Utopia Planitia Studios
Utopia Planitia Studios
  • 39
  • 140 082
S2 E11 "The Ragged Edge" | Meall Dearg, Aonach Eagach, Glaciation | The Munros: A Personal Voyage
The journey continues. In ‘The Ragged Edge’, we tackle Meall Dearg of Aonach Eagach, check out the famous notched ridge and conclude the epic story of Glen Coe’s creation with the attack of the ice ages.
BOOKS
Classic Mountain Scrambles in Scotland by Andrew Dempster: www.luath.co.uk/mountaineering-and-hillwalking/classic-mountain-scrambles-in-scotland
Highland Scrambles South (SMC) by Iain Thow: scottishmountaineeringpress.com/product/highland-scrambles-south-smc/
PROFESSIONAL GUIDES
Walk Glencoe: www.walkglencoe.co.uk
Wild Venture Scotland: www.wildventurescotland.co.uk
zhlédnutí: 331

Video

No Return: The Darien Disaster | The Story of Scotland's Doomed Bid for Empire | FULL DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 2 měsíci
Taken from 'Inglorious Revolutions II: Act of Union'. The Union occurred against a backdrop of European dynastic wars, English economic repression and, partly as a result of the above, Scotland’s abject impoverishment. But the bankrupting of Scotland was not solely the result of decades of royal neglect or hostile English trade policies. Like the Union itself, the final nail in the coffin of Sc...
Inglorious Revolutions II: Act of Union | Explaining the Jacobite Risings | Part One: Descent
zhlédnutí 1,4KPřed 2 měsíci
The epic sequel to our most popular documentary, ‘Inglorious Revolutions II: Act of Union’ explores the momentous events in the British Isles, Europe and across the globe that led to the creation of "Great Britain" and the Jacobite riposte, the risings of 1708, 1715 and 1719. Never before or since was there a greater chance of success in restoring the Catholic Stuarts to the Three Kingdoms than...
Knives In the Dark: Engineering the Glen Coe Massacre | FULL DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 4,1KPřed 7 měsíci
On the morning of February 13 1692, one of the most infamous of Scotland’s numerous atrocities occurred in Glen Coe; one that began the darkest chapter in the long history of the Ghàidhealtachd. How was it possible for such shameless slaughter to occur in a society based on community, solidarity and hospitality? How were narcissistic hatemongers in Edinburgh able to plan and enact such a naked ...
Cruel Is the Snow: Committing the Glen Coe Massacre | FULL DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 10KPřed 9 měsíci
In an age of slaughter, religious intolerance and bloody clan feuds, what makes Glen Coe stand out above the many other massacres in the Highlands? Should a soldier unconditionally follow orders, even if those orders are to murder children? Was it “the Campbells”… or is that just what the real villains wanted people to think? These questions and more are at the heart of our new film, ‘Cruel Is ...
Legends of the Féinn: Fionn MacCumhaill and the Fianna Eireann
zhlédnutí 906Před 10 měsíci
Taken from Series 2 Episode 10 “Legends of the Féinn”.
S2E10 "Legends of the Féinn"| Sgorr nam Fìannaidh, Gaelic Mythology | The Munros: A Personal Voyage
zhlédnutí 510Před 11 měsíci
This month we tackle Sgorr nam Fiannaidh at the western end of Aonach Eagach, visit the beautiful Glencoe Lochan and explore the epic, mind-bending Gaelic mythology of Fionn MacCùmhaill and the Fíanna. A must-watch for fans of Celtic culture.
S2 E9 "King of the Hill" (Bidean nam Bian, Stob Coire Sgreamhach, Glen Coe supervolcano)
zhlédnutí 1,6KPřed rokem
Welcome back! In this episode, we take on the mighty Bidean nam Bian, highest point in Argyll and the most complex massif south of the Great Glen, plus its shapely sidekick, Stob Coire Sgreamhach. Along the way, we’ll discover the spectacularly violent creation of Glen Coe, check out the famous Clachaig Inn, explore An Torr and Signal Rock and pop in to the National Trust for Scotland’s Glen Co...
Guardians to Gallows Herd: MacIain and the MacDonalds of Glen Coe
zhlédnutí 3,2KPřed rokem
Who were the Glen Coe MacDonalds? Why were they called 'MacIain' and what did they do to inspire such hatred among Lowlanders?
S2 E8 “Children of the Heather” (Stob na Broige, Stob Coire Raineach, Stob Dubh, the MacIains)
zhlédnutí 2,9KPřed rokem
