Affordable Backpacking Quilts! Comparing 3 Budget Quilts from Amazon!
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 07. 2024
- If you haven’t heard of backpacking quilts, I’ll be a little surprised. I tried quilts late last year and LOVE them. But the main issue is that backpacking quilts can be EXPENSIVE, which seemed odd to me because budget sleeping bags are very common (but some of them are terrible). Recently 3 backpacking quilts popped up on Amazon, all for less than $80 so I just couldn’t help but order all 3 and test them out. So I’ve got the ayamaya quilt, the One Tigris Featherlight Ultralight quilt, and the onewind Premium XL quilt. I’ve slept in all 3 on multiple nights so I can tell you what I like and don’t like about these 3 budget quilt options!
Have you tried any of these quilts? If so, drop your thoughts in the comments!
📺More Budget Gear Comparisons📺
-Sleeping Bag Showdown: • What is the BEST BUDGE...
-Sleeping Pad Comparison Round 2 (my favorite pad!): • BEST BUDGET SLEEPING P...
-Zero Degree Sleeping Bag Comparison: • 0 Degree Sleeping Bags...
-Winter Sleeping Pad Comparison: • Testing Two Budget Win...
🏕️ 👉 Help Support AND Shape Dose of Dirt through Patreon: / doseofdirt
You can vote in polls to help decide what gear to buy, test, review, and then give away to Patreon members! All gear purchased with Patreon funds will be given away to Patreon members! (Lots of other benefits too!)
📬Want to send something to Dose of Dirt? Send it here:
Jeff at Dose of Dirt
P.O. Box 173
Aldie, VA 20105
🔖Bookmarks🔖
0:00 Intro
1:04 The 3 Budget Quilts We’ll be Comparing
1:47 Intro to the ayamaya budget quilt
2:52 ayamaya sleep test
3:46 Intro to the OneTigris budget quilt
5:44 OneTigris sleep test
6:27 Intro to the onewind budget quilt
8:48 onewind sleep test
9:16 Packed Size Comparison
9:46 Which budget quilt os my favorite
⚙Gear Links⚙
-ayamaya $50 quilt: amzn.to/3szqFZa
-One Tigris Featherlight Ultralight Quilt: amzn.to/383oLIv
-onewind Premium XL Quilt: amzn.to/3L0MVSy
🌄Connect for More Adventures🌄
-Instagram: / dose.of.dirt
REMEMBER, LIFE IS BETTER WITH SOME DIRT IN IT!
Some of the links above are affiliate links. Buying things with the links doesn’t change the amount you pay, but helps support the channel since I would get a percentage of the sale. Thank you so much for supporting Dose of Dirt! - Sport
🏕 👉 Help Support AND Shape Dose of Dirt through Patreon: www.patreon.com/DoseofDirt
You can vote in polls to help decide what gear to buy, test, review, and then give away to Patreon members! All gear purchased with Patreon funds will be given away to Patreon members! (Lots of other benefits too!)
⚙Gear Links⚙
-ayamaya $50 quilt: amzn.to/3szqFZa
-One Tigris Featherlight Ultralight Quilt: amzn.to/383oLIv
-onewind Premium XL Quilt: amzn.to/3L0MVSy
Some of the links above are affiliate links. Buying things with the links doesn’t change the amount you pay, but helps support the channel since I would get a percentage of the sale. Thank you so much for supporting Dose of Dirt!
I really appreciate your focus on budgets items.
Thanks, Marla! I'm glad to hear that! I definitely prefer to spend less money wherever I can and it seems like it's hard to find good info on budget options. That's one reason I wanted to start the channel in the first place! Too many people think they have to spend $1,000 to get decent backpacking gear and so they never try it out!
Thanks so much for watching and for taking the time to leave a comment!
THANK YOU for understanding what “budget” means! All the other budget reviews I’ve seen give “budget” recommendations for ones that cost over $250!
It is great that you test budget items and with your own money. One of my favorite channels for that.
Nice video -- I am glad someone is taking the time to focus on the budget option side of the world. I have been impressed by the value and quality of all 3 brands (I have the top and underquilts from all 3.) Onewind does make some really good stuff for very reasonable prices if you are in the hammock world especially. And my One Tigris chair is probably my favorite camping chair of them all..... The only problem I have with those 3 brands is weight and volume (mostly volume)....If you want to carry a 70l+ plus pack, then those brands will serve you well and the quality is defiantly there as well. I am trying to stay with about a 50l pack - and I just can't make those 3 brands work for me for that. But if I am setting up in the back yard or if I am "camping" instead of packing in.....you can bet I would not hesitate to choose offerings from any one of those 3 companies.
