Is India China’s Biggest Threat? - Subramanian Swamy
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2021
- Patrick Bet-David sits down with Subramanian Swamy, he is an Indian politician, economist and member of Parliament in the upper house of Indian Parliament. In this interview they talk about India's economic growth, their relationship with China and what the future of India will look like.
Check out Dr. Swamy's book: amzn.to/2TBOH6H
Recommended video:
- Patrick Bet-David Keynote: Mumbai, India: • Patrick Bet-David Keyn...
- The Most Powerful Woman in India - Arundhati Bhattacharya: • The Most Powerful Woma...
About guest: Subramanian Swamy is an Indian politician, economist and statistician, who serves as a nominated Member of Parliament in Rajya Sabha, the upper house of the Indian Parliament. Before joining politics, he was a professor of Mathematical Economics at the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi.
Music selection used through agreement with Epidemic Sound bit.ly/2B8DxK1
Make sure to subscribe to Valuetainment for the updates: bit.ly/2aPEwD4
To reach the Valuetainment team you can email: info@valuetainment.com
About Valuetainment:
Founded in 2012 by Patrick Bet-David, our goal is to impact entrepreneurs around the world through value and entertainment. We are the #1 channel for entrepreneurs because of the best interviews, best how to videos, best case studies and because we defend capitalism and educate entrepreneurs.
Follow Patrick on social media:
Website: www.patrickbetdavid.com
Facebook: / patrickbetdavid.valuet...
Instagram: / patrickbetdavid
Twitter: / patrickbetdavid
Linkedin: / patrick-bet-david-3731553
#PatrickBetDavid #Valuetainment
Will India pass up China?
No
No, Indian politics won't allow it. Mark my words, India will be way behind even if you are reading this comment after 15-20 years.
The USA needs Mexico and they would rule the world for at least another 200 years
100% India will pass China.
Maybe not in the next 10-15 years, maybe longer than that.
If the Indian government can make some drastic changes, they yeah, India will overtake China.
Yes but not in 10 years but definitely in 20-30 years
Once India gets out of its own way, nothing can stop it. I've been saying this for years. I can't wait for India to surpass China in terms of real GDP. Cutting-edge manufacturing and supply chain technology, stable and modern monetary policy, accommodative infrastructure build-out are all key to their success. One of the youngest age demographics in the world, this is a once-in-a-lifetime moment to harness this resource and educate these young people to build India to its full potential. This American is rooting for you, India.
Thanks Man!!
God bless America!!
Yes West made China rich for 30yrs since it does not have borders. Now west is shifting Silicon Chip fabs & Giga factories back to west and India will be super power nice plan.
🙏🙏
Well analyzed, we are A Grade self sabotaging masochistic idiots sometimes.
India is a machine that has been engineered to destroy itself.
He is probably the only member of the BJP who openly criticizes prime minister Modi.
True.... And thts what I like about him... They should make this man financial minister
@@bhuvaneshs.k638 never haha
@@bhuvaneshs.k638 never ever
All is well that ends well
Seriously,There are many BJP supporters and members who criticize Modi/BJP/Ministers and even tag them. Go sometime on Twitter in Right Wing zone to see that.
The collective enthusiasm among Indians for India is a happy reminder for me of the enthusiasm Americans had during the 1950-60s. Today, many young people in America are ashamed of their country, converting into anti-America haters with the enthusiasm of a brand-new convert. This is a bad place to be.
Never imagined that US will end up this way. I used to wonder how big empires like Roman Empire collapsed. Now I know.
i agree you should abandon the marxists and post-modernists they ll kill your nationalism . we indians love the usa as its the best country in the world.
I was surprised to see a video of Indians scolding someone for littering, it is possible for a society to change when enough people want the change. I think we will eventually get up with the toxic environment and scold the nut jobs in America
yeah because the limited history of america is tainted in blood but thankyou for modern democracy and state capatalism
Sir, the American people's enthusiasm got brainwashed by America's own elite university. The Marxist theory is being taught at elite universities.
I want Indians to be prosperous, healthy, and happy; I want to see India as a friend to every other nation... This is just as I see it. I'm fed-up with the war/destruction going on...nations competing with each other...to globally dominate..."leaders" do what they do...common people get killed/suffer...I find this stupidity ridiculous...
True. Beyond everything, India has life. Having lived elsewhere, I do not find the same vibrance. Late night pubs and lots of alcohol is not vibrancy according to me.
for God's sake recognise your potential now
That's when you become a superpower!
When every Indian is healthy, happy, and prosperous!
When you are a model to others!
There are no friends in geopolitics
This comment is ridiculous
His biggest power is being truthful and accepting the wrongs
India is emerging superpowers country. India poverty ratio 6% less than USA and India eliminated extreme poverty rates say by IMF reports. India lifted over 400 mn poverty sayed by Germany foreign minister. India is boosting every sector. India is largest democracy in the world. India is IT hub. India is digital superpowers country. USA and many countries required to India to give UPI system. India launched own 5G technology. With the help of 5G technology India leading the world. beat China to cost and accuracy in manufacturing. India is fastest growing economy in the world. Every countries facing heavy crises except India. America and China traps to gdp ratio is 200% mean both traps is more than gdp. India is not facing any kind of traps. China already very dangerous economy signs and China economy rapidly falling down. China falls it's own debt trap. India is global leader. India is acquired G20 presidency and many other organizations. IMF said India economy show best performance in the world other hand evening countries going to heavy recessions and crisis. Lot of things learn from India says by IMF president. World countries demand India to gets permanent seats in UNSC. India definitely become permanent members of UNSC in future. India is emerging as top investment destination says by sovereign investors. India eye on 33 trillion dollars investment. World countries appreciate India policy. China and UAE diplomatic big fans of India foreign policy. India is becoming manufacturing king. India made own defense weapons and exports very rapidly in the world. Make In India, Atmanirbhar Bhat, New nation logistics policy, Gati Shakti and PLI schemes make India manufacturing hub.Every thing India manufactur and exports world wide. India exports reached 2 trillion dollars in 2030. India is become 3rd largest economies in 2027. China manufacturing sector is destroyed by its China bad policy. India replaces to China in manufacturing sector says by IMF president. India's ISRO is most successful space agency after NASA. In future ISRO beat NASA in space tourist because of ISRO mission is very low cost and high efficiency than NASA. In future space sector is trillion dollars market. ISRO now capture this market. India already leading in science and technology. India in already IT hubs. You can't show Bangalore silicon city, Hyderabad, Mumbai and beautiful cities in India. Space technology, manufacturing and IT is coming future and India is master in this field. So India is economically beat China and America. Already both America and China facing many crisis. Both economy economy is very dangerous issues. Stop showing to India.
