Board Gems
Board Gems
  • 189
  • 289 062
Summer 2024 — a break from my usual schedule.
Hello! Short summary: I recently had knee surgery, and I have a few things I want to do over the summer. So I decided not to have a set schedule for the next couple of months, so I can take it easy and recover at my own pace. You might see some one-off videos, just things that strike my fancy, without much work going into them. The next "proper" video will likely be on September 3rd. Have a great summer! Or winter! Wherever you are, whatever the season, have a great one of those!
Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten!
Join & Support: czcams.com/channels/X9Ab6egkU1ru3sgP8TUI2A.htmljoin
Twitter: booned
BGG Blog: boardgamegeek.com/blog/10011
BGG New Videos List: boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/276559/
BGG Requests & Suggestions List: boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/279371/
Brought to you by Pizzeria Ludica! www.ludica.ca/
#boardgames #tabletop #vancouver #ludica
zhlédnutí: 399

Video

Through the Desert - Side-by-Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 926Před měsícem
There's a new version of Reiner Knizia's classic game Through the Desert! In this video I compare 2024's Allplay edition with one of the earlier English versions (Fantasy Flight 2005, which in my experience is one of the more common ones to find on the used market.) There are many editions over the years, in fact four different FFG ones, and of course the original Kosmos version which I'd love ...
Puerto Rico - Side by Side Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 707Před měsícem
In this video I compare two editions of the highly-regarded strategy board game Puerto Rico (Andreas Seyfarth/Alea): the earliest edition from 2002 and the recently-reimagined "1897" edition. There have of course been many editions over the years, including a deluxe anniversary edition and a short-lived reprint in 2020 maintaining its colonial setting, but here I'm comparing what currently are ...
Klunker - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 585Před měsícem
Remember the 1990s? There was lots of purples and oranges and greens and everything was radical and extreme! Back then, Uwe Rosenberg wasn't famous for complex harvest-set or polyomino board games. He was much less famous in the hobby, and was known for making simple, quirky card games. His most famous was Bohnanza, and it is still enjoyed today. Klunker (1999 Hans im Glück) is another quirky R...
Black Gold AKA Giganten - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 242Před 2 měsíci
In this video, I compare two editions of a classic oil-drilling and -selling Wilko Manz board game: Giganten (1999 Kosmos) vs Black Gold (2011 Fantasy Flight). Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czcams.com/channels/X9Ab6egkU1ru3sgP8TUI2A.htmljoin Twitter: booned BGG Blog: boardgamegeek.c...
Evo - Side-by-Slide Board Game Comparison 💼
zhlédnutí 330Před 2 měsíci
In this video I compare the two editions of the classic Philippe Keyaerts board game Evo: 2001 Eurogames vs 2011 Asmodée. Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czcams.com/channels/X9Ab6egkU1ru3sgP8TUI2A.htmljoin Twitter: booned BGG Blog: boardgamegeek.com/blog/10011 BGG New Videos List: boa...
Magna Grecia - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 855Před 2 měsíci
Magna Grecia (Clementoni 2003), with its yellow tiles and earth-tone player colours, had a reputation as one of the uglier OG board games! But being a rare joint design of Leo Colovini and Michael Schacht, two celebrated OG game designers, this game is worth a look beneath surface level. Get past the presentation and you'll find a unique, engaging connections-and-investment game (qualities for ...
Via Magica AKA (Rise of) Augustus - Side-by-Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 394Před 3 měsíci
Designer Paolo Mori and publisher Hurrican released a Spiel des Jahres nominated game. In 2013 it was called Augustus, alternately Rise of Augustus, and in 2020 it was called Via Magica. Let's compare the two, side-by-slide, with my semi-charming commentary. Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czcams...
Mission: Red Planet - Side-by-Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 441Před 3 měsíci
In this video, I compare the two editions of Mission: Red Planet, designed by Bruno Cathala and Bruno Faidutti. One is from Asmodée (before they became huge) in 2005, and the other 2015 from Fantasy Flight (...which is now a part of Asmodée). Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czcams.com/channels/X9...
Pollen AKA Samurai: The Card Game - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 947Před 3 měsíci
Based on the VERY well-respected board game Samurai (1998 Hans im Glück), designer Reiner Knizia shrunk the action down into a square-card game in, you guessed it, Samurai: The Card Game (2009 Rio Grande/Abacus). Players play cards to a checkerboard-like grid, trying to surround scoring cards to gain victory tokens of three types. Samurai scoring is special: You have to lead in one type to win,...
