India's Beggar Problem
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 08. 2024
- DOWNLOAD KUKUFM
Download Link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/bw9n/wwmx
Coupon code - MOHAK50
(Coupon valid for first 250 users)
We all come across beggars almost daily in our lives. While we often wonder whether we should give them money or not, a more important question escapes us: why do so many beggars exist in our country in the first place? Many of us tend to think that most beggars are part of a syndicate that is run by an underground mafia, but such assumptions often have no grounds in evidence. Instead, problems of poverty, migration and even religion lie at the heart of the begging problem. In this video, we discuss these factors in detail while also emphasizing on what needs to be done to alleviate the problem.
******
Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/18...
******
Research:
Vishwa Thakkar: / vishwathakkar5
Mohit Priyadarshi: / mohitprior
Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
Channel Manager :
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
Thumbnail :
Aanchal verma: / aanchal_creates
Subtitles:
Dhruv Bambhaniya: / dhruvkumar_2920
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
Liked the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: bit.ly/3A7bUx7
******
🗳Support on Patreon: / sochyoutube
👾Discord: / discord
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
******
Playlists
🇮🇳Indian Society: • Hijab: Ban Right or Wr...
🗺Geopolitics and Foreign Affairs: • Will China Invade Taiwan?
🧍🏽♀️Issues of a Young Indian: • Are Indian Girls Bad a...
💰Economy: • How Kerala Changed its...
🗳Indian Politics: • UP Elections: Why Are ...
🇮🇳 Discoveries of India: • How Goa Joined India
📈Money, Stocks, and Crypto: • Why Indian Youth is NO...
******
Creative commons:
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
Markers
00:00 Introduction
01:15 Beggary in ancient India
02:47 Difference
04:45 Causes (i) Poverty and Unemployment
07:59 Causes (i) Disability
09:39 Causes (i) Religion
10:51 What does the government do?
11:28 Conclusion
DOWNLOAD KUKUFM
Download Link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/bw9n/wwmx
Coupon code - MOHAK50
(Coupon valid for first 250 users)
Love your videos they are eyes opening
Whether Congress or BJP I don't trust any Government figures. The corrupted system reality was seen by everyone during lockdown.
Apne sahi kaha Zakat ki paiso ki liye masjid ki bahar vir hota hai...
Actually Zakat ka concept hai ki jo log garib hai unko financial support dena (ek acchi amount) taki wo log kuch chota mota dhanda karke atma nirvar banjaye...ye koi bhik nehi hai..garibo ka haq hai and unki ghar ma bhejdena hota hai..taki unki dignity bhi salamat rahe. ..jese govt scheme hota hai........ Iski liye muslim country ma government ki taraf se zakat foundation hota hai jo ye kam karta hai.. Humara iha aisa kuch nehi hai to amir log inko bheek ki tarah masjido ki bahar batna chalu kardiya awr puri concept ko hi change kardiya...i hope mai apko kuch information de paya zakat ki barema..
mohak plz make a video on tamil hindus and north indian hindus like i am seeing many argument on twitter where tamil hindus saying we arent hindus and we can eat beef etc etc i am really interested to know it but could not find a satisfying video
Beggars are in US as well I would say Boston has probably more beggar than most Indian state
(Except for Bengal)
And SF probably on par with bengal
Great video!
It took me time but i do have clarity now, i prefer giving money to beggars. Not because I am sure my money will be used wisely but because I have more and they have less. It's really none of my business to worry about how they would use it. Just like we can't control when a normal working person destroys their life with wrong decisions, we can't really control a beggar's life, they will misuse someone else's money if not mine. But if everyone stops giving them money, and give only food or clothes, then they are stripped from their freedom to grow, and they won't be able to rest knowing that they can afford their next meal, or a day off. It's their right (just like everyone else) to save and build, even if they're not earning, only beginning, and even if they misuse money and fail to do so. My job is to offer them a fair chance. I hope one day I do something with a bigger impact on the underprivileged.
-Mandeep
❤️❤️j sir ✨
Yoooooooo
Such a great answer !
ok
There are certain reports that kids and old aged were forcefully pushed into begging, kids especially are the victims sometimes intentionally eyes were removed or handicapped. I have seen both but it's your wish to give money but i sometime feel whether my hard earned is not being misused or affecting someone even though I'm not sure about so finally I've come up with a solution: i take them to nearest hotel, juice centre or bakery and will provide them what they want.
*“In a country well governed, poverty is something to be ashamed of. In a country badly governed, wealth is something to be ashamed of.”* - Confucius
@@Jajshshshs dont be ashamed rather find a solution and work on it 😀
@@Jajshshshs ok good
@@Jajshshshs Then maybe don't call yourself indian.
@@Jajshshshs hmm prob a 9yo punk
@@sb3987 🤡
13:00 "andhe ko aankh de" Ye zimmedaari hai kiski?? bhagwaan ki?? hamrai?? Ya phir hamaare sarkaar ki??..... Simple line with very deep meaning if you try to understand ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️
Why West Bengal & Assam has so many baggers?