Every countries is not perfect. Many issues in India but still India is emerging and rising superpowers country. Putin, Biden, Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, Elon Musk says future belongs to India. I am proud my Indian 🇮🇳
Oh please we all know Swami is bullshtng about everything.
He's certainly not an ediot but his biggest problem is his ego that got hurt when modi didn't give him ministerial position and i can see why. Thank God!
In 2017 under modi Indian troops went and stopped Chinese road construction on Bhutanese territory.
Not on indian but Bhutans territory.
In galwan and ever since that it's india under modi thats confronting Chinese.
Maybe Swami doesn't remember but i do. During previous governments rule Chinese use to come and grab territories just like now but did you see this level of confrontation back then?
On covid vaccines, economy everything you judge after a year how wrong Swami was.
Subramanian Swamys bloated ego is his biggest enemy and precisely why Modi kept him out of the government.
he is not truthful he is just another politician , you should learn about his history and the way he double speak .
Yes that's why we need people like him
@@MrBiltoria Realised mistakes to change your stance doesn't mean double standards
I've worked in the casino for 10 years and let me say, I have never came across a race that gambles harder then the Chinese.
Indians don't gamble like that , they are bit conservative while playing. Mostly because of some religious beliefs associated with gambling.
Our religious epic poem( Mahabharata) predicted that gambling match is fixed so invitees will lose match anyway and it will invite the war. That's why we are most conservative while gambling
Thanks
That's a genetic thing lol
@@niccwhite cultural*
@@sagarpatel3962 He was not talking about Indians he is talking about Chinese.
GOD Bless India! The USA Loves You All!
🔥ttam🤣
Usa- United States of asshôlés😂
God Bless America.... An Indian Citizen here,
God Bless USA too.
Which god? I heard a million gods in India
God Bless 🇺🇸
Dr Swamy is a walking plethora of knowledge. Such an insightful interview, I sure learnt a couple of pointers. I wish Peace upon every country and every person. God bless all.
czcams.com/video/MCyBL8dBOEo/video.html u mean he is insightful to say Muslims are not in the equal category under India's constitution?
India has ton of potential but Politicians and Bureaucrats are screwing it up !
Some blame lies local population,who are willing to be divided by region, religion and corruption,as practised by several conquerers.
Yes , it's damn true. China have only bi party system but india have multi party system . And you know this local minister or MLA's can do for just out seat.
No one wants to become politician in this country and tag politics as a dirty game.
Then you expect sincere politicians.
"As you sow,so as you reep."
And cast reservation :)
specially in education department ...politicians are not qualified to make laws on education in INDIA GODDAMITT!!
“Income tax gets you hardly anything, except harassment” 👌👌😂
He is a vehement supporter of Abolishing Income tax entirely
@Atheist when you don’t earn why should you bother . In all cases, only the father pays . When do you pay 30%? Only after claiming standard deduction of Rs50,000/ and 1,50,000/for various savings . Upto net income of 5,00,000/tax is levied only at20% . So it is only after the gross income is more than 7 lakh one has to pay @30% on the amount in excess of 7 lakhs . This is so for salaried person. If it is income from business or business, mostly people make all kinds of deduction and invariably pay tax on a fraction of their income. Let the bridge come then you can cross it. First equip yourself.
@Abhi Raj you must be rich then.
Hahahaha sad but true
It's the second biggest source of tax receipts for government after corporate tax... Economists are past the debate of income tax. I suggest we develop on the lines of Scandinavian countries than American.
I love Indian people I’m Cuban and Italian I lived in America since I’ve been born and I absolutely really hope we get an alliance with India and cut China out completely!!🇺🇸
If India and the US learn to trust each other and commit to each other, we can together define a better future for the world.
If (India develops an education system properly), then (India can overtake China in 10 - 15 years). I approve this message, what a high IQ statement.
And India will develop an education system in 10 15 years, so that totals 30 years.
India supa powah 2050??
True that bro! After all, if the biggest tech companies of the world are headed by Indians, clearly our level of innovation is at par with Americans, South Koreans and Japanese. But I couldn't agree more that our education system needs major reforms. Thats the only reason why solid visionaries leave for America after completing their graduation!
@@Egomorph1987 South Koreans and Japanese will deeply deeply ashamed by your comment LOL😆 What innovations do you even have ?
@@yushyangng6751 My apologies. What I meant was the potential of innovation. But do you really think non-innovative people can head companies like Google, Microsoft, Adobe, Mastercard etc.? And please don't be under the misconception that mocking other people makes you look cool.
High IQ???🤣🤣🤣🤣 Google global IQ rank please
I like the fact that he openly criticised Modi’s weakness and the party’s shortcomings. Respect!