Rheinländer - Side by Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 547Před 4 měsíci
A long time ago I covered the Reiner Knizia board game Rheinländer: czcams.com/video/vZqiBtXKkh8/video.html This is a side-by-slide comparison, with commentary, of the two editions: 1999 Parker (German only) and 2005 Face2Face (Multilingual, including English). Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czc...
Löwenherz / Domaine - Side by Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 550Před 4 měsíci
In this video I compare the classic Klaus Teuber game Löwenherz (1997 Goldsieber) with its sequel, also called Löwenherz in Germany but commonly known in English as Domaine (2003 Kosmos). Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Join & Support: czcams.com/channels/X9Ab6egkU1ru3sgP8TUI2A.htmljoin Twitter/X: bo...
Expedition Northwest Passage - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 4 měsíci
In Expedition Northwest Passage, players attempt to traverse the northern Canadian archipelago, trying to reach the other side - and preferably back again! Tiles show land, water and features that can be explored for points. As the year progresses, the ice will creep southward, potentially trapping your ship. Consider putting out your sled, but mind it doesn't get left stranded! This board game...
Balloon Cup AKA Piñata - Side-by-Slide Board Game Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 128Před 5 měsíci
If you watched my last video on Balloon Cup (2003) AKA Piñata (2013), you will have seen both of these board games. So maybe you don't need to watch this as well! Anyway, here they are side by slide, a comparison of the two versions. Board Gems highlights older board and card games that are still great games today, and deserve to not be forgotten! Twitter: booned BGG Blog: boardgame...
Balloon Cup AKA Piñata - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 660Před 5 měsíci
Balloon Cup AKA Piñata - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
Black Friday - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 459Před 6 měsíci
Black Friday - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Conspiracy - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 450Před 6 měsíci
Conspiracy - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Conspiracy - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 800Před 6 měsíci
Conspiracy - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
Leonardo da Vinci - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 7 měsíci
Leonardo da Vinci - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
Leonardo da Vinci / Codex Leicester - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 511Před 8 měsíci
Leonardo da Vinci / Codex Leicester - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Quo/Zoo Vadis - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 1,1KPřed 8 měsíci
Quo/Zoo Vadis - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Leonardo da Vinci's Codex Leicester (Dicetree) - How to Play 🎲
zhlédnutí 1,9KPřed 9 měsíci
Leonardo da Vinci's Codex Leicester (Dicetree) - How to Play 🎲
Adel Verpflichtet AKA Hoity Toity - Side by Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 448Před 10 měsíci
Adel Verpflichtet AKA Hoity Toity - Side by Slide Comparison 👥
Equinox / Colossal Arena - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 645Před 10 měsíci
Equinox / Colossal Arena - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Kuhhandel AKA You're Bluffing - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 1,9KPřed 10 měsíci
Kuhhandel AKA You're Bluffing - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
Basketboss - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 346Před 11 měsíci
Basketboss - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Archeos Society / Ethnos - Side by Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 738Před 11 měsíci
Archeos Society / Ethnos - Side by Slide Comparison 👥
Arkadia - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
zhlédnutí 1,8KPřed 11 měsíci
Arkadia - How to Play 🎲 and Is It a Gem? 💎
Pollen AKA Samurai: The Card Game - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 825Před rokem
Pollen AKA Samurai: The Card Game - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
Tigris & Euphrates - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥
zhlédnutí 1,2KPřed rokem
Tigris & Euphrates - Side-by-Slide Comparison 👥

Komentáře

  • @ChadQuick270W
    @ChadQuick270W Před dnem

    Great review there. I love the 3M games. They were very cool and had some great games. How can you go wrong with Sid Sackson?

  • @Mr.E1
    @Mr.E1 Před 5 dny

    I love this game

  • @tkzubaran
    @tkzubaran Před 8 dny

    Just get better. Cheers from Brazil.