Ans : illigal Immigration from Bangladesh
Yeah
That's why Bangladesh gdp per capita is 2764 dollar
West Bengal 1600 dollar, Assam 1300 dollar
Bangladesh can feed west bangal and Assam alone.
@@Vignesh_15 There more than 6 lac bihari and indian working in Bangladesh.
Do we ever complain about them.
@@lifelesson28 bruh just see in Assam literally in every street and corner you can see a bangledeshi migrant, most of them work in construction and rickshaw pullers. Most beggars are either Bangladeshi or Bihari, our local tribal never beg in cites they can live in village comfortably with agriculture and animal husbandry. Indians population in Bangladesh is negligible compared to illegal bangladeshis population in India especially, Bengal, Assam and Tripura. That's why we needed NRC and you comparing a country with two under developed states, Compare with a major state like Maharashtra or Gujarat.
@Gurmeet Aulakh Bacause it’s mostly BJP political Propaganda.
Yes there are illegally immigrants, but they aren't as high as they said. Many bihari also illegally working in Bangladesh.
The border area is congested and complicated, and population density is more than 1000/sq km, so you can't control these things.
Bjp is ruling more than 8 years, BSF is in their control by central power. Then why they are still complaining about it.
The problem is whenever they see Muslim in Border area, they tag it with illegal Bangladeshi Immigrants.
And rohingya..
This guy is the definition of how a content should be on CZcams. No reviews, no illogical stunts..
But true problems of our society.
Love from Bihar ❤️.
Call him an example not defination. It is actually a big word. No one is perfect in this universe not even the god..
proud to be sanatani vegan muslim
उदासी भी एक लत है,जिसे लग जाए वह सुख से भी दुःख का पता पूछता है।
~ डॉ हरिओम
@@abhijitbarman7541 shi keh rha hai bhai tu
good to see people of every state watch these vids n get educated
this brings my faith to this country back tbh
@@SanataniVegnMuslim0 kuch bhi.
We need people like Mohak Bhai , who can understand the real problem and provide effective solutions, Great work , hats off to you.
Dhruv rathee
Aisa Koi Saga Nahi Jise 🙏 😃Neta Lalu Ji 😂) 🤣 Ne Thaga Nahi .Since 1970 . 40 % Children are Malnutrition anemia , No blood , 40 gram Children in Our Area . 100 kg weight Lalu Yadav and Daughter .. Soo much health lalu yadav and Seven 7 Daughter heavy weight 100 kg to 150 kg hah ha ha . But Sell us Rs 2 per man . 40 gram man ., Do not Care death of Poor.. Poor may not get job , health . but Lalu son and daughter are Safe and money . Forgot poor
@@Yourmother282 Yes , very few people are atleast speak up , In order to make India great, we have to come forward and discuss about problem and solutions , We need young politician who can understand the real issues. It will take maybe a decade but we will definitely win and change this dirty politics to a good politics where we will discuss ideas..
@arvind kumar bhai ar bhi leader ke naam batau sir lalu hi kyu
Ancient org bhikaris be like-bhiksham dehi Today's bhikari be like- IPhone dehi 😂😂
Most of the beggars in West Bengal are from Bihar. And they are not poor it is their business
Lol
True
It's true
😂Lol, bihari pure India mai hai par gareeb Sirf Bengal? Matlab dusre ko dosh dena hai har cheej mai. Mana ki kafi Bihar ke logo mai problem hai but har cheej jo unpe dal kar apne ko cover karna it's wrong
I will try that one day your prospective towards Bihar and bihari citizens gets changed.I am not a citizen of Bihar but I am citizen of India and bihar is also a part of our privious country and bihari 's are like our siblings so definitely it is hard for me to hear such things about them 😢.
Nothing else I can say at this time but to try atleast to support them.😞😟
Keep discussing about social problems 🙌
His life will be in danger
@@mohammaadyousuf
When we are trying to talk about press freedom
Modi government:- go to the hell
@@mohammaadyousuf not until he goes against BJP 😅
One of yours best Video!! ⚡
Aisa Koi Saga Nahi Jise 🙏 😃Neta Lalu Ji 😂) 🤣 Ne Thaga Nahi .Since 1970 . 40 % Children are Malnutrition anemia , No blood , 40 gram Children in Our Area . 100 kg weight Lalu Yadav and Daughter .. Soo much health lalu yadav and Seven 7 Daughter heavy weight 100 kg to 150 kg hah ha ha . But Sell us Rs 2 per man . 40 gram man ., Do not Care death of Poor.. Poor may not get job , health . but Lalu son and daughter are Safe and money . Forgot poor
Yeah , here in Assam the begging is what you can find handy with a small and large town / chowks .. Mohak da is absolutely right , me and my friends observed & talked to some of them and we found out all the problems aforesaid . May Government take some steps to make them skilled (rather than distributing free things creating beneficiaries)so that they can earn the bread on their own . Regards from Assam ..
