoebills? Birds let their offspring fight and even kill each other. Panda's when they have more than one cub, mistreat one of them which often leads to the death of the cub from starvation. One species throws cub away while facing the predator so the cub gets eaten in expense for the life of a mother. You definetely know nothing about animals.

    • @flowrepins6663
      @flowrepins6663 Před 8 měsíci +17

      ​@@mmgs1148there are animals that do lots of cruel stuff but pp think of animals as disney creatures

  • @caspence56
    @caspence56 Před 2 lety +3135

    If my husband did this to my child without my knowledge, that would have been the last thing he ever did on this earth. How Rose Kennedy stood by him after she found out about the lobotomy, along with his numerous affairs throughout their marriage, I'll never know.

    • @paperluvxhearts8510
      @paperluvxhearts8510 Před 2 lety +211

      Yes, as a mom nothing is more important than my child. If my husband did that, I will literally kill him,

    • @bigbawlzlebowski8886
      @bigbawlzlebowski8886 Před 2 lety +206

      @@paperluvxhearts8510 it was expected of women to be docile and subservient back then. Leaving him would have left her with nothing because she probably didn't work being a housewife and all

    • @caspence56
      @caspence56 Před 2 lety +294

      @@bigbawlzlebowski8886 Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy, whose father was the Mayor of Boston, came from a very wealthy family. No doubt this was the main reason why Joseph Kennedy was determined to marry her, as it would have given him a boost up the social and political ladder. She was hardly a "penniless housewife."

    • @zezmerelda240
      @zezmerelda240 Před 2 lety +70

      catholic

    • @tinypoolmodelshipyard
      @tinypoolmodelshipyard Před 2 lety +114

      Um don't you remember how catholic that Kennedys where. They didn't live in today society they love a 100 years ago and she was to catholic for divorce or to kill him. Jesus take off your 2021 rose color glasses and understand how different times were and how religious they were. She wasn't going to do either and did what most other women would have done in that time period. There was no tinder for quick rebounds back then...cmon

  • @londonm3161
    @londonm3161 Před 2 lety +3793

    A nurse did the same thing to me when I was born! Only for a few minutes, not a few hours, but she had the same reasoning: the doctor wasn't in yet, the birth needed to be delayed. I was born 70 years after Rosemary, in September of 1998. I suffer from numerous neurological problems now, but live an otherwise normal life as a disabled 23 year old woman. I wish Rosemary could've said the same

    • @MsSwitchblade13
      @MsSwitchblade13 Před 2 lety +556

      Oh dear God!! 1998??? There's no reasoning for that! It doesn't take a doctor to birth a child! Women do it unassisted if they have to and that nurse I'm sure had the basic know-how!
      I'm sorry that happened but glad you can live relatively normal. I hope your mother or you sued that idiot nurse or the hospital.

    • @smiley1960
      @smiley1960 Před 2 lety +57

      I don't understand, we're you stuck in the birth canal? Is that why the nurse wanted the doctor? Sometimes babies do get stuck, it's dangerous and it's what leads to C- sections to get the baby out before more oxygen loss.

    • @londonm3161
      @londonm3161 Před 2 lety +254

      @@smiley1960 no, I crowned before the doctor was in and the nurse pushed against my head the keep me there until a doctor was present. I wasn't stuck, my mom had already had one baby by that point and had given birth vaginally then too. the nurse just insisted that a doctor be the one to deliver the baby

    • @emilyangel._.
      @emilyangel._. Před 2 lety +182

      The same thing happened to me except when I crowned the nurse didn’t push my head in she just kept yelling at my mom to quit pushing cause the doctor wasn’t there yet, I was born in 2003

    • @samanthacook2495
      @samanthacook2495 Před 2 lety +172

      @@londonm3161 Or that was the excuse the evil witch used. I'm so sorry that happened to you and to your mother.

  • @emilyheyokaevans
    @emilyheyokaevans Před rokem +14

    Thank you so much for this lovely tribute to Miss Rosemary. Such a shame how her father mistreated her for the sake of his perfectionist goals. Im glad that the rest of her family saw the worth in her and cared for her ❤️ 💕 💓 Rest in peace Rosemary ❤❤❤

  • @lynette50
    @lynette50 Před rokem +11

    Such a sad story. I'd always read that Joseph Kennedy was a tyrannical individual but I didn't realise just how much. Here in Scotland, I never even knew Rosemary existed. Thank you for this video. I am glad someone gave this poor woman the time and effort to have her story be heard

  • @SterlingKato
    @SterlingKato Před 2 lety +5592

    I actually met her while I was in primary school. We went to deliver homemade Christmas cards to a nursing home, and each one of us were assigned a member of the facility to make a card for, and I got Rosemary Kennedy. I didn't know exactly who she was at the time. I was pretty young.
    We went to the home, sang some Christmas songs for them, and then it came time to deliver our cards to our designated people.
    When I delivered mine, I remember seeing a smiling face on the woman and it warmed my heart. She was shown the card by her aid and she looked at it and smiled at me again. She didn't speak at all, but did make sounds that you could tell were words (perhaps saying "Thank you"?).
    Either way, some years later I learned who it was I gave that card to and honestly, it was really a shock at first but then learning more about her, I'm glad that in some part I could give her a little hint of joy with that little card.
    It's still a memory I remember pretty well.
    :)

    • @Madmarsha
      @Madmarsha Před 2 lety +254

      Oh, wow. And what a nice thing for young children to do to learn how to think about others.

    • @seemedecrazymuse
      @seemedecrazymuse Před 2 lety +43

      Wow! Cool

    • @Dvp1169
      @Dvp1169 Před 2 lety +143

      It’s the little things that we do for others that often make the biggest difference. That is beautiful that you were encouraged to visit a care home as a child. I feel like it’s not done enough these days, and children are more likely to grow indifferent to the elderly and the marginalized.

    • @roseelley4470
      @roseelley4470 Před 2 lety +6

      Where did you live?

    • @roseelley4470
      @roseelley4470 Před 2 lety +20

      Diana Dacks - I totally agree that children are growing up today indifferent to the marginalized.

  • @racheldeselms2515
    @racheldeselms2515 Před 2 lety +1669

    I heard she wasn't really even handicapped, she just couldn't fit the Kennedy mold. She wasn't an A student and was something of a free spirit I guess.

    • @lob1523
      @lob1523 Před 2 lety +251

      Yea I mean even tho it’s photos but it seemed like she wasn’t that bad off before the lobotomy. Such a horrible thing they did to her.