Thanks, Dusty! Glad you appreciate the focus on more budget friendly items! These just end up being the types of gear I typically backpack with because I'm just too cheap to spend more! I took the One Tigris on my last backpacking trip in Shenandoah and it was perfect (took that one because it's warmer at night, so didn't need the warmer ones). As you said, the tough part can be volume and weight (depending on how far your'e going) but plenty of great packs that can fit it all.
Thanks for your comment! Truly appreciated!
4:48- It’s basically keyword stuffing. It says “down” just to try and rank for that keyword so the quilt pops up in more search results. Chinese sellers in particular do stuff like this
Thank you so much for your budget gear videos. They have helped me out so much for my beginner gear
Hey Katherine! I'm so glad to hear that! The cost of backpacking gear can be offputting, but I honestly think you can build a great loadout without breaking the bank. I have a few full budget loadouts coming up.
Let me know if there are any other questions you have or videos you think would be helpful!
Enjoy the trails!
I have the onewind xl quilt and am very impressed with it , I've also used it as a poncho sitting by the fire super nice quilt.
Thanks, Daniel! I think if it had a few more snaps and/or a cinch cord it would have been my fave. But I can definitely see the appeal for being able to wear it. Gets cold quick out there after the sun goes down, so having a quilt that doubles as a blanket/jacket is awesome!
Thanks for watching!
Love your detailed reviews on low budget items also your sense of humor is great. Thanks!
Thanks, Carmen! I'll try to keep them coming, but no promises on good humor... 😆
@@DoseofDirt 😜
I have the Onewind and like it. It's fun to go Poncho-Style too!!
Definitely a good option for big guys and gals. Quilts are the way to go!
Thanks, Nalim! Yes! I LOVE quilts! I definitely feel like I have more room in them, but can still stay warm. Sleeping bags can make me feel claustrophobic now. A quilt with pad straps will stay in place and keep you warm! I don't know if I can ever go back to a bag!
I’ve never looked into these. I can see maybe some pros for warmer weather camping. I guess I better get one and try it out haha. Thanks for the video. 👍🏻
Thanks, Jake! Definitely some great summer options. I LOVE quilts after trying them. I'm planning to do a video about why I prefer quilts over sleeping bags now, ESPECIALLY for summer like you said.
Thanks for watching!
I have the tigris and mine IS 100% DUCK DOWN. As per the description. It also has a polyester LINER, NOT FILLING. This is common to keep the feathers from popping thru the outer layer of material. After using this on a recent trip to 14c I had to uncover my legs in the night to cool off a bit. I love this quilt, because of the compactness and weight. I plan on doing more Motorcycle camping in a hammock and this will definately serve my needs.
Thanks, Steve! I will admit that I've gravitated more towards the One Tigris lately this summer. I'ts just so compact and light and comfortable! Definitely a great quilt!
OneTigris never mention whether their down fillings are ethically sourced. This means you can pretty much assume the birds have been abused. Probably live plucked. I can't bring myself to buy anything by them.
Yo bro hi from Ausralia first n foremost,u got me hooked on your channel with your great sense of humour. " spun with unicorn hair",lol
loved the quilt "bit" :P
Haha! Thanks, Odin!
Good review. I have been thinking about getting a quilt but I had some doubts on how well they work. After seeing how you have to close them I think I will stick with my sleeping bags, they make a lot more sense to me.
Ya, admittedly these budget ones aren't as good with the closure method as nicer quilts. But I know a lot of people prefer bags. Nice that there are so many options!
Thanks
I'm to the point now that I'm just considering using a blanket like I did many years ago
I think just a light blanket works great in the summer! For colder times of year I need more insulation than a light blanket can provide (and I don't want the weight of a heavy blanket).
I think I seen myself in your video 😁👊🏻
You did a really great job on demonstrating all three quilts.
The first quilt , I think I liked the best.
That means you were the best looking dude in the video!
@@DoseofDirt 😁😁
Another great job on your review video.
Thank you! Truly appreciate that!
seem like decent summer options. especially the onewind
Ya, definitely summer options. I think I could take the ayamaya into fall or late spring, but the other two will be strictly summer quilts.
Thanks for watching!
I have the one wind, I am going to sow on some extra straps and loops to have it connect to a sleeping pad.
I like it. It is warm and practical for the weight, feels great.
But. Slips off the body a bit too easily, only one strap at calve height.
A few adaptations make it a great quilt. Cheap too.
I made a 1/2 second cameo! hahah Your getting good with these Amazon finds videos man!
Yessir! Easy to see who I watch on CZcams just based on the results of my 'backpacking quilt' search! 😆
LOL! Great video.