Aisa Koi Saga Nahi Jise 🙏 😃Neta Lalu Ji 😂) 🤣 Ne Thaga Nahi .Since 1970 . 40 % Children are Malnutrition anemia , No blood , 40 gram Children in Our Area . 100 kg weight Lalu Yadav and Daughter .. Soo much health lalu yadav and Seven 7 Daughter heavy weight 100 kg to 150 kg hah ha ha . But Sell us Rs 2 per man . 40 gram man ., Do not Care death of Poor.. Poor may not get job , health . but Lalu son and daughter are Safe and money . Forgot poor
That’s their vote bank. They will never do that.
I have been a subscriber of this channel when it had only 100k subscribers. One after another so many amazing analytical contents Mohak had shared in this channel is really commendable. Only thing that surprises me is that his channel is not growing at a faster rate. It is probably that most of the viewers on CZcams don't want to watch free educational, analytical, socio-political-economic contents with deep understanding. Nonetheless, I thank Mohak to keep up his genuine work as he does.
It's good to see people like you are addressing this type of issues. It's also needed for issues like why india has slums & their solutions, hawkery etc.
This video gave a very dim picture of India's future. The only thing it misses, is the terrible corruption practice of the government officers of all levels, from federal to state. Without the elimination of the corrupt practice, it will be difficult to eliminate Poverty from the root.
The program mentioned in the video literally teaches the person to come back to working society, not giving them cash. It's a good start IMO.
Overpopulation is a curse for the world. That's why me and my cousins have unanimously decided to be the last generation of our family by choosing a single and childfree life.🤗
@@anewlife5846lol that not gonna solve anything . ur decision got nothing to do with overpopulation, it's ur personal decision. I feel sad for ur ancestors.
@@RAM-iz6ky there is nothing to be sad for his ancestors.
Reservation hatado
Aadhe problem wahi solve ho jayengi
You would hardly see any rikshaw or cab driver being from SC or ST community
Rather they belong to so calked upper caste from whom these useless govt has snatched employment and education opportunities to give freebies to worthless SC ST candidates
My comment will maybe seems as a bit harsh for some user but it is the reality. Most of the beggars are healthy people who can find a work(not good but decent one) but they still begs because it doesn't require any efforts and outside of temple they can easily earn enough for a day.
Dude that's a fact not for everyone but ya some people don't want to work
Research says otherwise. Where is your research please publish
That is one of the reason of unemployment.
"People don't want to work"
Sorry but jobs are not easy to find and there's no point in doing a job that pays less then begging either. So your statement is not entirely true
Because begging is a business in India...It's a very well organized sinister business.
You give as a very correct and serious information , after that we know about our region's problem very clearly... Thanks for all information sir 😇
0:54 "MAA MUJHEY SUB DIKHAYI DE RAHA HAI"..!!😅🤣🤣
I'm from West Bengal and you're absolutely right many beggars aren't even beggars they just make it a business.
And why government is allowing them near the train stations and tourist places it's just frustrating at first you might get emotional and give some money but the moment you give money another 10 would show up it's a never-ending cycle lol
So i created a policy not to give money or food to anyone
the video was release 3 mins ago video is 13 minutes long, did you just wanted to make an opinion after seeing a few seconds of a video? Get a life Kid
Yes it's buisness now days
Its kind of fine if you don't give Money to them but giving food is the best alternative here.
This way we know that it's going to them directly.
@@shivanisamyal3143 right even in old times only food is donated not money
Have you watched the whole video or just the first part.
Excellent topic. As someone who visits different parts of India, I have always been intrigued by why begging is not as visible in TN despite having comparable or less income than say Maharashtra or Punjab. I feel the main reason is the social services such as amma kitchens, shelters, mid-day meals for school children provided by the govt. You don't have to be rich to eliminate beggary. A little bit of state support goes a long way. There is plenty of food and shelter to accommodate everyone. I feel beggary is not a social problem but rather a choice made by the society and the political class.
I will also add tamil nadu is very developed that's why you see less beggars. Whereas in wb and Bihar you find more cause of less development.
And the lack of decentralization
Not just informative but indeed an impactful video.
What I use to do while interacting with beggers:
1) I personally look at the person whether he has some issues like Physically disabled, age factor, health etc. If the person aged between 30-50 and physically completely fit then I avoid giving them money.
2) Instead of money, prefer giving food items, fruits etc.
3) On special occassions, like bithday or parents anniversary, I love to spend money on them, also intercation with them for psychological support.
4) What I really like the idea of Rajasthan govt like shelter, health support. Many beggers do not have access to even basic amenities. Constitution provide Right to dignified life for everyone. It's not just the duty of state but also of the individual, to help them in our capacity, just on economic front but also on knowledge, social front.
Thanks a lot for video :)
Population is the main problem all of this
No one can destroy that😁
Did you know there is a country called china which has a population of 1.4billion which has surpassed India's population late 2022 ,So they have literally 1.2% poverty
@@jmkind1613 China has land and education, we don't.