    • @stacyharris4824
      @stacyharris4824 Před 2 lety +138

      Rachel, I am older , and a long time ago I saw a long documentary on how there was never anything wrong with ROSE. Her father felt that she was rebellious and had a lobotomy done. Her father Joe was actually an evil man and made all his money as a boot legger. Gloria Swanson was his life long mistress and he convinced her to allow him to invest her life savings. He promptly stole all of it. But what he did to Rosemary was down right evil ; all because he felt he couldn't control her.

    • @mikkey246
      @mikkey246 Před 2 lety +12

      Wtf, that is scary asf

    • @susannaCdonovan23
      @susannaCdonovan23 Před 2 lety +29

      Not entirely true. She was epileptic. She had a slowness, but unless you read it from Rose I wouldn't believe the drivel

    • @WholeHeartily
      @WholeHeartily Před 2 lety +16

      Yeahhhh… sounds more like she just may have been on the spectrum

  • @nikkiej.5875
    @nikkiej.5875 Před 2 lety +18

    It's so sad to see that the father was embarrassed of her because she was different than her siblings. Enough to hide her in a mental hospital and undergo a controversial procedure without the family knowing. It's so messed up and I felt so bad for her. I like that after their father's passing, they didn't hesitate to see her. They didn't care because she was still their sister and family.

  • @Liz-hz6dd
    @Liz-hz6dd Před rokem +35

    This is just heart breaking. My daughter was deprived of oxygen at birth which caused her to be diagnosed with severe non-verbal autism. She’s 6 now and still can’t talk and is still in nappies. And do you know what we do with her?………. Love her with every ounce of our being because she is perfect the way she is.

    • @Izzylovesdinos
      @Izzylovesdinos Před rokem +2

      I had no clue that being deprived of oxygen at birth can cause autism, I thought it was just a brain thing. /gen

    • @amelia8127
      @amelia8127 Před rokem +8

      autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder and that affects how your nervous system including brain develops and is not caused by oxygen deprivation at birth. the cause of autism isn't known but it's generally known that because it's a neurodevelopmental disorder it isn't caused by one off events and rather a mix of genetics and environmental factors :)

    • @Izzylovesdinos
      @Izzylovesdinos Před rokem +1

      @@amelia8127 sorry I was just curious but does that mean autism is just something that happens as soon as the brain is formed and is like how the brain is coded or like after a kid is born and the outside world makes the brain autistic? I’m trying to learn lots because I’m trying to get a diagnosis and there’s still lots I don’t know /gen

    • @amelia8127
      @amelia8127 Před rokem +4

      @@Izzylovesdinos no worries, there's a lot of misconceptions about asd. There's not much known about what actually causes autism/ autistic people's brains to develope differently, but ultimately people with ASD have brains that function a little differently. While it's not an inherently negative thing, it's 'the outside world' which causes difficulties for people with ASD :) good luck with the diagnosis, it's a difficult process but to me it was very worth it

    • @Izzylovesdinos
      @Izzylovesdinos Před rokem +1

      @@amelia8127 thank you!

  • @themoreyouknow3523
    @themoreyouknow3523 Před 2 lety +2221

    What they did to her was the very definition of inhumane it makes my blood boil just thinking about it.

    • @emw5
      @emw5 Před 2 lety +1

      $FREEROSEMARY

    • @kimmycasts2811
      @kimmycasts2811 Před 2 lety

      I feel you

    • @genenewallace6868
      @genenewallace6868 Před 2 lety +4

      That's why his family was cursed

    • @sbh2888
      @sbh2888 Před 2 lety +8

      I didn’t know about the loss of oxygen at birth. I had just heard that she was flirty and promiscuous which was a huge no-no at the time. For women that is. Joe had his mistresses at his house, and no disrespect, but we all know what JFK and Robert were like too. No lobotomies for them however…

    • @farrellmcnulty909
      @farrellmcnulty909 Před rokem +1

      @@sbh2888 I remember this family photo in which Rosemary struck a glamor pose. She knew she was beautiful, vivacious,and that she could possibly use it to her advantage. I see later photos of the Kennedy women and imagine her with them. The front cover of a book called "The Kennedy Women" showed all the sisters sitting in a row striking the same pose for the camera, but Jackie was the only one who posed differently. Imagine Rosemary being able to pose for that photo. She would have wiped Jackie clear out of the way.

  • @sandrabenson4792
    @sandrabenson4792 Před 2 lety +3018

    I have probably read every book about Rosemary Kennedy. Though it was so sad, her brother's brought into law about allowing people with mental issues to live in their homes with their families and not be institutionalized. Rosemary's sacrifice and having to deal with such a deranged father also freed many others who were locked away in nursing homes. Because of what her father did to her, it became public knowledge after her father's death and many laws were written and made effective for the safety of people with mental health issues. Thank you Rosemary. If not for you, I may be one of those people that would have been locked up and institutionalized by the old standards. You had done so much for the mental health community. (As well as her brother, JFK) It's just so sad.

    • @jayleemittens9858
      @jayleemittens9858 Před 2 lety +116

      It wasn't a sacrifice. A sacrifice is done with permission

    • @tomdavis3038
      @tomdavis3038 Před 2 lety +23

      The Kennedy’s are a mental institution that somehow keeps getting elected.

    • @arcious60
      @arcious60 Před 2 lety +21

      I hate special Ed but it's better than a lobotomy.

    • @hectorsmommy1717
      @hectorsmommy1717 Před 2 lety +56

      So many positives done by her siblings but the most significant was her brother Ted creating and getting the Americans with Disabilities Act through congress. The ADA is all encompassing, whether the disabilities are mental or physical, and many people's lives are better because of it. The most significant is requiring employers to make "reasonable accommodations" for disabled employees and not being able to fire them because of a disability.

    • @hectorsmommy1717
      @hectorsmommy1717 Před 2 lety +9

      @Brp 549 Every person's situation is different but proving discrimination over a firing isn't as hard as many people think it is. Generally there is a pattern leading up to it and if the employee documents well it can be proven. There are many attorneys who specialize in ADA cases and work on contingency so you don't need money to hire one.
      My documentation was so good that they settled out of court and I actually wrote most of the complaint and responses myself. My attorney only needed 15 minutes to edit and be with me for the hearing. We settled and she said my case was so easy she would just bill me for her time which came to a total of $600.

  • @khfan4life365
    @khfan4life365 Před 2 lety +13

    I’m glad that her siblings immediately went to her after their father died and involved her in the family again.

  • @joanndelise4834
    @joanndelise4834 Před rokem +12

    How awful what was done to Rosemary. Her father was a terrible person. I'm glad her family was able to see her later in life. They loved her.

  • @deidre1965
    @deidre1965 Před 2 lety +2321

    As a mother of a special needs adult child... this is horrifying! I'm blessed to be my daughter's mother. How could a father do that to his child?

