Video

Works for basic foley creation, but nothing or anybody is John Williams. He is the machine for real.

so... illegally scraping the original work to train the system that then recreates the original work but not as good. it's so weird. how does anyone think we have animal sounds and motorcycle sounds and gun sounds to begin with? someone went out with a microphone and recorded them, and then sound designed them into a film or series. then AI comes along, swallows up all the work like a mega-Jaws, and poops it all out again and calls it extraordinary. but it's all just a bunch of Terminators stepping on the skulls of the artists who did the work in the first place.

So "John Williams" was used as a keyword search and explicitly "how did Jurassic Park create Trex sound"? That’s AI as IP infringement in a nutshell, or at best data search. No intelligence. Try using "Korngold" or "Max Steiner" next time.

You used a clip from Jurassic Park, and didn't pick up on the irony of the movie's most iconic line: "Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, that they never stopped to think if they SHOULD." AI is just an easier method of plagiarism, and an ethical nightmare. This is very disappointing from a channel that usually tries to instruct other creatives.

Sticking your head in the sand as many are doing won't change anything. AI is improving exponentially and jobs will (are) be at risk. When the bean counters realise they can save time and money they will adopt anything. Learn Adapt Survive

Amazing! This A.I technology will have profound effects on filmmaking: “A.I the final frontier” ! Exciting times!

You turned Jaws italian!

BRB. Gotta ask AI to generate a comment about what I think about this subject. 😊

Yep. Client needed some punch ins on an older script -- 11Labs cloned the talent with with a 00:01:32 clip DEAD ON. Voice to text for the pickups -- just stunning.

I respect what Ai can do, but I freaking hate this. Death of creativity…

fly

honestly the most jarring part of the video is your voiceover. It sounds dead and artificial. The soundtrack also seems off and probably only passable for a fan project or B movie. Sound effects honestly sound great though.

I think udio does not allow to use eg. John Williams as a reference...

I love how everyone is proud of how they can replace another creator. What happens when they come for you?

boo.

This is an excellent example of the lack of respect we hold for humanity and those that built the greatness that we keep trying to imitate with these tools. Training on their life work and disregarding their authentic innovations for the sake of common accessibility. Everyone always want the glory of the feat but when you are using a machine to do everything there is no human glory that you could claim in that.

This is a cynical and damaging endeavour, you should be ashamed of yourselves

Thanks for another depressing video. The mixing and placement automation is she to not be far behind either. It’s great that these tools and the future ones to come will be in the hands of everyone interested, but deeply depressing to further dilute the rarity and special something that is cinema… and that’s to say nothing of those who have put the blood, sweat and tears into learning the craft whose careers to an end… not too sure where civilization is headed because it will come for all sectors. I know this sounds like a dig, but I blame you no more than I would have blamed Howard Beale.

It was interesting. The theme did sound very John William-esque but not wholly original as if he wrote a new piece of music for the scenes. We're not there yet, but almost, but I do believe you could make a movie with ai tools now.

Someone conducts an interesting experiment, presents the results and people are FLIPPING OUT

What IA tools did they use?

Impressive but it still lacks that umami or magic we got from John Williams and his orchestra.

This sucks. For a team that's produced so much good insight, this is so incredibly tone deaf and off-putting. Ethical issues aside, this is also just pure slop. No thanks.

Oof hate everything about this. I know a lot of filmmakers are saying "AI is the future, we need to embrace it now" but people's jobs and livelihoods are at stake. Use AI to make jobs easier, not to take jobs away.

That is insane! Ever single part of this video, and it is scary, i forgot an AI was reading your voice too, AI is so exciting and scary. Thanks for exposing me t o this amazing tools :-)

None of this is exciting. All of this sounds like sophisticated plagiarism.

You imitated those mega annoying "dramatic" orchestra soundtracks perfectly 😄

Epic light media The BMW R 75 does not sound like a BMW R 75 at all. Why have you done this so wrongly? This is like the Apollo 11 Saturn five moon rocket with the sound of a Chinese petrol lawnmower.

We need AI youtubers instead of human youtubers.

Sfx sounds terrible when you play them isolated.

It’s almost creepy how good of a job it can do. For someone like me who does little short films with basically 0 budget, these tools can be so helpful. I definitely understand the extreme concerns on a professional level though

Never unsubscribed so fast in my life. Fuck you. this is an insult to the original artists.

We used AI to rip off John Williams doing a John Williams score and it sounds like a John Williams score. Great. We asked AI to tell us Gary Rydstrom created the T-rex roar, then we asked AI to rip it off. Awesome. Copies of copies. How many generations of this before "art" is nothing but a thin, synthetic ghost of a thousand generations ago?

Thanks for showing us the actual steps. It's much more valuable that way. My reference point for 'made by Ai' is the song Savages, featuring Ai Jay-Z. I was a little surprised to find from an interview, that when you drilled down, the only bit made by Ai was the texture of one of the voices! The group created all the music. The rapper wrote and performed his own raps. And he also wrote raps in the style of Jay-Z, and then performed them in the style of Jay-Z. And then Ai altered the texture of his voice to sound like Jay-Z for those parts. It turned out to be about 5% Ai

Great tipps! What software did you use for the narration? Thank you!

These tools will be one way of lowering the barrier to entry into film and it reduces cost.

except that UDIO is under scrutiny because is using composer's original samples without authorisation. Copyright Infringment detected

Who is AI?

There’s a lot of potential for AI tools in small-team or fast-turnaround applications to get a “good enough” solution. Much like how things like hybrid cameras and LED light panels made quality video production affordable to the masses. If the budget exists, being able to tailor the music and audio to be exactly right and consistent across the production rather than good enough will still win out. Larger productions might still want to use the tools to speed up production of some sound assets, particularly elements to be blended into layered sounds, or for more generic sounds that are not a point of audience focus.

next step : no human intervention at all, just feeding the app with no sound footage and let it work its magic

"The music is almost as good as the original" only in the sense that Rosie O Donnel is "almost as sexy" as Margot Robbie

Is this voiceover AI generated as well?

This is eerily good except for the mixing and the infamous double layered Wilhelm Scream. In that Indy shot. The rifle sounds terribly thin.

Interesting. So, when I input a composer into Udio they reject it. How did you get around it?

😮

AI is overrated crap. A computer program standing on the shoulder of giants. Ask it to make a mega blockbuster movie with an amazing soundtrack that will inspire generations for decades and show me what it comes up with.

Very scary future for the creative world. We are almost at a point where literally every photo realistic thing you see on screen can be created with AI. Ive said before that AI is to the visual effects industry what cgi was to the practical effects industry. But much faster……

2:27 “The music is almost as good as the original” No.

The sound FX fooled me but the voice over was DEAD inside, was struggling to listen to it for the length of the video, compared to your usual enthusiasm.

It’s great that the technology can do this… But I hope you get arrested and spend some time behind bars. I’m sure you have nobody’s permission to do this.