That ramzan point is tooo relatable......... You can experience that in masjid bunder , colaba - mahim dargah - mira road ...... This area are mainly gold making place for beggars ....... On an average muslim beggars make 1200 ruppess...... And this was told buy my friend who was once beggars in that area .... 🙂 ....
1200 rupees every day ..... And around 5k during Friday easily....... And they have proper timing, reserved place and even free food by muslim hotels near by daily ..... They just don't have home 🙂🥴
proud to be sanatani vegan muslim
उदासी भी एक लत है,जिसे लग जाए वह सुख से भी दुःख का पता पूछता है।
~ डॉ हरिओम hj
@@SanataniVegnMuslim0 dude get a life
@@SanataniVegnMuslim0 Bhai tune jo phooka hai same maal mujhe bhi chahiye
No wonder many hindus dress up as Muslims to beg during Ramadan or get alms and clothes from Muslim localities.
Great work. The staticial data you provided makes so much sense. I hope this video changes how people perceive beggers and be more kind towards them. You changed my perspective I hope you change the country's perspective. Good luck
Thank you for bringing to light such critical issues with such detailed analysis. 🙏
Make one video on corruption please
If u agree like here👇
@Shillong Target yes
😢😢c
Ju l
A❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
yeah i support it
An extremely important topic to be discussed in India's context. Very well researched and well made video, Mohak!
The personal touch at the end really hit right in my conscience. Keep up the good work.
Your eyes at the end of the vid, in the conclusion part.
They say it all.
And it's said that eyes never lie.
Kudos Mohak !!
We need people like you who can bring this kind of dialectic, discussion on the table.
Dude you are too good for this society
No one in this whole world ever told me about such issues
Eye opening video
Love your work 👍
These beggers should be put in shelter or prisons
Overpopulation is a curse for the world. That's why me and my cousins have unanimously decided to be the last generation of our family by choosing a single and childfree life.🤗
@@anewlife5846 wrong, country ki fertility rate 2.1 honi chaiye for a stable population and as per recent studies, India ki average rate in future isse niche hi jaane waali hai, so daba ke bacche karo😝(max. 2)(max. 4 if you are Parsi or Jain).
Paid comment
@@yourstruely744 itne faltu kr paise nahi hai bhai mohak bhaiya ke paas😂
Aandhen ko aakhe dete... that line just touched my core! Something serious to ponder about! Huge appreciation for Mohak. 👏👏👏
In Islam, we have to give 2.5% of charity from the savings each year. As a Muslim, I strictly follow this So i usually have have donate around 1Lac+ to people who do not have cumulative cash or jewelry for more than 50k.
I usually give my zakat to these beggers in an around my area. But I have stopped giving zakat to beggers. As recently I found many from good earning family also start begging without any valid reason. So now I started donating my zakat to ngos or madarsa which are giving good education to youth to make them employable. 😊
A very well researched piece of work. Gives a lot of insights into the cause of the problem.
The valuable thing in Mohak's logics is he doesn't loose Emotions. ❤️❤️❤️
Aisa Koi Saga Nahi Jise 🙏 😃Neta Lalu Ji 😂) 🤣 Ne Thaga Nahi .Since 1970 . 40 % Children are Malnutrition anemia , No blood , 40 gram Children in Our Area . 100 kg weight Lalu Yadav and Daughter .. Soo much health lalu yadav and Seven 7 Daughter heavy weight 100 kg to 150 kg hah ha ha . But Sell us Rs 2 per man . 40 gram man ., Do not Care death of Poor.. Poor may not get job , health . but Lalu son and daughter are Safe and money . Forgot poor
'lose'
10:04, despite being a Muslim i didn't knew that begging is prohibited. It may be due to the fact that how much the people around me give money to beggars but what you said about "ZAKAT" may be a little off track, it is basically a tax that we have to pay, which is 2.5% of the money that you have in your savings i.e (Your income) - (Money used for household use). At first we used to pay it to the Masjid but nowadays we pay it to the local NGOs who use this money for the locality, like buying medical equipments, installing street lights and yes, giving it to the people who need it the most.
We have a similar thing in Sikhism it is called "Dasvand" meaning to give 1/10th of your income to the society (to invest in things that helps in upliftment of society like free food,water or even sponsering a needy child's education)
Firstly:
In Islam It is not permissible for anyone to ask people for money when he is not in need or he is able to earn a living. There are certain categories for whom it is permissible to ask of people. They are: the poor person who is destitute, the man who owes a debt, and the one who has been stricken by financial calamity and lost all his wealth. In these cases it is not permissible to ask for more than one needs, on condition that he does not have enough to meet his needs and is not able to earn enough for his livelihood.