    • @lighthouselaura4324
      @lighthouselaura4324 Před 2 lety +14

      It was the norm to institutionalize special needs the.

    • @rickyparrilla2426
      @rickyparrilla2426 Před 2 lety +37

      Thank you. There is no excuse for what he did and her brothers & sisters should have fought harder for there sister since she couldn't.

    • @bailey7792
      @bailey7792 Před 2 lety +38

      I mean.. were really expecting people who were just BARELY out of the Victorian Era, to have the ethics, morals, and medical information that we have today? Like come on lol.. the way we think today, was not the norm for people back then. Yes its sad what happened to her.. but you can't honestly expect that people back then, should've behaved how we do today.

    • @user-yc7qe5jc8w
      @user-yc7qe5jc8w Před 2 lety +9

      Monster

    • @user-yc7qe5jc8w
      @user-yc7qe5jc8w Před 2 lety +52

      @@bailey7792 being humane is not tied to a time in history, no excuse.....

  • @WouldntULikeToKnow.
    @WouldntULikeToKnow. Před 2 lety +702

    Her father thought power, influence, and reputation were more important than his daughter. What a horrible human.

  • @mariciamariani2468
    @mariciamariani2468 Před rokem +3

    Holding that baby inside her Mother, definitely caused Rosemary’s condition. Poor woman

  • @susanross1651
    @susanross1651 Před rokem +5

    What a terrible story, poor poor woman & what an evil father.

  • @tyishaariel
    @tyishaariel Před 2 lety +2228

    I’m in tears 😭.. my heart goes out to Rosemary. She was beautiful & didn’t deserve to spend all those years alone and in the shadows. This is a very sad story.

    • @sarai373
      @sarai373 Před 2 lety +31

      This made me cry as well. The thing is so many children of the wealthy who were born with some challenge back in those days were sometimes banished away from the family in a secret room in their house or sent away. The first time I read that I cried like a baby for all those children. Research it. In fact no don't research it. It's depressing. Just pray for their precious little souls.

    • @xyz7572
      @xyz7572 Před 2 lety +20

      A bit poorly worded, sounds a bit like you mean the reason she didn’t deserve it was because she was pretty. She wouldn’t have deserved it even if she was really ugly.

    • @kimberleelovett9377
      @kimberleelovett9377 Před 2 lety +6

      Indeed, very sad. Bless precious heart.

    • @judylloyd7901
      @judylloyd7901 Před 2 lety +17

      The sad thing about the story is that it all would have been prevented from the start if the nurse had not pushed the baby's head back into the birth canal for TWO HOURS!!!!

    • @tomdavis3038
      @tomdavis3038 Před 2 lety +1

      Cry me a River. What do all the tears do? Noting

  • @brendabailey4319
    @brendabailey4319 Před 2 lety +729

    Who the hell pushes a baby back in when it's being born ! It's just stupid

    • @nancyhopple8138
      @nancyhopple8138 Před 2 lety +37

      Don't you wonder what type of medical personnel would do this ? See what money can do for you if you are evil at heart.

    • @brendabailey4319
      @brendabailey4319 Před 2 lety +18

      @@nancyhopple8138 Yes I hear you There is much evil in the world 😢

    • @fania_mania
      @fania_mania Před 2 lety +15

      Sadly It’s still done…

    • @joywebster2678
      @joywebster2678 Před 2 lety +7

      @@nancyhopple8138 medical personnel? They did it to wait for the doctor. Likely told to stop by a hospital worker, midwife or student doctor. Back then the one bigwig hospital doctor had prestige and power. He was one and the nuns in a catholic hospital ran the wards.

    • @noradiaz7752
      @noradiaz7752 Před 2 lety +7

      Only crazy evil person w.no heart women's back in days had.no say has to do what husband said.

  • @carpediem.9
    @carpediem.9 Před rokem +5

    The father basically destroyed his daughter's life ... then lived happily without ever seeing her or caring ... disgusting...

    • @jasong6789
      @jasong6789 Před 10 měsíci +1

      Joe Kennedy sr suffered a stroke in 1961 that left his right side paralyzed that was his karma

  • @457B1B1
    @457B1B1 Před 2 lety +17

    Such a heartbreaking story, and to think about the countless people who’s undocumented lives were also derailed cause of this “procedure”. I had never heard of this story until today, thankful I was brought up where at least a handful of doctors know there’s not a quick fix to everything and can be held accountable for the most part

  • @_squarecube
    @_squarecube Před 2 lety +1213

    she was only 23? she was so beautiful and could have had a wonderful life if they just let her stay the way she was. such a tragedy for that young woman.

    • @angeliquedevosd416
      @angeliquedevosd416 Před 2 lety +60

      It's the whole thing. The Kennedy' tragedy. They all died from killed or accidents with many questions unanswered. Was all these tragic deaths caused by KARMA?

    • @Hlirving15
      @Hlirving15 Před 2 lety +34

      I'm beginning to believe it's karma.

    • @tessajones9393
      @tessajones9393 Před 2 lety +17

      @@angeliquedevosd416 no, not karma. They just take risks and do whatever they want because of who they are. Mass egos

    • @karinasarah_24
      @karinasarah_24 Před 2 lety +8

      I'm beginning to think the father was responsible for all their tragic deaths.

    • @katesun2957
      @katesun2957 Před 2 lety +15

      What a monster father, who also encourged his sons to seduce as many women as possible, to show their manliness.

  • @katemaloney4296
    @katemaloney4296 Před 2 lety +2341

    Kathleen Kennedy had thoroughly investigated the lobotomy procedure and was appalled at what she found. In fact t, she told Joe Sr, "No, Daddy. This is not what we want for our Rosie." I am sure Kick had an inkling as to what her father had done and that was the catalyst to her staying behind and marrying Protestant Marquis William Cavendish. I also think Rosemary helped Kick find that rebellious side--that unfortunately led to her death a couple of years later.
    I do know that when Rose found out what had occurred to her beloved daughter (Rosemary was actually Rose Marie Jr, being named after her mother) she unleashed hell on Joe and refused to sleep with him ever again. Her hate and disdain for Joe went so deep that, despite being in the same room while Joe was having a stroke, she went out and played a few holes of golf--waiting two hours to call for help. The stroke was so severe that Joe lost the ability to move freely and communicate normal speech. It is said that she took wicked delight in tending to her invalid husband. She made him suffer the way her namesake and the family had because of his narcissism.
    I like to think there is a special place in Hell for Joe Kennedy Sr.