I dont like he criticise modi
@Shekar Lakshman Swamy is well wisher of BJP, that's why he criticise shortcomings of this government
He shud bee made Finanace Minister
And he is from Modi's party
@Shekar Lakshman BJP needs an intellectual like swami
Current finance minister is good for nothing so she relies on babu(beaurocrats), and you know how corrupt beaurocrat are
Guy like swami deserves to be finance minister
@Shekar Lakshman only minster which has done good work is NITIN GADKARI , PIYUSH GOYAL is also good but rest of the minister arenot good
So we need good finance minister like swamy
Great interview. Nice to hear a guest that knows what he is talking about and not just pushing his politics.
True. Subramanian Swamy is known for speaking facts.
I'm on the fence about his push for Nuclear power stations. One side is they don't take up much land but generate tons of steam power. The other side is It takes only one meltdown to cause decades of fallout.
@@RoodeMenon Subramanian Swamy mentioned the need to develop thorium based nuclear reactors. For one thing India is sitting on 40% of the worlds thorium deposits. Secondly thorium reactors are much safer options for nuclear energy. There is less radioactive waste and it stays active for a shorter period, operation can take place at much less pressure and the process can be stopped instantaneously unlike uranium reactors. This would have drastically changed the outcome of what happened in Fukushima.
If India can make itself a leader in building an maintaining thorium based reactors, we could build them for the world. Another benefit is that thorium reactors don’t produce plutonium as a byproduct which is needed for nuclear weapons.
@@prithvi24 We have US imposed sanctions against mining our Thorium.
@@zoomzoom7444Cant you see that he just defends for his ruling party.India struggles in vaccinating people and all he states that ,india is a leading vaccine manufacturer.The central Govt has given up on vaccinating the 18 to 45yrs age group and they just shoved the responsibility on States,without giving any fund.His speech is full of Shit about so many things. If a man speaks clearly in english,doesnt means he's speaking facts. BJP guys have the worst philosphy about indians future and they act like are the saviour of india.
India will undoubtedly pass China with blink of an eye. Swami is genius!
I’m blinking. Nothing is happening. Maybe you’ve got your eyes closed and are dreaming
@@DARKONE710he said will not now
India's core problem is bureaucracy. Govt comes and goes, policies change but the implementation of these policies never truly happen due to this juggernaut bureaucratic system... This needed to be changed.
Swamy....he didn’t choose THUG LIFE....THUG LIFE chose him....all hail Swamy Ji!
Stupid Fellow, he is supporting a school thats under harassment charges..
A very very direct person…..I mean straight to the point types!
Swamy doesn’t sugar coats
BS
He is overrated
Jai Shri Ram, Jai Swamy Ji, Jai Bharat.
India's biggest problem was it used to follow the socialist way till 1990's and now although we're a mixed economy but the bureaucracy is too much. These trade unions are also nothing but burden
Your name though 😂😝🤣
Socialism was not the problem, the problem was the licence raj...
Which didn't allow businesses to grow, eventually making india weaker...
Even Denmark and Norway follow socialism and they didn't fail
@@anuragsrivastava8633 😂
@@musicstudy7610 Denmark and Norway doesn't follow socialism,they follow free market economy which means capitalism they just tax everyone equally that's what socialist policy is there. See economic freedom index they're way higher than USA which is capitalist.more Bureaucracy comes from socialism. We don't have to be full capitalist we can just give free education that's it
@@musicstudy7610 bro denmark is a socialist country!!!!!Lmao. Denmark PM himself said in an interview that he hates when some people call Scandinavian nations a socialist country. They are free market economies, not socialist economies....
One of the most honest politician with a good brain in india.
If India would have been the second superpower like China and China would have been like India, then USA and EU would see China as their ally and India as their enemy.
I guess you understood what I'm trying to say.
Agree. From inside they are pirates.
No it won't happen establishment is planning to break China and it can be possible only by helping India
India was always seen as a threat by western powers not because India will attack them, it's because India is capable of growing far beyond them.
I wonder if India being a democracy changes things.
@@ranguy1379 It doesn't look at Saudi Arabia...
Bureaucracy and illiterate politicians are India’s major weakness.
What do you get when you mix Globalism and illiteracy? Modi.
Leadership =/= Literacy
Political illiteracy which inturn have direct correlation with the people who vote for mandir, masjid & gimmicks are the real underlying issue. ......... Nothing more nothing less....
India focus on your people not china, China is ahead of India....in future.
2021 India suffering from virus which has no oxygen supplies no bed and no hospital people are dying and suffering from pain crying 🤣😂🤣😂.
2021 china building space station... successful land rover on Mars, China changing the future but India bring back the stone age 😂🤣.
U know what India is like baby need to depends other western country for help. What a loser 😂🤣😂India.
India just keep supporting Made in China economy and technology.
@@eshwarashawn4493 PKMKB
Subramanian Swamy entered the Ram Mandir case and produced an unbeatable argument that paved the way to Build Ram Mandir.
Rams birth place is kosala
Also, Swamy is a great man but didn’t actually do anything officially in the Ramjanmabhoomi case
This aaSwamy will claim everything to boost his pride
@@mahendraperiyadanam3801 rama watching, will punish who claim false credit, just like modi went on stage to do puja and not allowing anyone to come on stage. Abv died a bad death by claiming voted in the name of rama
Truth always in that way
As a Chinese, I have lots of indian friends. My observation is that most Indian are very smart and hardworking. However, when they are teaming together, everyone has a very big ego and the team sometimes falls apart.
Individually speaking, Indians are of great potential of success. But when put into a group, sometimes things are not working out because of everyone has big ego.
Indians definately have great potential since each indicidual are great, but a lot of times, they need to put away their big ego since teamwork is what really matters.
As indian i agrees with you
Very true
Absolutely
No, that is not main problem. Main problem is that admin is bad and not of same standard everywhere.
( ego problem is there but it is not main problem)
Well i agree with you...In india when a guy becomes rich people start to pull him down. In a way we are like crabs and we must change
Yes. Interest rates are too high. I was shocked when I first heard an American youtuber calling 5% expensive!!