The scholars of the Standing Committee said:
It is permissible to ask people for money, for the one who is in need and does not have enough to suffice him and he is not able to earn a living. He may ask people for as much as will meet his needs only. As for the one who is not in need, or the one who is in need but is able to earn a living, it is not permissible for him to ask and whatever he takes from people in this case is haraam for him, because of the hadeeth of Qabeesah ibn Mukhaariq al-Hilaali (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: It was narrated that Qabeesah ibn Mukhaariq al-Hilaali said: I incurred a debt (in order to reconcile between two parties) and I came to the Messenger of Allaah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) to ask him (for help) with it. He said: “Stay with us until the zakaah comes, and we will order that something be given to you.” Then he said: “O Qabeesah, asking for help is not permissible except in one of three cases: a man who has incurred a debt (in order to reconcile between two parties), for whom it is permissible to ask for help until he has paid it off, then he should refrain; a man who has been stricken by a calamity that has destroyed all his wealth, for whom it is permissible to ask for help until he gets enough to get by - or he gets enough to meet his basic needs; and a man who is stricken by poverty and three men of wisdom among his people acknowledge that So and so has been stricken by poverty, then it becomes permissible for him to ask for help until he gets enough to get by - or to meet his basic needs. Apart from these cases asking for help, O Qabeesah, is haraam and the one who begs is consuming something haraam.” Narrated by Ahmad, Muslim, an-Nasaa’i and Abu Dawood.
And (it is haraam) because of the hadeeth, “Whoever asks of people to accumulate wealth is asking for a live coal” and the hadeeth “Charity is not permissible for a rich person, or for one who is strong and healthy.”
Repulsing or chiding the beggar is also not allowed because Allah, may He be exalted, says (interpretation of the meaning): “and do not chide the one who asks for help” [ad-Duha 93:10]. What is referred to here is rebuking him and raising one’s voice against him; this includes both the one who asks for money and the one who asks about shar‘i rulings. But this does not rule out offering guidance to the beggar who is asking wrongfully, and advising him with wisdom and beautiful preaching.
As for what we often see in the streets or in the mosques of beggars who ask people for money, they are not all truly needy people. In fact it has been proven that some of them are independent of means, and it has been proven that there are gangs to exploit those children and make them ask people for money. This does not mean that there are no cases that are truly deserving. Hence the one who wants to give money to one of these people should try to use his own intuition to work out whether he is genuine or not.
Secondly:
What is well known among all the scholars, and is the opinion of the majority and almost reaches the point of consensus among the scholars of the righteous salaf, is that zakaah is not to be spent on building mosques or buying books etc., rather it is to be spent on the eight categories which are mentioned in the aayah of Soorat al-Tawbah [9:60], namely: the poor; the needy; those employed to collect the funds; those whose hearts are to be softened towards Islam; to release captives; for those who are in debt; for Allaah’s Cause; and for wayfarers.
@@abdullahmuhammad360 zakat is also not permissible to non Muslims
@@valerierit2003 to those whose hearts are to be softened towards Islam
@@valerierit2003 Yes, Zakat is not permissible to non-Muslims but Sadaqa is. Zakat is a particular percentage and Sadaqa has no limit.
bro keep up your work
what u r doing is incredibly amazing
i love your content and also sharing it with my other friends
becoz u always point out very main topics ...keep going and growing bro ...i support your work♥️
Ancient org bhikaris be like-bhiksham dehi Today's bhikari be like- IPhone dehi 😂😂
I liked it. How calmly you agreed that people are going to disagree on your religion point and probably abuse you but you kept your point and asked them to think and comment if they disagree.
I'm sorry guys I've no hatred towards India. I love every South Asian folks. But I would like to mention because of our open border system. A lot of people from india specifically bihar and slightly up too in Nepal. Ofc there are many nepali beggers as well but majority of them seem and are from ind. It has been very irritating from past 3 months. Every religious sites there are tons of people begging. They climb on people. Pull their leg. , even spit. I once asked one girl near Boudhha she was literally pulling my leg. I asked her kaha se ho, Nepal se hi ho? Then she didn't speak. I said I'll give you 50 rupee If you answer me, then she said bihar me gau he. Definitely there is some BIG RACKET behind this just like human trafficing. Our gov isn't very concerning so there is no point behind qsing government. I hope nobody takes this as a hate comment but would just like to mention it because of the subject been discussed.
I'm from Nepal too. And yes I once too asked this lady who was carrying infant. He was crying a lot. I asked didi esari bacha narakhnu. But she said paisa dena hai toh do jaldi. She was damn arrogant tho. I replied where is your husband here and there after questioning her little bit. Of course she was annoyed but then she said she was from some supal or suapaul gau which is in bihar as a Nepali I don't like that but as human I feel for them. Our government along with Indian government should take some action.
Hello Mohak,I have been watching your videos for quite a while now and it amazes me the content you come up with,making the general public know about the issues while also providing feasible ways to solve them too while proving statistical evidence. I have keen interest in your topics and was wandering whether u use any specific websites to get such accurate data of various things in present time. If so plz do share some links to those websites as it would be a great help.