    • @user-yd4nk4lm6s
      @user-yd4nk4lm6s Před 2 lety +195

      That is all untrue. You ought to read Kate Larson's book on Rosemary. Her mother denied knowledge of the lobotomy years later. She did, however, send Rosemary away to various schools without informing them of her disability. One school has documented that Rosemary was dropped off with an understanding that she would support teachers! They found that she was not mentally her age and unable to keep up. Her mother refused their calls. She dumped her there and travelled from spa to spa in the meantime. JFK even called his mother a terrible person and she included this in her own book. She was evil. She definitely knew but felt great shame in later years.

    • @fidelnenas8390
      @fidelnenas8390 Před 2 lety +99

      @@user-yd4nk4lm6s all the schools that she attended were before she had the lobotomy. Her father had the procedure done when she was in her early twenties after the family returned to the United States from Joe completing his Ambassadorship to the Court of St James in England. After the Lobotomy Joe, found a catholic parish where he had a little house built for his daughter at St. Colette and had nuns take care of her until the day she died

    • @user-yd4nk4lm6s
      @user-yd4nk4lm6s Před 2 lety +16

      @@fidelnenas8390 Yes, I'd hope that people would be able to infer that given the teachers finding out gradually that Rosemary was not her mental age.

    • @tessmolloy2388
      @tessmolloy2388 Před 2 lety +21

      There most certainly is a special place in hell for that man.

    • @angelacarleton9575
      @angelacarleton9575 Před 2 lety +36

      I'm glad to know one Kennedy did speak up! I am appalled by this and stupid Rose didn't have the common sense to say "no!" I will continue to give birth and say. "don't tell me something against the law of what is right." I had just come out of the operation for a ruptured ovary and when the doctor spoke to me I got nervous by what he saw were my insides were beautiful? I could just see that SOB telling me to remove something from inside that my dear people is what he said next that chilled me to the bone. He tried to call me to ask me two stupid questions first how old I was and second if I was married? He couldn't get in touch with me for about a week since I spent one week recuperating at my mother's place. I got the message to call back and he ask those questions which he suggested I have a hysterectomy? I said, to him I may be 30 years old and single but I planned to get married and have children- then I hung up the phone! I spoke to another doctor who said I would not suggest such "SURGERY" and said there was not the reason for it. Luckily I went by my gut instincts or that I would not be able to have the family I wanted all along. Be ever careful what surgeons or doctors tell you get a 2nd opinion. Never accept what they say because they are so eager to cut you open and in my "gut instinct" he was very eager to do his worse without any true reasons at all.

  • @aimeeseattle
    @aimeeseattle Před rokem +20

    I can’t believe what her father did to her, even didn’t tell the mother or Rosemary. I had to stop the vid at 9:12 because I broke down in tears. My 2 of 4 sons have autism, my youngest more severe. I’m heartbroken from Rosemary’s story. 🙁

  • @bonniemagpie9960
    @bonniemagpie9960 Před 2 lety +7

    Mrs Rose Kennedy was aware of the idea of labotomy because there is a letter where she had written to her other daughter Kit, asking about the potential positive outcomes for it and Kit wrote back advising against it. The doctor who performed this fail upon Rose was ordered not to perform any more surgeries in the late sixties due to other disasters which he did to people.

  • @xpxnchyx
    @xpxnchyx Před 2 lety +845

    Disgusting what was done to her, but the fact that her siblings stuck by her after what her father did to her is really heartwarming. I can’t imagine how horrifying it was for her family to see what happened to her, let alone how traumatizing it must have been for Rosemary

    • @pb4ugo19
      @pb4ugo19 Před 2 lety +15

      I mean they worshipped their father. & judging by Ted Kennedys book, they didn't blame him at all for what happened to Rosemary.

    • @basbleupeaunoire
      @basbleupeaunoire Před 2 lety +19

      @@pb4ugo19 Children tend to be forgiving to their parents (and vice versa). The Kennedy kids could be angry and saddened by what their father did to Rose and still admire him. Plus, I don't think anyone expects the Kennedy kids to air the hard feelings they have about their father.

    • @pb4ugo19
      @pb4ugo19 Před 2 lety +17

      @@basbleupeaunoire you could be right, but idk aside from Eunice (& later on Ted), it didn't seem that any of them really cared much. Even when it was revealed, Bobby & Jfk didn't make much of an effort with her. I appreciate the Kennedy accomplishments for this country, but I get the sense that that family was very cold & f**ked up behind closed doors.

    • @marylougeorge9890
      @marylougeorge9890 Před rokem +8

      What gets me is they had All the money to have Full-time care for her. She didn't Have to leave home!

    • @basbleupeaunoire
      @basbleupeaunoire Před rokem +2

      ​@@marylougeorge9890 The father was ashamed of her and probably himself, too.

  • @margaretandrade8367
    @margaretandrade8367 Před 2 lety +3470

    She was the most beautiful daughter amongst her sisters.

  • @BethBurns68
    @BethBurns68 Před rokem +5

    I've known of Rosemary's story and how tragic her life was...you did such a fine job o detailing the events of her life with compassion.

  • @yeshazion4098
    @yeshazion4098 Před rokem +8

    SO sad. All I can think is that in some odd way Rosemary helped handicapped kids to this day thru her sister.

  • @okaymea
    @okaymea Před 2 lety +882

    This is so sad, she could've thrived had they allowed her to live in London. I feel so bad for her. She was so beautiful

    • @rucianapollard4057
      @rucianapollard4057 Před 2 lety +12

      Rosemary had to leave London, because of WW2, her parents allowed her to stay there as long as it was safe. This is why Rosemary and her dad were the last of the family to leave London before the threat of war mounted.

    • @choughed3072
      @choughed3072 Před 2 lety +27

      @@rucianapollard4057 well she probably would of been ok if daddy Kennedy didn't say Britain was going to lose the war because he sympathised with the Nazis.

    • @emapheonix
      @emapheonix Před 2 lety

      I think it was within their best interests to leave her there because her father wouldn't have to deal with her that way

  • @jenalba1791
    @jenalba1791 Před 2 lety +1363

    What they did to her is the start of the Kennedy's Curse

  • @jadehei538
    @jadehei538 Před 8 měsíci +4

    The nurse telling a woman in labor to hold the child in is unbelievable! What the hell was she thinking? Poor Rosemary could've had a normal life. Even after having developmental problems she could've had a wonderful life if her father had had more empathy towards his daughter. The way he put her away after the lobotomy further proves, he actually cared much more about how his family looks, than their wellness.