The journey continues. In “Children of the Heather” we return to the Greatest Herdsman to tackle Stob na Broige, then on to the wee Buachaille with the stunning viewpoints of Stob Coire Raineach and Stob Dubh. Along the way we’ll explore the spectacular Pass of Glen Coe, discover the Ralston Memorial, visit An Tinnean Mòr and dive into the history of the MacIains - the MacDonalds of Glen Coe. 0...
S2 E7 "The Greatest Herdsman" (Stob Dearg, Buachaille Ètive Mòr)
zhlédnutí 2,4KPřed rokem
The journey continues. In “The Greatest Herdsman”, we climb the world-famous Stob Dearg of Buachaille Ètive Mòr, arguably Scotland’s most iconic mountain. Along the way, we’ll explore the grandiose geography of Glen Coe and look back at nearly 130 years of climbing on the Buachaille with some of the biggest names and greatest writers in Scottish mountaineering. Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 06:4...
Fallen Kingdom: The MacDonalds, Lords of the Isles | FULL DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 30KPřed rokem
There’s much more to the MacDonalds than Glen Coe. In ‘Fallen Kingdom’ we chart the epic saga of the most powerful and influential sons of Somerled, from their earliest Celtic roots to the downfall of their Righ nan Èileanan - the vast, Gaelic-speaking Kingdom of the Isles. Taken from Series 2 Episode 6 “The White Corries”.
Inglorious Revolutions: Explaining the Jacobite Cause | FULL DOCUMENTARY
zhlédnutí 41KPřed 2 lety
If Jacobitism was the answer, what was the question? Before Bonnie Prince Charlie, Prestonpans or Culloden, before the ‘United Kingdom’ was even a thing, there was the ‘89: the original Jacobite Rising. We’ve often mentioned the Jacobites during our historical forays among the Munros, but we’ve never taken the time to explain their cause. In this history special, we go back to where it all bega...
S2 E6 "The White Corries" (Meall a'Bhùiridh, Creise, the MacDonalds)
zhlédnutí 1,7KPřed 2 lety
The journey continues with a special feature-length episode. In “The White Corries,” we arrive at the mouth of Glen Coe to climb the amazing viewpoints of Meall a’Bhùiridh and Creise, explore the 270-year history of the last Kingshouse, look back at early ski tourism in the Scottish Highlands and, in our deepest historical dive yet, chart the epic saga of Clan Donald, the Lords of the Isles; a ...
S2 E5 “Heart of Kinglass” (Beinn nan Aighenan)
zhlédnutí 891Před 2 lety
The journey continues. In ‘Heart of Kinglass’, we venture into the wilds of Northern Argyll to climb Beinn nan Aighenan, learn how the glorious granites of the Etive range were formed and explore the history of iron making in Glen Kinglass and Bonawe. As well as the usual stunning views and detailed route information there’s also some rare sightings of plant and animal life, hand-drawn animatio...
S2 E4 “Goliath” (Stob Ghabhar, Stob a’Choire Odhair)
zhlédnutí 1,3KPřed 3 lety
S2 E4 “Goliath” (Stob Ghabhar, Stob a’Choire Odhair)
S1 E4 “Praise of Beinn Dòrain” (Beinn Dòrain, Beinn an Dòthaidh) [Remastered]
zhlédnutí 1,2KPřed 3 lety
S1 E4 “Praise of Beinn Dòrain” (Beinn Dòrain, Beinn an Dòthaidh) [Remastered]
S1 E3 “The High Castle” (An Caisteal, Beinn a’Chroin) [Remastered]
zhlédnutí 1,6KPřed 3 lety
S1 E3 “The High Castle” (An Caisteal, Beinn a’Chroin) [Remastered]
S1 E2 “The Boulders of Cruach Ardrain” (Cruach Ardrain, Beinn Tulaichean) [Remastered]
zhlédnutí 1,9KPřed 3 lety
S1 E2 “The Boulders of Cruach Ardrain” (Cruach Ardrain, Beinn Tulaichean) [Remastered]
S1 E1 “Boldly Go” [Remastered]
zhlédnutí 3,3KPřed 3 lety
S1 E1 “Boldly Go” [Remastered]
S2 E3 “The Fox of Glencoe” (Hamish MacInnes)
zhlédnutí 6KPřed 3 lety
S2 E3 “The Fox of Glencoe” (Hamish MacInnes)
S2 E2 “Rise of the Campbells” (Beinn Eunaich, Beinn a’Chochuill, Kilchurn Castle, the Campbells)
zhlédnutí 1,7KPřed 3 lety
S2 E2 “Rise of the Campbells” (Beinn Eunaich, Beinn a’Chochuill, Kilchurn Castle, the Campbells)
S2 E1 “The Hollow Mountain” (Ben Cruachan, Stob Daimh)
zhlédnutí 3,9KPřed 3 lety
S2 E1 “The Hollow Mountain” (Ben Cruachan, Stob Daimh)
S1 E23 “Queen of the South” (Ben Lui, Beinn a’Chleibh)
zhlédnutí 1,7KPřed 3 lety
S1 E23 “Queen of the South” (Ben Lui, Beinn a’Chleibh)
S1 E21 “Hard Water 2” (Beinn Achaladair)
zhlédnutí 866Před 4 lety
S1 E21 “Hard Water 2” (Beinn Achaladair)
S1 E20 “Hard Water” (Beinn Mhanach)
zhlédnutí 1KPřed 4 lety
S1 E20 “Hard Water” (Beinn Mhanach)
S1 E18 “The Lyon's Mouth” (Carn Mairg Group)
zhlédnutí 846Před 4 lety
S1 E18 “The Lyon's Mouth” (Carn Mairg Group)
S1 E17 “Breaking the Lawers 2” (Meall Greigh, Meall Garbh)
zhlédnutí 910Před 5 lety
S1 E17 “Breaking the Lawers 2” (Meall Greigh, Meall Garbh)