  • @osmoduh
    @osmoduh Před 10 dny

    Thank you so much for showcasing the basic version of Zoo vadis. Seems like all the influencers got the upgraded version from Bitewing and it is hard to find out what the differences are when all the videos have the deluxe pieces.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 9 dny

      No problem! I'd guess most of the ones Bitewing gave out for free to influencers were the deluxe edition, to see the game at its best. This was bought with money. 😁 10-15 years ago I used to love deluxe editions of games! But standards have shifted so much, I find retail editions pretty great quality by my standards, and deluxe editions often, well, a bit much, actually.

  • @ioannispaxinos5171
    @ioannispaxinos5171 Před 12 dny

    It depends though. Part of the joy of root for example is the cute animal theme that hides the vicious, murderous even terrorist actions the players are simulating. It wouldn't work the same if it were realistic. It would be more like a GMT game, which is fine but doesn't cover the same audiences necessarily. I for example love Root but can't stand GMT games.

  • @nochindeluxe
    @nochindeluxe Před 13 dny

    Bro, get the shrink off that copy of Genoa! It's such a great game!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 13 dny

      In my defence, I have an old copy on a different shelf that *does* have the shrink off. 😁

  • @enriquevivar27
    @enriquevivar27 Před 15 dny

    Hi, thanks for the video. I wanted to know if the old manual mentions that after scoring the huts/monks they disappear from the board. In the new version they don't mention it and every time I've played it I've left the monks that have already been scored on the board. But watching Zen Garcia's video I get the impression that they all have to be removed!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 15 dny

      The rules suggest removing villages that are in "unfavourable terrain" after scoring zero for them. Villages that score stay on the board. In practice, it doesn't matter, the village will score once when it's formed (and that score may be zero), then it doesn't matter whether they're on or off the board, they'll no longer have any effect on the game.

    • @enriquevivar27
      @enriquevivar27 Před 15 dny

      @@BoardGems Yes, it's true what you say, although it sometimes confuses with the new board design, which is a bit color crowded. Anyway, it's a great game. Never get rid of your previous version. Greetings from Peru!

  • @rinaldodelucca8073
    @rinaldodelucca8073 Před 16 dny

    Hi, have you ever played Mundus Novus? I recommend that one. I had a bad knee/nerve problem on March and I know it's not easy to fix a knee. Hope you get better soon! Keep doing physio every day.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 15 dny

      I've played it once a looooooong time ago. Didn't leave much of an impression at the time, but I'd like to revisit it! I'll add it to the suggestions list, so if I come across a copy easily/cheaply I'll know to pick it up!

    • @rinaldodelucca8073
      @rinaldodelucca8073 Před 15 dny

      @@BoardGems the rulebook is not completely clear and it's necessary to consult BBG a lot, but once you get the game right you will like it. It's very good even with only two players.

  • @Thesussysuscat
    @Thesussysuscat Před 17 dny

    Niche channel i like it

  • @zekefan8082
    @zekefan8082 Před 17 dny

    Hi, by board got borken abit, if i want to glue it , can i use the same glue?

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 17 dny

      You can, so long as it's not on a fold in the board. If your board is split along a fold then the glue won't survive folding along that edge, and you'll need to look at some sort of tape solution. Even if not on a fold, you may need to add support underneath the board, or it'll be easy to come loose again.

  • @gregwestman
    @gregwestman Před 19 dny

    All the best with recovery Darryl! Enjoy your summer as well!

  • @garymay4257
    @garymay4257 Před 20 dny

    Good choice. Thanks for sharing. I love your How to Play and is it a Gem? videos. Family first.

  • @celacanto
    @celacanto Před 20 dny

    Good recovery and enjoy the summer, we will still be here when youre back!

  • @bspiel
    @bspiel Před 20 dny

    Wish you a speed recovery and Enjoy your summer!