  • @alynsak
    @alynsak Před rokem +7

    I heard about this a while ago. It’s absolutely horrific. They only did that to her because they couldn’t reign her in and make her act the way they wanted. She could have had a full life, but they took any hope of that away from her for no reason. The nurse who made her mother deprive her of oxygen for so long effective gong her permanent issues that she shouldn’t have had should not have been a nurse. I don’t understand why the nurse either didn’t want to or wasn’t allowed to deliver rosemary. My mom was pregnant with my younger brother when the nurse told her to not deliver him until the doctor came. The nurse was rude and literally told her not to push or let him out yet. He ended up coming out so fast that he caused my mom massive internal bleeding and you could see on his head where he had hit her pelvis on the inside. I don’t get why people still insist on giving women horrible advice when birthing considering it can be so dangerous.

  • @fabiwilliams4644
    @fabiwilliams4644 Před 2 lety +569

    Geez imagine making a baby suffer like that, forcing her not to be born for no logical reason, causing her brain damage & then putting her through such a dangerous operation. They have a lot to answer for

    • @user-yd4nk4lm6s
      @user-yd4nk4lm6s Před 2 lety +21

      They didn't know any better. Rose was instructed to do this by the nurse. The doctor is at fault because he wanted to be there to deliver for profit. Read Larson's book on Rosemary. These were different times with little understanding.

    • @davidhutchinson7888
      @davidhutchinson7888 Před 2 lety +8

      They won't answer for shit because they're last name is Kennedy

    • @Imissyoulou
      @Imissyoulou Před 2 lety +2

      @@user-yd4nk4lm6s I read the book, however, a lot of people on this site hasn't. That is why their comments are so far off.

  • @tricksfollies9549
    @tricksfollies9549 Před 2 lety +1593

    As someone who grew up with ADHD, I’m very thankful I grew up in a time where people were more understanding towards these things.

    • @boymeetworlf3433
      @boymeetworlf3433 Před 2 lety +23

      SAME

    • @ReiverGrad14
      @ReiverGrad14 Před 2 lety +1

      Amen

    • @christophg.6339
      @christophg.6339 Před 2 lety +5

      I think I would ended up with the military because of ADHD. A short lived life, but at least not one as the family disappointment.

    • @FiveOClockTea
      @FiveOClockTea Před 2 lety +8

      Same.
      Though I still had some teachers who told my parents ADHD was made up...

    • @oooh19
      @oooh19 Před 2 lety

      many people still aren't as accepting or understanding as they think! society is still racist, sexist, etc

  • @mayday6916
    @mayday6916 Před 4 měsíci +2

    What is this idea about trying to delay a birth??? What a stupid and dangerous idea. They even KNEW about the risk of causing permanent brain damage, and still made the mother do it. Poor Rosemary. As for her father... I guess he was partly a product of the times he lived in. I wonder what or who made him become so completely free of empathy and understanding. What a nightmare.

  • @maryhlad7501
    @maryhlad7501 Před 5 měsíci +1

    I’m very grateful to Mrs. Kennedy-Shriver for having founded the Special Olympics. I participated in my first Special Olympics one year, competing in bowling, and won a 3rd Place ribbon.

  • @Violetbunnyfish
    @Violetbunnyfish Před 2 lety +294

    The lobotomy also made her lose control over her bowels permanently. It was a ridiculously cruel thing to do to anyone.

    • @lighthouselaura4324
      @lighthouselaura4324 Před 2 lety +14

      It is cruel; but at the time, the lobotomy was new technology/treatment. He trusted his doctors & they thought it might "cure" her. It was like the blindly medication of children for adhd- when in reality they are normal kids. That just needed structure, balanced diet & attention. Plus doping kids from k5 on & not giving them life skills has consequences we have yet to discover.

    • @stacyrussell460
      @stacyrussell460 Před 2 lety +11

      @@lighthouselaura4324 agreed. My nephew was one of those labeled "ADHD & difficult to teach" early on in school. Yes, he had learning difficulties. Doctors just bounced him from one medication cocktail to another. He has a high school diploma, but can barely read or write. No Child Left Behind for him meant he was just pushed thru the school system so they wouldn't have to deal with him anymore. Sad. He's now an adult, married with two young children. He works minimum wage jobs & barely scrapes by, but he's doing his best. My sister raised him primarily by herself bc his father couldn't be bothered 99% of the time (he didn't want to deal with a son who wasn't perfect). My sister had no idea at the time what she was agreeing to with all those different medications. She truly believed doctors were helping her boy. Instead they made an already difficult situation worse.

    • @PrSndreLrsn
      @PrSndreLrsn Před 2 lety +1

      @@lighthouselaura4324 and may he burn forever in hell what a swine of a father!

    • @basbleupeaunoire
      @basbleupeaunoire Před 2 lety

      @@lighthouselaura4324 I get your larger point, that many people were convinced that it was effective, but prescriptions are not the same as poking around in someone's brain with a sharp object. Joe Sr. hid the planned procedure for a reason.

    • @kimberlyelliott7933
      @kimberlyelliott7933 Před 2 lety +1

      😔

  • @cristynlane6507
    @cristynlane6507 Před 2 lety +747

    She saved many disabled people from suffering the same fate. God bless her soul.

    • @cristynlane6507
      @cristynlane6507 Před 2 lety +10

      @Opal Allen So awful, I am so sorry to anyone who would be given that operation.

  • @nat5072
    @nat5072 Před 2 lety +5

    This brought tears to my eyes! As the mother of a child with a disability, my heart breaks for her.

  • @madisonlaster6824
    @madisonlaster6824 Před 2 lety +5

    There’s always going to be that sibling bond that absolutely no one can break it.

  • @yaqbulyakkerbat4190
    @yaqbulyakkerbat4190 Před 2 lety +967

    The operation didn't go "tragically wrong".
    There was never any good that could come of it!
    The fact people were psychotic enough to think ramming a rail spike into a person's skull was a good idea a mere 40 years ago is mortifying.
    It was just Trepanning with a different label. Possibly worse!

    • @gtthepesprofessor1986
      @gtthepesprofessor1986 Před 2 lety +45

      Exactly. A medieval way of torture if you ask me!

    • @awg7068
      @awg7068 Před 2 lety +38

      It went tragically right They were no doubt ordered to press on until she lost the ability to speak. This way, she couldn’t say anything embarrassing that Joe would find confronting about his ‘perfect genes’.

    • @joncampos5551
      @joncampos5551 Před 2 lety +1

      Trepanning?

    • @CircleThinker
      @CircleThinker Před 2 lety +10

      @@joncampos5551 Drilling a hole into the skull to relieve pressure on the brain - one of the earliest known instances of surgery (they have found ancient skulls with trepanning holes that have started closing over, meaning that the person survived the procedure). It's still done today in extreme cases of brain swelling.