Komentáře

  • @viking_training_system

    Anglo Saxons? Nothing to do with the Highlands...you mean Scots and Picts?

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 4 dny

      I think you misunderstand. Scots - Anglo-Saxons- were in the Lowlands; the south east of Scotland which became Alba. The “Highlanders” of this age were, as far as we know, Pictii. There is no conclusive evidence to make unqualified statements about who was where so long ago. We can theorise, but not state as fact.

    • @viking_training_system
      @viking_training_system Před 4 dny

      ​@@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios No, I absolutely understand who the Scots were in that era, I have nearly every book written on the topic😬 The Scots and Picts united to create the kingdom of Alba with Strathclyde as a sub kingdom and Deira having shifting boundaries to the south.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 4 dny

      @viking_training_system Right, so what's the objection? At no point do I say there were anglo saxons in the Scottish Highlands.

    • @viking_training_system
      @viking_training_system Před 4 dny

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios You stated the kingdom of Alba was created by the Picts and Angles.

    • @viking_training_system
      @viking_training_system Před 4 dny

      ​@@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios I suggest you read From Pictland to Alba by Alex Woolfe for starters. Also, the Pictish kingdoms were focused in Angus, Fife and Moray.

  • @martinanderson4832
    @martinanderson4832 Před 6 dny

    excellent video just subscribed

  • @Anaris10
    @Anaris10 Před 6 dny

    I've heard to this day at Clan Gatherings here in CALIFORNIA "Never trust a Campbell".

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 5 dny

      I mean, it may have been a fair rule of thumb back in the day, but I think it's probably best consigned to history. There's enough division in the world without perpetuating arcane, irrelevant prejudices.

  • @PAADVENTURES1
    @PAADVENTURES1 Před 7 dny

    Nice one Sam. Your a master at alternative routes to these high places! Watched your videos for a long time now and still think these munro adventures are the best!! Paul

  • @jho7389
    @jho7389 Před 7 dny

    Nice documentary, many thanks for creation. Found this as part of my preparations for my 1st trip to Highlands. Hope his work will never be forgotten.

  • @nollem41
    @nollem41 Před 7 dny

    By far the best and most truthful documentry of Scotland!