Mohak you have become one of my favourite youtuber...please keep posting similar content with no bias to anything but truth.....hopefully you will still keep it same despite becoming more and more popular, and never bring political or religious bias to your videos like some youtuber with similar content started doing...God bless you!
I started watching Mohak after i saw him in a collab video with Dhruv Rathee and believe me it was worth it.
For the first time I'm commenting on your video although I'm an old subscriber...
So I live in kolkata since 3 years...I' had been in north kolkata where I rarely saw beggers on streets but now I live at kalighat in south kolkata and here I can see begging is a business now a days... may be some of them are "majboor" but many of them have taken it as their profession. I would love to tell everyone that help them who can't help themselves like aged persons.
I am watching his videos since over an year and i am impressed over how he discusses the global issues unbiased.Good work we need more of you👍
One of the best videos by Mohak. Last seconds of the video gave me chills and forced me to think.
Good work!
This is a very important video. Rarely can someone make a video like this. Whenever I see someone in poverty, I wonder if that guy will be able to change his situation in a lifetime or not. I think the solution is to provide a good education to the children who are in poverty. And also to train and educate unemployed people with skills like plumbing, electrician , driving, etc. Government support is really essential for their rehabilitation.
Appreciate the Rajasthan govt's action to enhance the skills of Beggers by skill training for 2-3weeks & enable them a income generating job
This will solve the Involuntary Begger issue. But the other factors, needs specialised planning & execution
Rajasthan govt is giving skill training to beggers, meanwhile unemployed graduates here are all set to become beggers. ☠️💀
@@user-mp1uf6lf5p 🤣
The same government who is bringing the old pension scheme, lol.
@@BruceWayne-qe7bs I appreciate BJP on this to keep national interest above political gains.
Overpopulation is a curse for the world. That's why me and my cousins have unanimously decided to be the last generation of our family by choosing a single and childfree life.🤗
Sometimes i do feel that there're many problems in india which are very fundamental and have no solution. Apart from religion, geographical/climatic conditions does make major impact on human behaviour. In the northern countries due to harsh climate and scarcity of resources people over there need to be very active and innovative unfortunately throughout the history we were so blessed from nature which makes us unproductive.
Thanks !!! Much appreciated !👍
This video is like an eye opener to many. Thanks Mohak 💐🙏
You are right mohak, i also find it very frustrating that if i should give them money or not but i think giving them food or old clothes is better than giving Money because we don't know where money is going but they can use other things.
Also if you have access then you should try to suggest them works they can do for a living.
Do you always know where your money is going? When you bribe your local police for not wearing helmet, your milk man, your politicans, vegetables vendors etc.
Thats a dumb excuse for not giving money to anyone.
Every time I face a scenario you have a video for me to explain the roots of it.. like a week back when i was in Surat for a religious occasion with almost 75000 members of the community we saw almost hundreds of beggers chasing the attendees and I was having a hard time thinking why would they bother us at every step and at one point I was wondering wether we should refine ourselves from actually giving them but now I know we should always help as much as we can..thanks Mohak
It means u are dawoodi bohra too
That last ganesh ji ki aarti, was heart touching.. I felt emotional after that.. This is a real problem, which should be solved at governmental, societal and individual level.
Divided by borders, united by social issues
India and Pakistan
9:33 On the topic of self-inflicted injury, the context - I am from nepal. Real Story, there was a begger who had a injured leg and use to beg next to Kathmandu Mall. My colleague use to see him daily and he had an open wound in a leg and that begger had that same wound for more than 4 months. so my colleague tried to help him and with help of an organization took him to a hospital and treated and bandaged the injury. his leg was infected as per the doctor and if this continued he might have to face a leg amputation. he was left with some food, bandaged leg and medicine and few supplies. after a week the same begger had another similar wound and later it was found out. he use to self inflict injury on himself so he would get money and this money he would spend on alcohol and ciggerattes.
Omg 🤐 same here I am uttarakhand, haldwani I have been here for 9 year In these year every time I visited the market A little near road with huge traffic and crowd and road was just a slim way colony I have seen a old(now she seems to be old only little)women perfectly fine and a person being disabled and many man , children and women, where they sit they had fruits, biscuits and other things people donated and sometimes or barely few incidents When we just come off auto (taxi) I children big and small start attacking on my mom purse by opening their ✋hand saying give, give money sometimes they all fight from each other and all are laughing I don't mean that they shouldn't but it's situations makes them it's less even there are incidents so I am now always confused that should I help Or not?
@@Wishperwind_04 I am also from haldwani
@@factfish3949 great👍:)
This is what we need to talk about society . Great content Mohak...
This is wonderful. I have to admit I also thought beggars might not always be truthful but this video has definitely changed my perspective. Thank you dude, amazing work as always 👍
This video gave me goosebumps at the last. It's a good video on an important topic. Thanx Mohak
Hats off for the fact you are talking about this issue!!And also if you are worried that giving money to beggars will may or may not lead to right person give them food instead as it doesn't matter much as long as anyone is eating it❤❤
That's a really important issue to talk about but unfortunately nobody talks about that. We all encounter beggers in our daily basis . Sometimes we feel sorry for them & sometimes irritates us.