  • @YakovPetrovich
    @YakovPetrovich Před 20 dny

    have a great summer! i just got a copy of Taluva and played it once so far, I really enjoyed it 😁 looking forward to the coverage

  • @Ragelog
    @Ragelog Před 20 dny

    A “real” CZcamsr would have turned this life/channel update into a 45-minute short film. 😂 Glad to hear things are going well and enjoy the break.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 20 dny

      "Are knees really all THAT important?" A video essay to the tune of Moonlight Sonata 😁

  • @BoardGems
    @BoardGems Před 21 dnem

    Someone suggested a mailbag episode. Feel free to send some questions my way! If I get enough, I'll do just that.

  • @cfrost6167
    @cfrost6167 Před 21 dnem

    Maybe a mailbag Q&A ep would be an easy vid if you feel up to it - or not. 😜 Glad to hear your recovery is going smoothly!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 21 dnem

      Could do that! I got lots of questions in the early days. Not so much these days... Feel free to send some my way!

  • @kolomahler
    @kolomahler Před 21 dnem

    A very wholesome announcement. Thank you. Wishing you a speedy recovery.

  • @19tonami57
    @19tonami57 Před 21 dnem

    Wishing you a good recovery and remember: don’t hurry , be happy !

  • @shortydancer
    @shortydancer Před 21 dnem

    Hope everything goes well! Teaching a teen to drive, ugh. 😂

  • @pedrostruck
    @pedrostruck Před 21 dnem

    I agree with the fantasy-fication point.

  • @slenkhar
    @slenkhar Před 22 dny

    Damn, never seen this channel, sub ! A game reviewer with a calm and thoughtful demeanor, what a gem !

  • @davidmiller9869
    @davidmiller9869 Před 24 dny

    Wow just discovered your channel and subscribed. Being a 51 year old board gamer I love to find these older gems and so few are focused on these classics and are only focused on what’s new. I checked your video list and don’t see a TOP 10 - I’d love to know your best of the best of these older games! 😁

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 23 dny

      Thank you! I find it so hard to compare different board games to do a Top Ten. I know that's kind of the expected format of content, I know other CZcamsrs do it, but anything I do feels quite arbitrary. Like, how do I compare Ave Caesar with The Rose King with Kingdoms, three of my favourite games? They have completely different "use cases" - I can say one is better than another in a particular situation, but not overall. Well, I intend to take a small break for the summer, and during that period I'll probably put together a handful of one-off videos without a set schedule. I'll give some thought to maybe doing something more or less along those lines. Cheers!

    • @davidmiller9869
      @davidmiller9869 Před 23 dny

      @@BoardGemsmakes sense! Yeah maybe instead of a top 10 just simply your favorites to play - that works too👍. Thanks

  • @gregwestman
    @gregwestman Před 26 dny

    Hey Darryl! I recently acquired the older Kosmos edition, the plastic seems so be getting sticky, any board game know how expertise on how to remove the stickiness? Looking forward to playing and thanks for the coverage of the game!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před 26 dny

      Hmm, the Kosmos plastic is soft, kind of bouncy, compared to the hard plastic of FFG. But not sticky, not mine. I don't think I've encountered sticky plastic in any game! Sorry!

  • @christianbank393
    @christianbank393 Před měsícem

    I got the new Allplay edition with the upgrades. I do like using the wooden camels, but the wooden leaders are almost unusable, so I use a mix of wooden camels and plastic leaders. I prefer the plastic oasis miniature to the wooden one as well. I haven't tried it yet, but I'm hoping that if I hole punch the baggies (or use larger baggies) that it will eliminate the lid lift.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      The game comes with big baggies. And I always get as much air out as possible before sealing. Short of printing out the tuckboxes, or storing everything agonizingly neatly (like tiling the cardboard tiles at the bottom), I just don’t see no -lid-lift as something reasonably possible. Which to be clear might not matter to a lot of people! But it does to me. Using a mix of plastic and wooden camels would drive me nuts. 😄

  • @NikolajLepka
    @NikolajLepka Před měsícem

    according to Efka from No Pun Included you absolutely CAN fit everything back into the box without lid lift, if you know how to pack the game away properly

    • @bushibayushi
      @bushibayushi Před měsícem

      You can, I packed everything (with the expansion) without a lid lift. The cards were not sleeved though.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      AllPlay provided tuckbox templates you can print out. After this video I took a long time to cut, fold and glue them. I have to CRAM them into the box, such that I’m not confident they will survive the pressure. But there is no lid lift then. Now tuckboxes don’t magically create extra space, so it’s possible, if you for example neatly line up all the tokens, or take the time to lay them flat tiled on the bottom. But bagged? Absolutely not, and it’s not even close.