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 7 dny

      That’s very kind of you, thanks for watching!

    • @nollem41
      @nollem41 Před 7 dny

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios I have subscribed and hit the bell I also have located part two.

  • @lesleypithie6227
    @lesleypithie6227 Před 8 dny

    there is no way i would like to have lived in those days

  • @nickdeagle3271
    @nickdeagle3271 Před 8 dny

    Lovely terrain

  • @andrewdeacon4384
    @andrewdeacon4384 Před 10 dny

    Brilliant - thanks for uploading.

  • @manuelhung7571
    @manuelhung7571 Před 12 dny

    I have oft pondered, do MacDonalds eat Campbells Soup?

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 5 dny

      They made their own a thousand years prior. Besides, even in the depths of starvation, they probably wouldn't have considered it edible.

  • @ObjectiveAnalysis
    @ObjectiveAnalysis Před 14 dny

    Man these videos are criminally under rated. The quality of the information and delivery here is superb, your dry humour had me nearly spitting out my porridge at times! Bravo my friend 👏

  • @aigslmnop
    @aigslmnop Před 18 dny

    lord of the isles title must've caused confusion with the wider island group or groups maybe 21:33

  • @joenolan4917
    @joenolan4917 Před 18 dny

    Top notch story telling mate. You’d have been a valued bard back in the day

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 18 dny

      Damn, that’s quite the compliment! Thanks dude, glad you enjoyed the film.

  • @manuelhung7571
    @manuelhung7571 Před 22 dny

    The house at Glencoe has been the subject of intense vandalism of late targetted at the last owner Jimmy Savile.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 22 dny

      Yeah... we don't talk about him. 🤮

    • @manuelhung7571
      @manuelhung7571 Před 22 dny

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios I completely get that. Just incredibly sad that Scottish Heritage didn't buy the house and return it to the way Hamish furnished the place and erect a Blue Plaque in his honour. A highly significant place in the World history of climbing and home of a true giant of this sport.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 22 dny

      @manuelhung7571 Absolutely agree. 💯 It’s a real shame, would be a great place to have a wee museum of Hamish’s life, work and astonishing contribution to mountaineering and mountain rescue worldwide.

  • @Hrossey
    @Hrossey Před 23 dny

    McDonald’s = foreign terrorists.

  • @ytfeelslikenorthkorea

    descended to Hidden Valley yesterday... An idea of doing it in Winter feel RIDICCULOUS! I did two winter ascents of the easiest Munros (Ben More, Stob Binnein) and I promised myself to NEVER DO THIS AGAIN. Had some close calls in low visibility as well. Conclusion: I will only climb Munros when it's nice weather, clear skies.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 22 dny

      Yeah time and again folk underestimate the ferocity and severe challenges of winter on the Munros. When it's bad you may as well be in the Alps. I watched two people downclimbing into the Lost Valley in spring last year when there was plenty of snow left - hard, windblasted snow prone to avalanche - WITHOUT CRAMPONS OR AN ICE AXE. Absolutely mind-bogglingly stupid and irresponsible behaviour. I couldn't believe what I was seeing. By dumb luck they made it down...just. You're absolutely right, if unsure or especially if you don't enjoy it, it's definitely better sticking to the more clement seasons!

    • @ytfeelslikenorthkorea
      @ytfeelslikenorthkorea Před 22 dny

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios downclimb there without crampons in Winter??? That's just plain stupid!

  • @sashavasko
    @sashavasko Před měsícem

    Awesome man. Lost world climb is a classic. Met him in 1994 alongside Chris Bonnington at Glencoe just before climbing Ben Nevis in a winter storm. Didn't appreciate it as much at the time, but it slowly catches on. I did not know that he climbed in Caucasus. Could have had a great time just like we did with Chris.

  • @mrhm6549
    @mrhm6549 Před měsícem

    4:37 can you please give me the source for this backround image? i think this was the painting of George Mackenzie, 1st Earl of Cromartie, handing over authority to James Douglas, 2nd Duke of Queensberry.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před měsícem

      Hi! It’s Charles II (left) with his brother James, then Duke of York and later James VII and II (right).