Thanks, Damarias! Who says reviewing gear can't be fun? 😂
I’ve got the one Tigris quilt! Says 20 degree I think?? I can verify that I’m super warm in mine
I bought the onetigeress and it got a bit chilly. I almost took my poler fleece blanket but then it would have been quite bulky
I like the concept of the concept of using it like a warm poncho of the onewind, but wish it completely closed on the back.
Ya, that would be a nice feature for colder months!
Nice shirt!
Ha! Thanks dude! I like it even more because you were there when we earned it together!
Thanks For showing the Celsius
Thanks, Leigh!
The one that turns into a Pancho is a cool idea ,, iv personally never had any experience with a quilt.
I love quilts! Seriously, I don't think I'll ever use a bag again. I just feel like I get so twisted up inside them. I'm all about the quilt now!
@@DoseofDirt I'm going to have to try one
Crazy, I could NOT do the fastenings behind your back thing, that is flawed. Ideally then, a square sleeping bag with a zip all of the way around that can open as a quilt is the way to go, I have one, Snugpak navigator.
Not the way to do it. Snap in front and stick your head through. I do it wearing a Bipap mask.
Twist quilt, Velcro, twist back. 👍🏼
I'm looking into the onetigris quilt. I need the synthetic fill version due to a down allergy.
The 50 dollar one is discontinued could you recommend another ? Thank you for Budget stuff appreciate it
Lol I was actually thinking about whether to get a quilt or a better sleeping bag . Looked at the onetigris but ended up getting a down bag. Walked into a camping store in the mall the other day looking for something else and it was on sale for almost half off , less than a cup of coffee more than the quilt and warmer and lighter too, and no waiting for delivery 😁
Hey Shawn! Have to love it when you just walk into a deal like that! If you're not in a hurry when buying gear, waiting for a sale can save some serious money! I definitely prefer the quilts at this point, but there's something to be said for the warmth of a sleeping bag!
Thanks for watching!
@@DoseofDirt it's a semi rectangular with a hood and a two way zipper so good room and venting options, there was a mummy bag for the same price, a little lighter but not by enough to be worth sacrificing the extra space
@@shawnr6117 Nice! Love me some new gear! And the fact you didn't have to wait for delivery is awesome!
I feel like you're the only one doing videos like this, and it's great. I hope you keep making videos.
Don't have the Onewind quilt...All my quilts are down and lightweight but I will say the Onewind hammock and tarp are as good as there is on the market and very affordable...
Hi Jeff, Do any of the quilts have pad straps? It looks like you could fashion some kind of shock cord with the closures in the back, I also look for something like a draft collar around the neck and the cinch cord is vital to trapping in the heat. Thanks for the review :-)
Hey Darren! None of them have pad straps, which I was a bit disappointed by, but I have already tried a few things with shock cord using the attachments that are there (on the ayamaya and the One Tigris). My other two quilts (Hammock Gear and Paria) both have pad straps, and I really like them. They make a big difference when it's a little chillier and are one of my favorite things about quilts!
Thanks for watching!
you should do a comparison on cotton sleeping pads/mats but used on tent floor rather than on a camping bed as they are designed to be used both ways. Would make a good alternative to the usual pads/mats. 2 to check out are from kingcamp and redcamp. I would pair with foam pad though not necessary.
Interesting! I haven't used those cotton pads before. I wasn't even aware they existed since I'm more of a backpacker than a car camper, but they look super comfortable and would probably work fantastic with a quilt!
@@DoseofDirt I'm going to try out the kingcamp one while backpacking in the summer.
@@GMiller75 nice! Would love to hear how you end up liking it!
hey, awsome video! Maybe consider cutting the music during talking sections? keep up the greater content!
I'm really interested in the onewind all the onewind gear I've gotten is pretty decent
Hey Evan! I don't think I was aware of onewind until I saw this quilt. I guess I need to pay more attention! The quality seems good. I think it would have been my favorite if it had just a few more snaps down the back. Plus who doesn't like wearing it around camp?! 🤣
Thanks as always for your comment!
@@DoseofDirt I'm really interested in the hammock tarp they offer
@@DoseofDirt the onewind seems to be designed to work as a system with their hammocks.
@@Summitperry Yes, it can definitely be used that way, which is nice. The versatility is good because it can be used for both. So far I'm just a ground dweller, but for a hammocker the onewind would be the way to go between these 3 I think.
I think if it had some shock cord along the shoulders I would have liked it a lot more, but it's a good quilt for what it is.