  • @dandurkin9735
    @dandurkin9735 Před měsícem

    I saw the production by Allplay at Dice Tower West back in March and couldn't stop shaking my head - and now it shakes again with your video: box crammed with unneeded expansions; replacing the iconic camels with hollow ones - a far cry from the originally promised wooden camels; weird scaling of the camel to board size; weirdly folder board with a misprinted - after how many previous editions?! While I'm happy the game is back in circulation, I think this edition clutters a previously elegant game. Sheesh! At DTW, we went to the library and checked out the FF version. Thank you and enjoy!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      The wooden camels were an add-on that I didn't get. I like wooden stuff as much as the next old-school gamer, but plastic camels has always been the iconic look of TtD so I stuck with that. I actually can't complain too too much about the components, barring the misprinted board of course. But the box was *way* too small. I haven't decided which to keep for myself. I was pretty fine with my old FFG one. The only thing I strongly prefer in the new edition is the nice, big board.

    • @kerim8666
      @kerim8666 Před měsícem

      My buddy got the wooden camels as an add-on. I can definitely say that switching back to the plastic ones were the right choice. It is really hard to decipher which caravan belongs to who, because you can only identify the leaders if you look from the sides. It shouldn’t be hard to play a game like this. Allplay charged so much for that add on as well. My poor buddy😢

    • @dandurkin9735
      @dandurkin9735 Před měsícem

      @@BoardGems As I recall Allpplay's campaign (and there's some documented history on BGG), they originally previewed ONLY wooden camels. They looked more elaborate than the ones now available as an add-on. These were abandoned for the hollow plastic ones and I think the wooden add-ons were later added because of backer outcry (?). I think it's all reflective of rushed development, which is especially odd for a game that has existed for 25 years ... and existed quite fine. Thanks!

  • @Ragelog
    @Ragelog Před měsícem

    Strongly prefer the FFG version, so much so that I got rid of my Allplay copy despite the graphical improvements and extra variety. Going for the smallest box, but the largest components to the point where it won’t fit back into the box still baffles me.

  • @bushibayushi
    @bushibayushi Před měsícem

    For a brief moment I had a Z-man Edition and Allplay edition and I preferred the Z-man edition. The camels were much better ;). And the Allplay edition has a misprint on the board regarding the waterhole (one is missing).

  • @Southfloridelphia
    @Southfloridelphia Před měsícem

    That is the odd game that looks worse as you put more pieces out. A lot of older games look very bland at first but are a sea of primary colors by the end. This just looks so difficult to discern what is going on.

  • @Melville1800s
    @Melville1800s Před měsícem

    It's pathetic to see board game makers cave in to people who are so fragile that the mere sight of something rooted in actual history causes them to screech. Sigh.

    • @pluntododo1188
      @pluntododo1188 Před měsícem

      I don't really want to think of slavery when I'm supposed to be having fun.

    • @Melville1800s
      @Melville1800s Před měsícem

      @@pluntododo1188 You should play Candy Land then.

    • @pluntododo1188
      @pluntododo1188 Před měsícem

      @@Melville1800s I said I wanted to have fun 💀

    • @madeline7272
      @madeline7272 Před 17 dny

      You seem like a pleasant person to be around

  • @tkzubaran
    @tkzubaran Před měsícem

    I am so happy I have my original 10 year edition, not censored by the vile culture warriors.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      I don't mind change in setting at all. If the change was so ridiculous that the setting/mechanisms no longer make any sense together, I'd be the first to complain, but it makes as much sense now as before. They could have gone with a space-colonization theme instead, and I'd like that, much, much less. If they're going to change the setting, this is the way to do it IMO. But yeah, the anniversary edition is really nice!