Inflation in America and India are also very different
The most fearless man in Indian politics and the most fearless promoter of capitalism in one video. I LOVE IT!
2:15 introduction, who is Subramanian Swamy
4:41 which politician of US would Mr Swamy be compared to?
5:34 what changes India gone through in last 60years (Here he speaks about India could overtake China in next 15 years)
8:34 who is Gandhi to you?
10:36 you call modi economically naive? If you were his finance minister what recommendations would you make?
26:00 Market playbook of China vs US
31:06 don't you think America empowered china and got world to heavily rely on it?
33:30 India needs 1.2 billion doses of vaccine for covid19 and there is one place to go (China)
37:00 what does India rely on China for?
43:30 what is the long term action against china? Whether India is going to side with us or join china or stand on its own?
49:00 Do you think china is waiting for modi to lose elections and then grab more lands of your country?
53:50 what concerns you more does religious ideologies imposed on your country or philosophy of another country imposed on your country concern you more? *(It seems The host does not know that Hinduism is the majority religion of India... Mr. Swamy clearifies that)*
59:47 you once said if Muslim population is more than 30% then the whole population is in danger explain
1:05:40 what is the biggest threat the US faces in your perspective?
you're awesome, thanks for this!
Thank you
Thank you lad ❤️
Thank you
100th like
I do realize, the only way Indian economy could flourish would be to adopt extreme-right oriented policies, adopt free-market economy, the problem is not with BJP or Modi or others, the problem is with left-leaning ideologies in India of almost every political party, some more left, some lesser left, and people having no knowledge of busiuness, production, et.c and also the population load of the predominantly socialistic country, even after years of oppression (both mughal and british), that is it!!
Rightly said !!!!
But now, we are reforming away from socialism and more towards a market economy . And extreme right wing economics cannot be adopted overnight...
@@EragonShadowSlasher yes they have been much better than before, although they r not complete right but more of centrist approach sort of, but still its better !!
there will be always left and right .. deal with it...
@@udhayakumarMN yeah but there is no economic right in india... bjp is at best centrist economically... and the other parties are basically socialists
I admire the optimism of Indian intellectuals to point out the shortfall of the Chinese Economy. I hope the same wisdom could be share to make India a more prosperous country. catching up to her northern neighbor as the gap between these two giant nations is widening each passing year.
india is an example why china didn't adopt western liberal democracy
@Amartya Shankar India’s is an example of lack of leadership
@@SanSha2100 you have a choice of leadership in your country ?
@@SanSha2100 , You have plenty of choices? What is the outcome? Verbosity!
@@levelazn Lets See who will won The long race.Dont forget who are the one taught you guys wisdom in ancient times .Very Bad students 😆😆😆
Subramanian Swamy is an author, politician, economist, statistician and a perfect bad ass!
And a lawyer with 100% win track record..
Well said well said well said, and well said
Johnny sins ka bap
@@rudrajeet814 no many of his cases have been thrown out by the judiciary.
Just talks and theory?
He's straight forward blunt either u like it or hate it
He’s what the world needs right now🏝
Love to hear him though
He is amazing! Intelligent, bold, honest and the list goes on. Respect 🙏🏻
This is one of the best intellectual conversations I've seen in recent times with an Indian 🇮🇳 economist. 🙏 Subramanium Sir is savvy....😎 point is If we truly want to push India to global power beyond China, India needs to adopt practical capitalism, stop religious conflicts, and have better planning and policies for the people of 🇮🇳 , Only then will people feel to giveaway back and eventually grow faster.
Thank You for the knowledge, guruji. You just saved India's future.
Finally your got the man that is fearless in Indian politics and such a well educated person!!
He is one the best we have .
Is this really a question? The arrogance of turban, sandNa$. India wants to be the new pet of America, trying to be the new Israel. India wants to Invent an enemy for the west, we drag them out for the mud houses and in return they fight China. The problem is that Israel had this planned out for hundred of years and they are very smart.
@@jamesbolton7617 nothing much I wanna say but Israel got freedom in 1948
Lol he is an idiot. His predictions never worked.
mobile.twitter.com/Swamy39/status/439759483632250880
mobile.twitter.com/Swamy39/status/366591518624067584
@Meer davis thats quite funny, considering India is about to ban western social media fir not restricting freedom of speech, as they are willing for the Americans...
India, great culture ,get your act together and be in the place you deserve.. long live India and its good people..
Thanks buddy, Love from india 🇮🇳
@U1 Uz porkistan and cryna should worry about themselves first.
Great culture how?
@@KenHuyn arts architecture medicine math astrology, longest continuous civilization in the planet yet known..they have great potential and have resisted the intromission of external powers and the Muslim hordes thru centuries long live India.lol that's how ..
Imo, India needs a systemic change. The territorial provincial&local leaders need to be paid on the basis of a percentage of GNP of their area territory or province etc. They need a vested interest in the financial success of their area rather than a vested interest in systems that impede financial success.
Also,
1:06:50 He hit the nail on the head .
That's the china model leads to unsustainable projects empty cities just for show kind of stuff
One of best interview on the CZcams in the recent years. I have lots of love, respect to Dr Swamy for his honest talk. He is still having the fresh economic mindset.
He's one of the most educated MP's in India. He deserves to head India's finance ministry.
With Nationalist PM Modi...Yes...this moron Swamy says Modi has no economic sense..such arrogance this person has... He will do anything for an MLA seat...He was the one who broke the Vajpayee government with a teaparty...he promises to do that again ..he just serves the CIA and Chinese... He is useless
His book Reset is laughable ..
India is the only country after Modi took PM, to lift 16 crore people out of abject poverty in just 7 years... Direct transfer and digital transfer into their Bank Accounts... No middlemen anymore... Farmers have the same international laws now in contrast to the mandi or socialists system which the colonial congress used and this so called economist still tries. He is nothing but an arrogant, rogue petty old man..