Thank you❤
Fakir tumlogome bohut hain.
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz non Muslim bhi muslim dress pahenkar bhik magte hai
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz That's because Muslims have highest poverty rate and lowest literacy rate in India, Lower than dalit.
Overpopulation is a curse for the world. That's why me and my cousins have unanimously decided to be the last generation of our family by choosing a single and childfree life.🤗
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz Ones a great man said,"Fakir aadmi hoon, jhola leke chal padenge. "
That's what came to my mind few days back that most people won't beg if they had resources. I travel by local daily and I decided to donate atleast once to a begger and a transgender per week.
Superb video,it is too much necessary to underline such problems from the society, and to create social awareness as well as to find some solutions! Good effort 👍
Thanks for making a video on this topic which nobody considers a real problem as if seeing beggars on the streets has become part of our day to day lives. Mostly people just ignore them without thinking about their survival. Hope a solution gets implemented to support them. Meanwhile, we can help them collectively as a society.
It also takes a lot of courage to change ones opinion which has formed over the years of following other people and acknowledge that maybe you were not right all along. More power to you.
Top quality content in India. Hands down that's my take. The fact that you display research articles is also indicative of the amount of time and work that goes into making these type of videos. Please do not stop creating content like these. It's why I'm subscribed to your channel otherwise we all know the content quality of other well known Indian youtubers.
What a stunning piece of content! Your best video so far, production is on top
Well explained, happy to see a discourse on this vital social issue in India.
His videos are so informative , I literally binge watch them.
You are the creator who has never disappointed me in terms of content...Salute to you man...
Accept the defeat and Stop the war vladmir.
@@tibontibon5772 Nah bruh... Moscow will never back off...But NATO and Ukraine will have to...
@@vladimirputin48 keep up the good work and keep the west at bay 👍
The way is explained and the ending of the video is really heart touching 🙏.
Appreciate to your team & your level of explaination ❤🙏
I appreciate your approach towards the problem of our society. Keep going
You are made of titanium 💙
Sadly, as a daily commuter on the western railway line of Bombay, I can say that I do see beggars(mostly children) entering the train compartments during the afternoon hours.
It's just a disheartening when I see children as old as 7 or 10 with no footwear entering the trains begging for money or trying to sell coloring books with heavy loads of those on their backs. Once, when I was travelling through the FC compartment from Andheri, back home from my CET prep class, I saw a boy barely 8 y.o entering the train. He had no slippers on his feet, torn clothes and looked to malnourished that my heart broke after seeing that impoverished child. He was walking from seat begging for money, when he approached me, rather than giving him money I gave him a packet of patties from Merwan which I had brought previously after my class ended.
I didn't have my breakfast that day and hadn't eaten anything since I left for class that morning, and I intended to eat those patties during the afternoon, on the way home. But that boy looked to famished that he probably hadn't eaten in 3 days. It's a pitiful sight that I'm used to seeing everyday while travelling by train.
It's disgraceful of our politicians to farcically bicker over religion, when children of both Hindus and Muslims have to sleep with an empty on some nights!!
Lol. Their parents are responsible for this. If they don't have home, job then why the hell they gave birth. Government is not responding for this. In foriegn countries they don't give birth to kids if they are poor.
Why don't people understand this problem. Religion has been made utmost priority when it should be paid minimal attention to. But It's the thing that gets them the votes. If only people wouldnt fall for this propoganda
Hats off
Salute bruh. Politicians are meant for power and greed rather focusing upon basic needs of people. At least a small home, and a free intermediate medical services, compulsory class 12th education and good education background.
Sahi baat bhaiya. Politicians are just thieves are
Wow this guy never disappoints.
Your are a gem!!
Great topic, ended on even greater note.
A decent video Mohak. But you could have also added a few points in the beginning, and in the end. One is, overpopulation, where all of this begins. The lack of perception and awareness within the economically weaker sections, due to the lack of education(or free education). And aapne starting mein bola tha that ye ek ‘social’ problem hai; Shouldn’t the term be ‘socio-economic’?
You have an amazing channel Mohak. That too you make videos in Hindi so that it can reach maximum people. Great job!
The ending of the video had me in tears when you mentioned the Ganesh Aarti. Thanks for the video and Kuddos to the Rajasthan Government 👏👏
Bhai jabse aapki videos dekhne lga hu Mera chijon ko dekhne ka nazriya hi badal gya hai
Or Jo mehnat aap ek video bnane mein krte ho vo dikhti h hai aapke content mein ❤
This video bought in soo many new perspectives, learned a lot! Kudos!💯
End message was heart and thought changing! 👍🙏 Superb video as always!
Great video, great points☝️
Thank you so much for this knowledge video.
