Video

Just for reference, this performance is about 22 minutes long. The performance I grew up with was by Reiner. And that's about 16 minutes long. From the very first moment that I heard this interpretation I was utterly transported to another world. It's like I never heard it before. It is sensual. I swear this conductor in his most magical moments stopped time in a way no other has ever done. I absolutely love this interpretation.

0:03 to 7:56

Thank you. The best Eroica ever. Would you kindly tell what cd is it from?

Slow and boring. Heavy and pro-Wagner, but anti-Beethoven

Maestro grande. He drives it to the extremes. 10 Minutes plus to Karajan. Thats really something, and it is a grand experience to listen to one of Celis rare recordings. He exhausts the full potential of this best of all symphonies ever composed by any master.

trop lent ! too slow ! wrong concept. Céli 1961 (Stuttgart; 61') and Celi 1991 (Munich; 64 ') are much better

Thank you for this SPECTACULAR rendition! Celibidache & Mozart: music one can actually feel!

Sin duda es algo genial... Cuando un musico moderno mira una partitura lo que ve es metrónomo, equilibrios del volúmen, intencidad, fuerza, pero cuando un genio ve una partitura mira emociones, la marcha funebre siempre crei que era una pieza triste y ya... Pero aqui es una oda a la vida, todas las emociones que teanscurren en una vida ... Para el musico moderno dirigir es bajar un archivo midi y equilibrar los timbres y volumenes y mantener el tempo de la orquesta, pero cuando le exiges a Un director de s gunda que interprete, que use a la orquesta como medio de expresión no pueden, no saben...

Celibidache nació con el propósito de dirigir Bruckner

I remember my childhood

❤ danke

16:12

7:23

17:34

この録音いいですね😊

7:40 If this doesn't touch your heart you don't have one.

Fast as a car 0:54

0:14

Спасибо

Celibidache is indeed one of the truly great conductors of the 20th century. It feels irreal now that I took part in the performance of his mass in si-minor from JS Bach in Munich in 1990 as a young singer. Celibidache gave courses on the phenomenology of music at the University of Mainz, where I was able to attend twice. A great man, and he died too young. Should have composed more music.

It is very annoying to see in most comments " The Greatest ' , there is absolutely not the Greatest in anything, it all comes to taste and mood and one's personality. And this Celi Eroica is cumbersome, BUT

The clarity and coherence of the orchestral introduction is astonishing. Celibidache treats it with the same care as any of Beethoven's symphonies.

Genialul Celibidache @

People get so upset about Celi's tempo choices...just listen afresh.

total opposite of the old seattle symphony recording which is done in 16 minutes

I can't hear the section from around 47:45 without imaging the screams from Siegerstram's performance (also here on YT) anymore.🤣

So good pure dedication to brilliance....many thanks.

He should have learned the dynamics first. Totally overrated. Don’t mind the tempi , but really no dynamics.

Monumentalul Celibidache!

柔らかい絹糸が波打つような音、癒されます。❤

00:00 Gemäßigt, mehr bewegt, misterioso 24:30 Adagio. Bewegt, quasi Andante 41:09 Scherzo. Ziemlich schnell 49:04 Finale. Allegro

Nice tempo

What a wonderful all-Celibidache channel!!! Celi is the best conductor (and teacher) of 20th century. No doubt...Thanks a lot!!

Pirate record?

Hermosa interpretación 🎉

Thanks for uploading this gem! It helps us all!

This is one of the most impressive performances I have ever listened to.

عاويه

Perfection.

I Dedicated my composition to chelibidache, from psalm 130 for 6 CONTRABASS Benjamin Ashkenazy I studied from him and with him

Verry beautifull simphony! Thank's to mr Celibidache! 👏👏👏

Ενα αριστουργημα.Ωραιος ηχος,φυσικος και διαυγης.❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

Didn't know David Lynch conducted Beethoven.

The initial "Allegro con brio" is more of an "Allegro depresso" (Allegro depressed); the " Marcia funebre" (Funeral March) is very funereal, tired; the third movement would be a "SCHERZO" (Scherzo: ALLEGRO VIVACE)"; .... It sounds like a cross between a minuet and an oktoberfest länder and the final "Allegro con molto" is perhaps just "Allegro". In general the whole symphony is heavy as a spoiled cheesecake.... POOR BEETHOVEN!!!...

Cast?

00:02:50

Celi’s Eroica is one of my most favorite performances. So deep so expressive so attractive.

19:00 suspense build up | 25:28 build up |

19:57 | 22:33 lead | 31:59 marriage/elegance | 37:29 | 41:17 | 46:19 spiral | 49:19 face-off | 56:26 spiral |

ただのヘボ演奏。