  • @RobertMcQuillan-my3du
    @RobertMcQuillan-my3du Před měsícem

    Just watched this amazing documentary, well done again it's a hard subject to make entertaining. Well done you managed that feat❤

  • @RobertMcQuillan-my3du
    @RobertMcQuillan-my3du Před měsícem

    I'm a subscriber and I'm learning allot from your channel and loving it so thank you my family history is Irish but love Scotland and have shared history.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před měsícem

      And many thanks for watching! Glad you’re finding it all useful! 🙂

  • @cynthiaskidmore7545
    @cynthiaskidmore7545 Před měsícem

    My 13th great grandfather was James MacDonnell, brother of Sorley Boy. We ended up in the American colonies. So much pain. Even my dad shared in the pain of being of this lineage. So much lost. Just heartbreaking. Pain doesn’t stop because your family is relocated. Again, absolutely heartbreaking. Never home. We can never go home

  • @aaravtulsyan
    @aaravtulsyan Před měsícem

    Criminally under-rated amount of views for the sheer production quality

  • @chrissaltmarsh6777
    @chrissaltmarsh6777 Před měsícem

    Beware the weather. Started up Bidean nam Bian (this was 45 years ago) in pleasant weather. Around 40 minutes in and the fog/cloud came down, fast. Socked in. Got a bit lost, came down to Hidden Valley. It was like Gormenghast with the fog and the moss on the rocks. Utterly magic, but make sure you have the kit; Bidean can bite.

  • @macalad8486
    @macalad8486 Před měsícem

    MacDonald here, from Sunderland, im guessing some of my ancestors settled here during the civil war when the Scots were fighting the royalists

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 5 dny

      Just a quick point on the semantics here as I know it's confusing. In Scotland, Royalists were mostly Scots (English-speaking Lowlanders: 'Albannaich' in Gaelic). The Gaels (Highlanders) were the traditional opponents of the Crown. This changed in the early modern era when the 'wrong' king - William of Orange - displaced James VII, whose supporters -Jacobites - included many Gaels; indeed, the Jacobite army at Killiecrankie was predominantly comprised of Highlanders. But yes, it's quite possible your ancestors were forcibly relocated from their Highland territory as part of the Highland Clearances.

  • @fgaze72
    @fgaze72 Před měsícem

    the outer wilds theme tune was a surprise 😂

  • @TheDickPuller
    @TheDickPuller Před měsícem

    Great video thanks for sharing. The ‘MacDonalds’ viewing this video will love this wee true story; Alastair Campbell, the very twisted & hated Spin Doctor of PM Teflon Tony Blair, you know the British Prime Minister that ordered the invasion of Iraq, murdering millions of innocent people. Well, Alastair Campbell was chucked out the Clachiag Inn, Glencoe. Where there’s a Sign over the Door; ‘No Hawkers or Campbells’ I’m from the West Highlands, a Presbyterian loyal to the Court of St James & our British Royal Family. My family were a Hanoverian Clan fighting Bonny Prince Charlie & the Jacobites. We hate Edinburgh, the corruption & lies of the Scottish ‘Government’. Never trust anyone from the East of Scotland!! God save the King Rule Britannia 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧🇬🇧

  • @RobertMcQuillan-my3du
    @RobertMcQuillan-my3du Před měsícem

    I'm a technophobe and have no idea how you can make such top quality and I'm my opinion as good as BBC ect no better than good wit unbiased and educated.Well done I'm now a subscriber and also I'm a Munro bagger❤

  • @monkmichael-munkmiikael-hy7842

    Excellent work with this and the two previous videos! I learned a lot. I really enjoyed your sarcastic jokes in the first episode. Here you had a more respectful tone, fittingly in tune with the greatness of the atrocities. Thank you!

  • @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964

    Not many people liked the Campbells. Pretty much everyone was at war with them. I know the Macgregor of Glenstrae and Campbell of Argyll were deadly enemies.

  • @madisennicolekirkpatrick5964

    I am Macdonald on my moms side. My moms dad, his mother , was hewitt/hewittson, which is a sept of clan Macdonald

  • @eileenavci7105
    @eileenavci7105 Před měsícem

    My Grandfather was Alexandra Mac Donald of Ronald Moore .