I hope this video will change the narrative towards begger
Dear Mohak, I do not understand Hindi as I am a 2nd generation Malaysian Indian. I speak only Tamil, English and Malay. Some 3-4 years ago I visited Tamil Nadu and my husband insisted that we stay in a poor area, to see the " real Indians" What a surprise. We saw no beggars nor squatters. We saw one drunk but he seem to us of a northern Indian origin. The eating places were very clean, food services were fast as lighting and the people so helpful. No one made any attempt to cheat us . The only problem I had was that it was hard to find a meat eating place and because I am from Malaysia( a foreigner) , I was charged double the price of locals to all entrances of exhibits, science centres and ect. (a common practice in all countries). The churches were mind boggling(amazing) and the services beautiful. Pondichery was so clean, you could eat off the road. There are so many places we did not see. I also like your roads, so wide. Thank you India.
Are you pure Tamil or mixed with Chinese or malay
Wide roads are not a good thing in a hot climate. Also I am a tourist in Tamil Nadu currently staying in Chidambaram which is probably like 25 kms away from pondicherry and there are plenty of beggars here. Will be visiting pondi day after tomorrow. Happy to see you enjoyed your stay.
They are many beggers in tamil nadu as I have seen maybe you didn't see but there are many
@@songoku-jj2to 2nd gen Malaysian Indian means born to parents one of whom is Malaysian and one is Indian. So, she is not pure Tamil
Aisa Koi Saga Nahi Jise 🙏 😃Neta Lalu Ji 😂) 🤣 Ne Thaga Nahi .Since 1970 . 40 % Children are Malnutrition anemia , No blood , 40 gram Children in Our Area . 100 kg weight Lalu Yadav and Daughter .. Soo much health lalu yadav and Seven 7 Daughter heavy weight 100 kg to 150 kg hah ha ha . But Sell us Rs 2 per man . 40 gram man ., Do not Care death of Poor.. Poor may not get job , health . but Lalu son and daughter are Safe and money . Forgot poor
Never stop making such thought provoking videos Mohak!
Great work Mohak and the team.
Keep it up.
Best wishes from Germany.🇩🇪
Mohak bhai you are making videos on sensitive and important topics, Hats Off to you Bhai
Thanks a ton , Team Mahak for addressing such an insightful manner this sensible topic.
Hi brother... I am a 12th class student....the solution you talked about that the beggers don't actually know how to earn.... I had this exact same thought..I even planned to take some steps regarding this.... After seeing this video...I am now more sure of what I was thinking and what I planned for...and that I am not the only one With these thouhts....So thanks bro... and GREAT VIDEO btw!!!
I'm from Cuttack,Odisha and the reason of these things is rapid growth of our population
Great video , very people will talk about this kind of problem
Why does India have so many beggars is somewhat synonymous with "Why does India have so much population?"
simple....
just bcoz of Bihar and UP.
@@Himanshu.9211 so you think if you don't count UP and Bihar population India's population will not cross 100 crores mark
@@Himanshu.9211 very foolish comment in our UP most people prefer hardwork rather then begging mind your words next time 🤬🤬😤😤
Ppl dnt realise he's actually pointing out the basic issues that many ignore. Though dhruv is good but his issues r more intense and high level. These r the foundation. Public administration at its best. Well done mohak✍️😊🤗
Dhruv good hai?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@anuragyadav2086 dhruv best hai😁
@@asiddi821 rehne de Bhai😭😂😭🤣😳😳
@@anuragyadav2086 khush hojao kabhi toh zindagi mein 😂
@@asiddi821 dhruv propaganda failata hai, modi bad, hindu bad yahi hai uske saare vids mai🤣🤣😂😭
Good video! Thanks for sharing it. ✌️
Important topic ...Thanks man ..Be blessed 👍👍
One unique about Mohak is he chooses the taboo topics for his videos, which are very rare...
Thanks Bhai 👍
I know it's a serious topic but ACP Pradyuman gotta take a chill pill😂
8:42 true words, In India you have to fight for your rights from the Government. How ironic, a big mouthed "Largest Democracy" and its attitude towards its own people's rights who don't fit into conservative idea of "Human Being."
Log agar 10 10 bacha paida karenge toh sarkar kya kaare
Awesome brother ❤️ Dil Jeet liya. Zbrdast 👍🙂
Wow!! What a unique topic and perspective. From now onwards I'll try to pay any beggar who approaches me in the light that atleast some of them would be in genuine need and hoping I was able to help a person in need. Hope our country as a society is able reduce such cases in future generations to a minimum.
Guys, first of all hats off for making a video, which is completely new and never touched by anyone in this world in so much depth.
such a brilliant video. Broke my heart.
बिना बोध के हर कोई भिकारी ही है। बस अन्तर इतना है कि कम माँगने वाले धार्मिक स्थलों के बाहर मिलते हैं और ज्यादा मांगने वाले धार्मिक स्थलों के अंदर...🙏🙏🙏😊