    • @tkzubaran
      @tkzubaran Před měsícem

      @@BoardGems I oppose out of principle. A year or so ago they were organizing an online lynch mob on BGG to try to destroy the life of the designer of Terraforming Mars. One of them dug a tweet containing wrong-think of the victim. They were doing not only with the blessing, but also the help of the BGG administration. I felt so disgusted I deleted my account from the site. This is the morality police that decides what themes we are allowed in board games.

  • @peperesines
    @peperesines Před měsícem

    Yet another disappointing production from Alea, unfit for such a great game. This printing is better, but I have the previous one without text in the buildings, and Alea just washed their hands of it. Will not be buying from them again.

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      Yeah there are many horror stories of the misprints and poor production choices in 1897, so many that the publisher couldn't/wouldn't fix them for everyone and mostly just quietly fixed it for new printings. I was keenly aware of it and waited REALLY long to pick it up to give them a chance to iron it out, and even then I was taking a chance that what I ordered was the newer fixed version and not some old copy. It worked out for me, but I feel bad for all the early adopters.

    • @tjhinglis
      @tjhinglis Před měsícem

      ​@@BoardGemsI was one of the earliest adopters. I got four coffee tiles and a replacement coin (came out of punchboard badly), then I got a new rulebook, then I (professionally) printed out five copies of the new building player aid. All good now and it's good that they sent the tiles and rules for free, but a bit of a palava!

  • @shortydancer
    @shortydancer Před měsícem

    I love the way Alea does their rulebooks. The sidebars are so helpful. I also love the colored boxes on the "insert" of Alea games. They don't really do anything, but they really make a nice backdrop.

  • @daveflynn3397
    @daveflynn3397 Před měsícem

    Love this game! Chaotic back-stabby area control that plays in under an hour. I also like the steam punk art in the 2nd edition.

  • @gabudabi
    @gabudabi Před měsícem

    So... any board game that is a good alternative to Fae/clans? I like the mechanics but it seems like a bulky game for what it is

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      Not sure if you mean physically bulky or, like, not streamlined in gameplay. I think Clans is not bulky in either way; Fae is a bit big. An even-more streamlined hidden-colour board game is Heimlich & Co., though I haven’t seen a small version.

  • @Oliver-zy8sq
    @Oliver-zy8sq Před měsícem

    What to do when I have a lot or even all of trump cards? Sooner or later i will have goten five tricks with the trump suit and then have to lead with trump. Doesn't that mean that if I have all or almost all the trumps I defenetely get negative points? I think that this is a fundamental flaw of the game. A solution would be to be the saboteur and only get 4 negative points, IF no one else takes the saboteur before me. What would you do?

  • @millsdavid
    @millsdavid Před měsícem

    Great game for a Board Gems. I have heard of Klunker, but didn’t really know anything about it. I do have a copy of that 7-player Bohnanza, so it might be worth a try!

  • @jonathanlecarpentier2994
    @jonathanlecarpentier2994 Před měsícem

    Thanks again for this video !! I saw behind you Kaigan and El Caballero... Do you considere those games as gems ?? Thank yo2 !!!

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      Yes, but with caveats. They're not for everyone. Actually I tried once before to cover El Caballero, but had technical problems and after two attempts at recording I gave up on it. I'll return to it (and cover Kaigan) someday.

  • @helxis
    @helxis Před měsícem

    Bohnanza is good because, among other reasons, it teaches an actual real world valuable skill - negotiation. Attentive players can actually learn what it means to be in an advantageous position and how to leverage it. The downside to Bohnanza and other strongly player-balanced games (Modern Art, Zoo Vadis) is that basically every instance of the we games that I've ever played has been thrown (or made random) by an inattentive or less-caring player. As a result, these types of games have largely fallen out of my personal taste in favor of ones that provide a little more individual impact over the one's personal outcome. I would still try Klunker, though!

  • @Taplash
    @Taplash Před měsícem

    I see your somewhat familiar with trick taking games per your shelf :P. Any chance you'd do a video on a few of your favorites?

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      If they’re old enough, you bet!