His daughter writes for the Hindu and she day in amd day out writes anti-national articles .... This guy is just a paper stamp
@@hansl244 national PM or marketing genius?
@@hansl244 MODI HAS ABSOLUTELY NO KNOWLEDGE OF ECONIMICS
@@theniravpanchal whatever you said is perfectly inferable from his statements, but whatever he said about russian economy, China's aggression on indian borders are backed by facts so we have to negate or weaken those facts to weaken his argument
@@theniravpanchal although I am not a supporter of BJP, but one of the economic survey of India, I think of 2016-17 mentioned China's assembling capacity, not producing capacity, so I think whatever he is saying is true,
And in fact I don't have any formal background of economics, but whatever I studied for my exam preparation, I am looking with that knowledge and to me he seems right in whatever he said about economy
This should have been a 3-hour interview
If i'm PM i hire this man. No one Congress BJP not one see Indian potential they are just seeing their ways to stay in power
He is one of the biggest hypocrite in Indian politics. He can't be trusted.
@@rishavbarnwal7155 India needs to trust your words of wisdom and should make you the finance minister of India.
"We have 150 million cows and they give an average of 200 liters per year. One Israeli cow gives you 11.000 liters per year. So I believe India's potential is tremendous..." Poor holy cows, what a future awaits them...
Don't burst your neurons over it... you... you see turtles 🐢 Don't fly... 😆
😂😂😂 cow as an example wow
Metaphors dude🤷
Very impressed with this interview. The USA needs India and we should do a weapons deal ASAP. There is zero reason Turkey should have our airplanes and NOT India.
There is just one problem. Americans do not really respect Indians deep down in their hearts. Once Nixon called Mrs. Gaudy a witch. That says all.
@@emmawang1999 Mrs. Gaudy? Wtf is Gaudy?
Who is "our"?
And why shouldn't they?
Did you ask India if they even want your weapons or they prefer Russian weapons
(s400)
Everyone's a gangsta until Mr Swamy walks in. 😀
Well said, Jayesh 👌
But we should call him as
Dr. Swamy...
Was kicked out of Harvard for being racist.
@@rdas072 hahaha Harvard couldn't digest the truth Dr.Swamy said, they want political correctness n hypocrisy.
Dr.Swamy is unbiased n to the point unlike many politicians.
Real gangsta
@Debashis Debata you go fight for cows
I'm an American for the most part in my life Indian ppl were cool with me over the last ten yrs that view point declined. Listening to this smart man renews my thoughts if Indian ppl. I really thought y'all was losing it
So now Indians are not cool with you ?.
Wtf are you trying to say
Never expected swamy would come to valuetaiment. Love it
Well done Patrick. Thanks for bringing THE MAN Subramanian Swamy. He is so addictive and charismatic and FEARLESS. I love him. 🙏From UK🇬🇧
Woah! That was totally unexpected to see him here. Fantastic valuetainment
Yup totally unexpected
His kids must have directed him to the channel.
Yeah man !
Quote “Income tax is harassment in India “ I totally agree with that statement.
Apart from pretending shocked and attentive all the time he should come up with better questions, having a guest like Subramanian Swamy, who is with India since Independence should ask questions related to India's current situation. 1hr full of when will India overtake china, when will India surpass China,
Tomorrow dude, after having breakfast, we will go and overtake China
True , income tax hardly gives you anything except harassment.
lol torturous process if I may add.
Australian here sending love to all India, an amazing country and culture much appreciated down under.
Thanks ❤️
Australia stolen Land
@civil Don't know the story, sorry for that, every country has it's wankers. 😉
@@aseeb1906 what century are you living in 😜 btw over 40% of Australian land mass is in the hands of the native population!
@@Randomcliff01 there is a List of massacres of Indigenous Australians
Beautifully conducted interview. Totally free and fair. No prejudices. No leading questions. You are very good.
This is one was treat to my eyes ❤️❤️❤️! Thank you so much! Yes Ronald Reagan and Swamy was always my favourite political figures! And it’s shocking that he said Ronald Reagan. He is 10x time better than Modi in so many ways! But Indians are not ready for people like him.
Not anymore..people have understood real modi now..
3:58 He is nominated for president not prime minister(that is modi RN) ..He himself said it bro....😂😁😁..... Actually prime minister has more powerful than president in India...So... Yeah you can expect him to be a president soon....
@@prashantkumar-pl8vi but people fear for getting worst then modi with other political parties with vulture mindset that's why they vote modi until someone else better than him emerge as national leader
indeed but look at his poltical career history he is not the person to be trusted by bjp people.
No one messes with Dr. Swamy in India he breaks the government, he makes government, he proves corruption has happened, gives hard time to his political opponents in various court cases.
Literally a living legend.
This interview was totally unexpected
Love for India
From Pakistan occupied Sindhudesh
He's the real Hero India needs.... Modi started it but he needs to handover the power to right people like him!
It was IIT Bombay's Entrepreneurship Summit, where I saw both of them in the same event.
Delighted to see you both again.
When Dr. Subramanian Swamy becomes the FM or the PM, there is a real chance of India achieving her greatest possible potential....till that time it will be just a dream...
Many South indians are eligible, swamy, tharoor, thomas issac, tamilnadu finance minister, etc... But no hope.....Because number of constituancy less in south ..... South Indians are woking US head quarters in key positions especially in finance and defense. In new zealand one kerala based vetenery doctor working like under secretary in New Zealand government.
@@jijujiji245 sitraman is South Indian...just because she is a woman?? This guy Swamy is so arrogant that he thinks he is the only brain on the world....ahankar of the first order...he will sell india to his best friends in China
@@jijujiji245 the TN finance minister is a misfit and so is a guy like PC.
@@jijujiji245 sitaraman is also a South Indian bro
This guy is full of it. He called China a place that doesn't make anything LOL.