  • @HalifaxPeacock
    @HalifaxPeacock Před 2 měsíci

    1:01:51 What location is this with the stadium behind the cathedral? Thank you for producing and posting these episodes. They’re beautifully crafted.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      It’s Edinburgh Castle, the unfortunate timing of the photo means the seating is for the ‘Tattoo’ and concerts during the summer!

  • @HalifaxPeacock
    @HalifaxPeacock Před 2 měsíci

    VIKING VI=6 SIX KINGS

  • @jackharrison6771
    @jackharrison6771 Před 2 měsíci

    This is the most in depth account of the Glen Coe massacre I have ever heard, and I say thanks for the research and posting. One only has to visit the area briefly, to get a hint of the atmosphere; which I have more than once. I would recommend this and the dramatised version, featuring James Robertson Justice..

  • @michaeharvey1175
    @michaeharvey1175 Před 2 měsíci

    I should add the viking families in the Macdonald family go back to Antiochus the first antichrist in the book of Daniel.. its a crazy history them vikings had

  • @michaeharvey1175
    @michaeharvey1175 Před 2 měsíci

    My x6 grandfather was Ewan Macdonald grandson of William Macdonald of Aird and valley, Ewan was sent to tasmania as a convict more so a political prisoner with his sentence was also added he was never to return to GB...pretty handy for the women like men in power today 😂

  • @bryanwatson9407
    @bryanwatson9407 Před 2 měsíci

    Well worth the wait. Informative, insightful and entertaining. More detail than I’ve seen anywhere else on Darien which was an unexpected bonus, albeit quite a bleak and sobering chapter in our history. Kudos Sam, love your work and you deserve a much bigger audience.

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      That's extremely kind of you, thanks. It's good to hear Darien hit as intended, it wasn't pleasant to research but a key part of getting at why the Union occurred. It's just really sad. The unforgivable decision to send a second expedition was at least a case of corporate manslaughter.

    • @bryanwatson9407
      @bryanwatson9407 Před 2 měsíci

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Darien is just a tragic saga in our history. Poorly represented and exploited by the union driving the misguided attempt to develop our own colony and break the reliance on the oppressors. The second colony attempt was a desperate act of hubris, but that doesn’t excuse the tragic negligence of the outcome and the ironic impact it had on strengthening the union.

  • @jamiemacgregor1602
    @jamiemacgregor1602 Před 2 měsíci

    Good work sir by the way

  • @jamiemacgregor1602
    @jamiemacgregor1602 Před 2 měsíci

    My name is Jamie Gow Stewart Robertson MacDonald MacKeinzi MacGregor .clan Campbell u don’t want to meet me on a dark night .

  • @VicariousAdventurer
    @VicariousAdventurer Před 2 měsíci

    Whiskey was a big incentive (and factor?) in invention of the barrel

  • @arowdeyhmstr234
    @arowdeyhmstr234 Před 2 měsíci

    I think there are some bias around the glorious revolution. Although as said it wasn’t excepted as a whole but the GR was the nail in the coffin of monarch absolutism and the start of parliamentary supremacy which I think was ultimately a good thing

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      Thanks for watching and for your excellent comment. The progress made in the 1689 Bill of Rights - primacy of legislature over the executive- was definitely a good thing. The whole faux-invasion thing is what we’re ridiculing: William was forced to accept being constrained by Parliament to his great frustration. As mentioned in the film, the ideas the Jacobites espoused were on the wrong side of history. This progressive movement towards more democratic ways of government is expanded upon in Inglorious Revolutions: Act of Union which just went up last week. :)

    • @arowdeyhmstr234
      @arowdeyhmstr234 Před 2 měsíci

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios great content though don’t get me wrong I have spent a good few hours with your voice in my ear

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      Thanks so much mate, means a lot! Inglorious Revolutions: Act of Union | Part One (1690-1700): czcams.com/video/fLtJjFJcld8/video.html

  • @richardvanderpoll6885
    @richardvanderpoll6885 Před 2 měsíci

    I hope you do not regard that as a great achievement.....