    • @peekiethedogpeekie1080
      @peekiethedogpeekie1080 Před 2 lety +2

      No drilling into the skull... the procedure was done through the eye socket while the patient was awake?

  • @OldRaver
    @OldRaver Před 2 lety +635

    Apart from my horror hearing of a nurse forcing a baby back into the birth canal by pushing on it’s head for two hours😱🤬... just IMAGINE the AGONY for the mother to endure that?
    Any woman who has given birth naturally can tell you how painful that would be!
    Good Lord it was on 1918, you’d think they’d have understood about oxygen depravation by then?? Obviously not.
    That poor poor girl. Her father should have left her in England where she could have lived a happy life. 💔

    • @kimberlyelliott7933
      @kimberlyelliott7933 Před 2 lety +6

      💔💔💔

    • @Maki-00
      @Maki-00 Před 2 lety +57

      Yeah, he could have just left her there to thrive since he didn’t seem to really give a shit about her anyway.

    • @sophiemarie7125
      @sophiemarie7125 Před 2 lety +2

      All women give birth naturally

    • @Andy.G8
      @Andy.G8 Před rokem +38

      @@sophiemarie7125 What the hell is your point?

    • @veravaladez1525
      @veravaladez1525 Před rokem +16

      Rose Kennedy shouldn't have listened to the nurse and she should have pushed down to have the baby!!

  • @alefeb1
    @alefeb1 Před rokem +5

    What an evil and selfish father… if you can even call him that. He destroyed his daughter for his pride.

  • @lovingmayberry307
    @lovingmayberry307 Před rokem +8

    I'd never heard this story before.
    What an SOB Joe Sr was!
    RIP Rosemary 💙

  • @sandrad7633
    @sandrad7633 Před 2 lety +422

    I have an intellectually disabled 23 year old, 6 foot 3 son who functions at the level of a three year old. He is an absolute joy. This story is absolutely stomach churning. However, the Special Olympics are fabulous and my son loves attending it.

    • @MickeyMallone.
      @MickeyMallone. Před rokem +18

      I love filling out forms for the Special Olympics for our patients; they've done so much to make the world see that cognitive disabilities don't mean lack of enjoyment in things!

    • @sherrywalton4848
      @sherrywalton4848 Před rokem +10

      God Bless You n your son.
      Sandra.

    • @Leemu786
      @Leemu786 Před rokem +16

      Sandra I transport Special needs children to Specialized school. Most of them are non verbal. I treat them like I treat my children. I talk and sing to them. You can see their expressions and know they are engaged. I think only lucky people are blessed with these children.

    • @canailleism
      @canailleism Před rokem +4

      ❤❤❤

    • @SoaringTrumpet
      @SoaringTrumpet Před rokem +3

      ❤❤❤

  • @oldcollegecoed
    @oldcollegecoed Před 2 lety +232

    The real tragedy was Rosemary wasn’t severely mentally handicapped. Today, she would be considered to be a slow learner and placed in special education classes. But compared to the rest of the children who were raised in a very competitive environment which demanded perfection, her very slight handicap appeared much worse. Even then, despite not having any special education, she was a perfect, well-behaved child who tried very hard to make her parents proud. Of course, once she hit her teens and realized her brothers and sisters were allowed to do a lot more than she was, she reacted like any teenager would, and THAT was unacceptable. Instead of blaming her outbursts on puberty and typical teenage anger, her father insisted her mental faculties were failing and she was only going to get worse. Plus, he was a avid supporter of eugenics and Hitler’s plan to eliminate “useless eaters:” the mentally & physically disabled, alcoholics, chronically unemployed, drug addicts, homosexuals, etc. So despite her glowing report cards from her private schools, he arranged for the lobotomy, which not only failed to improve her handicap, it made it far worse. A beautiful, articulate, loving, sweet young woman became a complete invalid with the mental capacity of a 2 yr old! Once it was apparent Rosemary was permanently damaged, Joe lied to everyone about her absence, and none of Rosemary’s siblings were allowed to see her for decades….JFK didn’t see her until 1958 & was horrified by what she’d been reduced to. Her mother waited 20 years to see her and Rosemary “recoiled” upon recognizing her!
    Joseph Kennedy destroyed his adoring daughter for one reason, and that was to protect himself and his family from being viewed as having weak genes! Despicable!

  • @mollyb4541
    @mollyb4541 Před rokem +3

    How sad. No mother in labor should be forced to pause her delivery. Same happened to me. My doctor was going to be at the hospital in 30 minutes. I didn’t wait. They grabbed a Dr checking on one of their patients and he delivered my son. Very sad for Rosemary.

  • @pennyfields491
    @pennyfields491 Před 2 lety

    Love your channel...you are very well spoken and the stories are extremely well presented!

  • @blueviolets52
    @blueviolets52 Před 2 lety +219

    I don't think her parents were worried about her roaming the streets bc they were concerned for her safety...I think they were embarrassed that she was wandering around in public. Such a sad story, I hope she found some peace.

    • @Celisar1
      @Celisar1 Před rokem +20

      The father was afraid she would become sexually active, maybe get pregnant, and bring shame to the family name.
      That’s why he crippled her.

    • @odapunkt
      @odapunkt Před 11 měsíci +5

      Absolutely

  • @opaulamorgan4265
    @opaulamorgan4265 Před 2 lety +949

    What a beautiful girl she was, the most beautiful of all the Kennedy women. Heartbreaking what was done to her.

    • @clv4556
      @clv4556 Před 2 lety +50

      The operation was horrifying she was tough to get that far along! Joseph Sr was a monster sand I blame the mother too it was not her first pregnancy. What a trip

    • @Undefinedde
      @Undefinedde Před 2 lety

      What was the lobotomy like

  • @mikemanjo2458
    @mikemanjo2458 Před rokem

    Great episode. Thank you for sharing this story with us.

  • @ivanfranco2363
    @ivanfranco2363 Před rokem

    You go so into the specific details of these cases that I feel the urge to support you on patreon to help you continue making these videos.

  • @kristinebailey6554
    @kristinebailey6554 Před 2 lety +506

    One detail you leave out, is that midwives and nurses at that time were practically forced to delay a birth until an MD arrived, as the MD earned 125.00 on average for a delivery. If the baby arrived before the MD he got almost nothing in pay.

    • @Sunflower-sh6ys
      @Sunflower-sh6ys Před 2 lety +55

      I was looking for a comment like yours, because I heard about this payment arrangement too. Thanks for mentioning it.

    • @cindynewcomb7139
      @cindynewcomb7139 Před 2 lety +35

      Nursing was definitely not the same way back then!