Adding value on a manufacturing supply chain is a growth process that Japan and South Korea all went through and is still doing, China has moved up the manufacturing value chain for many if not all industries.
The fact that he dismisses the process of reaching high tech manufacturing economy, (first through low value added manufacturing), as nothing to emulate should tell you this guy is full of it.
He is the embodiment of what is wrong with India, wanting to achieve quick results while not doing any of the hard work.
Just take a listen of what he's saying, in his over 1 hour rant about how india will be superpower did he say the word "Infrastructure" a single time? NO. to be even considered a low end manufacturing power, you need some decent infrastructure, otherwise how are you going to ship the goods around and export it?
This is the problem of india, claiming they've identified the "problem" which is always some political problem mainly caused by the opposition, but never about infrastructure which is the actual hard work countries need to develop.
We the philippines would love to be a great ally of india. We would love if india would also be a competing financial investor for the philippines and also help us to develop nuclear power for energy and for defense purposes.
I read a lot of replies. Everything talk about india ahead of the world depend on "if"...what can I say? In china we talk about develop and never use "if". Good luck my india friend.
Thanks a lot! Respect from India❤️
Hope you know the common populace admires China a lot
Never thought I'll see swamy in valuetainment
#MeToo
This is my sweetest surprise
I know right !
@@ashwinigautam7282 and also sweetest shit
Well,a hint. Before and during the Israeli embassy was built, the Israeli visas were provided from Swamy's residential address. I respect him for that, to stay true to India's real friends.
The point about buying land is real. It took 5.5 years for purchasing a factory land. They applied under one prime minister and it got sanctioned under another prime minister’s term.
Lobbies
Woo it's so awesome interview with Dr.Subramanian Swamy.
Our current Prime Minister is "innocent of Economics". Sick burn..
More like ignorant 😂 surprised he twisted his tongue
In all the noise surrounding I only know "modi hai toh mumkin hai"🙏
swami is a capitalist 😂 unlike others socialist
True I figured it after the demonatization speech that this guy have no idea how economics works
As long as opposition is ScamGress with Rahul and Sonia ,Modi and BJP will continue to rule
Finally an interview with the man whose economic idea's are so enticing in the indian context. Has the current leadership the moral and mental strength needed to put him at the helm of indian economic affairs. Drastic are the realities of the indian economy under the tyranny of the bureaucracy and selfish politicians helbent on enriching themselves at the cost of citizens in India. Thank you valuetainment from india
Your comment made me happy.
You have captured the essence of the problems in India, untainted by political and ideological bias, only loyal to the betterment of our country and its citizens.
True patriotism is a hard thing to find in most mainstream popular discourse nowadays, and I’m truly happy when I do encounter it.
is it you allen???
Subbu is not trusted by politicians. He talks too much.
Yea he is a loose cannon. A genius though but you need tongue control in politics. Example is Trump.
Thanks for this timely and important interview Patrick with Swamy Sir. I subscribed finally 👍
This interview was 2 years back, now I see our finance decisions proven correct and Mr. Swamy proven inaccurate regarding finance ministry etc. Time is the best judge. 💫🙏
his perspective is interesting however consider that he is talking about India's "potential", and China is in the actualization mode.
China's actualization mode, is completely because of American hedge funds and Corporations.
Rightly said he is saying the same thing since ages now
Please stop following western media. Collect info. Its have taken more then century usa to become what it is today. Democracies grow like this. Biggest problem with china is that it does not have freedom. And without freedom you know friend critical thinking can not flourish. Yes for time being you can make fast progress like soviets did and now china did. But when next levels of inovation collide with closed system tussle will start. Like now what is happening with alibaba and tencent. India will take more 3 or 4 decades to reach where whole world recognise what india is capable of. Because under the hood lot of inovation is going on in india.
@@thendino1 american apple went to india and the workers couldnt read english manuals and went on strike on the first month, india superpower!
@@purigoswami4925 no freedom in china, but freedom to make 5g, huawei xiaomi dji
freedom in india and no high tech comes out of it
Notice he said I’m an Indian nationalist?! That’s what every citizen needs to be per their country.
you need to be a patriot not nationalist
He is from a nationalist party
No u need to be a humanist not nationalist.
@@forwardobservations8222 what is diffrence bro can you explain bit more for me it's same and yes i am a nationalist and patriot too.
@@biniljoy2542 what's wrong with that caring and loving your nation and thinking of betterment of it . nationalism is humanism in way but keeping their people at priority.
Top class interview and discussion on major topics. Thank you Patrick.
How did I miss this one. Thanks David. Good one.
My experience with immigrants from India has almost always been positive. They are generally polite, respectful and intelligent.
As a Canadian, I am nonetheless disappointed with the leader of one of our federal parties who is of Indian heritage. He has expressed support for Khalistani separatism and is also a socialist race baiter.
Khalistan was born in Canada and Khalistan is in Canada, here in Punjab they would be beaten up, if they speak in favour of Khalistan.
@@dotsanddash8083 Really? That's a good news
India must stand United
@@jafferkhan175 it has always been that way, there are no takers for it here in India.
@@AmarjitSingh-ts9rm have an opinion keep it to yourself, keep no ambiguity that if anyone talks about breaking apart my nation, conspires with India's western neighbor to break India and incites violence, they'll be met with the same force. khalistan didn't even start in Punjab or in any parts of India, it all started in Canada, and even in Canada nobody was ready to listen to it, in 1979 circa march, Sikh conference in Toronto, Kuldeep Singh sodhi raised khalistan and literally he was manhandled and thrown out from there by 4 young Sikhs. You have freedom of speech in a democracy but remember it's not absolute and is subject to restrictions.
That Politician represents the political foolhardiness of many people of India
2 Legends Together In Single Frame... Swamy Sir We Need U as Our Finance Minister
Patrick I have been listening to you on You Tube occasionally for the last one year- & find your podcasts forceful.