Nice budget comparison Jeff! Have you tried either the Aegis Max or the Nature Hike bag/quilt? They're around $100, pack small, weigh around 19 ozs and can get you down to around 50 degrees.
Hey Dave! I have thought about trying those, but really wanted something that could get me down to 40 degrees. I still may give them a shot because 19 ounces if half the weight of any of these!
You thinking about giving them a go?
@@DoseofDirt Nice! You can combo up a S2S liner to add 10-14 degs for around 8-9 ozs and still be lighter. I have the Nature Hike quilt/bag. Got it because of it's ability to open all the way up and use as a wrap sort of like your poncho here 🤣 I need to do more weather testing with it to really narrow in the comfort range.
@@DaveOffGrid Looking forward to hearing your thoughts about it!
I was wondering if anyone else would mention AegisMax. I got the Nano2 a couple years ago for $85. Since it doesn't have a hood, it can be unzipped and used like a quilt with a sewn footbox. Perfectly comfortable at 40 degrees, weighs 22oz. Unfortunately, it's pretty rare to find it that cheap these days.
The Enlightened equipment revelation apex 30 is in my opinion the best quilt under $200.
Thanks, Kyle! I've thought about picking up an enlightened equipment quilt, but ended up going with a Hammock Gear Econ Burrow for now. It was also $200. You can't beat the warmth to weight ratio of real down!
What do you like about your revelation??
Thanks for watching!
@@DoseofDirt I should have said best synthetic quilt. But I personally prefer synthetic as I don't like having to baby my gear (which you kind of have to do with down)
@@kylemckinney_22 Sometimes synthetic just makes more sense! You're right that you have to baby down. I find I never really think about my sythetic fill bags/quilts, but the down ones I stress out more about condensation, etc.
@@DoseofDirt Yeah I live in the blue ridge mountain area and it pretty humid most of the year, plus I use a single wall tent, so synthetic just makes sense for me.
@@kylemckinney_22 Can't argue with you there! I'm still figuring out how to deal with the humidity over here in Virginia since most of my previous backpacking was in Utah where it is DRY!
U deserve way more views...
Hey! Can't tell you how much I appreciate the support!
@@DoseofDirt My pleasure!
you might have done this vid but are you planning to make vid about pillow showdown?
@@tlcairsoft4703 I have been thinking about it, but haven't put it on the schedule yet, but I really should. I've done at least one video one very other part of the sleep system, it's probably high time to talk about some pillows! Thanks!
Brother where can I find the Ayamaya quilt, it's no where on Amazon? Thanks for the info
Can quilts be stored in compression sacks or should they be stored open like sleeping bags?
Whuts the best fillin material? As in least finnakey?whut requires the least care?love down,but killed mine in a stuff sack...
Should compare these to the Paria Thermodown quilts. Those Paria ones and the current king of the budget quilt crowd.
You read my mind! I think it would do well in the comparison but the Paria might have it beat on warmth. I also have Hammock Gear Econ Burrow that is rated for 40 degrees that I’m planning to compare. Been thinking about doing several videos comparing the nudge option to a more expensive option (quilts, backpacks, sleeping pads). Sometimes the budget option can be just as good AND save you tons of money!
Thanks for watching and for taking the time to leave a comment! Truly appreciated!
@@DoseofDirt I own the Hammock Gear Efon 40, 20 and 0F quilts all excellent products.
Keep doing what you're doing being the anti-Dan Becker. Channels likes yours, Outdoor Gear Review and Homemade Wanderlust are appreciated for your honest non-sponsored reviews.
@@lakorai2 Thank you! And DANG, to even be thought of in the same comment as Homemade Wanderlust and The Outdoor Gear Review makes me blush!
That's awesome you have all 3 of those HG Econs. I have actually thought I would eventually have those same ones (40, 20, and 0). I think my next purchase will probably be the HG Econ Burrow zero degree. The price is insanely good for the weight and quality with DWR treated down!
Given the weight for these what is the advantage over a sleeping bag? I already use my bags in the summer zipped open mostly replicating this style. Are these only targeted for hammocks? As always appreciate what you do. Your sticker looks lovely on my 2 burner propane stove.
Hey Dudly! thanks for your comment! That is an excellent question that I'll admit I didn't think about.
I agree that at these weights I don't think there is a weight advantage for these quilts over a sleeping bag. But I do think the Ayamaya quilt is better and warmer than any sleeping bag I've tried for less than $50.
And for me the quilt is more comfortable. I only have mummy sleeping bags, so opening them up all the way isn't quite the same. I do think that these are targeted at hammockers, but also work well for us ground dwellers.