    • @mellisafrancis8783
      @mellisafrancis8783 Před 2 lety +19

      Whatever who cares of about the MD it's about the baby smg

    • @gemoftheocean
      @gemoftheocean Před 2 lety +12

      Laughably WRONG. I was born in 1956, and delivered by a doctor. Delivery charge. $10 dollars. The entire bill for everything, including 4 days in the hospital was, $75. And some odd cents. No way in hades was a home delivery well over $100 in 1918.

    • @elainaveasey5831
      @elainaveasey5831 Před 2 lety +25

      @@gemoftheocean for one of the most wealthy and influential political families??? Even though they weren’t as famous yet, they were still very wealthy in their area. I’m sure that the Kardashian babies cost far more than another birth in the exact same hospital on the exact same day because they pay for the celebrity treatment. Perhaps the Kennedys did the same.

  • @AS-pn5zl
    @AS-pn5zl Před 2 lety +338

    Her dad never saw her again because he was guilty. How could he look her in the face.

    • @teresarivasugaz2313
      @teresarivasugaz2313 Před 2 lety +38

      I think he didn't feel any guilt, it was more of his inflated ego being hurt. He wouldn't accept his supposed "brilliance" failed. He wouldn't accept he was wrong. If there's in fact an afterlife, I'd like to think he'll be forever seething because nowadays people remember him for being a n4zi and for what he did to his wonderful daughter. "Perfect family"? Hell naw.

    • @lelrica6883
      @lelrica6883 Před 2 lety +2

      @@teresarivasugaz2313 that reminds me, the nazis did that to disabled Germans. If you weren’t their walking talking image of perfection in nazi Germany, you were killed or hidden too.

    • @YAH-1
      @YAH-1 Před 2 lety +1

      @@teresarivasugaz2313 It is an afterlife go sho, and Joe is in Hell 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @victorcontreras9138
    @victorcontreras9138 Před rokem +3

    Good, factual video! I had heard of this hidden sister but didn't know much in detail until now. It's sad that her condition was probably due to careless people and could have been prevented. How sad.

  • @med6399
    @med6399 Před 14 dny +1

    Well presented! Thank you!🌟🌟🌟😎😎😎 (I have always been interested in her story?)

  • @cw4608
    @cw4608 Před 2 lety +277

    “Worried about her disability becoming public knowledge…” That is so sad, she was their precious daughter. Can’t have her around to tarnish the Kennedy name.

    • @Sadimal
      @Sadimal Před 2 lety +10

      Sadly, this was quite common in influential families. Queen Elizabeth II's cousins were hidden away in an asylum in the 1940s.
      It was even more common in the 1800s when just existing meant a woman could be locked away in an asylum.

    • @yadiracamacho499
      @yadiracamacho499 Před 2 lety +2

      For powerful families that relied on alliances through marriage, being seen as having "bad genes" was a devastating. Hiding things that would make difficult for their children to marry into the right families was deemed necessary.

  • @Yolduranduran
    @Yolduranduran Před 2 lety +326

    California passes The Lanternman Act due to the Kennedys. This act ensures that developmentally disabled people receive services that allow them to live as independently as possible and ensure that their rights are respected.

    • @Yolduranduran
      @Yolduranduran Před 2 lety +5

      @Rob Roy yes you are right. We struggle a lot with ridiculous legislation. But again we also offer many services to the needy. My mother was able to receive a liver transplant and the best care in the country due to this. California is very complex.

    • @marienewton164
      @marienewton164 Před 2 lety

      @Rob Roy je

  • @alyssascott1601
    @alyssascott1601 Před 2 měsíci +2

    This is sooo sad she was unique in her own way!!! Not everyone is the same!! She was beautiful!!!! 🥺 Her father was an absolute monster!!

  • @barbara3358
    @barbara3358 Před rokem

    Well done. Everyone should be required to see this!

  • @applesandpears
    @applesandpears Před 2 lety +622

    “Rosemary taught us the worth of every human being”. That’s more disturbing than anything that happened to her.

    • @devilovesdevil
      @devilovesdevil Před 2 lety +59

      Right the implications behind that is just wrong

    • @IlikepurpleXP
      @IlikepurpleXP Před 2 lety +37

      Yep that stood out to me the most..

    • @deecee4644
      @deecee4644 Před 2 lety +10

      @@IlikepurpleXP What stood out to me was who had the balls to even say it - Ted Kennedy. What did that scumbag know about human worth?

    • @basbleupeaunoire
      @basbleupeaunoire Před 2 lety +5

      That's not chilling. They were young in an era when mental disability and illness were terribly misunderstood. They had an experience that few people shared, and could compare themselves to how terribly their father treated Rose.

    • @lizc6393
      @lizc6393 Před 2 lety

      @@devilovesdevil I'm having a really slow moment, but what is the implication here?

  • @debbiepugh2055
    @debbiepugh2055 Před 3 lety +946

    This is so tragic they could of helped their daughter and others instead they hid her away 😢 💔

    • @larryyeadeke2953
      @larryyeadeke2953 Před 2 lety +25

      Not they, that pos Joe. Although her brothers and sister could have looked into it more. I mean the girl disappeared for years.

    • @aj-sz8mu
      @aj-sz8mu Před 2 lety +10

      @@larryyeadeke2953 it IS they then. They eventually did find out, so pretty sure it could have been much much much earlier. The family collective thought they didnt need her in their life all those decades. And they didnt. All that they regretted was the lobotomy, not sending her away. Thus they're part of the blame.

    • @Randomyoutubecommenter
      @Randomyoutubecommenter Před 2 lety +13

      They had to keep the perfect bloodline image

    • @gracie3174
      @gracie3174 Před 2 lety +6

      That’s what Kennedy’s do…they hide their sins….but God knows every one of them.

    • @covertLLC
      @covertLLC Před 2 lety +4

      Yeah they *could've* ... Could + have = could've not could of....

  • @pathuff9511
    @pathuff9511 Před 2 lety

    Excellent coverage.

  • @danie8106
    @danie8106 Před 10 měsíci +7

    I feel so sorry for her. From the birth to the lobotomy..how she couldn't keep up with her siblings and just wanted to live and enjoy life but couldn't. Then to grow to an old woman knowing that you were mistreated..your dad just threw you away and just never bothered to check on you again. That's a horrible life. God I feel so sorry for her. May she rest in peace. Smh.

  • @proudatheist2042
    @proudatheist2042 Před 2 lety +202

    I read a biography about Rosemary Kennedy several years ago. It was devastatingly heartbreaking. I cried while reading it. It was interesting that the author states that Rosemary's difficulties inspired her siblings and their children to use their power to create positive changes in society.