I lived in India for the first 50 years of my life & now in the US for the last 36 years in Georgia.
Your interview with Dr Subramaniam Swamy ( who I have also listened to often on You Tube) was excellent. I was born raised & educated in India in an Anglophone milieu & environment & hence my mother tongue was and is English. In India. I graduated in Electrical Engineering from Poona India in 1957 & then worked in Public Sector & Siemens India all over India based in Bombay but worked in most of the Indian States in Bengal/ Bihar/ Orissa & Assam in Eastern India for Industrial Projects while in Siemens India - so I agree 100% with what Dr Swamy says about Indias potential- I know that since I interacted with my Indian colleagues of all religions & faiths Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Parsees & Christian/Catholics- of which I am a staunch one from Goa- as my name suggests.
India has one of the finest &
Disciplined Armed Forces in the World. India needs have the sense to get into an Arms Supply Agreement with the U.S. to supply its Forces with Arms Gratis ( NO boots on the ground)to counteract against an Chinese war/ aggression & the U.S. should have the sense to make such a deal with India in its own interest when India can open a second front in the Himalayas when the U.S. takes on China in the South China Seas- otherwise the U.S. will lose/ come out second best as inKorea/ Vietnam/Cambodia//Iraq/ Afghanistan . The U.S. needs the 1.4 billion Indians on its side against China in such an event to be successful
Sydney Desouza - A Goan Indian American in Alpharetta/ Atlanta when you next visit here- will like to take you out for lunch/ dinner & update you about India
After watching so many interviews of Swamy ji, I have noticed that he speaks one sentence expecting people to understand the underneath reason of the sentence. His interviews are not to watch and comment on what he says, but to think why he says that.
True.. he is a bjp person but his views transcends all parties. He is a gem.
Debashish , can you please elaborate what you just said ! ....because what I concluded is that swami wants to behold the defining chair in economics in India. And he is actually condemning PM's decesions to team up rookies in main chairs and not experts.🙄
May be that could be his point.
Pls explain. I want to know.
If a Chinese politician said similar things, he will be ran off stage immediately 😂 that is the difference between China and India
This was good. This was SO GOOD team Valuetainment! Loved this piece. Kudos to you Partrick!
@Prabhat Kumar Singh Swamy has some good ideas but many of things he say is bonkers.
@Prabhat Kumar Singh good question. How does the developed countries banking industries operate? Any insights?
@@Mayankbhattacharya the concept of developed country is a hoax.. Every Macroeconomic catastrophe starts there.
@Prabhat Kumar Singh he can share in small steps only in a show perhaps. If you hear in other areas you might get picture. His way is get use low interest rates elsewhere to bring in capital here and shore things up . There has been gradual reduction in GCF in india over a decade, to increase savings shore up rates and for business reduce rate using capital brought in low rates from outside..
Hey Mayank hiii I am from Ahmedabad Gujarat, where are you from.
India's pride..Dr.Subramanian swamy...🇮🇳🔥
BY 2050, INDIA WILL BE THE WORLD'S NUMBER ONE POWER, ECONOMICALLY AND MILITARILY.
Hahahaha
Dear Swamy, lift the 6 yr. Land buying restrictions and give US companies tax brake incentive to build companies in India! God bless India!
It’s not a restriction per se, but bearucratic process is two sloth like and there will be NGO which will run marches against you to extort money
This was true 6 years back but now it'll take u only about 1 ,2 years to set up a factory through fast pass acts where the minister gives clearance directly than bureaucrats.
this guy doesn't known ANYTHING about industry. He called China a place that doesn't make anything LOL. adding value on a manufacturing supply chain is a growth process that Japan and South Korea all went through and is still doing, China has moved up the manufacturing value chain for many if not all industries.
The fact that he dismisses the process of reaching high tech manufacturing economy, first through low value added manufacturing, as nothing to emulate should tell you this guy is full of it.
What a coincidence when your neighbour is about to surpass you and they get hit the hardest from your flu...
It's fine. We're like phoenix 😉
Now the cases are going down but have to get ready for possible third wave.
My thoughts exactly!
India is the home spiritual self expression. China is the home of oppression of the human spirit.
@@goodgamegaming777 And see what mess lndia is in now ... after throwing cow dungs in the air in religious festival without mask and social distancing.
@@ftd7435 are u aware that india is like continent with 28 States and 8 union Territories?
It's like Europe continent with 1600 languages. You don't generalize 1.34 billion people 🙄
Holy crap i did NOT expect this interview! I have some critiques of dr.Sub Swamy but I’m still thankful to hear him!
I have a high difference of opinion over some of the things he says but he is a master in economics. What he said about economic conditions is absolutely spot on.
I called this two years ago. When their money fell. I bought into their currencies, and I bought into some of their businesses because they made a production trade deal. Hopefully India is the next production power house. They are peaceful earth living people who will make a positive impact on this world economy
Are you kidding!! you have no clue at what you are loking at do you , India Its too predatorial, and a ridged class based (cast) variations of human value. Equal rites is unheard of , a cess pool of antient human value systems Great for European work horse with their Indian Ruling subset at the operational core. Most of the pieces are already in place, and in play. However they are deadly afraid of India's fragmentation, now being challenged.by their ridgid cadre of under class value system . reformation is in the works and may cause separate states
@@cosmopessoa1556 😂😂 there won't be any seperate state out of India. Coz u haven't read about the history of nationalism within the Indian system.
Meanwhile India is digitising itself much faster thn any country on this planet.
Now infra works is on the way.
Bt u can carry on with your caste prejudice about the Indians. It's actually beneficial for us😂
Namaste from india🙏
India is the most dangerous country for women to live. How is that peaceful?
@@MichelleSuiComedy lol! Ppl do not disappear.
@@MichelleSuiComedy I’m because the only violence you named from there is one form of violence we have that here an everywhere now show me where their shooting each other hurtin woman raping an killing for a tv an sneakers?