The other advantage to quilts for me is the straps, but none of these have any. I'm planning to try making my own with some shock cord. I like how the straps make it stay in place if I'm tossing and turning at night (which I often do...).
Thanks for sporting the dose of dirt sticker!
Always appreciate your comments!
You make the snap behind the neck look harder than it really is. Bring both corners to the front, snap it and stick your head through. I manage it with a full face mask Bipap and all the usual tubing so it can’t be that hard. I haven’t decided if I agree on the cinch cord up top or not. I can see some definite safety reasons NOT to have it especially given the kind of cord they use at the bottom.
I love this piece of gear. Nice comparative review though.
that song you were trying to sing at the end was from the muppets, mahna mahna lol
Glad I'm not the only one that hears that when I say 'ayamaya'! 😆 Muppets for the win! 🤣
An overhead shot of the quilts in ‘sleeping mode’ would have been useful. Together with a rule.
Thank you! This is a great idea! I'll try to include that in future reviews for quilts, bags, and pads! Much appreciated!
Thanks for watching!
Where can I get that hat?!
Aren't you supposed to fixate the footbox to the sleeping pad?
Have you tried the feather stone top quilt?
I have not had the chance to try their quilt yet, but I'd like to! I have two quilts from Hammock Gear. I wait for them to have 30% off sales and then they are much more affordable.
@@DoseofDirt agree. Lot of times I find used on eBay or sales or just save up. Depends what am looking for. Need to weed out unused stuff this spring. Hold on to what works
Wow. Marketing at its finest. Featherlight quilt has no feathers! 😂
🤣 I didn't even think about that! And I'm not sure something that weighs over 2 lbs should be called 'featherlight ultralight' ... But hey, I guess it's the lightest of these 3 at least!
Thanks for watching!
Ayamaya
Weird…. It’s like you read my mind !
haha! You can always count on me looking for a bargain! 😂
Dodo dodo dodo dodo
Welcome to the Gearlight Zone 👻
@@shawnr6117 🤣🤣🤣
Why not just unzip a sleeping bag and use it like a quilt? Genuine question.
Coz like I reckon I could pick up a quality 2nd hand down bag for bargain and modify it to be a quilt?
You definitely could! It wouldn't quite be the same, but you could use it that way!
@@DoseofDirt would it differ in effect, or just in the minor details such as hood placement and the lack of quilt specific hard ware like straps for under pad etc?
He picked Ayamaya there I saved you time.
Guess I should have made the video just 5 seconds long... 🤣
I let this slide because it was cold 🥶 why didn't you do that thing when your in a rush and you have put you t-shirt on backwards so you take your arms out but not your head and spin it around...😜
Good walk through of entry level gear 👍
😂😂😂 I should have done that!
@@DoseofDirt 👍⛺
I think I’ll be a stubborn “bagger” the rest of my life, just because. 😅
Stick to your guns! But just know that I'll continue to tempt you with quilt reviews and comparisons... 😆
I don't think quilts work for everyone, but for me they are amazing. The biggest thing is turning around and changing positions. I just couldn't do it in a bag without a ton of effort, but in a quilt it's so much easier. I probably change sleeping positions 5-6 times during the night so this makes a big difference for me.
@@DoseofDirt I’m a back sleeper who sleeps like a corpse and doesn’t move 😂. You can’t even tell where I’ve slept in a bed some times because the 1/2 of a bed I use is completely untouched.
@@GIRLplusDOGAdventures "like a corpse" 😆 Sounds like a bag is the way to go then!
Donyou sell any of your equipment i know u have alot of extra stuff an im trynna save some cash i wanna get started with backpacking an camping
???
I find it funny for a company like monsanto to be used with sustainable. gmo'd quilt? lol
Balance? 😂
eye-ah... my ah... as in Maya or I am 'igher (thats how Id say it but then I'm English)
I didn't even think to pronounce the 'maya' part like 'maya'. 😂🤦♂ You're probably right!
@@DoseofDirt You're my new goto for gear reviews btw. Love the channel.
@@DoseofDirt You emphasise the 3rd syllable: eye-ah-MA-ya. Chinese doesn't really work that way, but if you emphase the 3rd syllable in English, that's close enough. And you got the sounds exactly right, it's "Ma", not "My" sound. The meaning is something like "Oh my goodness!!", like if you're surprised or in awe. To me it's a terrible, jokey "meme" name for a brand, but what do I know? 😆 And thanks for the great reviews!
You need a better microphone my dude, your voice has a weird pitch with this one that makes it harder to understand what you're saying
Thanks for the feedback!
Go to the next price tier, under $150 price point. Any sensible B-packer would not debate the point of "you get the lightness and warmth you pay for!"