  • @higochumbo8932
    @higochumbo8932 Před 2 měsíci

    6:00 - I don't think that is a fair summary of the Reformation. Talking about indulgences as "catholic tradition" is like talking about whoremongering as a catholic tradition just because some popes whored. You might have as well talked about the "inherent racism of protestantism", which would actually have more of a doctrinary basis if we were to judge by Luther's own writings. You could have just talked about "papal corruption" or something that didn't sound like a manichean good vs evil reductionism. Also, no, indulgences do not get people into heaven, they do not exempt people from their sins. 16:42 - In this case it might be true for some contemporary perceptions, but we should be careful not to pass it as ageneral rule. You could, for instance, ask the very much Catholic enactors of the Spanish Constitution of 1812 if they were pro-authoritarianism or pro-democracy, or to all those many historians who see a direct link between Lutheranism and Nazism. And you can tell the many Protestant believers in predetermination if they have "more agency and intelligence of their own" than the many Catholics who believe in free will. 24:04 - Spain was still the 2nd global power, definitely ahead of England and the Netherlands. The myth of Spanish decadence in the 2nd half of the XVII century has long been debunked. Spain had lost its hegemonic position, not its great power status.

  • @mmcc5846
    @mmcc5846 Před 2 měsíci

    The darien disaster that England started deliberately to sign up to this fraud of uk

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      Not really. As the film explains, the Darien scheme was created by Scots with William’s encouragement.

  • @jamesjenner8159
    @jamesjenner8159 Před 2 měsíci

    Summit is a noun not a verb!

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      I think you’ll find the mountaineering community may disagree with you on that; it can be both.

  • @SeestheDayphotography71
    @SeestheDayphotography71 Před 2 měsíci

    I am a McDonald. My father’s DNA shows that we descended from Somerled. However, there are a lot of gaps that I would love to fill . My 5th great grandfather was Capt John McDonald born in 1742 . He fought in the Revolutionary war. Capt John Mc. Arrived ( with Cherokee Indians) at Abaco Bahamas after the war in 1783. He settled there in a place now known as Cherokee Sound. That information is confirmed with historical record. I suspect that Capt John’s father and grandfather were both named Alexander MacDonald . The only sure record I have is from an interview with John McDonald - Magistrate & School master of Cherokee Sound, who stated that his grandfather was a Loyalist soldier, and his great grandfather a ship builder in the river Clyde. I’d LOVE to know more about

    • @nickdeagle3271
      @nickdeagle3271 Před 22 dny

      Really interesting. Would love to hear more of these folk’s stories.

  • @andrewheaney6858
    @andrewheaney6858 Před 2 měsíci

    “ Warring Picts and Anglo Saxons united in defence “ ? 1500 hundred years ago the Anglo Saxons had been settling Northumbria from what’s now Edinburgh down the East coast for a mere 50 years, they were no where near the Western Isles ? and “when Scotland was inhabited by Picts and Anglo Saxon tribes” there were two wave of invasion? the Anglo Saxon were the invaders and what about the native Brythonic Briton’s who inhabited the west coast of Scotland from Dumbarton castle all the way down to Wales at the time, no mention? The historical inaccuracy’s in the first 5 minutes set a tone of fiction to come !

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      Coming in hot there chief. What you call historical inaccuracies are legitimate academic theories for which there is evidence both for and against. Hence the “Lively academic debate”, this is a contested subject. We are all contributing to the debate.

    • @andrewheaney6858
      @andrewheaney6858 Před 2 měsíci

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Takes a stretch of the imagination to think of the Anglo Saxons coming up to the western isles to join forces with the Picts to fight the Vikings thus forming Scotland no matter what academic theories you follow, just saying !🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios
      @UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Před 2 měsíci

      Nowhere in the film is it suggested that Anglo-Saxons were in the western isles or even the west coast. Thanks for watching though!

    • @andrewheaney6858
      @andrewheaney6858 Před 2 měsíci

      @@UtopiaPlanitiaStudios Go back and listen to to your opening narrative it’s as clear as day, from you reply though it’s sounds unintentional , thank you too for going to the trouble of making the video it’s very good, history matters and has brought us to where we are today, Slainte Pal

  • @kevinbalfour
    @kevinbalfour Před 2 měsíci

    Hello again...poll position for this one

  • @buzsalmon
    @buzsalmon Před 2 měsíci

    Your work and presentation was extremely well done. And,well received by this viewer. I can and must say a sincere thank you Mr. Barber.