  • @tinastagg6258
    @tinastagg6258 Před 2 lety +690

    “Let me win - but if I cannot win, let me be brave in the attempt.” - the Special Olympics athletes’ oath, written by Eunice Kennedy Shriver in 1968. Special Olympics events are when you see the very best of true sportsmanship, when a runner will stop to help their fallen competitor get to their feet and run on. It’s seriously good stuff that also involves a lot of free hugs.

    • @mirandaeberts7800
      @mirandaeberts7800 Před 2 lety +1

    • @cshell9137
      @cshell9137 Před 2 lety +28

      I was a coach for Special Olympics summer and winter games for a few years and it was an amazing experience! I learned so much from them and got So much love!

    • @verdaschultz2446
      @verdaschultz2446 Před 2 lety +16

      I was in special Olympics for track softball throwing swimming 25 freestyle and diving I had a lot of fun and special Olympics and it's from the Kennedy foundation

  • @Dr.MichaelVallario
    @Dr.MichaelVallario Před 10 měsíci +1

    Well done. The ending was beautiful. Thank you.

  • @viridiangreen8259
    @viridiangreen8259 Před 9 měsíci

    So good that you brought this into the light

  • @missBehavin22
    @missBehavin22 Před 3 lety +587

    I learned about her some years ago. Tragic . She played a pivotal role in the creation of the ADA. The only good that came from her sad story . Her family didnt deserve her , such a spirit . 💗

    • @jessicagore6199
      @jessicagore6199 Před 2 lety +5

      Your words in the ears of God!

    • @Dina-zh3fw
      @Dina-zh3fw Před 2 lety +16

      Agreed. Her family did NOT deserve her.

    • @MsSwitchblade13
      @MsSwitchblade13 Před 2 lety +40

      Well her father didn't deserve her. He seems to have ruled the family including the mother. How else would be be okay in not consulting her about the lobotomy? He didn't care for what she thought. To him the wife was prob just a barer of children for him to use.

    • @dianapeterson3404
      @dianapeterson3404 Před 2 lety +23

      Her family LOVED her! Her DAD was the monster

    • @elizabetholiviaclark
      @elizabetholiviaclark Před 2 lety

      I tend to think of Justin Dart as having served as the pivotal role in the passage of the ADA. I'm not inclined to dismiss Rosemary's entire family as though undeserving of her, either.

  • @pepsiyummie1
    @pepsiyummie1 Před 2 lety +379

    They stuffed her back when she was being delivered. Hard to believe the medical staff was that dumb! Very sad story.

    • @helene4397
      @helene4397 Před 2 lety +15

      Only because some doctor wasn't there yet...

    • @marycarricaburu3683
      @marycarricaburu3683 Před 2 lety +9

      They didn't understand a lot of things back then. A lot of people commenting have no idea how medicine was back in those days. I am 87 and I remember a lot of it. It wasn't unheard of at all to delay the birth. I also think what the mother was feeling to have labor 2 hours longer than necessary. I had short labors but I can't imagine having 10 children. But, that is me.

    • @breezybest6064
      @breezybest6064 Před 2 lety +5

      @@marycarricaburu3683 They don't understand a lot of things now. They're still experimenting on us and don't seem to care if it goes well or not.

    • @marycarricaburu3683
      @marycarricaburu3683 Před 2 lety +1

      @@breezybest6064 Yep. I have been outright lied to by doctors, and of course misdiagnosed too. Now, they want us to believe them when they keep changing their minds. For example, from what the papers are telling me, they have decided that if you got Moderna vaccine for example, they used to say you had to stay with Moderna. Now they have almost decided that you can get Pfizer. and it will be OK, they think.

    • @breezybest6064
      @breezybest6064 Před 2 lety

      @@marycarricaburu3683 Yet they couldn't possibly have ANY idea since there's been NO time to do any long term testing! It sure doesn't help that we already know Big Pharma is nothing but a giant group of CROOKS!

  • @Juggernauts_N_Barbs
    @Juggernauts_N_Barbs Před 2 lety

    I just found your channel, and I must say… I’m hooked! Love ❤️ it… totally subscribed

  • @libbyfforbes
    @libbyfforbes Před 11 měsíci +1

    It’s lovely that her siblings included her and she was not shunned by them, like so many at the time.

  • @hellsbelle7533
    @hellsbelle7533 Před 2 lety +484

    My youngest son was early with walking but crawled “late”. He also started speaking “late” as well. He definitely wasn’t like any of the other kids my “friends” had, as we all had kids around the same time. I knew he was perfectly fine despite people saying he wasn’t. He is almost grown now and is brilliant and also amazing in artistic ways. He is much more advanced than his peer group and tends to relate more with adults. He is amazing! I understand that some children may have disabilities. However, how dare any parent assume their child is not capable before they are old enough to really understand what is going on inside their child. I NEVER gave up or accepted what I knew was not true. I knew my son so well and spent countless hours just being with him and getting to know who he is as a PERSON. This is just awful and heartbreaking.

    • @okaymea
      @okaymea Před 2 lety +22

      I'm so glad your son is doing well

    • @bellerain381
      @bellerain381 Před 2 lety +22

      Your son sounds like an amazing person! He is so lucky to have you as a parent!

    • @MsSwitchblade13
      @MsSwitchblade13 Před 2 lety +24

      You're the definition of a great mother!
      My cousin and I grew up together and he's autistic. Mind you this was in late 80s when Austism wasn't known much about. He was pretty bad as far as how it affected him up until he was in his teens. He transitioned to regular classes and graduated at age 22 but he did it and he's gifted in other areas. He's sincerely kind, caring and holds down a simple job. How many people can we say that about!
      I am glad your son is doing great.

    • @arrow2589
      @arrow2589 Před 2 lety +25

      as a person with some learning disabilities I just wanted to say that its the parents like you that the world needs more of.

    • @musicissmylife0511
      @musicissmylife0511 Před 2 lety +6

      yeah but on the other side those were the old times u wear put away or hidden for simple having anxiety,depression or bipolar and were treated like some kind of monster...ofc today its partly still like this that a child is seen diffrent just because of being 'slower' then others but lets remind ourselfs that this was WAY back when people hated peoole who were 'diffrent' even more then in todays times.Also i'm glad ur child is doing okay❤️...i was the same but now i'm very happt how i turned out 😬😅

  • @JmadiRN
    @JmadiRN Před 3 lety +403

    This is simply gut wrenching. It didn’t have to be this way, which is why it was so tragic !

  • @yorkiepit
    @yorkiepit Před rokem +1

    So tragic and sad, God bless Rosemary Kennedy.

  • @bettyprussia9777
    @bettyprussia9777 Před 2 lety

    First timer here love your videos looking forward to more of your work 😀