  • @chadwilburn6451
    @chadwilburn6451 Před měsícem

    We have a group we play a lot of bohnanza with..I guess I need to drag this off the shelf and give it a go.. thanks

  • @matejathos3645
    @matejathos3645 Před měsícem

    Board game we have played the most, old art. Gonna buy new style, nice saturation! but - coniferous trees were realistic unlike deciduous trees in mammoth times, now it looks like there are 25 degrees Celsius - tygers should have been kept red for clarity - great that hunter monument of ultimate power is gone, yes it was OP, made animals not interesting until it was placed - compared to classic Carcassonne roads, rivers here give you animals and fish, so game is more balanced, new version of hunters looks even more sensitive this way... but it's still not enough! I wish there was more animal power on weaker piles, so lakes wouldn't be better 80% of the time! Two mammoths instead of one on that pile of sadness where there is nothing else, for example *Some rules I made as a strategy enthusiast* 1. Everytime you get a piece you can't immediately score points with, you can send it to 'exposed public inventory' (exventory) and take another. Everyone can take pieces from there instead of standard move. At the end you must take from there. When someone points out there is way for you to score immediately you must play that card and you're not allowed to physically attack them. Player who has to build bigger alone is losing too much. Especially in games of many players it's about taking equal power in every small forest and river where fight for dominance is not worth it. This way players score the most per turn - and it's usually not your strategic fault when it's your turn and you can't do it. Therefore... 2. Player who owns the largest closed forest or river of the game and had no pawn intruders can keep their pawn laying down there and they have points one more time at the end - all river systems with no intruders also give owner doubled points at the end. When someone closes greater or equal forest or river, doesn't matter if with intruders, you don't get any second points. Your sad pawn goes back to your inventory. 3. You can't place river hut in the forest... but... this idea is too good: Forest hut: you can place one on forest card and immediately connect it to forest where you have at least one pawn. You take hut back when forest is closed, but you can't place forest hut when you're closing this forest. Each hut gives you half the power of pawn! This ruins overpowered forest cooperation and brings whole new decision on the table: river system dominance at the expense of forest power. 4. Great option is also to give some of these 3:33 to each player and use them as tokens of tribal demand: when other player is placing piece you want, you use up one token and piece is yours for next turn and they take another. Before that, player sooner on turn, if there is any, can decide to demand card instead. If they don't wanna claim it for themselves, you ask everyone (in order you choose) if they wanna disagree and use up their token to burn your demand. It's great mechanic because you want to use tokens in your critical moments but sometimes it's better to keep them to stop others, you want the most out of it but not waste it in conflict with someone else while 3rd side(s) manage to use it... makes game more exciting for plenty of reasons: - winning players will be stopped more likely than losing - makes it easier to get rare piece you need to don't get stuck, or to block/connect in conflict with less caring opponent - luck of taking better cards and bonus pieces becomes less important cos it can be stolen or drain you of tokens - makes more favorable to avoid major conflict due to which others use up their tokens and get nothing from them... That's usually still the best way to victory for how overpowered dominance over main pasture is. However, if you play tournament of many games counted together, demand tokens & lone builder bonuses add new winning strategies and importance of changing them according to situation. Uninvolved player can help the strong one on plain or river system to estabilish dominance and take away points from others involved, while building their own stuff. Strategy to steal wealth won't be that thoughtless decision, and it's a little safer to do what you want and achieve ice age success that way. Oh, did you just read this all? I doubt it! :)

  • @shortydancer
    @shortydancer Před měsícem

    Will you cover the newest version now? Or just talk about if it fixes some issues?

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      Likely not. I don't want to buy a new version, I'm happy with what I have. 😊

  • @michaelkaufmann6555
    @michaelkaufmann6555 Před měsícem

    Would love to hear your thoughts about "World without end" as well. Great Video ❤

    • @BoardGems
      @BoardGems Před měsícem

      Thanks! It wasn't on my radar but I'll consider it if I come across a used copy. I've added it to my Requests & Suggestions list on BGG. Cheers!

  • @susyquark
    @susyquark Před měsícem

    Does anyone knows where I can find this game?. It seems impossible to find, even a second hand.

  • @cmted41
    @cmted41 Před 2 měsíci

    Brilliant video! Really well explained. Thanks !

  • @morrigambist
    @morrigambist Před 2 měsíci

    These games are excellent for three players.