Swamy and PBD! Now that's one heck of a crossover!
Patrick actually managed to get Subramanyam Swami!
Didnt expect this really…for patrick to call him or for Swami to agree
Loved the podcast ❤️❤️. If Swami will be interviewed by Indian journalist it would be time wasting. Great deep conversation 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻☺️☺️☺️
Right off the rip I agree that's why China got so worried when Trump and Modi were getting so close
@वंदे मातरम जय हिंद lmao u knoe nothin abut poltics. China under Trump was scared af Now China don't give a shit abut Biden and does watver it wants without any repercussions cause old Biden don't know how to deal with China
@@eddyadityapradhan7960 Fact: under Trump，China export to US was increased in large number, not a problem to China, China know how to deal with it.
@Pedro Danielhey spammer .
I have seen your same comment many times in this thread.
Get some life.
@@jxmai7687 只出直拳特朗普，不讲武德老逼登
A Big "Thank You" to Patrick for this interview with Dr. Swamy. This is something more people in America need to see.
Please add military training program for our children in school syllabus so that we can tackle anyone in future
Looking back at this interview now June end 23...
We are on path..
Amazing amazing interview , Dr. Subramanian Swamy in his 80s now but still with a razor sharp intellect as always. I Bow to you great man.
The lack of professionalism is the sorrow of India .
How about corruption.
@@abeninan4017 corruption is most common in all most all developing nation . China is also suffering from the corruption , yes u are right corruption is also an issue in India but due to transparency and technology it is declining .
@@abeninan4017 dont just repeat like a parrot what others keep repeating. Please check corruption index of other nations before jumping on conclusions. And I think check specifically for China as well.
@@abeninan4017 just check corruption index of china and India and then tell me the real issue
@@abeninan4017 check the corruption index in Modi's era it has changed drastically .
Thank you PBD for doing this interview this great context a lot people still see India as a underdog but if you see right now India is growing fast inside and outside of India. We have a lot of Indian in higher positions in USA
India needs more people like him who can help understand normal citizens the value that we can get from free market economy.
Exceptional Interview!! I, being an “educated intellectual” in India, seeing the growing sense of unity, increasing level of confidence and now getting what our extremely prosperous Hinduism is, in BJP governance. Ideally changing entire India with population of 1.4 Cr. and many more problems we had because of the consistent invasion and attacks for more than 800 years, will definitely take time. We have show our perseverance. We Indians have nothing to fear if we are united. Last but not least 2 democracies will definitely be good allies!! 🇮🇳 🇺🇸❤️
They will overtake china if they can keep it 100% although engineering superpower that china is they are churning out engineers faster than USA is churning out gender studies undergrads
I just thought yesterday that India is the crucial country in the battle to save freedom.
If the US can help to build up India along with Brazil and even Russia as we work to save our own democracy and freedom (I’m American) and strengthen ties with all of them, we will essentially prevent China from taking over.
India can't even feed itself with most people living in absolute poverty.
We should not involve them in our military attempts to contain China.
It will just cause more suffering for the poor in India. And we've done more than enough damage with our meddling in the 3rd world already.
Lol. US helping to build India? Bro, the US are even having difficulty helping itself. Being in USD28 trillion in debt, with plans to spend another 6 trillion adding to that pile just to keep up with China in terms of infrastructure and trying outrun the Chinese on tech. Good luck getting any help
We had been working to seperate influence of China over Russia, but western countries especially Europeans and NATO started their campaign in the form of Ukraine-Russia conflict which is still ongoing. This has given China edge over Indian influence over Russia.
Still, we are trying to drift Russia's interests away from China but as long as this conflict is ongoing, China is being benefited from it.
Fact: Russia is a military superpower, while China is an economic superpower.
@@tomjohnston3393 Your entire country is been run on loot done in India. Burglar can't be preacher's
@@tomjohnston3393😂 jokers in a dacced you will resolve leave alone India
According to me, the biggest problem that a democracy can have is to be a democracy!! this makes people decide what's the fate of the country for the next 4-5 years. This can become a setback to the the country's growth, where the people who don't have knowledge of long term goals of a country, try to choose a lethargic/non-competent/anti-national leadership for there short term personal gains. Thankfully, India has a kind of leadership that has the guts to take strong decisions, although the pandemic has costed our PM lose some of his reputation of being a incontestable political decisions, He still has proved to be the best option India have had after former fierce PM Indira Gandhi.
Not only that, he has granted unquestionable power to the Indian military in order to tackle China, And he has made India proud internationally and lifted India's perception as a country for the West. Yes this is difficult time for him to stabilize the oppositional propagandas inside the country, but eventually he will succeed. We will see him as a PM again in 2024.
Lifted India's perception from west from democracy to electoral autocracy. Very good. And bullshit people keep using terms like anti national.😑
@@sahdevrai3368 As if it wasn't a electoral autocracy in the congress regime for 70 years, with one party, one family, one supremo. As if Indira Gandhi wasn't a dictator, and manmohan Singh wasn't a puppet? And some dickheads believe Modi made democracy into an autocracy! What a bigotry, isn't it?
Subramanian Swamy is one of the most candid and learned politician in India, this is one of the most well-thought interviews I have watched in recent years. Firstly thank you, Kudos to you Patrick bringing such people to the table and having such a discussion with them. Whatever he has said is so true including the taxation, agriculture industry, I hope we can see some of the reforms in coming years and India once again is on the growth track, China and India is soo very different that they shouldn't be compared (In my opinion ) both countries despite their challenges have shown significant potentials in their respective path, yes we have differences and conflict scenario has risen but I believe that if political interest can be set aside Asian countries have much more offer in solving the problem which far more catastrophic( environment,health, energy)
Dr. Swami is a rock star of india.. and extremely popular among indian youth..